1
SAVUNUCULUK
VE
FEBÃJÃA7B7H?;JAÃB;C;
Dkh^WdO[djha
BWZ[dOkhjjW]b[h
O_Â_j7aiWaeÂbk
Ãh\WdD[p_heÂbk
>WX_fAeYWcWd
;Xhk7ÂZka
2 143,3!3*3)4#.-*Í2Í)*0'#2)Í*#+# -TQG@M8DMS}QJ+@CDM8TQSS@F}KDQ8HÌHS JR@JNÌKTÎQE@M-DYHQNÌKT'@AHO*NB@L@M$AQT ÌCTJ ¨RS@MATK!HKFHdMHUDQRHSDRH8@X©MK@Q© 23*`@KÀÐL@K@QÀÔ$ÌHSHL*HS@OK@QÀ '1 ,ÕÕÕÕ !@RJ©¨RS@MATK.B@J !HKFH¨KDSH«HL&QTAT8@X©MB©K©J,}YHJ8@O©LUD'@ADQ I@MR©+SC ªSH 8@Y©«L@ CQDRH¨MxM}"@CCDRH-N *T«SDODªH«KH¨RS@MATK 3DKDENMÔ%@JR www.bilgiyay.com #ÕNMQR? yayin@bilgiyay.com "?ʨR¨K dagitim@bilgiyay.com
"GXG#BGRwP| 7?W¿L?&?X¿PJ?W?L Nurhan Yentürk )?N?ITC)GR?N2?Q?P¿K¿'}L@MTQ!@ÌKÀ "GXEGTC3WESJ?K?,@Q@SNM#HYFHDUH "|XCJRG1DLYH AA@R ?QI¿TC!GJR2DM@.ERDS LA@K@IUD,@SA@@BÀKÀJ2@M 3HB +SC ÏSH +HSQNR8NKT ,@SA@@BÀK@Q2HSDRH!!KNJ*@S-N-!ÔÔ3NOJ@OÀÎRS@MATK 3DKDENMÔ%@JR
‹stanbul Bilgi University Library Cataloging-in-Publication Data ¬RS@MATK!HKFHdMHUDQRHSDRHS@Q@EMC@MJ@S@KNFK@ML¯SQ
Yentürk, Nurhan.
2@UTMTBTKTJUDONKHSHJ@K@QÄDSJHKDLD-TQG@M8DMS}QJ:DS@KK < p. cm.
ISBN 978-605-399-135-9 (pbk.)
1. Advocacy - Turkey. 2. Social justice. 3. Non-governmental organizations - Turkey 4. Social advocacy - Turkey. 5. NGOs. 6. Civil society – Turkey.
3
ÖNSÖZ
IJAwWbÚÅcWbWhÚ#;Â_j_cA_jWfbWhÚ:_p_i_½d[^eÅ][bZ_d_p$ ÃijWdXkb8_b]_{d_l[hi_j[i_IJA;Â_j_cl[7hWÅjÚhcW8_h_c_½d_d"IJA½bWh__dZp[db[Z_Â_aWfWi_j[][b_Åj_hc[[Â_j_cb[h_ (&&)oÚbÚdZWXWÅbWcWZWddY["p[bb_ab[^Waj[c[bb_WbÚÅWdIJA½bWhÚd_^j_oWbWhÚdW]h[oWpÚbcÚÅ"XkIJA½bWhÚdZ[d[o_c l[WbÚÅcWabjhb[h_d_Z_aaWj[WbWd"[Â_j_cb[h_[ja_daÚbcWa__d][h[ab_oWpÚbÚZ[hicWj[hoWb_d_d[ai_ab_Â_"ead[cb_X_h iehkdebWhWaaWhÅÚcÚpWÚajÚ$;Â_j_cb[hih[i_dY[[Â_jc[db[h_c_p_d^WpÚhbWZÚabWhÚZ[hidejbWhÚ"Z[hib[hZ[a_jWhjÚÅcWbWhl[ aWjÚbÚcYÚbWhÚdZ[d[o_cb[h_ob[][b_Åj_"eb]kdbWÅjÚl[IJA½bWhZWWbÚÅWd]dbboWZWfhe\[ioed[bb[h_dakbbWdWX_b[Y[ab[h_ oWpÚbÚaWodWabWh^Wb_d[ZdÅj$8k][b_Åc[l[[Â_j_cfhe]hWcbWhÚdWaWjÚbWcWoWdIJA½bWhÚdoeÂkd_ij[ab[h_p[h_d[" ÃijWdXkb8_b]_{d_l[hi_j[i_½dZ[IJAwWbÚÅcWbWhÚ#;Â_j_cA_jWfbWhÚ:_p_i_p[h_d[WbÚÅcWoWXWÅbWZÚa$ 8kZ_p_d_d_baWÅWcWiÚ(&&-oÚbÚdZWjWcWcbWdZÚl[X[ÅjWd[i_j[b_\_a_jWd[i_j[hYc[a_jWfebcWap[h[o[Z_a_jWfoW# oÚcbWdZÚ$J[b_\a_jWfbWh"Fhe`[:d]iOd[j_c_?0Fhe`[j[ab_\_oWpcW"_pb[c[l[Z[Â[hb[dZ_hc[1Fhe`[:d]iOd[j_- c_??08j[b[c["Z[Â[hb[c["hWfehbWcW1IJA½bWh__dCk^Wi[X["<_dWdicWdl[L[h]_Ko]kbWcWbWhÚdW=_h_Å1=dbb-b[hb[ÃÅX_hb_Â_1IjhWj[`_a:Ådc[#IjhWj[`_=[b_Åj_hc[XWÅbÚabWhÚdÚjWÅÚcWajWZÚhbWh$J[hYc[a_jWfbWhiW"7lhkfWAedi[# o_OWoÚdbWhÚjWhW\ÚdZWdXWiÚbWd[Â_j_caÚbWlkpbWhÚdZWdJ#A_ji_a_i_d_dj[hYc[i_Z_h0zh]jOd[j_c_l[AWodWa=[b_Åj_h-c[l[<edOd[j_c_$ (&&/oÚbÚdZWIJAwWbÚÅcWbWhÚ#;Â_j_cA_jWfbWhÚ:_p_i_½d_d_a_dY_WÅWcWiÚdÚjWcWcbWZÚa$Ãa_dY_WÅWcWZW_a_a_jWfo[h WbZÚ$8kdbWhÚdX_h_dY_i_7lhkfWAedi[o_OWoÚdbWhÚjWhW\ÚdZWdXWiÚbWd[Â_j_caÚbWlkpbWhÚdZWdJ#A_jiIeioWb:ÚÅbWdcW½dÚd j[hYc[i_"_a_dY_i__i[78"8jdb[Åc[l[IJA½bWhXWÅbÚabÚa_jWfjÚh$:_p_d_ddYl[iedWÅWcWiÚdZWIWlkdkYkbkal[ Feb_j_aWbWhÚ;ja_b[c[XWÅbÚabÚ[Â_j_ca_jWXÚdÚoWoÚcbÚoehkp$ IJAwWbÚÅcWbWhÚ#;Â_j_cA_jWfbWhÚ:_p_i_jWcWcbWdZÚÂÚdZW"IJAaWfWi_j[][b_Åj_hc[fhe]hWcbWhÚdÚebkÅjkhkha[dl[ih# Zhha[dIJA½bWhÚd_^j_oWZkoZkabWhÚdÚ]hZÂcpl[fhe]hWcbWhÚcÚpWZW^_b[jj_Â_c_pjcZ[hib[h_da_jWXWZdÅc[# i_d_iWÂbWcÚÅebWYWÂÚp$:_Â[hoWdZWdIJA½bWh__dkpWajWd[Â_j_cWÂÚhbÚabÚihZhZÂcpaWfWi_j[][b_Åj_hc[fhe]hWc# bWhÚdZWakbbWdZÚÂÚcÚp]hi[bl[_Å_ji[bcWbp[c[b[h__[h[dIJA;Â_j_c9:½b[h_d[Z[^jjf0%ija$X_b]_$[Zk$jhWZh[i_dZ[dkbW# ÅWX_b_hi_d_p$7lhkfWAedi[o_OWoÚdbWhÚebWd[Â_j_caÚbWlkpbWhÚ"7lhkfWAec_ioedkl[7lhkfWAedi[o_jWhW\ÚdZWdohjb[d =[d;a_f;Â_j_c___dEhjWabÚaFhe]hWcÚ½dÚdhdb[h_Z_h$8kehjWaWbÚÅcWbWhbW_b]_b_ZW^W\WpbWX_b]_WbcWa__dmmm$ jhW_d_d]#oekj^$d[ji_j[i_d_p_oWh[j[Z[X_b_hi_d_p$ IJAwWbÚÅcWbWhÚ#;Â_j_cA_jWfbWhÚ:_p_i_"IJA;Â_j_cl[7hWÅjÚhcW8_h_c_½d_dÃijWdXkb8_b]_{d_l[hi_j[i_OWoÚdbWhÚ½obWeh# jWaohjjÂX_hWbÚÅcWZÚh$8kZ_p_[h[l[i_dZ[oWoÚcbWdWYWaebWda_jWfbWhÚ^jjf0%ija$X_b]_$[Zk$jhl[^jjf0%mmm$X_b]_# oWo$YecWZh[ib[h_dZ[d_pb[o[X_b_hi_d_p$ JcXkoWoÚdbWhÚh[jc[c_p_dWcWYÚ"IJA½bWhÚd[lh[b[h_dZ[]hZab[h_iehkdbWhWod[b_aebWhWa[ja_b_l[kpkdZd[cb_ pcb[hXkbcWih[Y_dZ[Waj_\ebWX_bc[b[h_1o[h[b"kbkiWbl[kbkibWhWhWiÚod[j_cb[h_iehkdbWhÚdpcb[h___d][h[ab_ feb_j_aWbWhÚh[jc[o[odb[dZ_h[X_bc[b[h_WcWYÚobWIJA½bWhWZ[ij[aebcWal[IJA½bWhÚdJha_o[½d_dZ[ceahWj_ab[Åc[i_d# Z[d[cb_X_hWajhebcWbWhÚdWaWjaÚZWXkbkdcWajÚh$ ÃijWdXkb8_b]_{d_l[hi_j[i_IJA;Â_j_cl[7hWÅjÚhcW8_h_c_½d_dakhkbcWiÚl[_^j_oWbWhÚdÚdaWhÅÚbWdcWiÚaedkikdZW[d XoaZ[ij[Â_l[hZ_${d_l[hi_j[d_dWaWZ[c_al[jc_ZWh_aWZheikIJA½bWhZWd[Â_j_cfhe]hWcbWhÚdWaWjÚbWd^[ha[i[ akYWaWjÚl[d_l[hi_j[d_dÂh[dY_b[h_dZ[diWoZÚ$Jcd[j[Å[aah[Z[h_c$8_h_c_d\WWb_o[jb[h_d_d[ci[o_f\_dWdiWb aWjaÚZWXkbkdWdjcZ[ij[a_b[h_c_p[l[a_jWXWZ[Â[hb_aWjaÚbWhÚebWdO7I7:;H½[Z[j[Å[aah[Z[h_c$zp[bj[Å[aahc (&&)oÚbÚdZWd_j_XWh[dihZhZ]cpjc[Â_j_cfhe]hWcbWhÚdÚdaWjÚbÚcYÚbWhÚdW$ Fhe\$:h$Dkh^WdO[djha ÃijWdXkb8_b]_{d_l[hi_j[i_I_l_bJefbkcAkhkbkÅbWhÚ;Â_j_cl[7hWÅjÚhcW8_h_c_:_h[ajh IJAwWbÚÅcWbWhÚ#;Â_j_cA_jWfbWhÚ:_p_i_;Z_jh5
ÃwÃD:;AÃB;H
IKDKÄ0
D;:;DI7LKDK9KBKAAÃJ78?5
%Dkh^WdO[djhal[BWZ[dOkhjjW]b[h$$$$$$$
-
?$8zB{C0
I7LKDK9KBKA"OKHJJ7ÄB?AL;A7J?B?C
%BWZ[dOkhjjW]b[h$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$9 '$OkhjjWÅbÚal[Z[ceahWi__b_Åa_i_$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$9 ($:[ceahWi_l[aWhWhl[hc[%feb_j_aWoWfcWih[b[h_WhWiÚdZWa__b_Åa_$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$11 )$AedkbWhÚdj[ci_b_0DWiÚbl[d[h[Z[5$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$16??$8zB{C0
I7LKDK9KBKAIJH7J;@ÃIÃ
%O_Â_j7aiWaeÂbk$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$'/ '$IWlkdkYkbkal[_b]_b_jWdÚcbWh$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$19 '$'$IWlkdkYkbkad[Z_h5$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$19 '$($Odj[cb[h$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$21 '$)$8WpÚj[c[bWhWbWh0AWcfWdoWl[beX_Y_b_a$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$22 '$*$AWjÚbÚc"^WabWhl[iWlkdkYkbka$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$23 '$+$IJA½bWhl[i_oWi[j$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$(* '$,$Feb_j_aWih[Y_$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$25 ($IWlkdkYkbkaijhWj[`_i_^WpÚhbWcWoW]_h_Å$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$(- ($'$7ZÚcWZÚcijhWj[`_^WpÚhbWcW$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$(- )$IjhWj[`_][b_Åj_hc[$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$33 )$'>[Z[\b[hl[kpkdl[aÚiWZd[cb_WcWbWhÚdX[b_hb[dc[i_$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$33 )$($IC7HJWdWb_p_$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$)* )$)$7ajhb[h_djWdÚcbWdcWiÚ$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$36 )$*$IMEJWdWb_p_$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$38 )$+$Ãb[j_Å_cijhWj[`_i_$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$*'???$8zB{C0
IJA½B7HL;A7DKDO7F?CI{H;9ÃDÃ;JAÃB;C;0
OzDJ;CB;H"zHD;AB;H"zD;HÃB;H
'$I_l_bjefbkckdJha_o[8oaC_bb[jC[Yb_i_½dZ[aWdkdoWfÚcih[Y_d[aWjÚbÚcÚdW _b_Åa_d\ÚhiWjbWhÇÃh\WdD[p_heÂbk$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$*/ '$'$J8CC½Z[aWdkdoWfÚcih[Y_d[i_l_bjefbkcd[Z[daWjÚbcWbÚZÚh5$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$*/ '$($IJA½bWhÚdaWdkdoWfÚcih[Y_d[_b_Åa_daWfWi_j[iehkdk$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$50 '$)$J8CC½Z[oWiWcWih[Y_ob[_b]_b_j[c[baWlhWcbWh$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$51 '$*$J8CC½Z[j[c[bakhkcbWh$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$55 '$+$AWdkdjWiWhÚbWhÚl[aWdkdj[ab_\b[h_d_d^WpÚhbWdcWih[Y_$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$+- '$,$=[d[bebWhWaJ8CC½Z[aWdkdoWfÚcih[Y_$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$60 '$-$J8CC½Z[aec_ioedbWh$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$63 '$.$=dZ[cZÚÅÚaedkÅcW$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$69 '$/$=[d[bAkhkb½ZWaWdkdoWfÚcih[Y_$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$-' '$'&$9kc^khXWÅaWdÚ½dYWedWo$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$-* '$''$H[ic_=Wp[j[½Z[oWoÚcbWdWhWaohhbÂ[]_hc[$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$-* ($FWhbWc[dj[hZ[d[j_c\WWb_o[jb[h_d[i_l_bjefbkcaWjÚbÚcÚÇ>WX_fAeYWcWd$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$-+ ($'$FWhbWc[dj[hZ[d[j_c$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$-- ($($FWhbWc[dj[hZ[d[j_coebbWhÚ$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$-. ($)$:[d[j_c_Åb[l_]h[daec_ioedbWh$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$1026 )$OWiWcWih[Y_dZ[IJAaWjÚbÚcÚ0KbWibWhWhWiÚhd[ab[hÚÅÚÂÚdZW Jha_o[½Z[a_Zkhkcl[d[h_b[hÇ;Xhk7ÂZka$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$119 )$'$AWjÚbÚcd[Z_h5$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$119 )$($AWjÚbÚcif[ajhkck$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$121 )$)$AWjÚbÚcih[Y_dZ[j[c[bebWd_ba[b[h$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$'(* )$*$AWjÚbÚcÚdddZ[a_[d][bb[h$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$'(- )$+$w[Å_jb_ba[b[hZ[aWjÚbÚcko]kbWcWbWhÚ$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$128 )$,$AWjÚbÚcWod[b_aJha_o[½Z[lWhebWdoWiWb[h[l[$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$129 )$-$J8CC½Z[aWjÚbÚcc[aWd_pcWbWhÚdÚ]b[dZ_hc[a__dd[h_b[h$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$131 )$.$=[d[bZ[Â[hb[dZ_hc[$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$')*
?L$8zB{C0
A7CK>7H97C7B7H?D?DÃPB;DC;IÃ0IJA½B7HÃwÃD
O;DÃ8ÃHI7LKDK9KBKA7B7D?
%Dkh^WdO[djha$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$135 '$I_l_bjefbkcakhkbkÅbWhÚl[aWck^WhYWcWbWhÚdÚd_pb[dc[i_0D[Z[dl[dWiÚb5$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$135 ($AWck^WhYWcWbWhÚdÚ_pb[c[a__dj[c[bX_b]_b[h$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$136 ($'$AkhkcbWh$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$136 ($($AWlhWcbWh$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$'*& ($)$>WhYWcWbWhÚdiÚdÚ\bWdZÚhÚbcWiÚ$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$'*) ($*$weaoÚbbÚXj[b[c[ih[Y_$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$'*, )$Jha_o[½Z[ieioWbaehkcWl[Wia[h_^WhYWcWbWh$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$150 )$'$IeioWbaehkcW^WhYWcWbWhÚdÚd_pb[dc[i_0(&&,#(&''$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$151 )$($7ia[h_^WhYWcWbWhÚd_pb[dc[i_0(&&,#(&''$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$'+- )$)$7ia[h_"ieioWbl[[aedec_a^WhYWcWbWhÚdaWhÅÚbWÅjÚhÚbcWiÚ$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$',*A7OD7AB7H
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$',-:ÃPÃD
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$'-'
-IKDKÄ
D;:;DI7LKDK9KBKAAÃJ78?5
Dkh^WdO[djhal[BWZ[dOkhjjW]b[h 8_b]_IJAakhkbZkÂk]dZ[dX[h_i_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_daWfWi_j[b[h_d_][b_Åj_h[X_bc[b[h___d^[ch]jod[j_c_"^[c Z[aWlhWciWbWbWdbWhZW[Å_jb_[Â_j_cb[hZp[db[c_Åj_h$:p[db[d[d_ba[Â_j_cb[h"h]jb[h_dc_ioedl[l_poedbWhÚdÚjW# dÚcbWcWbWhÚdZWd"aWodWa][b_Åj_hc[b[h_d[1ijhWj[`_afbWdbWcWZWd"_b[j_Å_cj[ad_ab[h_d[aWZWhh]jb[h_d][d[baWfWi_j[# b[h_d_][b_Åj_hc[o_^[Z[\b[c_Åj_h$8_b]_IJA"WohÚYWaWlhWciWbebWhWai_l_bjefbkc"Z[ceahWi_"_diWd^WabWhÚ]_X_aedkbWh# ZWZWo[d_jWhjÚÅcWbWhWcWoÚWcWbWcÚÅjÚh$Ãba[Â_j_cb[h_doWfÚbZÚÂÚZd[cZ["iW^WdÚdj[c[b_^j_oWYÚi_l_bjefbkch# ]jb[h_d_daWfWi_j[i_d_d][b_Å_c_d[l[i_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_dihZhb[X_b_hb_Â_d[aWjaÚZWXkbkdWYWafhe]hWcbWhÚikd# cWajÚ$D_j[a_c(&&)¸(&&*oÚbÚdZWi_l_bWbWdWXWaÚbZÚÂÚdZW"Xk]d[aÚoWibW^[c^Waj[c[bb_WbÚÅWdh]jiWoÚiÚea ZW^WWpZÚh"^[cZ[_b]_b_h]jb[h_d][h[aaWodWa"][h[ai[h]ji[baWfWi_j[b[h_WÚiÚdZWdihZhb[X_b_hb_ab[h_iedZ[# h[Y[iÚdÚhbÚZÚh$7dYWa][[dih[Z[^[c8_b]_IJA"^[cZ[WbWdZWh]jb[h_daWfWi_j[][b_Å_cb[h_d_WcWbWoWdZ_Â[hh# ]jb[hjWhW\ÚdZWdZp[db[d[d_b]_b_fhe]hWcbWhÚdiWoÚiÚdÚdl[[ja_WbWdbWhÚdÚdWhjcWiÚ_b[^Waj[c[bb_WbÚÅWdh]jb[h_d iWoÚiÚdZWl[aWfWi_j[b[h_dZ[WhjÚÅ]pb[dc_Åj_h$zh]jb[h_daWfWi_j[b[h_d_dWhjcWiÚdZW"WbWdWWajWhÚbWdaWodWabWhZWWh# jÚÅl[h]jb[dc[p]hbÂ_b[_b]_b_aWdkdbWhZWa_Z[Â_Å_ab_ab[hZ[iWoÚbWX_b_h$zh]jiWoÚiÚdÚdl[aWfWi_j[i_d_dWhjcWiÚ _i[iW^WZWXWÅaW_^j_oWbWhÚZeÂkhckÅjkh$ =[d[bX_h[h[l[__dZ[WbÚÅWdh]jb[h[Å_jb_WbWdbWhZWkpcWdbWÅcWl[kpcWdbWÅjÚabWhÚWbWdZWZW^WZ[h_dl[kpkd ih[b_jWhjÚÅcWbWhW_^j_oWZkoZkabWhÚdÚX[b_hjc_Åb[hZ_h$>Waj[c[bb_WbÚÅWdoWZW^Waj[c[bb_WbÚÅcWoÚWcWbWoWdh# ]jb[h"^Wa_^bWbb[h_d_[d][bb[c[al[%oW_diWd^Waj[c[bb_Z[Â[hb[haedkikdZW\WhaÚdZWbÚÂÚWhjjÚhcWa__dWbÚÅÚha[d feb_j_aWbWhÚ"fhe]hWcbWhÚl[%oWoWiWbWhÚ[ja_b[c[d_dd[c_d_\Wha[jc_Åb[hZ_h$7odÚZd[cZ["i_l_bWbWdZWa_][b_Åc[b[# h_doWdÚiÚhW"(&&&½b[hXeokdYW^[cZdoWZW"^[cZ[Jha_o[½Z[i_l_bWbWdZWWbÚÅWdh]jb[h_doWiWbWhÚl[feb_j_aWbW# hÚZ[Â_Åj_hc[aedkikdZWa_WXWbWhÚebkcbkiedkbWhl[hc_Åj_h$=[h[ai_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_djWb[fb[h_"][h[ai[c[l# Ykji_oWi_aed`edajh^Waj[c[bb_h]jb[h__diWlkdkYkbkaWbWdÚdZWWbÚÅcWoÚ][h[ab_l[pehkdbkaÚbcÚÅjÚh$8k][b_Å# c[b[hÚÅÚÂÚdZW"i_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_"iWlkdkYkbkaWbWdÚdZWWbÚÅcWl[aWfWi_j[b[h_d_][b_Åj_hc[aedkikdZWfhe]hWc# bWhjWb[f[jc_Åb[hZ_h$ 8_b]_IJA"XkjWb[fb[h_]pdd[WbWhWa"(&&.¸(&&/Zd[c_dZ[iWlkdkYkbkaWbWdÚdZWi_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_daWfW# i_j[b[h_d_][b_Åj_hc[a__diWlkdkYkbkal[feb_j_aWbWhÚ[ja_b[c[aedkikdZWX_hfhe]hWc^WpÚhbWcÚÅjÚh$Fhe]hWcj[c[bi_# l_bjefbkcjWhjÚÅcWbWhÚdÚ[b[WbWdX_haWlhWciWb]_h_Å_b[XWÅbWcÚÅjÚh$7hZÚdZWdh]jod[j_c_d[_b_Åa_dWdWaedkbWhW Z[Â_d_bc_Åj_h$Fhe]hWcÚd_baXbcdZ[^[caWlhWciWb"^[cZ[h]jod[j_c_d[_b_Åa_dj[c[bjWhjÚÅcWbWhoWfÚbcÚÅjÚh$ Fhe]hWcÚd_a_dY_XbcdZ[_i[iWlkdkYkbkaeZWabÚj[c[bjWhjÚÅcWbWhWod[b_dc_Åj_h$;Â_j_cfhe]hWcÚdZWWahWd[Â_# j_c_d[ZWoWbÚX_hodj[cX[d_ci[dc_Åj_h$8kodj[ciWo[i_dZ[aWjÚbÚcYÚbWhX_hX_hb[h_d_dZ[d[o_cb[h_dZ[doWhWhbWdcW _ca~dÚXkbckÅbWhl[fhe]hWcÚd_[h_Â_d[d[cb_X_haWjaÚiWÂbWcÚÅbWhZÚh$;b_d_pZ[a_a_jWf"[Â_j_cfhe]hWcÚdZWoWfÚbWd# ZÚhÚbWdZ[hib[hl[fhe]hWcaWjÚbÚcYÚbWhÚdÚdZ[d[o_cb[h_d[ZWoWdWhWaoWfjÚabWhÚaWjaÚbWhp[h_d[akhkbckÅjkh$A_jWf__d# Z[a_Xbcb[h"[Â_j_cfhe]hWcÚXeokdYWoWfÚbWdZ[hib[h_d_[h_ab[h_"Z[hidejbWhÚl[jWhjÚÅcWbWhÚj[c[bWbÚdWhWaoWfÚbWd# ZÚhÚbcÚÅjÚh$Fhe]hWcÚdiWlkdkYkbkaXbcdZ[a__[h_Â_j[c[bZhjWdWWbWdZWdebkÅcWajWZÚh$ÃbaXbcZ[iWlkdkYkbka aWlhWcÚl[aWjÚbÚcWhWiÚdZWa__b_Åa_d_djWhjÚÅÚbZÚÂÚZ[hib[h"_a_dY_XbcZ[iWlkdkYkbkaoWfcWa__d][h[ab_ebWdijhWj[`_ ][b_Åj_hc[]_X_j[c[bX[Y[h_b[h"dYXbcZ[iWlkdkYkbkaWbÚÅcWiÚdZWd[cb_X_ho[h[iW^_febWdoWiWoWfcWi# h[b[h_l[j[ci_b_Z[ceahWi_o[aWjÚbÚcÚdZdoWZWdhd[ab[h_l[iedXbcZ[_i[iWlkdkYkbkaoWfcWdÚdd[cb_X_hWoW# ÂÚebWdaWck^WhYWcWbWhÚ_pb[c[ih[Y_XkbkdcWajWZÚh$A_jWf"[Â_j_cfhe]hWcÚdÚd_[h_Â__b[ZeÂhkZWd_b_Åa_b[dZ_h_b[h[a akh]kbWdcÚÅjÚh$8kd[Z[db[hb[[b_d_pZ[a_a_jWfZhjXbcZ[debkÅcWajWZÚh$8_h_dY_XbcZ[Laden Yurttagüler½_diWlkdkYkbkaaWlhWcÚl[aWjÚbÚcWhWiÚdZWa__b_Åa_o_jWhjÚÅjÚÂÚoWpÚiÚXkbkdkoeh$8k
8 ][h[ab_ebZkÂkdWZ[Â_d_b_oeh$J[ci_b_Z[ceahWi_ih[Y_dZ[Z_b[][j_h_bc[o[daedkbWhÚddWiÚbl[d[h[Z[]dZ[c[][j_h_b[# X_b[Y[Â_d_djWhjÚÅÚbZÚÂÚXkcWaWb[Z["iedebWhWao[h[b"kbkiWbl[kbkibWhWhWiÚhd[ab[hl[h_b_oeh$ Ãa_dY_XbcZ[O_Â_j7aiWaeÂbk"IJA½bWhÚdiWlkdkYkbkaijhWj[`_b[h_d_ebkÅjkhWX_bc[b[h___doWfcWbWhÚ][h[a[d^WpÚhbÚabW# hÚl[akbbWdWX_b[Y[ab[h_WhWbWhÚ"ko]kbWcWhd[ab[h_d[l[IJA½bWhÚdZ[d[o_cb[h_d[ZWoWdZÚhWhWa[b[WbÚoeh$8kXbc aedkZWdebkÅkoeh$IWlkdkYkbkal[beX_Y_b_a]_X_aedkbWh"_b]_b_jWhjÚÅcWbWhWZ[Â_d_b[h[a[b[WbÚdÚoeh$8bcd_baaedk# ikdZWWcWbWdWd"Z[d[o_cb[hb[_b]_b_hd[ab[hakbbWdWhWa"IJA½bWhÚaedk_b[_b]_b_aWlhWcbWhp[h_d[jWhjÚÅcWoWaWjcWa# jÚh$Ãa_dY_aedkZW_i["IJA½bWhÚdZW^WeaX_haÚbWlkpebWhWaakbbWdWX_b[Y[ab[h_"IJA½bWhÚdiWlkdkYkbkaijhWj[`_i_^WpÚhbW# cWbWhÚdWebWdWaiWÂbWoWdWbÚÅjÚhcWbWho[hWbÚoeh$8kXbcdiedkdZWko]kbWdWX_b_hX_hiWlkdkYkbkaijhWj[`_i_d_h]# jda[dZ_a[dZ_d[^WpÚhbWcWiÚdWebWdWaiWÂbWcWoWod[b_aodb[dZ_hc[b[h[l[ko]kbWcWbWhWo[hl[h_b_oeh$ IJA½bWhÚdoWiWoWfÚcih[Y_d_[ja_b[c[aedkikdZWakbbWdWX_b[Y[ab[h_odj[c"hd[al[d[h_b[h_djWhjÚÅÚbZÚÂÚdYX# bcZ[o[hWbWd"aedk"kpcWdjWhW\ÚdZWdWohÚWohÚebWhWaoWpÚbZÚ$8kXbcdX_h_dY_aedkik"Ãh\WdD[p_heÂbkjWhW# \ÚdZWdoWpÚbWdi_l_bjefbkckdJha_o[8oaC_bb[jC[Yb_i_½dZ[oWiWoWfÚcih[Y_d[aWjÚbÚcÚdW_b_Åa_d\ÚhiWjbWhÚdÚ]dÚÅÚ# ÂÚdWÚaWhcWoÚWcWbWoWdX_hWbÚÅcWZÚh$8kWbÚÅcW"aedk_b[_b]_b_ih[Y[_b_Åa_dX_b]_l[X[Y[h_o_hd[ab[hb[l[d[h_b[h# b[IJA½bWhÚdakbbWdÚcÚdWikdkoeh$8bcd_a_dY_aedkik_i[fWhbWc[dj[hZ[d[j_c\WWb_o[jb[h_d[i_l_bjefbkckdaWjÚbÚcÚ# dÚWhjÚhcWa__dodj[chd[al[d[h_b[h_aWfiÚoeh$8kaedkdkdoWpWhÚ>WX_fAeYWcWd"WbÚÅcWiÚdZWiÚabÚabWZkoZkÂk# ckpc[Yb_iWhWÅjÚhcWiÚ"][diehk"c[Yb_iiehkÅjkhcWiÚlX$Z[d[j_coebbWhÚdÚdIJA½bWhjWhW\ÚdZWd[ja_b[d[X_bc[i_aedk# ikdZWX_b]_b[hl[hd[ab[hl[h_oeh1d[h_b[hZ[Xkbkdkoeh$;Xhk7ÂZka½kdaWb[c[WbZÚÂÚ"XkXbcddYaedkikdZW" aWjÚbÚckbkibWhWhWiÚdYZ[d[o_cb[hXeokjkdZW_dY[b[d_oeh$OWpWh"okhjjWÅbWhÚdl[i_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_daWhWhWbcW ih[b[h_d[aWjÚbÚcÚaedkikdZWWpiWoÚZWZWebiWlWhebWdZ[d[o_cb[h_ip[h[a"][h[aaWjÚbÚcÚd__d_dWdbWcbÚebWhWaZeb# ZkhkbWX_bc[i_WcWYÚobWd[cb_deajWbWhÚjWhjÚÅÚoeh"][h[ai[XkjWhjÚÅcWbWhZWdoebWÚaWhWaJha_o[½Z[a_[ai_ab_ab[h_dWb# jÚdÚ_p_oeh$8kaedkIJA½bWhÚdaWdkdoWfÚcih[Y_d[aWjÚbÚcbWhÚdÚWhjÚhWX_bc[b[h_d[od[b_aieckjd[h_b[hb[iedXkbkoeh$ A_jWXÚdZhZdYXbcIJA½bWh__do[d_X_hiWlkdkYkbkaWbWdÚebWdaWck^WhYWcWbWhÚdÚd_pb[dc[i_p[h_d[aedk# ZWdebkÅkoeh$Dkh^WdO[djhajWhW\ÚdZWdaWb[c[WbÚdWdZhZdYXbcdX_h_dY_aedkikdZWIJA½bWhÚdaWck^WhYW# cWbWhÚdÚ_pb[c[i_d_dd[Z[db[h_l[Xk_pb[c[d_d[ja_b[h_l[iÚdÚhbWhÚjWhjÚÅÚbÚoeh$8bcd_a_dY_aedkik_pb[c[d_doWfÚbW# X_bc[i___d_aj_iWjÚebcWoWdokhjjWÅoWZWIJAj[ci_bY_b[h_d_daWckakhkcbWhÚ"Xj[aWlhWcbWhÚl[^WhYWcWbWhÚdÚdiÚ# dÚ\bWdZÚhcWbWhÚ_b[_b]_b_j[c[beakcWl[oWpcWX_b]_b[h_d_l[hc[o_WcWbÚoeh$8bcddYaedkikdZW"^Waj[c[bb_ IJA½bWh__d_a_d[cb__pb[c[aedkikebWdieioWbaehkcW^WhYWcWbWhÚdWl[Wia[h_^WhYWcWbWhWod[b_a(&&,¸(&''oÚb# bWhÚdÚaWfiWoWdX_h_pb[c[oWfÚbÚoeh$8kXbc_b[_pb[c[iedkbWhÚaWZWh"_pb[c[odj[c_l[l[h_aWodWabWhÚaedkikdZW IJA½bWhWX_haÚbWlkpebkÅjkhkbkoeh$
9
?$8zB{C
I7LKDK9KBKA"OKHJJ7ÄB?AL;A7J?B?C
BWZ[dOkhjjW]b[h '/.&½b[h"X_hoWdZWd"ieioWbh[\W^Z[lb[j_d_dpbc[o[XWÅbWcWiÚ_b[okhjjWÅl[Z[lb[jWhWiÚdZWa__b_Åa_d_djWhjÚÅÚbcW# oWl[o[d_Z[doWfÚbWdZÚhÚbcWoWXWÅbWdZÚÂÚX_haÚhÚbcWZd[c_oZ_$IeioWbZ[lb[jl[ieioWb^WabWhXWÂbWcÚdZWa_jWhjÚÅ# cWbWh"okhjjWÅbWhÚdZ[lb[jb[^WabWhl[iehkcbkbkabWhXWÅbÚÂÚWbjÚdZWa__b_Åa_i_d_ieh]kbWZÚÂÚ"cpWa[h[[jj_Â_l[o[d_Z[d oWfÚbWdZÚhZÚÂÚl[^Wb[doWfÚbWdZÚhÚbWdX_hWbWdÚdWÚbcWiÚdÚiWÂbWZÚ$7odÚZd[c"ZdoWdÚdXWcXWÅaWo[hb[h_dZ[\Wha# bÚÅWhjbWhWbjÚdZWl[\WaWjj[ci_b_o[jb[_b]_b_X[dp[hiehkdl[jWb[fb[hb[okhjjWÅbÚaaWlhWcÚdÚdiWZ[Y[^Wal[iehkcbkbka _b_Åa_i_ob[iÚdÚhbÚebcWZWd"aWjÚbÚcl[j[ci_b_o[j[_b_Åa_djWhjÚÅcWbWhÚZW_[h[h[ao[d_Z[dZÅdbZÂX_hZd[cebZk$ '/.&½b[hZ[diedhWZ[lb[jokhjjWÅ_b_Åa_b[h_dZ[a_Z[Â_Å_c"\WhabÚZ[pWlWdjW`bÚ]hkfbWhÚdc[lYkjZ[ceahWj_aih[b[hZ[o[h WbWcWcWbWhÚl[ZW^WiÚo[hWbWcWcWbWhÚdÚi[ib[dZ_hc[o[XWÅbWcWbWhÚokhjjWÅbÚal[j[ci_b_o[jaWlhWcbWhÚdÚdo[d_Z[d jWhjÚÅÚbcWiÚdWd[Z[debZk$8kih[j[Z[ceahWi___dZ["aWhWhl[hc[c[aWd_pcWbWhÚdWaWjÚbÚcZWd"aWdkdoWfcWi# h[b[h___dZ[o[hWbcWbWhÚdW1feb_j_aWbWhÚdko]kbWdcWiÚdZWd"ko]kbWcWbWhÚd_pb[dc[i_d[aWZWhokhjjWÅbWhÚd\WhabÚi# h[b[h[ZeÂhkZWdaWjÚbÚcÚjWb[f[jj_ab[h_"XkjWb[fb[h_cpWa[h[[jj_ab[h_l[^[fi_ebcWiWX_b[XWpÚcpWa[h[b[h_diedk# YkdZWih[Y[ZW^_bebZkabWhÚZd[cb[hoWÅWdZÚ$zp[bb_ab['//&½bWhl[(&&&½b[h^[cah[i[b"^[cZ[o[h[bXWÂbWcZWi_l_b jefbkch]jb[h_d_diWoÚbWhÚdÚdl[[ja_WbWdbWhÚdÚdWhjcWiÚobW"okhjjWÅbWhÚdaWhWhl[hc[ih[b[h_d[aWjÚbÚcÚl[%oWaWjÚbÚ# cÚjWb[f[jc[i_ZW^WoWo]ÚdaedkÅkbkh"oWhWhbWhÚl[ebkcikpodb[h_jWhjÚÅÚbÚh^Wb[][bZ_$J[ci_b_Z[ceahWi___dZ[jWh# jÚÅÚbcWoWdaedkbWhi_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_"okhjjWÅ_d_i_oWj_\b[h_"fbWj\ehcbWh]_X_[Å_jb_h]jb[dc[X__cb[h_WhWYÚbÚÂÚobW \WhabÚi[l_o[b[hZ[]hdhaÚbÚdZÚbWh$:W^WiÚokhjjWÅbWhÚd\WhabÚi[l_o[b[hZ[aWhWhih[b[h_d[aWjÚbÚcÚ"oWfjÚabWhÚiWlkdk# YkbkaWbÚÅcWbWhÚl[beX_\WWb_o[jb[h__b[aWdkdbWhÚdÚaWhÚbcWiÚ"feb_j_aWbWhÚdh[j_bc[i_l[ko]kbWdcWiÚWÅWcWbWhÚdZW o[d_Z[d[o_cb[hl[Z[Â_Å_cb[hoWÅWdZÚ$ 8kXbcZ[okaWhÚZWXW^i[Z_b[dXkZ[Â_Å_cih[Y_okhjjWÅbÚa"iWlkdkYkbkal[aWjÚbÚc_b_Åa_i_p[h_dZ[djWhjÚÅÚbWYWa# jÚh$8kih[Y_dd[Z[dokhjjWÅbWhÚdaWjÚbÚcÚ__dd[cb_l[][h[ab_ebZkÂkdWZ[Â_d_b[Y[aj_h$7ohÚYWZ[pWlWdjW`bÚ]hkfbWhÚd ^WabWhÚdÚaehkcWbWhÚl[^WabWhÚdWkbWÅÚcbWhÚp[h_dZ[d"Xkih[Y_d^Wd]_Wajhb[hWhWiÚdZWl[^Wd]_ÅWhjbWh[h[l[# i_dZ[oWfÚbWdZÚhÚbcWiÚ][h[aj_Â_d[_b_Åa_dX_hjWhjÚÅcWoWfÚbWYWajÚh$8bcd_baaedkikdZWokhjjWÅbÚaaWlhWcÚdWZ[Â_# d_b[Y[aj_h$OkhjjWÅl[j[ci_b_o[jWhWiÚdZWa__b_Åa_d_djWhjÚÅÚbWYWÂÚXkXbcZ["okhjjWÅbÚÂÚdo[h[b"kbkiWbl[ah[i[bXWÂ# bWcZWdWiÚbZ[Â[hb[dZ_h_bZ_Â_d[l[\WhabÚakhkcbWhl[aWhWhWbcWih[b[h_dZ[\WhabÚokhjjWÅbÚal[j[ci_b_o[jZkhkcbWhÚ# dWeZWabWdÚbWYWajÚh$:[ceahWj_aoWfÚbWh__dZ[j[ci_b[Z_bc[l[j[ci_b[Z_b[c[c[iehkdbWhÚdÚdjWhjÚÅÚbWYWÂÚaedk"j[c# i_b[Z_b[c[c[d_doWhWjjÚÂÚiehkdbWhWZ[Â_d[Y[aj_h$8bcd_a_dY_aedkikdZWZ[ceahWi_l[aWhWhl[hc[ih[b[h_d[aW# jÚbÚcWhWiÚdZWa__b_Åa__dY[b[d[Y[aj_h$<WhabÚi[l_o[b[hZ[aWhWhl[hc[ih[b[h_d[aWjÚbÚcÚdl[aWhWhl[hc[ih[b[h_d[aW# jÚbÚcÚdokhjjWÅbÚabW_b_Åa_i_XkXbcZ[WdWb_p[Z_b[Y[aj_h$IedaedkZW_i[aWhWhl[hc[ih[Y_d[aWjÚbÚcÚdiWÂbWZÚÂÚ\Wha# bÚaedkbWhÚdj[ci_b_o[j_d_dZ[ceahWj_aokhjjWÅbÚÂÚdWiÚb[ja_b[Z_Â_jWhjÚÅÚbWYWajÚh$'$OkhjjWÅbÚal[Z[ceahWi__b_Åa_i_
IWlkdkYkbkal[aWjÚbÚcjWhjÚÅcWbWhÚdÚda[i_Åc[deajWiÚdZWZkhWdj[c[baWlhWcokhjjWÅbÚajÚh$B_X[hWbZ[ceahWi_b[hZ[" akhkcbWhZWdl[%oWi[_ci_ij[cb[h_dZ[dj["Z[ceahWi_d_dpd[i_ebWdokhjjWÅbWhÚda_cebZkabWhÚl[okhjjWÅbÚaaWlhW# cÚdÚddWiÚboWfÚbWdZÚhÚbZÚÂÚjWhjÚÅÚbcWajWZÚh$7oÅ[AWZÚeÂbk"_b]_b_oWpÚdZWokhjjWÅbÚaaWlhWcÚdÚd*\WhabÚÅ[a_bZ[akbbWdÚb# ZÚÂÚdÚX[b_hjc[aj[Z_h$8kdbWhZWd_ba_kbkiWba_cb_al[oWc_bb_o[jebWhWajWdÚcbWdWdokhjjWÅbÚa"_a_dY_i_[lhWabWhj[c[b_dZ[ jWdÚcbWdWdokhjjWÅbÚa"dYi^WabWhj[c[b_dZ[jWdÚcbWdWdokhjjWÅbÚa"ZhZdYi_i[]h[ll[iehkcbkbkabWhj[c[# b_dZ[jWdÚcbWdWdokhjjWÅbÚajÚh$KbkiWba_cb_al[c_bb_o[jebWhWajWdÚcbWdWdokhjjWÅbÚa"kbki#Z[lb[jceZ[b__b[X_h[o_d_b_Åa_ akhcWX__c_d_dWdYWakbkiWba_cb_al[oWc_bb_o[jiÚdÚhbWhÚ__dZ[ebWX_b[Y[Â_lWhiWoÚcÚdZWdoebWÚacWajWZÚh$'-./Ãd# iWd>WabWhÚ8[oWddWc[i_½dZ[o[hWbWdl[[][c[db_a_ba[i_d_dj[c[bZWoWdWÂÚdÚdkbkiebZkÂkdkdWbjÚdÚ_p[doWabWÅÚc"10 ih[j[X_h[ob[h_dWdYWaX_hkbki#Z[lb[j_do[i_ebWhWalWhebWX_b[Y[ab[h_d[_b_Åa_daWdÚoÚZ[ij[ab[Z_$1 D_j[a_cokhjjWÅY_-toyenaWlhWcÚkbkiWbX_ha_cb_aX_b_dY_d[iW^_fl[kbkiWaWhÅÚiehkcbkbkabWhÚdÚdX_b_dY_dZ[ebWda_Å_b[h__dakbbWdÚbcW# oWXWÅbWdZÚ$2zp[bb_ab[(&$opoÚbZWkbkic_bb_o[jp[h_dZ[dakh]kbWdWdokhjjWÅbÚajWdÚcbWhÚ^[ci_oWi_aWjÚbÚcÚdWhW# YÚl[c[Åhk_o[j_"^[cZ[^WoWb[Z_b[dj[akbkiWkbWÅcWa__dp[h_dZ[WbÚÅÚbWdX_haedk^Wb_d[][bZ_$zhd[Â_d"kbkibWhÚd a[dZ_aWZ[hb[h_d_a[dZ_b[h_d_djWo_d[jc[i_d[_b_Åa_djWhjÚÅcWbWhl[[d]hdhko]kbWcWbWhÚ'$:doWIWlWÅÚiedhWiÚd# ZWM_bied_ba[b[h_[h[l[i_dZ[ZWÂÚbWd_cfWhWjehbkabWhZWdakhkbWYWaebWdkbki#Z[lb[jb[h__d]dZ[c[][bZ_$3OkhjjWÅ# bÚal[c_bb_o[j_dpZ[Åb[Åj_h_bZ_Â_XkWdbWoÚÅbWkbki#Z[lb[jb[hl[aWfiWZÚabWhÚiÚdÚhbWhX[b_hb[dZ_$8kWdbWoÚÅbW][b_Å[dX_h XWÅaWko]kbWcW_i[jcokhjjWÅbWhÚdWodÚkbkiWbZ[Â[hb[hZeÂhkbjkikdZWj[c[b[Â_j_cl[%oWWia[hb_a]_X_oWfÚbWdZÚhÚYÚ c[aWd_pcWbWhÚakbbWdWhWa[Â_j_bc[i_Z_h$*Ãa_dY_akbbWdÚbWdokhjjWÅbÚaaWlhWcÚ[lhWabWhj[c[b_dZ[jWdÚcbWdWdokhjjWÅbÚa# jÚh$A_Å_b[h_d^kaka_aedkckdkX[b_hb[o[d[lhWabWhWhWiÚdZWd\kiYpZWdÚoWZWfWiWfehj]_X_a_Å_o[p[b[lhWabWhiWoÚ# bWX_b_h${dYi^WabWhj[c[b_dZ[jWdÚcbWdWdokhjjWÅbÚajÚh$8kokhjjWÅbÚajWdÚcÚdZW"p[bb_ab[J$>$CWhi^Wbb½ÚdºIeioWb IÚdÚ\l[OkhjjWÅbÚa»_i_cb_WbÚÅcWiÚj[c[bWbÚdÚh$8kWbÚÅcWZWCWhi^Wbb"okhjjWÅbÚÂÚdi_l_b"i_oWi_l[ieioWb^WabWhZWd ebkÅjkÂkdkd[ih[h$CWhi^Wbb½W]h[X_hokhjjWÅÚd^WabWhÚdZWdoWhWhbWdWX_bc[i___d"jc^WabWhÚdWkbWÅÚcÚ][h[ab_# Z_h$J[c[b^WabWhÚdZWdX_h_oWZWX_haWÚ_^bWb[Z_bZ_Â_dZ[Z_Â[h^WabWhÚdÚZWakbbWdWcWp^Wb[][b_h$5IedebWhWa"]h[l l[iehkcbkbkabWhj[c[b_dZ[jWdÚcbWdWdokhjjWÅbÚao[hWbcWajWZÚh$JefbkckdoWhWhÚdÚd"okhjjWÅÚdoWhWhÚdZWddZ[ebZk# ÂkXWÂbWcbWhZW"okhjjWÅbÚaa_Å_d_d]h[lb[h_p[h_dZ[djWdÚcbWdcWajWZÚh$6 <WhabÚokhjjWÅbÚajWdÚcbWhÚ"\WhabÚjefbkciWbdehcbWhÚdl[Z[Â[hb[h_doWdiÚcWiÚZÚh$'/.&½b[hZ[oWÅWdWdh[\W^Z[lb[j_d_d ah_p_^[cokhjjWÅbÚaaWlhWcÚdÚd"^[cZ[okhjjWÅl[Z[lb[jWhWiÚdZWa__b_Åa_d_dieioWbX_b_cY_b[hjWhW\ÚdZWdo[d_Z[djW# dÚcbWdcWiÚdWl[jWhjÚÅÚbcWiÚdWd[Z[debZk$OkhjjWÅbÚal[^WabWhp[h_d[oWfÚbWdjWhjÚÅcWbWh"X_hoWdZWd"WodÚZd[cZ[ oWÅWdWda_jb[i[bo[d_ieioWb^Wh[a[jb[h_doWdiÚcWbWhÚoZÚ$OkhjjWÅbÚajWdÚcbWhÚ__dZ[XkbkdWdCWhi^Wbb½ÚdaWlhWciWb# bWÅjÚhcWiÚ"'/.&½b[hZ[a_jWhjÚÅcWbWhbWZW^W\WpbW]dZ[c[][bZ_$'/.&½b[hZ[a_ieioWb^Wh[a[jb[h"i_oWi[j[d[Å_j^WabWhW iW^_febWdokhjjWÅbWhÚd"ieioWbl[[aedec_aebWhWaZW]b[dc[i_][h[aj_Â_d_l[ieioWb^WabWhWZWiW^_febcWbWhÚ][h[a# j_Â_d_iWlkdkoehZk$8ob[b_ab[okhjjWÅbWhjc^WabWhÚdÚakbbWdWX_b_hZ_$IeioWb^Wh[a[jb[h_dXWÅWhcWoWWbÚÅjÚÂÚ"]WhWdj_ WbjÚdWWbÚdcÚÅieioWb^WabWh"WdYWai_oWiWb"^kaka_l[_ZWh_fhWj_ab[hZ[Z[Â_Å_cb[h][h[ab[Å_hi[ccadebWX_b_hZ_$-8k ZkhkcZW"jcZ[Â_Å_cb[h_d][h[ab[Å[X_bc[i___dokhjjWÅbWhÚdb_X[hWbZ[ceahWi_b[hZ[aWhWhl[hc[c[aWd_pcWbWhÚdZW l[feb_j_aWoWfcWih[b[h_dZ[j[ci_b_][h[ab_Z_h$ B_X[hWbZ[ceahWi_b[hZ[okhjjWÅbWhÚdZ[ceahWj_aj[ci_b_WdWp[bb_Â[iW^_fj_h$8kdbWhZWd_ba_j[ci_b[Z[dl[j[ci_b [Z_b[dWhWiÚdZWa_WdbWÅcWobW_b_Åa_Z_h$J[ci_b[Z_bc[Zkhkck"eÂkdbkabW"iÚdÚhbWh__dZ[kbki#Z[lb[jiÚdÚhbWhÚ__dZ[ l[h[ic_akhWbbWhZW^_b_dZ[][h[ab[Å_h$J[ci_b[Z[db[h"j[ci_b[Z_b[db[h_dZÅdY[b[h_d_l[\WoZWbWhÚdÚ]pdd[WbcWa ZkhkckdZWZÚhbWh$Ãa_dY_i_"j[ci_b_o[jZkhkckdkfeb_j_a_aj_ZWhÚdX[bb_iehkcbkbkabWh__dZ[][h[ab[Åj_h_b[Y[Â_X_hWbWd ' >[][b½_dZ[lb[j_aWlhWciWbbWÅjÚhcWX__c_l[Z[lb[jb[okhjjWÅWhWiÚdZWa__b_Åa_o_"okhjjWÅbÚÂÚebcWoWdX_h[ob[h_djWcebWhWa_diWdebWcWoWYWa# bWhÚdW_b_Åa_ddejkAWZÚeÂbk½dkdcWaWb[i_dZ[XkbWX_b_hi_d_p$ ( AWZÚeÂbk"7oÅ[(&&."LWjWdZWÅbÚa0AWlhWcÚd<WhabÚ7dbWcbWhÚ"LWjWdZWÅbÚÂÚd:dÅc__dZ["Z[hb[o[dAWZÚeÂbk"7oÅ["C[j_iOWoÚdbWhÚ"Ãi# jWdXkb"i$(($ ) M_bied_ba[b[h_dZ[dX_hjWd[i_Z[Z[aebed_pWioedkdiWÂbWdcWiÚl[kbkibWhÚda[dZ_][b[Y[ab[h_d_X[b_hb[c[b[h_oddZ[Z_h$M_bied_ba[b[h_^Wa# aÚdZWaÚiWX_b]___dXWaÚdÚp0^jjf0%%mmm$jkhaY[X_b]_$Yec%m_biedUfh[di_fb[h_%Wdi_abef[Z_ * M[X[h";k][d['/-,"F[Wi[dji_dje<h[dY^c[d0J^[CeZ[hd_pWj_ede\HkhWb<hWdY['.-&#'/'*"IjWd\ehZ"IjWd\ehZKd_l[hi_joFh[ii$7oÅ[AW# ZÚeÂbkZW_b]_b_oWpÚdZWd[cb_X_ho[h[iW^_febWdXka_jWfjWdXW^i[jc[aj[Z_h$M[X[h"WbÚÅcWiÚdZWaÚhiWb<hWdiW½ZWoWÅWoWdaobb[h_dWi# a[hb_aWhWYÚbÚÂÚ_b[dWiÚbehjWakbkiWbZ[Â[hb[haedkikdZW[Â_j_bZ_ab[h_dZ[dXW^i[jc[aj[Z_h$;Â_j_c_dkbkiWbZ[Â[hb[h_dWiÚboWo]ÚdbWÅjÚhZÚÂÚdW _b_Åa_dJha_o[hd[Â___dXap${ij[b"<ikd(&&*"CWaXkbLWjWdZWÅÚdF[Å_dZ[0??$C[Åhkj_o[j½j[d8k]d[LWjWdZWÅbÚa;Â_j_c_"Ãb[j_Å_cOWoÚd# bWhÚ"ÃijWdXkb$ + OkhjjWÅbÚal[^WabWh_b_Åa_i_d_dZ[jWobÚjWhjÚÅcWiÚ__dXWaÚdÚp0CWhi^Wbb"J$>$(&&+ºIeioWbIÚdÚ\l[OkhjjWÅbÚa»"IeioWbFeb_j_aWOWpÚbWhÚ__d# Z["Z[hb[o[d8kÂhW"7oÅ[l[A[oZ[h"wWÂbWh"Ãb[j_Å_cOWoÚdbWhÚ"ÃijWdXkb$ , AWZÚeÂbk"7oÅ[(&&."ºLWjWdZWÅbÚa0AWlhWcÚd<WhabÚ7dbWcbWhÚ»"LWjWdZWÅbÚÂÚd:dÅc__dZ["Z[hb[o[dAWZÚeÂbk"7oÅ["C[j_iOWoÚdbWhÚ" i$(.$ - Jkhd[h"8hoWd(&&."º8_hLWjWdZWÅbÚaAkhWcÚdÚd7dW^WjbWhÚ»"LWjWdZWÅbÚÂÚd:dÅc__dZ["Z[hb[o[dAWZÚeÂbk"7oÅ["C[j_iOWoÚdbWhÚ"Ãi# jWdXkb"i$'')$
11 l[^[iWfl[h[X_b_hb_ajWdÚcbWh$D_j[a_cj[ci_b[Z_b[db[h_d"okhjjWÅbWhÚd"_b]_b_feb_j_a_aj_ZWhl[^[iWfl[h[X_b_hb_ap[h_d# Z[^[cX_h[ja_i_"^[cZ[aedjhebXkbkdkh$IedebWhWaj[ci_b_o[jZkhkckdZW"j[ci_b[Z_b[db[h_deokfeb_j_a[Å_jb_a__d j[c[bX_hWhWl[bcX_h_c_iWÂbWh$87dYWaj[ci_b[Z[db[heÂkpWcWdfeb_j_a[b_jb[hZ[debkÅkh"a_XkZkhkcokhjjWÅ# bWhÚd[Å_jeobWhÚebcWiÚdWhWÂc[d"[Å_jj[ci_bb[h_aedkikdZWY_ZZ_X_h[d][bZ_h$;Å_j^WabWhWiW^_febWdokhjjWÅbWhÚd[Å_j j[ci_b_d_dlWhebcWZÚÂÚdW_b_Åa_dd[cb_[b[Åj_h_b[hp[bb_ab[\[c_d_ijoWpÚdZWd][bc_Åj_h$7dd[F^_bb_fi"Demokrasinin Cinsiyeti _i_cb_WbÚÅcWiÚdZW"Z[ceahWi_Z[[Å_jj[ci_b^WaaÚdÚdºlWhcÚÅ»]_X_jWdÚcbWdZÚÂÚdÚ"WdYWa^[ci[c["^[c Z[i[_bc[d_d"aWZÚdbWhWÚiÚdZWd"[Å_jebWhWa][h[ab[Åc[Z_Â_d_iWlkdkh$9F^_bb_fiaWZÚdbWhÚdaWhWhl[hc[l[feb_j_aW oWfcWc[aWd_pcWbWhÚdZWo[hWbcWZÚabWhÚdÚ"WdYWao[hWbcWbWhÚdÚdZWj[apcebcWZÚÂÚdÚiob[h$F^_bb_fi½[]h["WodÚ pWcWdZWZ[Â_Åc[i_][h[a[dfeb_j_aWbWdÚdl[XkWbWdÚebkÅjkhWdih[b[h_da[dZ_i_Z_h$AWZÚdbWh]_X_XWÅaWZ[pWlWdjW`bÚ ]hkfbWhZWb_X[hWbZ[ceahWj_ac[aWd_pcWbWhZWj[ci_b_o[jiehkdkoWÅWcWajWZÚhbWh$>[hd[aWZWh[Å_ji_oWi_^WabWhWiW# ^_febiWbWhZW"[Å_jÅ[a_bZ[j[ci_b[Z[d"Z_Â[hX_hZ[o_Åb[aWhWhl[h[dl[feb_j_aWoWfWd"aedkckdW[h_Åj_ab[h_d_iob[c[a ccadZ[Â_bZ_h$weÂkpWcWdXk[Å_ji_pb_aokaWhÚZWiÚhWbWdWdokhjjWÅbÚajWdÚcbWhÚ_b[c[ÅhkbWÅjÚhÚbÚh$8WpÚZkhkcbWh# ZWokhjjWÅl[kbkiWba_cb_a[Åb[Åj_h_bc_Åj_h$8ob[ZkhkcbWhZW"a[dZ_d_eÂkdbkÂkdiW^_febZkÂkkbkiWba_cb_Â_dZÚÅÚd# ZWjWdÚcbWoWdbWhj[ci_bb[_b]_b_iehkdbWhoWÅWcWajWZÚhbWh$8_hXWÅaWZkhkc_i[[lhWabWhp[h_dZ[djWdÚcbWdWdokhjjWÅ# bÚajÚh$AWZÚdbWhÚdj[ci_b__b[_b]_b_oWfÚbWdjWhjÚÅcWbWhZWZW]hbZÂp[h["[lhWap[h_dZ[[Å_j^WabWhWiW^_faWZÚdbWh j[ci_b_o[jXWÂbWcÚdZW[Å_jZ[Â_bZ_h$:hZdYjWdÚcZW_i[kbkikd_o_b_Â_"a_Å_b[h_d_o_b_Â_dZ[dZW^WdY[b_ab_Z_h$8kZk# hkcZWa_cb[h_dj[ci_b[Z_bZ_Â_d[cb_l[dY[b_ab_"pWj[d"ebWcWp$
($:[ceahWi_l[aWhWhl[hc[%feb_j_aWoWfcWih[b[h_WhWiÚdZWa__b_Åa_
B_X[hWbZ[ceahWj_aod[j_cb[h[_b_Åa_d'/.&½b[hZ[dXkoWdW^WhWh[jb[Z[lWc[Z[dd[cb_jWhjÚÅcWbWhZWdX_h_j[ci_b_o[j l[j[ci_b_o[j_dc[Åhk_o[j__b[_b]_b_Z_h$weÂkpWcWd^Wd]_Wajhb[h_dj[ci_b_o[j__dko]kdoWZWc[ÅhkebZkÂkjWhjÚÅcW# iÚ"_b]_b_okhjjWÅbWhjefbkbkÂkdkddWiÚbl[^Wd]_ih[b[hb[od[j_bZ_Â_oWZWod[j_bc[i_][h[aj_Â_jWhjÚÅcWiÚdZWdaWo# dWabWdcWajWZÚh$>[hd[aWZWhj[ci_b_o[ja[dZ___dZ[Z[ceahWj_aÂ[b[h_XWhÚdZÚhiWZW"j[ci_b_Z[ceahWi_dhdebWd jc^ac[jb[h_djWcWcÚobWZ[ceahWj_aebZkabWhÚdÚiob[c[accadebcWoWX_b_h$:_Â[hX_hZ[o_Åb["[bX[jj["a[dZ_# d_j[ci_b[Z[Y[aX_hWZWoÚi[c[al[Z[ij[ab[c[Z_Â_ddeajWZWeokdkXWÅaWiÚdWl[hc[aj[ci_b_Z[ceahWi_o[c[ÅhkX_h p[c_diWÂbWcWajWZÚh$7dYWaj[ci_b_Z[ceahWi_WhWYÚbÚÂÚobW_aj_ZWhW][bc_ÅebWdjc^ac[jb[h_da_j[ci_b_o[jZkhk# ckokhjjWÅbWhÚda[dZ__hWZ[b[h_d_i[j_ab[h_j[ci_bY_b[h_d[WajWhZÚabWhÚZkhkcZkhaWhWhl[%oWko]kbWcWbWhÚWÚiÚdZWd jWcebWhWaZ[ceahWj_aebZkabWhÚdÚiob[c[accadebcWoWX_b_h$Ãb]_b_j[ci_bY_b[hl[j[ci_bY_b[hWhWYÚbÚÂÚobW^ac[j# b[hWbZÚabWhÚaWhWhbWhl[ko]kbWZÚabWhÚfeb_j_aWbWhbWX[bb_]hkfbWhÚl[edbWhÚd_^j_oWoWZWiehkdbWhÚdÚ]hc[pZ[d][b[X_b_h oWZW\WhaÚdZWebcWoWX_b_hb[h$JcokhjjWÅbWhÚdj[ci_b[Z_bc[Z_ab[h_X_hZkhkc"j[ci_b[Z_bc[o[dokhjjWÅbWhÚd_hWZ[b[h_# d_dl[]b[h_d_d]hc[pZ[d][b_dZ_Â_X_hjWXbeZkh$JcokhjjWÅbWhÚd_^j_oWbWhÚdÚdl[iehkdbWhÚdÚdj[ci_b[Z_bc[Z_Â_oW ZW[Z_b[c[Z_Â_ZkhkcbWhZW"okhjjWÅbWhÚdaWjÚbÚcÚdÚiWÂbWcWa"X_hb_aj[oWÅWcWoÚccadaÚbcWal[_b]_b_aedkbWhÚ]d# Z[c[][j_hc[a__dWbj[hdWj_\oebbWhWhWdÚh$8kXbcZ[Z[ceahWi_l[aWhWhl[hc[_b[feb_j_aWoWfcWih[b[h_dZ[o[h WbcWWhWiÚdZWa__b_Åa__dY[b[d[Y[aj_h$zdY[b_ab[aWhWhl[hc[ih[b[h_d[aWjÚbÚc__dWbj[hdWj_\oebbWh"WhZÚdZWdXkoebbW# hÚddWiÚboWfÚbWdZÚhÚbcWiÚ][h[aj_Â_jWhjÚÅÚbWYWajÚh$ B_X[hWbj[ci_b_Z[ceahWi___dZ[aWhWhl[hc[l[feb_j_aWoWfcWc[aWd_pcWbWhÚ__dZ[o[hWbcWdÚdebWiÚoebbWhÚdZWdX_h jWd[i_iWlkdkYkbkajkh$IWlkdkYkbka"XWpÚaWodWabWhZWºi[ib[h_d_ZkokhcWa»ebWhWajWdÚcbWdcÚÅjÚh$108WpÚbWhÚdZWiW# lkdkYkbka"aWhWhl[h_Y_b[h_[ja_b[c[al[feb_j_aWbWhÚZ[Â_Åj_hc[a__daWcfWdoWYÚbÚajWd"beX_Y_b_Â["WhWÅjÚhcWl[_b[j_# Å_cZ[d" ehjWabÚabWh ][b_Åj_hc[o[ aWZWh kpWdWd \WhabÚ ijhWj[`_b[h_ aWfiWoWd X_h Å[ci_o[Z_h$11 8WpÚbWhÚdZW _i[ okhjjWÅ#bWhÚd"aWhWhbWhÚl[feb_j_aWbWhÚebkÅjkhcWih[b[h_d[[h_Å_c_l[aWjÚbÚcÚl[Xkih[b[h_[ja_b[c[WXWiÚl[]YebW# . 9Wij_]b_ed[":Wh_el[MWhh[d"CWha;$(&&,"ºH[j^_da_d]:[ceYhWj_YH[fh[i[djWj_ed0;_]^jJ^[eh[j_YWb?iik[i»"H[j^_da_d]:[ceYhWj_YH[f-resentation __d^WpÚhbWdcÚÅcWaWb["9[djh[\ehj^[IjkZoe\:[ceYhWj_Y?dij_jkj_ediKd_l[hi_joe\8h_j_i^9ebkcX_W$^jjf0%%mmm$j^[\kjkh[e\# h[fh[i[djWj_l[Z[ceYhWYo$eh]%\_b[i%fZ\%h[iekhY[i%mpXUh[iekhY[iU9Wij_]b_ed[$fZ\ / F^_bb_fi"7dd[(&&+"Demokrasinin Cinsiyeti"C[j_iOWoÚdbWhÚ"ÃijWdXkb$ 10 IWck[b"@e^d(&&("ºM^Wj_iF[efb[#Y[djh[Z7ZleYWYo5»FB7Dej[i"*)0/#'($ 11 º7d7ZleYWYo=k_Z[\eh<[c_d_iji»"Oekd]Mec[dWdZB[WZ[hi^_f"de0'"7hWbÚa(&&)$
12 hWajWdÚcbWdcWajWZÚh$12>WjjWiWlkdkYkbkao[d_Z[ceahWj_aodj[cb[hl[aWjÚbÚcX__cb[h_j[ab_\[jj_Â_d_d[h[db[hZ[ XkbkdcWajWZÚh$13IWlkdkYkbkaaWlhWcÚdÚdZWoWdZÚÂÚ_a_j[c[bdeajWaWjÚbÚcl[[ja_Z_h$AWjÚbÚcaWlhWcÚ"XkXWÂbWcZW" i_oWi_aWjÚbÚc_b[_b_Åa_b[dZ_h_bc[aj[Z_h$>[hd[aWZWhi_oWi_aWjÚbÚcj[ci_b_Z[ceahWi__b[pZ[Åb[Åj_h_bi[Z["eol[hc[a ]_X_"X_h[oi[boWZWh]jbebWhWaoWfÚbWdaWcfWdoWoWfcWa"h]jb[dc[a]_X_[ob[cb[h_Z[_[hc[aj[Z_h$'*8_hXWÅaW jWdÚcZW_i[i_oWi_aWjÚbÚc"eÂkdbkabW"feb_j_aWoWfcWl[ko]kbWcWih[b[h_d_[ja_b[o[doWZW[ja_b[c[o[WbÚÅWdokhj# jWÅ\WWb_o[jb[h_15oWZWokhjjWÅbWhÚdZ[Â[hb[h_d_l[jWb[fb[h_d_"aWck_ZWh_^_pc[jb[h_d_oWfWha[dZ_bb[dZ_hc[b[h_l[aWck ^_pc[jb[h_d_dXkZ[Â[hb[hl[jWb[fb[hZeÂhkbjkikdZWoWfÚbcWiÚdÚdiWÂbWdcWiÚZÚh$16OkhjjWÅbWhÚdaWjÚbÚcÚ_b[_b]_b_d[c# b_X_hp[bb_a"aWjÚbÚcÚd_b]_b_aedkZWkpcWdebcWoWdokhjjWÅbWhÚdZWoWd_fhe\[ioed[bfbWdbWcWYÚbWhoWZW_b]_b_aedkZW kpcWdebcWoWdXheahWjbWh]_X_aWhÅÚbÚabÚ_b[j_Å_c__dZ[ohjb[dfeb_j_aWfbWdbWcWih[b[h___dZ[o[hWbcWbWhÚZÚh$ 8kaWjÚbÚch]jb]hkfbWh"ZeÂhkZWdZ[ceahWj_aaWjÚbÚc"h[\[hWdZkc"_b]_b_IJA½bWhÚdfbWdbWcWl[aWdkdoWfcWih[# b[h_dZ[o[hWbcWbWhÚ"kpbWÅcWjefbWdjÚbWhÚ"aed\[hWdibWh"XheahWjbWhl[okhjjWÅbWhWhWiÚdZWoWfÚbWdoklWhbWacWiWjef# bWdjÚbWhÚl[oWiWlkdkYkbka\WWb_o[jb[h_Å[ab_dZ[ebWX_b_h$OkhjjWÅbWhÚdaWjÚbÚcÚ_b[_b]_b_"^[hd[aWZWhhjaf[aeajWli_o[ ebiWZW"_baWÚajWli_o[8_hb[Åc_ÅC_bb[jb[hw[lh[l[AWbaÚdcWAed\[hWdiÚ½dZW'//(oÚbÚdZWoWfÚbcÚÅjÚh$w[lh[l[AWbaÚd# cWAedkikdZWH_e7ÚabWcWiÚ½dZWdX[h_okhjjWÅbWhÚdfeb_j_aWoWfcWih[b[h_d[aWjÚbÚcÚaedkikdWWohÚYWbÚabÚX_hd[c l[h_bc[o[XWÅbWdcÚÅjÚh$ '-IWlkdkYkbka"okhjjWÅbWhÚdfeb_j_aWoWfcWl[aWhWhl[hc[ih[b[h_d[[h_Å_cl[aWjÚbÚcfejWdi_o[bb[h_dZ[aWoZWZ[Â[h X_hWhjÚÅWd[Z[debcWajWZÚh$IWlkdkYkbka"okhjjWÅbWhWl[okhjjWÅ]_h_Å_cb[h_d[]dZ[cebkÅjkhcWl[feb_j_aWoWfcW ih[b[h_d_[ja_b[c[l[WhWYÚiÚp"oWd_X_h_b[h_jWhW\ÚdZWdj[ci_b[Z_bc[Z[d"ZeÂhkZWdaWjÚbÚcÅWdiÚl[hc[aj[Z_h$8ki# h[okhjjWÅbWhÚdºi[ib[h_d_»ZkokhcWoWoWhWh$7dYWaih[j[º^Wd]_okhjjWÅbWhÚd»i[ib[h_d_ZkokhWX_bZ_Â_d[cb_jWhjÚÅ# cWaedkbWhÚdZWdX_h_Z_h$IWlkdkYkbka\WWb_o[j_"feb_j_aWbWhÚ[ja_b[c[al[aWhWhc[aWd_pcWbWhÚdWaWjÚbÚc_b[_b]_b_Z_h$7d# YWa^Wd]_Wajhb[h_daWhWhc[aWd_pcWbWhÚdWaWjÚbWX_b[Y[Â_"_b]_b_Wajhb[h_doWfWX_b_hb_ab[h_l[kbWÅÚcbWhÚ_b[iÚdÚhbÚZÚh$ >Wd]_okhjjWÅbWhÚdaWhWhl[hc[l[feb_j_aWoWfcWih[b[h_d[aWjÚbWYWÂÚ"oWfÚbWYWafeb_j_aWbWhÚdl[WbÚdWYWaaWhWhbW# hÚd^Wd]_okhjjWÅbWhb[^_d[ebkfebcWoWYWÂÚdÚ[ja_b[o[Y[aj_h$7aj_l_ij_d;bA_jWXÚ½dZWHWdZoI^WmIWd<hWdY_iYe½ZWÅ[# ^_hc[ha[p_dZ[o[hWbWdX_hcW^Wbb[d_da[dji[bZdÅc[h[l[i_dZ[][_hZ_Â_Z[Â_Å_cb[h_WdbWjÚha[d"X[b[Z_o[d_di# h[Y_dXWÅÚdZWa[dji[bZdÅcdWajhb[h_ebWhWa]hZÂcj[W^^_jb[h_aWhWhl[hc[ih[b[h_d[aWjjÚÂÚdÚWajWhcÚÅ# jÚh$7dYWacW^Wbb[iWa_db[h_ih[Y_dZÚÅÚdZWjkjkbckÅbWhZÚh$A[dZ_^WoWjbWhÚ^WaaÚdZWaWhWhl[hc[o_jWb[f[Z[dcW^Wb# b[iWa_db[h_h]jb[dc_Ål[fbWdbWcWih[Y_dZ[o[hWbcWa__d^[c^kaka_oebbWhÚakbbWdcÚÅ"^[cZ[aWckeokdZW\Wh# aÚdZWbÚaoWhWjcWa__dWbÚÅcWoWXWÅbWcÚÅbWhZÚh$Ih[j["cW^Wbb[d_doeaikbiWa_db[h_X[b[Z_o[d_dfbWdbWcWjefbWdjÚ# bWhÚdZWo[hWbWX_bc_Å"cW^Wbb[b[h_d_dZ[Â_Å_cih[Y_d_dX_hfWhWiÚebcWoÚXWÅWhWX_bc_Åb[hZ_h$18>Wd]_Wajhb[h_daWhWh l[hc[ih[b[h_d_dfWhWiÚebWYWÂÚ"WbÚdWdaWhWhbWhÚl[ko]kbWdWdfeb_j_aWbWhÚZeÂhkZWd[ja_b[c[aj[Z_h$OkaWhÚZWa_h# d[aj[Z[]hbZÂp[h["oWbdÚpcj[W^^_jb[h_daWjÚbWYWÂÚaWhWhl[hc[ih[b[h_"[bX[jj[okhjjWÅaWjÚbÚcÚZÚh"WdYWaXb# ][Z[oWÅWoWdbWhÚd_^j_oWbWhÚdÚ"jWb[fb[h_d_"ZW^WiÚj[c[b^WabWhÚdÚaWhÅÚbWcWcWajWZÚh$D_j[a_ccW^Wbb[iWa_db[h_d_d aWjÚbÚcÚ_b[WbÚdWdaWhWhbWhl[ko]kbWcWbWhZ[Â_Åc_Ål[_^j_oWbWhbWkokcbk^Wb[][bc[i___dY_ZZ_X_hcpWa[h[ih[# Y_oWÅWdcÚÅjÚh$:ebWoÚiÚobWi[i_d_ZkokhWcWoWd"Z[pWlWdjW`bÚ]hkfbWhÚdaWhWhl[hc[ih[b[h_d[ZW^_bebcWbWhÚ"X_h_b[h_# 12 IeaebelW"CWh_dW(&&,"º7ZleYWYo:[ceYhWYoCeZ[i08[d[\_jiWdZB_c_jWj_edi»"?d\ehcWY_`eiCeaibW_"de0)-"i$'''$ 13 ºIWlkdkYkbka:[ceahWi_i_»Z_o[WZbWdZÚhÚbWdXko[d_odj[cb[hl[aWjÚbÚcX__cb[h__b[_b]_b_jWhjÚÅcW__dXWaÚdÚp0:Wbjed"Hkii[bb@$"IYWhhem" IkiWdl[9W_d"8hkY[(&&)":[ceYhWYoJhWdi\ehc[Z50;nfWdZ_d]Feb_j_YWbEffehjkd_j_[i_d7ZlWdY[Z?dZkijh_Wb:[ceYhWY_[i$9[dj[h\ehj^[ IjkZoe\:[ceYhWYo"FWf[h&)¸&*$^jjf0%%h[fei_jeh_[i$Zb_X$eh]%YiZ%&)#&* '* =Wl[djW"@e^dl[LWbZ[hhWcW"9Wc_be'///"ºFWhj_Y_fWj_ed"9_j_p[di^_fWdZBeYWb=el[hdWdY[»"Ijh[d]j^[d_d]FWhj_Y_fWj_ed_dBeYWb=el[h# dWdY[Wjbo[i___dh[j_b[djWhjÚÅcWc[jd_"?dij_jkj[e\:[l[befc[djIjkZ_[i">Wp_hWd('#(*"8h_]^jed$OkhjjWÅbWhÚdeoakbbWdcWajWd"\WhabÚ feb_j_aih[b[h[aWjÚbcWbWhÚdWaWZWhi_oWi_aWjÚbÚcbWhÚdÚdoWdÚiÚhW1_ZWh_ih[b[h__pb[c[oWZW_ZWh_ih[b[h[_b_Åa_djWb[fb[h_Z_b[][j_hc[o_ Z[_[h[dº_ZWh_»aWjÚbÚcebWhWaWZbWdZÚhÚbWdX_haWjÚbÚcX__c_Z[c[lYkjjkh$IeaebelWokaWhÚZWh[\[hWdiÚl[h_b[dcWaWb[i_dZ[XkWohÚcÚakb# bWdcÚÅjÚh$7dYWaX[d_ZWh_aWjÚbÚcÚdi_oWi_aWjÚbÚcZWdWohÚbWcWoWYWÂÚdÚZÅdoehkc$ÃZWh_aWjÚbÚcWohÚcÚl[XkWohÚcW_b_Åa_dZ[Â[hb[dZ_h# c[b[hXWÅaWX_hWbÚÅcWdÚdaedkikebWYWajÚh$ 15 DW][b"@WYa'/.-"FWhj_Y_fWj_ed";d]b[meeZ9b_\i"Fh[dj_Y[>Wbb"D@$ 16 P_cc[hcWd"@$'/.,"Fefkb_icH[l_i_j[Z"IjWj[=el[hdc[dj"Y$+."i$'-(¸'-.$ '- IeaebelW"CWh_dW(&&,"º7ZleYWYo:[ceYhWYoCeZ[i08[d[\_jiWdZB_c_jWj_edi»"?d\ehcWYÚ`eiCeaibWÚ"de0)-"i$'''$ 18 I^Wm"HWdZo(&&("7aj_l_ij_d;bA_jWXÚ"7ohÚdjÚOWoÚdbWhÚ"ÃijWdXkb$
13 d_dj[ci_b_Z[ceahWi_WhWYÚbÚÂÚobWi[j_ab[h_oWZWi[c[Z_ab[h_edbWhWZÚdWaWhWhl[hc[i_dZ[dZW^W\WpbWZ[ceahW# j_aih[b[h[^_pc[j[Z[X_b_h$P_hWCWhi^Wbb½ÚdZWX[b_hjj_Â_]_X_X_hokhjjWÅÚdjc^WabWhÚdÚakbbWdWX_bc[i_jc^WabWhÚ# dWkbWÅÚcÚl[akbbWdWX_bc[i_ob[_b]_b_Z_h$IWd<hWdY_iYehd[Â_dZ["[Â[hcW^Wbb[iWa_db[h_aWhWhl[hc[ih[b[h___dZ[ o[hWbcWiWbWhZÚ"oWd_i_oWi_^WabWhÚdÚakbbWdWcWiWbWhZÚ"a[dji[bZdÅcdX_hfWhWiÚebWhWa[lb[h_dZ[dWohÚbcWape# hkdZWaWbWYWabWhl[ieioWb^WabWhÚdZWdX_h_ebWdXWhÚdcW^WabWhÚZW_^bWb[Z_bc_ÅebWYWajÚ$A_c_di[i_d_dZkokhkbWYW# ÂÚdW_b_Åa_doWfÚbWdjWhjÚÅcWbWhZWdX_h_Z[okhjjWÅbWhl[okhjjWÅebcWoWdbWhbW_b]_b_Z_h$IWlkdkYkbkaih[Y_Z[pWlWdjW`# bÚ]hkfbWhÚdaWhWhl[hc[l[feb_j_aWoWfcWih[b[h_d[aWjÚbÚcÚdÚWcWbWcWajWZÚh$7dYWa][h[aaWdkdbWhÚdoWfÚbcWiÚ" ][h[ai[feb_j_aWoWfcWih[b[h_"eÂkdbkabW"kbki#Z[lb[jiÚdÚhbWhÚ__dZ[l[kbki#Z[lb[jl[okhjjWÅ[ai[d_dZ[ZÅdb# c[aj[Z_h$EoiW]dcpZ[c[ha[p_oWZWo[h[bod[j_cb[h_dfeb_j_aWbWhÚdZWdoWZWko]kbWcWbWhÚdZWd[ja_b[d[dZ[pW# lWdjW`bÚ]hkfbWh__dZ[okhjjWÅebcWoWdbWhZW"hd[Â_dcbj[Y_b[h"XkbkdcWajWZÚh$:ebWoÚiÚobWaWhWhl[hc[c[aWd_pcW# bWhÚdWaWjÚbÚcÚoWbdÚpYWokhjjWÅbWhbWiÚdÚhbÚjkjcWoWdl[\WaWj_b]_b_ko]kbWcWoWZWfeb_j_aWbWhZWd[ja_b[d[doWZW[ja_# b[d[X_b[Y[ajcWajhb[h_daWjÚbZÚÂÚ"º_diWdeZWabÚ»X_hih[ebWhWaakh]kbWcWad[cb_Z_h$:[pWlWdjW`bÚ]hkfbWhÚdaW# hWhl[hc[ih[b[h_d[aWjÚbÚcÚdÚWcWbWcWaih[Y_d_baaÚicÚdÚebkÅjkhkha[d"aWjÚbÚcÚddWiÚbccadaÚbÚdWX_b[Y[Â__i[ ih[Y_d_a_dY_aÚicÚdÚebkÅjkhcWajWZÚh$ IWlkdkYkbka\WWb_o[j_d_dj[c[bWcWYÚZ[pWlWdjW`bÚl[i[i_ZkokbcWoWd]hkfbWhÚdjWb[fb[h_d_l[j[hY_^b[h_d_ZkokhcWal[ i[ib[dZ_hc[aj_h$>[hd[aWZWhiWlkdkYkbka"eÂkdbkabW"i_ij[cWj_aebWhWaaWckfeb_j_aWbWhÚdÚ[ja_b[c[aebWhWaZÅ# dbi[Z["c[lYkjZkhkckdZ[Â_Åc[i___dfeb_j_aWZ[Â_Å_ab_Â_][h[ab_WdYWao[j[hb_Z[Â_bZ_h$:[pWlWdjW`bÚ]hkfbWhÚd^Wa# bWhÚdÚd_^bWb[Z_bc[i_d[d[Z[debWdjefbkciWb[Å_ji_pb_aWZWb[ji_pb_ab[h_Z[Â_Åj_hc[a__doWfÚiWb"jkjkcl[Z[Â[hb[hb[_b# ]_b_Z[Â_Å_ab_ab[h[_^j_oWlWhZÚh$:ebWoÚiÚobWZ[pWlWdjW`bÚ]hkfbWhÚdfeb_j_aWoWfcWih[b[h_dZ[o[hWbcWiÚdÚdoWdÚiÚhW jefbkciWboWfÚbWhÚd"dehc^Wb_d[][bc_ÅZ[Â[hl[jkjkcbWhÚdZWZ[Â_Åc[i___diWlkdkYkbka\WWb_o[jb[h_][h[ab_Z_h$AW# XWYWiWlkdkYkbka\WWb_o[j_d_d(WdW[ai[d_ebZkÂkiob[d[X_b_h$8kdbWhZWd_ba_feb_j_aWbWhÚ[ja_b[c[ap[h[aWjÚbÚcZÚh" Z_Â[h__i[jefbkciWbZ[Â_Å_c__dc[lYkjjkjkcbWhÚdl[Z[Â[hb[h_djWhjÚÅÚbcWiÚdÚiWÂbWoWYWa]dZ[cb[h_oWhWjcWajÚh$ =[h[afeb_j_aWbWhÚ[ja_b[c[a"][h[ai[c[lYkjjkjkcl[Z[Â[hb[h[_b_Åa_djWhjÚÅcWbWhÚXWÅbWjcWZWZ[pWlWdjW`bÚ]hkfbWhÚd ih[Y[aWjÚbÚcÚdÚiWÂbWoWYWaodj[cb[h][b_Åj_hc[a][h[ab_Z_h$wWbÚÅcWdÚdXkXbcdZ["dY[b_ab["feb_j_aWbWhÚ[ja_b[# c[aaWlhWcÚjWhjÚÅÚbWYWajÚh$Feb_j_aWbWhÚ[ja_b[c[aWlhWcÚdÚdjWhjÚÅÚbZÚÂÚXkXbcZ["Z[pWlWdjW`bÚaWhWhih[Y_d[ZW^_b [jc[oebbWhÚdWl[d[Z[db[h_d[WdWb_p[Z_b[Y[aj_h$IedebWhWa_i[iWlkdkYkbka\WWb_o[jb[h_WhWYÚbÚÂÚobWaWckeokdZWc[l# Ykjjkjkcl[Z[Â[hb[h^WaaÚdZWjWhjÚÅcWbWhebkÅjkhcWoWaÚiWYWZ[Â_d_b[Y[aj_h$ IWlkdkYkbkÂkdWcWbWhÚdZWdX_h_feb_j_aWbWhÚ[ja_b[c[aj_h$Feb_j_aW][b_Åj_hc[a"o[h[b"kbkiWboWZWkbkibWhWhWiÚod[# j_cb[hjWhW\ÚdZWd][h[ab[Åj_h_bc[i_ZÅdb[d\WWb_o[jb[h_doWZW_b]_b_\WWb_o[jb[h_dih[b[h_d_djWdÚcbWcWl[ih[# b[h[_b_Åa_dfbWdbWcWbWhÚdoWfÚbWdZÚhÚbcWiÚZÚh$8_hXWÅaWjWdÚcZWfeb_j_aW][b_Åj_hc["X_h[ob[h_d"]hkfbWhÚdoWZWak# hkcbWhÚdfbWdbWcWbWhÚdÚd"fhe]hWcbWhÚdÚdl[fhei[Zhb[h_d_ddWiÚb][h[ab[Å[Y[Â_d[_b_Åa_daWhWhl[hc[ih[b[h_ebW# hWajWdÚcbWdcÚÅjÚh$19Feb_j_aWoWfcWih[Y_d_d_baWÅWcWiÚdÚi_oWiWb]dZ[c[][b[diehkdkdoWZWaedkdkdpbc[# i_oWZWZ[Â_Åj_h_bc[i___d_b]_b_fbWdbWcWdÚd"fhe]hWcÚdoWZWfhei[ZhdoWfÚbWdZÚhÚbcWiÚebkÅjkhkh$=dZ[c[][b[d aedk%iehkdoWiWbl[%oWXheahWj_ac[aWd_pcWbWhZW[b[WbÚdÚh$IehkdkddWiÚbjWdÚcbWdWYWÂÚ"feb_j_aWdÚd_[h_Â_d_ZeÂhk# ZWdX[b_hb[h$:ebWoÚiÚobWoWdbÚÅjWdÚcbWdcÚÅoWZWaedk_b[_b]_b_Wajhb[h_ZW^_b[jc[Z[djWdÚcbWdWdX_hiehkd"][b_Åj_# h_b[Y[aebWdfeb_j_aWoÚZWiÚdÚhbWoWYWÂÚ__d_b]_b__^j_oWbWhÚaWhÅÚbWoWcWp$Feb_j_aW][b_Åj_hc[ih[Y_d_dd[cb_WcW# YÚebZkÂkiob[d[X_b_h$Ãba_lWhebWdiehkdbWhÚdpc"_a_dY_i_h[aWX[j^Wb_dZ[a_ÚaWhbWhWhWiÚdZWkpbWÅcWiWÂbWcWa l[dYi_i[c[lYkjfeb_j_a]dZ[c_od[jc[aj_h$20zhd[al[hc[a][h[a_hi["_b]_b_feb_j_aWa[dji[bZdÅciedk# YkehjWoWÚaWdXWhÚdcWiehkdbWhÚdÚieioWboWhZÚcc[aWd_pcWbWhÚdÚ^Wh[a[j[][_h[h[apc[aebWX_b_h$Ãa_dY_aedkoW hd[a_i[a[dji[bZdÅciedkYkaWhÅÚaWhÅÚoW][b[dcW^Wbb[iWa_db[h_l[cW^Wbb[o[oWjÚhÚcoWfcWoÚfbWdbWoWdoWjÚ# hÚcYÚbWhWhWiÚdZWkpbWÅcWoÚiWÂbWcWajÚh$IWd<hWdY_iYehd[Â_dZ[oWjÚhÚcYÚbWhcW^Wbb[o[(Xoaej[bakhcWoÚWcW# bWcWajWZÚhbWh$CW^Wbb[iWa_db[h__i[oWÅWZÚabWhÚo[h_j[ha[jc[a_ij[c[c[aj[Z_hb[h${h[j_b[dfeb_j_aW"cW^Wbb[iWa_db[h_# d[oWfÚbWYWaebWdej[bb[hZ[_ij_^ZWciWÂbWcWoÚ"WohÚYW_b]_b_ej[bb[h_dcW^Wbb[d_d_o_b[Åj_hc[i_d[Z[ij[aebcWiÚdÚWcW# 19 8kjWdÚc^jjf0%%mmm$oekhZ_Yj_edWho$Yec%feb_YocWa_d]"^jjf0%%mmm$cedZe\WYje$Yec%\WYji%Z_Yj_edWho5feb_Yo!cWa_d]"iWo\WiÚdZWa_feb_j_aW oWfcWfeb_YocWa_d]jWdÚcÚdZWdWbÚdcÚÅjÚh$ 20 Ijh_d][h"@$l[H_Y^WhZied"@$'/-/"ºCWdW]_d]j^[Feb_j_YWb7][dZW0FheXb[c:[\_d_j_edWdZFeb_YoCWa_d]_d8h_jW_d»"FWhb_Wc[djWho7\\W# _hiEdb_d["de0))0()#)/"i$()$
'*
bWoWX_b_h$IedebWhWa"i_oWi_]dZ[c[XWhÚdcW_b[_b]_b_o[d_iehkdbWh][j_h_bZ_Â_dZ[]dZ[c_iehkdbWhl[jWb[fb[h[h[# l[i_dZ[od[jc[o_WcWbWoWX_b_h$
Feb_j_aW oWfcW ih[b[h_ j[c[bZ[ * WÅWcWZWd ebkÅkh$ Ãba WÅWcW" ZW^W dY[ Z[ X[b_hj_bZ_Â_ p[h[" X_h iehkd jWdÚcÚ oWfÚbÚh$Ãa_dY_WÅWcWZW"jWdÚcbWdWdfheXb[c]pddZ[XkbkdWhWaWbj[hdWj_\pcb[h][b_Åj_h_b_h${dYWÅWcWZW ebWiÚpcb[hZ[dX_h_"aWhWhl[h_Y_oWZWaWhWhl[h_Y_b[hjWhW\ÚdZWdi[_b_h$IedWÅWcWZW_i[d[h_b[dpc"feb_j_aW ko]kbWdÚh$21Feb_j_aWbWhÚd_[h_Â_"ih[Y_d__dZ[XkbkdWdWajhb[h_dWcWbWhÚ"jWb[fb[h_l[]dZ[cb[h__b[_b_Åa_b_l[iÚ# dÚhbÚZÚh$zp[bb_ab[jefbkciWbfeb_j_aWbWhipaedkikebkdYW"feb_j_aWbWhÚd][b_Åj_h_bc[i_dZ[oWZW_o_b[Åj_h_bc[i_dZ[o[h[b" kbkiWbl[kbkibWhWhWiÚZp[oZ[feb_j_aWYÚbWh"XheahWjbWhl[ko]kbWoÚYÚbWh]_X_aWhWhl[h_Y_b[hih[Y[ZW^_bebkhbWh$AWhWh l[hc[ih[Y_d[ZW^_bebWdoWZWebcWoWWbÚÅWdWajhb[hZ[dX_h_Z[i_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_Z_h$ JWdÚcbWhÚ"aWfiWcbWhÚl[_Åb[lb[h_^WaaÚdZW\WhabÚ]hÅb[hebcWiÚdWhWÂc[d"i_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_eÂkdbkabWºjef# bkciWboWhWh»iWÂbWoWdakhkbkÅbWhebWhWad_j[b[dZ_h_bc[aj[Z_h$JefbkciWboWhWhaWlhWcÚ"[bX[jj["\WhabÚh]jb[hl[XWaÚÅ WÚbWhÚjWhW\ÚdZWd\WhabÚjWdÚcbWdWX_b_h$:_Â[hX_hZ[o_Åb[d[o_d_o_"d[o_dajebZkÂk^[hXWaÚÅWÚiÚdW]h[\WhabÚp[b# b_ab[h__[h_h$zh]jb[hjWhW\ÚdZWdjWdÚcbWdWdl[X[b_hb[d[dº_o_»l[ºaj»"h]jdi_oWi_ZkhkÅk"_dWdbWhÚl[_ba[b[h_ _b[iÚdÚhbÚZÚh$8kZkhkcZWIJA½bWhÚjefbkciWboWhWhiWÂbWoWdh]jb[hebWhWa]hc[d_doWdÚiÚhW"jefbkcW_b_Åa_db[ab[h_ _b[iÚdÚhbÚXoaoWZWaaZ[Â_Å_c_^[Z[\b[o[dl[ZebWoÚiÚobWc_ahei_oWi[joWfWdakhkbkÅbWhebWhWajWdÚcbWcWa ZWccadZh$I_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_dWÚaWX[b_hj_bc_Å_Z[ebe`_aX_hWcWYÚoWZWibe]WdÚebcWiWX_b["_Z[ebe`_aX_h oWdiÚcWiÚebWYWÂÚck^WaaWajÚh$22:W^WiÚX_hiehkdWoWZWaedkoWWÚaWpcb[h][j_hc[o_WcWbWZÚÂÚdÚX[b_hj[di_l_b jefbkch]jfeb_j_aWoWfcWih[b[h_d[aWjÚbÚcÚWcWbWoWYWajÚh$ I_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_dfeb_j_aWoWfcWih[b[h_dZ[o[hWbcWiÚ"p[bb_ab["]hdc[pl[i[ii_pebWdbWhÚd_^j_oWbWhÚdÚl[ jWb[fb[h_d_]dZ[c[][j_hc[b[h_WÚiÚdZWdd[cb_Z_h$zp[bb_ab[Z[pWlWdjW`bÚa_Å_b[h_doWZW]hkfbWhÚdX_hWhWoW][bc[i_ _b[akhkbWdi_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_"a_Å_b[h_doWZWh]jb[h_dZ[d[o_cb[h_d[ZWoWdWhWa_b]_b_WbWdbWhZWiehkdbWhÚ"a_Å_b[h_d _^j_oWbWhÚdWko]kdjWdÚcbWoWX_b_hb[hl[%oWWbj[hdWj_\pcb[hh[j[X_b_hb[h$A_Å_b[h_da[dZ_Z[d[o_cb[h_d[ZWoWdWhWaie# hkdbWhÚdÚjWdÚcbWcWbWhÚl[oWjWb[fb[h_d_][b_Åj_hc[b[h__^j_oWbWhbWZeÂhkZWd_b_Åa_akhcWoÚiWÂbWh$8ob[b_ab[XheahWjbW# hÚdoWZWfeb_j_aW][b_Åj_h[db[h_dakÅXWaÚÅÚl[_a_XeokjbkiehkdWdWb_pb[h_l[][b_Åj_hZ_ab[h_feb_j_aWbWho[h_d["_^j_oWiW^_# X_d_dh[ic_d__dZ[d][b_Åj_hZ_Â_pcb[h]dbafhWj_ab[hb[ZW^WkokcbkebWX_b_h$Ã^j_oWiW^_fb[h_d_da[dZ_iehkdbWhÚdÚ jWdÚcbWoWX_bc[b[h_l[Xk_^j_oWbWh__dh]jb[d_fiWlkdkYkbkaoWfWX_bc[b[h___d^[c\WhaÚdZWbÚabWhÚdÚdWhjcWiÚ"^[c Z[_^j_oWbWhÚdÚjWdÚcbWoWX_b[Y[aX[Y[h_b[h_[Z_dc[b[h_][h[ac[aj[Z_h$Ãb]_b_oWpÚdZW]b[dZ_hc[ebWhWa][[daWlhWc" Z[pWlWdjW`bÚX_h[ob[h_da[dZ_^WabWhÚdÚiWlkdWX_bc[b[h_X_hijhWj[`_l[WodÚpWcWdZWWcWjÚh$=b[dZ_hc[_b["eÂkdbka# bW"aWZÚdbWh"oeaikbbWh"[d][bb_b[h]_X_Z[pWlWdjW`bÚX_h[ob[h_da_Å_i[b][b_Å_cb[h_d[aWjaÚZWXkbkdcWa"WohÚYWWbZÚabWhÚ^_p# c[jb[hp[h_d[ipiob[c[^WabWhÚdÚdXkbkdcWiÚWcWbWdcWajWZÚh$=b[dZ_hc["_^j_oWZkoWdbWhWZWdÚÅcWdbÚaiWÂ# bWcWajWd"fbWdbWcWbWhoWfÚbÚha[dZ[pWlWdjW`bÚ]hkfbWhÚdaWjÚbÚcÚdWaWZWh][d_ÅX_hWbWdZWa_\WWb_o[jb[hZ_h$:[pWlWdjW`bÚ ]hkfbWh"p[bb_ab[^_pc[jWbZÚabWhÚZkhkcbWhZW][h_X_bZ_h_c__dp_oWh[j[Z_b_hb[h$7dYWaXkj[ajWhW\bÚX_hih[j_h$Ih[Y_d _a_odbebcWiÚdÚiWÂbWoWYWa\WWb_o[j_i[Z[pWlWdjW`bÚ]hkfbWhZWdiWZ[Y[][h_X_bZ_h_cjefbWcWaZ[Â_b"WodÚpWcWdZW Xk][h_X_bZ_h_cb[h_d_b]_b_feb_j_aWbWhÚdoWZWko]kbWcWbWhÚd][h[ab[Åj_h_bc[i_dZ[]pdd[WbÚdcWiÚZÚh$:[pWlWdjW`bÚ a_Å_b[h_doWZW]hkfbWhÚd]b[dc[i_^[ch]jb[dc[b[h___d][h[ab_]l[dl[X[Y[h_b[h_aWpWdcWbWhÚdÚiWÂbWh"^[cZ[ h]jb[d[h[aa[dZ_Z[d[o_cb[h_dZ[dc[Åhk_o[j_d_WbWd_^j_oWbWhÚdÚl[jWb[fb[h_d_Z_b[][j_hc[b[h_d_aebWobWÅjÚhcWajWZÚh$ I_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_d"p[bb_ab[Z[pWlWdjW`bÚ]hkfbWhjWhW\ÚdZWdh]jb[d[di_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_d"feb_j_aWoWfcW l[aWhWhl[hc[ih[b[h_d[aWjÚbÚcÚ_a_jhbebWX_b_h$8_h_dY_i_i_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_dih[Y_dZÚÅÚdZWaWbcWbWhÚl[ ih[Y[ZÚÅWhÚZWdcZW^Wb[[jc[b[h_Z_h$Ãa_dY_i__i[i_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_dih[Y[ZeÂhkZWdaWjÚbÚcÚl[feb_j_aWoWfcW ih[Y_dZ[o[hWbcWbWhÚZÚh$238kdbWhZWd_ba_i_l_bjefbkch]jdd"feb_j_aWoWfcWih[Y_d_dZÚÅÚdZWebcWiÚdWhWÂ# c[dih[b[h_[b[Åj_hc[i_l[ih[b[h_dZ[Â_Åj_h_bc[i___d_[h_Z[XkbkdWdi_oWi_b[h_l[XheahWjbWhÚ_adWWbÚÅcWbWhÚZÚh$ 21 ?hm_d"B[m_i=$(&&)"J^[Feb_Yo7dWboij½i>WdZXeea0HWj_edWbFheXb[cIebl_d]_dWFeb_j_YWbMehbZ"C$;$I^Whf[?dY$"D[mOeha"i$*($ 22 7aWo">Wb[(&&-"I_l_bJefbkcAkhkbkÅbWhÚÃ_dIjhWj[`_a:Ådc[l[IjhWj[`_=[b_Åj_hc["ÃijWdXkb8_b]_{d_l[hi_j[i_OWoÚdbWhÚ"ÃijWdXkb"i$/$ 23 <_jpZk\\"CWh_l[9^khY^"9^[oWdd[(&&*" ºIj[ff_d]kfjej^[JWXb[0D=EIjhWj[]_[i\eh?d\bk[dY_d]Feb_Yoed9ed\b_Yj?iik[i»"D=EiWjj^[ JWXb[__dZ["Z[hb[o[d<_jpZk\\"C$l[9^khY^"9$(&&*"HemcWdWdZB_jjb[\_[bZFkXb_i^_d]=hekfi"BWd^Wc"i$($
15 8hWjjed"'//&½bWhWaWZWhi_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_ddY[b_ab[_aj_ZWhÚdZÚÅÚdZWaWbcWoÚj[hY_^[jj_ab[h_d_X[b_hjc_Åj_h$(*:_# Â[hX_hZ[o_Åb["i_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_ih[Y_dZÚÅÚdZWdc[lYkjoWZW][b_Åj_h_b[dfeb_j_aWbWhÚ_pb[o_f"[b[Åj_h_b[h_d_][j_h# c[aj[Z_hb[h$8_hZ_Â[hWbj[hdWj_\_i[ih[Y[_b_Åa_dd[h_b[h_oWZWZ[Â_Å_ab_ab[h_feb_j_aWbWhÚoWfWdbWhÚ[ja_b[o_f]dZ[c[ ][j_hc[b[h_Z_h$O[d_b[d[X_b_h;d[h`_OWiWiÚAWcfWdoWiÚ½dZW=h[[df[WY[l[_ÅX_hb_Â_oWfjÚÂÚZ_Â[hh]jb[hfeb_j_aWh[j# c[ih[Y_d_dZeÂhkZWd__dZ[ebcWZWd"ih[Y[ZÚÅWhÚZWdaWcfWdoWoÚh]jb[o[h[al[_[h_Z[a_c_bb[jl[a_bb[h_d[beX_oW# fWhWaZW^_bebckÅbWhZÚh$25 I_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_d"feb_j_aWoWfcWih[b[h_d[aWjÚbcWoebbWhÚdZWdX_hZ_Â[h_Z[ih[Y_d__dZ[o[hWbcWbWhÚZÚh$ Feb_j_aW][b_Åj_hc[ih[Y_dZ[cWiWZWo[h_ebWdWajhb[hZ[dX_h_ebWhWai_l_bjefbkch]jddfWoZWÅbWhZWdX_h_^Wb_d[ ][bc[i_d[cb_Z_h$zp[bb_ab[^_pc[jWbWdZ[pWlWdjW`bÚa_Å_oWZW]hkfbWhÚdakhZkabWhÚi_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_"a[dZ_Z[d[# o_cb[h_l[_^j_oWbWhÚdWZWoWdWhWafeb_j_aWoWfcWih[Y_dZ[o[hWbWX_b_hb[h$OkaWhÚZWa_XbcZ[Z[X[b_hj_bZ_Â_]_X_"Z[# pWlWdjW`bÚ]hkfbWhÚdih[Y_d__dZ[o[hWbcWiÚfeb_j_aW][b_Åj_hc[ih[Y_d_d_baWÅWcWiÚebWdiehkdkdjWdÚcbWdcWiÚi# h[Y_d_d[cb_bZ[[ja_b[o[X_b_h$D_j[a_ciehkdZeÂhkl[_^j_oWYWko]kdÅ[a_bZ[jWdÚcbWdZÚÂÚbZ["feb_j_aWbWhZW_^# j_oWbWhWY[lWfl[h[Y[aÅ[a_bZ[][b_Åj_h_b[X_b_hb[h$I_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_dih[Y[ZW^_b[Z_bc[i_d[d[cb_hd[ab[hZ[d X_h_7ÚaAeehZ_dWioedOdj[c_½Z_h$7ÚaAeehZ_dWioedOdj[c_"(&&&oÚbÚdZWa_B_pXedIjhWj[`__b[7lhkfW8_hb_Â_ba[b[h_ jWhW\ÚdZWdX[d_ci[dc_ÅX_hodj[cZ_h$8kodj[c[]h["p[bb_ab[ieioWb_[hc[WbWdÚdZW"ieioWb^_pc[jWbWdÚdZWW# bÚÅWdi_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_dkbkiWbºieioWb_[hc[X[b][b[h_»d_d^WpÚhbWdcWiÚdZWl[ºkbkiWb[ob[cfbWdbWhÚ»dÚdoW# fÚbcWiÚdZW]hÅb[h_d_dWbÚdcWiÚl[ih[Y[ZW^_b[Z_bc[b[h_][h[ac[aj[Z_h$I_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_"feb_j_aWbWhÚd][b_Å# j_h_bZ_Â_ih[b[h[]hÅl[h[h[aaWjÚbcWdÚdoWdÚiÚhWoWiWoWfcW\WWb_o[jb[h_dZ[Z[XkbkdcWoÚjWb[f[jc[aj[Z_hb[h$7d# YWaXkjWb[f"eÂkdbkabW"oWiWoWfcWdÚdºj[ad_aX_h_Å»ebZkÂkWh]cWdÚ_b[][h_[lh_bc[aj[Z_h$I_l_bjefbkch]jb[# h_d_doWiWoWfcWih[b[h_d[ZW^_bebcWiÚdÚdddZ[ºoWiWoWfcWZ_b_d_X_bc[Z_ab[h_»iWlÚZkhcWajWZÚh$8heahWjbW# hÚdl[i_oWi_b[h_dºX_bc[a»p[h_dZ[dakhZkabWhÚXk_aj_ZWh"h]jb[h_d^[coWiWoWfcWa__d_pb[dc[i_][h[a[dfhei[Z# hX_bc[Z_ab[h_"^[cZ[oWiWoWpcWZ_b_d_X_bc[Z_ab[h_d_d[ihc[aj[Z_h$7dYWaoWiWoWfcWfhei[Zhdl[oWiWZ_b_# d_Xk^_o[hWhÅ_Z[dakhjWhcWal[^[cÅ[\\W\"^[cZ[kbWÅÚbWX_b_haÚbcWaccadZh$OWiWoWfcWoW_b_Åa_doWfÚbWdZÚhÚ# bWdl[aehkdWdXk_aj_ZWhWbWdÚ"^[cXheahWjbWhÚdl[i_oWi_b[h_dºod[jc[»o[_b_Åa_d]Ydf[a_Åj_hc[aj["^[cZ[i# h[Y_ddWiÚb_b[hb[o[Y[Â_d[aWhWhl[hc[Z[i_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_ZÚÅWhÚZWXÚhWacWajWZÚh$26EoiWoWiWoWfcWZ_b_d_Wd# bWÅÚbWX_b_haÚbcWao_d[oWiWoWfcW_aj_ZWhÚdWiW^_febWdbWhÚd[b_dZ[Z_h$:_Â[hX_hZ[o_Åb["oWiWoWfcW]Yd[b_dZ[jk# jWdbWh"ih[Y_dfhei[Zhb[h_d[l[Z_b_d[^Wa_cebZkabWhÚ__d_aj_ZWhÚ[bb[h_dZ[jkjcWpbWh$7ai_d[_aj_ZWh[bb[h_dZ[ebZk# Âk__dih[Y_aedjheb[Z[X_b_hb[h$ 8kaedkZWiedebWhWa"i_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_dfeb_j_aW][b_Åj_hc[ih[b[h_d[_ij[hZÚÅWhÚZWd"_ij[hi[_[h_Z[debikd ^Wd]_c[Åhk_o[jp[c_d_dZ[daWjÚbZÚabWhÚdÚoWZWaWjÚbcWoÚjWb[f[jj_ab[h_d_jWhjÚÅcWa\WoZWbÚebWX_b_h$weÂkpWcWd"i_# l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_d"p[bb_ab[Z[pWlWdjW`bÚ]hkfbWhjWhW\ÚdZWdh]jb[dc_Åb[hi["j[ci_b[Z_b[c[o[db[h_j[ci_b[jj_ab[# h_ZÅdbc[aj[Z_h$7dYWai_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_dj[ci_b[Z_b[c[o[doWZW[Z_bc[o[da_Å_b[h_oWZW]hkfbWhÚZ[Â_b"ae# dkbWhÚj[ci_b[Z[hb[h$zh]jb[h"aedkÅkbcWoWdoWZW]hdc[o[daedkbWhÚdjWhjÚÅÚbcWiÚl[]hdhaÚbÚdcWbWhÚ__dW# bÚÅÚhbWh$P_hWa_Å_b[h_j[ci_b[jj_ab[h_d__ZZ_W[ji[b[h"j[ci_b_o[jb[_b]_b_c[lYkjiehkdbWhl[iehkbWhi_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_# d[Z[iehkbWX_b_h$zhd[Â_d'$&&&o[i_oWZW]dbbiXkbkdWdi_l_bjefbkch]jddZ_bb[dZ_hZ_Â_iehkd"aedkoWZW _^j_oW")&o[i_oWZW]dbbiebWdh]jdZ_bb[dZ_hZ_Â_aedkoWZWiehkdZWdZW^WcÚc[Åhk"d[cb_oWZWWZ_bZ_h$ A[pW"c[Åhk_o[j_iWÂbWoWdiWoÚiWbeÂkdbkaebiWoZÚ"c[Yb_ij[j[ci_b[Z_bc[aj[dd[\WhaÚebWX_b_hZ_5:ebWoÚiÚobWi_l_bjef# bkch]jb[h_aedkbWhÚd]dZ[c[][bc[i_d_"aWckeokdZWjWhjÚÅÚbcWiÚdÚl[_b]_b_feb_j_aWbWhÚd][b_Åj_h_bc[i_d_oWZWZ[# Â_Åj_h_bc[i_d_WcWbWoWX_b_hb[h$ D_j[a_ciWlkdkYkbka_a_dY_\WWb_o[j_ebWdWbWdZWjkjkcl[Z[Â[hb[hb[_b]_b_\WhaÚdZWbÚaoWhWjcWaedkoW_b_Åa_d"j[ci_b [Z_b[daedkdkdjWhjÚÅÚbcWiÚdWod[b_aX_h\WWb_o[jj_h$8khWZWWcWbWdWda_Å_oWZW]hkfbWhÚdjWhjÚÅÚbcWiÚZ[Â_b"ZW^W (* 8hWjjed"C_Y^W[b'//&"ºDed#]el[hdc[djWbEh]Wd_pWj_edi_d7\h_YW09WdJ^[o?d\bk[dY[Feb_Yo5»":[l[befc[djWdZ9^Wd]["Y$('0.-#''." i$/)$ 25 =hXp"zp]h(&&,O[d_b[d[X_b_h;d[h`_OWiWiÚAWcfWdoWiÚ"ÃijWdXkb8_b]_{d_l[hi_j[i_IJA;Â_j_cl[7hWÅjÚhcW8_h_c_"IWlkdkYkbkal[ Feb_j_aWbWhÚ;ja_b[c[Aed\[hWdiÚ"de0+$ 26 Ãaj_ZWhl[X_b]__b_Åa_i_d[_b_Åa_dZ[jWobÚjWhjÚÅcWbWh__dXap$<ekYWkbj"C_Y^[b(&&+zpd[l[Ãaj_ZWh"7ohÚdjÚOWoÚdbWhÚ"ÃijWdXkb$
16 p_oWZ[a_Å_oWZW]hkfbWhÚdjWdÚcbWZÚÂÚiehkdoWZW_^j_oWbWhÚdjWhjÚÅÚbcWiÚdWod[b_aj_h$zhd[Â_dJha_o[½Z[a_i_l_bWbWd l[iWlkdkYkbkÂW_b_Åa_dd[cb_aWpWdÚcbWhZWdX_h_ebWdaWZÚd^Wh[a[j_l[iWlkdkYkbkaWbÚÅcWbWhÚX_hoWdZWdZeÂhk# ZWdoWiWoWfcWih[Y_d_[ja_b[c_Å"Z_Â[hoWdZWdaWZÚdbWhÚd^WabWhÚdWkbWÅÚcÚaedkikdkdj[ahWh]dZ[c[][bc[i_d[ l[jWhjÚÅÚbcWiÚdWd[Z[debckÅjkh$
(-)$AedkbWhÚdj[ci_b_0DWiÚbl[d[h[Z[5
J[ci_b[Z_b[c[o[d]hkfbWhÚdi[ib[h_d_ZkokhWX_bc[b[h_"jWb[fb[h_d_Z_b[][j_h[X_bc[b[h_l[_b]_b_aedkbWhÚ]dZ[c[][j_h# c[b[h_o[h[b"kbkiWbl[kbkibWhWhWiÚZp[oebcWap[h[\WhabÚi[l_o[b[hZ[ebWX_b_h$J[ci_b[Z_b[c[o[d]hkfbWhjWhW\ÚdZWd Z_b[][j_h_b[daedkbWho[h[b"kbkiWboWZWkbkibWhWhWiÚ]_X_\WhabÚZp[ob[hZ[l[o[h[bod[j_cZ[d"kbkiWbc[aWd_pcWbWhW" ^WjjWkbkibWhWhWiÚoWfÚbWhWaWZWh\WhabÚWajhb[hb[fWobWÅÚbWX_b_hb[h$Ãb]_b_aedkdkd^Wd]_Zp[oZ[jWhjÚÅÚbWYWÂÚjWb[f[Z_# b[dfeb_j_aWoWZWoWiWZ[Â_Å_ab_Â_d_d^Wd]_Zp[oZ[ebZkÂkoWZW^Wd]_c[aWd_pcWbWhWhWYÚbÚÂÚobW][h[ab[Åj_h_b[X_b[# Y[Â__b[_b]_b_Z_h$ O[h[bZp[oZ[okhjjWÅ_d_i_oWj_\b[h_l[i_l_bh]jb[dc[b[hWhWYÚbÚÂÚobW_b]_b_aedkbWhÚdj[ci_b[Z_bc[i_"eÂkdbkabW"o[h[b od[j_cZp[o_dZ[oWfÚbWdiWlkdkYkbka\WWb_o[jb[h__b[][h[ab[Å_h$O[h[bod[j_cZp[o_dZ[feb_j_aWoWfcWl[aWhWh l[hc[c[aWd_pcWbWhÚdWaWjÚbÚcp[bb_ab[d[cb_Z_h$>[hd[aWZWhkbkiWboWZWkbkibWhWhWiÚZp[oZ[oWfÚbWdaWdkdbWhl[ ko]kbWdWdfeb_j_aWbWh^WoWjÚcÚpÚ[ja_b[i[Z["o[h[bod[j_cZp[o_dZ[WbÚdWdaWhWhbWhl[ko]kbWdWdfeb_j_aWbWhZeÂhk# ZWd]dZ[b_afhWj_ab[h_c_p_l[oWÅWZÚÂÚcÚpo[h_Å[a_bb[dZ_h_hl[%oWZ[Â_Åj_h_h$O[h[bZp[oZ[feb_j_aW][b_Åj_hc[l[aWhWh l[hc[c[aWd_pcWbWhÚdWaWjÚbÚcZWko]kbWdWdc[jejbWhÚdZhjWdW[ai[dZ[jefbWdZÚÂÚiob[d[X_b_h$8kdbWhZWd_ba_^Wba jefbWdjÚbWhÚ"ZWdÚÅcWZeacWdbWhÚ%hWfehbWhÚ"aec_j[b[hl[iehk#Y[lWfjefbWdjÚbWhÚ]_X_][b[d[ai[bc[jejbWhZÚh$Ãa_dY_i_" eÂkdbkabW"^_pc[jWbWdbWhWod[b_aoWfÚbWdZÚhÚbWd^_pc[jWbWdZ[Â[hb[dZ_hc[WhWÅjÚhcWbWhÚcÅj[h_Z[Z[d_bc[aj[Z_h" Å_a~o[j%c[cdkd_o[jakjkbWhÚ]_X_^_pc[jWbWdeZWabÚWbÚÅcWbWhÚ${dYi_dj[hWaj_\m[XiWo\WbWhÚ"okhjjWÅfWd[bb[h_" eZWa]hkfWbÚÅcWbWhÚl[h[\[hWdZkc]_X_oWhWjÚYÚc[jejbWhZÚh$IedebWhWaZhZdYi_i[okhjjWÅbWhÚd\WhabÚaedkbWh ^WaaÚdZWaWjÚbÚcÚdÚj[Ål_a[Z[dokhjjWÅ`h_b[h_"cW^Wbb[fbWdbWhÚ"o[hb[Å_c_^j_oWWdWb_pb[h_"][b[Y[Â[od[b_aokhjjWÅ# bWhÚdoWZWcW^Wbb[iWa_db[h_d_dX[ab[dj_b[h_d_diÚhWbWdZÚÂÚl_poed[]p[hi_pb[h_l[[Å_jb_aedkbWh^WaaÚdZW\ehkcbWhZWd ebkÅWdaWjÚbÚcYÚodj[cb[hZ_h$28O[h[bod[j_cb[hZp[o_dZ[aWhWhc[aWd_pcWbWhÚdWaWjÚbÚcÚdXWpÚZkhkcbWhZWoWiWbWhbW [h[l[i__p_bc_Ål[]WhWdj_WbjÚdWWbÚdcÚÅjÚh$ O[h[bZp[oZ[feb_j_aW][b_Åj_hc[l[aWhWhl[hc[c[aWd_pcWbWhÚdWaWjÚbÚc__dko]kbWdcWoWWbÚÅÚbWdceZ[bb[hZ[dX_h_ Z[a[djaedi[ob[h_Z_h$29=dZ[c('½_dÚaÚÅdeajWiÚ">Wp_hWd'//(½Z[H_eZ[@Wd[h_e½ZWoWfÚbWdl[ºO[hopP_hl[i_»ebW# hWaWZbWdZÚhÚbWd8_hb[Åc_ÅC_bb[jb[hw[lh[l[AWbaÚdcWAed\[hWdiÚ½ZÚh$H_eAed\[hWdiÚ"'/-(>Wp_hWdÚ½dZW"'')ba[d_d aWjÚbÚcÚobWjefbWdWdIjeYa^ebcAed\[hWdiÚ½dZWIjeYa^ebc9ed\[h[dY[edj^[>kcWd;dl_hedc[djj[c[bb[h_WjÚbWdX_h ih[b[XWÅbWcÚÅjÚh$IjeYa^ebcAed\[hWdiÚ"ah[i[bWfjWoWfÚbWd_baZeÂWaehkcWl[aWbaÚdcW_b[_b]_b_aed\[hWdiebcW p[bb_Â_jWÅÚh$'/.)½Z[8_hb[Åc_ÅC_bb[jb[hw[lh[l[AWbaÚdcW{p[h_d[:doWAec_ioedk½dkMehbZ9ecc_ii_eded;dl_# hedc[djWdZ:[l[befc[djakhckÅjkh$:hjoÚbiedhW_i[_baiW^WhWfehkebWdEhjWa=[b[Y[Â_c_pEkh9ecced<kjkh[30 oWoÚdbWdcÚÅjÚh$8hkdjbWdZAec_ioedkebWhWaZWX_b_d[daec_ioed"Xjd_diWdbÚÂÚ_ÅoWfcWfhWj_ab[h_Z[Â_Åc[pi[l[][# b_Åc[ZdoWdÚd[aebe`_ab_c_jb[h_d[ko]kd^Wb_d[][j_h_bc[pi["aWXkb[Z_b[c[pZ[h[Y[Z[WYÚl[[lh[i[bpWhWhbWhbWaWhÅÚ aWhÅÚoW][b_d[X_b[Y[Â_aedkikdZWkoWhcÚÅjÚh$HWfehWohÚYWºÃdiWdbÚaaWbaÚdcWoÚihZhb[X_b_h^Wb[][j_h[X_b[Y[a"Xkdk ZW][b[Y[ad[i_bb[h_da[dZ__^j_oWbWhÚdÚaWhÅÚbWoWX_bc[i_d[[d][bebcWZWdoWfWX_b[Y[aaWX_b_o[jj[Z_h»Z[c_Åj_h$8_hb[Å# c_ÅC_bb[jb[h'/./½ZWihZhb[X_b_haWbaÚdcWdÚddWiÚbXWÅWhÚbWX_b[Y[Â_d_ehjWoWaeocWa__dw[lh[l[AWbaÚdcW{p[h_d[ Aed\[hWdi½Ú9ed\[h[dY[ed;dl_hedc[djWdZ:[l[befc[djfbWdbWcWoWXWÅbWcÚÅjÚh$Ãa_oÚbXeokdYW"ZdoWdÚd^[ho[h_d# (- AWZÚd>Wh[a[j_l[oWiWZ[Â_Å_ab_Â___dXap$7ocWd"P[bWb(&&*"Jha_o[½Z[AWZÚd>Wh[a[j_l[IWlkdkYkbkawWbÚÅcWbWhÚ"P[bWb7ocWd"ÃijWd# Xkb8_b]_{d_l[hi_j[i_"IJA;Â_j_cl[7hWÅjÚhcW8_h_c_"IWlkdkYkbkal[Feb_j_aWbWhÚ;ja_b[c[Aed\[hWdiOWpÚbWhÚde$'$ 28 A[djb[Åc[ÄkhWiÚ(&&/"8WoÚdZÚhbÚal[Ãia~d8WaWdbÚÂÚjWhW\ÚdZWdZp[db[dc_Åj_h"^jjf0%%mmm$XWo_dZ_hb_a$]el$jh%jkhaY[%a[djb[ic[%a_jWf'&$ fZ\$OkaWhÚZWiÚhWbWdWdbWhÅkhWdÚda_jWXÚaWodWaWbÚdWhWap[jb[dc_Åj_h$ 29 A[djAedi[ob[h_c[lpkWjÚ^WaaÚdZWXWaÚdÚp0^jjf0%%mmm$c[lpkWj$WZWb[j$]el$jh%^jcb%(-'--$^jcb 30 ^jjf0%%mmm$kd$eh]%ZeYkc[dji%]W%h[i%*(%Wh[i*(#'.-$^jc'-Z[dkpcWdbWhl[i_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_dZ[dX_db[hY[_diWdaedkobW_b]_b_WbÚÅcÚÅl[aed\[hWdiWaWjaÚZWXkbkdckÅjkh$31 JcXkjWhjÚÅcWbWhÚdj[c[bfh[di_X_"_diWdbWhÚdihZhb[X_b_haWbaÚdcWdÚdeZWÂÚebZkÂkZkh$Aed\[hWdijWl[_b]_b_jWh# jÚÅcWbWhZWeZWa"_diWdbWhÚd"ZeÂWobWkokc__dZ["iWÂbÚabÚl[h[ja[dX_h^WoWjW^WabWhÚebZkÂkp[h_d[Z_h$'//(½Z[oW# oÚdbWdWdH_e:[abWhWioedk½dkdi_l_bWbWd"iWlkdkYkbka\WWb_o[jb[h_l[aWhWhWbcWc[aWd_pcWbWhÚdWaWjÚbÚcbW_b]_b_ebW# hWaah_j_aebWdp[bb_Â_"aed\[hWdijWakbbWdÚbWdl[h_b[h_djefbWdcWiÚl[Z[abWhWioedkd^WpÚhbWdÚfoWoÚdbWdcWiÚih[Y_dZ[ oWbdÚp^ac[jb[h_dZ[Â_b"i_l_bWbWdZWdkpcWdbWhÚdl[i_l_bjefbkch]jb[h_d_daWjaÚbWhÚdÚdkbkibWhWhWiÚZp[oZ[jWb[f [Z_bc_Ål[[ja_debWhWaakbbWdÚbcÚÅebcWiÚZÚh$ =dZ[c('fhe]hWcÚ"H_eZ[abWhWioedkdZWaWhWhl[h_bc_Åj_hl[ihZhb[X_b_haWbaÚdcWoWokhjjWÅbWhÚdl[okhjjWÅ_d_i_# oWj_\b[h_d_daWjÚbÚcÚdÚWcWbWcWajWZÚh$=dZ[c('fhe]hWcÚdÚdWcWYÚo[h[bod[j_cb[h[l[aWhWhWbcWih[b[h_d[][# d_ÅaWjÚbÚcÚdiWÂbWdcWiÚoebkobWihZhb[X_b_haWbaÚdcWoW^_pc[j[jc[aj_h$A[djaedi[ob[h_d_d"c[lpkWjjWo[h[bZp[o# Z[aWjÚbÚcÚdoWo]ÚdbWÅjÚhÚbcWiÚ"ehjWaoWÅWcX_b_dY_d_d][b_Åj_h_bc[i_"eaehjWabÚod[j_Å_cWdbWoÚÅÚdÚdX[d_ci[dc[i_l[ ihZhb[X_b_h][b_Åc[d_diWÂbWdcWiÚ]_X_]h[lb[h_lWhZÚh$A[djaedi[ob[h_WhWYÚbÚÂÚobWo[h[bod[j_ciWa_db[h_d_daWhWh l[hc[l[feb_j_aW][b_Åj_hc[ih[b[h_d[ZeÂhkZWdaWjÚbÚcÚWcWbWdcÚÅjÚh$ O[h[bZp[oZ[aWhWhl[hc[ih[b[h_d[aWjÚbÚcÚdoWdÚiÚhW"kbkiWbZp[oZ[^[coWiWoWfcW"^[cZ[feb_j_aWbWhÚ[ja_# b[c[ih[b[h_d[aWjÚbÚcÚd[cb_l[][h[ab_Z_h$KbkiWbZp[oZ[oWiWoWfcWih[b[h_d[aWjÚbÚc"i_l_bjefbkch]jdd ZeÂhkZWdoWiWoWfcWih[Y_d[aWjÚbÚcÚoWZWfeb_j_aWbWhÚ[ja_b[c[a__d_[h_Z[a_Wajhb[h_[ja_b[c[o[WbÚÅcWiÚebW# X_b_h$KbkiWbZp[oZ[feb_j_aWbWhÚ[ja_b[c[d_dd[cb_l[_o_hd[ab[h_dZ[dX_h_"ZW^WdY[Z[XW^i[Z_bZ_Â_p[h[aWZÚd ^Wh[a[j_d_dC[Z[d_AWdkdl[Jha9[pWAWdkdkih[b[h_dZ[a_XWÅWhÚZÚh$AWZÚd^Wh[a[j_"aWZÚdÚd^WabWhÚdWkbWÅÚcÚ aedkikdZWaWckeokdZW\WhaÚdZWbÚaoWhWjcWdÚdoWdÚiÚhW"^WabWhÚdÚd]WhWdj_WbjÚdWWbÚdcWiÚl[aWZÚdbWhÚdoWÅWcbWhÚ# dÚd_o_b[Åj_h_bc[i___d_b]_b_aWdkdbWhÚdl[feb_j_aWbWhÚdZp[db[dc[i___dWbÚÅcÚÅjÚh$P[bWb7ocWd½Úd"aWZÚd^Wh[a[j_d_d" C[Z[d_ AWdkd½k l[ Jha 9[pW AWdkdk½dk Z[Â_Åj_hc[ WXWiÚdZWd l[ ih[Y_dZ[d XW^i[jj_Â_ aedkÅcWiÚdZW" ih[j[
Jha_o[½Z[a_^kakai_ij[c_l[Z_b_^WaaÚdZWX_b]_jefbWcWdÚdX_haÚhÚbcWdeajWiÚebZkÂkdWZ[Â_dc_Åj_h$327ocWdWohÚYW" ^[caWckeokdZW\WhaÚdZWbÚaoWhWjÚbcWiÚdÚd"^[cZ[kbkiWbWfjW"Z_Â[hh]jb]hkfbWhZWd"i[dZ_aWbWhW"c_bb[jl[a_b# b[h_dZ[dc[Yb_ij[a_oWiWoWfWdXheahWjbWhWaWZWh\WhabÚWajhb[hb[ehjWabÚabWhÚd][b_Åj_h_bc[i_d_dd[c_d_lkh]kbWcÚÅjÚh$ ÃcpWaWcfWdoWbWhÚdZWd"fhej[ijeohoÅb[h_d["Z_b[a[[ob[cb[h_dZ[d"c[Yb_ij[c_bb[jl[a_bb[h__b[]hÅc[b[h[aWZWh [Å_jb_oebbWhbW"aWZÚd^Wh[a[j_oWiWoWfcWih[Y_dZ[i[i_d_ZkokhcWoÚXWÅWhcÚÅl[ih[Y[ZW^_bebckÅjkh$Ãb]_b_oWiW# bWhÚdo[d_Z[dakh]kbWdcWiÚdZWaWZÚd^Wh[a[j_[Å_jb_aWdWbbWhWhWYÚbÚÂÚobWih[Y[ZW^_bebckÅl[jWcWc[debcWiWX_b[ aWZÚdbWhÚd^WoWjbWhÚdÚebkcbkÅ[a_bZ[[ja_b[o[Y[aZ[Â_Å_ab_ab[h_debcWiÚdÚiWÂbWcÚÅjÚh$D_j[a_ckbkiWbZp[oZ[oWiWl[ feb_j_aWbWhÚZ[Â_Åj_hc[a__d^Wh[a[j[][c[a"7ocWd½W]h[oWiWbWhÚZ[Â_Åj_h[h[a"aWZÚdbWhÚd^WoWjÚdWaWjÚbWYWaebWd WdbWcl[Z[Â_Å_ab_Â_df[Å_d[ZÅc[aj_$33KbkiWbWfjWoWfÚbWdoWiWl[feb_j_aWZ[Â_Å_ab_ab[h_"WodÚWdZWl[iÚdÚhbWh __dZ[a_jcYeÂhW\oWZWoWfÚbZÚÂÚ__dd[cb_X_h_lc[l[aWpWdÚciWÂbWoWX_bc[aj[Z_h$ OWiWbWhÚl[feb_j_aWbWhÚZ[Â_Åj_hc[d_dX_hZ_Â[hoebkc[lYkjoWiWbWhÚdl[feb_j_aWbWhÚd]hdhl[WdbWÅÚbWX_b_hebcWiÚ# dÚiWÂbWcWajÚh$=hdhbal[WdbWÅÚbWX_b_hb_Â_diWÂbWdcWiÚ__d][h[ab_ebWd"_b]_b_feb_j_aWoÚoWZWko]kbWcWoÚ_pb[c[a l[hWfehbWcWajÚh$8_b]_IJAjWhW\ÚdZWdf[aea\WhabÚh]jdaWjÚbÚcÚobWih[]_Z[dºaWck^WhYWcWbWhÚdÚ_pb[c[»WbÚÅ# cWiÚ_o_X_hhd[aebWX_b_h$8kWbÚÅcWiÚdZWWcWaWckdkdaWZÚd"eYka"][db[h"iWÂbÚa]_X_[Å_jb_j[cWj_aWbWdbWhW WoÚhZÚÂÚ^WhYWcWbWhÚd_pb[dc[i_l[oWfÚbWd_pb[c[p[h_dZ[d[Å_jb_feb_j_aWbWh][b_Åj_hc[aj_h$AWckXj[i_d_l[^WhYW# cWbWhÚ_pb[c[a"^[cXj[]_X_[aedec_WbWdÚdZWkpcWdbÚa][h[aj_h[dl[ºoWXWdYÚZ_b»iWoÚbWdX_hWbWdÚdkpcWdeb# cWoWdbWhjWhW\ÚdZWdWdbWÅÚbÚhaÚbÚdcWiÚdÚiWÂbWcWajW1XkZWXj[d_dZW^W]hdhl[Å[\\W\ebcWiÚdW^_pc[j[jc[a# 31 ^jjf0%%mmm$kd$eh]%ZeYkc[dji%]W%Yed\'+'%WYed\'+'(,#'Wdd[n'$^jc 32 AWZÚd>Wh[a[j_l[oWiWZ[Â_Å_ab_Â___dXap$7ocWd"P[bWb(&&*"Jha_o[½Z[AWZÚd>Wh[a[j_l[IWlkdkYkbkawWbÚÅcWbWhÚ"P[bWb7ocWd"ÃijWd# Xkb8_b]_{d_l[hi_j[i_"IJA;Â_j_cl[7hWÅjÚhcW8_h_c_"IWlkdkYkbkal[Feb_j_aWbWhÚ;ja_b[c[Aed\[hWdiOWpÚbWhÚde$'"i$(($D_j[a_c"okaWhÚ# ZWZWXW^i[Z_bZ_Â_]_X_"^kakaZ_b_^WaaÚdZWX_b]_[Z_dc[al[aedk^WaaÚdZW\_a_hh[j[X_bc[a^kakap[h_dZ[diWÂbWdWdl[okhjjWÅbWhÚdaW# hWhl[hc[c[aWd_pcWbWhÚdWZW^_bebcWiÚdÚpehbWÅjÚhWdd[cb_l[]bX_h_aj_ZWhÚdaÚhÚbcWiÚdÚiWÂbWcÚÅjÚh$ 33 AWZÚd>Wh[a[j_l[oWiWZ[Â_Å_ab_Â___dXap$7ocWd"P[bWb(&&*"Jha_o[½Z[AWZÚd>Wh[a[j_l[IWlkdkYkbkawWbÚÅcWbWhÚ"P[bWb7ocWd"ÃijWd# Xkb8_b]_{d_l[hi_j[i_"IJA;Â_j_cl[7hWÅjÚhcW8_h_c_"IWlkdkYkbkal[Feb_j_aWbWhÚ;ja_b[c[Aed\[hWdiOWpÚbWhÚde$'"i$(*$KbkiWbZp[oZ[ oWiWl[feb_j_aWZ[Â_Å_ab_Â_WbÚÅcWbWhÚ__dP[bWb7ocWd½ÚdoWpÚiÚd[cb_X_hhd[alWaWZÚh$