Earthquake hazard assessment in Turkey: the Mw=7.4, Golcuk (August 17, 1999) and the Mw=7.1, Duzce (November 12, 1999) earthquakes

Tam metin

(1)Available online at www.sciencedirect.com. ScienceDirect Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 629 – 636. ,96C5 !?E6C?2E:@?2=6@8C2A9J+J>A@D:F> '%

(2) . 2CE9BF2<6 92K2C52DD6DD>6?E:?,FC<6J E96%H P=4R<F8FDE

(3)

(4) 2?5E96 %H

(5) RK46 &@G6>36C

(6)

(7) 62CE9BF2<6D *646A76 "+)*%2)1!-)5%12)37"#4+37.&132 "-$#)%-#%2%/"13,%-3.&%.'1"/(7

(8) "+)*%2)1 41*%7. %&$& FC:?8 E96

(9) E96 ?@CE9H6DE6C? A2CE @7 ,FC<6J 6IA6C:6?465 EH@ >2;@C 62CE9BF2<6D P=4R< 2?5 RK46 2=@?8 E96 &@CE9 ?2E@=:2?2F=E1@?6 ,96 P=4R< 2CE9BF2<6@44FCC65@?F8FDE

(10) 2?542FD6552>286:?2K@?66IE6?5:?87C@>FK46E@ !DE2?3F= ,96 RK46 2CE9BF2<6 DECF4< @? &@G6>36C

(11)

(12) 2?5 42FD65 52>286 :? RK46 #2J?2V=U 2?5 @=F ,96D6 EH@ 62CE9BF2<6D 42FD65 D:8?:7:42?E 492?86D :? ?2EFC2= 6?G:C@?>6?E DF49 2D DFC7246 CFAEFC6 4C24<D =2?5D=:56D @77D6ED :? E96 C:G6C365D5:D492C86@7DF3DFC7246H2E6C7C@>F?56C8C@F?5=:BF6724E:@?2?54@2DE2=4@==2AD6 ,96DFC7246CFAEFC6H9:49:D

(13) <>=@?86IE6?5:?87C@> #2J?2V=U E@ P=4R<:DE96>@DED:8?:7:42?E ,96492?86D27E6CE9662CE9BF2<6DH6C6:56?E:7:657C@>7:6=5 >62DFC6>6?ED2?52DD6>3=:?8E966I:DE:?8>2AD2E

(14) 2?5

(15)

(16) D42=6D L

(17) ,96FE9@CD (F3=:D9653J=D6G:6C $E5 Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. *646A76%F?:C'KEFC<2?5!3C29:>E2=2J +6=64E:@?2?5A66CC6G:6HF?56CC6DA@?D:3:=:EJ@7 Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the Organizing Committee of GEOMED2013. %76.1$2 ,FC<6J@=4F<62CE9BF2<6FK4662CE9BF2<686@>@CA9:467764EDFC7246CFAEFC6. !&$"'&"! ,H@ =2C86 62CE9BF2<6D DECF4< ?@CE9H6DE6C? ,FC<6J :?

(18) ,96 P=4R< 62CE9BF2<6 @44FCC65 @? ,F6D52J F8FDE

(19) E9

(20) 2E

(21) =@42=E:>62?59252>@>6?E>28?:EF56@7%H ,9642FD6@7E9662CE9BF2<6H2D E96DF556?3C62<286@CCFAEFC6@7E9662CE9YD4CFDE2=@?8E96H6DE6C?A2CE@7E96&@CE9?2E@=:2?2F=E1@?6:8 ,96 P=4R< 2C62 :D =@42E65 :? E96 ?@CE9H6DE6C? A2CE @7 ,FC<6J 2?5 @? E96 62DE6C? D9@C6 @7 E96 +62 @7 %2C>2C2. @CC6DA@?5:?82FE9@C *646A76 ,")+"$$1%22 C646A6769@E>2:= 4@>. 1877-0428 © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the Organizing Committee of GEOMED2013. doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2014.02.143.

(22) 630. Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 629 – 636. :8

(23) ,96 62CE9BF2<6 =2DE65 7@C D64@?5D 2?5 27764E65 2 H:56 2C62 :? ?@CE9H6DE ,FC<6J !DE2?3F= !K>:E 52A2K2CU RK46 @=F 02=@G2 FCD2 2?5 1@?8F=52< ,9:D 62CE9BF2<6 :D <?@H? 6:E96C 2D E96 %2C>2C2 62CE9BF2<6@C2DE96 P=4R< 62CE9BF2<6 @==@H:?8 E96 D6:D>:4 6G6?E @G6C

(24) A6@A=6 5:65 2?5 @G6C H6C6 :?;FC65 ,96 62CE9BF2<6 52>2865 3F:=5:?8D24C@DDD6G6?AC@G:?46D7@C25:DE2?46@7 <>7C@>!DE2?3F=E@@=F 52JD 27E6C E96 P=4R< 62CE9BF2<6 2?@E96C A@H6C7F= 62CE9BF2<6 @44FCC65 :? E96 RK46 2C62 ,96 RK46 62CE9BF2<6@44FCC652E

(25)

(26) =@42=E:>6@?&@G6>36C

(27)

(28) 2?59252>28?:EF56@7%H

(29) RK46 :D2=D@ =@42E65:??@CE9H6DE6C?,FC<6J !E27764E65 RK46#2J?2V=U@=F2?5P=J2<22?53C@F89ED6G6C652>286E@E96 2C62 ,9:D 62CE9BF2<6 :D <?@H? 2D E96 RK46 62CE9BF2<6 ,96 RK46 62CE9BF2<6 2C62 :D AC:>2C:=J =@42E65 :? E96 H6DE6C?A2CE@7=24<+62*68:@?3FE:E27764E65E962DE6C?%2C>2C2C68:@? +6G6C2=D6:D>:4 86@=@8:4 86@A9JD:42=2?5E64E@?:4DEF5:6DH6C642CC:65@FE:?E962C62+6?8@C

(30) +6?8@C6E 2=

(31) +E6:?6E2=

(32) ,2J>2K -++ /:EE6C (2C<66E2= E2=2J 762?5 &@G2<@HD<: !? E9:D DEF5J E96 P=4R< 2?5 RK46 62CE9BF2<6D @7

(33) 2C6 :?G6DE:82E65 3@E9 :? E6C>D @7 86@=@8:4>@CA9@E64E@?:4D2?586@>@CA9@=@8:4DECF4EFC6D2DH6==2D492?86D:?E9662CE9YDDFC724676 2 . !". . $()%. )'(. . %"'. '$. . . '+)')$. #). %. . . . . . . . &% )#". !" . . . .

(34) . .

(35) . #&*. . . . ,+. . .

(36) &#)

(37)

(38)

(39) . .

(40). . .

(41) . )'(. .

(42) .

(43)

(44) . . . $). $!. . . . !#!". "$.

(45). . :8

(46) +EF5J2C62. .

(47) Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 629 – 636. &$!&" ,96DEF5J2C62:D=@42E65:?E96?@CE9H6DE6C?A2CE@7,FC<6J2?56?4@>A2DD6DE962C6236EH66?@=F2?5!DE2?3F= :8

(48) ,96DEF5J2C62:D36EH66? M Y2?5

(49) MY62DE=@?8:EF562?5 M Y2?5

(50) M Y?@CE9=2E:EF56 +EF5J H2D 4@?5F4E65 56A6?5:?8 @? 7:6=5 @3D6CG2E:@?D

(51) D42=6 E@A@8C2A9:42= >2AD H6C6 FD65 E@ 56E6C>:?6 E96 5:C64E:@?@7DFC7246CFAEFC6D

(52) !!% ! %'%%"! %.+.')#"-$'%.,.1/(.+.')#&%"341%2 ,96 5:DEC:3FE:@? @7 62CE9BF2<6 :?E6?D:EJ H2D DEC:4E=J 27764E65 3J E96 A9JD:42= AC@A6CE:6D @7 E96 2C62 ,96D6 A9JD:42=AC@A6CE:6DAC:>2C:=J:?4=F56E64E@?:4DECF4EFC6D 3FE2=D@:?G@=G686@=@8J86@>@CA9@=@8J !?E9:DC6DA64E A9JD:42=492C24E6C:DE:4D42?366>A=@J65E@6IA=2:?62CE9BF2<6:?E6?D:EJ2?5E965:DEC:3FE:@?@752>286 %.+.'7 ,9686@=@8:42=DECF4EFC6@7E9662DE6C?%2C>2C2H2D>@DE=J7@C>655FC:?8E96@D6?'=:8@46?6A6C:@53JE96 4=@D:?8@7 E96 :?EC2A@?E:5 H9:49:DE96A2CE@7 ,6E9JD '462? ,96C62C65:776C6?E86@=@8:42=7@C>2E:@?D6 8 7C@> (2=6@K@:4E@)F2E6C?2CJ 6C27@F?5:?E96DEF5J2C62C:?<>2??

(53)

(54) ,96 @=56DE 7@C>2E:@?D @7 E96 DEF5J 2C62 4@?D:DE @7 (C642>3C:2? 2?5 (2=6@K@:4 >6E2>@CA9:4 C@4<D 4@?E2:?:?8 D6CA6?E:?6D49:DE8?6:DD2?58C2?:E6D (2=6@K@:47@C>2E:@?D2C6@FE4C@AA65:?E96=>24U<2?5+2>2?=U >@F?E2:?D @? E96 D@FE96C? A2CE @7 62CE9BF2<6 2C62 +:=FC:2? 6G@?:2? FAA6C 2C3@?:76C@FD C64CJDE2==:K65 2?5 5@=@>:E:4 =:>6DE@?6D @44FC @?E96?@CE9@752A2K2C: 6@=@8:42= 7@C>2E:@?D 36=@?8:?8 E@ E96 C6E246@FD A6C:@5 2C6 H:56DAC625 :? E96 ?@CE962DE6C? 2C62 @7 +2A2?42 $2<6 !K>:E 2?5 E@ E96 ?@CE9 2?5 ?@CE9H6DE 2D H6== 2D E96 ?@CE9H6DE6C? D:56 @7 6JG6 2?5 :ED ?@CE962DE6C? A2CE %6E2>@CA9:4 C@4<D E92E 36=@?8 E@ E96 ,C:2DD:4 6C2 368:? D@FE9 @7 +2A2?42 $2<6 E@H2C5 !K?:< $2<6 ,C:2DD:4 2?5 "FC2DD:4=:>6DE@?6D @44FC :?E96E9:DA2CE@7E96K@?6 ,96!K>:E2J:D=@42E652=@?8E96&@CE9?2E@=:2?72F=EK@?6 !?:ED62DE6C?A2CEDE96C62C6G2DE2==FG:2=A=2:?D 36EH66?+2A2?42$2<62?5!K>:E2J ,968C@F?5@7E96D6A=2:?D86?6C2==J4@?D:DED@7G6CJE9:4<>@56C2E6=J4=2J @CD:=EJD2?5DEC2E2 +65:>6?E2CJ56A@D:EDH:E9C@F?565A633=68C2G6=2?5D2?52C64@>>@?:?E96A=2:?D C62D 25;246?E E@ E96 72F=E =:?6 2C6 ?@E DF:E23=6 7@C 56G6=@A>6?E 3J G:CEF6 @7 E96D6 8C@F?5 762EFC6D ,96 A6C46?E286C:D<@7=:BF6724E:@?:D9:89:?E96=@H6DEA=2:?D@7E962C62 (2CE:4F=2C=J:?52A2K2C: P=4R< 2?502=@G2 D6C:@FD52>286@44FCC653642FD6@78C@F?5762EFC6D. :8 !?F?52E:@?3JD62H2E6C5F6E@4@2DE2=DF3D:56?46?62CP=4R<. :8 %@=6EC24<2=@?8E968C@F?5CFAEFC6?62C<J2KU . 631.

(55) 632. Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 629 – 636. %.,.1/(.+.'7 ,96DEF5J2C62:?4=F56DE96 #@426=:A=2E62FE@E96?@CE92?5E96+2>2?=U=>24U<#6C6>2=: >@F?E2:?DE@E96 D@FE9 ,9656AC6DD:@?:D3@C56C653J2?6D42CA>6?EE92E6IE6?5DE@E964@2DE@7E96=24<+622?5:D<?@H?2DE96 $@H6C+2<2CJ2A=2E62F ,96+2<2CJ2*:G6CA2DD6DE9C@F89E966D42CA>6?E2C622?55:D492C86D:?E@E96=24<+62 ,96 N2>>@F?E2:?:D:?E96?@CE962DE6C?2C62@7E9652A2K2C:G2==6J2?5E96#6C6>2=:>@F?E2:?D:?E96D@FE9@7 E96 G2==6J == 56AC6DD:@?D :? E9:D 2C62 92G6 366? :?7=F6?465 3J E64E@?:4D 'G6C2== E96 6I:DE:?8 E@A@8C2A9J H2D 7@C>653JE96+2<2CJ22?5%6=6?C:G6CD2?5E96:CEC:3FE2C:6D2?5?6@E64E@?:4>@G6>6?ED .1/(.3%#3.-)#2 "$& !&"!

(56) '& "! & ,9:D :D 2 56IEC2= :?EC24@?E:?6?E2= DEC:<6D=:A 72F=E >@C6 E92?

(57) <> :? =6?8E9H9:4992D2AA2C6?E=JAC@A282E657C@>2DE6C?,FC<6J#2C=U@G2E@E96F=7@7@C:?E9:?E966862?+62 :8 2D:42==JE96&4@?DE:EFE6D23@F?52CJ36EH66?E96FC2D:2?2?5?2E@=:2?A=2E6D D2C6DF=E?2E@=:2 :D 6IECF565 H6DEH2C5 36EH66? E96 & 2?5 E96 4@?;F82E6 2DE ?2E@=:2? 2F=E AFD965 3J E96 4@==:D:@? 36EH66? FC2D:2 2?5 C23:2? A=2E6D ,96 D=:AC2E6D 6DE:>2E6D @? E96 & G2CJ 36EH66? >> JC 7C@> D6:D>@=@8:42= 4@?D:56C2E:@?D E@ >> JCX7C@> 86@=@8:42= 6G:56?46 2C<2

(58) F36CE 6E 2=

(59) 'C2=

(60) ,96C6 2C6 D>2==6C 72F=ED H9:49 >2<6 FA E96 H6DE6C? 3C2?496D @7 &@CE9 ?2E@=:2? 2F=E :? E96 DEF5J 2C62 76 2 76 3(2C<66E2= . " !. ". $()%. !". % " . . . . . . . . '$ ! ! . % . . !#. . . ! !.

(61)

(62) . . . "$. :8 (=2E6E64E@?:4D>@56=6IA=2:?:?8C646?E2?524EF2=E64E@?:424E:G:EJ:?,FC<6J+6?8@C6E2=

(63) ,96>2;@CE64E@?:4A=2E6D2C6E96 7C:42?C23:2?FC2D:2?2?5?2E@=:2?A=2E6D. ,)(!/.

(64) '& ,9672F=EH9:493@C56CDE96 RK46 32D:?:D=@42E6536EH66?@=J2<22?5#2J?2D=: ,96 E@E2==6?8E9@7E9672F=E :D<>2?5:E3C2?496D:?E@EH@E@E9662DE@7#2J?2V=U !

(65) '& ,96 6?56<72F=E:D:?E96H6DE6C?A2CE@7E96 RK46 2D:?2?5:E6IE6?5D36EH66?+2A2?42$2<6 2?5F>2J6C: :?2&+/5:C64E:@? !E:D2DEC:<6D=:A72F=EH:E92C:89EW=2E6C2=>@G6>6?E2?5:ED=6?8E9:D <> *

(66) '& ,96 N:=:>=:72F=E=:6D@?E96?@CE9@7 RK46 32D:?2?5:ED=6?8E9:D2AAC@I:>2E6=J

(67) <> ,9:D72F=E 7@C>D2>@CA9@=@8:42=5:D4@C52?4636EH66?E9632D6@7E96 RK46 32D:?2?5E96N2> >@F?E2:?D:?E96?@CE9 ,96 N:=:>=:72F=E:D24E:G62?5:D2DEC:<6D=:A72F=EH:E92C:89E=2E6C2=>@G6>6?E %.,.1/()#%&&%#32 .& 3(%%"13(04"*% ,96 P=4R< 2?5 RK46 62CE9BF2<6D 42FD65 3@E9 >:4C@2?5 >24C@=6G6= 492?86D E@ E96 ?2EFC2= 6?G:C@?>6?E ,96D6 492?86D G2CJ :? >28?:EF56 2?5 2C6 C625:=J @3D6CG23=6 :? E96 7:6=5 =E6C2E:@?D E@ E96 ?2EFC2= 6?G:C@?>6?E.

(68) Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 629 – 636. C6=2E65E@E96 P=4R< 2?5 RK46 6G6?ED:?4=F56E967@==@H:?8+FC7246CFAEFC6DE6?D:@?4C24<D2?5DA=:ED4@==2AD6D 2?5 =2?5D=:56DDFC7246@77D6ED:?E96C:G6C365D=:BF6724E:@?2?54@2DE2=4@==2AD6 '$ '#&'$% ,96 P=4R< 62CE9BF2<642FD652DFC7246CFAEFC6E92E:D

(69) <>=@?8:8 ,96DFC7246 CFAEFC6:D@3D6CG23=6:? >2?J=@42E:@?D36EH66? P=4R< 2?5 P=J2<2 @H6G6C2?@E96CCFAEFC6 H9:49:D<> =@?8 @44FCC65 2D 2 C6DF=E @7 E96 RK46 62CE9BF2<6 E@ E96 62DE @7 E96 P=4R< 72F=E ,96 E@E2= =6?8E9 @7 E96 EH@ CFAEFC6D:D2AAC@I:>2E6=J

(70) <> ,96>2I:>F>C:89E=2E6C2=D=:ADH6C6@3D6CG652E P=4R< >2?5C:7:J6 >. :8 52A2K2C:FAA6C=67EP=4R<FAA6CC:89EP=J2<2RK46=@H6C=67E2?5C:89E. 41&"#%4/341%.& 9+#;* "13(04"*% ,96 P=4R< 62CE9BF2<6 42FD65 2 DFC7246 CFAEFC6

(71) <> :? =6?8E9 ,96 7C24EFC6 6IE6?5D 7C@> #2C2>FCD6= E@ P=J2<2 =@?8 E96 CFAEFC6 K@?6 C:89E=2E6C2= 5:D=@42E:@?D @7 FA E@ > @44FCC65 ,96 5:C64E:@? @7 E9:D DFC7246 7C24EFC6:D &/ 67@C>2E:@?@44FCC65@?E964@2DE2=D:56@7E9668:C>6?56C62?5@=4F<2=@?8E9672F=E =:?6D +62H2E6C:?F?52E652C62D23@FE

(72) >6E6CD:?=2?5 ,9672F=E=:?6:?E6CD64EDE96+62@7%2C>2C2@?E96D@FE96C?D:56@7E96!K>:E32J ,@E9662DE@7E96!K>:E32J:? 0FG24:<E96DFC72467C24EFC65:G:565:?E@EH@A2C2==6=D68>6?ED2AAC@I:>2E6=J >2A2CE @76249@E96C ,9:D2C62 4@==2AD65 23@FE

(73) >6E6C ,96 2>@F?E @7 C:89E=2E6C2= @77D6E :D > :? 2?5 2C@F?5 #F==2C G:==286 :8 ,96 2?2=@8@FD@3D6CG2E:@?:D>F499:896C:?G2=F6@?E9662DE@7+2A2?42$2<6 ,962>@F?E@7E965:D=@42E:@?:D > E@ E9662DE@7C:7:J62?5 >D@FE962DE@7C:7:J6. 633.

(74) 634. Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 629 – 636. 41&"#%4/341%.& ;8#% "13(04"*% RK46 62CE9BF2<6 @44FCC65 2=@?8 E96 RK46 72F=E @? &@G6>36C

(75) E9 !? E9:D 62CE9BF2<6 E96 <J2KU #2C256C6 <DF P=J2<2 2?5 RK46#2J?2V=U 72F=ED >@G65 2?5 F=E:>2E6=J 4@?D:DE65 @7 2? 2AAC@I:>2E6=J <> CFAEFC6@?E96DFC7246 ,9672F=E=:?6H9:497@C>655FC:?8E96 RK46 62CE9BF2<64@>>6?46D2E 24UJ2<FAG:==286 H9:49 :D =@42E65 E@ E96 62DE @7 P=J2<2 ,96 72F=E =:?6 A2DD6D 7C@> E96 D@FE96C? D:56 @7 %6=6? $2<6 2?5 6IE6?5D E@H2C5D #2J?2V=U ,96DFC7246CFAEFC66IE6?5D/5:C64E:@?3FE:EG2C:6D36EH66?&/& ,96=2E6C2=@77D6ED :? E96 H6DE ?62C 7E6?: =2<6 >6E6CD 3FE :E C62496D E@ >6E6CD 2C@F?5 RG6? G:==286 ,96 2G6C286 @77D6E :D ?62C=J >6E6CD %2I:>F> 5:DA=246>6?E :D 7@F?5 @FE :? E96 >:55=6 A2CE @7 E96 CFAEFC6 +EC:<6 D=:A 5:DA=246>6?E 564C62D6D2EE963@E96?5@7E96DFC7246CFAEFC6$6EE:D6E2= ,96@77D6ED42?36@3D6CG65@?C@25DDEC62> 492??6=D 2?5 76?46D ,96 DFC7246 CFAEFC6 4FED E96 C@25 2?5 42FD6 567@C>2E:@? @? E96 =68D @7 G:25F4E ?62C @=F ,F??6=

(76) %-2).-1"#*2"-$/+)32 ,96DFC7246CFAEFC6E92EC6DF=E653642FD6@7E96 P=4R< 2?5 RK46 62CE9BF2<6D:D?@EC6AC6D6?E653J2D:?8=6=:?6 ,96K@?6:D

(77) >:?=6?8E92?54@?E2:?DE6?D:@?4C24<D2?5DA=:ED C24<D2?5DA=:ED=:6A2C2==6=E@E96>2:?CFAEFC6 :?>2?JA=246D3FEE9@D64C24<D56G6=@A65:?5:776C6?E56DE:?2E:@?D:?D@>6A=246D .++"/2%2"-$"-$2+)$%2 @==2AD6D 2?5 =2?5D=:56D :? 5:776C6?E D42=6D H6C6 @3D6CG65 :? 2 G2C:6EJ @7 =@42E:@?D :?4=F5:?8 E96 7@==@H:?8 =@42=:E:6D

(78) +@FE9@7!K>:E2J68:C>6?56C6 P=4R< 2?5DFCC@F?5:?82C62D:?E96D@FE9@7!K>:E 2J*6D:56?E:2=2C62D 2=@?82

(79) >H:56DEC:A@7E9668:C>6?56C64@2DEH6C64@>A=6E6=J56DEC@J653JE9662CE9BF2<6 !?#2G2<=:2?5 P=4R<=2?5D=:56D @44FCC65 @?E967=2E2C62D36EH66?E96D9@C62?5E96C@25>@DE=J@?7:==65:?2C62D:8 ,96 D9@C6=:?6 @7 +2A2?42 $2<6 +6G6C2= 4@==2AD6D 2?5 =2?5D=:56D H6C6 @3D6CG65 @? E96 ?@CE9 2?5 D@FE96C? 4@2DE@7+2A2?42$2<6 ,96H6DE6C?A2CED@7 P=J2<2 2?56DA64:2==J@?E96D@FE96C?D=@A6D@7#6C6>2=:>@F?E2:?D 24:J2<FA2?5E96DFCC@F?5:?82C62D2C@F?57E6?:$2<6 :8 ,96D=@A6D@7E96>@F?E2:?D?62C #2J?2V=UE96EF??6=@7@=F%@F?E2:?2?5DFCC@F?5:?82C62DA=FDE96@=F %@F?E2:?A@CE:@?@7E96!DE2?3F=?<2C29:89H2J !?86?6C2=C:89EDE6AA:?8C:89E=2E6C2=2?5D=@A6DE6AA:?8D@FE93=@4<5:DA=246>6?E@44FCC652E #2J?2V=U 2?5 :ED DFCC@F?5:?8 2C62D ,96 62CE9BF2<6D 42FD65 =2?5D=:56D @? E96 DE66A6C D=@A6D +@>6 >@F?E2:? C:586D @44FCC65 3642FD6@7E964@>AC6DD:?8D66?=@42==J@?E9672F=EK@?6 &&2%32)-)5%1("--%+2 ,9662CE9BF2<62=D@27764E65D@>6@7E96C:G6CD7=@H:?87C@>E96+2>2?=:2?5=>24:<%@F?E2:?D:?E96D@FE9 =@H=2?536EH66?!K>:E2J2?5 #2J?2V=U ,9672F=EK@?6CF??:?8A2C2==6=E@E96C:G6CD4@>:?87C@>E96?@CE942FD65 D@>69@C:K@?E2=2?5G6CE:42=5:D=@42E:@?D ,96D65:DA=246>6?EDC624965E9C66>6E6CD:?E96C:G6CDE92E7=@HE9C@F89 E96 RK46 56AC6DD:@? 36EH66? P=J2<2 2?5 P=@C>2?U ,96 4C66<D ?62C 24UJ2<FA G:==286 2?5 E96 !=:K2C 2?5 68:C>6?56C6 C:G6C 365D E92E 4@??64E E@ %6=6? $2<6 2=D@ 6IA6C:6?465 5:DA=246>6?E :8 ,96 DFC7246 CFAEFC6 42? 36 EC2465 7C@> E96 492?8:?8 86@>@CA9@=@8J @7 E96 C68:@? '77D6ED @7 D@>6 DEC62>D 2C6 >@C6 E92? E96 5:DA=246>6?EE92E@44FCC65:?E9:D62CE9BF2<6H9:49D66>DE@92G6366?27764E653JE96AC6G:@FD62CE9BF2<6D )04%&"#3).$:BF6724E:@?2?5E966>6C86?46@7D2?5JDFC7246 H6C6@3D6CG65@? >2?J@442D:@?D7@==@H:?8E96 P=4R< 2?5 RK46 62CE9BF2<6D ,96 =:BF6724E:@? 2C@D6 E9C@F89 E96 =2E6C2= 5:D=@42E:@?D @7 E96 E9:4< 2==FG:2= =2?5D E92E :?4=F56 D2?5=2J6CD :6=5H@C< F?56CE2<6?:?E96DEF5J2C6256>@?DEC2E6DE92EE96C6:D2=H2JD2A@DD:3:=:EJ@7=:BF6724E:@? 5FC:?8 2?J 62CE9BF2<6 E92E @44FCD :? E96 !K>:E P=4R< 2?5 52A2K2C: 2C62D $:BF6724E:@? 4@>>@? @? E96.

(80) Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 629 – 636. F?4@?D@=:52E65 8C@F?5 F?56C8@6D 4@>AC6DD:@? DBF66K:?8 @FE H2E6C 7C@> 36EH66? D@:= A2CE:4=6D !?4C62D:?8 E96 2G2:=23=6 H2E6C G@=F>6 :? E96 8C@F?5 564C62D6D 7C:4E:@?2= C6D:DE2?46 2?5 =@25 362C:?8 42A24:EJ 4@?D6BF6?E=J 564C62D:?8 E96 C6D:DE2?46 @7 E96 8C@F?5 ,96 =2?5D=:56D E92E H6C6 D66? :? #2G2<=: 2?5 68:C>6?56C6 @44FCC65 3642FD6@7=:BF6724E:@?AC@46DD6D ."23"+.++"/2% @==2AD:?8 6G6?ED 2?5 =2?5D=:56D E92E 92G6 @44FCC65 36EH66? E96 D9@C6=:?6D 2?5 E96 C@25 :? E96 #2G2<=: 2?5 P=4R< C68:@? H6C6 D66? >@DE=J :? 7:==65:? 2C62D :8 ,96 567@C>2E:@?D :?G@=G65 4@==2AD6D D=:5:?8 2?5 H2CA:?82?5=625E@:>A@CE2?E86@>@CA9@=@8:4492?86D:?E964@2DE2=K@?6 @H6G6CD@>652>286:DDA64:7:42==J C6=2E65E@DEC@?88C@F?5D92<:?8DF492DE964@==2AD6:?E9646?EC2=4@2DE2=K@?6@7 P=4R< 2?5+2A2?42$2<6 "!'%"!% ,96F8FDE

(81) E9

(82) P=4R< 62CE9BF2<69252>28?:EF56@7 2?5E96&@G6>36C

(83) E9

(84) RK46 62CE9BF2<6 9252>28?:EF56@7%H

(85) 7E6CE9662CE9BF2<6@44FCC652DFC724672F=E36EH66?P=4R<P=J2<2 H:E92=6?8E9 @7

(86) <>6>6C865 =D@E96 RK46 62CE9BF2<69252DFC724672F=E<>36EH66?C:7:J62?5 #2J?2V=U E@H?D ,96C:7:J6#2J?2V=U 72F=E>@G65 <>5FC:?8E96 P=4R< 62CE9BF2<6 ,96E@E2=DFC7246CFAEFC6:D

(87) <> C@F?5 762EFC6D E64E@?:4 DECF4EFC6 2?5 86@>@CA9@=@8:4 762EFC6D 27764E 2? 62CE9BF2<6YD :?E6?D:EJ 2?5 C6=2E65 52>286 !? 255:E:@?9@FD:?84@?DECF4E:@?56D:8?2?5>2E6C:2=D2=D@4@?EC:3FE65E@42E2DEC@A9:4@FE4@>6D G2C:6EJ@7724E@CD C2?8:?8 7C@> A@@C 4@?DECF4E:@? AC24E:46D E@ :?256BF2E6 D:E6 A=2??:?8 H6C6 :?G@=G65 %2?J A9JD:42= 762EFC6D 9J5C@=@8J 86@>@CA9@=@8J 92G6 366? 2=E6C65 5F6 E@ E96 62CE9BF2<6D ,9:D 2C62 @7 ,FC<6J H:== 4@?E:?F6 E@ 36 24E:G6:?2D6:D>:4D6?D62?52AAC@AC:2E6DE6AD?665E@36E2<6? ?@HE@ >:?:>:K6E96 67764ED2?572E2=:E:6D@7E96 ?6IE62CE9BF2<6. $!% <JFK + 2C<2 =EF?6= 2CE=63* +F?2= :6=5@3D6CG2E:@?D2?5D=:A5:DEC:3FE:@?@7E96&@G6>36C

(88)

(89) FK46 62CE9BF2<6%

(90) @=F,FC<6J ,96

(91) !K>:E2?5FK46 2CE9BF2<6AC6=:>:?2CJC6DF=ED 5 2C<2 #@424U' <JFK + >3C2DD6JD& & 2?5:?<6=

(92) ,96D6:D>:4:EJ@7,FC<6J2?525;246?E2C62D9:DE@C:42=C6G:6H

(93)

(94) !DE2?3F=(F3= %F9:EE:? +2=:9C6? AA >3C2DD6JD& & 2?5:?<6=

(95) $@?8E6C>+6:D>:4:EJ@7!DE2?3F=2?5E96%2C>2C2+62*68:@?,6CC2&@G2 C>:;@* %6J6C 2C<2 9232=:6C" F96CE6CC2C: 2<:C1 ,9672F=E3C62<D@7E96

(96) 62CE9BF2<6D:?,FC<6J2?5 E96E64E@?:46G@=FE:@?@7E96+62@7%2C>2C22DF>>2CJ ,96

(97) SK>:E2?5FK462CE9BF2<6AC6=:>:?2CJC6DF=ED 5 2C<2 #@424U' <JFK+ =EF?6= !DE2?3F=,649?:42=-?:G6CD:EJ E2=2J! 2CE9BF2<6D@7

(98) F8FDE2?5

(99) &@G6>36C

(100) :?,FC<6J 3DEC24ED !?E6C?2E:@?2=6@8C2A9:42=@?8C6DD

(101)

(102) F8FDE +6@F=#@C62 2C<2

(103) +=:A5:DEC:3FE:@?2=@?8E96&@CE9?2E@=:2?72F=E2DD@4:2E65H:E9=2C8662CE9BF2<6D@7E96A6C:@5

(104) W

(105) +6:D>@=@8:42= +@4:6EJ@7>6C:42 F==6E:?G A

(106) W

(107) C:?<>2??*

(108)

(109) ,9686@=@8J@7H6DE6C??2E@=:26@=@8J2?5 :DE@CJ@7,FC<6J 5 J + 2>A36==,C:A@=:+

(110)

(111)

(112) 76* +6<:?+

(113)

(114) 52?26J92?2CE9BF2<6 2E:9-?:G6CD:EJ(F3= &@ !DE2?3F= 76* 2 P=4R<2?5RK462CE9BF2<6D

(115) 2?E2J(F3= !DE2?3F= 76* 3 6@>@CA9@E64E@?:4D@7&@CE9H6DE6C??2E@=:2 +J>A@D:F>@?+6:D>:4:EJ@7/6DE6C??2E@=:2 (C@4665:?8DA

(116)

(117)

(118)

(119) !+&

(120) !K>:C,FC<6J 76 * &@G2<@HD<:& $2?5-D6(=2??:?8!?2CE9BF2<6(C@?6C62D !?E6C?2E:@?2=+J>A@D:F>@?6D6CE:7:42E:@? #@?J2,FC<6J "F?6

(121)

(122) $6EE:D/ 2499F36C" 2C<2 /:EE6C* C2?<>2? +FC72462F=E*FAEFC62?5+68>6?E2E:@?5FC:?8E96#@426=:2CE9BF2<6 ,96

(123) SK>:E2?5FK462CE9BF2<6AC6=:>:?2CJC6DF=ED 5 2C<2 #@424U' <JFK+ =EF?6= !DE2?3F=,649?:42= -?:G6CD:EJ 'C@=%

(124) =@32=(@D:E:@?:?8+JDE6>(+%62DFC6>6?ED:?,FC<6J

(125)

(126) #:?6>2E:4D@7E967C:42C23:2FC2D:2(=2E6 @==:D:@?1@?6 (9 ,96D:D %2DD249FD6EED!?DE:EFE6@7,649?@=@8J 6AC2E>6?E@72CE92E>@DA96C:42?5(=2?6E2CJ+4:6?46 - + (2C<6" * /9:E6* + %4#6?K:6 #FD4F! F==" % @CFC& +6?8@C % 4E:G672F=ED:?E96D62@7%2C>2C2/6DE6C? ,FC<6J:>28653JD6:D>:4C67=64E:@?AC@7:=6D ,6CC2&@G2

(127)

(128) AA +6?8@C %

(129) ,96&@CE9?2E@=:2?EC2?D7@C>72F=E:ED286@77D6E2?5E64E@?:4D:8?:7:42?46 " 6@= +@4 $@?5@?

(130) . 635.

(131) 636. Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 629 – 636 +6?8@C % @CFC& +2C@8=F

(132) +EC:<6D=:A72F=E:?82?5C6=2E6532D:?7@C>2E:@?:?K@?6D@7E64E@?:46D42A6,FC<6J2D242D6 DEF5J S?:55=6 # , G69C:DE:6=:4<65D +EC:<6D=:A2F=E:?82?52D:?@C>2E:@?+@4 '74@?(2=6@?E %:? +A64 (F3 +E6:?+ * 2C<2 :6E6C:49"

(133) (C@8C6DD:G672:=FC6@?E96&@CE9?2E@=:2?72F=ED:?46

(134) 3J62CE9BF2<6DEC6DDEC:886C:?8 6@A9JD:42="@FC?2=!?E6C?2E:@?2=

(135) .@=

(136) ,2J>2K, +6:D>@E64E@?:D@7E96%2C>2C2*68:@?+@FC4692C24E6C:DE:4D@7

(137) @=4F<+2A2?42FK462CE9BF2<6D ,96

(138) SK>:E 2?5FK462CE9BF2<6AC6=:>:?2CJC6DF=ED 5 2C<2 #@424U' <JFK+ =EF?6= !DE2?3F=,649?:42=-?:G6CD:EJ -++ !>A=:42E:@?D7@C2CE9BF2<6*:D<C65F4E:@?:?E96-?:E65+E2E6D7C@>E96#@426=:,FC<6J2CE9BF2<6@7F8FDE

(139)

(140) - + 6@=@8:42=+FCG6J:C4F=2C

(141)

(142) /:EE6C* $6EE:D* 2499F36C" 2C<2 GC6? 2<:C1 (286/ 6?86D9" +6:EK (2=6@D6:D>:4EC2?49:?8DEF5J 24C@DDE9602=@G2D68>6?E@7E96&@CE9?25@=:2?2F=E 6CD6<(6?:?DF=2,FC<6J ,96

(143) SK>:E2?5FK462CE9BF2<6AC6=:>:?2CJ C6DF=ED 5 2C<2 #@424U' <JFK+ =EF?6= !DE2?3F=,649?:42=-?:G6CD:EJ.

(144)