• Sonuç bulunamadı

View of Twitter Sentiment Analysis Based On Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "View of Twitter Sentiment Analysis Based On Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network"

Copied!
9
0
0

Yükleniyor.... (view fulltext now)

Tam metin

(1)

2449

Twitter Sentiment Analysis Based On Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network

Dr.P.Kavitha a

aAssistant Professor, Department Of Computer Science, Sri.Sharadha College for Women, Perambalur-621113 Article History: Received: 10 January 2021; Revised: 12 February 2021; Accepted: 27 March 2021;

Published online: 20 April 2021

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Abstract: Deep learning classification has recently shown its Twitter logs promises in recent times. Many of the works are

emotional on Twitter analysis is complete, but have not done the emotional impact survey sites on Twitter. In social media such as Twitter, Sentiment analysis has become a very important and difficult task. This environment requires a non-traditional method, such as data/tweet length, misspellings, abbreviations and special characters and properties of sentiment analysis tasks. Also, social media sentiment analysis is one of many interesting applications of basic questions. To overcome the issues in this work proposed, the method Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network (ADRNN) using for this analysis is useful in evaluating microblogging Twitter data analysis of information. In the case of social network data, deep learning analyzes large amounts of data to achieve the effect of the traditional top machine learning algorithm. Concatenated text and location with Twitter sentiment analysis, especially Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network (ADRNN) feature vectors work, deep learning classification methods can be used.To make full use of these data, developing a real-time Twitter sentiment analysis and visualization system. This is a Web application. Its purpose is a programming application package using the Python language to obtain real-time data from Twitter tags and keywords to use mining methods for Application Programming Interface (API) for tweets analysis. Twitter data is generated by applying different weighting schemes to improve the accuracy and F1 Score of the estimated classification.

Keywords: Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network (ADRNN), Deep Learning Classification, Sentiment Analysis, Twitter

Classification, Twitter Data, Accuracy, Application Programming Interfaces (APIs). 1. Introduction

Microblogging is a fast-growing online platform that allows people to write, publish, update and read short text messages known as tweets. By micro-blog, users can share views on specific topics, views and ideas. In general, Sentiment Analysis (SA) identifies and classifies the document in a polar, sentence and phrase level of the specified text. For example, the innovation in numerous fields, internet business, medication, legislative issues, and diversion, shows minority. Their item surveys and pick the best item dependent on popular assessment buyer opinion investigation is valuable to act as an illustration for organizations to screen buyers. The primary assignment of Twitter tweets in SA is to decide if it is positive or negative suppositions. Twitter estimation investigation's principal challenge is: tweets generally write in casual language give hints about the restricted feelings. Those abbreviations and shortened forms are broadly utilized on Twitter short messages.

Today, in the age of the Internet, individuals have changed the way they express their perspectives. Today, many individuals are utilizing Facebook, Twitter, Google Plus and other informal communication locales. To communicate their thoughts through online gatherings, item survey locales, perspectives and conclusions, blog articles, data for web-based media, etc. Online people group, permit buyers educated and persuasive intelligent media. Online Media Updates blog through publicizing microblogging condition of contact with the client leave remarks and different structures gives a stage produce a ton of feeling information to give ventures a chance. It depends vigorously on client-produced content on the web, principally for dynamic. For instance, on the off chance that somebody needs to purchase an item or utilization any assistance, they initially talk about its quest for online audits before web-based media and settle on a choice. Brokedown by various client-created content is too huge for the normal client. An assortment of assessment investigation innovation is broadly utilized because it requires Sentiment Analysis (SA) advice the client on the off chance that they have sufficient data on the items before they get it. Promoting and business investigation utilizing the information to see how their client necessities can convey their items and administrations.

Text data recovery innovation is mostly centered on looking for realities and information for the current examination. The truth of the matter is, there are a few fixings have required, yet the declaration of the emotional idea of a portion of the other content. The substance of the primary concerns, emotions, assessment, mentalities, feelings, structure the center of Sentiment Analysis (SA). It offers many provoking freedoms to grow new applications, predominantly because of the enormous data development from online sources like interpersonal organizations and blogs. For instance, the framework proposed by suggesting project recommendations might be, for example, to utilize such slant investigation of these activities, positive or negative perspectives is anticipated.

(2)

2450

2. Related work

Twitter slant examination has become an intriguing issue as of late. When confronted with the examination of existing arrangements with short and dubious Twitter news, Twitter is essentially thinking about the content of the message data (L. Wang, J. Niu 2020). Late investigations have shown that passionate extremity Twitter news Twitter is firmly identified with the enthusiastic dispersion model (S. E. Saad 2019). Twitter theme examination of information (microblogging) to the Twitter assessment investigation to separate the client's mindset, above, is developing quickly. Numerous analysts like to utilize calculations for this examination (Z. Jianqiang, 2018). Twitter notoriety examination innovation approaches studying public conclusions on their related exercises and items (M. Bibi et al., 2018). Most examinations have zeroed in on the enthusiastic capacity got by investigating the lexical and syntactic highlights. These capacities by passionate words, emojis, outcry points, and unmistakably are communicated as above (Z. Jianqiang 2017). Measurement decrease guarantees low computational intricacy and execution in the grouping interaction. Twitter information in each call and may not reflect human reactions and having trademark esteem (M. Bouazizi 2017). The vast majority of the current exploration on the Twitter conclusion examination zeroed in on the extraction of new passionate characteristics (H. T. Phan, V. C2020). Nonetheless, it chooses the pretreatment strategies and will be disregarded. Credit examination and assessment mining person-to-person communication presents late exploration center (S. M. Jimenez Zafra, 2019). Nonetheless, the standing of programmed examination, assessment mining informal communities, miniature blog and site to gather text, the greater part of the most recent innovation and exploration for both parallel grouping (i.e., "positive" and "negative") (T. Hu, 2020). Three sorts (ie, named "positive", "negative" and "impartial") text. Increment the measure of substance produced by Twitter clients tweet prompted the standing investigation, and become enthusiastic state data fundamental device for removing Twitter clients (J. Zhou, 2020)

Tweets order is a notable standing investigation undertakingsthe vast majority of the examinations for educators' advancement and solo framework isn't an excess of consideration regarding some phonetic wonders, like negative (Q. Lu, 2020). The passionate effect of each part of individuals' lives fundamentally affects their emotional wellness. The neighborhood client extricates information from geo-tweet feelings from December 2016 and examines it according to the perspective of existence (F. Iqbal et al., 2019). Its motivation is to level the enthusiastic viewpoint dissected to decide the extremity focus in this specific circumstance. Most past estimation examination models are typically reliant on the lack of extraction of the neighborhood and significant distance (M. A. Tocoglu, 2019). Past investigations didn't consider the effect of the guidelines of language structure examination of the perspective proportion of the emotional level. Also, the consideration component is intelligent too simple to even think about, causing us to notice data and foundation topics (M. U. Salur 2020). Notion examination has become a significant assessment digging innovation for the quick advancement of Internet innovation and web-based media. The adequacy of the different characterizations of enthusiastic ongoing examinations has shown that taking in calculation from a basic word reference-based technique is more unpredictable.

The investigation of text information via web-based media is turning out to be increasingly more significant because it contains the most recent data that somebody thought of. Additionally, feelings are the most important piece of human correspondence, where notion examination is a kind of data extraction measure that distinguishes a given book's enthusiastic condition (S. Amin et al., 2020). Associations utilize enormous scope individual criticism on occasions, items, and administrations, for example, web-based media stages like Twitter and Facebook. Nonetheless, conclusion characterization assumes a significant part in assessing client criticism. With the expanding utilization of information of Web 2.0 and web-based media devices, for example, these blog administrations stage and organization extraction and scattering of individual wellbeing data to challenge public feeling over the previous decade, it is turning into a more normal objective Twitter notoriety examination innovation gives an approach to explore public assessment on their related exercises and items (Z. Jianqiang, 2018). Most tweets have zeroed in on the capacity acquired by investigating the lexical and syntactic highlights.

3. Materials and Method

Sentiment classification task Tweets is notoriously difficult because it is simple and commonly used in non-standard

spelling and languages. Analysis using Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network (ADRNN) and many sentiment classification systems show a very accurate level, but most of the data has not been on Twitter for testing. Since the Twitter Application Programming Interface (API)analysis sentiment tweets for database and collecting data used as a source opinioned, it is used to analyze, retrieve, and preprocess after the analysis is based on emotion different approaches. Sentiment analysis method applied to the output of each message to all servers of the proposed

(3)

2451

standardized tweets positive emotion and negative emotion based on the Twitter chat wherein the total display data obtained by preprocessing.

Figure 1: Proposed diagram for Twitter sentiment Analysis

Figure 1 describes the proposed diagram for Twitter sentiment analysis using the data collection using API for large datasets is not available, so hence extract the Twitter API from the data and preprocessing the data using the training dataset For reading and writing the data to the database classifying the tweets in the Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network (ADRNN) classifying the output determine the Sentiment analysis.

3.1 Data collection

The data set collected from Twitter API to use tweets sentiment analysis for the data is collected the positive or

negative tweets. The data set is well-known, published in Natural Language Toolkit (NLTK) corpus resources, and has been widely analyzed in many studies. The total corpus size of 12000 Twitter posts from the 7000 positive 7000 negative tweets. For this task, have to collect and prepare data sets: one set contains 8000 tweets. This set will be used to train the model. Despite the 4000 Tweets from another group, but the group established a sentiment analysis classification model. Its main purpose is to analyze tweets' sentiment positive and classified as high, moderate, positive and neutral. Negative depending on the Tweets data collections. In the first phase of this work, data collection characteristics after use or tokens. As for the Score and the label tweet, a new approach has been proposed.

Stage 1: Assuming that each call and is classified as positive and negative call and depending on, and maybe based on

the call and the number of emoticons positive or negative word. This method allows calculating the polarization of each beep. Ignored the tweet gap in collection time because it is difficult and may affect the results.

Stage 2: Each tweet (t) is a value assigned to the call and each function's polarity in the overall value of the tweet data.

3.2 Data Preprocessing

Twitter API

Data

Pre-processing

Positive

Write Tweets

Sentiment

Analysis

Results Output

Data collection

Database

Adaptive Deep

Recurrent Neural

Network (ADRNN)

classifiers

Classification

Output

Data to

classify

Tweets

Read Tweets

Write

To DB

Positive

(4)

2452

Twitter contains many opinions on this work in the study of the use of the data: in the choice of data sets via Twitter two-class marks, different users' different ways have said. Negative and positive attributes and data make it easy for reputation analysis to observe various functions' effects. Inconsistent and redundant raw data is very sensitive before feature extraction, chirping pretreatment. Due to the use of slang, Uniform Resource Locator (URL) and delete the misspelled word. To solve the problem due to slang, a dictionary has been maintained, has the same meaning instead of words.Tweets are first preprocessed and then passed to the classification. Delete correction for all the URL (for example www.xyz.com), the hashtag (e.g. #topic), target (@UserName) spelling. Repeat the sequence of letters that should be treated in exchange for their emotional emoticons. Delete the non-English tweet (abbreviation dictionary can be used) all punctuation, symbols and abbreviations expanding digital stop words and remove deleted.

3.3 Application programming Interface (API)

Perform better and the amount of extracted entities in the API quality. , Collected over time by the Python using

Twitter Application Programming Interface (API) to create a tweet. Python is automatically calculated frequency push message is transferred per second, wherein - the top of the message based on the frequency chirping, sorted and stored in the specified database. It collects in a different database as the data needs to be stored only in Twitter Python API and contains the latest Twitter messages.Distribution and value of each word Tweet dictionaries JSON file from the match. As a vocabulary dictionary word, it cannot assign a value from each word's tweet limit. But the results to be obtained can be analyzed for each tweet, mean positive or negative, python language of science, and so on.

3.4 Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network (ADRNN) For Sentiment Analysis

The performance of neural networks is analyzed by deep emotion to microblogging. Thus, in addition to the tweet,

microblogging is based on a data set with anAdaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network (ADRNN). The tweet is automatically marked using a deep emotion class learning with a deep learning analysis. Assessment is a set of experiments for each architecture. The results showed that automatically tweet comments enabled.The feature set is integrated into the deep convolution neural network forecasting of training and emotional classification label. The accuracy of the experimental measures of the Twitter data set of models compared to baseline model performance results shows good sentiment classification.

(5)

2453

Figure 2 shows the Structure for typical Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network architecture used in connecting the input layers. The original at every layer of the time the connection is superimposed ADRNN. For ADRNN, hidden activation at the level L and the time t.

Algorithm steps

Input: Test Tweets

Output: Sentiment Tweets analysis accuracy score

Step1: Begin

Step 2: Pre-processing procedure

Enter the query string

Until the data stream is retrieved from the Twitter API Tweet filter information in English

Remove duplicate tweets Case conversion for each tweet

Delete the Twitter sign (# topic, @ username, retweets (RT)) Delete URL ( "HTTP: // URL")

Step 3: Training the data

Step 4: Procedure Sentiment Classification (Feature):

Classify tweet using Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network (ADRNN)

Step 5: Positive count and Negative Count

If (Predict Positive count) Then

Positive_Count +=1; [positive=Positive _count/Positive-count+Negative-count] Else

Negative_Count+=1;[Negative=Negative_count/Positive-count+Negative-count] End

Step 6:Stop

API-Application Programming Interface, ADRNN- Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network,and The system uses training data to train tweets in a set of tests to test your system's tweets. Integrated identify each base classifier determines each tweet the test of emotions (positive/negative). Further, each base classifier report classification is based on testing data (test beep) is calculated. All steps were calculated for each of the positive and negative tweets.

(6)

2454

4. Result and discussion

The experiment results and two network positive tasks: 1) Positive/Negative pairs and 2) positive, neutral and negative pairs. The sentiment analysis tool collects and searches the first user's Twitter website data to query it. ADRNN algorithm to find the emotional Score for each tweet. One hundred fifty tweets criteria relevant maximum current model can analyze the latest tweets and display the user's results.

Table 1: Simulation Parameters for the proposed method

Parameters Values

Simulation Language Python

Simulation Tool Anaconda

Dataset Tweets dataset

Num. of. Tweets data 1500

Training Data 1000

Testing data 500

Table 1 describes the proposed method analysis of the Sentiment accuracy score predicting the dataset's collection

using the positive, negative and Neutral tweets to be analyzed.

Figure 3: Analysis of Accuracy

Figure 3: shows the accuracy score for sentiment analysis, comparing the existing and proposed method; in the

proposed method, Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network (ADRNN) accuracy score is 84%. 0 20 40 60 80 100 1 0 0 2 0 0 3 0 0 4 0 0 5 0 0 A C C UR A C Y IN % NO.OF.TWEET LOGS

A N A LY S I S O F A C C U R A C Y

(7)

2455

Figure 4: Analysis of F1-Measure

Figure 4: shows the analysis of the F1 measures the false rate for tweets Sentiment Analysis. The proposed

method reduces the false rates by 30% using in Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network (ADRNN) Algorithm.

Figure 5: Analysis of the Time complexity

Figure 5 shows the time complexity based on analyzing the tweets predicting time. The proposed algorithm of

Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network (ADRNN) reduces the time 47sec timetaken for tweets analysis.

5. Conclusion

The importance of social network analysis and applications in various fields. It implements a Python program to implement and Twitter as the center, sentimental analysis. Twitter sentiment analysis neutral emotion needs to be improved and achieve significantly higher and verify the data classification's validity microblogging some pre-set method. The results showed that the URL removal with minimal impact removed stop words removed and the number of classifier performance. Also, it extends the negative and increases the classification accuracy of abbreviations that can be exchanged.The classification process itself has been successful with an Adaptive Deep Recurrent Neural Network(ADRNN) Analysis with an accuracy of 84%, an F1-measure is 30%,and Time complexity is reduced in 47

10 20 30 40 50 60 100 200 300 400 500 Ti m e i n Se c No.of.Tweet logs

Time complexity

(8)

2456

sec. However, it can be further improved, feels like an overview of the work in the future. This differs from the data classification experiment. Twitter and other social media data are essential that people complain about posting their views on the issues discussed current issues in real time. They use the product to express positive feelings in how many companies manufacture products and acquire a general sense of online data sentiment.

References

1. Aroulanandam, V.V., Latchoumi, T.P., Bhavya, B., Sultana, S.S. (2019). Object detection in convolution neural networks using iterative refinements. Revue d'Intelligence Artificielle, Vol. 33, No. 5, pp. 367-372. https://doi.org/10.18280/ria.330506

2. Amin .S et al., (2020) "Recurrent Neural Networks With TF-IDF Embedding Technique for Detection and Classification in Tweets of Dengue Disease," in IEEE Access, 8, pp. 131522-131533, 2020, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2020.3009058.

3. Balamurugan, K., Uthayakumar, M., Ramakrishna, M. and Pillai, U.T.S., 2020. Air jet Erosion studies on mg/SiC composite. Silicon, 12(2), pp.413-423.

4. Balamurugan, K., 2020. Compressive Property Examination on Poly Lactic Acid-Copper Composite Filament in Fused Deposition Model–A Green Manufacturing Process. Journal of Green Engineering, 10, pp.843-852. 5. Bibi .M et al., (2019) "Class Association and Attribute Relevancy Based Imputation Algorithm to Reduce

Twitter Data for Optimal Sentiment Analysis," in IEEE Access, 7, pp. 136535-136544,doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2942112.

6. Bouazizi .M and T. Ohtsuki, (2017) "A Pattern-Based Approach for Multi-Class Sentiment Analysis in Twitter," in IEEE Access, 5, pp. 20617-20639, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2017.2740982.

7. Bhasha, A.C. and Balamurugan, K., 2020, July. Multi-objective optimization of high-speed end milling on Al6061/3% RHA/6% TiC reinforced hybrid composite using Taguchi coupled GRA. In 2020 International Conference on Computational Intelligence for Smart Power System and Sustainable Energy (CISPSSE) (pp. 1-6). IEEE.

8. Garikipati P., Balamurugan K. (2021) Abrasive Water Jet Machining Studies on AlSi7+63%SiC Hybrid Composite. In: Arockiarajan A., Duraiselvam M., Raju R. (eds) Advances in Industrial Automation and Smart Manufacturing. Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering. Springer, Singapore.

https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-15-4739-3_66

9. Gowthaman, S., Balamurugan, K., Kumar, P.M., Ali, S.A., Kumar, K.M. and Gopal, N.V.R., 2018. Electrical discharge machining studies on monel-super alloy. Procedia Manufacturing, 20, pp.386-391.

10. Hu .T, B. She, L. Duan, H. Yue and J. Clunis, (2020) "A Systematic Spatial and Temporal Sentiment Analysis on Geo-Tweets," in IEEE Access, 8, pp. 8658-8667, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2961100.

11. Iqbal .F et al., (2019) "A Hybrid Framework for Sentiment Analysis Using Genetic Algorithm Based Feature Reduction," in IEEE Access, 7, pp. 14637-14652, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2892852.

12. Jimenez Zafra .S .M, M. T. Martin Valdivia, E. Martinez Camara and L. A. Urena Lopez,(2019) "Studying the Scope of Negation for Spanish Sentiment Analysis on Twitter," in IEEE Transactions on Affective Computing, 10(1), pp. 129-141, doi: 10.1109/TAFFC.2017.2693968.

13. Jianqiang .Z, G. Xiaolin and Z. Xuejun,(2018) "Deep Convolution Neural Networks for Twitter Sentiment Analysis," in IEEE Access, 6, pp. 23253-23260, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2017.2776930.

14. Jianqiang .Z and G. Xiaolin,(2017) "Comparison Research on Text Pre-processing Methods on Twitter Sentiment Analysis," in IEEE Access, 5, pp. 2870-2879, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2017.2672677.

15. Jianqiang .Z, G. Xiaolin and Z. Xuejun, (2018) "Deep Convolution Neural Networks for Twitter Sentiment Analysis," in IEEE Access, 6, pp. 23253-23260, , doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2017.2776930.

16. Lu .Q, Z. Zhu, D. Zhang, W. Wu and Q. Guo, "Interactive Rule Attention Network for Aspect-Level Sentiment Analysis," in IEEE Access, 8, pp. 52505-52516, 2020, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2020.2981139.

17. Phan .H .T, V. C. Tran, N. T. Nguyen and D. Hwang, (2020) "Improving the Performance of Sentiment Analysis of Tweets Containing Fuzzy Sentiment Using the Feature Ensemble Model," in IEEE Access, 8, pp. 14630-14641, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2963702.

18. Ranjeeth, S., Latchoumi, T.P., Sivaram, M., Jayanthiladevi, A. and Kumar, T.S., 2019, December. Predicting Student Performance with ANNQ3H: A Case Study in Secondary Education. In 2019 International Conference on Computational Intelligence and Knowledge Economy (ICCIKE) (pp. 603-607). IEEE.

(9)

2457

19. Salur .M. U and I. Aydin,(2020) "A Novel Hybrid Deep Learning Model for Sentiment Classification," in

IEEE Access, vol. 8, pp. 58080-58093, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2020.2982538.

20. Salur .M. U and I. Aydin,(2020) "A Novel Hybrid Deep Learning Model for Sentiment Classification," in IEEE Access, 8, pp. 58080-58093, , doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2020.2982538.

21. Saad .S .E and J. Yang,(2019) "Twitter Sentiment Analysis Based on Ordinal Regression," in IEEE Access, 7, pp. 163677-163685, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2952127.

22. Tocoglu .M .A, O. Ozturkmenoglu and A. Alpkocak,(2019) "Emotion Analysis From Turkish Tweets Using Deep Neural Networks," in IEEE Access, 7, pp. 183061-183069, doi:10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2960113. 23. Wang .L, J. Niu and S. Yu, (2020) "SentiDiff: Combining Textual Information and Sentiment Diffusion

Patterns for Twitter Sentiment Analysis," in IEEE Transactions on Knowledge and Data Engineering, 32(10), pp. 2026-2039, doi: 10.1109/TKDE.2019.2913641.

24. Yookesh, T.L., Boobalan, E.D. and Latchoumi, T.P., 2020, March. Variational Iteration Method to Deal with Time Delay Differential Equations under Uncertainty Conditions. In 2020 International Conference on Emerging Smart Computing and Informatics (ESCI) (pp. 252-256). IEEE.

25. Zhou .J, S. Jin and X. Huang,(2020) "ADeCNN: An Improved Model for Aspect-Level Sentiment Analysis Based on Deformable CNN and Attention," IEEE Access, 8, pp. 132970-132979, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2020.3010802.

Referanslar

Benzer Belgeler

In total, 4 patients were diagnosed as having idiopathic spontaneous pneumoperitoneum (1.18%) in the no acute abdomen group.. The remaining 53 patients and 2 patients (who

birden fazla mahlas kullandığı sonucuna ulaştıran temel ipucu budur. Divan’ın elyazması nüshalarındaki bazı şiirler, Nesîmî dışında mahlaslar taşıdığı için

"Kasımpaşa iskelesi, yanmda îb rahim çavuşun kahvesi, yanmda camiişerifin iradı beş göz kayık­ hane, yanmda zahire anbarları, i­ ki göz mühimmat

1960 ihtilali sonrası yargılandı ve 16 Eylül 1961'de Başbakan Adnan Menderes'in ardmdan kabinedeki diğer arkadaşı Haşan Polatkan ile birlikte asıldı.. Naaşı, ölümünden

Üzerinde sade bir manto, başında millî mücadele gün­ lerinde olduğu gibi baş örtüsü ile, vapurdan inen büyük Türk kadını içten gelen teza­ hürler

Marinalardaki hizmet kalitesinin yansıtılması açısından SERVQUAL önermelerine bağlı değerlendirme yapıldığında 2015 yılında yapılan ilk araştırmaya benzer

Kaynak, eserleri plağa en çok okunan bestekarlardandır, ¡fakat, Hamiyet, Küçük Nezihe, Müzeyyen ve Safiye hanımlarla Münir Nurettin Bey gibi aynı dönemde yaşayan

✓ баланың бос уақытын дұрыс ұйымдастыру; ✓ баланы мектептен мектепке ауыстырғанда, балаға қолайсыздық туғызбайтын жағын қарастыру; ✓