Teorik 5. Do ğ al seçilimin gücü

5. Do

ğal seçilimin gücü

Teorik

5. Do

ğal seçilimin gücü

Uygulama

  ɪ•‡–—’‰‡‘–›’‡…‘—–• ƒʳŞ…ſɫɯřɩɯřɫƀɪƒ‡”‹…ƒ• †ʳŞ…ſɥřɪřɮɮƀɪ†”—œ‡ ɪ‰‡––Š‡—„‡”‘ˆ’‡‘’Ž‡•ƒ’Ž‡†ſ•ƒ‡ˆ‘”„‘–Šƀ ʳŞ•—ſƒƀ ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡–Š‡ˆ”‡“—‡…›‘ˆ–Š‡ƒŽŽ‡Ž‡Ş‘”’ ɪˆ‘”ƒ‡”‹…ƒ• ’ɏƒʳŞſſƒƃɨƄƋɩƀʫƒƃɩƄƀŵſɩƋƀ ɪˆ‘”†”—œ‡ ’ɏ†ʳŞſſ†ƃɨƄƋɩƀʫ†ƃɩƄƀŵſɩƋƀ ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‹‰–Š‡ˆ”‡“—‡…›‘ˆſ‘”“ƀ‹•–Š‡–”‹˜‹ƒŽ “ɏƒʳŞɨŞ’ɏƒ “ɏ†ʳŞɨŞ’ɏ† 1H[WZHFDQFDOFXODWHWKHDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHVIRUWKHPHWDSRSXODWඈRQඈH$PHUඈFDQVRI(XURSHDQGHVFHQWDQG'UX]HFRQVඈGHUHGDVDVඈQJOH SRSXODWඈRQ7KඈVඈVDVVඈPSOHDVWDNඈQJWKHPHDQRIWKHWZRDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHV ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡–‘–ƒŽƒŽŽ‡Ž‡ˆ”‡“—‡…› ’ɏ–ʳŞſ’ɏƒʫ’ɏ†ƀŵɩ “ɏ–ʳŞɨŞ’ɏ– :ඈWKWKHVHDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHVFDOFXODWHGZHFDQYHU\HDVඈO\FDOFXODWHH[SHFWHGKHWHUR]\JRVඈWඈHVUHPHPEHUWKඈVඈVMXVW  ɪˆ‹”•–…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡‡š’‡…–‡†Š‡–‡”‘œ›‰‘•‹–›ˆ‘”–Š‡–™‘’‘’—Žƒ–‹‘• ɪƒ‡”‹…ƒ• Š•ɏƒʳŞɩƋ’ɏƒƋ“ɏƒ ɪ†”—œ‡ Š•ɏ†ʳŞɩƋ’ɏ†Ƌ“ɏ† ɪ–Š‡–ƒ‡–Š‡‡ƒ‘ˆ–Š‹• Š•ʳŞſŠ•ɏƒʫŠ•ɏ†ƀŵɩ ɪ‡š–…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡‡š’‡…–‡†Š‡–‡”‘œ›‰‘•‹–›ˆ‘”–Š‡‡–ƒ’‘’—Žƒ–‹‘• Š–ʳŞɩƋ’ɏ–Ƌ“ɏ– :ඈWKDOOWKHUHOHYDQWH[SHFWHGKHWHUR]\JRVඈWඈHVඈQSODFHZHDUHQRZUHDG\WRFDOFXODWH) ZKඈFKZHFDQGROඈNHVR ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡ˆ•– ˆ•–ʳŞſŠ–ŞŠ•ƀŵŠ– ,I\RXUFDOFXODWඈRQVZHUHFRUUHFWWKHQ\RXVKRXOGKDYHDQ) HVWඈPDWHRIWKඈVඈVYHU\KඈJKIRUEHWZHHQWZRKXPDQSRSXODWඈRQV2QHZD\WR ඈQWHUSUHWWKH) YDOXHZHKDYHKHUHඈVWKDWRIJHQHWඈFYDUඈDQFHZHREVHUYHGඈIIHUVEHWZHHQSRSXODWඈRQV6ඈQFHSRSXODWඈRQFDQH[SODඈQVXFK DODUJHGඈIIHUHQFHඈQWKඈVFDVHZHPඈJKWH[SHFWVHOHFWඈRQWREHUHVSRQVඈEOH«

:UඈWඈQJDVHWRI) IXQFWඈRQV

7KHFRGHඈQWKHSUHYඈRXVVHFWඈRQZDVXVHIXOWRGHPRQVWUDWHKRZZHFDQFDOFXODWH) EXWඈWZRXOGEHDORWRIZRUNWRUXQWKURXJKWKඈVHYHU\ VඈQJOHWඈPHZHZDQWHVWඈPDWHWKHVWDWඈVWඈFIRUDORFXV7KඈVEHඈQJ5ZHFDQRIFRXUVHHDVඈO\FUHDWHDIXQFWඈRQWKDWZඈOOGRDOORIWKHOHJZRUNIRUXV :HZඈOOWDNHWKHFRGHZHZURWHRXWඈQWKHODVWVHFWඈRQDQGXVHඈWKHUHWRZUඈWHWZRIXQFWඈRQVWKDWZHFDQXVHZKHQZHZDQWWRFDOFXODWH) 1RWH WKDWIRUVඈPSOඈFඈW\ZHZඈOORQO\ZUඈWHIXQFWඈRQVWKDWZRUNIRUWZRSRSXODWඈRQV )ඈUVWZHZඈOOZUඈWHDIXQFWඈRQFDOOHG…ƒŽ…ɏƒˆZKඈFKZඈOOWDNHJHQRW\SHFRXQWVIURPWZRSRSXODWඈRQVDQGFDOFXODWHDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHV7KHIXQFWඈRQ DOVRDOORZVIRUVDPSOHVඈ]HVWRYDU\EHWZHHQWKHWZRSRSXODWඈRQV ɪƒ•‹’Ž‡ˆ—…–‹‘–‘…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡ƒŽŽ‡Ž‡ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡•‹–™‘’‘’—Žƒ–‹‘• …ƒŽ…ɏƒˆʳވ—…–‹‘ſ’‘’ɨř’‘’ɩƀƇ ɪ‰‡––Š‡—„‡”‘ˆ•ƒ’Ž‡• ɏɨʳŞ•—ſ’‘’ɨƀ ɏɩʳŞ•—ſ’‘’ɩƀ ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡ˆ”‡“—‡…›‘ˆɮ•–ƒŽŽ‡Ž‡Ş’ ɪˆ‘”’‘’ɮ ’ɏɨʳŞſſ’‘’ɨƃɨƄƋɩƀʫ’‘’ɨƃɩƄƀŵſɩƋɏɨƀ ɪˆ‘”’‘’ɯ ’ɏɩʳŞſſ’‘’ɩƃɨƄƋɩƀʫ’‘’ɩƃɩƄƀŵſɩƋɏɩƀ ”‡–—”ſ…ſ’ɏɨř’ɏɩƀƀ ƈ 6ඈQFHඈWඈVYHU\VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGIRUXVHWRFDOFXODWHWKHIUHTXHQF\RIWKHVHFRQGDOOHOHRQFHZHKDYHWKHIUHTXHQF\RIWKHIඈUVWඈH RXU …ƒŽ…ɏƒˆ IXQFWRQZOORQO\FDOFXODWH IRUERWKSRSXODWRQV/HW¶VWHVWWRQWKHGDWDIURPRXUSUHYRXVH[DPSOH

,-67 67 67

67

67 67

-   Ã ,

,

  ɪ–‡•–‹‰‘—”ˆ—…–‹‘‘–Š‡ƒ‡”‹…ƒŵ†”—œ‡‡šƒ’Ž‡ ƒˆ•ʳŞ…ƒŽ…ɏƒˆſ’‘’ɨʰ…ſɫɯřɩɯřɫƀř’‘’ɩʰ…ſɥřɪřɮɮƀƀ 6RQRZWKDWZHKDYHDIXQFWඈRQWKDWFDOFXODWHVDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHVඈQWKHWZRSRSXODWඈRQVZHFDQZUඈWHRXU…ƒŽ…ɏˆ•–IXQFWඈRQWRWDNHWKHVH IUHTXHQFඈHVDQGFDOFXODWH) IURPWKHP ɪƒˆ—…–‹‘–‘…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡ˆ•– …ƒŽ…ɏˆ•–ʳވ—…–‹‘ſ’ɏɨř’ɏɩƀƇ ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡“ɮƒ†“ɯ “ɏɨʳŞɨŞ’ɏɨ “ɏɩʳŞɨŞ’ɏɩ ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡–‘–ƒŽƒŽŽ‡Ž‡ˆ”‡“—‡…› ’ɏ–ʳŞſ’ɏɨʫ’ɏɩƀŵɩ “ɏ–ʳŞɨŞ’ɏ– ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡‡š’‡…–‡†Š‡–‡”‘œ›‰‘•‹–› ɪˆ‹”•–…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡‡š’‡…–‡†Š‡–‡”‘œ›‰‘•‹–›ˆ‘”–Š‡–™‘’‘’—Žƒ–‹‘• ɪ’‘’ɮ Š•ɏɨʳŞɩƋ’ɏɨƋ“ɏɨ ɪ’‘’ɯ Š•ɏɩʳŞɩƋ’ɏɩƋ“ɏɩ ɪ–Š‡–ƒ‡–Š‡‡ƒ‘ˆ–Š‹• Š•ʳŞſŠ•ɏɨʫŠ•ɏɩƀŵɩ ɪ‡š–…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡‡š’‡…–‡†Š‡–‡”‘œ›‰‘•‹–›ˆ‘”–Š‡‡–ƒ’‘’—Žƒ–‹‘• Š–ʳŞɩƋ’ɏ–Ƌ“ɏ– ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡ˆ•– ˆ•–ʳŞſŠ–ŞŠ•ƀŵŠ– ɪ”‡–—”‘—–’—– ”‡–—”ſˆ•–ƀ ƈ /HW¶VWHVWRXUIXQFWඈRQRQWKHDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHVZHFDOFXODWHGZඈWKRXU…ƒŽ…ɏƒˆIXQFWඈRQ ɪ–‡•–‹‰‘—”ˆ—…–‹‘‘–Š‡ƒ‡”‹…ƒŵ†”—œ‡‡šƒ’Ž‡ …ƒŽ…ɏˆ•–ſƒˆ•ƃɨƄřƒˆ•ƃɩƄƀ 7KඈVVKRXOGEHWKHVDPHDV\RXJRWEHIRUHEXWZඈWKDORWOHVVZRUN1H[WZH¶OOORRNDWDSSO\ඈQJDIXQFWඈRQWRDEඈJJHUGDWDVHW

$SSO\ඈQJIXQFWඈRQVWRPDWUඈFHVDQGGDWDIUDPHV

([WHQGඈQJRXU/&7DQGODFWDVHSHUVඈVWHQFHH[DPSOHOHW¶VJHWVRPHGDWDIURPPXOWඈSOHKXPDQSRSXODWඈRQV<RXFDQGRZQORDGWKHGDWDKHUH KWWSVHYROXWඈRQDU\JHQHWඈFVJඈWKXEඈROFWBFRXQWWVY Ž…–ɏ…‘—–•ʳŞ”‡ƒ†ɏ†‡Ž‹ſɑŜŵŽ…–ɏ…‘—–Ŝ–•˜ɑř†‡Ž‹ʰɑɎ–ɑƀ <RXVKRXOGQRZKDYHDWඈEEOHඈQ\RXU5HQYඈURQPHQWZඈWKDOOHOHFRXQWVIRUWKH613UVIRUSRSXODWඈRQV$JDඈQWKHVHGDWDDUHDOOIURP %HUVDJOඈHUඈHWDOKWWSVZZZVFඈHQFHGඈUHFWFRPVFඈHQFHDUWඈFOHSඈඈ6 :KDWZHKDYHඈVWKHFRXQWVRIDOOOHOHVEXWZKDWZHDFWXDOO\ZDQWඈVWKHDOOHOHIUHTXHQF\IRU7WKDWඈVKRZZHFDQFDOFXODWH) +RZHYHUDV\RX ZඈOOUHFDOORXU…ƒŽ…ɏƒˆIXQFWඈRQWDNHVWKHඈQSXWIRU7:2SRSXODWඈRQV&DOFXODWඈQJIUHTXHQFඈHVඈVSUHWW\VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGVROHW¶VVඈPSOඈI\RXU IXQFWඈRQZHZඈOOFDOOඈW…ƒŽ…ɏƒˆɏ•‹’Ž‡ …ƒŽ…ɏƒˆɏ•‹’Ž‡ʳވ—…–‹‘ſ…‘—–•ƀƇ ɪ‰‡––Š‡—„‡”‘ˆ•ƒ’Ž‡• ʳŞ•—ſ…‘—–•ƀ ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡ˆ”‡“—‡…›‘ˆɮ•–ƒŽŽ‡Ž‡Ş’ ɪˆ‘”’‘’ɮ ’ʳŞſſ…‘—–•ƃɨƄƋɩƀʫ…‘—–•ƃɩƄƀŵſɩƋƀ ”‡–—”ſ’ƀ ƈ /HW¶VWU\WKඈVIXQFWඈRQRXWRQFRXQWVIRUDVඈQJOHSRSXODWඈRQ:HXVHඈQGH[ඈQJKHUHWRVHOHFWWKHIඈUVWURZDQGRQO\FROXPQVVඈQFHRXUIXQFWඈRQ ඈVRQO\H[SHFWඈQJWKHFRXQWGDWDQRWWKHSRSXODWඈRQQDPH …ƒŽ…ɏƒˆɏ•‹’Ž‡ſŽ…–ɏ…‘—–•ƃɨřɩśɫƄƀ 67 67

  *UHDW6RWKඈVZRUNVZHOO1RZOHW¶VJHW WKHIUHTXHQF\RIWKH7DOOHOHIRUDOOWKHSRSXODWඈRQV:HFDQGRWKඈVH[WUHPHO\IDVWDQGHDVඈO\XVඈQJ ƒ’’Ž› ɪ™‡…ƒ™”‹–‡‹––Š‹•™ƒ› ’ʳŞ•‡Ž‡…–ſŽ…–ɏ…‘—–•řŞ’‘’ƀʩʴʩƒ’’Ž›ſɨř…ƒŽ…ɏƒˆɏ•‹’Ž‡ƀ ɪ‘”–Š‹•™ƒ› ’ʳރ’’Ž›ſ•‡Ž‡…–ſŽ…–ɏ…‘—–•řŞ’‘’ƀřɨř…ƒŽ…ɏƒˆɏ•‹’Ž‡ƀ ƒ’’Ž›ඈVDVඈPඈODUIXQFWඈRQWR•ƒ’’Ž›H[FHSWඈWZRUNVRQPDWUඈFHVRUGDWDIUDPHV$OOඈWWDNHVWKUHHDUJXPHQWVWKHREMHFW ඈHPDWUඈ[GDWDIUDPHZKඈFK\RXZDQWWRDSSO\ඈWWRWKHඈQGH[\RXDSSO\ඈWRYHUDQGIඈQDOO\WKHIXQFWඈRQ\RXDUHDSSO\ඈQJ,QWKHWZRH[DPSOHVRI KRZWRZUඈWHDQƒ’’Ž›FRPPDQGDERYHZHIඈUVWUHPRYHGWKH’‘’FRPPDQGZඈWK•‡Ž‡…–DQGZHWKHQXVHGɨWRGHQRWHZHDUHRSHUDWඈQJRYHU

WKHURZVRIWKHGDWDIUDPH)ඈQDOO\ZHVSHFඈI\WKDWIRUHDFKURZZHZඈOOXVHRXU…ƒŽ…ɏƒˆɏ•‹’Ž‡IXQFWඈRQ

:HFDQQRZFRPEඈQHRXUYHFWRURIDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHVZඈWKWKHSRSXODWඈRQQDPHVWRFUHDWHDGDWDIUDPHRIIUHTXHQFඈHV/ඈNHVR

Ž…–ɏˆ”‡“ʳރ•Ŝ–‹„„Ž‡ſ†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡ſ’‘’ʰŽ…–ɏ…‘—–•ɛ’‘’ř’ƀƀ

ɤɤƒ”‹‰śļƒ•Ŝ–‹„„Ž‡ſƀļ‹•†‡’”‡…ƒ–‡†ř—•‡ļƒ•ɏ–‹„„Ž‡ſƀļſ„—–‹†–Š‡‡™•‡ƒ–‹…•ƀŜ ɤɤŠ‹•™ƒ”‹‰‹•†‹•’Žƒ›‡†‘…‡’‡”•‡••‹‘Ŝ

1RZZHFDQHDVඈO\FDOFXODWHDSDඈUZඈVH) ZඈWKRXU…ƒŽ…ɏˆ•–IXQFWඈRQ)RUH[DPSOHOHW¶VFDOFXODWH) IRU(XURSHDQ$PHUඈFDQVDQG(DVW

$VඈDQV:HZඈOOXVH†’Ž›”FRPPDQGVIRUWKඈV5HFDOOWKDWŶPHDQVRU

ɪ‡š–”ƒ…–ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡•

ƒˆ•ʳވ‹Ž–‡”ſŽ…–ɏˆ”‡“ř’‘’ʰʰɑ—”‘’‡ƒɏ‡”‹…ƒɑŶ’‘’ʰʰɑƒ•–ɏ•‹ƒɑƀʩʴʩ’—ŽŽſ’ƀ

ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡ˆ•–

…ƒŽ…ɏˆ•–ſƒˆ•ƃɨƄřƒˆ•ƃɩƄƀ

$OOWKH’—ŽŽIXQFWඈRQGRHVKHUHඈVUHWXUQRXU’FROXPQDVDYHFWRUZHFDQXVHඈQWKH…ƒŽ…ɏˆ•–IXQFWඈRQ$VZඈWKRXUSUHYඈRXVH[DPSOHZHFDQ

VHH)aa67ඈVDFWXDOO\SUHWW\KඈJKEHWZHHQWKHVHSRSXODWඈRQVIRUWKඈV613:KDWDERXWඈIZHFRPSDUHG(DVW$VඈDQVZඈWKWKH%HGRXඈQSHRSOHIURP ,VUDHO" ɪ‡š–”ƒ…–ˆ”‡“—‡…‹‡• ƒˆ•ʳވ‹Ž–‡”ſŽ…–ɏˆ”‡“ř’‘’ʰʰɑƒ•–ɏ•‹ƒɑŶ’‘’ʰʰɑ‡†‘—‹ɏ‡‰‡˜ɏ•”ƒ‡Žɑƀʩʴʩ’—ŽŽſ’ƀ ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡ˆ•– …ƒŽ…ɏˆ•–ſƒˆ•ƃɨƄřƒˆ•ƃɩƄƀ +HUHZHVHH) ඈVVXEVWDQWඈDOO\ORZHU$OOHOHIUHTXHQF\GඈIIHUHQFHVDUHORZHUEHWZHHQWKHVHSRSXODWඈRQV

9ඈVXDOඈVඈQJ) DORQJDFKURPRVRPH

1H[WZHZඈOOFRPEඈQHWKHVNඈOOVZHOHDUQHGZඈWKƒ’’Ž›DQGRXUFXVWRPIXQFWඈRQVWRFDOFXODWH) IRUDVHUඈHVRI613VඈQWKHYඈFඈQඈW\RIWKH/&7

JHQHRQFKURPRVRPH7KඈVඈVHVVHQWඈDOO\DJHQRPHVFDQDQDSSURDFKWKDWFDQEHXVHGWRGHWHFWVඈJQDWXUHVRIVHOHFWඈRQඈQWKHJHQRPH<RX FDQGRZQORDGWKHGDWDKHUHKWWSVHYROXWඈRQDU\JHQHWඈFVJඈWKXEඈR/&7BVQSVWVY )ඈUVWRIDOOZHZඈOOUHDGඈQWKHGDWD Ž…–ɏ•’•ʳŞ”‡ƒ†ɏ†‡Ž‹ſɑŜŵɏ•’•Ŝ–•˜ɑř†‡Ž‹ʰɑɎ–ɑƀ 7KඈVGDWDඈVDOVRIURPIURP%HUVDJOඈHUඈHWDOKWWSVZZZVFඈHQFHGඈUHFWFRPVFඈHQFHDUWඈFOHSඈඈ6,WඈVWKHDOOHOH IUHTXHQF\ඈQYDUඈRXVKXPDQSRSXODWඈRQVIRURQHDOOHOHDWDVHWRIEඈDOOHOඈF613PDUNHUVFORVHWRWKH/&7JHQHRQFKURPRVRPHඈQWKHKXPDQ JHQH(DFKURZඈVD613DQGWKHUHDUHWKUHHIUHTXHQFඈHVRQHIRU1RUWK$PHUඈFDQVRI(XURSHDQGHVFHQWRQHIRU$IUඈFDQ$PHUඈFDQVDQGRQHIRU (DVW$VඈDQV 6ඈQFHZHKDYHWKHDOOHOHIUHTXHQFඈHVZHFDQHDVඈO\FDOFXODWH) IRUHDFKRIWKHVH613V)RURXUH[DPSOHKHUHZHZඈOOGRWKඈVEHWZHHQ ‡—”‘’‡ƒɏƒ‡”‹…ƒ•DQG‡ƒ•–ɏƒ•‹ƒ•)ඈUVWRIDOOOHW¶VXVHRXU…ƒŽ…ɏˆ•–IXQFWඈRQRQMXVWDVඈQJOH613 …ƒŽ…ɏˆ•–ſŽ…–ɏ•’•ƃɨřɫƄřŽ…–ɏ•’•ƃɨřɭƄƀ +RZFDQZHVFDOHWKඈVXSFDOFXODWH) IRUDOOWKRVHORFඈUDSඈGO\":HFDQGRWKඈVඈQDVඈQJOHOඈQHRIFRGHXVඈQJDIXQFWඈRQFDOOHG’ƒ’ ɪ–‡•––Š‡…‘†‡ ’ƒ’ɏ†„ŽſŽ…–ɏ•’•řɌ…ƒŽ…ɏˆ•–ſŜŜɫřŜŜɭƀƀ ɪƒ‡ƒˆ•–…‘Ž— Ž…–ɏ•’•ɛˆ•–ʳŞ’ƒ’ɏ†„ŽſŽ…–ɏ•’•řɌ…ƒŽ…ɏˆ•–ſŜŜɫřŜŜɭƀƀ :KDWGඈGZHGRKHUH":HOO’ƒ’FDQEHDWUඈFN\IXQFWඈRQWRXQGHUVWDQGEXWඈQWKඈVH[DPSOHඈWඈVSUHWW\VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUG,WWDNHVPDඈQDUJXPHQWV WKHIඈUVWඈVRXUGDWDIUDPHŽ…–ɏ•’•WKHQZHXVHɌWRGHQRWHZHZDQWWRDSSO\DIXQFWඈRQWRWKHURZVRIWKඈVGDWDIUDPH)ඈQDOO\ZHXVHRXU …ƒŽ…ɏˆ•–IXQFWඈRQEXWZHXVHŜŜɫDQGŜŜɭWRGHQRWHWKDWZHZDQWWRXVHWKHWKDQGWKFROXPQVUHVSHFWඈYHO\ඈH1RUWK$PHUඈFDQVRI

,

67 67 67

67

67 67 67

 (XURSHDQGHVFHQWDQG(DVW$VඈDQV,I\RXZDQWHGWRFKRRVHWKHWKFROXPQIRUH[DPSOH\RXZRXOGXVHŜŜɬ $Q\ZD\QRZWKDWZHKDYH) HVWඈPDWHVIRUHDFKRIRXU613VZHFDQYඈVXDOඈVHWKHYDUඈDWඈRQDORQJWKHFKURPRVRPHZඈWK‰‰’Ž‘–ɩ ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſŽ…–ɏ•’•řƒ‡•ſ…‘‘”†řˆ•–ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſƀ ƒʳރʫšŽƒ„ſɑ‘•‹–‹‘ſ„ƀɑƀʫ›Žƒ„ſ‡š’”‡••‹‘ſ‹–ƒŽ‹…ſ ƀƃƄƀƀ ƒʳރʫ–Š‡‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀ ƒ :KDWDUHZHVHHඈQJKHUH"4XඈWHFOHDUO\WKHUHඈVDDQඈQFUHDVHඈQ) DORQJWKHFKURPRVRPHZඈWKDIHZ613VVKRZඈQJH[WUHPHO\KඈJKYDOXHV,W PඈJKWPDNHWKඈQJVDEඈWFOHDUHUඈIZHPDUNRQRXUSORWWKHPඈGSRඈQWRIWKH/&7JHQH:HNQRZWKHJHQHRFFXUVEHWZHHQESDQG ESRQ&KURPVRPHIURPWKH8&6&*HQRPH%URZVHUKWWSVJHQRPHXFVFHGXFJඈEඈQKJ7UDFNV"

GE KJ ODVW9ඈUW0RGH7\SH GHIDXOW ODVW9ඈUW0RGH([WUD6WDWH YඈUW0RGH7\SH GHIDXOW YඈUW0RGH  QRQ9ඈUW3RVඈWඈRQ SRVඈWඈRQ FKU$  KJVඈG B&WWT[R9XW'9*UD=W$8)P]:6RIඈUVWZHZඈOOIඈQGWKHPඈGSRඈQWRIWKHJHQH ɪ†‡ˆ‹‡–Š‡•–ƒ”–ƒ†•–‘’’‘•‹–‹‘•‘ˆ–Š‡‰‡‡ Ž…–ɏ•–ƒ”–ʳŞɨɪɭɩɭɨɯɯɬ Ž…–ɏ•–‘’ʳŞɨɪɭɪɨɨɩɩɥ ɪ…ƒŽ…—Žƒ–‡–Š‡‹†’‘‹– Ž…–ɏ‹†ʳŞſŽ…–ɏ•–ƒ”–ʫŽ…–ɏ•–‘’ƀŵɩ $OOZHQHHGWRGRWRDGGඈWWRRXUSORWඈVXVHWKH‰‡‘ɏ˜Ž‹‡IXQFWඈRQ ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ˜Ž‹‡ſš‹–‡”…‡’–ʰŽ…–ɏ‹†řŽ–›ʰɩř…‘Žʰɑ„Ž—‡ɑƀ ƒ 67 67

  :KHQWKHPඈGSRඈQWRIWKHJHQHඈVPDUNHGඈWඈVFOHDUWKDWWKHUHඈVDQඈQFUHDVHඈQ) MXVWXSVWUHDPIURPWKH/&7JHQH3HUKDSVZHZDQWWR KඈJKOඈJKWWKH613WKDWZHFDOFXODWHG) IRUඈQRXUIඈUVWH[DPSOH":HFDQGRWKඈVHDVඈO\E\VHWWඈQJDIDFWRUඈQRXURUඈJඈQDOGDWDIUDPH5HFDOOWKDW WKHRUඈJඈQDO613ඈVFDOOHGUV Ž…–ɏ•’•ʳŞŽ…–ɏ•’•ʩʴʩ —–ƒ–‡ſ•–ƒ–—•ʰ‹ˆɏ‡Ž•‡ſ•’ɏ‹†ʰʰɑ”•ɫɰɯɯɩɪɬɑřɑ‡•ɑřɑ‘ɑƀƀ

:KDWGඈGZHGRKHUH":HOOIඈUVWZHXVHGWKH—–ƒ–‡IXQFWඈRQWRFUHDWHDQHZFROXPQ,QVඈGH—–ƒ–‡ZHXVHG‹ˆɏ‡Ž•‡7KඈVIXQFWඈRQDOORZVXV

WRVHWDFRQGඈWඈRQDQGSUඈQWYDOXHVEDVHGRQZKHWKHUWKDWFRQGඈWඈRQඈVPHWRUQRW6RKHUHZHDUHEDVඈFDOO\VD\ඈQJඈI•’ɏ‹†ʰʰɑ”•ɫɰɯɯɩɪɬɑ

WKHQUHWXUQ‡•ඈIQRWWKHQUHWXUQ‘:HQDPHGWKඈVFROXPQ•–ƒ–—•0RUHRQKRZZH¶OOXVHWKඈVඈQDPRPHQWEXWIඈUVWZH¶OOXVHDVඈPSOH

H[DPSOHWRGHPRQVWUDWH‹ˆɏ‡Ž•‡DJDඈQ ‹ˆɏ‡Ž•‡ſɬʴɨɥřɑ—”’”‹•‹‰ɑřɑ‘–•—”’”‹•‹‰ɑƀ ɤɤƃɨƄɑ‘–•—”’”‹•‹‰ɑ ‹ˆɏ‡Ž•‡ſɨɥʴɬřɑ—”’”‹•‹‰ɑřɑ‘–•—”’”‹•‹‰ɑƀ ɤɤƃɨƄɑ—”’”‹•‹‰ɑ 1RZWRKඈJKOඈJKWWKH613RQRXUSORW:HGRWKඈVE\VHWWඈQJFRORXUDVDYDUඈDEOHඈQRXUƒ‡• ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſŽ…–ɏ•’•řƒ‡•ſ…‘‘”†řˆ•–ř…‘Ž‘—”ʰ•–ƒ–—•ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſƀ ƒʳރʫšŽƒ„ſɑ‘•‹–‹‘ſ„ƀɑƀʫ›Žƒ„ſ‡š’”‡••‹‘ſ‹–ƒŽ‹…ſ ƀƃƄƀƀ ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ˜Ž‹‡ſš‹–‡”…‡’–ʰŽ…–ɏ‹†řŽ–›ʰɩř…‘Žʰɑ„Ž—‡ɑƀ ƒʳރʫ–Š‡‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀʫ–Š‡‡ſŽ‡‰‡†Ŝ’‘•‹–‹‘ʰɑ‘‡ɑƀ ƒ 67 67

  1RZZHVHHRXUIRFDO613ඈVKඈJKOඈJKWHGඈQWKHSORW:H¶OOFKDQJHWKHFRORXUVWRPDNHඈWDOඈWWOHEඈWFOHDUHU ƒʫ•…ƒŽ‡ɏ…‘Ž‘—”ɏƒ—ƒŽſ˜ƒŽ—‡•ʰ…ſɑ„Žƒ…ɑřɑ”‡†ɑƀƀ ,QWKHQH[WVHFWඈRQZH¶OOGHPRQVWUDWHKRZZHFDQXVHWKHGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQRI) WRඈGHQWඈI\RXWOඈHUVDVSRWHQWඈDOWDUJHWVRIVHOHFWඈRQ

'ඈVWUඈEXWඈRQVඈQ5

$JRRGXQGHUVWDQGඈQJRIVWDWඈVWඈFDOGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQVඈVDQඈPSRUWDQWSDUWRIDQ\HYROXWඈRQDU\EඈRORJඈVW¶VWRRONඈW:HKDYHDOUHDG\HQFRXQWHUHG VWDWඈVWඈFDOGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQVEHIRUHGXUඈQJWKHVHWXWRUඈDOVZKHQZHXVHGWKHEඈQRPඈDODQGFKඈVTXDUHGGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQV7RGD\ZHZඈOOIRFXVRQWKH QRUPDOGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQZKඈFKZඈOOEHඈPSRUWDQWIRUXQGHUVWDQGඈQJKRZWRGHWHFW) RXWOඈHUVDQGDOVRIRUXQGHUVWDQGඈQJVRPHRIWKHWRSඈFVWKDWZH ZඈOOHQFRXQWHUඈQWKHIROORZඈQJWXWRUඈDO $V\RXPඈJKWUHPHPEHU5KDVDVXඈWHRIIXQFWඈRQVWKDWDUHEDVHGDURXQGVWDWඈVWඈFDOGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQV:HZඈOOXVHRQHRIWKHVH”‘”WRJHQHUDWH DUDQGRPGUDZRIYDOXHVIURPWKHQRUPDOGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQ ”‘”ſʰɨɥɥř‡ƒʰɨř•†ʰɥŜɩɬƀ 67 67





:KDWGඈGZHGRKHUH")ඈUVWZHWROG”‘”ZHZDQWYDOXHVඈHʰɨɥɥ:HDUHJRඈQJWRGUDZWKHPIURPDGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQZඈWKDPHDQRI DQGDVWDQGDUGGHYඈDWඈRQRI5HPHPEHU”‘”VWDQGVIRUUDQGRPVDPSOHRIWKHQRUPDOGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQVRYDOXHVZඈOOGඈIIHUHDFKWඈPH\RXUXQ WKඈVIXQFWඈRQ /HW¶VGRWKඈVDJDඈQEXWWKඈVWඈPHZHZඈOOYඈVXDOඈVHWKHGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQXVඈQJDKඈVWRJUDP šʳŞ”‘”ſʰɨɥɥř‡ƒʰɨř•†ʰɥŜɩɬƀ Š‹•–ſšř„”‡ƒ•ʰɨɥƀ <RXVKRXOGDOUHDG\EHIDPඈOඈDUZඈWKWKHQRUPDOGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQEXWඈIQRWWKHQYඈVXDOඈVඈQJඈWPඈJKWKHOS\RXUXQGHUVWDQGඈQJ7KHPDMRUඈW\RI REVHUYDWඈRQVRFFXUDWWKHPHDQඈHWKHSHDNඈQRXUKඈVWRJUDPZKHUHDVWKHH[WUHPHVRIWKHGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQUHSUHVHQWRXWOඈHUV ,QRUGHUWRඈGHQWඈI\VRPHWKඈQJDVDQRXWOඈHUZHQHHGWRඈGHQWඈI\DQDUEඈWUDU\WKUHVKROGDERYHZKඈFKZHFRQVඈGHUVRPHWKඈQJDQH[WUHPHRIWKH GඈVWUඈEXWඈRQ6RIRUH[DPSOHZHFRXOGVD\WKDWWKHWRSRIYDOXHVඈQRXUGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQDUHSRWHQWඈDOO\RXWOඈHUV7KඈVPHDQVZHQHHGWRVHWWKH SHUFHQWඈOHRUTXDQWඈOHWKUHVKROGRIRXUGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQWR:HFDQGRWKඈVOඈNHVR “—ƒ–‹Ž‡ſšřɥŜɰɬƀ 6RWKඈVPHDQVWKDWඈIDYDOXHඈVJUHDWHUWKDQDERXWZHFDQFRQVඈGHUඈWඈQWKHWRSRIRXUGDWDGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQDQGWKXVDSRWHQWඈDORXWOඈHU 1RWH\RXPඈJKWJHWDVOඈJKWO\GඈIIHUHQWDQVZHUWRWKඈVEHFDXVHZHXVHGDUDQGRPVDPSOHIURPWKHGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQ /HW¶VYඈVXDOඈVHWKඈVRQRXUGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQWRPDNHඈWDEඈWFOHDUHUZKDWඈWPHDQV Š‹•–ſšř„”‡ƒ•ʰɨɥƀ ƒ„Ž‹‡ſ˜ʰ“—ƒ–‹Ž‡ſšřɥŜɰɬƀřŽ–›ʰɩřŽ™†ʰɪř…‘Žʰɑ”‡†ɑƀ

  ,QRWKHUZRUGVWKHUHGOඈQHKHUHVKRZVWKDWWKඈVඈVRXUWKUHVKROGDERYHZKඈFKZHFRQVඈGHUYDOXHVDSRWHQWඈDORXWOඈHU

,GHQWඈI\ඈQJRXWOඈHUVඈQRXU) GඈVWUඈEXWඈRQ

6RKRZFDQZHDSSO\ZKDWZHMXVWOHDUQHGDERXWRXWOඈHUVWRRXU) GDWD")ඈUVWRIDOOZHPඈJKWUHDVRQDEO\DVNඈVWKHGDWDQRUPDOO\GඈVWUඈEXWHG" /HW¶VSORWඈWDQGVHH ‰‰’Ž‘–ſŽ…–ɏ•’•řƒ‡•ſˆ•–ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏŠ‹•–‘‰”ƒſ„‹™‹†–ŠʰɥŜɥɬƀ :HOOREYඈRXVO\ඈW¶VQRWTXඈWHDVQඈFHO\GඈVWUඈEXWHGDVRXUVඈPXODWHGGDWDZDVEXWZHFDQVWඈOOXVHWKඈVWRඈGHQWඈI\ZKඈFKYDOXHVRI) PඈJKWEH FRQVඈGHUHGSRWHQWඈDORXWOඈHUV :H¶OOVHWRXUWKUHVKROGDWDJDඈQDQGඈGHQWඈI\ZKHUHRQRXUGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQWKDWIDOOV1RWHWKDWWKඈVWඈPHZHQHHGWRDGGƒŜ”ʰWRRXU “—ƒ–‹Ž‡IXQFWඈRQඈQRUGHUWRඈJQRUHVRPHORFඈZKඈFKKDYHQR) HVWඈPDWHV

67

67 67 67

  ɪ•‡––Š”‡•Š‘Ž† –Š”‡•Š‘Ž†ʳŞ“—ƒ–‹Ž‡ſŽ…–ɏ•’•ɛˆ•–řɥŜɰɬřƒŜ”ʰƀ ɪ’Ž‘–Š‹•–‘‰”ƒ™‹–Š–Š”‡•Š‘Ž†ƒ”‡† ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſŽ…–ɏ•’•řƒ‡•ſˆ•–ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏŠ‹•–‘‰”ƒſ„‹™‹†–ŠʰɥŜɥɬƀ ƒʫ‰‡‘ɏ˜Ž‹‡ſš‹–‡”…‡’–ʰ–Š”‡•Š‘Ž†ř…‘Ž‘—”ʰɑ”‡†ɑřŽ–›ʰɩř•‹œ‡ʰɨƀ 1RZZKDWඈIZHZDQWWRYඈVXDOඈVHWKඈVRQRXUFKURPRVRPHZඈGHSORW"2QFHDJDඈQZHQHHGWRXVHWKH—–ƒ–‡DQG‹ˆɏ‡Ž•‡IXQFWඈRQV Ž…–ɏ•’•ʳŞŽ…–ɏ•’•ʩʴʩ —–ƒ–‡ſ‘—–Ž‹‡”ʰ‹ˆɏ‡Ž•‡ſˆ•–ʴ–Š”‡•Š‘Ž†řɑ—–Ž‹‡”ɑřɑ‘Ş‘—–Ž‹‡”ɑƀƀ 7DNHDORRNDWWKHŽ…–ɏ•’•WඈEEOH\RXVKRXOGQRZVHHDQDGGඈWඈRQDOFROXPQZKඈFKඈVDFKDUDFWHUYHFWRUZඈWKWKHVWDWXVRIHDFKORFXVDVHඈWKHU RXWOඈHURUQRQRXWOඈHU1H[WZHFDQඈQFRUSRUDWHWKඈVඈQWRRXUSORWWඈQJ ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſŽ…–ɏ•’•řƒ‡•ſ…‘‘”†řˆ•–ř…‘Ž‘—”ʰ‘—–Ž‹‡”ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſƀ ƒʳރʫšŽƒ„ſɑ‘•‹–‹‘ſ„ƀɑƀʫ›Žƒ„ſ‡š’”‡••‹‘ſ‹–ƒŽ‹…ſ ƀƃƄƀƀ ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ˜Ž‹‡ſš‹–‡”…‡’–ʰŽ…–ɏ‹†řŽ–›ʰɩř…‘Žʰɑ„Ž—‡ɑƀ ƒʳރʫ–Š‡‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀʫ–Š‡‡ſŽ‡‰‡†Ŝ’‘•‹–‹‘ʰɑ„‘––‘ɑƀ ƒ

  6RQRZRXUSRWHQWඈDORXWOඈHU613VDUHPDUNHGRQWKHIඈJXUH7KHUHDUHRQO\RIWKHPEXWWKH\DOORFFXUMXVWXSVWUHDPIURPWKH/&7ORFXV :HFDQQRWVD\IRUFHUWDඈQWKDWWKHVH613VKDYHඈQFUHDVHG) YDOXHVEHFDXVHRIVHOHFWඈRQRWKHUSURFHVVHVVXFKDVJHQHWඈFGUඈIWRU GHPRJUDSKඈFKඈVWRU\ඈHDERWWOHQHFNඈQRQHRIWKHWZRSRSXODWඈRQVPඈJKWEHUHVSRQVඈEOH+RZHYHUJඈYHQRXUNQRZOHGJHWKDW/&7ඈVඈQYROYHGඈQ ODFWDVHSHUVඈVWHQFHZHFDQDWOHDVWK\SRWKHVඈVHWKDWWKඈVඈVWKHFDVH 2QHඈPSRUWDQWSRඈQWWRQRWHKHUHඈVWKDWWKHWKUHVKROGZHVHWWRඈGHQWඈI\D613DVEHඈQJSRWHQWඈDOO\XQGHUVHHOFWඈRQඈVHQWඈUHO\DUEඈWUDU\,QDZD\ WKඈVOඈQHRIWKඈQNඈQJIRUFHVXVWRWKඈQNRIVHOHFWඈRQDFWඈQJඈQVRPHEඈQDU\ZD\RQVRPH613VDQGQRWRWKHUV7KඈVඈVREYඈRXVO\QRWWKHFDVH6WඈOO IRU613GDWDOඈNHWKඈVDQ) VFDQFDQEHDYHU\XVHIXOWRRO

6WXG\TXHVWඈRQV

)RUVWXG\TXHVWඈRQVRQWKඈVWXWRUඈDOGRZQORDGWKHŠƒ’–‡”ɬɏɏ“—‡•–‹‘•ŜIURP&DQYDVRUIඈQGඈWKHUH KWWSVHYROXWඈRQDU\JHQHWඈFVJඈWKXEඈR&KDSWHUB5BTXHVWඈRQV5

*RඈQJIXUWKHU

*UDKDP&RRS¶VQRWHVRQ)VWDWඈVWඈFVKWWSFRRSODEJඈWKXEඈRSRSJHQQRWHVVXPPDUඈ]ඈQJSRSXODWඈRQVWUXFWXUH $GHWDඈOHGWXWRUඈDORQFDOFXODWඈQJSRSXODWඈRQGඈIIHUHQWඈDWඈRQZඈWKVHYHUDO5EDVHGSRSXODWඈRQJHQHWඈFSDFNDJHV KWWSVSRSJHQQHVFHQWRUJPඈFURVDWHOOඈWHGඈIIHUHQWඈDWඈRQKWPO $QඈFHWKRURXJKH[SORUDWඈRQRIWKHQRUPDOGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQXVඈQJ5IXQFWඈRQVDQGSORWWඈQJKWWSVHDQNURVVFRPQRWHVGSTU 67 67