في مفهوم حوار الحضارات والثقافات إشكاليات الجدوى والفعالية / في مفهوم حوار الحضارات والثقافات إشكاليات الجدوى والفعالية
14
0
0
Tam metin
(2)
(3) . !"
(4) # $ % &'
(5) ( ")*+(,-*./)& 0123 6778 4$15 . . Nâdiye Mahmûd Mustafaa Kahire Üniversitesi İktisadi ve İdarî İlimler Fakültesi Uluslararası İlişkiler Öğretim Üyesi, KAHİRE. a.
(6)
(7) !
(8) ! "#$% &' ( )*+, -./ +0 8
(9) 2 #
(10) #23
(11) # +#,4# 5 4# 67 , #1 D!C# 8B A)$ : ! +9 :; ! <=$ >? @,
(12) 5F! ' G $ 8: E> , 8 .
(13) #+ &7# 6 ', A- # ) ; - &7 8#, E+ - &7 #$
(14) ( 'I
(15) JK:;!
(16) +>5
(17) #.&1;
(18) 6* H+ - 7 !
(19) 5I2B
(20) I52N FIFN, I O'P I! IB Q I 8I L'IM'# =$
(21) /+I "'I2/ I R. I,
(22) I: C O.&
(23) /?
(24)
(25) /#* "II H+II +II>5 -&II 7 +II# I / TII$: S
(26) II? II & II! VII # +, 'II# )WII =II$ ) II 8IIB A"II3 UII#2/ "II/3 I!% OI1
(27) JKI:; I
(28) I/' .'I I! &I I! +KI# X', AL'M'# = \+Z D([2 8 . O
(29) YFN#. I2 + 8IB
(30) I 2
(31) #2
(32) E / ' U'M ]2/
(33) I * +#
(34) I2 + -& I7 _+I !
(35) 2 +#!
(36) B'('# \ ^
(37) $ +. A)
(38)
(39) .C. a'II#b
(40) II 'II$ `II ?
(41) II* 2 +II7# DII([ =II B II OII1 =I$
(42) I ! 6Ie 8I
(43) Id+5c + & 8B
(44) 1+ D ]M'5 )d+ I!
(45) I.f+ gI#2 &ICB% I7, 8 ` '
(46) 1+ L'M'#. A"'5# 71 8
(47) 5,+#
(48) #$;
(49) * & "I#$% i+IB \=I hI I. , $+5,
(50) YNK, 7.
(51) .+>5 $j,% !
(52) !
(53) 3
(54) !+ -+ 8B ]I ? %'I( L +FI !
(55) I: C# ! 'I IM'
(56) I <=I$ kI#: ' XI1 . IC , lI 'I mI.+>B `/ FI. I I .
(57) B+ m`, ' ' n O'>,. Copyright © 2007 by İslâmî Araştırmalar Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3). A ' 2
(58) ?
(59) .f o . \ +M #, YNK =$ 249.
(60) Q3iB KKK0 13KKK J#KKK KKK B,KKKD,&KKK ;
(61) =;6;+/6;$*3,<' -,: @C4 +/AB3>$&? 3@, .KKK;,KKK-.HKKK 3KKK+&#KKK4+KKKO <' 3KWi& 0 &2 &) * 4^#a _KK$>- ) *KK+)3KK,KK'o&KK+KK9&!KK ) *+N#4,'o&+ -%3-Q# _? .K;jE *&!Q3iB 0Q30t. 0#~ C #MK']2 K+pKK-o&K+>K0K9& !K /5 Q YKK5%3KK-_KK::+$h#KK9&,KK? ^#KKa:KK5 F9,? u9& /5tqrrs#9/9, ) *KK+,/:KK/.KK;KK'3KK0^#KKa Ki E K/ hWKK5KQ K5Q 3KK%K-UKk Q 3KK0Q3iB KK0JKK,KK:/#KKcQ}KKEDJ#KK C KE R 2 K-CQhU>K-h #K9pC=>0> K/03K0 ) *K+,K-.H -& )H K+GK_$3^#a ,KK?&!KKDKK KKFKK:+$<K E&) *KK+ QoKJ#K C ) * )3KKK+_MKKK-N3KKKO3/<KKEo&KKK+!KKK[ KK-#aKK/ =>KK0KK "3<KKE 3+HKK$%#KK C !KK[XK5#$U>KK5 _K3Q K5 KK)K-N#HK Q ^#a:' E # L & +$FR/$ E> D_ "3& 3KK] N#KK4.)3KK ?KK
(62) 3KKo&KK+. ^ KKKK:'UKKk ) *KK+,KK-KKjKK/B v#K
(63) _$ m = & *tN3O3/:J# C2 -C K7:P/ 0 i$18# D_ E#d=2 B KKK4 7HKKK-,/:KKK/.KKK; KKKO 3KKK >KKK0KKKL&# <KKEKKK KKKFKKKR/&=) KKK9' jKK/B*KK KK 9L KK- d KK$oKKtN3KKO3/ KFKRJ#K wd ) *+ ,- K K&2 /2 K-C,K- gK C!K,DQ &2C, 0#K7$- K /<E FH7,?/& < 3+:'. K/ h#9/9Kss pK8E KO ;&= #Ki7$Q 5]>. /0130DN3O3/ -. /0 !KK -xy<KKE# MKK_KK Q3iB KK0#MKKB KK FKK4 7$<KKE 3 KKQKK- ) *KK+.KK4 K KKKK%) KKKKKK
(64) ;<KKKKKK7?&Q3iB KKKKKK0 KKKKKK#d .KKK&Q3iB KKK0z#KKKdQ , KKK,KKK[/ - :#<E / #7 " k3/B <K:%#& aF:+$%:'.3& %2) 9^#+ %) *KK+<K 01 FK+<KKE KK -. KK/01{)2 K:%#K7/K5#+/ J3K,K 0) 9' h#KKK-,KKK'#K K|9'Q3iB KKK0Q}KKKE>KKK-DKKK K :/i<KE &) *K+KE R2 -C -. /01 250. KK& V#KKFKK4 7$<KKE 3 KKQKK- . K/>K0<KE 3K<K7? &Q3iB 0 #dC. KK0 i$%KK',KK-N#KK7$ KK" KK 3KK3$KK_KB 8 ) *+,- j/B 387: , KK:KKC'3KK/i 3KKKK'3 KK- " FK:+:%KKC%) *+$F0 &= %) *KK+.3KK 7%KK E KKl KK KK<KKE ]> KKKK/0C)KK KKlKK KKKK) V3KK& KE R!2 -_ L'Wi& Kc K4K K)2' ) *K+N#K4FK0J# B,D KK9LN #KK4J3KKN#KK4FKK+FKKKK . ) *+)3F0l :S#+/5 .KKE RKK/2 KK-CKK:'#HKK& '#KK4 F?KK
(65) KKl= & *KK%3KK:KK&2 /2 KK-CK KK/&. ) *K)3+-n/&]></ Qh3 3K0 K 6K<$\&Sk>0F9lF' EJ3 lN#HK.)3K+ ) *+,-F4 WKi&.3K+>K0K:' 6Kz#KdnH&F0 lN#HKQ3K?&l) 3+Q3?& e K<KE ) *K+,K-IK 1Q) 9':' QoKKK N#HKKK<KKKEW9KKK3KKK0GKKK_KKK$k JK h#K-K:'#6K$<K<K0 . Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3).
(66) KKKK:#/KKKK9L K KKEJ#KKKK CKKKK:', KKKK+ KKK h#KKK7$Q,KKK?/&FKKK0!KKK,KKK KKKP&) #KKKKc#KKKK m KKKKO%KKKK&iKKKK/ KKKKO37 F9K3K0)3K+Q3K?&Q,K?/&F0lN#H l +_h,{#P:! . . K#d 3K i 0 i$8/B. 13KKKKKKKKKK56&- CDKKKKK,KKKKK-Q3iB KKKKK0 K LB)3+B ?uE#&!, Q3iB 0 KKKKJ3KKKK KKKKBh3$ KKKK w KKKK,KKKK ! KK^3KKi= KKi$KK-#aJ3KK KK 3K0 K=>K0o9Q) 9' - <; N#HK3K0 K R9]D &) *K+E R2 -C .KK;! KK'= KKi$^#KKaWKKB ",KK]) *KK+ 9K1Q3K?&,)3+Q}E!, ,/:/ = Ki$ &) *K+KE RK/ `#K7 &" Q * KKE) KK Q3iB KK0 13KKuE#KK& -Q ~ KK J3Qh3$G– ) *+,-Q3?$ K : C#7/<0 -n H/ uE#K$K K:KK&e),K LB KK/ g HKK; * K E) KK ) *KK+GKK$ )2 HKK KK0) 9' -KK;%) *KK+.KK; .KK; ,KK' KK' E2!KK,KK .2 HKKN#HKK: FK- _B3*KE#&1#K AQ3K:9&,&>K,/:/ K' E2 K _K)3+:Q_Q3B &. KKKKE R,KKKK-)3KKKK+KKKKE RKKKK&2,KKKK' K <E C=) 9' - ) *+ ,KK K LB KK/ 'B KKBKK&e) ,KK K LB I) KK )3KK+KK/0\- I#KK$KKKK&e) G, \5 ^3M!C,-]) *+ N EKKK2#KKKi GKKK .KKKKKK/ KKK# D.;,')>'1 N#HK)3K+Q 3K&-oK R= Ki$1 ,KK<KKE ) *KK+,KK- KK: 1 KKKK0 K0 #K +Q= i$1>0,E)J#& # K[B<K ) *K KE )3+ -n/$1 23KKK&,KKKoKKK+-tKKKJ3KKKQXKKK KKK 1. Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3). #K AK:']) *KjK/B`#KEK1)3+ {#KP:J)#KO)3K+QJ#K&# m E)Q}E _ #E3$Q -1_B1 0#_h,! KKKwKKKE KKK+_KKKE0wKKK+&<KK?v#MKKK 9KK=) KK9' -] t_ KK$k)3KK+.3KK 7_*KK& KKK . KKKwKKK 3KKKhS#MKKK/!0 KKK7: D/: ) *KK+)3K = Ki$KJ#K %) K9<KKE ) *KK+.KK4KK3/]HKK!KK),KK `#K'1!K h,K ;-#%# . K7&#$,K K LB K $ $K3/=>0:' )3+: / - E R%) *+:'3 KE#B K,K K LB ]) *K+]#K?7 ! KK:Je#KKKK9dKK:'#6KK$KK7:PKK&#?E ,KYK3/K:'#6K$F- _$ B3?,- FKKK:+: KKK KKKE R ) *KKK+k KKKP$ D_',< Q 3K,K?/&_KB K0[/ -#&i 1 J#KKK9?KKKR KKK0 i$1=>KKK0,KKK-2KKK+ )KK/,KK-2KK+ KK%#KK95KK")-w- KKL$ t KK; KK3 KK#9: J#KK9?KK&#?7 FKKK ,KKK'_KKK&e)_KKK)KKK/=>KKK0,KKKFKKK?E K9d,K' ' K7:#K7FK 5]) *+ DB $.'#4 0#03" ' 7=>0 *KKK,KKK KKK0 i$1=>KKK0YKKK3FKKKR/$ ! &e),! 73/2 ) *+ ,- . K[ +9 - i B 0) m /3,' )#KKKK1Q KKKK,KKKKK KK&X3KKKK+B <KKKK . KKB1N#HKK,KKKK&X3KK+B.KK#9: 8KK7: Q Q3KK; Q3&) KK Q3KK3 8KKKKB 5k}KKKKE HKKKK7uKKKK-<KKKKE!0KKKKE) )3KK,KK' KK' E2#KKR5C<KK0KK#9:KK)/ %2) KKKK9^#KKKK+KKKK- KKKK! KKKK'<KKKKE ) *KKKK+ Q\KKK-8KKK3GKKK7B<KKKEI#KKK$1KKK E KKK/3 2 KKKKK-C KKKKK0#\$<KKKKKEg3KKKKK7$KKKKKE R2 KKKKK-C QJ#KK$,KK? KK3n HKK/i$#KK1 251.
(67) !0 KKK7,KKK+&)#KKKOKKK:/'%2)3KKK+ FKKF KKF9KK5 KKE R KKKK:'</ KK D5#M/&#H/ & *F5 M/ Q}KE &) KK)/ K3)/ )2 HKK/ -I#KK'1<KKE KK; KK KK/" Q2 3KK+$<KK-#a KK<KE'#HK ! K- K/EQ3K7:P&!K B1 <K)3KB ? &) *K+KE R2 K-C#\K$Qh 3 9L DF5 J3n H/ '#H-B) / W9KKK-N#HKKQ3&) KKKQ3KK3J#KKK&KKE ! KKK? K K ]) *KKK+<E K KRIKKK 1 &) /KKKKKKKK1 '#MKKKKKKKK/KKKKKKKK_KKKKKKKKB3"#& K-#aVK1KE RK/ 	 K9K# K95 KB hQ3K;KL&,K<E YKK:P$,KK? ! $KK:+$! $#KK7$<KKE <E KKR ,KK)3KK+KKB ?oKK,KKKK;KKE# D_' )3KKKQ 3KKKKKKRKKKu9KKKFHKKKE , LB,/:/#H$I & ) *+ #K Au9KFHK&.;:'%#6/&e) #HK2 K "3K0 ) *K+)3KQ 3K J) *KK+N#HKKKK "3<KKE%KK&i_9 KK\D^#aWB ", ,KKYKK3/ KK:'g KK7$1Q}KKEJ#KK %) KK9Q K0 i$1uK-,-_')3+B ? KKKKKKE#B KKK,KKK KKK9B_KKKB1wKKK+$ & *KK KK$KK'–J#KK KK/5– >KK DKK7:P KKR)KK/F KKQN#HKK. )3KK+ D & *&+$o,Y:P$ 2E$*E'DD BC< . 2KKKKi$ 0KKKK-#9/9KKKKss pKKKK KKKK ! h%3- ) * +,- 3 1i =) HKKKKBQ3iB KKKK0 13KKKKV 'KKKK!KKKK$ #KKR5g KKQ KK5,KK?D_KK%2 *KK/ 13KK/ oKt KK&-<KE _K:'Q K5 /) 30$ 252. Q K-! K/Y3<E < ;I#L+O ,K<K7EtFK/+/& )H O3<EQ 5 ,L
(68) S)3&3B:' /i <Eu9J) !KK%#LKKKKO!:KK/W*KKa KK:' KK2 u9KKKQ}KKKE KKK-#a KKKKKKOKKK-#a g KK<KKE KK/i <KK#KK[KK_KKi$#KK A - 0);9M/ ?9M)2n H/N#4 )2 3K KiQ}KE>K t K <E 2 -C,- &) *+ E R2 -C,- ,K 0$ pC=>0#7$<Ei$#1 KKKKKK?&#C KKK- LP<KKKE )3KKKL$ h#KKK-oKKKt# KK95 KK/ hWKKK5KKK KKK?&#C 3K0]) *K+N#HKFK0 2 Ki< 6 F9KK KKl=)HKK3KK0 K l! KK!KK?+&]>KK %)2K:' ) *K+)3)&F0l_ "3/ l:#/=>0 3K K0 i$1. B iG7B#/ KK0#a-KKB) / -&) *K+KKE R2 K-CQh <B K?<B Khg K-%#K/=>K0<KE Q#K,? = KKi$KK/ KK?&#C KK -j9$#KK&2KK+ ,KK#MKK']2 KK+KK-,/:KK/.KK;! KK' z3KKKO3-I#KK'1KK&X$,KK!c# KK9Et#9/ 9KK. KKKK- LP<KKKE&) *KKKK+KKKKE R 2#KKKK7/ V3KKKKK–/KKKKK##KKKKKc/KKKKK#KKKKK?&#C = Ki$S K0FK(:E– &)3+ H ,K_KB) 9':'! :]3E R#7uE#& h KKK$-3HKKK# KKK[BF5 MKKK/FKKKKKK23KKK& KKK1 | F9KKK1!KKK,KKK KKK -3,KKK' KKKE R I#KK'FKK- /<KE _d#KK
(69) #E3KK$KK-)3KK+ KKKK,KKKKKKKK0#KKKK:#/Q#KKKK m= KKKKi$ ]) *KKN#KK4,KK'z3KKO3-YMKK?$KK?&#C ,K'o&K+_Kn9HK& ,/:K/.;= i$ ]>KKK)3KKK+QC . KKK1FKKK9,KKK)3KKK+ _KK$ 5)wKKE ^#KKa v#MKK-Q3?KK)KK QC KKK| /.KKK;3KKK01_KKK$ & c3KKK+B KKPKKE R2 KK-CYKK(3$KK?&#C KK Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3).
(70)
(71) & % ' ( $ ! "# - ./ 0. 1 ,2 3 -- . * ) + !, 64
(72) 78# 9: ; < = * 4 5 - # < >8 . , ?@ 5 AB+ 5 AB+& < 5 AB+& F C & 9 -"E-+ C = D + G HI J
(73) B. = + .' 5K2 L * 1 -; = M&
(74) = NKO P ;0A; RQ . RQ . 4 E# L-M - M IB , O-# B B RS T 0* W0-U; = VE;
(75) B; J 0 -
(76)
(77) A+2 X B 9SEO M IN #Y# 4 NKO =
(78) , [0\ P ; O Z U 1 EY
(79) 5 ;-C& B-# = I
(80) P! ]- N . 0* / E-; = I * ^B+ K
(81) # -# _ 8+ JV# ;T 0* 9=\ E. =_ B = + =;#`. 0* 9; O ; 0N2 ED -A; + 0* 9 8Oa + ; ; 1 OZ 8T " #- , . * <b A- cM = B-0; !6C 5 R= B-0; !6C de -+ L VO- –
(82) "- ,". 9 4#Q M [ f gO f 1 * -; O 0; -;VE. 9 + . .K2 O; f ;0A; B-& . 5 4# - ; O 5/% Y- P? + . $, h O
(83) ]+ VK;
(84) M " = j M IB
(85) 5 ;-C& iN 98;-8 . a* !6C = M # O 8D [f P f 1iN – Z ?
(86) ; = A`; 0* 90;. B0 F 0;O k+ " !6C ' 8T
(87) < B-+& = 80^-. = f + G HI [ f = . V+ ( 9 ) f cT . Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3). - M lO8 I ) M 8AE
(88) 7B P] 0* m -# ]I# [+ T W= C "# K
(89) i ;- ;M ]#& B. nU0-# $6 8 0 ! "#& W#j T ;I. Jp 0* `# ; O -o M, O- DB;M = C "# L ;Z . C A+2 X B 5- P]# * f .. r -. # I
(90) -q s? J 8 ]+ 9 )M f J
(91) )E;. )M, . < ? S0U- 1e, . 0U-; 1 I . M * t 8-N <K? . 3Q 9+ A+2 5 B- L * 9
(92) 1 I =/ "+' = A`. L N . L O =\ E; JT t 8-N& 6C . uE;M Bc Z U L
(93) .K2
(94) O A+2 X B L N 3Q P .K2
(95) O P + A+' ; * 1 I * 8O# [ 8Z =6
(96) SMO- = p' J\ -v ' JZ - C w C x M I L B . B E-. * ;". Z 0* X #& + A+2 E- C 8-* 6?Y# - ; O PXKU. J;a- = I 1 E uA-# -y < ". :8 9 ; * JT a. 9 O. = p' 4#& ". C gH 5K2
(97) NKO P ( .
(98) O 1 I LC A# k"M -z ; O JT a;0 < 0 Z .K2 P + A+2 ; B 4# # {D f ; . g-BM 4 $ A ! "#& W#j !, . ?@ )
(99) -N. 253.
(100) GKK&) *KK+ >KK -YKK&#>KK0Q. n9HKK$ ) *KK+)3KK,KK<E K RKK91 | l_ 2 -C0J# C & * `#K7& ) *K+)3Q 3,?/&F0 =>KKK0 KKK/i]) *KKK+<E K KRFKKK:+^#KKK &) *K+E R & * -. /01 ?M/ l %#
(101) 9/. KKK <KKKE _KKKB\5! KKKQ3KKK?&QuKKKE) -s K QCtY K3/ E R) ?EC,-N#4 KKK&2 /KKK/3 KKKmFKKK(<KKKEJ3KKKQh3KKK$ KKd#7KK/0< /KK#. KK[:#E3KK$KKE R %22#iJ#?7<E RFi&]>#C30 FK(<KE !K,K K3,K'#K9 "G HK:')3+:S 0GQh3.' 1 KK3WKKLk. KK[QCt<E KKRJ#KK?7 <KE ' K$,K,K?&X)_/1)3+:Fi& Dw + "3. </ KKK'J3KKKKKK:' KKKuKKKE) -q 2#i30G Y:P /' " 3,? 3KK-)CK?&#CF K#Q3/* z#KKdKK&#BWKKi&,KK?…KKE R ' KKO K5#K K5#) Kd<KE K/' " KK/ #& KK F K Rv KKB 3KKUKKk ! KK <E KKKKK)3KKKKKKKKKK&3CuKKKKKE) KKKKK"2X/ ^3K")3KK+-VKK9Q2 /MKK KK<K V HK;&#HK K'X]HK DD^3" - 9K/$Q2 :+' /" & *<E )3KK+ </ KK. KK[,KK'%)2 HKKKK+ <KKKE ^3MKK:KK' /ig3KKK+ 3KK<: KK KKKKKKKK' /"1 KKKKKKKK 3 0#HKKKKKKKK#KKKKKKKK&#$ &)#* Bh3 E R&2 H1 .3Ki0f#K-<E#?7 B/Q B;g3 DD /M&#HO2 *. KKKK6/^#KKKK_KKKK:R/&oKKKK R= KKKKi$1 ,KK;,&#K ?7/U>KK5 /KK#KK; 254. t)3KKK+:13KKK9 * K KE)! 73KKKIKKK KKK:' )3K+ KO3 & *K,! -##[ %)3KKK4KKK0. KKK/01%)6KKK-QKKK+:BN#HKKK !KKK,KKK KKK `#KKK&<KKK 9MKKK.KKK; %KKK'.KKK;KKK9L-FHKKK& KKK!0) *KKK+ Z HKKKP-FHKKK& KKK KK/ KK &#KK
(102) KK-#a KK $#[-KKB) / -KK;%) *KK+ T&) KKK<KKKE KKK; KKK) // -FHKKK& KKK B &K^ +K4 = Ki$-#a 0# [-B) / DJ# C E R 2 KKK-= KKKi$1>KKK0JHKKK&J#KKK %) KKK9,KY3/ 9:<E %#
(103) 9/&) *+E R < KK 6KKz#KKL$<KK 2 KK-C<K0D.KK; WK$#& .K; -E#h^#aJS 0F0 KK9 KK&3B<K 0.l. KK;,KKFKK>KK0 KK :' ! B!'X-_:0\-_$) *_E R-/ g H; ,&K<E _E 1^#aQ30#?&-Q3/:/]lDD%) *+ JK" 3KV)AZKP:$1 /",?/&>0 K'3/i K '3/i,-_',)3+ !K LBKLB ) 3K+J"<E,??M/ #KKK9&_KKKK#- ) *KKKK+) 3KKKKN3KKKKO3Q K" 7%)3H-_-V 71- B "# ' 3O3 N#KK4KK&#[BKK:'FKKE2#KK5 KK>KK #KKK9&1!KKK,KKK_KKKB Q3iB KKK ) *KKK+ >K0^ +K4D KJK"k4 ' 3O3 2 MK12 K/fi+Q33&3h w !0 1\ED)3+J"<EU?MY3<E ,KKKK-)3KKKK+Q3KKKK?&Q,KKKK?/&1_KKKKBQKKKK56& ,KKK-6E KKK?^ KKKcFKKK(<K KE & KKKi ) *KKK+ QKK-1J3KKQh3KK$.KKB ED) 3KK+I#KKd K&#& KI#KdCK_E<:/& O*7& #KKK AI#KKKLTKKO#&,KKK<KKEFKKK7 -)2 KK9& 2GKKD% )2 KK9/KK:'2#KKFKK7-jKKE.3KK& Q,KKwKK>KK0^ +KK4KK'>KK0+KK4KK:' = & *K2+&)3+%" *&]>30^#a Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3).
(104) g3KK+ KK&#+ & *KK 3KK)KK$%2 KK'<K0 %)#KKOKK&2 %#KK/g3KKKK4 KK&2#7 g3KKKK/ ' #KK9]#KKKK&# KK # KK;&#MKK:%KK i #KK7 Q KKB; c K4I K$%#
(105) 9^#a! $ & * <0 i8+$^#a 0&#&<:5 M:'g#M %) *KKK+2KKK &]>KKK^ KKK0);)>KKK"KKKi n KK/<K+/Q,<E-#a .#K3K0-^#Ka K {#K&<K K/<0– wKKK>KKK0J#KKK&DI KKK 1<KKKE#KKK AwKKK 13K0 ) *+)3QuE#U?M/ KK0,KKDn HK/N#KK4 K0V)<KK7P$K " !0 K7)3+%3' -,: 7#c!0 ]#KK?7uKK-,KK<$\KK$<KKN3 KK- 3KK9 <KKE #KK/R$Q,KK?/&1%3KK'2 KK BUKKk ^#KKa. )2;J3K0QC</ K#J3/:' ! &) `#K7$_K ,K]>KN#HK K3K0/# D)3KK+GKK%3KKwKKL KK ,KK + HKK K%3'K2#KiQwK>K0^ +K4K56& R-h3+$Q,?/&1^#a,$\$<)3+ B K$<K-#a F(<EUkg#M KKK,#KKK,LKKK:7KKK:' KKK3!KKK:[ KK!0KK'>KK E 8/HKK -KK:75) MKK/ D)3+:'' &1N#H]26&. ,6KKK/)3KKK+:KKK&6/wKKK KKK / /3Q/:,w:LE=i-. DN#HKKGKK@& KK`#KK7& KK3>KK0Q Q,KKKK1KKKK->KKKK03KKKK:9&Q KKKK/iKKKK:'Q JKKi$,KK KKd 9<KKEK i8KK33*KK& & *K,' DD 5#MO),'3R+9&Q! :E D_ K K iB=) KKK02hKKK:'' KKK$)3KKK+J>KKKa$ w$ KK'KK:' KK$3KKS KK0>KK0wKK+&KK #Ka&Q_K:E^#Ka KD 3\K/)3+<E#d wL,':P&Q") P_$ +, FK/+&QK KK:']2 KCS#+ .KK;,KK'9:KK%)3HKK#KKa$<KKE_3KK. Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3). #KcV XK"_'F F/+$< ^#a<E Q _KKK:Eg#MKKK KKKD KKK 6KKK,KKKFKKK: W",9B i:' D<9:<:/)2LP& 1 ,&>KKKK ! $ KKKK/iFKKKK 2V16KKKK03KKKK:/+&Q D K "3=>K0_"3:' )3+Ji-Q36& KK&:$#KKc%KK&"W K,KK' KR+9&Q K/ :' K 3K43 K /0 K/-) ) *K+,K-)3+: FKR)3K+:/K# 3Z:$ /i/ DQ &2C)3 KK4),KK?/&_KKBKK%) KK
(106) ;)KKi$>KK0. ,??MKKK/<KK&#E,KKK-oKKK wKKK&#EYKKK3 <K-#z#KKLQJ#KK&]>KK3K 0,EKK/. z#KKd3KK0 ) *KK+)3KKN3KKO3/<KK; )HKK/,KKKK9&_KKBCFKK4Cz#KKL3KK0!&KK ,KK KK3KK0 K Qm#KK3KK0<K C ^3MK KFK <KEC;GC KK&KK&2 -I#KK'1,KK K LBJ#KK C K4uE#K$K&23 Q}KEF- / <E E R Q KK&2CJ3KKKK:'V3KK)3KK+:z#KKd] GKK,0#KK<K -#az#KKL Q KK/5 ) *KK+ !K,K K IK0w+ #d1. ) *KK+)3KK+,0#KK<KK;z#KKLQ}KKE ,KK KKO#E` #KK7z#KKdFKK-FKKE2)1GKK <K;! KK:' 3/'g#M:'^#a 3KK0 <K -#az#KKL>KK0 D 4 3HKK <K -# ) *K+:p 330 ) *+:G$ 9 9KK ' 3KKO3 KK :i&oKK KK - KK: FKK4Cz#KKLQ,KK<KKE N#HKK^#KK+: _K&->< ;z#L30 ) *+)3+ -oK Rw>0 wE– WiE> D # < K$<K <E KR< K,K-:'3 K-#aK4 7H-?&#Ci$#;<E <KKE<KK;<K-#! KK= KKi$KK '7HKKD<. [)3L$,0#:#/ _',)3+J" 3 i -j9$#& K&#[B K/0K/0C a K-,* 3 i. 255.
(107) %#6KKK/KKK&#[B,KKK'D$>KKKKKK%#6KKK/ JKK"<KKEQ3??MKK/ K9 c!KK0- u9KKJ#KKE :','Cn7$ E . 0 -o9MQ-)3+ K:' KB 3'Q3K?$!K,KKO /<E U # K
(108) 6Q3KK?$#KKO +<KKE KKS KK+& KKS)2 # Au9 DF9/<E S + :' ' /KK
(109) KK:' KK$ 7 FKK5wKK:$ K /$3*KKE#E KK9$ KK7:P$QKK:'KK5 %#6KK/KK&#[B K&#+!K:FKw&#d<E#. "#$ 3KKdKK-.KKE^#KKa KK E) KK<KKKK Q K56wK>K0^ +K42#L&DY:P$ KK9c)%2 KK'_KK953&=>KK0%#6KK/KK&#[-Q KK/&; 5 B:' 25\ ED. >_&X$<EO# )K_KE# A:'n7$)3+I#$%) * ) KKg#MKK E KKa 9/h KKi,KKFKK:#KKc K'N#HK/ %#L/ *&30 K' ) *+)3N3O3/ED :_Q 5 FK/+& K/#R5\K-FK/ N3KO33K0w>0 Q3KK?&QT&) KK)KKKK:'KK&1_KK:5#C KKE KKK:#FKKK5<KKKE>KKK \& n HKKK/KKK:' ' #KKK4 KKKKKE &2 HKKKKK%2KKKKK+/KKKKKKKKKKP&) $ _KEniK&N#4_B30#//,? &#?' #KK[uKKa- Y*KK#KKP&,KK<KKEJ3KKC #K[uKa-Y*K3K0,KJ3K30,/' &#?KKKK' _ K KK$2N#HKKKKN3KKKKO3,KKKK' :inO3,Q 5Q &2 H %XKK78KKKKKKE R 2C2 KK-CQQA _K:'8KB 5 K/-B) / - %&' ) 9'1. DF9, K&#[B# [$%#6/&#[BF- <E )3KKK+%#0 KKK(FKKK4\$KKKKKK$<KKK$>KKK - LP:&#?7)>iN3"# -J) *+ KKKK *KKKK #HKKKK'<KKKKEKKKK'3/KKKK-# K; ) K,K-FK' 7 & * ?
(110) D^#Ka, 73-#&) #9:. ) K=>K0GK&+$:'&#[=>0.3$ 256. kD_ K/$ K0)3L$- &-'&#?7 Q12KK$!KK>KK0KK'3 KK:L8KKB 5 _K/$wK:LFK"K,K&Kk Cz#d #7$ + *, ) =>0Y330 #KKapKK<KKEKK-#KKL/FMKKE^ 9KK >K D K+{k3K/BFK9$<EFME_B\-^3:L/ n" KJ) *+)3+v#
(111) !0,Q#9' ,KKKK+:KK&BKK&e)!&KK$KKB /:KKB3KK0 KK B,KKKK;#KK?7T&) KKKKBKK B KKF9KK3KK02 KK-C{2XKK KK>KK EDJ#KK ,KKKK-KKKK/ 5#MKKKK/!KKKKKKKKLI MKKKK5 D ) *+ %#6/&#[B8B 5k_B_EU
(112) 1 / K $ :L/*E)% B )#9 i i_"3$ KKKK&#[BQ}KKE ) *KK+)3KKuKKE)<KKE K i i 0)KK-#KKR$<K #9:_KK"3 k<$>KK IKKK0KKK&+$3KKK+B KKK $ :L/%KKK B )#KKK9 :KKKC)3KKKR$!KKK,KKKD_KKK$ m_KKK$ & c)3KKK+ . K+,K' K-. K-# K7BKBF0 #KK[B<KKE- )3KK+FKK0l]) *KK+ KK"k3/B,KK' ^#KKa,K'FK:#K mF9K3K0-<K#9:) K KK:L ,KK >KKKK{ KK+BFKK0lKK&",KK K"#/,K'N EK: * K&{ K+B.jKE#9 KKK.3KKKi `#KKK$8+KKKO<KKKKKK; >KB" +,'*7E 0,lg L #K4 J#K?E2 K "KK" <KE *K&,+E ,/*KKKK&Q KKKK5Q.KKKK;QCtFKKKK' EJ3KKKK B KKKB;%KKK 3KKK:KKK4\$Je) #KKK[$ Q3KKKK?<K KKEQh3KKKKQ#KKKK/IPK KK1 ,/:KK/T&) KK$KKE KK) //Q1 KK0#c 3K. 7',#R5#R$,/:/ %#KKK9P-)#KKK KKK3,KKK-FKKK4C,KKK-%3KKKi7 3KK4C,KK'N EKK:KK" +,KK'UKK0 BDT&) KK K:'GK :'.3i0,_ "3$ O $k DjE,/:/. Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3).
(113) /$&e)nl-k - B KK?/& w- KKJKK`#KKV3KKOKK:' )3K ,K'<K&e)nu-'Y3QA <KKKKKKEnKKKKKK/=>KKKKKK0ZP:KKKKKK$ ) *KKKKKK+ #KK4 ' 3KK)KK$K&#[B /0KK ,'3KK/i KKK5#KKKB Rt KKKi/>KKK ]#KKK[FKKK4\ ]#KK?E< KK )) KK$23KK" KKB ? 3KK)K $ K0# :#/<E ) *+)3 3<-#' D<;<-#T&) ,h\/ ]#[F4\#4 '-s. )3KKKKKK<KKKKKE<KKKKKR+9 KKKKKKi/:V KKKKKK/B1Q <K5#+ Ki/V /B1,# R5 ) *+ >KK0) KK9' - #KK4 =>KK -. KK/0 EKK&_KKE 1 KipK ,K–nKO3w9 /5– i/ Y\KKKK#KKKR&<KKK KKKK KKKKKKKK)2 w9KKK KKK#( KKK& K K0) KK /0 KKK 3 KKKi << 2 H1 -. /012i$_-[ D 9&-<E <KE ^3K:L/FK4\>0#4 'ZP:$ , ,&9. )#KK9/ N#KK4.)3KK ?KK
(114) 3KK- KKKKKKKKE R2 KKKKKKKK-C,KKKKKKKK-KKKKKKKK EKKKKKKKK i$#1. 1 Ki '#K4 ) *K+)3K FR/& <KEKK KKKK)2 1 KKi ,KK K KKUKKk KK"#& %2) KK9^#KK+KK- KKKK:# KK KK:&) *KK+KKE R2 KK-Ch#KK K=>K #K7/ &3%':'0# KK 2 KK & *KK KK S#KK+/ 9L KK-UKKk KK"#&…>KK?0 ' KK7v KK/B N#H KV K B ):'^ 9C,& 2+J $ Q &2C )2234 <"33&&C K")2K J23K+BK:'<") KP<: K,V#KKK",KKK<: KKK:<") KKKPz KKK",KKK%#KK95 Q KKKK- KKKK3:/ 1 HKKKK$1<K KKE%)3KKKKR Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3). !KKK&#?KKK KKKKKK-#aKKK/ 8KKK+$ KKK:' KKK/ KKK/51wKKK9&!KKK:E &2 HKKK1 D * &<E RH oKK 9WKK#/KK+:&QWKKi'KKE>KK KK
(115) KKKK/3 ^ KKL KKQ </&2 KK5C QK-,&KKE R%) *K+ -. K/01234 - KKKFKKK#<KKE 2 KKK KKK /01 KKK4 i$#K1FK3 -{#7B1%2) 9^#+ D<3KKKK:' KK&2 HKK1!KK &#?KK KK 3KKKK$!KK ' KK7QKK&>KK0FKK5 D 9:<E ,&%) *+ ,? jE2 H1 KKKK#dJXKKKaKKKK#KKK[WKKKKi&>KKK < KE#Ka$,K_K:R/$ K")2o,Q3iB 0 KKK_KKK B KKK KKKKKK)2)3KKK[ !KKK KK&:KK3KK:#KK-%KK&"KK:# )3[Q3iB 0)3[Q) 9':' :? %#& KKKa KKK:L,K K,KKK? N#HKKK <K K D ) *+ K#dJ# B,#[Wi& /5 )3KKL,KK-KK: KKi$ KK0) 9' -Q3iB KK0 n HKKKKK/KKKKK ,KKKK-Je#KKKKK#KKKKK[<KKKKE !KQ3iB 0z#dQ oDJ #9?i$#1 ,K'#K9$_K? 2 #Ki K&" &#[B #d.& KKmKK0KK-#a%) *KK+:%KK&"KK3i0KKm 8KKKKKKA=>KKK0t]) *KKK<E KKK KKK9 k - KK K&#?E)>" k,?+ Dz3O3w/")2G7-,?$!,? ,KKK',KKK+/Q}KKKEFKKK- /HKKKKKK:' K R) 3[!0)-Q3:R/& ) *+)3 KK&:KK R/ KK:#KK- %KK&"KK:#<KKE 2 KK/'1 %KK&i KK R/!KK <' KK/i,KKC KKKK/ KKKK/i/KKKK:# <K KK0 2 KKKK9/. k - iKKQ3KK:R/&!0)KK-V16KK0D)3KK+ %3KKK!:KKKKKK:'! 73KKK/-, $#KKK$KKK'3 KKKE2 D 257.
(116) .3KK 723KK4KK#KK[B <B}KKEJ#KK %) KK9KK&+$ KK ,KK '#KK4 ) *KK+)3KK K-#aK ):. g <E _O ] tKK:? i$#KK1 <KE_KK7(3$ KK ,KK KKK KKK%)2 2,KKK%2=) KKK9' KKK-#a%# KKK,KKK KKKLBV3KKKKKK0# %)3KKL KK0,KKDKK-#%# KK,KK- iKK D&2 /J3Qh3$F: F(<E9B. K ?K
(117) ,K ?K
(118) 1G)3+ -q WKK#UKKkKKB <B}KKE>KKD. ) *KK+,KKYK43-K&)>'K' E2 E2, LB M K_Ki$QWKi&)3 B\-0# J#KKK KKK B,KKKKKKB KKK/5 KKK B,KKK)3KKK * K&K0#K +=>K0ZPMK$V)#/ %#KKK KKK B\- KKK"33&& )#KKK9,KKK K KLB D</+! N#H KKKK0#iEKKKKN#HKKKKKKKK#d8KKKKB 5k}KKKKE KK-KK)3KK+KK#d8KKB 5k Q3iB KK0 KKKK:' aMKKKKB1Q1KKKKO#'1KKK#dC 5 3KK+>KK0KK:',#KKL,&>KK -KK-# KK N#K4.)3K J#K"]>K< R- L1 < KFK- <Ki /<E#/2 B1w+& D * &. Q3iB KKK0KKK#d8KKKB 5k KKK B,KKK/E K K$wK:L<P &) K$Q3B K5N#HK#?$ KK B,KK KKLB KK3KK)/ KK:L K 9J3KKn HKK/N#KK4 KK9 KKJ#KK . )#KKKK9 KKKKE28KKKK+$ & ) *KKKK KKKE KKK&2 N#HKQ1 +KOw9K /5 i$# .3KK 7_KK'#KK9&]>KK–KKKK&e)wKKE– ,K,KK3K EDJ#K *KF/+& E #K AK:'V *KK&1 ]#MK9N /"1 KE K:' KE .3KK:'.3/05\$ .3KC,K-K3&N#HQ!0C30&1 <E KKKKKKRIKKKKKK 12#KKKKKKi/KKKKKK7:P/FKKKKKK:/ KKK/ - EKKK.3KKK 7 j9$#KKK&>KKK]) *KKK+ 258. QC t<KK-#a{k3KK/KK/3'FKK- <KKE.KK; KP&) $ KB3B GK 1 K%', E KKO37, "#P$ /8^#+QC D 1 +F5<EF*E J# B,,? v /B, L /B=) 9' - ) *+)3Q}E )K:' ) *+,- $>P$J# =h#KKKK9&<KKKK2g KKKK_KKKK-P&) KKKK KKKK0)3L$ KmwK+Kh1 d#K
(119) _KQ K/5D_&)3& D_E0C134_$)2; K5#+^ LP<E h#-)3+Q 5k ss F9] ,&#MQ#,# C U>KKKEqsK K Q#KKKKKK&- KKK qrrq #9/9KKK K") P K%)2 2,K%2=) 9' FKK'37WKKB ",KKV3KK <KK.h\KKFKK#/ h#KK7& <K 2g KK<K EUKKk D 7*KKKK&3 ,KKKK B1KK:#/KK9d,KKKK- _KK$2+ <KKK. KKK[KKK ,KKK <KKK. KKK[FKKK?0 7HKK$,KKFKK5 'KK$8KK+$KKh\/,0#KK #9/9KKKK,KKKK#MKKKK']2 KKKK+KKKK RKKKK9L <KE&) *KK+KKE R2 KK-CKK:' / $ KK ?B D<. [ K4K:' Q3K?&Q,?/&1 )3+Q /5 jKKKE.h\KKKFKKK#<K KE jKKKE</ K K#j/KKK #KK9'%KK/KK:/'_K ? _KK< KKYKK(3: K/&K/0CoK,K d 3902 34T&) !K,K D]#MK9F' 7,'3 LB#9' +:LHKK KK3KK+>KK0KK:'I2#KK&KK3KK E )3KKK K K ? D<E KKKR FKKK' 7 Y KKKR J#KKK =) KK9' -N ~ J2)WKKB "_KK)3+ KKE KK7:P F( <E %)2 m,m%2 K/ E,&#K A,KGK?:'/3. [B.h\$ Q KKK/5DFKKK#/ KKK/"<KKKEQ#/KKKQKKK/ ,KKFKK#<KKE KK"#$h#KK-KK_KK$k)3KK+ K/ '&2 HKK F(<E T&) D'3 Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3).
(120) <KE_K"k /B_K–&e)wE- )3+. K) // <KEK&39 K<E <Bm#Z I) K wK+$Km3K0DT &) K#9'; DN32 _O#7$]> ]) *+ F' 7v /B,j/5QA_39Q}E!, K ' E2 &)>K' K73&QWi&1]) *+ KKKK "3<K KKE^#KKKKa KKKK $KKKK "3<K KKE V )2V KK9KK:' K ( 7 '#HKK! $ KK ,K? ]2 K/Y*K,' O 3 ) L 8KK-3 KK$k,KK KKLB)3KK+Q3KK?&QWKKi& ,K-Km2#Ki,K'# K9$ 0 & *K,K C Q3K?&QL&#
(121) U>5D& c G J# m 2 KK-C,KK'' 3 KK-KK0#KK:#/<KKE K B # 3KKKK #KK AI#KKLKK'2<K E'#HKK <'3 KK- KB # )3KK+ KK- LP-KK7:a8K B 5 & *KKKKKK&+$KKK:'J3KKK KKKBh3$#KKKKKK+_K#E3K$QL&#K
(122) D_Ki B _$ & c )3+ KKK) KKK:' FKKK' 7]3KKK)3KKK+v#KKK
(123) </KKK# J3KKK/KKK:'w9KKK/<KK9)3KKK+ K3v3aKOFK$1 | L&#
(124) # ]#?7 Q39 L! ED,&#?7/WP,/#:' D#H)>'G#H2 "_BCt)3+ {k3KK/BJ#KK+$ KK ,KK#HKK2 KK "3KK0 KKK5XIPKKK1!KKK '#MKKKKKK4 / p+&]>#H2 "30 DI) Q#/ 43HKKKP % KKK/KKK&#+ K K,KKK' KKKaFKKK- <K KE KKK1KKKd3KKK / <K KK KKKKd#3/&&3KKKK,KKKKC.KKKK D-#a%# ,)3+Q3' -p+& KKK8KKKB 5k)3+ KKK- wKKK+&1.KKKQ}KKKE - &KK-)3KK+KKE Q}KKEJ#KK %) KK9-D%23KK7 1 KK& a5K.3K 7,KwK:L$QWi& )>KK'1 .KK13KK0.KK,KK/Q3KK?& D&) *+ >%V#-,'N E. Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3). 34 23KKK " #KKK9PKKK KKK +V3KKKOKKK:' E R)3%)2<E<;<-#WB i I#KK'1V3KKOKK:' _KK3<KKE#/{ KKB1 <KKKK/3:KKE R &KK+%)3KKL KK+K- K>K4 _#-<;! _"3$ I#K'1V3KOK:' #9/9,#M']2 + <E KKKKKRFKKKKK/:i$#KKKKK!/HKKKKK$%)#*KKKKKIKKK0GKKK?$ _KKK0 i$^#KKKa<KKKE<KKK; ! K,K- KV K-%2 K';]) *N#M F9KKK,KKK' )3HKKK$.KKK$ ^#KKKa<KKK; Q#<EE R &+:<;! "3 <. [Z H F(<E ,&#M3 D! z#KKKd<KKK?/& w9KKK KKKFKKK5V3KKKOKKK:' KKKKKKKK-#'KKKK&e)2 KKKK-C KKKK #KKKK4 ZP:KK$<E KKR Q KK)3KK+,KK'i$#KK <$A 5. :L/-. ]2 K+K- K 1"!/3 1"Q -<3KK:' K5!K-87MK5#9/9K,K#M' #HK'<E,/:/h_8:4 w/',' 3KK+BKK:' KK?&#CKK/ #HKK'KK/3 #KK
(125) 6,KK'oKK+9:KK KK" +_KK8+KKO KKX B1 3KK'2FKK- <KKEKK /KKB // KKK3KKK/"#9%2 KKK
(126) #KKKB!KKK DO&#Ln H:' ( 7 KK- KK#HKK'<KKEKK;Je#KKKK:'Q -KK/3#HKK'KK–#9/9KK,KK#MKK']2 KK+ _KKKKE KKKK /_KKKKE GKKKK KKKKO|*KKKK&#E QWKi&<K K:L/!K0,KFKD5#+ <:& $ "#PJe#=>0F?M$!?+$ K?E1 K3+)| KK/3) 9'Wi&1 S ,KKK#MKKK']2 KKK+T&) KKK$FKKKiB1 WKKKi& _KKK Q Q3KKKK/ / KKKKB\- KKKK5)2;) KKKK#9/9KKKK 259.
(127) N EKKKFKKK72)YKKK3<KKKE%KKK+/ KKK&13 <'E /0 7 $ +:LH $ 5))#+B F- <EDDQ ) /1 / #&#+ DD KK:C .KK #KK A ^ KK0); QA KK <E KR]) *K+K9 -. /01FHE.'Wi& 1 oKK+-tJ3KKKQh3KKK$ KKK2 KKK-C,KKK' &) *KKK+N#HKKK KKKE2 13KKK<KKKEg#KKKaB GK? + HJ3 Bh3$ E2, B Dn+4 K5\$KCh! h,- /iBQ QA! K<KEKC KO_K:'+O :' )3K , >K,3 7/,-S 9
(128) 1U7B Q #E3KKKB ) *KK+N#KKK4 ) *KK+ <+K4)3KV#K";Khv#M n*$ QCt &) *K '#4hX$<I#[2+B 1 -Q KKK&2C U>KKK5– ) *KKK+,KKK-IKKK 1 DN#H_$k<E3& F'37-^. %X" K'%)2 K#Kc K3?+![K9$o D 7-- i1,' #KKKK9'9MKKKKKKKKB/ 5) MKKKK/=>KKKK0Q #HK' 0#E3&< - i&;!0,|< | 2+ &KK+$KK "3<KKE .KK;,/:KK/:KK/3 )Ki&_KB1D^ K0);K:'K?&#C^#+ &KK-Q3K?$Q,K?/&1 5) MKK/=>K0Q 3K FK5 <KE-3:L/&)>i #a,' 5 % K+![K$<K &#M&)3 3KK+KK:' KK' /"1&2 HKK1 KK KKK' /"1KKKKKKd#3/&wKKK+&]>KKK - i1)34F/?$> ' &2 H1/ ! KK'YKK?&,KK<KKKK") P &KK+:KK:' 7 D "3,',/:/.; Z HP -". ,KKwKK:L$1KK;KK&e#8KKB 5k 1 I) KK$ KKa,KK,KK?N#KK4KKa KKKKKK:'.3KKK$,KKK?jKKK/$3KKK+BKKK$ %3KK'2KK; KK#8KKB 5k N3KK *K& K B1 K E) K9"1=#51 ,/ : D' E2 &#	$ &)>'8. K&e)#K4 'FKR/$ /B - #4 Q wKKK+$,KKKKKK&e)<KKK0D : KKK
(129) KKKKKK&#?E .3K$&e)<0 /B jE/)3? GKKK2#KKK7Q KKKB;3KKK/-I#KKK'1KKK:' #KKKR&w- KKKFKKK:+Q KKK5k}KKKE!KKK,KKK 1 ,0#KKKKC KKQ KK5k}KKEDj K E KK3?+ ,KK 3'KKJXKKa 3KK. 7KK1 KK' &K+:K:' EK3?/K) - ih#7& Q K&2C)3K ]) *K+ <E R)3+F" J#KK )2 HKKS KK0Q}KKE KKC KK "3$<KK *K&3 E ^#a <E RQ :H5 2#KK7,KKVKK-t9iKK/KK5#+ KKB ?; ,KKKK'% KKKK KKKK#dCB KKKKKKKK9&1 <KE<BK/ K/i/J3 %#C2 DQ &2CN#4 ]) *+ <E RN#H K3 02K#K9' - /E : $ :E ?$ KK; KK KK'KK:'G?KK$<KK #MKK-#aJ3K K</ K', *$3+B KK iKK' KK:'G?KK$ KK)KK-^#a KKKKK/3:%2 *KKK/ Q KKKB;g3KKK+%#KKK4 / D%&i B d /:/ 5) MKKKQ^ KKK0);KKKOKKK?&#C^#KKK+: uKK-KK:'KK5\:KK& KK/BFKK:+Q. KK5# KK6 KK02#KKE–,/:KK/ <0)3C FKK",KK ' KK7=>KK0<KKE-KKBKK' /" FK7$F9!0,3 % /&#+ <E K)3 3Q X&X$ B,! KKK'_KKK"3$<KKKKKK/ &KKK+:- iKKK1 ]) *K+I) K:9K_:i$, *v#M ,&#MKKKK3Q#KK<KKE,/:KK/.KK; ,KK?/9KKQ3KK?&Q_KK-J\KK$!KK,KK <KK+ 260. Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3).
(130) % KKKQ3KKK?&Q#KKK mI#KKKdKKK:'I#KKKL<E KKK K $1K "3<KE#K	N E)>' K $k K-)<KEV3K,/:/.%2/ D ") . #KKKK?7h3KKKK).KKKK& J#KKKK KKKK B,KKKK9 3: ? #d#4 /<; !KKKK;!KK,KK-KK-) /,KK/E<E KKR KKKE R 11KKK,KKK'KKK&e#!&KKK$KKKKKK-#a FK:+$K ,0#< 0) d<E%#4 / KK Q KK&2C)2KK&3 KK/3,KK-KK ,/:KKK/:53:KKKKKKE R2 KKK-C<KKKEoKKK+9 KK- KKKK/3 d3aKKOFKK(<KKE KK:1 <KKKEQ KKKB;g3KKK ,KKK'o&KKK+KKK KKK+ KKKDg 3KKK2#KKKiGKKK )#*KKK5.KKK; ,K-K!K,KK/3K/ ,-X/ D/3.;. GK KR/F9KK:'{k K/B18=>0 KKK:'{k KKK/B ]#KKK[B<KKKE <KKK$<KKK0#HKKK+ <E KKKR)>KKK'1 GKKKKKKE R%)2 KKK9/ KKK-#' K K&e)c KKK43KKK+B.KKK: EKKK${k KKK/B J3K/K:'c HK=>K0<ES) M$ D</ KKhS KK0QKK:'Q3KK7& KK/iQ KK5k}KKE KKK1nKKKO<E KKK–<KKK/KKK- kKKK/ ' )2 KK.KK;Q}KKE. )3KK[/KK"#W"3K& ]) Ki &e#,$<E!0 $&e).&Q:' KK:1N KKO 3KKKK4 ! KK: c KK4 D! <E/:/ #KKc^ KKLPKK" <KKE,KK+B %#KK %) KK9^ KKLPKK" <KKE,KK+B <' KKE2#KKc ])>KK' HKKKKKK H KKKKKK; >KKKKKK,KKKKKKwKKKKKK:L& Qh3KwK+&Uk# A= i$%)2 9/- D:' 7 30]>&e#<E KKKE .KKKKKKE !0 KKK78KKKB 5k <KKE KK$!KK&#KK A 3KK9KKE n KK Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3). <K;z#KLQ}KEE R )3+FE + k #6KK' KKE#K O Q3KK?&QWKKi& KK 2K$^#Ka.K; )3K KB8B 5 B3/*KK" )3K 3K d K$g$<E %#KKO KK;KK&e# Q3KK?$QWKKiEKK
(131) DTDDDDDk k%#6:' E jKLP$K'KE R%)2 9/ ^3:L/Qk <KKKE<KKK;<E KKKRFKKK/:i$#KKKKKK&e) KKO,KK'KK:5KK&e),KK KKLBUKKk^#KKa #K A.3Ki0<KEJ#K 2 K-,K- <E KR9 <KKE<KK; <E KKRKK9 KKO,KK' KK0 i$ K9>K ED< K;]) *+`3 N#M KLGK- ; -<;<E R &2 HKK1 KK J #KK C2 KK-C -:HKK KK; KKF5 MKKQ}KKEU>KK5D&#?KK 23K KB ?,K'FHK7$ KL$1E R /:K/ K i%#HK<K;<E KRF/ D^#a E R,'^#a<E i$#KKKK1KKKK&e#Q}KKKKE J#KKKK %) KKKK9<KK9$GKK%KK',KKwKK:L$QWKKi&KK-3:L/ )3KKS KK0GKK:EDJ #KK CGKKCuKK-KK:' KK&2 /KK ,KKV KK75#KKc,KK-<KK<E KK FKK+=2#KK7/-F9KKGKK_KK$k<KKE)3KK+Q KK/5 D_&# A :5 M .KKKK;LKKK,KKKK KKKLB E UKKKKk KKK Q}KE]) *K+I) K,K'_K&e),K KLB KKK&i:F9KKKFKKKR/&]) *KKK+I) KKK>KKK0 #KKKK?75) MKKKK/KKKK B,KKKK &KKKK]) *KKKK+ ,/ ]) *+&i:/'<E<; DJ# B %#LKK 2%)3KKL S)2,KK!c# KK9E ^) KKKKiQ1 QAKKKKE R KKKK KKKK/ ' KK7$ *K &S KK0QKK56$ KK /"KKP&) ,KKKK-S KKKK?1wKKKK+$KKKK 2 0- KKKKB-KKKKE <KKKE KKK/ 2Q3KKK?&1S KKK?1>KKK0D ) *KKK+ - KKK&2 7*KKK– %) *KKK+KKK+EDKKK= KKKi$ 261.
(132) J3C ) *+:' 0) mS#$Q 0)/#& KKK/-– KK; $) *KKK8KKB 5kD KK&2 h K K_KKKB1QA8KKK"#$KKKKKK&2 /J3KKK 3KK0KK&3#KKR5KK/0#KKR5#KK m_KK"KK:/: ,KD,/ K:_ K).K;<KE!3[ 3/:KKn9HKK&Q,KK?/&YKK5!KK 7BQ,KK?/& KK0 <KKKE.KKKKKK4)^#KKKa3/:KKK#KKKi / 2 K <- KB;S K?1>K0 K ,K^#a <E<;<E RF/i$#Q}E!, W"3& N3B,2 "<0_0 i$^#a D%B /F9F5 )2 H/. KK KKKK/3 7LHKK23KK/+KK&2 BD2 -s .3KK:KK/3)#KK+ z KK7KK9',&KKYK D2 <KE Dsxx %#0 " .3:! . ") P &+ 7LH 23/+ &2 B D2 /' D; i L-) <E <; ! : ,&#MQ#& B <E ;! &+$N#M D CFH7 sxxx 5#MKKK:E KKKRKKK9 7LHKKK23KKK/+KKK&2 B D2 -q {#KKKE#KKKL-Q /KKK D2 <K KE LKKK3/KKK-)C KLKEK/:; K9$#F9%B /')#+ KKK <KKK-#,d3KKKKKK:' KKK0#\$jKKKCg#MKKK Dsxx %#0 -# )p3+9. K") P &+ 7LH23/+&2 B D2 -3 KKO <B KKR FHKK7 w- KK KK"#… < KK;! KK: K& B<KE <-#a<i$#1#?7<E ,/:/.; KK ) *KK+.KK4 KK#d,KK ,&#MKKQ#KK D.E# ;& #d KKKKK<E KKKKKRQ KKKKK 7LHKKKKK23KKKKK/+KKKKK&2 B D2 -4 #MKKK']2 KK+#/$6KK/ KK/' <KKE KK-#a KK6/. 262. 3KKK+B Q3KKK'8KKK+$KKK;Q3MKKK:KKK:'CGKKK:i/: Dsxxx _B3& <]) *N#M. <E KKRFKK/i$#KK 7LHKK23KK/+KK&2 B D2 -5 V#KKK9 N KKK/"KKK.KKKoKKK+-^#KKKa<KKKE<KKK; Dqrrr _3&,#-<E 3?&;. KK:' ) *KK+)3KK 7LHKK23KK/+KK&2 B D2 -6 %KKB KK/'^ KK5 <K E KK0#KK KKV3KKO qrrqssqy-qq ) *K+)3F Y5 wMK2 B#&;;&)3 /i:E R&) M/ Dqsr-s qrrs. &) *K+KE R2 K-C 7LH 23/+&2 B D2 -7 )3KKKF9KKK#9/9KKK,KKK #MKKK']2 KKK+pKKKKKKE J2 +- ) *+ )3F9%BE ) *+ K;&)3 /i:E R&) M/ #9/9,#M' Dqrry#& & wM2 B#&; &) *KKKK+ &KKK+ 7LHKKK23KKK/+KKK&2 B D2 -8 _KK3,KK KKP2KK <KE <KK;! KK:KK") P qrrr Q#KKKKKKEKKKC Q3KKK'8KKK+$! KKK<KKE<KK KKK KKK):%) *KKK+XKKK5# 2 KKK^ KKK? Dqrry %#0 . K?&#C K )#K+ 7LHK23/+&2 B D2 -9 &) *KK+ KKE R2 KK-C,KK- , /:KK/.KK;= KKi$ )3Kf B#- #O +::D i$#12 -C,- KKK:5 ) *KKK+)3KKKf KKKB#- s !KKK) ) *KKK+ Dqrrq#-35 %#0 " .3:2 H1. Q)#KKK+ KKK&h3KKK-KKK'D2 7LHKKKKKK&2 B D2 -10 )3Kf B#-D. ) *+)3<E-#c-#' - L Dqrr %#0 .)2 2 HC:5 ) *+ .3KK 7,KK^#KK1 ?KK
(133) 7LHKKKK&2 B D2 -11 oK R2K ! K<KE< 3 . ) *+)3 D.qrry 0sq ):%) *+X5#. KE R2 K-CK/3 &K+$ 7LHKK&2 B D2 -12 ,76'3/i <E &e) /&) *+ Dqrr wM2 <-##?7)2 .;F9. Journal of Islamic Research 2007;20(3).
(134)
Benzer Belgeler
Büyük b ir tesadüf eseri olarak Yirmisekiz Mehmet Çelebinin oğlu Sait efendi 1741 senesinde Sait Paşa olarak Paris'e elçi gönderildi.. O da büyük tablolara
Hatta, bütün bu yaşama ge zisinden sonra, uzayın bile, bu kitabın söylemek iste diği ‘sığmama’nın azıcığı kaldığını açıkladık.. Kitabın son
politikacıların Nâzım Hik met konusunu kullandıklarını vur gularken “ Ellerini çeksinler artık Nâzım ’dan” diye konuştu.. Şair Hü seyin Atabaş,
TNDer Spinal ve Periferik Sinir Cerrahisi Öğretim ve Eğitim Grubu Yönetim Kurulu Başkan : Serkan Şimşek. Başkan : Ali Dalgıç Sekreter : Mesut Yılmaz Üyeler :
Periferik sinir stimülasyon ya da lezyonları, Spinal kord stimülasyon ya da ablatif cerrahileri, derin beyin stimülasyon ya da lezyon cerrahileri dirençli ağrı olgularında
View of The Analysis of the Primary School Mathematics Exam Questions According to the MATH Taxonomy
2011-2012 eğitim-öğretim yılı güz ve bahar dönemlerinde bu ildeki ilköğretim okullarında uygulanmış olan matematik dersi sınav sorularının ait olduğu
Dengesizliğin konum ve miktarının belirlenebilmesi için geliĢtirilen metotlar açıklanmıĢ dengesizliğin açısal konumunun belirlenmesi için kullanılacak olan
Zemin yapı etkileşimi konusunda hazırlanan bu tez çalışmasında birçok sayısal örnek verilerek gerçekçi sonuçlar elde edilmeye çalışılmıştır. Tarafımızca yapılan
