• Sonuç bulunamadı

Effects of some antibiotics on enzyme activities of carbonic anhydrase from erythrocytes in vivo and in vitro

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Share "Effects of some antibiotics on enzyme activities of carbonic anhydrase from erythrocytes in vivo and in vitro"

Copied!
12
0
0

Yükleniyor.... (view fulltext now)

Tam metin

(1)

#%%#

HXb Z_\Q]^aZ _^XSY\_[b[ NL[ >N  _\b MaYb[R\b_YVb`_WW]b^JSVb[a^_WWWaOa^P]\P_^a[V[

a^ZWTYa^P XTV_^[    K^YbbY QS Z_`_WSJa^P _ [aVRWb QT` UT^Y_Vb^`_W \b_Z`a]^ `Xb \bOb\[aQWb XSY\_`a]^]UN@`]QaZ_\Q]^_`b_^Y_R\]`]^`Xb[b Vb`_WW]b^JSVb[ _\b a^O]WObY a^ _ VTW`a`TYb ]U RXS[a]W]PaZ_W_^YR_`X]W]PaZ_WR\]Zb[[b[_^Y`Xba\

a^XaQa`a]^Wb_Y[`]\b[R]^[b[`X_`V_SQbbBRW]a`bY

`Xb\_RbT`aZ_WWS Db[aYb[  a[]U]\V[ X_Ob Qbb^

Yb[Z\aQbYTR`]^]M   ]UMXaZX_`Wb_[`NLKKKA

FLN>HH>C>?@3;7L5@<DK@5@:1L7=NF>EKIH;1 ;b[b_\ZXL\`aZWb

F_Zb``bRb?Da]W+NXbV  



!N]\\b[R]^Yb^Zb`]6 IbWV_Ia^_^

D_WaGb[a\ 3^aOb\[a`S IZab^Zb + L\` <_ZTW`S =bR_\`Vb^` ]U Da]W]PSNL:KI9_VRT[ D_WaGb[a\HT\GbS

HbW6( <_B6(

> V_aW6[]J^T\Q_WaGb[a\bYT`\

>UUbZ`[]UI]VbL^`aQa]`aZ[]^>^JSVbLZ`aOa`ab[]UN_\Q]^aZL^XSY\_[b U\]V>\S`X\]ZS`b['%'&" _^Y'%'!"

)2,'4)5.4.  

D_W.Gb[a\3^aOb\[a`S<_ZTW`S]UIZab^Zb_^YL\`=bR_\`Vb^`]UDa]W]PSD_W.Gb[a\HT\GbS

D_W.Gb[a\3^aOb\[a`S<_ZTW`S]UIZab^Zb_^YL\`=bR_\`Vb^`]UNXbVa[`\SD_W.Gb[a\HT\GbS

D_W.Gb[a\3^aOb\[a`SIT[T\WTGHbZX^]W]PSA]Z_`a]^_WIZX]]WFaPXb\>YTZ_`a]^D_W.Gb[a\HT\GbS

*015(,2."/ * 3104(1

!'#'!"

;bZbaObY

=bZbVQb\

;bZbaObYa^\bOa[bYU]\V

<bQ\T_\S

LZZbR`bY

<bQ\T_\S

LO_aW_QWb]^Wa^b

?T^b

K^`Xa[[`TYSUa\[`WS`XbbUUbZ`[]UbaPX`_^`aQa]`aZ[^_VbWSZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^ZXW]\_VRXb^aZ]W

\aU_VSZa^IAZWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`bZaR\]UW]B_Za^Pb^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^

Qbb^a^Ob[`aP_`bY'%&'!"$ FTV_^b\S`X\]ZS`b[NL K_^YNL KKa[]JSVb[Mb\b[bR_\_`bWS RT\aUabYQS_UUa^a`SZX\]V_`]P\_RXSK^XaQa`a]^bUUbZ`[]UbaPX`YaUUb\b^`_^`aQa]`aZ[]^XNL a[]JSVb[Mb\bYb`b\Va^bYT[a^P`XbN@XSY\_`_[bVb`X]YQSRW]``a^P_Z`aOa`S/&

VbYaZ_WY\TP KNO_WTb[]U`Xb_^`aQa]`aZ[bBXaQa`a^Pa^XaQa`a]^bUUbZ`[Mb\bU]T^YQS Vb_^[]U`Xb[bP\_RX[K`M_[]Q[b\ObY`X_`b_ZX_^`aQa]`aZ[[X]MbY_^a^XaQa`a]^bUUbZ`

]^XNL K_^YXNL KKXSY\_`_[b_Z`aOa`SI]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^[X]MbYP\b_`b[`a^XaQa`a]^bUUbZ`

]^XNL K_^YXNL KK_Z`aOa`SU\]V'%&'!"[`TYab[K^]\Yb\`]Yb`b\Va^b`Xba^XaQa`a]^[`_`Tb ]U`Xb[bY\TP[]^_WaOa^P[S[`bV`XbbUUbZ`[]U[_Vb_^`aQa]`aZ[]^NLb^JSVb_Z`aOa`S]U V]T[bb\S`X\]ZS`b[M_[a^Ob[`aP_`bY'%&'&"NaR\]UW]B_Za^ VPGPZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^

_U`b\X _^YXY\TP_YVa^a[`\_`a]^Wb_Y`]a^Z\b_[ba^VNLNXW]\_VRXb^aZ]W 

VPGPYaY^]`bBXaQa`_^SbUUbZ`U]\`XbVNL'%&'&"$ F]MbOb\NL_Z`aOa`S_U`b\[]YaTV _VRaZaWWa^_^YZbU_J]Wa^[]YaTV_YVa^a[`\_`a]^[X]MbY[`_`a[`aZ_WWS[aP^aUaZ_^`YbZ\b_[b_`

X]UY\TP_YVa^a[`\_`a]^'%&'&" R6_^Y\b[RbZ`aObWS

* 02 5415/.3

XNL6 XTV_^ Z_\Q]^aZ _^XSY\_[b0 NL K6 Z_\Q]^aZ _^XSY\_[b ]^b0 NL KK6 Z_\Q]^aZ _^XSY\_[b`M]0VNL6V]T[bb\S`X\]ZS`b[

2- /0&3

N_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[b

>\S`X\]ZS`b

L^`aQa]`aZ[

'%&'&"

'%&'!"

(2)



ALADAKKK,,KK,KKK_^Y,KAZ]^[`a`T`bO_WaY

`_\Pb`[U]\`XbYbObW]RVb^`]U^]ObW_^`aPW_TZ]V_

_^`a`TV]\_^`a]Qb[a`S]\_^`aZ]^OTW[_^`Y\TP[ 

 

K`X_[Qbb^\bR]\`bY`X_``Xb_Z`aOa`SWbObW[]UNL a[]JSVb[a^XTV_^ FNL K_^YFNL KKb\S`X\]ZS`b[

O_\SZ]^[aYb\_QWbT^Yb\Zb\`_a^R_`X]W]PaZ_W_^Y RXS[a]W]PaZ_W Z]^Ya`a]^[ NX_^Pb[ a^ NL _Z`aOa`S X_ObQbb^_[[]Za_`bYMa`XVb`_Q]WaZYa[b_[b[TZX _[Ya_Qb`b[VbWWa`T[_^YXSRb\`b^[a]^  K`X_[

Qbb^\bR]\`bY`X_``Xba^XaQa`a]^]UNLM_[U]T^Y`]

aVR_a\ R\]`]^ [bZ\b`a]^ a^`] `Xb R\]BaV_W `TQTWb WTVb^ _^Y `Xb\bQS YbZ\b_[bY QaZ_\Q]^_`b

\b_Q[]\R`a]^L``Xb[_Vb`aVba^XaQa`a]^]UNL_W[]

YbZ\b_[bY `Xb \_`b ]U _ZaYaUaZ_`a]^ ]U T\a^b

R\]YTZa^P_WG_Wa^bT\a^b_^YbOb^`T_WWSVb`_Q]WaZ _ZaY][a[  

NLb^JSVb[RT\aUabYU\]VO_\a]T[]\P_^a[V[X_Ob Qbb^[X]M^`]Qba^XaQa`bYQSO_\a]T[Z]VR]T^Y[

ITWU]^_VaYb[WaGb_Zb`]J]W_VaYb_^YXb_OSVb`_W[

_\bZ]^[aYb\bY_[`Xb[`\]^Pb[`NLa^XaQa`]\[  K^

_YYa`a]^[]Vb'%&'!" _^Y'%&'&" [`TYab[[X]MbY

`X_`[]Vb_^`aQa]`aZ[a^ZWTYa^P[`\bR`]VSZa^[TWU_`b

[]YaTV YaRS\]^b V_P^b[aTV [TWU_`b []YaTV ZbU`aJ]BaVb []YaTV ZbUT\]BaVb []YaTV ZbU]Rb\_J]^b [`\]R`]VSZa^b [TWU_`b _^Y Vb`XSWVSZa^b[TWU_`b[]VbZXbVaZ_W[_^YUa^_WWS

[]VbRb[`aZaYb[_W[]a^XaQa`NLb^JSVb_Z`aOa`S`]_

MaYb\_^Pb]UYbP\bb[  

L^`aQa]`aZ[_\bY\TP[Yb\aObYMX]WWS]\R_\`a_WWSU\]V Zb\`_a^ VaZ\]]\P_^a[V[ _^Y _\b T[bY `] `\b_`

Q_Z`b\a_W]\UT^P_Wa^UbZ`a]^[HXbS_\ba^bUUbZ`aOb _P_a^[`Oa\T[b[MXaZXba`Xb\GaWWVaZ\]]\P_^a[V[]\

[`]R`XbVU\]V\bR\]YTZa^P  HXbP\b_`^TVQb\

]U YaOb\[b _^`aQa]`aZ[ ZT\\b^`WS _O_aW_QWb Z_^ Qb ZW_[[aUabYa^YaUUb\b^`M_S[bPQS`Xba\ZXbVaZ_W [`\TZ`T\b `Xba\ VaZ\]Qa_W ]\aPa^ ]\ `Xba\ V]Yb ]U _Z`a]^HXbS_\b_W[]U\b-Tb^`WSYb[aP^_`bYQS`Xba\

bUUbZ`aOb\_^Pb

E_Z\]WaY_VRXb^aZ]W_Va^]PWaZ][aYb_^YRb^aZaWWa^

Yb\aO_`aOb_^`aQa]`aZ[ `XbV][`MaYbWST[bYQ\]_Y [RbZ`\TV _^`aQa]`aZ[ _\b bUUbZ`aOb _P_a^[` Q]`X :\_V R][a`aOb _^Y :\_V ^bP_`aOb Q_Z`b\a_   Db`_ W_Z`_V[ _\b Z]VR]T^Y[ Ma`X _ Qb`_ W_Z`_V

\a^Pa^`Xba\[`\TZ`T\b HXbSZ]VR\a[bR\a^ZaR_WWS`Xb Rb^aZaWWa^[ _^Y `Xb ZbRX_W][R]\a^[ QT` _W[] `XbS a^ZWTYb ZW_OTW_^aZ _ZaY HXb_Va^]PWaZ][aYb _\b R\]YTZ`[]U_Z`a^]VSZb`b[ []aWQ_Z`b\a_]\[bVa [S^`Xb`aZYb\aO_`aOb[]U`Xb^_`T\_WR\]YTZ`[   HXbQb`_ W_Z`_V_^`aQa]`aZ[Qa^Y`]b^JSVb[_^Y a^XaQa` `XbV ^bbYbY U]\ `Xb [S^`Xb[a[ ]U `Xb RbR`aY]PWSZ_^M_WW2XaWb`XbSX_ObWa``WbbUUbZ`]^

\b[`a^PQ_Z`b\a_`XbS_\bWb`X_W`]YaOaYa^PQ_Z`b\a_

_[YbUbZ`aObM_WW[Z_^^]`R\]`bZ``Xb]\P_^a[VU]\V QT\[`a^Pa^XSR]`]^aZ[T\\]T^Ya^P[

E_^S_^`aQa]`aZ[X_ObQbb^T[bYa^`Xb\_Rab[HXb\b _\bUbMWa`b\_`T\b\bR]\`[\bW_`bYMa`XZX_^Pa^P]U b^JSVb_Z`aOa`ab[K`X_[Qbb^\bR]\`bY`X_`[]Vb a^Z\b_[a^P ]\ YbZ\b_[a^P b^JSVb _Z`aOa`S WbObW[

Mb\b U]T^Y ]^ XTV_^ WaOb\ [TZX _[ _[R_\`_`b _Va^]`\_^[Ub\_[b LIH0 I:@H _W_^a^b _Va^]

`\_^[Ub\_[b L5H0 I:CH _^Y _WG_Wa^b U][U_`_[b   Ia^Zb`XbbUUbZ`[]U[]Vb_^`aQa]`aZ[X_Ob

^]` Qbb^ _^_WSJbY ]^ NL a[]JSVb[ MXaZX _\b Z]^`_a^bY _` `Xb XaPXb[` V]W_\ _V]T^`[ a^

b\S`X\]ZS`b[ '% &'&" _^Y '% &'!"HXb a^`b\_Z`a]^

Qb`Mbb^XTV_^b\S`X\]ZS`bWS[_`b[_^Y_^`aQa]`aZ[

M_[ [`TYabY _^Y `Xb bUUbZ` ]U a^`\_ZbWWTW_\

Z]VR]^b^`[]^`Xb_Z`aOa`S_^YQa^Ya^P]U`XbY\TP[

M_[ Yb`b\Va^bY QS 9]\^PT`X #! $   K^ `Xb [`TYab[ T[a^P RT\b R\bR_\_`a]^[ ]U Z_\Q]^aZ _^XSY\_[b \bOb_WbY `X_` `Xb NL a[]JSVb a[ `Xb V_8]\Qa^Yb\]U`Xb`b`\_ZSZWa^b[_^YJa^ZYaY^]`

a^XaQa`b^JSV_`aZ_Z`aOa`S]UZ_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[b

L^]`Xb\[`TYS_Q]T`Z_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[ba^Q]^b

\b[]\R`a]^a^YTZbYQSYaXSY\]BSOa`_Va^='%

&'!"HXbV][`[aP^aUaZ_^`Ua^Ya^PM_[`X_` @F

= a^YTZbYZ_WZaTV\bWb_[bM_[_ZZ]VR_^abYQS _ [aP^aUaZ_^` a^Z\b_[b a^ `Xb Z_\Q]^aZ _^XSY\_[b

(3)



_Z`aOa`S]UQ]^b_`Q]`XX `\b_`bYZ]^`\]W\_`a]#

NbU_J]Wa^ []YaTV ZbRX\_Ya^b _^Y [TWQ_Z`_V

ZbU]Rb\_J]^b _^Y ZXW]\_VRXb^aZ]W []YaTV [TZZa^_`b_^`aQa]`aZ[Mb\b[`TYabYQSN]Q_^b`_W

_^Ya^`Xa[[`TYS`XbKNO_WTb[Mb\ba^YaZ_`bY_[

]U_^YVE]^XNLK_^Y_^Y

VE]^FNLKK\b[RbZ`aObWS  DT``Xb\ba[^]

\bR]\`_Q]T`Z_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[ba[]JSVb[FNL K _^Y FNL KK Ma`X `Xb a^XaQa`a]^ ]U ZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^

ZXW]\_VRXb^aZ]W \aU_VSZa^ IA ZWa^Y_VSZa^

RX][RX_`b ZaR\]UW]B_Za^ Pb^`_VSZa^ [TWU_`b

[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^_^YZbU_J]Wa^[]YaTV <aPT\b

K^ `Xb R\b[b^` [`TYS `Xb '% &'!" bUUbZ`[ ]U `Xb[b _^`aQa]`aZ[]^XNLa[]JSVb[RT\aUabYU\]VXTV_^

b\S`X\]ZS`b[_^Y`Xb'%&'&" bUUbZ`]^VNLb^JSVb U\]VVaZbb\S`X\]ZS`b[Mb\ba^Ob[`aP_`bY

IbRX_\][b D 5 `S\][a^b [TWU_^SW_VaYb R\]`ba^

_[[_S \b_Pb^`[ RXb^]W \bY _^Y ZXbVaZ_W[ U]\

bWbZ`\]RX]\b[a[Mb\b]Q`_a^bYU\]VIaPV_NXbV

N] EaW_^] K`_WS LWW ]`Xb\ ZXbVaZ_W[ Mb\b _^_WS`aZ_WP\_YbEbYaZ_WY\TP[Mb\bR\]OaYbYQS W]Z_WRX_\V_ZS

($0/'41/04$-

>\S`X\]ZS`b[Mb\bRT\aUabYU\]VU\b[XXTV_^QW]]Y ]Q`_a^bYU\]V`XbI`_`bF][Ra`_Wa^D_WaGb[a\HXb QW]]Y[_VRWb[Mb\b Zb^`\aUTPbY_`\RVU]\

Va^_^Y`XbRW_[V__^Y QTUUSZ]_`Mb\b\bV]ObY

HXb\bYZbWW[Mb\ba[]W_`bY _^YM_[XbY`MaZbMa`X

/7_NW_^YXbV]WS[bYMa`X O]WTVb[]UaZb Z]WYM_`b\HXbPX][`_^Ya^`_Z` ZbWW[Mb\b\bV]ObY QSZb^`\aUTP_`a]^_`\RVU]\Va^_`]N

HXbRF]UXbV]WS[_`bM_[_Y8T[`bY `]Ma`X[]WaY H\a[ FNW HXb XbV]WS[_`b M_[ _RRWabY `] `Xb R\bR_\bY IbRX_\][b D 5 `S\][a^b [TWU_^SW_VaYb

_UUa^a`SZ]WTV^b-TaWaQ\_`bYMa`XVEH\a[ FNW

E 7_I@ RFHXb_UUa^a`SPbWM_[M_[XbY Ma`X VEH\a[ FNWVE7_I@ RFHXb XTV_^ Z_\Q]^aZ _^XSY\_[b FNL K _^Y FNL KK a[]JSVb[ Mb\b bWT`bY Ma`X  E 7_NW VE 7_FC@ RF_^YE7_NFN@@E 7_NW@ RF\b[RbZ`aObWS  

HXb_Q[]\Q_^Zb_`^VM_[T[bY`]V]^a`]\`Xb R\]`ba^a^`XbZ]WTV^bUUWTb^`['T_^`a`_`aObR\]`ba^

Yb`b\Va^_`a]^ M_[ _ZXabObY QS _Q[]\Q_^Zb Vb_[T\bVb^`[ _`  ^V _ZZ]\Ya^P `] D\_YU]\Y  Ma`XQ]Oa^b[b\TV_WQTVa^[`_^Y_\Y

I=I R]WS_Z\SW_VaYb PbW bWbZ`\]RX]\b[a[ M_[

Rb\U]\VbYa^]\Yb\`]Ob\aUS`XbRT\aUabYb^JSVbK`

M_[ Z_\\abY ]T` a^ / _^Y / _Z\SW_VaYb Z]^Zb^`\_`a]^[U]\`Xb\T^^a^P_^Y`Xb[`_ZGa^PPbW

\b[RbZ`aObWS Z]^`_a^a^P / I=I _ZZ]\Ya^P `]

5_bVVWa  I_VRWb P M_[_RRWabY`]`Xb bWbZ`\]RX]\b[a[VbYaTV:bWM_[ [`_a^bYU]\Xa^

/ N]]VV_[[ab D\aWW_^` DWTb ;  a^ /

Vb`X_^]W_^Y/_Zb`aZ_ZaY`Xb^Yb[`_a^bY Ma`X [bOb\_WZX_^Pb[]U`Xb[_Vb[]WOb^`Ma`X]T``Xb YSbHXbbWbZ`\]RX]\b`aZR_``b\^M_[RX]`]P\_RXbY <aPT\b

HXbNLb^JSVb_Z`aOa`SM_[_[[_SbYQSU]WW]Ma^P

`Xb XSY\_`a]^ ]U N@ _ZZ]\Ya^P `] `Xb Vb`X]Y Yb[Z\aQbY QS 2aWQT\ _^Y L^Yb\[]^   N@ XSY\_`_[b _Z`aOa`S ]U b^JSVb M_[ Yb`b\Va^bY _`

\]]V`bVRb\_`T\ba^_Ob\]^_WQTUUb\ RFMa`X RXb^]W \bY_[a^YaZ_`]\_^Y[_`T\bYZ_\Q]^Ya]BaYb []WT`a]^_[[TQ[`\_`ba^_Ua^_WO]WTVb]UVWHXb

`aVb a^[bZ]^Y[`_Gb^U]\`Xb[]WT`a]^`]ZX_^Pb U\]V\bY`]SbWW]MM_[Vb_[T\bYHXbb^JSVbT^a`

>3M_[Z_WZTW_`bYT[a^P`Xbb-T_`a]^ ` `Z `Z MXb\b`_^Y`Z_\b`Xb`aVb[U]\RFZX_^Pb]U`Xb

^]^ b^JSV_`aZ _^Y b^JSV_`aZ \b_Z`a]^[

\b[RbZ`aObWS

(4)



<aPT\bHXb[`\TZ`T\b]UVbYaZ_WY\TP[

(5)



 31!&523

<]\`Xba^XaQa`a]^NXW_\a`X\]VSZa^ZXW]\_VRXb^aZ]W

\aU_VSZa^IAZWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`bZaR\]UW]B_Za^

Pb^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^_^YZbU_J]Wa^

[]YaTV_`YaUUb\b^`Z]^Zb^`\_`a]^[Mb\b_YYbY`]

a^XaQa`b^JSVb_Z`aOa`S;b_Z`a]^VaB`T\b VW Z]^`_a^bYVWRXb^]W\bYVWN@[]WT`a]^

VW QTUUb\ []WT`a]^  VW a^XaQa`]\ _` O_\a]T[

Z]^Zb^`\_`a]^[ _^Y  VW b^JSVb []WT`a]^

Ib^[a`aOa`S ]U NL `] _^`aQa]`aZ[ M_[ bB_Va^bY QS Vb_[T\a^PNL_Z`aOa`Sa^`XbR\b[b^Zb]Ua^Z\b_[a^P Z]^Zb^`\_`a]^[]U`Xb[bVbYaZ_WY\TP[NL _Z`aOa`ab[

Ma`X `Xb \bW_`bY _^`aQa]`aZ[ Mb\b _[[_SbY QS U]WW]Ma^P `Xb XSY\_`a]^ ]U N@ Cb\Zb^` _Z`aOa`S P\_RX[ Mb\b Y\_M^ U\]V `Xb \b[TW`[ `] Ua^Y KN

O_WTb[ _` UaOb YaUUb\b^` _^`aQa]`aZ Z]^Zb^`\_`a]^[

MXaZX[X]M_Q]T`/a^XaQa`a]^bUUbZ`K^]\Yb\`]

Yb`b\Va^bKN O_WTb\bP\b[[a]^_^_WS[a[P\_RX[

Mb\bY\_M^QST[a^PRb\Zb^`a^XaQa`a]^O_WTb[QS_^

>BZbWW R\]P\_V ]^ _ Z]VRT`b\ HXb a^XaQa`a]^

Z]^Zb^`\_`a]^[Z_T[a^PTR`]/a^XaQa`a]^Mb\b Yb`b\Va^bY U\]V `Xb P\_RX[ NL _Z`aOa`S Ma`X]T`

Rb[`aZaYb[ _^Y a^XaQa`]\[ M_[ _ZZbR`bY _[ /

_Z`aOa`S >_ZX a^XaQa`a]^ bUUbZ`[ Mb\b \bRb_`bY _`

Wb_[``X\bb`aVb[HXb[`\TZ`T\b[]UVbYaZ_WY\TP[

T[bY_\b[X]M^a^<aPT\b

31!&523

7a^bVaZb  Ya]WbZ`aZT[MXa`b`SRb    P Mb\b [bWbZ`bY U]\ a^`\_VT[ZTW_\

_YVa^a[`\_`a]^]Ub_ZXY\TPEaZbT[bYU]\'%&'&"

[`TYab[X_ObQbb^GbR`T^Yb\[RbZa_WZ]^Ya`a]^[ a^

_Ma^Y]MWb[[\]]V&NMa`XWaPX`]^U]\XU]\

V]^`XLP\]TR]U`X\bbVaZbMb\ba^ZWTYbYa^`Xb [`TYSU]\_Z]^`\]WP\]TRMXaZXa[^]`[TQ8bZ``]_^S Y\TP _YVa^a[`\_`a]^ =\TP Y][_Pb U]\ VaZb M_[

Z_WZTW_`bY U\]V [TPPb[`bY Y][b U]\ XTV_^[ a^

VPGPNaR\]UW]B_Za^ VPGPZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^

Pb^`_VSZa^ [TWU_`b  VPGP ZWa^Y_VSZa^

RX][RX_`b  VPGP ZXW]\_VRXb^aZ]W 

ZbU_J]Wa^ []YaTV  VPGP Mb\b a^8bZ`bY a^`\_VT[ZTW_\WS a^`] b_ZX V]T[b <]\ b_ZX Y\TP VaZbMb\b[_Z\aUaZbYQST[a^PZb\OaZ_WYa[W]Z_`a]^

Vb`X]Y _`   _^Y  X `aVb R]a^`[ ]U `Xb Y\TP _YVa^a[`\_`a]^DW]]Y[_VRWb[Mb\b`_Gb^]T`U\]V b_ZXV]T[b_``Xb[bR]a^`[_U`b\a^8bZ`a]^DW]]Y M_[Z]WWbZ`bYa^`]`Xb`b[``TQb[Z]^`_a^a^P>=HL _^Y RW_[V_ M_[ [bR_\_`bWS QS Zb^`\aUTP_`a]^

FbV]WS[_`bM_[R\bR_\bYaVVbYa_`bWS_^Y[`]\bY _` &NYT\a^P`XbR\bR_\_`a]^]U_^_WS[a[

<aPT\bI=I CL:>]UXTV_^Z_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[bK_^Y KK HXb R]]WbY U\_Z`a]^[ U\]V _UUa^a`S ZX\]V_`]P\_RXS [bRX_\][b D5 `S\][a^b[TWU_^aW_VaYbM_[_^_WSJbY QS I=I CL:> / _^Y / _^Y \bOb_WbY QS N]]V_[[abDWTb[`_a^a^P>BRb\aVb^`_WZ]^Ya`a]^[Mb\b Yb[Z\aQbY a^ `Xb Vb`X]Y 5_^b  Z]^`_a^bY  P ]U O_\a]T[ V]WbZTW_\ V_[[ [`_^Y_\Y[6  P_W_Z`][aY_[b

]URT\aUabYXTV_^Z_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[bK W_^b_^YK W_^bVaP\_`bYMa`X_V]QaWa`SZ]\\b[R]^Ya^P`]_^

_RR_\b^`E\ G=_

(6)



)1415315(4,4.4,-353

I`_`a[`aZ_W _^_WS[a[ M_[ Rb\U]\VbY T[a^P ICII R\]P\_V L^_WS[a[ ]U O_\a_^Zb HTGbS FI= M_[

T[bYMXb^V]\b`X_^`M]P\]TR[Mb\bZ]VR_\bY

=_`__\bR\b[b^`bY_[Vb_^I=HXbO_WTb[C4

Mb\bZ]^[aYb\bY[aP^aUaZ_^`

+)%)

31!&523

FTV_^b\S`X\]ZS`b[NLK_^YKKMb\bRT\aUabYQS T[a^P`Xb_UUa^a`SPbWMa`X`XbbWT`a]^QTUUb\[]UE 7_NW VE 7_FC@ RF  _^Y  E 7_NFN@@E7_NW@ RF\b[RbZ`aObWS

CT\aUaZ_`a]^]U`Xba[]b^JSVb[M_[Z]^Ua\VbYMa`X I=I R]WS_Z\SW_VaYbPbWbWbZ`\]RX]\b[a[ <aPT\b

NXW_\a`X\]VSZa^ ZXW]\_VRXb^aZ]W \aU_VSZa^ IA

ZWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`bZaR\]UW]B_Za^Pb^`_VSZa^

[TWU_`b_^Y[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^_^YZbU_J]Wa^[]YaTV Mb\b ZX][b^ U]\ `Xb a^Ob[`aP_`a]^ ]U a^XaQa`a]^ ]\

_Z`aO_`a]^bUUbZ`[H][X]Ma^XaQa`a]^bUUbZ`[_Z`aOa`S / O_WTb[ ]U FNL K _^Y FNL KK U]\ UaOb YaUUb\b^`

Z]^Zb^`\_`a]^[ ]U b_ZX VbYaZ_W Y\TP Mb\b Yb`b\Va^bYN_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[b_Z`aOa`SMa`X]T`_

VbYaZ_WY\TPM_[_ZZbR`bY_[/_Z`aOa`S<]\

`XbY\TP[bBXaQa`a^P_^a^XaQa`a]^bUUbZ``Xba^XaQa`]\

Z]^Zb^`\_`a]^[Z_T[a^PTR`]/a^XaQa`a]^ KN

Mb\b Yb`b\Va^bY U\]V `Xb \bP\b[[a]^ _^_WS[a[

P\_RX[KN O_WTb[]Q`_a^bYU]\FNL K_^YFNL KK _\b[X]M^a^H_QWb<\]V'%&'!" [`TYab[FNL K _^Y FNL KK Mb\b a^XaQa`bY QS _WW VbYaZ_W Y\TP[

P\_YT_WWS I]YaTV _VRaZaWWa^ M_[ V][` bUUbZ`aOb a^XaQa`]\[U]\FNL K_^YFNL KKHXb]Q`_a^bYKN

O_WTb[]U[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^Mb\b VE]^

FNL K _^Y  VE ]^ FNL KK NbU_J]Wa^

[]YaTVX_YVa^aVTVbUUbZ`]^FNL K_^YFNL KK  VE_^Y VE\b[RbZ`aObWSMXb^

`XbZ]VR_\b`]]`Xb\_^`aQa]`aZ[:b^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b X_Ya^XaQa`a]^bUUbZ`]^b_ZXb^JSVbL[[bb^a^

H_QWb  KN O_WTb[ ]U Pb^`_VSZa^ [TWU_`b M_[

U]T^Y`]QbVE_^YVE

31!&523

<]\ '% &'&" [`TYab[ V]T[b b\S`X\]ZS`b[ NL M_[

Yb`b\Va^bY_``X\bb`aVbR]a^`[^_VbWS_^Y

X_U`b\a^8bZ`a]^HXb\b[TW`[]U'%&'&" bUUbZ`[]Ub_ZX _^`aQa]`aZ_\bR\b[b^`bYa^H_QWbHXbVb_^I=

O_WTb[]UZ_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[b_Z`aOa`ab[a^`Xb`b[`

P\]TR_^YZ]^`\]WP\]TRMb\bZ]VR_\bYa^<aPT\b

 @T\ Y_`_ [X]MbY `X_` `Xb\b a[ ^] Z]\\bW_`a]^

Qb`Mbb^ `Xb '% &'&" _^Y '% &'!" bUUbZ`[ ]U b_ZX _^`aQa]`aZbBZbR`[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^_^YZbU_J]Wa^

[]YaTVNaR\]UW]B_Za^ VPGPZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^

Pb^`_VSZa^ [TWU_`b  VPGP _^Y ZWa^Y_VSZa^

RX][RX_`b  VPGP bBXaQa`bY [`_`a[`aZ_WWS [aP^aUaZ_^` _Z`aO_`a]^ bUUbZ` U]\ `Xb V]T[b b\S`X\]ZS`b[ NL _Z`aOa`S R$ F]MbOb\ NL _Z`aOa`S_U`b\[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^_^YZbU_J]Wa^[]YaTV _YVa^a[`\_`a]^ [X]MbY [`_`a[`aZ_WWS [aP^aUaZ_^`

YbZ\b_[b_`X]UY\TP_RRWaZ_`a]^'%&'&" R6

_^Y  \b[RbZ`aObWS <]\ ZaR\]UW]B_Za^

ZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^_^Y\aU_VSZa^IA`Xb_Z`aOa`S]U`Xb Z]^`\]W MXaZX YaY ^]` Z]^`_a^ _^S Y\TP M_[

Yb`b\Va^bY _[  >3 HXb^ `Xb Y\TP a^8bZ`a]^ M_[ Rb\U]\VbY ]^ `Xb Z]^`\]W P\]TR[

a^`\_Rb\a`]^b_WWSHXb_Z`aOa`ab[]U`XbP\]TR[_U`b\

`XbY\TPa^8bZ`a]^Mb\bVb_[T\bY_`_^YX

_^Y Z]\\b[R]^Ya^P _Z`aOa`ab[ Mb\b U]T^Y `] Qb

_ Q _^Y _ U]\

ZaR\]UW]B_Za^0 _ Q _^Y

_ U]\ ZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^0 _

H_QWb K^XaQa`a]^bUUbZ`[]UY\TP[]^Z_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[b

KN VE

=\TP FNL K FNL KK

NaR\]UW]B_Za^  

NXW_\a`X\]VSZa^  

;aU_VSZa^IA  

:b^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b  

NWa^Y_VSZa^CX][RX_`b  

NXW]\_VRXb^aZ]W  

I]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^  

NbU_J]Wa^[]YaTV  

(7)

<aPT\bK^OaO]bUUbZ`[]UZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^ZXW]\_VRXb^aZ]W\aU_VSZa^IAZWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`bZaR\]UW]B_Za^Pb^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^_^YZbU_J]Wa^[]YaTV ]^V]T[bb\S`X\]ZS`bZ_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[b_Z`aOa`SA_WTb[_\bVb_^I=U]\^#a^YbRb^Yb^`bBRb\aVb^`[Rb\P\]TR]UNL_Z`aOa`SVb_[T\bY_U`b\`XbY\TP_YVa^a[`\_`a]^ L^_WS[a[]UO_\a_^ZbH39>1M_[T[bYMXb^V]\b`X_^`M]P\]TR[Mb\bZ]VR_\bYHXbO_WTb[C4Mb\bZ]^[aYb\bY[aP^aUaZ_^` NZ]^`\]WP\]TR0XNL_Z`aOa`S /_U`b\`XbY\TP_YVa^a[`\_`a]^0!`Xb[`_`a[`aZ_WWS[aP^aUaZ_^`Y_`_ X CU]\ZaR\]UW]B_Za^X CU]\ZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^X C_^YX CU]\ \aU_VSZa^bIAX CU]\Pb^`_VSZa^b[TWU_`bX C_^YX CU]\ZWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`bX CU]\ZbU_J]Wa^[]YaTV[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^X  R6

(8)



Q_^YQZU]\\aU_VSZa^IA

\b[RbZ`aObWS H_QWb  @T\ Y_`_ [X]MbY `X_`

ZaR\]UW]B_Za^ ZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^ _^Y \aU_VSZa^ IA a^Z\b_[bY`Xb_Z`aOa`S]UNLa^'%&'&" [`TYab[

<]\Pb^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b_^YZWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`b

a`M_[]Q[b\ObY`X_``Xb_Z`aOa`S]U`XbZ]^`\]WMXaZX YaY ^]` Z]^`_a^ _^S Y\TP M_[ Yb`b\Va^bY _[

>3_^Y>3\b[RbZ`aObWSHXb

_Z`aOa`ab[]U`XbP\]TR[_U`b\`XbY\TPa^8bZ`a]^Mb\b Vb_[T\bY _`   _^Y  X _^Y Z]\\b[R]^Ya^P _Z`aOa`ab[Mb\bU]T^Y`]QbZ_

_^Y Q U]\ Pb^`_VSZa^ [TWU_`b _^Y

Q _ _^Y Q U]\

ZWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`b\b[RbZ`aObWSHXbXaPXb[`

_Z`aO_`a]^O_WTb[Mb\bU]T^YU]\X_U`b\a^8bZ`a]^

]U `Xb[b _^`aQa]`aZ[ _^Y  X _U`b\ a^8bZ`a]^ ]U ZWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`b

H_QWbHXba^OaO]bUUbZ`[]UZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^ZXW]\_VRXb^aZ]W\aU_VSZa^IAZWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`bZaR\]UW]B_Za^

Pb^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b_^Y[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^_^YZbU_J]Wa^[]YaTV]^b\S`X\]ZS`b[Z_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[b_Z`aOa`S=_`_

\bR\b[b^``XbVb_^I=^#Yb^]`b[`Xb^TVQb\]UVaZbT[bYa^b_ZXbBRb\aVb^` HTGbSFI=6C4

=\TP[ VPVW HaVb X 7TVQb\ ^ NLLZ`aOa`S

Vb_^I=

CA_WTb

NaR\]UW]B_Za^

N]^`\]W    

     

     C4

    

NXW_\a`X\]VSZa^

N]^`\]W    

     

     C4

     

;aU_VSZa^IA

N]^`\]W    

     

     C4

     C4

:b^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b

N]^`\]W    

     C4

     

     

NWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`b

N]^`\]W    

     C4

     

     C4

NXW]\_VRXb^aZ]W

N]^`\]W    

     

     

     

I]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^

N]^`\]W    

     

     C4

     

NbU_J]Wa^[]YaTV

N]^`\]W    

     

     C4

     C4

(9)

)))#

E_^SZ]VR]T^Y[_W`b\`Xb_Z`aOa`S]U_^b^JSVbQS Z]VQa^a^PMa`Xa`a^_M_S`X_`a^UWTb^Zb[`XbQa^Ya^P ]U[TQ[`\_`b_^Y]\a`[`T\^]Ob\^TVQb\ITQ[`_^Zb[

`X_` \bYTZb _^ b^JSVb _Z`aOa`S a^ `Xa[ M_S _\b G^]M^_[a^XaQa`]\[E_^Sa^XaQa`]\[_\b[TQ[`_^Zb[

`X_`[`\TZ`T\_WWS\b[bVQWb`Xba\b^JSVb"[[TQ[`\_`b QT` ba`Xb\ Y] ^]` \b_Z` ]\ \b_Z` Ob\S [W]MWS

Z]VR_\bYMa`X`Xb[TQ[`\_`bITZXa^XaQa`]\[_\b Z]VV]^WS T[bY `] R\]Qb `Xb ZXbVaZ_W _^Y Z]^U]\V_`a]^_W^_`T\b]U_[TQ[`\_`b Qa^Ya^P[a`b_[

R_\`]U_^bUU]\``]bWTZaY_`b`Xbb^JSVb"[Z_`_WS`aZ VbZX_^a[V  E_^SZXbVaZ_W[_`\bW_`aObWSW]M Y][_Pb[_UUbZ``XbVb`_Q]Wa[V]UQa]`_QS_W`b\a^P

^]\V_Wb^JSVb_Z`aOa`SR_\`aZTW_\WSa^XaQa`a]^]U_

[RbZaUaZb^JSVb  HXbbUUbZ`[Z_^QbY\_V_`aZ _^Y [S[`bVaZ   K^YbbY NL a[]JSVb[ _\b aVR]\`_^` b^JSVb[ a^ Vb`_Q]Wa[V QbZ_T[b `XbS

\bPTW_`b RF a^ V][` `a[[Tb[ NL a^XaQa`]\[ O_\S _ZZ]\Ya^P`]`Xba\_UUa^a`S]UQa^Ya^P`]_R_\`aZTW_\

NL a[]JSVb R]`b^ZS KN U]\ a^XaQa`a^P `X_`

a[]JSVb _^Y RXS[aZ]ZXbVaZ_W R\]Rb\`ab[ MXaZX Z_^a^UWTb^Zb`Xba\`a[[TbYa[`\aQT`a]^_^Y[Z]Rb]U _Z`aOa`S  

K` X_[ Qbb^ \bR]\`bY `X_` `Xb V][` Z]VV]^

a^XaQa`]\[U]\NL_\b[bOb\_WVbYaZ_WY\TP[   K^ _YYa`a]^ []Vb [TWU]^_VaYb Yb\aO_`aOb[

_^`abRaWbR`aZY\TP[_^YVbW_`]^a^X_ObQbb^T[bY QSa^Ob[`aP_`a]^[U]\a^XaQa`a]^]UNL_Z`aOa`S'%&'&"

_^Y '% &'!"   F]MbOb\ `Xb\b M_[ ^]`

VTZXa^U]\V_`a]^_O_aW_QWb]^a^XaQa`a]^]UXTV_^

NLb^JSVb[QS_^`aQa]`aZ[K^`XbR\b[b^`[`TYS`Xb a^Ob[`aP_`a]^]UbUUbZ`[]UZb\`_a^VbYaZ_WY\TP[]^

XTV_^ b\S`X\]ZS`b[ Z_\Q]^aZ _^XSY\_[b K _^Y KK a[]JSVb[M_[R\]R][bY

L^`aQa]`aZ[ _\b _^ aVR]\`_^` P\]TR ]U RX_\V_

ZbT`aZ_W[a^`]Y_S"[VbYaZa^bK^`Xa[[`TYSV_Z\]WaY

_VRXb^aZ]W _Va^]PWaZ][aYb Rb^aZaWWa^ _^Y Qb`_

W_Z`_V Yb\aO_`aOb[ _^`aQa]`aZ[ Mb\b ZX][b^ HXb

ZX][b^ ]U YaUUb\b^` P\]TR[ ]U _^`aQ_Z`b\a_W _^`aQa]`aZ[0 ZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^ ZXW]\_VRXb^aZ]W

\aU_VSZa^IAZWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`bZaR\]UW]B_Za^

Pb^`_VSZa^ [TWU_`b _^Y []YaTV _VRaZaWWa^ _^Y ZbU_J]Wa^[]YaTVMb\bZX][b^U]\`Xba^Ob[`aP_`a]^

]U a^XaQa`a]^ ]\ _Z`aO_`a]^ bUUbZ`[ KN O_WTb[

]Q`_a^bYU]\a^Oa`\][`TYab[]UFNL K_^YFNL KK_\b [X]M^a^H_QWb

HXb_^`aQa]`aZ[bVRW]SbYa^`XbR\b[b^`[`TYSMXaZX _\bZ]VV]^WST[bYa^`Xb\_RS[X]MbYa^XaQa`]\S bUUbZ`[ ]^ `Xb _Z`aOa`S ]U XTV_^ b\S`X\]ZS`b[

Z_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[ba[]b^JSVb[K_^YKK`]O_\a]T[

YbP\bb[ I]YaTV _VRaZaWWa^ M_[ V][` bUUbZ`aOb a^XaQa`]\U]\FNL K_^YFNL KKHXb]Q`_a^bYKN

O_WTb[]U[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^Mb\b VE]^

FNL K_^Y VE]^FNL KKDbSYbVa\b`_W

  _W[] \bR]\`bY `X_` FNL K _^Y FNL KK Mb\b a^XaQa`bYQS[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^NbU_J]Wa^[]YaTVX_Y Va^aVTVbUUbZ`]^FNL K_^YFNL KK  VE _^Y VE\b[RbZ`aObWSMXb^`XbZ]VR_\b

`] ]`Xb\ _^`aQa]`aZ[ :b^`_VSZa^ [TWU_`b X_Y a^XaQa`a]^ bUUbZ` ]^ b_ZX b^JSVb KN A_WTb[ ]U Pb^`_VSZa^[TWU_`bM_[U]T^Y`]QbVE _^YVEF]MbOb\a`a[\bR]\`bY`X_`FNL K_^YFNL KKMb\ba^XaQa`bY_`Pb^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b Z]^Zb^`\_`a]^TR`]VE_^Y_Z`aO_`bY_`TR`]

VE  

K^]\Yb\`]Yb`b\Va^b`Xba^XaQa`a]^[`_`Tb]U`Xb[b Y\TP[ ]^ _ WaOa^P [S[`bV `Xb bUUbZ`[ ]U [_Vb _^`aQa]`aZ[ ]^ NL b^JSVb _Z`aOa`S ]U V]T[b b\S`X\]ZS`b[M_[a^Ob[`aP_`bY'%&'&"<]\'%&'&"

[`TYab[V]T[bb\S`X\]ZS`b[NLM_[Yb`b\Va^bY_`

`X\bb`aVbR]a^`[^_VbWS_^YX_U`b\a^8bZ`a]^

HXb\b[TW`[]U'%&'&" bUUbZ`[]Ub_ZX_^`aQa]`aZ_\b R\b[b^`bYa^H_QWb@T\Y_`_[X]MbY`X_``Xb\ba[

^]Z]\\bW_`a]^Qb`Mbb^`Xb'%&'&" _^Y'%&'!" bUUbZ`[

]Ub_ZX_^`aQa]`aZbBZbR`Rb^aZaWWa^_^YQb`_ W_Z`_V Yb\aO_`aOb[[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^_^YZbU_J]Wa^[]YaTV

\b[RbZ`aObWS K^YbbY ]`Xb\ ZW_[[ ]U _^`aQa]`aZ[

ZaR\]UW]B_Za^ ZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^ \aU_VSZa^ IA



(10)

Pb^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b_^Y ZWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`bMb\b bBXaQa`[`_`a[`aZ_WWS[aP^aUaZ_^`_Z`aO_`a]^bUUbZ`U]\`Xb V]T[bb\S`X\]ZS`b[NL_Z`aOa`S R$F]MbOb\

NL _Z`aOa`S _U`b\ []YaTV _VRaZaWWa^ _^Y ZbU_J]Wa^

[]YaTV _YVa^a[`\_`a]^ [X]MbY [`_`a[`aZ_WWS [aP^aUaZ_^`YbZ\b_[b_`X]UY\TP_RRWaZ_`a]^'%&'&"

R6  _^Y  \b[RbZ`aObWS K^ _YYa`a]^

ZaR\]UW]B_Za^ ZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^ _^Y \aU_VSZa^ IA a^Z\b_[bY`Xb_Z`aOa`S]UNLa^'%&'&" [`TYab[

<]\Pb^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b_Va^]PWaZ][aYbYb\aO_`aOb _^`aQa]`aZ[a`M_[]Q[b\ObY`X_`MXaWb`Xb_Z`aOa`S]U

`XbVNLM_[a^Z\b_[bY_`X`Xb_Z`aOa`SYbZ\b_[b

 X _U`b\ Y\TP a^8bZ`a]^ F]MbOb\ `Xb XaPXb[`

_Z`aO_`a]^O_WTb[Mb\bU]T^YU]\X_U`b\a^8bZ`a]^

]U `Xb[b _^`aQa]`aZ[ _^Y  X _U`b\ a^8bZ`a]^ ]U ZWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`b@T\\b[TW`[Mb\b[TRR]\`bY QS_[`TYSMXaZXa[[X]MbY`X_`\_`b\S`X\]ZS`b[NL _Z`aOa`Sa^XaQa`bYQSPb^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b_U`b\X_^Y

XY\TP_YVa^a[`\_`a]^  

NXW]\_VRXb^aZ]WX_Ya^XaQa`a]^bUUbZ`]^NLa^'%

&'!" [`TYab[MXb\b_[a`Y]b[^]`[X]M_^SbUUbZ`]U

`Xbb^JSVb'%&'&"$ LZ`T_WWSV]T[bNL_Z`aOa`SM_[

_Z`aO_`bY QS ZXW]\_VRXb^aZ]W  X _U`b\ Y\TP _YVa^a[`\_`a]^QT`a`a[^]`[`_`a[`aZ_WWS[aP^aUaZ_^`

@^`XbZ]^`\_\S]^b]U`Xb'%&'&" \b[TW`[[TRR]\`bY '%&'!" Y_`_Cb^aZaWWa^_^YQb`_ W_Z`_VYb\aO_`aOb _^`aQa]`aZ[^_Vb]U[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^_^YZbU_J]Wa^

[]YaTVYbZ\b_[bY`Xb_Z`aOa`S]UVNL_U`b\XY\TP a^8bZ`a]^HXa[a^XaQa`a]^M_[[`[`a[`aZ_WWS[aP^aUaZ_^`

R4

K`a[Pb^b\_WWS\bZ]P^aJbY`X_`NLZ]^`\]W[`XbQTWG]U Z_\Q]^ Ya]BaYb bBZX_^Pb Qb`Mbb^ QW]]Y _^Y

`a[[Tb[_[MbWW_[`Xb\bPTW_`a]^]UR\]`]^_^Y]`Xb\

a]^ V]ObVb^`[ Qb`Mbb^ ZbWW[ _^Y bB`\_ZbWWTW_\

UWTaY[ LWW ]U `Xb NL a[]JSVb[ _\b _W[] YbbRWS a^O]WObYa^_P\b_`^TVQb\]U[bZ\b`]\S_Z`aOa`ab[

a^ZWTYa^PUWTaYV]ObVb^`[  Ia^ZbNLa[_Ob\S aVR]\`_^`b^JSVbU]\`XbQ]YS`Xba^XaQa`a]^bUUbZ`[

]U`Xb[bVbYaZ_WY\TP[[X]TWYQbZ]^[aYb\bYU]\^]`

]^WS`Xbb\S`X\]ZS`bFNL K_^YFNL KKa[]JSVb[QT`

_W[]_WWNLa[]JSVb[<]\bB_VRWba^`M]\bZb^`

[`TYab[ WaOb\ `]`_W NL NLK NLKK NLKKK NLKA _Z`aOa`S M_[ YaVa^a[XbY a^ [`\bR`]J]`]Za^ a^YTZbY Ya_Qb`aZ \_`[   HXb[b [`TYab[ _W[]

YbV]^[`\_`bY PWTZ]^b]Pb^b[a[ _^Y T\b_Pb^b[a[

Ma`X _^ a^Z\b_[b a^ a[]JSVb NL A _Z`aOa`S a^

XbR_`]ZS`b[   HXbS X_Ob [X]M^ RF Ya[b-TaWaQ\aTVa^`Xb\_`WaOb\`X_`Z]TWYQbbBRW_a^bY QS`XbZX_^Pb[a^NL_Z`aOa`SK^_YYa`a]^V_^S]U

`Xb [aYb bUUbZ`[ ]Q[b\ObY _\b R\]Q_QWS YTb `]

a^XaQa`a]^ ]U NL a[]JSVb[ <]\ bB_VRWb `Xb

\b[Ra\_`]\S _ZaY][a[ a[ R\]Q_QWS \b[R]^[aQWb U]\

[]Vb ]U `Xb [aYb \b_Z`a]^[ ]Q[b\ObY YT\a^P _Zb`_J]W_VaYb`Xb\_RS[TZX_[U_`aPTbXb_Y_ZXb

`_[`b[b^[_`a]^[_^YU]\`XbYa[`\b[[a^`XbZX\]^aZ WT^Pb\  <]\b_ZXY\TP[[TPPb[`a]^Y][_Pba^

VbYaZ_W `\b_`Vb^` a[ ^b_\WS [Ta`_QWb U]\ Z_\Q]^aZ _^XSY\_[bb^JSVb_Z`aOa`SbBZbR`[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^

_^YZbU_J]Wa^[]YaTVU\]V'%&'&" [`TYab[

LZZ]\Ya^P `] ]T\ \b[TW`[ <aPT\b  `Xb T[b ]U ZaR\]UW]B_Za^ ZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^ \aU_VSZa^ IA

Pb^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b_^YZWa^Y_VSZa^RX][RX_`b_`

`Xb[TPPb[`bYZ]^Zb^`\_`a]^a^Z\b_[bY`Xb_Z`aOa`ab[

]U NL b^JSVb F]MbOb\ `Xb T[b ]U []YaTV _VRaZaWWa^_^YZbU_J]Wa^[]YaTV_``Xb[TPPb[`bY Z]^Zb^`\_`a]^a^XaQa`bY`Xb_Z`aOa`ab[]UNLb^JSVb

HXb\bU]\b `Xb T[b ]U []YaTV _VRaZaWWa^ _^Y ZbU_J]Wa^[]YaTVZ_^^]`Qb\bZ]VVb^YbYU]\`Xa[

b^JSVb

=aUUb\b^`a_W [b^[a`aOa`S ]U ]\P_^a[V NL[ VaPX` Qb YbRb^Ya^P]^_^TVQb\]UU_Z`]\[K`a[R][[aQWb`X_`

YaUUb\b^Zb[a^a^XaQa`a]^_^Y_Z`aO_`a]^\]]`bYa^`Xb YaUUb\b^Zb[a^Qa^Ya^P_UUa^a`S]U`Xb_^`aQa]`aZ[]\

Vb`_Q]WSJa^PR\]YTZ``]`Xbb^JSVb N]^[b-Tb^`WS

Z_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[bb^JSVb_Z`aOa`SM_[a^XaQa`bY QS`XbT[b]Ub_ZXY\TPU]\ '%&'!" [`TYab[QbZ_T[b ]U`XbRT\bb^JSVba[V]\b[b^[a`aObU]\`Xb]T`[aYb bUUbZ`[F]MbOb\`Xb[b_^`aQa]`aZ[X_Y^]`a^XaQa`a]^

bUUbZ`[]^V]T[bb\S`X\]ZS`b[Z_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[b



(11)

bBZbR`[]YaTV_VRaZaWWa^_^YZbU_J]Wa^[]YaTV@^

`XbZ]^`\_\S`Xb[b_^`aQa]`aZ[X_Y_Z`aO_`a]^bUUbZ`

]^V]T[bZ_\Q]^aZ_^XSY\_[b_Z`aOa`SU\]V'%&'&"

[`TYab[HXb\bU]\bZaR\]UW]B_Za^ZXW_\a`X\]VSZa^

\aU_VSZa^IAPb^`_VSZa^[TWU_`b_^YZWa^Y_VSZa^

RX][RX_`b Z_^ Qb \bZ]VVb^YbY U]\ `Xb T[b ]U VbYaZ_W`\b_`Vb^`U]\`Xa[b^JSVb

*# +++#%

HXa[ M]\G M_[ [TRR]\`bY QS D_WaGb[a\ 3^aOb\[a`S

;b[b_\ZX C\]8bZ`[  _^Y  HXb _T`X]\[M]TWYWaGb`]`X_^G`]D_WaGb[a\3^aOb\[a`S

;b[b_\ZXNb^`b\]ULRRWabYIZab^Zb[ D3;NLIU]\

R\]OaYa^P`Xb\b[b_\ZXU_ZaWa`ab[

+++#+)

 ITRT\_^ NH IZ]JJ_U_O_ L N]^M_S ? N_\Q]^aZ L^XSY\_[b*K`[K^XaQa`]\[_^YLZ`aO_`]\[N;NC\b[[6 D]Z_;_`]^7bM1]\G5]^Y]^

 IWS2IFTC1 L^^T;bODa]ZXbV

 C_[`]\bG]O_IC_\GGaW_IC_[`]\bG?ITRT\_^N

H?>^JSVbK^XaQEbYNXbV 

 ITRT\_^NHIZ]JJ_U_O_LN_[a^aLEbY;b[

;bO

 2a^TV?1IZ]JJ_U_O_LE]^`b\]?5ITRT\_^N

H>BRb\`@Ra^HXb\C_` 

 IZ]JJ_U_O_LE_[`\]W]\b^J]LITRT\_^NH>BRb\`

@Ra^HXb\C_` 

 5bX`]^b^ ? IXb^ D AaXa^b^ E N_[a^a L

IZ]JJ_U_O_LITRT\_^NHC_\GGaW_L9I__\^a]?

9aObW_L?2_XbbYLIWS2IC_\GGaW_I?Da]W

NXbV

 <T8aG_M_ LY_ZXa97a[XaV]\aKH_PTZXaH@^a[XaI

?Da]WNXbV 

 <T8aG_M_ LY_ZXa97a[XaV]\aKH_PTZXaH@^a[XaI

:b^]VaZ[

 7a[XaV]\a K ATWW] = K^^]Zb^`a L IZ]JJ_U_O_ L

E_[`\]W]\b^J]L ITRT\_^ NH ? EbY NXbV 



 ATWW]=<\_^ZXaE:_WW]\a>L^`bW?IZ]JJ_U_O_

LITRT\_^NH ?EbYNXbV

 2bQb\LN_[a^aLFba^bL9TX^=ITRT\_^NH

IZ]JJ_U_O_L9WbQb: ?EbYNXbV  

 ATWW]=A]aRa]?K^^]Zb^`aL;aOb\_N;_^GaF

IZ]JJ_U_O_L9_aW_9ITRT\_^NHDa]]\PEbY

NXbV5b`` 

 IO_[`]O_>FTWaG]O_L;_U_8]O_Ec_`]OaZ]O_E

:aQ_YTWa^]O_LN_[a^aLNbZZXaLIZ]JJ_U_O_L

ITRT\_^NHC_[`]\bG?C_[`]\bG]O_I <>DI5b``



 NbZZXaLFTWaG]O_LC_[`]\bG?C_[`]\bG]O_I

IZ]JJ_U_O_L 2a^TV ?1 E]^`b\] ?5 ITRT\_^

NH?EbYNXbV 

 C_\Ta;:_VQa\99EbX\]`\_CCDa]ZXbVK^` 



 C_\Ta;:_VQa\99N\TJKF][`b^L@Da]ZXbV

K^` 

 F_^^bY]bZXbH5_J_\]E=bWP_Y]L:D]a`_\YN

5_Z]T\D:\T^UbWY?CNWa^IZa 

 Aa`_WbLE E]^[b\\_` ?E N_[`aWX] C ;]Y\aPTbJ

>EN]VRDa]ZXbVCXS[a]WC_\`N 

 DbSYbVa\ ) NaUZa E @JVb^ K @GT\]PWT E>E

@JYbVa\F9TU\bOa]PWT@KCX_\V_Z]W;b[ 



 DbSYbVa\)NaUZaE9TU\bOa]PWT@KDTSTG]GT\]PWT

E>Da]WCX_\VDTWW  

 5TG_Z[ : @X^] E bY[ ;bZb^` C\]P\b[[ a^ `Xb NXbVaZ_WIS^`Xb[a[]UL^`aQa]`aZ[Db\Wa^6IR\a^Pb\ Ab\W_P



 ?_Vb[ 5E 9_`Xb\a^b E FaWWb\ E=

MMMbVbYaZa^bZ]VbVb\P`]RaZX`V

 D\]M^L:CT\bLRRWNXbV 

 CaZGb\a^P59@"N]^^]\=EL^Yb\[]^=D_a\_^

LN<baPa^;=NXb\\S?= ?K^UbZ`=a[



 HT\ZGENW_\G;LDb_`SF7F]WVb[999_\^bS

22;bWWb\5D?K^UbZ`=a[ 

 Ia^PXOaIEFb_WYL<:_YbQT[ZXFF;b[^aZG

E>=aU_Ja]5H5ba`JEL?5_QNWa^EbY 



 EbYb\DE_WVQ]\PLI2b\[_WW?>BRb\`_EbYaZ_



 F]^8]H2_`_^_QbL?R^?L^`aQa]` 



(12)

 9]\^PT`XE59T^a^NE ?K^UbZ`=a[$   



 F_WW:>9b^^SL= N_WZaUHa[[TbK^`   



 f]Q_^ LH 7_WQ_^`]PWT D f.W E1 dJYbVa\ F

9eU\bOa] WT@KH\?EbYIZa  

 L\[W_^ @ 7_WQ_^`]PWT D =bVa\ 7 @JYbVa\ F

9TU\bOa] WT@KH\]R?EbYIZa 

 D\_YU]\YEEL^_WDa]ZXbV  

 5_bVVWa=97_`T\b  

 2aWQT\9EL^Yb\[]^7:?Da]WNXbV 



 A]b`=A]b`?:Da]ZXbVa[`\S?]X^2aWbS+I]^[

7bM1]\G

 F]ZX[`b\ ;E 9_`b[ E 'T_[`bW ?E Eb`_Q]WaZ K^XaQa`]\[O]W*LZ_YbVaZC\b[[7bM1]\GRR*



 NX\a[`b^[b^:E@W[]^=;abYbWD>^Oa\]^;b[

 

 DbSYbVa\I:TWZa^K ?>^JSVbK^XaQEbYNXbV

LR\  

 L\[W_^@1_V_^N>\Jb^Pa^EH_W_^K DTWWCT\b LRRWIZa  

 D]`\%<D]`\%ND]`\<:\][:I`]\bSDH bY[

N_\Q]^aZ _^XSY\_[b 2ba^XbaV6 ANF

Ab\W_P[Pb[bWW[ZX_U`

 =]YP[]^I?2_`U]\YEL\ZXDa]ZXbVDa]RXS 



 E]S^aX_^?D>^^a[IDa]ZXbV?

 N_\`b\ 7= =]YP[]^ I? 'T_^` CL Da]ZXaV

Da]RXS[LZ`_

 2a[`\_^Y C? 5a^Y-Oa[` L a^ N_\Q]^aZ _^XSY\_[b

2ba^XbaV6ANFAb\W_P[Pb[bWW[ZX_U`*



Referanslar

Benzer Belgeler

Biyodizelin en genel tanımı; hayvansal ve bitkisel atıkların eklenmesiyle üretilen dizel yakıttır. Bilimsel olarak tanımlanırsa; organik olan yağların baz ve alkol ile

Bolu İli Dörtdivan İlçesinde aile planlaması yöntem kullanma sıklığını belirlemek ve aile planlaması açısından kadınların risk durumunun; 15-49 Yaş Kadın İzlem

Bu çalışma Bolu ilindeki çift toynaklı (Artiodactyla) memeli türlerinin belirlenmesi zamansal ve mekansal bilgilerinin ortaya konulması için yapılmıştır.. Bolu

Bu araştırmada, Bolu ekolojik koşullarında 18 ekmeklik buğday çeşidi tane verimi, verim unsurları ve bazı kalite özellikleri yönünden incelenerek, bölge

Alanda tespit edilen Boz ayılar (a: Üretim faaliyeti öncesi, b: Üretim faaliyeti sonrası, c, d: beslenme amaçlı alanı kullanması).. Alanı sonbaharda daha yoğun

45,X/46,XY mosaicism can be seen in cases with normal male external genitalia.. This phenotype is generally related with bilateral testes and possible higher number of the cell

Bu çalışmada boyunda kitle şikâyeti ile gelen ve hiyalin vasküler tip Castleman hastalığı tanısı konulan bir olgu sunuldu.. Anahtar kelimeler:

The effects of treatment temperature and time on mass loss, wood density, chemical changes, and decay resistance were evaluated using an ANOVA and Duncan’s comparison test..