• Sonuç bulunamadı

View of A Study of failure Multi-Term Central HVDC Conductors In Wind Power Transmission Systems

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "View of A Study of failure Multi-Term Central HVDC Conductors In Wind Power Transmission Systems"

Copied!
6
0
0

Yükleniyor.... (view fulltext now)

Tam metin

(1)

Research Article

A Study of failure Multi-Term Central HVDC Conductors In Wind Power Transmission

Systems

Kayapati Rajagopal A And Dr. Subhashish Bose

aResearch Scholar, Dept. of Electrical Engineering,Sri Satya Sai University of Technology & Medical Sciences,

Sehore, Bhopal-Indore Road, MadhyaPradesh, India

bResearch Guide, Dept. of Electrical Engineering,Sri Satya Sai University of Technology & Medical Sciences, Sehore, Bhopal-Indore Road, MadhyaPradesh, India

Article History: Received: 11 January 2021; Revised: 12 February 2021; Accepted: 27 March 2021; Published online: 10

May 2021

Abstract: Wind power is developing quickly all throughout the planet as a methods for managing the world energy deficiency

and related natural issues. Adaptable direct current (DC) transmission network innovation is a viable strategy for huge limit clean energy admittance to control grids, however the DC cut off identification for it is a troublesome issue for wind structure. The multiterminal dc wind farm is a promising geography with a voltage-source inverter (VSI) association at the coastal matrix. Voltage-source converters (VSCs) are robust to ac-side shortcoming conditions. Be that as it may, they are defenseless against dc deficiencies on the dc side of the converter. For the modular multilevel converter HVDC (MMC-HVDC) systems, when a solitary pole to-ground deficiency happens, the flaw current is little, and it is hard to recognize the issue rapidly. Two variable-speed age frameworks are thought of: doubly-fed induction generators (DFIGs) and perpetual magnet simultaneous generators (PMSGs) in light of their ubiquity these days for wind turbines scaling to a few MW frameworks. The impact of the wind power plant control technique in the short out conduct of the HVDC connect has likewise been contemplated. Results show that the elements of the wind power plant commitment to post to-ground shortcomings are somewhat more slow than those of the wind turbines current control circles. Consequently, the wind turbine front end converters can be utilized to diminish the pinnacle and normal estimation of the issue current in such a system.

Keywords: Modular Multilevel Converter (MMC), wind farm, grids, HVDC link. 1.Introduction

Wind energy as a notable sustainable power asset, has stood apart to be perhaps the most encouraging elective wellsprings of electrical force. It is harmless to the ecosystem and has the chance of huge scope execution in seaward situations. Wind age ought to likewise be joined with elective outflow decrease estimates, for example, emanation duties or exchanging plans, replacement of fossil fuelled plant, and request decrease plans. The previous decade has seen an emotional blasting of environmentally friendly power all throughout the planet, while the huge entrance of them into power lattice has become a typical marvel and is considered as the future pattern of shrewd grids by both created and non-industrial nations. Notwithstanding, their characteristic property of high arbitrariness and irregularity unavoidably brings about various issues. Especially, the sustainable power is generally situated a long way from load focuses along these lines a successfully mass electrical force transmission with significant distance is critical to guarantee a dependable and controllable force supply. As of late, because of its one of a kind specialized and monetary benefits, high voltage direct current (HVDC) systems have been generally utilized in significant distance huge limit power transmission and enormous region network situations. The fast HVDC system improvement is because of the way that it can empower an offbeat activity of two force systems and associate force systems with various frequencies, which implies that a HVDC system can be interconnected nonconcurrently and it additionally can forestall unintentional circle streams in an interconnected rotating current system.

Wind power is being advanced in numerous nations via government-level arrangement and set up by genuine business age projects. Enormous scope seaward wind farms are arranged, particularly in Europe, where shallow-water and seaward wind assets are various. By 2020, it is arranged that 20% of force burned-through in Europe likely could be provided by sustainable assets. The acknowledgment of this goal-oriented arrangement depends intensely for huge scope seaward wind farm activity. Multiterminal dc wind farm geographies are pulling in expanding research exertion. For matrix association of wind farms, the geography utilizes high-voltage direct current transmission utilizing voltage-source converters (VSC-HVDC). With ac/dc converters on the generator side, this geography can be formed into a multiterminal dc network for wind power assortment, which is particularly reasonable for huge scope seaward wind farms because of benefits, like no prerequisite for generator synchronization, full-evaluated VSCs being equipped for following a wind turbine greatest force point, dc transmission to keep away from the air conditioner transmission distance impediments for far off seaward wind farms, and system proficiency improvement. The establishing strategy for MMC-MTDC is for the most part a little current establishing system which can restrict the amplitude of fault currents, yet the voltage of solid DC lines and AC transformer optional sides will be influenced and afterward the lines and hardware activity security

(2)

is undermined on the system, so it is of incredible commonsense importance to concentrate on the quick assurance of post to-ground issues in DC power systems..

1.1 Wind Power Generation Systems

At present, two famous variable-speed steady recurrence wind power age systems overwhelm. Wind power age is power age that converts wind energy into electric energy. The wind creating set assimilates wind energy with an extraordinarily planned sharp edge and converts wind energy to mechanical energy, which further drives the generator pivoting and acknowledges change of wind energy to electric energy. The normally utilized wind power age systems incorporate the direct-determined wind power producing set and the twofold taken care of wind power creating set; the direct-determined wind power creating set is associated with the framework through a full force converter, while the double-fed wind power producing set is associated with the grid through a double-fed converter.

1.1.1 Doubly-Fed Induction Generators

The DFIG is at present the system of decision for multi-megawatt wind turbines. In the event that the streamlined system is equipped for working over a wide wind speed range then ideal streamlined productivity can be accomplished by following the ideal tip-speed proportion. In this way, the generator's rotor ought to have the option to work at a variable rotational speed. The DFIG system gives this office by working in both suband super-simultaneous modes with a rotor speed range around the coordinated speed. The stator circuit is associated with the matrix while the rotor winding is associated by means of slip-rings to an AC/DC/AC three-stage converter game plan. For variable-speed systems where the speed range prerequisites are modest, for instance ±30% of coordinated speed, the DFIG offers satisfactory execution and is adequate for the speed range needed to abuse normal wind assets. The AC/DC/AC converter associating the rotor windings to the matrix comprises of two voltage-source converters, i.e., rotor-side converter (RSC) and grid side converter (GSC), which are associated “back-to-back”, appeared in Figure 1.1. Between the two converters a DC-interface capacitor is set, as energy stockpiling, to keep the voltage varieties (or ripple) in the DC-connect voltage little. With the rotor-side converter it is feasible to control the shaft force or the speed of the DFIG and furthermore the force factor at the stator terminals. The principle objective for the network side converter is to keep the DC-connect voltage consistent paying little mind to the greatness and course of the rotor power. The matrix side converter works at the lattice recurrence (with a controllable driving or slacking power factor to assimilate or create receptive force). A transformer is frequently associated between the framework side inverter or the stator, and the lattice. The rotor-side converter changes its yield recurrence, contingent upon the wind speed.

Figure 1.1: Doubly-fed induction generator system and its power flows 1.1.2 Permanent Magnet Synchronous Generators

The DFIG systems use a gearbox that couples the wind turbine to the generator. The gearbox experiences blames and requires normal support. The dependability of the variable-speed wind turbine system can be improved fundamentally by utilizing a direct-determined PMSG − wiping out the gearbox. With the advancement of high energy magnet materials, the PMSG has gotten a lot of consideration in wind energy applications due to their self-excitation. The utilization of magnetisingcurrent in the rotor of the PMSG makes it pointless to supply charging current. Henceforth, on account of the shortfall of the charging current PMSG arrangements are regularly more proficient than different machines. To remove greatest force from the fluctuating wind, variable-speed activity of the wind-turbine PMSG is essential. Two force electronic geographies are proposed for variable-speed activity of PMSG. They require diverse control techniques for the generator. PMSGs are likewise being utilized in wind turbines with gearboxes, for instance, Doosan Heavy Industries. For the system, control procedures use wind speed to decide the ideal shaft speed, consequently, the generator speed. For an overall system, an anemometer-based control methodology expands cost and may even decrease the dependability of the general system. In any case, for enormous wind turbines, the anemometer addresses just a little part of the total cost and the control system dependent on wind speed to decide ideal generator speed is received. In the current vector of an inside kind PMSG is controlled to enhance the wind-turbine activity at different wind speed, which requires six dynamic changes to be controlled, Figure 1.2.

(3)

Figure 1.2: Large-scale PMSG power conversion system topology 1.2 Protection Development of DC Systems in wind farms

Fault vulnerability is perhaps the main issues that compel the advancement of voltage-source converter based DC organizations, particularly in high-power situations. Also, this is because of the absence of develop business DC switchgear items. Notwithstanding, as presented above, VSC-HVDC power transmission gives more prominent operational adaptability which suits environmentally friendly power sources. One ordinary application is for enormous scope seaward wind farm coordination to utility grids where a solid DC network is an essential. In such systems, link flaws do happen all the more much of the time contrasted and different pieces of the system. The most widely recognized justification link issue is protection crumbling and breakdown. There can be a few causes: actual harm (the most genuine short out issue can happen along these lines); natural anxieties like sodden, particularly at the intersections of links, where the cabling system is presented to soil or water; electrical burdens because of over-burden activity or activity at high temperature; and link maturing. These variables would all be able to prompt a ground issue. There has been restricted conversation about the impact of DC shortcomings on DC networks at transmission and dispersion levels. Regular line-commutated CSC-based HVDC transmission systems are vigorous to DC shortcoming over flows in view of their current-controlled nature. DC voltage change is utilized for shortcoming recognition. Since the use of line-commutated CSC-HVDC systems, the overvoltage marvel of this current-controlled DC system. As of late, CSC-HVDC insurance research has been centered around explicit link issue area draws near. Assurance coordination is only from time to time contemplated as a result of the absence of improvement in multi-terminal DC organizations. A high-recurrence beat wave is infused into the broken link and the deficiency area is found by the examination between the first and reflected waves. Nonetheless, when the system structure is intricate (for example fit for multi-terminal association) the DC transport will encounter various reflections which will impact area results. A definite link model is needed for precise deficiency area utilizing the transient reaction to a high-frequency pulse.

2. LITERATURE REVIEW

Eduard Muljadi, et al (2020): This paper clarifies about the short out Current Contribution for Different Wind

Turbine Generator. A significant part of wind power plant (WPP) sway examines is to assess the short circuit (SC) current commitment of the plant into the transmission network under various shortcoming conditions. This assignment can be trying to insurance designs because of the geography contrasts between various kinds of wind turbine generators (WTGs) and the ordinary producing units. This paper presents recreation results for SC current commitment for various kinds of WTGs acquired through transient investigation utilizing nonexclusive WTG models. The acquired waveforms are examined to clarify the conduct, for example, top qualities and pace of rot, of the WTG. The impact of shortcoming types and area, and the impact of the control calculations of force converters on SC current commitment are likewise examined. We show that the reaction of the WPP to issues will change dependent on the sort of the introduced WTGs. While in Type 1 and Type 2 WTGs, SC current will be dictated by the actual qualities of the acceptance generator, the commitment of Type 3 and Type 4 WTG will be for the most part portrayed by the force converter's control calculations, which are typically viewed as restrictive data by the wind turbine makers. In the years to come, there will be increasingly more WPPs associated with the grid. With the objective of 20% wind infiltration by 2030, the WPPs activity ought to be all around arranged. The force system switchgear and power system security for WPPs ought to be deliberately intended to be viable with the activity of customary simultaneous generators associated with a similar grid. This paper endeavors to delineate the conduct of SC current commitments for various sorts of WTGs. Interestingly, in an acceptance generator the polarizing transition is exhausted during the shortcoming and the issue flows are not economical for a long term.

AphrodisNduwamungu et al (2020): This paper clarifies about the Fault Ride through Capability Analysis

(FRT) in Wind Power Plants with Doubly Fed Induction Generators. Shortcomings in electrical organizations are among the key factors and wellsprings of organization unsettling influences. Control and robotization methodologies are among the key issue clearing strategies answerable for the protected activity of the system. A few analysts have uncovered different limitations of control and mechanization systems like a lethargic powerful reaction, the powerlessness to turn the organization on and off distantly, a high issue clearing time and misfortune minimization. For a system with wind energy advancements, if the force stream of a wind turbine is bothered by an issue, the middle circuit voltage between the machine side converter and line side converter will

(4)

ascend to unsuitably high qualities because of the gathering of energy in the DC connect capacitor. To beat the previously mentioned issues, this paper utilized MATLAB reenactments and examinations to break down and approve the outcomes. The outcomes uncovered that shortcoming ride through capacity with Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) watcher programming, Active Servo programming and wind sim bundles are more versatile to the varieties of voltage list, voltage swell and wind speed and keep away from loss of synchronism and improve power quality. Besides, for assurance purposes, a DC chopper and a crowbar ought to be joined into the administration of overabundance energy during shortcomings and a ferrite gadget included for the decrease of the electromagnetic field. Because of the variable idea of the wind speed, the solid, steady and dynamic activity of the force grid networks containing wind farms is a critical test for the two specialists and utility grid administrators. The prerequisites for voltage and recurrence variety inside the passable reach given by a country or district's grid codes and norms should be met to forestall the discontinuance or suspension of a force grid's administration during the hour of dynamic force grid unsettling influences.

Jorun I. Marvik et al (2020):This paper clarifies about the Analysis of grid deficiencies in seaward wind farm

with HVDC. Future seaward wind farms are required to be assembled farther away from shore and have bigger limits than today. This prompts new provokes identified with grid association. At distances longer than around 100 km, HVDC transmission is liked over AC transmission because of huge charging flows in AC-links. Customary LCC (line commutated converter) HVDC isn't appropriate for association with feeble grids like seaward wind farms, and the less develop VSC (voltage source converter) HVDC innovation is liked all things considered. A future enormous seaward wind farm with full force converter turbines and three-terminal VSC HVDC grid association has been demonstrated in PSCAD. With three terminals the HVDC connection can be utilized for direct transmission between the coastal terminals notwithstanding transmission of wind power. Because of the force gadgets interfaces, the system has low short out limit and is missing latency. Additionally, DC-links are released extremely quick during shortcomings. This prompts distinctive flaw reactions than in ordinary grids. This work centers around deficiency reactions and assurance of a HVDC-associated wind farm, both inside the wind farm itself and in the HVDC-interface. The focal point of this work is shortcoming reaction and security of a HVDC-associated wind farm, both inside the wind farm itself and in the HVDC-interface. A HVDC associated wind farm will have diverse flaw reactions than ordinary AC systems. Most writing talking about provokes identified with assurance of inverter ruled AC-networks are zeroing in on circulation/miniature grids with little force hardware interfaced age (DG) units, for example photograph voltaic units.

HongchunShu et al (2020):This paper clarifies about the Single Pole-to-Ground Fault Analysis of

MMC-HVDC Transmission Lines Based on Capacitive Fuzzy Identification Algorithm. The likelihood of a solitary pole to-ground deficiency in high voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission lines is moderately high. For the modular multilevel converter HVDC systems, when a solitary post to-ground issue happens, the flaw current is little, and it is hard to distinguish the deficiency rapidly. Through an itemized investigation of the qualities of the single shaft ground issue of the MMC-HVDC transmission line, it is tracked down that the single post to-ground flaw has clear capacitance-related attributes, and the transient cycle after the single shaft to-to-ground shortcoming is the release interaction of the conveyed capacitance of the line. Nonetheless, different issues don't have such clear capacitance-related qualities. In view of such element, this paper proposes a novel capacitive fluffy distinguishing proof technique to recognize the single shaft to-ground shortcoming. This calculation can viably recognize both the issue of single post to-ground and the issue shaft, which can add to the huge data set of things to come brilliant grid. This paper presents a novel technique called capacitive fuzzy PI, in which the single post to-ground shortcoming of MMC-HVDC transmission lines can be dependably and quickly recognized by using the capacitive attributes of transmission lines, while a connection examination is additionally attempted to distinguish the single poleto-ground faults.

Snehaprava Swain et al (2019):In this paper a three stage deficiency investigation is done on a DFIG based grid

incorporated wind energy system. A Novel Active Crowbar Protection (NACB_P) system is proposed to improve the Fault-ride through (FRT) ability of DFIG both for even just as unsymmetrical grid faults. Henceforth improves the force nature of the system. The insurance plot proposed here is planned with a capacitor in arrangement with the resistor not at all like the regular Crowbar (CB) having just resistors. The significant capacity of the capacitor in the assurance circuit is to dispense with the waves created in the rotor current and to secure the converter just as the DC-interface capacitor. It likewise remunerates responsive force needed by the DFIG during issue. Because of these benefits the proposed conspire upgrades the FRT capacity of the DFIG and furthermore improves the force nature of the entire system. Tentatively the issue investigation is done on a 3hp slip ring enlistment generator and recreation results are completed on a 1.7 MVA DFIG based WECS under various sorts of grid faults in MATLAB/Simulation and usefulness of the proposed conspire is confirmed. DFIGs are liked because of the benefits of decreased size (25 %–30 %) power converters, execution of force factor control at an insignificant expense and the four quadrant converter activity which makes it like that of a coordinated generator. It has the exceptional capacity to create power both in sub-simultaneous just as super-coordinated districts of rotor speed. To keep up the operability alongside dependability and force nature of the grid, Wind Energy Conversion Systems (WECS) are incorporated with the force grids rather working

(5)

independent. Yet, preceding grid incorporation, the WTs should satisfy the specialized guidelines carried out by the greater part of the force system administrators known as "grid codes".

ShiminXue et al (2019):This paper discloses about the Pole-to-Ground Fault Analysis and Fast Protection

Scheme for HVDC Based on Overhead Transmission Lines. Adaptable direct current (DC) transmission network innovation is a successful strategy for enormous limit clean energy admittance to control grids, however the DC impede identification for it is a troublesome issue. In this paper, the post to-ground flaw transient attributes in a multi-terminal DC power grid, in light of overhead transmission lines and DC circuit breakers, are broke down right off the bat. At that point, a quick security conspire is proposed by the flaw transient attributes. Just nearby data is used for issue discovery and area in the proposed plot. Besides, the plan is checked to have the upsides of quick activity speed, high unwavering quality and the capacity to oppose the change opposition. A four terminal DC power grid model dependent on genuine designing boundaries is set up in PSCAD/EMTDC, and the legitimacy of the security plot under various shortcoming conditions is checked by recreation results. In this paper, the post to-ground flaw transient qualities are dissected in detail first. In view of the shortcoming qualities investigation, a quick assurance conspire is proposed to distinguish and find faults. Through the proposed conspire, a post to-ground deficiency can be by and large distinguished by assurance gadgets at the two closures of the separation point in milliseconds.

Bin Li et al (2019):This paper clarifies about the Fault Studies and Distance Protection of Transmission Lines

Connected to DFIG-Based Wind Farms Doubly fed induction generator (DFIG) based wind farms are by and large progressively incorporated into power grids with transmission lines, and distance security is generally utilized as either the fundamental or the reinforcement insurance for the transmission line. This paper breaks down the sythesis of a DFIG cut off and shows the presence of a rotor speed recurrence segment. By examining a few genuine deficiency instances of the DFIG-based wind farms associated with transmission lines, the feeble force supply system and current recurrence deviation of the wind farm side are shown. At the point when a flaw happens on the transmission line, the short out current on the wind farm side is little and its recurrence may presently don't be ostensible because of the presence of rotor speed recurrence segment, while the voltage recurrence stays ostensible recurrence due to the grid support. Therefore, the regular distance security can't precisely quantify the impedance, which can bring about pointless electrical switch stumbling. Thusly, a period space distance insurance technique joined with the least-squares calculation is proposed to address the issue. The viability of the proposed strategy is approved with genuine shortcoming cases and reenactment.

3. CONCLUSION

In this paper, the Short circuit current commitments of various wind turbine generator for faults at the terminal of the generator are investigated. The duration of the fault is the shortest in light of the fact that the air hole transition implodes without the help of adequate line voltages. Albeit this kind of issue is the most drastically averse to happen, be that as it may, organizers utilize this flaw to figure the circuit breakers obligation and other change gear gadgets. The single line to ground is the destined to happen in the force grid. The terminal voltage and flows are supported longer in light of the fact that the line voltages, besides from one stage, can support air hole transition. Albeit the Short circuit current commitment from this sort of shortcoming is the least among the three distinct faults considered, organizers should utilize this kind of flaw to decide the base issue current setting for insurance. It very well may be utilized in a wind structure system and in circulated cogeneration to forestall shortcircuits (SC) at high voltage and additional high voltage levels against the spread of misfortunes in influence age. Once more, the deficiency ride through ability might be examined in a HVDC system along with SCADA watcher and SCADA Designer programming bundles

REFERENCES

1.

Eduard Muljadi, Nader Samaan, VahanGevorgian, Jun Li (2020), ”Short Circuit Current Contribution for Different Wind Turbine Generator” IEEE Power and Energy Society 2020 General Meeting Minneapolis, Minnesota.

2.

AphrodisNduwamungu, Etienne Ntagwirumugara, Francis Mulolani and Waqar Bashir (2020), “Fault Ride through Capability Analysis (FRT) in Wind Power Plants with Doubly Fed Induction Generators for Smart Grid Technologies”. 2020 5th International Conference on Sustainable and Renewable Energy Engineering (ICSREE 2020); Paris-France, 6–9 May 2020

3.

Jorun I. Marvika, Harald G. Svendsen (2020), “Analysis of grid faults in offshore wind farm with HVDC”. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of SINTEF Energi AS doi: 10.1016/j.egypro.2020.07.161

4.

HongchunShu, Na An, Bo Yang, Yue Dai and Yu Guo (2020), “Single Pole-to-Ground Fault Analysis of MMC-HVDC Transmission Lines Based on Capacitive Fuzzy Identification Algorithm”. Energies 2020, 13, 319; doi:10.3390/en13020319

5.

Swain, S., & Ray, P. K. (2016). Fault Analysis in a Grid Integrated DFIG Based Wind Energy System with NA CB_P Circuit for Ride through Capability and Power Quality Improvement. International Journal of Emerging Electric Power Systems, 17(6). doi:10.1515/ijeeps-2019-0095

(6)

6.

ShiminXue, JieLian, Jinlong Qi and Boyang Fan (2019) “Pole-to-Ground Fault Analysis and Fast Protection Scheme for HVDC Based on Overhead Transmission Lines”. Energies 2019, 10, 1059; doi:10.3390/en10071059

7.

Li, B., Liu, J., Wang, X., & Zhao, L. (2019). Fault Studies and Distance Protection of Transmission Lines Connected to DFIG-Based Wind Farms. Applied Sciences, 8(4), 562. doi:10.3390/app8040562

8.

Pannell, G.; Atkinson, D.J.; Zahawi, B. Analytical study of grid-fault response of wind turbine doubly fed induction generator. IEEE Trans. Energy Convers. 2018, 25, 1081–1091.

9.

Sulla, F.; Svensson, J.; Samuelsson, O. Symmetrical and unsymmetrical short-circuit current of squirrel-cage and doubly-fed induction generators. Electr. Power Syst. Res. 2019, 81, 1610–1618.

10.

Morren, J.; de Haan, S.W.H. Short-circuit current of wind turbines with doubly fed induction generator. IEEE Trans. Energy Convers. 2019, 22, 174–180.

Referanslar

Benzer Belgeler

Bu bakım dan / bar’m önderliğini yapr olduğu T İP ’in yeni bir sr yaiist hareket olarak d ğerlendirilm esi gerekı Gerçekten Aybar işçiler ta rafından kurulm

Yirm i beş senedir îstanbulu güldüren adam karşımda bir ıstırab ve elem timsali gibi dimdik... Elimi sıkarken belli ki zorluyor, zorluyor

Ülkeyi böldürmemek için elimizden ge­ len herşeyi yapacağız," diyen Yaşar Kemal, Türki­ ye'nin en büyük sorunu üzerine görüşlerini dile getirmeyecek

Orhan Karaveli, bir daha söylüyor; şiirleri günümüz diline dönüştürdüğünü.... Sayfaları

Dört bir tarafı koca koca kaya parçalarıyla beslenmiş, denizin altındaki yine bir kaya olan temelin üstüne dö­ şenmiş geniş bir plâtform, bir yuvarlak

Soldan sağa: Mesulmüdür ve Başyazar Hüseyin Vasıf (Çınar), Yazı müdürü, muhabir, mü* sahhih Esad (Çınar), idare, abone işlerine bakan Avnl efendi ve

adaptasyonun maliyeti çevik proje yönetimine göre oldukça fazladır çünkü katı yapıları esnetmek baştan inşa etmeyi gerektirebilir ancak çevik süreçlerde işin

N itekim Sarayburnu önünde tecrübe dabşlarını başarı ile tam am byan bu iki gemi, 1888 yılında çürüklüğe bağlanacak ve bu şeküde denizaltıcılık