Teorik frekansındaki de ğ i ş imler 3. Allelve genotip

3. Allel ve genotip

frekansındaki de

ğişimler

3. Allel ve genotip

frekansındaki de

ğişimler

 

7KH+DUG\:HඈQEHUJ0RGHO

7KH+:PRGHOඈVDZD\RIGHPRQVWUDWඈQJWKHUHODWඈRQVKඈSEHWZHHQDOOHOHDQGJHQRW\SHIUHTXHQFඈHV,WඈV PDWKHPDWඈFDOO\EDVඈFEXWYHU\ඈPSRUWDQWIRUXQGHUVWDQGඈQJKRZGඈIIHUHQWSURFHVVHVFDQDOWHUWKHVHIUHTXHQFඈHV $V\RXPඈJKWUHFDOOIURPWKHPDඈQWH[WWKHPRGHOKDVIඈYHPDMRUDVVXPSWඈRQV  $OOඈQGඈYඈGXDOVඈQWKHSRSXODWඈRQPDWHUDQGRPO\  7KHSRSXODWඈRQඈVඈQIඈQඈWHO\ODUJH  1RVHOHFWඈRQRFFXUV  1RPXWDWඈRQRFFXUV  1RJHQHIORZRFFXUV ,PDJඈQඈQJRXUඈGHDOඈ]HGSRSXODWඈRQZHZඈOOIRFXVRQDVඈQJOHORFXV ZKඈFKKDVWZRDOOHOHV DQG :H FDQXVH WRGHQRWHWKHIUHTXHQF\RIWKH DOOHOHDQG IRU 7KඈVPHDQVWKDWඈIZHNQRZ ZHFDQGHUඈYH

DV VඈQFH 5HPHPEHUWKDWWKH+:PRGHOඈVDPHDQVRIUHSUHVHQWඈQJWKHUHODWඈRQVKඈS EHWZHHQDOOHOHDQGJHQRW\SHIUHTXHQFඈHVDFURVVJHQHUDWඈRQV:ඈWKRXUDVVXPSWඈRQVRXWOඈQHGDERYHඈQSODFH WKHRQO\WKඈQJWKDWGHWHUPඈQHVWKHIUHTXHQF\RIJHQRW\SHVඈVWKHඈUSUREDEඈOඈWඈHVGHUඈYHGIURPWKHDOOHOH IUHTXHQFඈHV ,WඈVTXඈWHVඈPSOHWRGHWHUPඈQHWKHVHSUREDEඈOඈWඈHV:ඈWKDOOHOHV DQG ZHKDYHWKUHHSRVVඈEOHJHQRW\SHV DQGWKUHHZD\VWRGHWHUPඈQHWKHඈUSUREDEඈOඈWඈHVDV $QRWKHUZD\WRORRNDWWKHVHSUREDEඈOඈWඈHVඈVDVWKHH[SHFWHGIUHTXHQFඈHVRIWKHWKUHHJHQRW\SHVDW+DUG\ :HඈQEHUJHTXඈOඈEUඈXPJඈYHQWKHDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHV/HW¶VXVHVRPH5FRGHWRDFWXDOO\GHPRQVWUDWHKRZZH PඈJKWFDOFXODWHWKHVHH[SHFWHGIUHTXHQFඈHV)RURXUWHVWH[DPSOHZHZඈOOXVHDVඈPSOHFDVHZKHUHWKH IUHTXHQF\RI  ඈVDQGWKHIUHTXHQF\RI  ඈV ɪˆ‹”•–™‡•‡––Š‡ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡• ’ʳŞɥŜɯ “ʳŞɨŞ’ ɪ…Š‡…’ƒ†“ƒ”‡‡“—ƒŽ–‘ɮ ſ“ʫ’ƀʰʰɨ ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡–Š‡‡š’‡…–‡†‰‡‘–›’‡ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡•ſɕ‡†‡‘–‡•‡š’‡…–‡†ƀ ɨɨɏ‡ʳŞ’ɋɩ ɨɩɏ‡ʳŞɩƋſ’Ƌ“ƀ ɩɩɏ‡ʳŞ“ɋɩ ɪ•Š‘™–Š‡ƒŽŽ‡Ž‡ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡•‹–Š‡…‘•‘Ž‡ …ſɨɨɏ‡řɨɩɏ‡řɩɩɏ‡ƀ ɪ•‹…‡–Š‡•‡ƒ”‡‰‡‘–›’‡ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡•ř–Š‡›•Š‘—Ž†ƒŽ•‘•—–‘ɮŞ›‘—…ƒ…Š‡…–Š‹•Ž‹‡• ‘ •—ſ…ſɨɨɏ‡řɨɩɏ‡řɩɩɏ‡ƀƀ 6R\RXFDQVHHඈWඈVTXඈWHHDV\WRFDOFXODWHWKHIUHTXHQFඈHV\RXQHHGIRUWKH+:PRGHOඈQ5,I\RXZDQWWR \RXFDQSOD\DURXQGZඈWKWKHඈQඈWඈDOIUHTXHQFඈHVGHIඈQHGDWWKHVWDUWRIWKH5FRGHWRVHHKRZඈWDOWHUVWKH JHQRW\SHIUHTXHQFඈHV7KඈVඈVRQHQඈFHWKඈQJDERXWXVඈQJ5IRUHYROXWඈRQDU\JHQHWඈFVඈWඈVSUHWW\VඈPSOHWR GHPRQVWUDWHWKඈQJVPDWKHPDWඈFDOO\WREHQHIඈW\RXURZQXQGHUVWDQGඈQJ+RZHYHUඈWPඈJKWEHHYHQPRUHXVHIXO WRGHPRQVWUDWHWKHUHODWඈRQVKඈSVWKH+:PRGHOOD\VRXWJUDSKඈFDOO\7KDWZD\\RXFDQVHHKRZWKHH[SHFWHG JHQRW\SHIUHTXHQFඈHVDUHDOWHUHGRYHUDZKROHUDQJHRIDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHV/XFNඈO\IRUXV5ඈVJUHDWIRUWKඈVVRUW RIYඈVXDOඈVDWඈRQDQGWKඈVඈVDQH[FHOOHQWRSSRUWXQඈW\WRGHPRQVWUDWHVRPHSURJUDPPඈQJඈQ5

3ORWWඈQJWKHH[SHFWHGJHQRW\SHIUHTXHQFඈHV













   

   



 



 





 















7KHIඈUVWWKඈQJZHQHHGWRGRඈVJHQHUDWHDUDQJHRIDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHVWRYඈVXDOඈ]HWKHH[SHFWHGJHQRW\SH IUHTXHQFඈHVDFURVV:H¶OOGRWKඈVඈQWKHVඈPSOHVWZD\IඈUVWEHIRUHJRඈQJඈQWRKRZ\RXPඈJKWWDNHDSURJUDPPඈQJ DSSURDFKWRWKHVDPHSUREOHP(ඈWKHUZD\JHQHUDWඈQJDUDQJHඈVVඈPSOHZHMXVWQHHGWRGRඈWIRUDVඈQJOH DOOHOH DQGWKHQZHFDQYHU\HDVඈO\GHUඈYHWKHIUHTXHQF\RI :HZඈOOGRWKඈVOඈNHVR

ɪ‰‡‡”ƒ–‡ƒ”ƒ‰‡ˆ‘”’ ’ʳŞ•‡“ſɥřɨřɥŜɥɨƀ ɪƒ†ƒŽ•‘ˆ‘”“ “ʳŞɨŞ’ $OOZHGඈGKHUHZDVXVHWKH•‡“IXQFWඈRQZKඈFKZHIඈUVWVDZEDFNඈQ&KDSWHU KWWSVHYROXWඈRQDU\JHQHWඈFVJඈWKXEඈR,QWURGXFWඈRQKWPO5HPHPEHUZHRQO\KDYHWRGRඈWRQFHEHFDXVH ඈV WKHඈQYHUVHRI 1H[WZHQHHGWRJHQHUDWHWKHH[SHFWHGIUHTXHQFඈHV%HFDXVH5ඈVUHDOO\JUHDWDWKDQGOඈQJ YHFWRUVWKHFRGHIRUWKඈVඈVඈGHQWඈFDOIRUඈIZHZHUHXVඈQJDVඈQJOHYDOXH ɪ‰‡‡”ƒ–‡–Š‡‡š’‡…–‡†‰‡‘–›’‡ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡• ɨɨɏ‡ʳŞ’ɋɩ ɨɩɏ‡ʳŞɩƋſ’Ƌ“ƀ ɩɩɏ‡ʳŞ“ɋɩ 6RQRZZHEDVඈFDOO\KDYHWKHH[SHFWHGIUHTXHQFඈHVDW+:(RIRXUGඈIIHUHQWJHQRW\SHVDFURVVDUDQJHRIDOOHOH IUHTXHQFඈHVZඈWKMXVWDOඈWWOHYHFWRUFDOFXODWඈRQ+RZHYHUUHFDOOඈQJIURPEHIRUHWKDWZHRIWHQQHHGWRJHWRXU GDWDඈQWRD†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡ඈQRUGHUWRXVH‰‰’Ž‘–ɩZHQHHGWRGRDEඈWRIZRUNRQWKඈVIඈUVW:H¶OOQRZJHWRXU GDWDඈQWRD–‹„„Ž‡UHDG\IRUZRUNඈQJRQ« ɪƒ””ƒ‰‡ƒŽŽ‡Ž‡ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡•‹–‘ƒ–‹„„Ž‡ŵ†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡ ‰‡‘ɏˆ”‡“ʳރ•Ŝ–‹„„Ž‡ſ…„‹†ſ’ř“řɨɨɏ‡řɨɩɏ‡řɩɩɏ‡ƀƀ ɤɤƒ”‹‰śļƒ•Ŝ–‹„„Ž‡ſƀļ‹•†‡’”‡…ƒ–‡†ř—•‡ļƒ•ɏ–‹„„Ž‡ſƀļſ„—–‹†–Š‡‡™•‡ƒ–‹…•ƀŜ ɤɤŠ‹•™ƒ”‹‰‹•†‹•’Žƒ›‡†‘…‡’‡”•‡••‹‘Ŝ <RXDOVRPඈJKWUHPHPEHUIURPWKHSUHYඈRXVVHVVඈRQWKDWZHQHHGWRVRPHWඈPHVGRVRPHGDWDPDQඈSXODWඈRQWR JHWWKHGDWDඈQWRDIRUPWKDWZHFDQHDVඈO\SORW/XFNඈO\WKඈVඈVTXඈWHVWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGඈQWKඈVFDVHDVZHFDQXVH WKH‰ƒ–Š‡”IXQFWඈRQWRGRඈWTXඈFNO\DQGHDVඈO\ ɪ•‡‰ƒ–Š‡”–‘”‡•Šƒ’‡–Š‡†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡ˆ‘”•–”ƒ‹‰Š–ˆ‘”™ƒ”†’Ž‘––‹‰ ‰‡‘ɏˆ”‡“ʳމƒ–Š‡”ſ‰‡‘ɏˆ”‡“ř‡›ʰɑ‰‡‘–›’‡ɑř˜ƒŽ—‡ʰɑˆ”‡“ɑřŞ’řŞ“ƀ 1RZඈWඈVUHDOO\VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGWRPDNHDSORWWKDWVKRZVWKHH[SHFWHG+:²IUHTXHQFඈHVDFURVVRXUDOOHOH IUHTXHQFඈHV ɪ’Ž‘––Š‡‡š’‡…–‡†‰‡‘–›’‡ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡• ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſ‰‡‘ɏˆ”‡“řƒ‡•ſ’řˆ”‡“ř…‘Ž‘—”ʰ‰‡‘–›’‡ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏŽ‹‡ſƀ ƒʳރʫ›Žƒ„ſɑ‡‘–›’‡ˆ”‡“—‡…›ɑƀʫšŽƒ„ſɑ’ˆ”‡“—‡…›ɑƀ ƒʫ–Š‡‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀʫ–Š‡‡ſŽ‡‰‡†Ŝ’‘•‹–‹‘ʰɑ„‘––‘ɑƀ 





 

6RPHSURJUDPPඈQJWUඈFNVIRUWKH+:PRGHO

7KHH[DPSOHDERYHZKHUHZHGHUඈYHGWKHH[SHFWHGIUHTXHQFඈHVRIWKH+:PRGHOWRRNDGYDQWDJHRI5¶V DEඈOඈW\WRHDVඈO\KDQGOHYHFWRUV,QSUඈQFඈSOHWKඈVඈVWKHVඈPSOHVWZD\WRDFKඈHYHZKDWZHZDQWHGDQGඈWZDV TXඈFNDQGFOHDUWRFRGH+RZHYHUWKHUHDUHDFWXDOO\VHYHUDOGඈIIHUHQWZD\VZHFRXOGKDYHDSSURDFKHGWKඈV ඈVVXHXVඈQJVRPHSURJUDPPඈQJWUඈFNV:HZඈOOඈQWURGXFHWKHVHEUඈHIO\KHUHDVDGHPRQVWUDWඈRQEXWWKHVHDUH WRSඈFVZHZඈOOUHWXUQWRWKURXJKRXWWKHVHWXWRUඈDOV)ඈUVWXSZHZඈOOGHOYHඈQWRXVඈQJDˆ‘”ORRS

)RUZKRPWKHEHOOWROOV

:KDWඈIZHZDQWWRFDOFXODWHWKHJHQRW\SHIUHTXHQFඈHVRQWKHIO\"6RUDWKHUWKDQXVඈQJVHSDUDWHOඈQHVRI FRGHWRJHQHUDWHWKHUDQJHRIDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHVDQGH[SHFWHGIUHTXHQFඈHVZHFRXOGGRඈWDOOඈQRQHVKRUWFRGH EORFN"2QHZD\WRGRWKඈVPඈJKWEHWRXVHDˆ‘”ORRS7RඈPDJඈQHZKDWDˆ‘”ORRSGRHVඈWඈVHVVHQWඈDOO\D

EORFNRIFRGHWKDWඈVUHSHDWHGIRUGඈIIHUHQWYDOXHV,QSODඈQODQJXDJHZHDUHVD\ඈQJIRUHDFKYDOXHRI[GR\ 7KඈVPඈJKWDFWXDOO\EHDOඈWWOHFRQIXVඈQJWKHIඈUVWWඈPH\RXHQFRXQWHUඈWEXWDVඈPSOHH[DPSOHPඈJKWKHOSVR EHIRUHZHUXQDQH[DPSOHZඈWKWKHDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHVZHZඈOOVKRZWKHVඈPSOHVWˆ‘”ORRSZHFDQ ˆ‘”ſš‹ɨśɨɥƀƇ ’”‹–ſšƀ ƈ :KDWKDSSHQHGKHUH")ඈUVWO\\RXZඈOOVHHˆ‘”ඈVKඈJKOඈJKWHGDEඈWGඈIIHUHQWO\WRDQRUPDOIXQFWඈRQWKඈVඈV EHFDXVHඈWඈVDFRQWUROIORZVWDWHPHQWඈHUHVHUYHGIRUSURJUDPPඈQJඈQWKH5HQYඈURQPHQW7KHVWDQGDUG VWUXFWXUHRIDˆ‘”VWDWPHQWඈQ5ඈVˆ‘”ſ˜ƒ”‹ƒ„Ž‡‹˜‡…–‘”ƀඈQWKHH[DPSOHDERYHZHZURWH ˆ‘”ſš‹ɨśɨɥƀ$OOWKඈVPHDQVඈVWKDWZHDUHF\FOඈQJWKURXJKɨśɨɥDQGIRUHDFKYDOXHRIWKඈVඈHDQG

VRRQZHZඈOOFDOOඈWšDQGWKHQGRVRPHWKඈQJWRඈW7KHFXUO\EUDFNHWVWKDWIROORZRXUˆ‘”VWDWHPHQWDUHZKDW

ZHZඈOOWKHQµGR¶WRRXUYDOXHRIš,QWKඈVFDVHZHVඈPSO\’”‹–[WRWKHVFUHHQ

  ˆ‘”ſš‹ɨśɨɥƀƇ ’”‹–ſšʫɨɥƀ ƈ 1RWHWKDWඈQWKඈVVඈPSOHH[DPSOHZHQHHGWR’”‹–[HDFKWඈPH:HPඈJKWQRWZDQWWRSUඈQWHDFKYDOXHRIš ඈQVWHDGZHPඈJKWMXVWDVVඈJQඈWWRDYHFWRU6ROHW¶VUHWXUQWRRXUJHQRW\SHIUHTXHQF\H[DPSOH:HZඈOOZUඈWHRXW WKHIXOOˆ‘”ORRSDQGWKHQEUHDNඈWGRZQඈQWRPRUHGHWDඈO ɪ•‡–—’’ ’ɏ˜‡…ʳŞ•‡“ſɥřɨřɥŜɥɨƀ ɪ‹‹–‹ƒ–‡—ŽŽ˜‡…–‘”•ˆ‘”–Š‡‡š’‡…–‡†ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡• ɨɨɏ‡ʳŞ ɨɩɏ‡ʳŞ ɩɩɏ‡ʳŞ ɪ”—–Š‡ˆ‘”Ž‘‘’ ˆ‘”ſ’‹’ɏ˜‡…ƀƇ ɪ†‡ˆ‹‡“ “ʳŞɨŞ’ ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡‰‡‘–›’‡ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡• ɨɨɏ‡ʳރ’’‡†ſɨɨɏ‡ř’ɋɩƀ ɨɩɏ‡ʳރ’’‡†ſɨɩɏ‡řɩƋſ’Ƌ“ƀƀ ɩɩɏ‡ʳރ’’‡†ſɩɩɏ‡ř“ɋɩƀ ƈ ɪ…‘„‹‡–Š‡‹–‘ƒƒ–”‹šſƒ•ƒ‡šƒ’Ž‡Š‡”‡ƀ …„‹†ſɨɨɏ‡řɨɩɏ‡řɩɩɏ‡ƀ 7KඈVEORFNRIFRGHඈVDEඈWWUඈFNඈHUWKDQWKHVඈPSOHH[DPSOHVRIˆ‘”ORRSVZHVKRZHGSUHYඈRXVO\EXWWKH JHQHUDOSUඈQFඈSOHඈVWKHVDPH7KHPDඈQGඈIIHUHQFHKHUHඈVWKDWZHIඈUVWKDGWRGHFODUHYDUඈDEOHVVRWKDW

ZHFRXOGVDYHWKHRXWSXWRIRXUORRS)RUHDFKYDOXHRI RXUORRSIඈUVWFDOFXODWHV WKHQඈWFDOFXODWHVDOOWKH JHQRW\SHIUHTXHQFඈHV<RXZඈOOVHHWKDWඈWDOVRXVHVWKHƒ’’‡†IXQFWඈRQWRVDYHHDFKFDOFXODWඈRQWRWKHQXOO

YDUඈDEOHVZHඈQඈWඈDWHGEHIRUHUXQQඈQJWKHORRS1RWHWKDWZHDOVRGHPRQVWUDWHGKHUHWKDW\RXFDQFKDQJHZKDW \RXZඈOOFDOOWKHYDUඈDEOHඈQDˆ‘”ORRS)RUH[DPSOHKHUHZHFKDQJHGඈWWR’ZKHUHDVRXURUඈJඈQDOH[DPSOH

XVHGš %\QRZ\RXPඈJKWEHUHDVRQDEO\ORRNඈQJDWWKඈVFRGHDQGWKඈQNඈQJZHOOVXUHO\WKඈVඈVPXFKPRUHFRPSOඈFDWHG WKDQWKHOඈQHVZHZURWHSUHYඈRXVO\"$QG\RX¶GEHDEVROXWHO\UඈJKW$OWKRXJKZHXVHGWKඈVDVD GHPRQVWUDWඈRQRIKRZWRXVHDˆ‘”ORRSඈWඈVDOVRDQHDWGHPRQVWUDWඈRQRIWKHIDFWWKDW\RXGRQ¶WKDYHWR RYHUFRPSOඈFDWHWKඈQJVVRPHWඈPHVWKHVඈPSOHVWFRGHඈVEHVW

9HFWRUඈVDWඈRQ

$FWXDOO\WKHUHඈVDQRWKHUOHVVRQZHFDQOHDUQKHUHˆ‘”ORRSVඈQ5DUHRIWHQQRWRSWඈPDO7KH\FDQEHVORZ ZKHQDSSOඈHGWRYHU\ODUJHDPRXQWVRIGDWDIRUDVWDUWDQGDOVRWKH\DUHRIWHQXQQHFHVVDUඈO\FRPSOඈFDWHGDV ZHVDZDERYH,QWKHVHFDVHVඈIZHGRZDQWWRXVHDSURJUDPPඈQJDSSURDFKඈWඈVPXFKEHWWHUWRXVH YHFWRUඈVDWඈRQ7KඈVඈVJHQHUDOO\DPXFKIDVWHUDQGPRUHOඈJKWZHඈJKWDSSURDFKWKDQFRQWUROIORZVWDWHPHQWV7R GHPRQVWUDWHWKHSRZHURIYHFWRUඈVDWඈRQZHZඈOOXVHWKH•ƒ’’Ž›IXQFWඈRQ+RZHYHUඈWFDQVHHPDEඈW FRXQWHUඈQWXඈWඈYHWKHIඈUVWWඈPH\RXHQFRXQWHUඈW$VZඈWKWKHˆ‘”ORRSZHZඈOOJඈYHVඈPSOHH[DPSOHVIඈUVW •ƒ’’Ž›ſɨśɨɥřˆ—…–‹‘ſšƀšƀ )ඈUVWO\WKඈVඈVඈGHQWඈFDOWRWKHIඈUVWIRUORRSZHVKRZHG\RX/HW¶VEUHDNඈWGRZQ•ƒ’’Ž›VWDQGVIRUµVඈPSOHDSSO\¶ DQGඈWGRHVH[DFWO\WKDW<RXJඈYHඈWDYHFWRUɨśɨɥඈQWKඈVFDVHDQGWKHQඈWGRHVVRPHWKඈQJWRHDFKYDOXHRI WKDWYHFWRU7KHˆ—…–‹‘ſšƀVWDWHPHQWEDVඈFDOO\MXVWVD\VZHDUHJRඈQJWRFDOOHDFKHOHPHQWRIRXUYHFWRUš

,

-



$IWHUWKඈVZHFDQDFWXDOO\ZUඈWHZKDWZHZDQWWRGRšVඈQFHKHUHDOOZHZURWHඈVšZHDUHMXVWSUඈQWඈQJඈWWR

WKHVFUHHQ:KDWඈIZHZDQWWRDGGWRHDFKYDOXHRIRXUYHFWRUOඈNHZඈWKRXUVHFRQGˆ‘”ORRSH[DPSOH" •ƒ’’Ž›ſɨśɨɥřˆ—…–‹‘ſšƀšʫɨɥƀ 3UHWW\VඈPSOHEXWQRWKXJHO\GඈIIHUHQWUඈJKW":HOOඈWඈVZKHQZHUDPSXSWKHFRPSOH[ඈW\WKDW\RXZඈOOVWDUWWRVHH WKHGඈIIHUHQFH/HW¶VWU\UHZUඈWඈQJWKHFRPSOH[ˆ‘”ORRSDVDYHFWRUඈVHGRSHUDWඈRQKHUH:H¶OOඈQWURGXFHඈWDQG WKHQEUHDNඈWGRZQ ɪ•‡–—’’ ’ɏ˜‡…ʳŞ•‡“ſɥřɨřɥŜɥɨƀ ‰‡‘ɏˆ”‡“ʳŞ•ƒ’’Ž›ſ’ɏ˜‡…řˆ—…–‹‘ſ’ƀƇ ɪ†‡ˆ‹‡“ “ʳŞɨŞ’ ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡’”‘„ƒ„‹Ž‹–‹‡• ɨɨɏ‡ʳŞ’ɋɩ ɨɩɏ‡ʳŞɩƋſ’Ƌ“ƀ ɩɩɏ‡ʳŞ“ɋɩ ɪ™”‹–‡‘—– …ſɨɨɏ‡řɨɩɏ‡řɩɩɏ‡ƀ ƈƀ ɪ–”ƒ•’‘•‡–Š‡ƒ–”‹š–‘‰‡–‹––Š‡”‹‰Š–™ƒ›—’Š ‰‡‘ɏˆ”‡“ʳŞ–ſ‰‡‘ɏˆ”‡“ƀ 2.VRWKDWඈVVWඈOOPRUHFRGHWKDQZඈWKWKHVඈPSOHYHFWRUFDOFXODWඈRQDSSURDFK+RZHYHUWKඈVKRSHIXOO\ GHPRQVWUDWHVKRZDYHFWRUඈVHGDSSURDFKSURYඈGHVDVඈPSOHUVROXWඈRQWRDˆ‘”ORRS,IWKHOHQJWKRI’ɏ˜‡… ZDVORQJHUWRRWKHYHFWRUඈVHGDSSURDFKZRXOGEHPXFKIDVWHU7KHPDඈQWKඈQJKHUHඈVWKDWWKHFRGHIRUWKH YHFWRUඈVHGDSSURDFKඈVඈGHQWඈFDOWRWKDWZKHQZHGඈGWKHYHFWRUFDOFXODWඈRQVH[FHSWඈWඈVMXVWZUDSSHGඈQDQ

•ƒ’’Ž›IXQFWඈRQ<RX¶OODOVRQRWඈFHWKHƇƈEUDFNHWVDUHඈQWKඈVXVHRI•ƒ’’Ž›7KH\DUHQRWQHHGHGZKHQZH

GRDVඈPSOHRQHOඈQH•ƒ’’Ž›FDOOEXWKHUHZඈWKDPRUHFRPSOඈFDWHGIXQFWඈRQZHGRQHHGWKHPWRPDNHWKඈQJV

HDVඈHUWRUHDG2QHRWKHUSRඈQWWRQRWHඈVWKDWDJDඈQZHFKDQJHGšWR’ඈQWKHˆ—…–‹‘ſ’ƀVWDWHPHQW

GHPRQVWUDWඈQJRQFHPRUHWKDW\RXFDQFDOO\RXUYDUඈDEOHVඈQVඈGH\RXUYHFWRUඈVHGIXQFWඈRQVZKDWHYHU\RX¶GOඈNH )ඈQDOO\WKH–IXQFWඈRQඈVMXVWDVඈPSOHFDOOWRWUDQVSRVHWKHPDWUඈ[WKDW•ƒ’’Ž›RXWSXWV<RXFDQWU\UXQQඈQJWKH

FRGHZඈWKRXWWKඈVDQGORRNDWZKDW‰‡‘ɏˆ”‡“ORRNVOඈNH\RX¶OOVHHඈWඈVRUඈHQWDWHGRGGO\ඈIZHZDQWWRXVHඈWඈQ SORWWඈQJ

$QRWVRIඈQDOZRUGRQYHFWRUඈVDWඈRQDQGIRUORRSV

,QDPRPHQWZH¶OOMXPSEDFNඈQWRWKHHYROXWඈRQDU\JHQHWඈFVDJDඈQ+RZHYHUZHMXVWZDQWWRUHඈWHUDWHWKDWWKH DඈPKHUHඈVWRඈQWURGXFH\RXWRWKHVHFRQFHSWV,WWDNHVDORWRISUDFWඈFHWREHFRPHIDPඈOඈDUZඈWKORRSVDQG YHFWRUඈVDWඈRQ7KH\FDQERWKEHYHU\FRQIXVඈQJZKHQ\RXVWDUWRXWZඈWKWKHP3HUVRQDOO\ZHWU\WRDYRඈGˆ‘” VWDWHPHQWVZKHUHSRVVඈEOHYHFWRUඈVDWඈRQඈVXVXDOO\DOZD\VVXSHUඈRUDOWKRXJKQRWDOZD\V:HZඈOOFHUWDඈQO\ UHWXUQWRWKHVHWHFKQඈTXHVWKHDඈPKHUHZDVWRJඈYH\RXDWDVWHU

7HVWඈQJIRUGHYඈDWඈRQVIURPWKH+DUG\:HඈQEHUJ

([SHFWDWඈRQ

:H¶YHDOUHDG\OHDUQHGWKDWWKH+:PRGHOඈVHVVHQWඈDOO\DQඈGHDOඈVHGVFHQDUඈRZKHUHQRGHPRJUDSKඈFRU HYROXWඈRQDU\SURFHVVHVDUHVKDSඈQJWKHUHODWඈRQVKඈSEHWZHHQDOOHOHDQGJHQRW\SHIUHTXHQFඈHV:HFDQ WKHUHIRUHXVHඈWDVDQXOOPRGHODJDඈQVWZKඈFKWRWHVWRXUGDWD%DVඈFDOO\ZHFDQFRPSDUHRXUREVHUYHG JHQRW\SHIUHTXHQFඈHVIURPWKRVHH[SHFWHGXQGHU+:(7RJHWWKHH[SHFWHGIUHTXHQFඈHVZHMXVWJHQHUDWH WKHPIURPWKHDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHVDVZHGඈGඈQWKHSUHYඈRXVVHFWඈRQRIWKHWXWRUඈDO

  :HFDQZRUNWKURXJKDQH[DPSOHRIWKඈVWRJHWKHU2QFHDJDඈQZH¶OODVVXPHDORFXV ZඈWKWZRDOOHOHV DQG 7KඈVPHDQVWKUHHJHQRW\SHV  DQG :HVDPSOHඈQGඈYඈGXDOVIURPDSRSXODWඈRQ 7KHQH[WEORFNRI5FRGHVKRZVWKHQXPEHUVRIHDFKJHQRW\SHZHFROOHFWHGDQGDOVRFRPEඈQHVWKHPඈQWRDQ ‘„•‡”˜‡†YHFWRUIRUODWHUXVH ɪ—„‡”•‘ˆ‰‡‘–›’‡• ɨɨʳŞɯɥ ɨɩʳŞɨɬ ɩɩʳŞɬɬ ɪƒ‡‹–‘ƒ˜‡…–‘” ‘„•‡”˜‡†ʳŞ…ſɨɨřɨɩřɩɩƀ ,QRUGHUWRJRIXUWKHUKHUHZHQHHGWRZRUNRXWWKHDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHVIURPRXUREVHUYHGGDWD7KඈVඈVTXඈWH VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGKRPR]\JRWHVKDYHWZRFRSඈHVRIDQDOOHOHZKHUHDVKHWHUR]\JRWHVKDYHRQO\RQH6RZH GHUඈYHWKHQXPEHURIHDFKDOOHOHDQGGඈYඈGHඈWE\WKHWRWDO :KHUHWKHJHQRW\SHQRWDWඈRQKHUHUHSUHVHQWVWKHQXPEHURIJHQRW\SHFODVVDQG ඈVWKHWRWDOQXPEHURI DOOHOHV:HFDQFDOFXODWHWKHIUHTXHQF\WKHDOOHOHVඈQ5OඈNHVR ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡–‘–ƒŽ—„‡”‘ˆƒŽŽ‡Ž‡• ʳŞɩƋ•—ſ‘„•‡”˜‡†ƀ ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡ˆ”‡“—‡…›‘ˆɮ‘”’ ’ʳŞſɩƋſɨɨƀʫɨɩƀŵ ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡ˆ”‡“—‡…›‘ˆɯ‘”“ “ʳŞſɩƋſɩɩƀʫɨɩƀŵ ɪ’”‹–ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡•–‘•…”‡‡ …ſ’ř“ƀ 1RWHWKDWZඈWKWKHFRGHDERYHZHVXPPHGWKHQXPEHURIREVHUYHGJHQRW\SHVDQGWKHQPXOWඈSOඈHGE\DV WKHUHDUHDOOHOHVIRUHDFKඈQGඈYඈGXDOඈHWKHUHDUHඈQGඈYඈGXDOVDQGDOOHOHV:HQRZKDYHWKHDOOHOH IUHTXHQFඈHVVRZHFDQXVHWKHFRGHZHZRUNHGRXWඈQWKHSUHYඈRXVVHFWඈRQWRFDOFXODWHWKHH[SHFWHG+DUG\ :HඈQEHUJIUHTXHQFඈHVIRUWKඈVSRSXODWඈRQ ɪ‰‡‡”ƒ–‡–Š‡‡š’‡…–‡†‰‡‘–›’‡ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡• ɨɨɏ‡ʳŞ’ɋɩ ɨɩɏ‡ʳŞɩƋſ’Ƌ“ƀ ɩɩɏ‡ʳŞ“ɋɩ ɪ…‘„‹‡‹–‘ƒ˜‡…–‘” ‡š’‡…–‡†ɏˆ”‡“ʳŞ…ſɨɨɏ‡řɨɩɏ‡řɩɩɏ‡ƀ 6RQRZWKDWZHKDYHWKHH[SHFWHGJHQRW\SHIUHTXHQFඈHVWKHODVWWKඈQJZHQHHGWRGREHIRUHWHVWඈQJZKHWKHU WKHUHඈVDGHYඈDWඈRQIURP+:(ඈQRXUGDWDඈVFDOFXODWHWKHH[SHFWHGQXPEHURIHDFKJHQRW\SH7KඈVඈVHDV\ ZHMXVWPXOWඈSO\WKHIUHTXHQFඈHVE\WKHQXPEHURIඈQGඈYඈGXDOVZHVDPSOHG ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡‘„•‡”˜‡†‰‡‘–›’‡ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡• ‡š’‡…–‡†ʳއš’‡…–‡†ɏˆ”‡“Ƌɨɬɥ 7KHQH[WWKඈQJZH¶GOඈNHWRGRඈVVHHZKHWKHURXUREVHUYHGJHQRW\SHVGHYඈDWHIURPWKHH[SHFWHG:HZඈOOWHVW WKඈVIRUPDOO\EXWIඈUVWOHW¶VMXVWORRNDWWKHGඈIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHP7KHVඈPSOHVWZD\WRGRWKඈVඈVFRPEඈQH WKHPඈQWRDPDWUඈ[    

 



 





 



 

 







  ɪ…‘„‹‡‘„•‡”˜‡†ƒ†‡š’‡…–‡†ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡•‹–‘ƒƒ–”‹š ›†ƒ–ƒʳŞ…„‹†ſ‘„•‡”˜‡†ř‡š’‡…–‡†ƀ ɪƒ††”‘™ƒ‡• ”‘™ƒ‡•ſ›†ƒ–ƒƀʳŞ…ſɑɨɨɑřɑɨɩɑřɑɩɩɑƀ :HOOMXVWIURPH\HEDOOඈQJWKඈVPDWUඈ[ඈWGRHVORRNOඈNHWKHUHඈVSUREDEO\DGඈIIHUHQFH1RWDEO\WKHUHVHHPVWREH DORZHUIUHTXHQF\RIKHWHUR]\JRWHVWKDQZHH[SHFW6WඈOOMXVWORRNඈQJDWWKඈVඈVQRWHQRXJKZHQHHGWRWHVWඈW IRUPDOO\$V\RXZඈOOSUREDEO\UHPHPEHUIURPWKHPDඈQWH[WZHFDQXVHD&KඈVTXDUHGJRRGQHVVRIIඈWWHVW IRUWKඈVSXUSRVH7KH&KඈVTXDUHGWHVWඈVTXඈWHVWUDඈJKWIRUZDUG ,QRWKHUZRUGVWKඈVඈVWKHVXPRIWKHVTXDUHGGඈIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHH[SHFWHGDQGWKHREVHUYHGGඈYඈGHGE\ WKHH[SHFWHG,WVRXQGVFRPSOඈFDWHGEXWZඈWK5¶VYHFWRUKDQGOඈQJFDSDEඈOඈWඈHVZHFDQGRWKඈVH[WUHPHO\HDVඈO\ …Š‹ʳŞ•—ſſſ‡š’‡…–‡†Ş‘„•‡”˜‡†ƀɋɩƀŵ‡š’‡…–‡†ƀ 2XUFKඈVTXDUHGYDOXHඈVYHU\KඈJK%XWZHVWඈOOGRQ¶WNQRZඈIඈWඈVVඈJQඈIඈFDQW7RGRWKඈVZHQHHGWRFKHFNRXU YDOXHDJDඈQVWWKHNQRZQGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQRIFKඈVTXDUHG7KඈVඈVYHU\HDV\WRGRඈQ5XVඈQJWKH’…Š‹•“IXQFWඈRQ 7KඈVඈVSDUWRIDVXඈWHRIIXQFWඈRQVIRUSUREDEඈOඈW\GඈVWUඈEXWඈRQVZKඈFKZHZඈOOH[SORUHPRUHWKRURXJKO\ඈQDIXWXUH WXWRUඈDO%XWIRUQRZOHW¶VZRUNRXWZKHWKHURXUYDOXHඈVVඈJQඈIඈFDQW ɨŞ’…Š‹•“ſ…Š‹ř†ˆʰɩƀ ’…Š‹•“WDNHVWZRDUJXPHQWVWKHFKඈVTXDUHGYDOXHDQGWKHGHJUHHVRIIUHHGRP)RURXUFKඈVTXDUHGWHVW KHUHZHXVHGHJUHHVRIIUHHGRP<RXFDQVHHWKDWRXUSYDOXHඈVWKඈVPHDQVZHKDYHDKඈJKO\VඈJQඈIඈFDQW GHYඈDWඈRQIURP+:(ඈQRWKHUZRUGVVRPHDVVXPSWඈRQRIWKH+DUG\:HඈQEHUJPRGHOඈVYඈRODWHG:KDW SURFHVVFRXOGFDXVHWKඈVVඈJQඈIඈFDQWKHWHUR]\JRWHGHIඈFඈW"0D\EHQRQUDQGRPPDWඈQJ"

$QHDVඈHUZD\"

6ඈQFHWKHFKඈVTXDUHGWHVWඈVVXFKDIXQGDPHQWDOVWDWඈVWඈFDOWRROඈWSUREDEO\ZRQ¶WVXUSUඈVH\RXWRIඈQGWKDWWKHUH ඈVDFWXDOO\DOUHDG\D…Š‹•“Ŝ–‡•–IXQFWඈRQIRU\RXWRXVH:HGඈGQ¶WH[SODඈQඈWHDUOඈHUEHFDXVH«ZHOOFDOFXODWඈQJ WKඈQJVE\KDQGඈVVRPHWඈPHVWKHEHVWZD\WROHDUQ7KHIXQFWඈRQඈVKDQG\WKRXJKVඈQFHZHFDQFDOFXODWHWKH FKඈVTXDUHGYDOXHDQGDOVRWHVWWKHVඈJQඈIඈFDQFHඈQRQHJR:HFDQXVHඈWOඈNHVR ɪ’‡”ˆ‘”ƒ…Š‹Ş•“—ƒ”‡†–‡•– ›…Š‹ʳŞ…Š‹•“Ŝ–‡•–ſ‘„•‡”˜‡†ř’ʰ‡š’‡…–‡†ɏˆ”‡“ƀ +HUHZHSURYඈGHWKH…Š‹•“Ŝ–‡•–IXQFWඈRQZඈWKRXUREVHUYHGJHQRW\SHFRXQWV+RZHYHUZHDOVRQHHGWR VSHFඈI\RXUH[SHFWHGIUHTXHQFඈHVVRWKHUHඈVVWඈOOVRPHFDOFXODWඈRQUHTXඈUHG1RQHWKHOHVVWKHIXQFWඈRQUHWXUQV WKHVDPHFKඈVTXDUHGYDOXHZHKDYHSUHYඈRXVO\FDOFXODWHGDQGVKRZVXVWKDWZHKDYHDKඈJKO\VඈJQඈIඈFDQW GHYඈDWඈRQIURPWKHH[SHFWDWඈRQ 1RWHDVZHOOWKDWWKH›…Š‹REMHFWKDVDORWRIඈQIRUPDWඈRQVWRUHGZඈWKඈQඈW:HFDQWDNHDFORVHUORRNXVඈQJWKH IROORZඈQJ •–”ſ›…Š‹ƀ 8VඈQJWKHGROODUVඈJQQRWDWඈRQZHOHDUQHGDERXWඈQ&KDSWHU KWWSVHYROXWඈRQDU\JHQHWඈFVJඈWKXEඈR,QWURGXFWඈRQKWPOZHFDQH[WUDFWDQ\RIWKHVHDWZඈOO)RUH[DPSOH ›…Š‹ɛ‡š’‡…–‡†ZඈOOSURGXFHWKHH[SHFWHGYDOXHVZKHUHDV›…Š‹ɛ•–ƒ–‹•–‹…ZඈOOSURGXFHWKHFKඈVTXDUHG 



  

_

_

_















  YDOXH

6ඈPXODWඈQJJHQHWඈFGUඈIW

2QHRIWKHPDඈQDVVXPSWඈRQVRIWKH+:PRGHOඈVWKDWSRSXODWඈRQVDUHඈQIඈQඈWH7KඈVඈVREYඈRXVO\XQUHDOඈVWඈF$OO SRSXODWඈRQVDUHIඈQඈWHEXWZKDWGRHVWKඈVPHDQIRUKRZHYROXWඈRQXQIROGV"$QඈPSRUWDQWFRQFHSWඈQ HYROXWඈRQDU\JHQHWඈFVඈVKRZSRSXODWඈRQVඈ]HFDQඈQIOXHQFHWKHUHODWඈYHSRZHURIDSURFHVVVXFKDVJHQHWඈF GUඈIW'UඈIWHVVHQWඈDOO\GHVFUඈEHVWKHUDQGRPFRPSRQHQWRIVXUYඈYDOඈQDSRSXODWඈRQVRPHඈQGඈYඈGXDOVZඈOO VXUYඈYHDQGUHSURGXFHPRUHWKDQRWKHUVE\FKDQFH$QඈPSRUWDQWIDFWRUFRQWUඈEXWඈQJWRVXFKJHQHWඈFGUඈIWඈVWKH UDQGRPVDPSOඈQJRIDOOHOHVWKDWWDNHVSODFHDWIHUWඈOඈ]DWඈRQ)RUඈQVWDQFHMXVWOඈNHVRPHSDඈUVSURGXFHDQ H[FHVVRIVRQVDQGGDXJKWHUVDKHWHUR]\JRXVPDWඈQJSDඈU FDQSURGXFHRIIVSUඈQJZඈWKDQH[FHVVRI WKHJHQRW\SHV RU WKHUHE\FDXVඈQJDUDQGRPFKDQJHඈQDOOHOHIUHTXHQF\ඈQWKHSRSXODWඈRQ:KHQ DSRSXODWඈRQඈVODUJHWKHHIIHFWVRIGUඈIWZඈOOEHVPDOOUHODWඈYHWRRWKHUSURFHVVHVVXFKDVVHOHFWඈRQ+RZHYHU ZKHQDSRSXODWඈRQඈVVPDOOGUඈIWDVDUHVXOWRIUDQGRPFKDQFHKDVDPXFKEඈJJHUHIIHFW 2QHRIWKHEHVWZD\VWRJHW\RXUKHDGDURXQGDFRQFHSWOඈNHJHQHWඈFGUඈIWDQGKRZඈWඈQWHUDFWVZඈWKSRSXODWඈRQ Vඈ]HඈVWRDFWXDOO\VඈPXODWHZKඈFKඈVH[DFWO\ZKDWZHDUHJRඈQJWRGRKHUH:H¶OOIඈUVWH[SODඈQKRZZHFDQ VඈPXODWHඈWRYHUDVඈQJOHJHQHUDWඈRQDQGWKHQZHDUHJRඈQJWREXඈOGRXURZQFXVWRP5IXQFWඈRQWRGRDOOWKH OHJZRUNIRUXV6RZH¶OOQRWRQO\EHH[HUFඈVඈQJ\RXUXQGHUVWDQGඈQJඈQHYROXWඈRQDU\JHQHWඈFVEXWDOVR\RXU5 SURJUDPPඈQJFKRSVWRR

$VඈPSOHFDVHRIJHQHWඈFGUඈIWRYHUDVඈQJOHJHQHUDWඈRQXVඈQJWKH

EඈQRPඈDOGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQ

7RGHPRQVWUDWHDVඈPSOHFDVHRIGUඈIWZH¶OOXVHWKHH[DPSOHIURPWKHERRN:HKDYHDSRSXODWඈRQRI   ඈQGඈYඈGXDOVDQGZHZඈOOIRFXVRQDVඈQJOHORFXV ZඈWKWZRDOOHOHV DQG :HZඈOODVVXPHERWKDOOHOHVDUH HTXDOO\FRPPRQඈQWKHSRSXODWඈRQඈH  2XUOඈWWOHSRSXODWඈRQඈVඈQ+:(VXFKWKDWWKHUHDUHWZRRI HDFK DQG KRPR]\JRWHVDQGIRXU KHWHUR]\JRWHV 7RVඈPXODWHGUඈIWZHQHHGWRDOORZඈQGඈYඈGXDOVWRPDWHDWUDQGRP,QWKHERRN\RXZඈOOUHFDOOZHXVHGDFRඈQ IOඈSSඈQJH[SHUඈPHQWWRVDPSOHRXUDOOHOHVWRIRUPJHQRW\SHVVඈQFHERWKDOOHOHVKDYHDIUHTXHQF\RI7KඈVඈV HVVHQWඈDOO\DIRUPRIEඈQRPඈDOVDPSOඈQJ:HFDQHDVඈO\UHFUHDWHWKඈVඈQ5XVඈQJWKH”„‹‘IXQFWඈRQWR VDPSOHWKHEඈQRPඈDOGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQ:HZඈOOUHFUHDWHWKHFRඈQWRVVඈQJH[SHUඈPHQWH[DFWO\KHUHXVඈQJWKHIROORZඈQJ FRGH ɪ”‡…”‡ƒ–‡…‘‹ˆŽ‹’’‹‰‡š’‡”‹‡–—•‹‰„‹‘‹ƒŽ•ƒ’Ž‹‰ ”„‹‘ſʰɨɭř•‹œ‡ʰɨř’”‘„ʰɥŜɬƀ :KDWGඈGZHGRKHUH"/ඈNHZඈWKWKH’…Š‹•“IXQFWඈRQZHXVHGEHIRUHZHPDGHXVHRI5¶VVXඈWHRIIXQFWඈRQVIRU VWDWඈVWඈFDOGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQVDWRSඈFZHZඈOOFRYHUඈQPRUHGHWDඈOODWHU7KH”„‹‘IXQFWඈRQMXVWDOORZVXVWRVDPSOH WKHEඈQRPඈDOGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQ:ඈWKWKHʰɨɭIODJZHVDPSOHGඈWWඈPHV:HVHWWKH•‹œ‡WRPHDQඈQJZH VDPSOHHඈWKHURUඈHKHDGVRUWDඈOVDQGIඈQDOO\ZHVHWWKHSUREDEඈOඈW\RIVDPSOඈQJWRWKHVDPHIRUERWK RXWFRPHVZඈWK’ʰɥŜɬ +RZHYHUඈQWKHWH[WERRNZHDFWXDOO\XVHGSDඈUVRIFRඈQIOඈSVWRVඈPXODWHJHQRW\SHV:HFRXOGGRWKඈVඈQ5EXWඈW ඈVDEඈWFOXQN\ඈWඈVPXFKHDVඈHUWRMXVWIOඈSDFRඈQVRZHFRXOGDFWXDOO\XVHEඈQRPඈDOVDPSOඈQJඈQDGඈIIHUHQW ZD\WRDFKඈHYHWKඈV:HFRXOGVHWWKHVඈ]HRIWKHSRSXODWඈRQDVDQGWKHQMXVWVDPSOHRQHYDOXHIURPWKH GඈVWUඈEXWඈRQ7KඈVYDOXHFRXOGWKHQUHSUHVHQWWKHQXPEHURI DOOHOHVඈQWKHQH[WJHQHUDWඈRQVRZHFRXOG HDVඈO\ZRUNRXW DQG :H¶OODOVRWDNHWKඈVRSSRUWXQඈW\WRVHWWKHYDOXHRI KHUH

     



 

  

      

f

f



  ɪ•‡–’‘’—Žƒ–‹‘•‹œ‡ ʳŞɯ ɪ•‡–ƒŽŽ‡Ž‡ˆ”‡“—‡…› ’ʳŞɥŜɬ ɪ”‡…”‡ƒ–‡…‘‹ˆŽ‹’’‹‰‡š’‡”‹‡–—•‹‰„‹‘‹ƒŽ•ƒ’Ž‹‰ ɨʳŞ”„‹‘ſɨř•‹œ‡ʰɩƋř’”‘„ʰ’ƀ 5HPHPEHUVඈQFHZHDUHVDPSOඈQJDOOHOHVIRUGඈSORඈGඈQGඈYඈGXDOVZHQHHGWRPXOWඈSO\E\7KHYDOXHRIɨ ZඈOOGඈIIHUIRUHYHU\RQHVඈQFHWKඈVඈVDUDQGRPVDPSOHRIWKHEඈQRPඈDOGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQ:HFDQQRZHDVඈO\ZRUNRXW WKHYDOXHRI ඈHWKHQHZIUHTXHQF\RIWKH ඈQWKHQH[WJHQHUDWඈRQ1RWHWKDW5GRHVQ¶WDOORZWKHSUඈPH QRWDWඈRQVRIRUWKHDFWXDO5FRGHZHZඈOOXVH’ƒ

ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡’ľ

’ƒʳސɨŵſɩƋƀ

2.VRQRZZHKDYHDYDOXHIRU’ƒDJDඈQඈWZඈOOGඈIIHUIRUHYHU\RQHEHFDXVHZHSHUIRUPHGUDQGRPVDPSOඈQJ

<RXZඈOOVHHWKRXJKWKDW’ƒඈVOඈNHO\GඈIIHUHQWWR’VROHO\EHFDXVHRIUDQGRPVDPSOඈQJඈHZHKDYH

GHPRQVWUDWHGGUඈIWRYHUDVඈQJOHJHQHUDWඈRQ7RSURSHUO\XQGHUVWDQGGUඈIWRYHUPXOWඈSOHJHQHUDWඈRQVZHZඈOO QHHGWRXVHVRPHTXඈWHDGYDQFHG5FRGHVRIRUWKHQH[WVHFWඈRQZHZඈOOWDNHDEUHDNIURPSRSXODWඈRQ JHQHWඈFVDQGඈQVWHDGIRFXVRQKRZWRZUඈWHDFXVWRP5IXQFWඈRQ

:UඈWඈQJ\RXURZQ5IXQFWඈRQV

:UඈWඈQJIXQFWඈRQVඈQ5ඈVDQH[WUHPHO\XVHIXOWKඈQJWROHDUQ,WPඈJKWVHHPDOඈWWOHGDXQWඈQJEXWඈWඈVDFWXDOO\TXඈWH VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGRQFH\RXKDYHDKDQGOHRQWKHEDVඈFIRUPDWDQGVWUXFWXUHQHFHVVDU\)XQFWඈRQVFDQEHXVHIXO IRUFOHDQඈQJXS\RXUFRGHඈQVWHDGRIZUඈWඈQJWKHVDPHFRGHEORFNDJDඈQDQGDJDඈQ\RXFDQXVH\RXURZQ IXQFWඈRQ<RXDOVRPඈJKWZDQWWRGRඈWWRWKHQZUDSඈWඈQDPRUHFRPSOඈFDWHGRSHUDWඈRQOඈNHDˆ‘”ORRSRUD YHFWRUඈVHGDSSURDFK:HZඈOODFWXDOO\EXඈOGWRZDUGVVRPHWKඈQJOඈNHWKHODWWHUEXWIRUQRZZHZඈOOMXVWXVHD VඈPSOHH[DPSOH/HW¶VZUඈWHDIXQFWඈRQWKDWDGGVWRDQ\QXPHUඈFDOYDOXHZHJඈYHඈW ɪ™”‹–‡ƒ…—•–‘‡ˆ—…–‹‘–‘ƒ††ɮɫ–‘‡˜‡”›—‡”‹…ƒŽ˜ƒ”‹ƒ„Ž‡‹–‹•‰‹˜‡ ƒ††ɏ–‡ʳވ—…–‹‘ſšƀƇ ›ʳŞšʫɨɥ ”‡–—”ſ›ƀ ƈ ɪ–‡•–‹–‘—– ƒ††ɏ–‡ſɨɥɥƀ ƒ††ɏ–‡ſɨɥɥɥɥɥɥƀ ƒ††ɏ–‡ſɩɩƀ /HW¶VEUHDNGRZQZKDWZHGඈGKHUHඈQDEඈWPRUHGHWDඈO)ඈUVWO\ZHQHHGWRJඈYHRXUIXQFWඈRQDQDPHඈQWKඈV FDVHZHFDOOHGඈWƒ††ɏ–‡&UXFඈDOO\WKඈVඈVDOVRDQREMHFWZHDVVඈJQ2QFHDVVඈJQHGWKHIXQFWඈRQඈVFDOODEOHඈQ WKH5HQYඈURQPHQWMXVWOඈNHDQ\RWKHUIXQFWඈRQZHORDGIURPDSDFNDJHRUඈQWKHVWDQGDUG5GඈVWUඈEXWඈRQ:H WKHQXVHWKHVWDWHPHQWˆ—…–‹‘ſšƀWRVKRZඈWඈVDIXQFWඈRQ7KHšKHUHඈVWKHQDPHRIWKHYDUඈDEOHZHSDVV WRRXUIXQFWඈRQ7KHQDPHKHUHඈVFRPSOHWHO\DUEඈWUDU\ZHFRXOGMXVWDVHDVඈO\XVHDKXPDQQDPHRUDQ\WKඈQJ ZHFKRRVH+RZHYHUZKDWZHSDVVWRWKHIXQFWඈRQZඈOOEHUHIHUUHGWRWKඈVWKURXJKRXW

,QVඈGHWKHFXUO\EUDFNHWVƇƈඈVWKHERG\RIRXUIXQFWඈRQ+HUHZHGHIඈQHDQHZREMHFW›WKDWඈVVඈPSO\WKH

YDOXHRIšSOXVɨɥ)ඈQDOO\ZHXVHWKH”‡–—”ſƀIXQFWඈRQWRWHOO5WRSURGXFHWKHYDOXHRI›ZKHQZHXVH

RXUƒ††ɏ–‡IXQFWඈRQ:HFDQUHDOO\ZUඈWHDIXQFWඈRQIRUDOPRVWDQ\WKඈQJඈQ5DQGඈWZRXOGQ¶WWDNHXVORQJWRIඈOO

WKඈVWXWRUඈDOZඈWKH[DPSOHDIWHUH[DPSOH)RUQRZWKRXJKZHZඈOOVKRZ\RXMXVWRQHPRUHH[DPSOHDIXQFWඈRQ WKDWWDNHVWZRDUJXPHQWVඈQVWHDGRIMXVWRQHOඈNHRXUƒ††ɏ–‡IXQFWඈRQGඈG7KඈVWඈPHZHZඈOOZUඈWHDIXQFWඈRQ

WRPXOWඈSO\WZRQXPHUඈFDOYDOXHV

  ɪ™”‹–‡ƒ…—•–‘‡ˆ—…–‹‘–‘—Ž–‹’Ž›–™‘—‡”‹…ƒŽ˜ƒ”‹ƒ„Ž‡• —Ž–‹’Ž›ʳވ—…–‹‘ſšř›ƀƇ œʳŞšƋ› ”‡–—”ſœƀ ƈ ɪ–‡•–‹–‘—– —Ž–‹’Ž›ſɨɥřɨɥƀ —Ž–‹’Ž›ſɪřɬƀ —Ž–‹’Ž›ſɩɩřɫɫƀ 6RWKඈVඈVH[DFWO\WKHVDPHDVEHIRUHEXWQRZZHDUHSDVVඈQJWZRDUJXPHQWVšDQG›,QWKHERG\RIWKH IXQFWඈRQZHPXOWඈSO\WKHPERWKDQGWKHQUHWXUQWKHDQVZHU+RSHIXOO\WKඈVGHPRQVWUDWඈRQRIKRZWRZUඈWH IXQFWඈRQVඈVDVXIIඈFඈHQWH[DPSOH$VZඈWKRXUSUHYඈRXVSURJUDPPඈQJWRSඈFVඈWඈVVRPHWKඈQJZHZඈOOUHWXUQWR WKURXJKRXWWKHFRXUVHEXඈOGඈQJRQඈWIXUWKHUDQGIXUWKHU$JDඈQZHFHUWDඈQO\GRQ¶WH[SHFW\RXWRJRIURPWKHVH H[DPSOHVWRZUඈWඈQJFRPSOH[IXQFWඈRQV

8VඈQJDFXVWRPIXQFWඈRQWRVඈPXODWHGUඈIWRYHUPXOWඈSOH

JHQHUDWඈRQV

5HFDOOඈQJRXUFRGHIRUVඈPXODWඈQJJHQHWඈFGUඈIWOHW¶VGRWKHVDPHWKඈQJDJDඈQEXWWKඈVWඈPHZUDSඈWඈQDVඈPSOH IXQFWඈRQ7RVWDUWZඈWKZHGRWKඈVRQO\IRUDVඈQJOHJHQHUDWඈRQ ɪƒ…—•–‘ˆ—…–‹‘ˆ‘”•‹—Žƒ–‹‰†”‹ˆ–‹ƒ•‹‰Ž‡‰‡‡”ƒ–‹‘ †”‹ˆ–ɏ•‹ʳވ—…–‹‘ſř’ƀƇ ’ʳŞ”„‹‘ſɨřɩƋř’ƀ ’ʳŞ’ŵſɩƋƀ ”‡–—”ſ’ƀ ƈ ɪ”—†”‹ˆ–•‹‘–Š‡‡šƒ’Ž‡†ƒ–ƒƒ„‘˜‡ †”‹ˆ–ɏ•‹ſʰɨɭř’ʰɥŜɬƀ 1RZZHKDYHWKH†”‹ˆ–ɏ•‹IXQFWඈRQZHFDQHDVඈO\SOD\DURXQGZඈWKWKHDOOHOHVWDUWඈQJIUHTXHQF\ඈH’DQG DOVRWKHSRSXODWඈRQVඈ]H%XWZHVWඈOOKDYHQ¶WPDQDJHGWRH[WHQGRXUVඈPXODWඈRQVDFURVVPXOWඈSOHJHQHUDWඈRQV 1RZZHKDYHWKHEDVඈFIXQFWඈRQZHFDQDOWHUඈWWRGRMXVWWKDW ɪƒ…—•–‘ˆ—…–‹‘ˆ‘”•‹—Žƒ–‹‰†”‹ˆ–ƒ…”‘••—Ž–‹’Ž‡‰‡‡”ƒ–‹‘• †”‹ˆ–ɏ•‹ʳވ—…–‹‘ſř’ř‰‡ƀƇ ɪ‹‹–‹ƒŽ‹•‡’ ’ɏ‹‹–ʳŞ’ ɪ•ƒ’Ž‡ƒ…”‘••ƒŽŽ–Š‡‰‡‡”ƒ–‹‘• ’˜‡…ʳŞ•ƒ’’Ž›ſɨś‰‡řˆ—…–‹‘ſšƀƇ ’ʳŞ”„‹‘ſɨřɩƋř’ƀ ’ʳʳŞ’ŵſɩƋƀ ƈƀ ɪ…”‡ƒ–‡ƒ˜‡…–‘”‘ˆ’‘˜‡”–‹‡ ’ʳŞ…ſ’ɏ‹‹–ř’˜‡…ƀ ɪ™”‹–‡‘—– ”‡–—”ſ’ƀ ƈ ɪ”—†”‹ˆ–•‹‘–Š‡‡šƒ’Ž‡†ƒ–ƒƒ„‘˜‡ †”‹ˆ–ɏ•‹ſʰɨɭř’ʰɥŜɬř‰‡ʰɨɥɥƀ

  2.VRWKඈVZඈOOUHTXඈUHDOඈWWOHH[SODඈQඈQJ)ඈUVWO\\RXZඈOOQRWඈFHZHKDYHDGGHGWKH‰‡DUJXPHQWZKඈFKඈV WKHQXPEHURIJHQHUDWඈRQV,QVඈGHWKHIXQFWඈRQZHQHHGWRGHIඈQHWKHඈQඈWඈDOYDOXHRISඈHEHIRUHWKH VඈPXODWඈRQVEHJඈQ’‹‹–:HWKHQXVHDQ•ƒ’’Ž›FDOOWRXVHUXQRXUFRGHRYHUHDFKJHQHUDWඈRQ(DFKWඈPH ZHGRWKඈVZHXSGDWHWKHYDOXHRISWKඈVH[SODඈQVWKHGRXEOHDUURZʳʳŞZHXVHG:HKDYHWRGRWKඈV XSGDWඈQJEHFDXVHRWKHUZඈVHWKHYDOXHRI’ZඈOODOVREHUHVHWWRWKHඈQඈWඈDOYDOXHZKඈFKඈVQRWVXඈWDEOHZKHQ VඈPXODWඈQJGUඈIWRYHUWඈPH7KHIඈQDOSDUWRIWKHIXQFWඈRQRXWSXWVRXUYHFWRU’DQGඈQFOXGHVWKHRUඈJඈQDOඈQඈWඈDWඈQJ YDOXHIඈUVW 1RZWKDWZHKDYHDIXQFWඈRQWRVඈPXODWHGDWDDFURVVJHQHUDWඈRQVZHFDQHDVඈO\GRWKඈVIRUGඈIIHUHQWSRSXODWඈRQ Vඈ]HV/HW¶VVඈPXODWHJHQHUDWඈRQVRIGUඈIWIRUWKUHHSRSXODWඈRQVRIDQGඈQGඈYඈGXDOV:H¶OONHHS WKHඈQඈWඈDODOOHOHIUHTXHQF\’DWඈQDOOFDVHV:HZඈOOWKHQFRPEඈQHWKHPDOOඈQWRD–‹„„Ž‡DORQJVඈGHWKH

QXPEHURIJHQHUDWඈRQV ɪ•‹—Žƒ–‡†”‹ˆ–ˆ‘”–Š”‡‡†‹ˆˆ‡”‡–’‘’—Žƒ–‹‘•‹œ‡• ɨɥʳކ”‹ˆ–ɏ•‹ſʰɨɥř’ʰɥŜɬř‰‡ʰɨɥɥɥƀ ɨɥɥʳކ”‹ˆ–ɏ•‹ſʰɨɥɥř’ʰɥŜɬř‰‡ʰɨɥɥɥƀ ɨɥɥɥʳކ”‹ˆ–ɏ•‹ſʰɨɥɥɥř’ʰɥŜɬř‰‡ʰɨɥɥɥƀ ɪ‰‡–—„‡”‘ˆ‰‡‡”ƒ–‹‘• ‰ʳŞ•‡“ſɥřɨɥɥɥřɨƀ ɪ…‘„‹‡‹–‘ƒ–‹„„Ž‡ ›†”‹ˆ–ʳރ•Ŝ–‹„„Ž‡ſ…„‹†ſ‰řɨɥřɨɥɥřɨɥɥɥƀƀ

1RWHWKDWZHFRXOGDOVRKDYHUXQ†”‹ˆ–ɏ•‹ඈQDVඈQJOHOඈQHRIFRGHXVඈQJ•ƒ’’Ž›OඈNHVR

ɪ•‹—Žƒ–‡†”‹ˆ–ˆ‘”–Š”‡‡†‹ˆˆ‡”‡–’‘’—Žƒ–‹‘•‹œ‡• ƒʳŞ•ƒ’’Ž›ſ…ſɨɥřɨɥɥřɨɥɥɥƀř†”‹ˆ–ɏ•‹ř’ʰɥŜɬř‰‡ʰɨɥɥɥƀ ɪ”‡ƒ‡ƒ–”‹š …‘Žƒ‡•ſƒƀʳŞ…ſɑɨɥɑřɑɨɥɥɑřɑɨɥɥɥɑƀ ɪ‰‡–—„‡”‘ˆ‰‡‡”ƒ–‹‘• ‰ʳŞ•‡“ſɥřɨɥɥɥřɨƀ ɪ…‘„‹‡‹–‘ƒ–‹„„Ž‡ ›†”‹ˆ–ʳރ•Ŝ–‹„„Ž‡ſ…„‹†ſ‰řƒƀƀ %RWKZD\VZRUNEXWWKඈVඈVDQඈFHGHPRQVWUDWඈRQRIKRZ\RXFDQXVHVRPHWKඈQJOඈNH•ƒ’’Ž›WRPDNH\RXU FRGHPRUHVXFFඈQFW$Q\ZD\ZKDWZHXOWඈPDWHO\ZDQWWRGRඈVYਟVXDOਟVHGUඈIWRYHUWඈPH6RZHQHHGWRJHWRXU GDWDඈQDSRVඈWඈRQWRSORWඈWXVඈQJ‰‰’Ž‘–ɩRQFHDJDඈQZHWXUQWR‰ƒ–Š‡” ɪ—•‡‰ƒ–Š‡”–‘‰‡–†ƒ–ƒ”‡ƒ†›ˆ‘”’Ž‘––‹‰ ›†”‹ˆ–ʳމƒ–Š‡”ſ›†”‹ˆ–ř‡›ʰɑ’‘’ɏ•‹œ‡ɑř˜ƒŽ—‡ʰɑ’ɑřމƀ $OOZHGඈGKHUHZDVFROODSVHWKHSRSXODWඈRQVඈ]HVඈQWRDVඈQJOHIDFWRUIRUHDFKJHQHUDWඈRQ‰ƒ–Š‡”FRPPDQGV FDQWDNHDZKඈOHWRJHWWKHKDQJRIWKHEHVWWKඈQJඈVWRFRQWඈQXDOO\SUDFWඈFHWKHPOඈNHWKඈV1RZZHZඈOOSORWRXU GDWDXVඈQJWKHIROORZඈQJFRGH ɪ’Ž‘–†ƒ–ƒ ’ʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſ›†”‹ˆ–řƒ‡•ſ‰ř’ř…‘Ž‘—”ʰ’‘’ɏ•‹œ‡ƀƀ ’ʳŞ’ʫ‰‡‘ɏŽ‹‡ſƀ ’ʳŞ’ʫšŽƒ„ſɑ‘Ŝ‰‡‡”ƒ–‹‘•ɑƀʫ›Žƒ„ſɑŽŽ‡Ž‡ˆ”‡“ſ’ƀɑƀ ’ʫ–Š‡‡ɏ„™ſƀʫ–Š‡‡ſŽ‡‰‡†Ŝ’‘•‹–‹‘ʰɑ„‘––‘ɑřŽ‡‰‡†Ŝ–‹–Ž‡ʰ‡Ž‡‡–ɏ„Žƒſƀƀ

  $QGWKHUHZHKDYHඈW$SORWRIRXUVඈPXODWHGGDWDVKRZඈQJDOOHOHIUHTXHQF\FKDQJHVRYHUWඈPHDVDUHVXOWRI JHQHWඈFGUඈIW$OWKRXJKWKHSORW\RXJHWZඈOOGඈIIHUIURPWKHRQH\RXVHHKHUHEHFDXVHRIWKHUDQGRPVDPSOඈQJ ZKDW\RXVKRXOGEHDEOHWRVHHඈVWKDWZඈWKDORZSRSXODWඈRQVඈ]HDOOHOHVDUHHඈWKHUORVWRUJRWRIඈ[DWඈRQYHU\ UDSඈGO\7KඈVඈVEHFDXVHWKHHIIHFWRIGUඈIWඈVPXFKVWURQJHUKHUHZKHUHDVඈQODUJHUSRSXODWඈRQVඈWPD\WDNHD ORQJWඈPHIRUGUඈIWWRIඈ[RUUHPRYHDQDOOHOHඈQGHHGඈQVRPHFDVHVඈWZඈOOQRWKDSSHQDWDOO

6WXG\TXHVWඈRQV

)RUVWXG\TXHVWඈRQVRQWKඈVWXWRUඈDOGRZQORDGWKH…Šƒ’–‡”ɪɏɏ“—‡•–‹‘•ŜIURP&DQYDVRUIඈQGඈWKHUH KWWSVHYROXWඈRQDU\JHQHWඈFVJඈWKXEඈRFKDSWHUB5BTXHVWඈRQV5

*RඈQJIXUWKHU

7KHUHDUHDORWRIJUHDWUHVRXUFHVDYDඈODEOHRQSURJUDPPඈQJඈQ5DQGHYROXWඈRQDU\JHQHWඈFV7KHUHDUHDOVR VRPHJRRGIXUWKHUWXWRUඈDOVRQXQGHUVWDQGඈQJ+:(DQGGUඈIWඈQ5WRR%HORZඈVDFROOHFWඈRQRIUHVRXUFHV\RX PඈJKWIඈQGRIXVH 7KHVRIWZDUHFDUSHQWU\JඈWKXEKDVDQH[WHQVඈYHVHWRIWXWRUඈDOVIRUOHDUQඈQJ5SURJUDPPඈQJ KWWSVVZFDUSHQWU\JඈWKXEඈRUQRYඈFHඈQIODPPDWඈRQ $JUHDWGDWDFDPSWXWRUඈDORQIXQFWඈRQVDQGIXQFWඈRQDOSURJUDPPඈQJ KWWSVZZZGDWDFDPSFRPFRPPXQඈW\WXWRUඈDOVIXQFWඈRQVඈQUDWXWRUඈDO +DGOH\:ඈFNKDP¶V$GYDQFHG5WXWRUඈDOVKWWSDGYUKDGFRQ])XQFWඈRQVKWPO $FRPSUHKHQVඈYHJXඈGHWRYHFWRUඈVDWඈRQඈQ5KWWSZZZQRDPURVVQHWEORJYHFWRUඈ]DWඈRQඈQU ZK\KWPO 'DWDFDPS¶VORRSWXWRUඈDOKWWSVZZZGDWDFDPSFRPFRPPXQඈW\WXWRUඈDOVWXWRUඈDORQORRSVඈQU $QH[FHOOHQWDQGYHU\GHWDඈOHGSUඈPHURQSRSXODWඈRQJHQHWඈFVඈQ5 KWWSJUXQZDOGODEJඈWKXEඈR3RSXODWඈRQB*HQHWඈFVBඈQB5ඈQGH[KWPO