Hakemli Makale: Çocukların Cezai Sorumluluğu ve Yargılanmalarındaki Özellikler Üzerine Bir İnceleme
38
0
0
Tam metin
(2) .
(3) VE A SURVEY ON PENAL LIABILITY OF MENTALLY DISTURBED AND THE PROPERTIES OF THEIR JUDGMENT PROCESS ACCORDING TO TURKISH LAW. Halil POLAT. Özet:
(4) .
(5)
(6) .
(7)
(8)
(9) ! " # ! $%&' ()* $%'+ ,)* $&.$/ )) *
(10) .
(11) ! ! " "
(12) 0# !
(13)
(14)
(15) Anahtar Sözcükler: 0 !
(16) Summary: 1 # 2 !
(17) #
(18) !# #
(19) 3 2 ! # 22 4
(20) # 5 6# 2 " 2 4
(21) # 7 ! #
(22) " 2 4" "
(23) # ! 7 # ()*$%&'! 2
(24) ,)*$%'+! ! ! $&.$ # 822
(25) 6# 7 2" ! .
(26) .
(27) ! ". POLAT. 65. ##*#
(28) 4 ! # 6 "# "##2
(29) 4 # 2
(30) ( 2 " 2
(31) . # !2
(32) " Keywords: , # 2 # " #
(33) #
(34) ". ! " ! # $$ ! %
(35) ! ! ! ! & ! # ! $ $$ $ $ ' % 1 ( # ! $$ $ $$ ) $$ $ $ ( # ! ! $% # # ** +$
(36) % ! # $$$%$ # ! , #$ ! !$ $ $ $ ! . " ! ! ! % # ! " ! # $$ ! " $ $$ ! . % 2 + $ ! /034 5$ % $$ $ $ % ! 1 2. 6 7 & 8 . 79% ,
(37)
(38)
(39) " " " ) ( ! 0::; 3/3 " & <) 5$ % 5 , $$ % & ( &$$ = AÜEHFD **
(40) > >??; >.
(41) 66.
(42) . /034 5$ % 3> $$ $ $$ % $% % ! % #% %. ) ! ! $$ . % ! #% $$ ! "$ $ ! % $ “seçenek $
(43)
(44) $ $ . $ $$ $ $ # #% % " ! /034 5$ % $% $$ $ $$ $$ $ $$ % % $ #% % . % #% " ! %
(45) ( # $$ % ! ! # ! ! ! % 3 ( ! %
(46)
(47) ! #
(48) , ! % ! ! ! ! ! . 4. 3 4. B C D 7D E# 7D ) $ Ceza Hukuku Ge E#% E F " 5 ! D 0::? F;3 & )
(49)
(50)
(51) ! "
(52) # "
(53) $
(54) %
(55)
(56)
(57) $
(58)
(59) & ! # B G
(60) " C $$ & D ! + & " + )$ I 5 % ( ! 0::J 0.
(61) ! ". POLAT. 67. " ! ! . ! % " ! ! ! % % 6 " B , &
(62) #% F:73' # ! ! ! / $ $ . ! #% ! K ! # J 5$ ! >?;0 D ! 4 D 4J/ 5$ % ! % % % ! ! % /3 ! C # ! ; 0>>>>?4? ' ( $$ $ /3?/ , 0::/ $$ $ 00/3 , B E# ) M & N F> kavra
(63) #% F> # <Bu kanundaki küçük !
(64)
(65) !$ )* + ,". / J 4. ;. D 7E# 7) $ F;F 78 . 7, 3/> & >?;0 D ! % <$$= ! % <= #% 9 >? 0F /: <$$= Q F> J> J0 N ! . !
(66) % $$ " ! %.
(67) 68.
(68) . 00/3 ! ! > & % 0::/ $$ $ 4J/ 5$ % $$ $ /034 5$ % ! # % # ! #
(69)
(70) #% J >7! ! # "
(71) ! ! !!
(72) + $% >; . $$ $$ ! " % /3?/ , R,S 37>' $$ # "
(73) ! . + !!
(74) / !!,E#$ $ $ ! /3?/ , + $$ $ ! /034 5 /3?/ , $$ $% >; ! ! % . $$ ?
(75)
(76)
(77) ( ! ! # % ! $$ $ $$ ! % # % ! % # % ! ! $% 9 % $% /034 5$ % >0 %
(78) >0 ! % ! " 4J/ 5 # >> 4J/ 5 /37> B # >> ! % % % ?. N ! . $. % $% >; $ $ ,$$ % .
(79) ! ". POLAT. 69. " ! % $$ $ $$ $$ $ $$ # % % C ! % ! ! ! $ $ 5 ! % ! % ! % >: U 0 1 #
(80) ! % ! ! $$ % ! ! !$$ ! $$ # $ ! $$ % ! ! . % % % ! # ! ( $% !$ # ! 11. . 1.. Genel Olarak. ) $$ $ $ $% /034 5$ % ' 3> $% " 2)34!$ ! !!
(81)
(82)
(83)
(84)
(85) $
(86)
(87) ,&
(88) !
(89)
(90) 5
(91) 6 . . !+
(92) .
(93) . +, >:. 11. " D < % & ) $$ $ $$ C = +% C $ G
(94) " C $$ & D ! + & V )$ I 5 % 0::4 > 6 W <,
(95) '$$ $', B (. % B$ = 7 48 XY
(96) > >?F? ?/ .
(97) 70.
(98) . 2934!$ ! !!
(99)
(100)
(101) ! + !!
(102) !$:
(103)
(104) ;
(105) . ! 6 ! $ . < !
(106)
(107)
(108) $
(109)
(110) ,= +
(111) !
(112) 6 . . !+
(113)
(114) ,7!$:
(115)
(116) ;
(117) . . +
(118) :. ! 6 ! $ $< !+
(119) !
(120) $ ++ .!$ !! ! + 5++ .!$ !!!
(121) ! + !
(122)
(123) ,>$ ! +
(124) <!: !! / , 2?34!$ ! + !!
(125)
(126)
(127) ! !!
(128) !
(129) $ ++ .!$ !! ! !6 5++ .!$ !! ! + !
(130)
(131) ,>$ + ! +
(132) <!: ! / , $% ! " $$ $% /034 5$ % $$ $ $$ $ " >0 ! R5 3>7>S >0 12 % ! ! >3 12. >3. /034 5$ % ! 4J/ 5 % >> R4J/ 5 /37>S " >?34 ( 4 >?3: ( >F >?F; U >0 >?/: ) 4 >?J; " >F >?J> B >F >?/> ) >F >??J U N >F ! D 7E# 7) $ F;F D 7E# 7) $ F;4Q % ! D % R
(133) . %!S >? # <N $% >F ! = N ) 7E. . V )*8 )@I) = #
(134)
(135) " ) ( ! 0::? >;Q <D % >F >F R S ! ! ! % = & '& $ <E#
(136) W , RD 5$S % & ) RC , % D% Q " D " E N % D 5$ ( Z=4 =
(137)
(138) >.
(139) ) ) >
(140) 0 [ 0:>: 03 R, \ 9% .
(141) ! ". 71. POLAT. N ! #%$ $ ! ! ! ( Z >0 ! >/ ! " ! Z # % C ! ! Z % N ! #%$ $ ! % C ! ! Z 14 % ##$ $ $ " 5 J> # G$$ ! >/ >; " ! % ! ! >; # % ! ! . . "#$%&'&()*+ $,-(-/0)"%2$2-, 0$( &,&0*%* 0&,3&( 43420*%. . $ *5$&/%"20"0"3#-6-()$( /034 5 3> > . # >0 % ! ' >/ " % % N -. 14 >/. 9% S " #% K % ! ! . . <, /034 5 3>7> % >0 ! /30J ! >>7> ! Z % >/ % ! !# ! ! % >/ ! = ) J>.
(142) 72.
(143) . ! #%$ $ ! ! ! ! % . ! ! + Z >0 ! ! >J N ! >0 ! ! ! >0 ! >4 C >0 !$$ . $. $$ ! " $% >; ,$$ # $. ! # ! >? !$$ % " # >3 #$ ! #$$ ! $$ # # ! . N % ! $% #% 0: ! ! % 21 ! . # ! !>J. >4. >; >? 0:. 21. (%% 9%
(144)
(145)
(146) F "
(147) ) D 0::? 3/4Q " 9% $7B . U C J.
(148)
(149)
(150)
(151) !+
(152)
(153)
(154) >: "
(155) ) D 0::; 03FQ D ! %
(156) +# % 7
(157) C K. +
(158)
(159)
(160) E ** >0 " " ) ( ! C >??? >/?Q D 7 E# 7) $ F;4Q
(161) $ + #
(162)
(163) L" ) ( ! 0::4 /: D ! % ).
(164) % " J.
(165) ! "
(166)
(167)
(168)
(169) 0 " D 0::/ 3>3 , D 5 $ $ ! ! B 5
(170)
(171)
(172) ! "
(173) M . !+ Marmara G
(174) " C $$ & D ! + & " + )$ I 5 % ( ! 0::; /J /04> B 07>'. $$ #
(175)
(176) !!. +
(177) + ! . . 4J/ 5 /3.
(178) ! ". POLAT. 73. $$$22 &. ! % ,$$ ! ! ! ) ! ! ! #$ $ 03 ! ! $$ $ $ $$ $ $$ . $$ >0 $$ . /04> B 00373' % 24 748*(0&3*)7&%0*%&#-6-()$( aa. Genel Olarak /034 5 3> . # $% >; -. 22. 03 24. > . < ! = % < = D ! % Y 9% 9%! 7 B 6 !7V " %7 + 7( 5
(179)
(180)
(181) &. 2 30 "
(182) ) D 0:>: 0>;Q " ! #$ # <^ % /04> B 07>'. ! .
(183)
(184) ! ! ! ! " 5 3>7> % /04> B = 5 /3'/F ) 0: &+ 5 0:30::J C 0::J703:J 0::J73J3> ! $% ! R % S <" ! % ! , >> ! #%$ $ ! ! & ! ! % ! ! D ! ! ! . = B C. <, %
(185) =
(186) G
(187) " C $$ & D ! + )$ I 5 % 0::; J3'JF.
(188) 74.
(189) . #%$ $ ! $ ! " " $ $$% ,$$ . Q . # #%$ $ ! ! B # ! ! N . B 00373' % $ ! verilecektir 77
(190) 9:"0$($7&0*;*348*(0&3*)7&%0*%& , #%$ $ ! /034 5 /J :3:40::/ 5 /3?/ , R,S $%
(191) #% >> # &
(192) #
(193) ! !
(194)
(195)
(196) ! !+
(197)
(198)
(199)
(200) $
(201)
(202) + !
(203) 6 .. !+ ,
(204) $$ /3?/ , 37>' 0
(205) #% $ # $$ <#
(206) !
(207) . +:!$!! !
(208)
(209)
(210)
(211) ! !$:! ! ! . !+
(212) $
(213) .
(214) $$ ! , / $% " # ! # # ! ! ! " Q.
(215) ! ". POLAT. 75. a.> !+ ! Q #%$$ # b.N$!+ ! $$% $ Q ! ! ! #% # ;& !+ ! ! # _ ` #% ! % ! ) % $ !+ Z% $ !!` ! ! ! B e.& !+ ! ! )# ! 5 ! ! ! ! #% ! . _ Q ! " . ! . ! ! ! ! R, /73S. . "#$%&'&()*+ $,-(-/0)"%2", 0"< + $,-(-/0)"%2$2-, 0$( &,&0*%*0&,3&( 43420*%. /034 5 3> 0 . # 4!$ ! !!
(216)
(217)
(218) ! + !!
(219) !$:
(220)
(221) ;
(222) . ! 6 ! $ . < !
(223)
(224)
(225) $
(226)
(227) ,= +
(228) !
(229) 6 .. !+
(230)
(231) ,7!$:
(232)
(233) ;
(234) . +
(235) :. ! 6 ! $ $< !+
(236) -.
(237) 76.
(238) . !
(239) $ ++ .!$ !! ! + 5++ .!$ !!!
(240) ! + !
(241)
(242) ,>$ ! +
(243) <!: !! / ,
(244) >0'>/ ! ! Z % . . N ! % ##$ $ # % b ! #% Z 0/
(245) >0 >/ % ! Z # 6($=*=*(*>&(&("0"("<"0"(2$)->-(-(*6<&=& + . #$ . + ! $$ Z # ! ! . . ! d B # +
(246) .
(247)
(248)
(249)
(250) $
(251)
(252)
(253) !$
(254) < / ! !,= +
(255) +! 6 $ !+
(256)
(257) !
(258) $
(259)
(260)
(261) O $!
(262)
(263)
(264) !
(265) ,"
(266) < . +
(267)
(268)
(269)
(270) $
(271)
(272) + . $!$ !!! , + ! % % . . ! ! ! # ! # ! ! . ! . ! ! ! $ . . ! . 0J ) 0/ 0J. 9%
(273)
(274)
(275) 3/? " % 9%
(276)
(277)
(278) 3J:Q B 7( G%$ % Türk Ceza Hu
(279)
(280) 0 "
(281) ) D 0::? 3>JQ 78 . 7.
(282) ! ". POLAT. 77. ! # P P6 ! !$ !!5*9?I #( ?)Q9, !! ! )9 !!
(283)
(284)
(285) ! )* !!
(286) !:
(287)
(288)
(289) . +
(290) :. ! 6 ! $ $ ! $ !+
(291)
(292) !
(293) $
(294)
(295) O $!
(296)
(297)
(298) !
(299) . +
(300) !$ ! / !
(301)
(302)
(303) $
(304)
(305) + . ! !.6 6O
(306) ! !
(307)
(308) 5 $ !$
(309)
(310) /
(311) !$ !,9I #% . $ % . . M ! ! $$ Z # . $$ $ $ $ ! ! #% ) % #$ ! ! C #% . % ! [ ! 9 ! ! -. 04. , 3/?Q & 4Q 5 + !
(312)
(313)
(314) J "
(315) ) D 0::? 303Q <" # ! # Z ! # #$ ! ' . = Y 9% 9%! Türk Ceza Kanunun = #7 L * F " D 0:>: /J;Q D + /:Q " . Z D 7E# 7) $ # < $$ ! #% # , Z ! Z # ! !
(316) ! + >0'>/ ! ! #% #$ ! = D 7E# 7 ) $ F?> ) > + 0F:40::; 5 04447J04/ S#> 3F
(317) >> 0::; 00/; R6 9%! #( = /J;S.
(318) 78.
(319) . ! $$ ! ! R S ! % ,$$ ! ! ! % ! $ % E#$$ ! ! % $ $ + . ! . % ! ! #$ % ! " # # #$ % ,$$ ! # ! . "# ! & . . $% #$$ $ ! + ! !# ! # % ! % & Z # % Z ! D ! 9 # $ Z # . % ! + Z ! " ! Z # . N ! #%$ $ ! $ R5 3>70S " #%$ $ ! -.
(320) ! ". POLAT. 79. % 0; " ! % , / $$ $% ! " ! Z # % N ! 5 J> $$ 5 3>70 $$ ! % " . $ $$ $ ! , $. $ B 0>;70 $$ $% ! 0?. . ? "#$%&'&()*+ $,-(-/0)"%2", 0"< +@$,-(-/0)"%2$2-, 0$( &,&0*%*0&,3&( 43420*%. /034 5 3> 3 . # 4!$ ! + !!
(321)
(322)
(323) ! !!
(324) !
(325) $ ++ .!$ !! ! !6 5++ .!$ !! ! + !
(326)
(327) ,>$ + ! +
(328) <!: ! / , B # ! ! ` ! Q ! # ! " ! % . . ! D% ! % $ . 0; 0?. D 9%
(329)
(330)
(331) 3J> 78 . 7, 3/4.
(332) 80.
(333) . " # . K % " % ! . . % ##$ $ $3:. .
(334)
(335)
(336) VE
(337)
(338)
(339)
(340)
(341) A . . . ) $$ $ $ % % ! $ $$ ! % % % $ ! $$ . #$ " ! $$ $ $$ % % $ #% %. .
(342)
(343)
(344)
(345) A . . . + -6$4%*0& $<&6 *5$0$%-($*#*(*3$<=-%-20$% #-6-()$($, 4#4304>4(4($,-)->-A5*00&30*%. . /034 5 /:7> # $ % 3> $ #% # > . ! 9 $ % % -. 3: 3>. ( 7C D &
(346)
(347)
(348) 0 F " " ) ( ! 0::4 >4J /034 5 F?70 $$ # ! + ! !.
(349) ! ". POLAT. 81. ! " ! D 3 . # <> 6 U !
(350)
(351) U
(352)
(353) . ! :!$ !!
(354) + ++
(355)
(356) U!!$+ ! + / ! ! + " $$ # Z >; ! % $ % 5 /:7> . ! % " ! $$ ##$ $ + $$ ! % $ % % ! $$ 30 & $$ $ % 5 /:73 $$ 5 /:7> $$ % 5 /07F' $ $$ $ ) $$ $. $ % % ! % % # # ` % $ % ,$$ /04/ % E$ 5 ! (. % & >:J7F . # "
(357) ! ! !; 6! < !+
(358) ,&
(359) !! + /
(360) .
(361) ,
(362) #%$ >> . # <7 / ! !;
(363) . !; <
(364)
(365) & $ +
(366)
(367) ,&
(368) V)@? == J
(369) ! #
(370) .6 !; !, 5 $ % % # -. 30. D 9%
(371)
(372)
(373) 3J>.
(374) 82.
(375) . Q J>;3 # 33. . %=*0*2*4*66*6*6&#-6-()$($, 4#4304>4(4( $,-)->-A5*00&30*%. . /034 5 />7> . # 7!$
(376) ! ! U! +,&
(377) :!$ ! !!
(378) + + + ! !, " $$ # Z >; ! % $ % Q Z $% >; ! $ % $ % 9 >; # $ % 3 % ! ! " # >; ! . . *00& $30$%- "00$(2$3=$(/36"(-%$3-02$ 43420*%& #-6-()$($, 4#4304>4(4($,-)->-A5*00&30*%. >; % /034 5 /37> . ! 9 / % ! % 5 /37> $$ ! ! ! $ N F . # # :!$ ! !!
(379) ! + /
(380) .
(381) , " $$ # $% >; >; ! 33. + $ . . % # % #% .
(382) ! ". 83. POLAT. % 5 /37> ! ! 3F. . ? *3*%%4%4*66*6&#-6-()$($, 4#4304>4(4( $,-)->-A5*00&30*%. . /034 5 /;7> $$ # # $$ ! _ $ $$ D / . # 4!$ ! !!
(383) !$
(384) !
(385) .
(386) , + $% >; $ $$ % " $ # . >; # # $ ! # >; 9 . >4 ! R >; ! . %S ! >4 $ ( . >; % ,$$ # >; ! . . . $2$($,-2-4%*0*%&#-6-()$($, 4#4304>4(4( $,-)->-A5*00&30*%. .
(387) $$ ! ! $ % . % . ! " ! ! ! $ % % 3/. 3F 3/. " >; 5 /37> $$ % + ! J4;.
(388) 84.
(389) . 8 " ! . ve . + % ! ! ! $ % % % $$ $$ $$ ! % ! ! $ . % + % $$ 5 JJ J4 Q % % $$ 5 J; $% 5 JJ70 $$ # 4!$ ! !!
(390)
(391)
(392) ! + !!
(393) ! +
(394) 5 + !!
(395)
(396)
(397) ! !!
(398) ! .
(399) ! !, " $$ # ' N >0 >/ % $ 9 >F . ! . % % % $ >/ 4/ ' N >/ >; % $ 073 9 >J . ! . % % % $ >/ >: " # .
(400) ! !, ##$ $$ . % ! ! % . % ! # . % $ % % 3J ! % % $ . % % -. 3J. & &
(401)
(402)
(403) ; "
(404) ) D 0::? /33Q 7G%$ % J>3.
(405) ! ". 85. POLAT. ! $ $$ % % ! 34 % % $ 5 J;7> $$ ! D 0 . # 4!$ ! !!
(406)
(407)
(408) ! + !!
(409) ! +
(410) 5 + !!
(411)
(412)
(413) ! !!
(414) ! . / ! " $$ # Z ! $ Q ! % $ % % $ " . B # 9 >4 ! . ! 03 % >J R0F $ S % % $ !. .
(415)
(416)
(417)
(418)
(419) A . . + $2"$8$6-(-(#-02$6-(-(%=*0*(2*6& 43420*%&#-6-()$(. . . /04> % B >4>70 . # 9*? !! !
(420)
(421)
(422) /
(423)
(424)
(425)
(426)
(427)
(428)
(429)
(430) <+ $
(431) + ! .
(432) ! ! $ $
(433) ! + +D F . # N ! +
(434) !$ !!
(435)
(436) !$ " $$ # $ / ! $ ! N -. 34.
(437) " *9?I% S # !
(438)
(439)
(440) D ) D 0::4 >3>F.
(441) 86.
(442) . ! $ >; / 3 R, >?S. . 4324(#-30$(2$6-(-(*%&-%$3-02$6- 43420*%&#-6-()$(. . . B 03>7/ $$ # % $
(443) ! .
(444) !
(445) ! !; 5 . + +/3?/ , 03 # “Ço
(446) $
(447) ! .
(448) ! 8
(449) #
(450)
(451) !
(452) $ ! .+ +,= +
(453) ! ! !" $$ # $$ ! $ / ! 3
(454) A , % . % ! #% ! " # ! #% ! . % . % #% $$ $% " ! ! % %
(455)
(456) A + /%",="%2$9-$<$;$3$3$2#-6-()$( /3?/ , >/ # %
(457)
(458) !
(459)
(460)
(461) +
(462) ! .6
(463)
(464) / -.
(465) ! ". POLAT. 87. dan bizzat " $$ # # ! !%%. . 3; 9 . !
(466) $$ . . . 3?
(467) !%% . # D " % ( E B$$ $ $$ :>:>0::J 0 . F: 9 ! % !$ $ $ ! % #% ! ! $$ # 41 N ! % $$ $ #% . ! ! . ! #% . !%% . 42 /;">"(B$)*6&(&(0-(2$6-
(468) 6"04#-6-()$( ) % % $% $$ .
(469) . !%% /3?/ 3;. 3?. F: 41 42. <"%% . # . . $$ . = 6 7N ) 7D 6 8
(470)
(471)
(472)
(473) > 0 8
(474)
(475)
(476)
(477) " >4 " " ) ( ! 0::? /3>'/30 < . ! # ! E# % % ! $$ = D >>/
(478) #% $$ !% & V J.
(479) !
(480)
(481) % N# + 0 " D ) D 0::? ;4> " 9% $7Y 9% 9%! 7B . U C J.
(482) 8
(483)
(484)
(485)
(486) 4 "
(487) ) D 0::0 >>/4 & )
(488) $ < % ) & ,
(489) ==WEHFD Y***
(490) >'0 ) 0::F F.
(491) 88.
(492) . , >/70 $$ # "
(493) $
(494) / !
(495) ! !$ !
(496) $
(497) ! .6 +
(498)
(499) !
(500)
(501) +, " . !
Benzer Belgeler
• Genel olarak okul öncesi dönemin bilişsel gelişim açısından önemli olduğu (Üstün & Akman, 2003) ve bilimsel süreç becerisi daha çok fen ve doğa köşesinde
Future experiments are needed to resolve heat shock protein genes regulation, function, response to environmental change, and their action at the molecular level leading to aquatic
Oluşturulan bu model, manyetik alanlarla ilgili varolan pek çok soru işaretinin tümünü ortadan kaldırmasa da, gerçeğe çok yakın bir senaryo yaratılmasında çok
Süreçte, öncelikle alt kriterlere göre oluşturulan karşılaştırma matrislerinin VZAHP ağırlıkları hesaplanmış ve Tablo 3’te maliyet ana kriterinin alt kriterlerine
Fut- bolcular oynadıkları mevkilere göre gruplara ayrıldığında, savunma ve orta saha oyuncu- ları arasında boy ve vücut ağırlığı ortalama- sı arasında fark görülmesine
Views of Medicine Faculty Academic Staff to Medical Ethics Education (Gazi University Case). Traner CB, Tolchin DW, Tolchin B. Medical Ethics Education for Neu- rology
Figure 1 : Distribution of the opinions of the physicians on the effectiveness of generic drugs 21 % of the physicians participated in the survey state that the bioequivalent
Bizim çalışmamızdaki EEG kayıtlarında, keskin ve diken dalga aktiviteleri sıklıkla frontal ve temporal bölgelerde, yavaş dalga aktiviteleri ise daha çok frontal bölgelerde
