Geographical elements in country flags

Tam metin

(1)Available online at www.sciencedirect.com. ScienceDirect Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 116 – 123. +85B4 !>D5B>1D9?>1<5?7B1@8I*I=@?C9E= '%

(2) . 5?7B1@8931<5<5=5>DC9>3?E>DBI6<17C <11DD9>#WJW<P1?S<E )'(#/'.+'2#./'04#!0' #4!1)04,$"1!0',+#-.0*#+0,$,!')!'#+!#/#!&'+%):(#/'. 1.(#4.

(3) <17C G8938 1B5 B571B454 1C D85CI=2?<C ?6 3?E>DB95C 81F5 F1B9?EC 3?<?BC 1>4 CI=2?<C 138 3?<?B CI=2?< 3?1D ?6 1B=C 1>4 5=2<5= EC54 9> 6<17C 81C 1 C@539693 =51>9>7 .85> D85 =51>9>7C ?6 3?E>DBI 6<17C 1B5 5H1=9>54 9D 81C 255> 945>D96954 D81D 75?7B1@8931<5<5=5>DC1B59>3<E4549>D856<17C?6?6D85G?B<43?E>DB95C &1DEB1<?B8E=1>5<5=5>DC3?==?>?B49CD9>3D9> D853?E>DBIZC75?7B1@8931<5>F9B?>=5>D1B59>3?B@?B1D549>D856<17C !D9C945>D96954D81D>1DEB1<5<5=5>DC1B55=@81C9J549> ?6D856<17CG85B51C8E=1>5<5=5>DC1B55=@81C9J549> *?=5?6D85C55<5=5>DC1B5?351>CC51CB9F5BC<1;5CCE>C?9< =?E>D19>C 9C<1>4C 251385C C>?G 935 =9>5C 6<?B1 1>9=1<C 17B93E<DEB5 B5<979?> 5D8>93 CDBE3DEB5 1>4 =1>175=5>D CDI<5. EBB5>DCDE4I5H1=9>5CD85=51>9>7C?675?7B1@8931<5<5=5>DC9>3?E>DBI6<17C1>4D85B51C?>C2589>4D859BC5<53D9?>C. K

(4) +85ED8?BC (E2<9C8542I<C5F95B $D4 Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. *5<53D9?>1>4@55B B5F95GE>45BB5C@?>C929<9DI?6)535@65%E>9B'JDEB;1>4!2B189=D1<1I Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the Organizing Committee of GEOMED2013.. #43,."/<1775?7B1@8IB579?>1<75?7B1@8I3?E>DBI. <17C D81D 1B5 B571B454 1C D85 CI=2?<C ?6 3?E>DB95C 9>3?B@?B1D5 =1>I 3?<?BC CI=2?<C 3?1DC ?6 1B=C 1>4 5=2<5=C 1383?<?BCI=2?<3?1D?61B=C1>45=2<5=EC549>6<17C81C1C@539693=51>9>7 &1D9?>C@B5C5>DD859B C?391< 1>4 3E<DEB1< F1<E5C CE38 1C (1DB9?D9C= *?<941B9DI ?>5CDI <DBE9C= E=1>9C= '@D9=9C= +?<5B1>35 1B=?>I 97>9DI 5BF?B $?I1<DI 5B?9C= .9C4?= 5>5B?C9DI &?29<9DI -9BDE?EC>5CC (EB9DI 945<9DI B95>4<9>5CC ?>?B12<5>5CC%?45CDI+5>139DI*5<6<5CC>5CC>4EB1>3519D86E<>5CC"?I6E<>5CC2IEC9>73?<?BC. ?BB5C@?>49>71ED8?B +5<

(5) 61H

(6)

(7)

(8) . *')"".#// 1<11DD9>21<9;5C9B 54E DB. 1877-0428 © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license.. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the Organizing Committee of GEOMED2013. doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2014.02.088.

(9) Alaattin Kızılçaoğlu / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 116 – 123. 1>4CI=2?<C9>D859B6<17C +1B75DC?6D853?E>DBICE381C(5135*5B5>9DI,>9DIB?D85B8??4AE1<9DI&5EDB1<9DI $12?B -979<1>35 >DB5@B5>5EBC89@ 5D5B=9>1D9?> (B?7B5CC9?> (?G5B .5<61B5 1>4 (B?C@5B9DI 1B5 1<C? B5@B5C5>D549>D856<17C +85=?CD3?==?>D85=59>D856<17C?6D85G?B<49C9>45@5>45>351>4D852<??4D81D81C 255>C8549>D85CDBE77<56?B9>45@5>45>35 +89CD85=59CB5@B5C5>D542ID853?<?BB549>6<17C?69>45@5>45>D 3?E>DB95C

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

(11)

(12)

(13)

(14)

(15)

(16)

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

(18)

(19) +85 DB91>7<5C 9> D85 6<17 ?6 &5@1< 1B5 EC54 D? B5@B5C5>DD85 9=1<1I1%?E>D19>CG89383?>C9CD?6=?B5D81>81<6?6D85&5@1<C?9<1=?E>D19>?EC<1>4D1<1I

(20)

(21) ?<?B7B55>9>D856<17?6'=1>9CD85CI=2?<?6< 1:1B%?E>D19>C;>?G>G9D89DCCDB?>76<?B11>4 9=@?BD1>DG1D5BB5C?EB35C3?=@1B54D?5<C5G85B59>D853?E>DBIG85B5G1D5BC8?BD1759C5HDB5=5<I8978 ?<?BB54. 117.

(22) 118. Alaattin Kızılçaoğlu / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 116 –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

(23) Alaattin Kızılçaoğlu / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 116 – 123. 1B389@5<17?=145E@?6=19>1D?<<C +855=2<5=9>D856<17?6E1=9>(1396939>3<E45C125138 ?<?BG89D59> D856<17C?6>D97E11>41B2E41!C<1>4CI5<<?G21>4C9>D856<17C?6181=1C1B214?C1>4*19>D-9>35>D1>4D85 B5>149>5C1>4D853?<?BG89D59>D85CD1B9>D85BE216<17B5@B5C5>DD85251385C.

(24) )'*0,),%'!+"-#",),%'!#)#*#+0/ *?=5?6D853?E>DBI6<17C9>3<E453<9=1D?<?793?B@54?<?7935<5=5>DC?6D853?E>DBI +85CI=2?<?6=??>9>D85 6<17?6&5@1<B5@B5C5>DCD853??<1>43<?E4IG51D85B 9>D85 9=1<1I1CG85B51CD85CI=2?<?6CE>B56<53DCD85G1B= 1B51C9>D85<?G5B@1BDC?6D853?E>DBI ?<?BG89D59>D856<17?6!35<1>4G893881C<1>49>B3D93)579?>B5@B5C5>DC D859351>4D85C>?G1>4D85 CI=2?<?6D8539B3<59>D85 6<17?6 B55><1>4 5=@81C9J5CD85CE> G89389CB56<53D54 6B?=D859353?F5B547B?E>4 ?<?BG89D59>D856<17C?6B75>D9>189<5CD?>919><1>4$521>?>1>4+1:9;9CD1> B5@B5C5>DCD85C>?G3?F5B9>D85=?E>D19>?EC@1BDC?6D85C53?E>DB95C?BD85C>?G@9<5CD81D3?F5BCD8?C53?E>DB95C9> D85G9>D5B ?<?B?B1>759>D856<17?6B=5>91D851>7E<1BDB91>7<59>D85181=1C6<171>4D853?<?BB549>D85CD1B ?6BE216<17B5@B5C5>DD85C?9<3?<?B7B55>9>1>7<145C86<17B5@B5C5>DCD8565BD9<5C?9<9>D853?E>DBI1>43?<?B 2<13;9>D856<17?6?=9>931B5@B5C5>DCD85@B?4E3D9F5>5CC?6D85C?9<. 4".,%.-&'!#)#*#+0/ -1B9?EC8I4B?7B1@8935<5=5>DC?351>CC51CB9F5BC<1;5CG1D5B61<<C1>4C@B9>7C1B5?2C5BF549>3?E>DBI6<17C B5@B5C5>D542I49665B5>D3?<?BC1>4CI=2?<C 3?<?B?B1CI=2?<9CEC549>D856<17C?6 3?E>DB95CD?B5@B5C5>DD85 ?351>?BD85C51+12<5 ?6D85C53?E>DB95C1B59C<1>43?E>DB95C1>4D85I 81F565<DD85 >554D?5=@81C9J59> D859B 6<17C D85 ?351> G8938 9C ?>5 ?6 D85 9=@?BD1>D B5C?EB35C 6?B D85= 1>4 E>4?E2D54<I ?>5 ?6 D85 =?CD 3BE391< >1DEB1<5<5=5>DC9>D85C59C<1>4C ?6D85C59C<1>4C1B5C9DE1D549>D85(139693'351>1B59>1B92251>1B59> D85 !>491> '351> 1>4 1B5 9> D85 D<1>D93 '351> 3?E>DB95C 9> 6B931 3?E>DB95C 9> 5>DB1< =5B931 1>4 3?E>DB95C51389>*?ED8=5B9311>4EB?@5D81D81F53?1CD<9>5CD?59D85BD85?351>?BD?D85C5181F5?351>?BD85 C515=@81C9J549>D859B6<17C. 3?E>DB95C 81F5 5=@81C9J54 B9F5BC 9> D859B 6<17C G9D8 D85 EC5 ?6 3?<?BC +12<5 *9>35 8E=1> 13D9F9D95C 1>4 @?@E<1D9?>81F535>D5B54?>B9F5BC9>1=291$1?C&975B1>4*?ED8*E41>6B?=@1CDD?@B5C5>DD85C53?E>DB95C 81F5 65<D D85 >554 D? B5@B5C5>D D85 B9F5BC 9> D859B 6<17C ?<?B 2<E5 9> D85 6<17C ?6 CD?>91 9><1>4 1>4 +1>J1>91 B5@B5C5>DC D85 <1;5C 9><1>4 1 !,1+0.4 ?6 D8?EC1>4C ?6 )(#/ D1<1I

(25)

(26) NJ5I

(27)

(28) 1>4 +1>J1>91 G9D8 1> 12E>41>35 ?6 <1;5C 9> D85 $1;5C )579?> 9> D85 6B931> ?>D9>5>D 81F5 <1;5C 9> D859B 6<17C ?<?B G89D5 9> D85 ?=9>931> 6<17 B5@B5C5>DC D85 G1D5B61<<C D85 =?CD 3?==?> 8I4B?7B1@893 5<5=5>DC 9> D85 3?E>DBI ?<?B 2<E5 B5@B5C5>DCD85G1D5BC@B9>7C9>D856<17C?6&1=9291#1J1;8CD1>1>4814G85B51B94<1>43?F5BCF1CD1B51C ?<?B 2<E5 9> D85 6<17 ?6 814 CEBB?E>454 9> D85 >?BD8 2I D85 *181B1 5C5BD 5=@81C9J5C D85 C1F1>>18 1>4 17B93E<DEB1< 1B51C9>D85C?ED8D81D1B53?=@1B1D9F5<IB9389>G1D5BB5C?EB35C. ',%#,%.-&'!#)#*#+0/ <?B11>4J?? 75?7B1@8931<381B13D5B9CD93C?63?E>DB95C1B5B5@B5C5>D549>C?=56<17CG9D8D8585<@?63?<?BC1>4 CI=2?<C ?<?B 7B55> 9C EC54 9> C?=5 6<17C D? 5=@81C9J5 D85 >1DEB1< 6<?B1 ?6 D85 3?E>DBI ?=9>931 B5>141 E9>51 "1=1931 %1EB9D9EC %?>D5>57B? &1=9291 *19>D -9>35>D 1>4 D85 B5>149>5C *1? +?=5 1>4 (B9>39@5 +1>J1>91 01=291 1>4 &?B6?<; !C<1>4 1>4 D85 G945C@B514 6?B5CD 1B51C 5<1BEC B1J9< )5@E2<93 ?6 +85 ?>7? AE1D?B91<E9>5112?>81>1EI1>1$9D8E1>91&975B91 ?B5CD1B51C1B5CDB5CC549>D856<17C?6B1J9<1>4 85)5@E2<93?6D85?>7?G85B5B19>6?B5CDC1B5G945C@B514+R=5BD5;9>1>4NJ7RP 1>1491>6<1781CD85 =1@<5<516G89389CB571B4541CD85CI=2?<?6D853?E>DBI ?<?BG89D59>CD?>91>6<17CI=2?<9J5CD8521B;?6D85 29B38DB55D85=?CD3?==?>DB55DI@59>D853?E>DBI>?>I=?ECD85CI=2?<?6D85DB559>D856<17?6AE1D?B91< E9>51 B5@B5C5>DCD853?==?>2?=21HDB55D85DB55CI=2?<9>D856<17?65<9J5B5@B5C5>DCD85=18?71>IDB551>4 5=2<5=C ?6 DB55C 9> D85 6<17C ?6 C?=5 9C<1>4 3?E>DB95C ?=9>931> )5@E2<93 9:9 19D9 B9D9C8 !>491> '351> +5BB9D?BI 1>4 E1= B5@B5C5>D D85 G945C@B514 @1<= DB55 9> D8?C5 3?E>DB95C +85 DB55 5=2<5= 9> D85 6<17 ?6 (5BE B5@B5C5>DCD85 !'+!&,+0.##D85>1D9?>1<DB55?6(5BE1>4D85C?EB35?6 AE9>9>5 49C3?F5B542I!>31CD85>1D9F5C?6 (5BE +B555=2<5=9>$521>5C56<17B5@B5C5>DCD853541BDB55D85CI=2?<?6D853?E>DBI ?<?BB549>&5@1<6<17. 119.

(29) 120. Alaattin Kızılçaoğlu / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 116 – 123. B5@B5C5>DCD85>1D9?>1<@<1>D?6&5@1<D85B8?4?45>4B?>@<1>D3?==?><IC55>9>6?B5CD1B51C?6D853?E>DBI1>4D85 @<1>DCI=2?<9>D856<17?6%5H93?B5@B5C5>DCD85313DEC@<1>DG945<I?2C5BF549>D851B941B51C?6D853?E>DBI. &1DEB1< 5<5=5>DC CE38 1C 6?B5CD C1F1>>18 1>4 45C5BD 1B5 5=@81C9J54 9> D85 6<17C ?6 C?=5 6B931> 3?E>DB95C. ?<?B7B55>9>D856<17C?61=5B??>1>4?D5Z!F?9B5CI=2?<9J5C D856?B5CD1B51C9>D85C?ED8?6D85C53?E>DB95C. ?<?B7B55>9>1=5B??>6<171>43?<?B?B1>759>?D5Z!F?9B56<17B5@B5C5>DD85C1F1>>189>D85>?BD8 ?<?BB54 9>D856<17?61=291CI=2?<9J5CD85C1F1>>189>D853?E>DBI +85?B1>7521>49>D85&975B91>6<17CI=2?<9J5CD85 1B94 1B51C 9> *181B1 9> D85 >?BD8 ?6 D85 3?E>DBI 3?<?B I5<<?G 9> D85 %1EB9D1>91> 6<17 B5@B5C5>DC D85 C1>4C ?6 D85 *181B11>4D853?<?BI5<<?G9>D856<17?6814CI=2?<9J5CD8545C5BD9>D85>?BD8?6D853?E>DBI. ?1DC?61B=C?B CI=2?<CB5<1D54D?1>9=1<C1B51<C?C55> 9>D85 6<17C?6 C?=53?E>DB95C +85=?CD3?==?><I ?2C5BF54 1>9=1< 697EB5C 1B5 517<5C <21>91 7I@D %?<4?F1 %?>D5>57B? *5B291 1>4 01=291 1>4 <9?>C %?>D5>57B? *B9 $1>;1 1I=1> !C<1>4C "5BC5I *19>D (95BB5 1>4 %9AE5<?> #1J1;8CD1> G85B5 CD5@@5C 1B5 3?==?> 81C CD5@@5 517<5 9> 9DC 6<17 B5@B5C5>D54 9> I5<<?G %5H93? G8938 9>3<E45C 45C5BDC 9> 9DC 2?B45BC 81C 1> 517<5697EB9>5@5B3854?>1313DEC9>9DC>1D9?>1<6<17 <17?6(1@E1&5GE9>5145@93DCCDB5<9DJ91 B579>51D8529B4 ?6 @1B149C5 6<17 ?6 ?=9>931 45@93DC 1 >1D9F5 @1BB?D 1>4 D85 6<17 ?6 ,71>41 45@93DC D85 B54 !.#/0#" !.+# 0&# /4* ,),$0&#!,1+0.40&0)'2#/'+0&#.'"/2++&'+0&#/,10&,$0&#&.#/#.0&#!,0,$.*/'+0&#$)% ,$+%1'))/)+"'+0&#.' #+3&#.#0,1.'/0//3'*),+%/'"#",)-&'+/+,+4*,1/ "#-'!0/0&.##",)-&'+/ &#$)%,$4*+/)+"/3&#.#01.0)#$.*/.#2'/'0#" 4&1+".#"/,$0&,1/+"/,$0,1.'/0/#2#.4#."#-'!0/0&# $'%1.'+#,$01.0)#&##* )#* '+0&#$)%,$ *?ED85?B7911>4*?ED8*1>4G938!C<1>4C45@93DC@5>7E9>C51<1>4 B59>455B697EB9>5C ?1CDC?6D85C59C<1>4C@B?F945?@@?BDE>9D95C6?BD85D?EB9CDCG8?5>:?IC51<1>429B4G1D389>7.

(30)

(31)

(32)

(33)

(34)

(35) ?6 D85 3?E>DBI 6<17C 9>3<E45 8E=1> 5<5=5>DC ?6 6<17C 45@93D ?>5 ?B =?B5 ?6 D85 8E=1> 5<5=5>DC D81D D85 3?E>DB95C @?CC5CC *5DD<5=5>D 75?7B1@8I 53?>?=93 75?7B1@8I 3E<DEB1< 75?7B1@8I 1>4 @?<9D931< 75?7B1@8I. #00)#*#+0%#,%.-&4 *?=53?E>DBI6<17C9>3<E455<5=5>DCB5<1D54D?C5DD<5=5>D75?7B1@8I +85>E=25B?6CD1BC9>D856<17C?6C?=5 3?E>DB95C 1@5 -5B45 ?=?B?C *1? +?=5 1>4 (B9>39@5 *?<?=?> !C<1>4C 1I=1> !C<1>4C ??; !C<1>4C 545B1D54 *D1D5C ?6 %93B?>5C91 AE1D?B91< E9>51 1>4 *19>D #9DDC 1>4 &5F9C C8?GC D85 >E=25B ?6 9C<1>4C +85 CD1BC9>D856<17?6EB131?D85/C81@59>D85-1>E1DE6<17DG?<9<I<51F5C9>D85%131E6<171>4D85251=C9>D85 #9B921D96<17B5@B5C5>DD859C<1>4C?6D8?C53?E>DB95C &E=25B ?6CD1BC9>C?=53?E>DBI 6<17C?=9>931B5>141 45@93DC D85 >E=25B ?6 14=9>9CDB1D9F5 B579?>C 9> D85 3?E>DB95C *D1BC 9> D85 6<17 ?6 (89<9@@9>5C B5@B5C5>D D85 D8B55 =19>75?7B1@8931<B579?>C?6D853?E>DBI$EJ?>-9C1I1C1>4%9>41>1?F9CE1<C9>D853?1D ?6 1B=C9>B?1D91> 6<1745@93DD8569F589CD?B931<B579?>C?6D853?E>DBIB?1D91E2B?F>9;1<=1D91!CDB911>4*<1F?>913?<?BC9> D85 $92I1> 6<17 B5@B5C5>D D85 D8B55 =19> B579?>C ?6 D85 3?E>DBI CD1BC 9> D85 +EB;=5>9CD1> 6<17 B5@B5C5>D D85 B579?>C ?6D853?E>DBI8?B9J?>D1<21>4C9>D856<17?6+?7?45@93DD8569F549665B5>DB579?>C?6D853?E>DBI1>4 21>4C9>D856<17?6,>9D54*D1D5C?6=5B93145@93DD85 @9?>55B3?<?>95C9>D8551CD. !,+,*'!%#,%.-&4 *?=5 3?E>DBI 6<17C 45@93D 5<5=5>DC B5<1D54 D? 53?>?=93 75?7B1@8I CE38 1C 17B93E<DEB5 1>9=1< 8EC21>4BI 9>4ECDBI=1B9D9=51>4=9>9>7 ?<?B7B55>9>C?=53?E>DBI6<17C6781>9CD1>?<9F91B9DB51)5@E2<93?6+85 ?>7?1=291B5>141"1=1931%1EB9D9EC&1=9291*95BB1$5?>5+?7?1>409=212G53?<?B2<13;9>D856<17 ?6?=9>9311>4D85CI=2?<?61>38?B9>%?J1=29AE56<17B5@B5C5>D17B93E<DEB5 ?<?B7B55>9>D85&975B91>6<17 45@93DCD8565BD9<5<1>41B?E>4D85)9F5B&975B ?<?BI5<<?G9>D856<17?6,;B19>545@93DCD85G945C@B514695<4C?6 G851D 9> D85 3?E>DBI G85B51C D85 3?<?B I5<<?G 9> D85 6<17 ?6 3E14?B 1>4 D85 CE> B1IC 9> D85 6<17 ?6 #1J1;8CD1> B5@B5C5>DG851D7B?G9>7 9:96<1745@93DCCE71B31>51@B?4E3D?6D85+?BB940?>5 ?<?BG89D59>+1:9;9CD1>6<17.

(36) Alaattin Kızılçaoğlu / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 116 – 123. CI=2?<9J5CD853?DD?>D85C53?>4G945C@B514@B?4E3D16D5BD85G851D1>43?<?BI5<<?G9>D856<17?6*1?+?=51>4 (B9>39@545@93DCD853131??>5?6D85=19>17B93E<DEB1<@B?4E3DC?6D853?E>DBI. +85G89D5B1=9>D853?1D ?6 1B=C9>D856<17?61<;<1>4!C<1>4C!C<1C %1<F9>1C45@93DC?F9>561B=9>713D9F9D95C 9> D85 9C<1>4 D85 =?CD 3?==?> =51>C ?6 <9F5<98??4 6?B D85 9C<1>45BC *I=2?<C 1B5 EC54 9> D85 6<17C ?6 9C<1>4 3?E>DB95C9>D85(1396931>4D<1C'351>C*19>D(95BB51>4%9AE5<?>!C<1>4+?;5<1E1>4E1=D? 45@93D=1B9D9=5 13D9F9D95C. ?<?B7B55>9CEC549>D856<17C?6C?=5 6B931>3?E>DB95C AE1D?B91<E9>5112?>81>1#5>I1&975B91 )G1>41*95BB1$5?>51>401=291D?5=@81C9J5D85B938>1DEB1<B5C?EB35C?6D853?E>DBI ?<?B7B55>9>D856<17C ?6 C?=5 6B931> EB;9>1 1C? 3E14?B 81>1 %?J1=29AE5 )G1>41 *G1J9<1>4 +1>J1>91 +?7? 1>4 09=212G51>4*?ED8=5B931>?<9F91B1J9<EI1>13?E>DB95C45@93DCD85=9>5B1<45@?C9DC1>4D8512E>41>35 ?6=9>5C ?<?B2<13;9>D856<17?6?9<B938,>9D54B12=9B1D5C5=@81C9J5CD85?9<695<4C. 1)01.)%#,%.-&4 *?=53?E>DBI 6<17C 81F55<5=5>DCD81D45@93DD85B5<979?ECB1391<1>45D8>93CDBE3DEB5 ?6D85@5?@<5 +5>5DC?6 !C<1=8B9CD91>9DIE4489C= 9>4E9C=1>4"E419C=1B5B5@B5C5>D549>6<17CD8B?E78D85EC5?6F1B9?EC3?<?BC1>4 CI=2?<C <17C?63?E>DB95CG85B5D85=1:?B9DI?6@5?@<51B5%EC<9=C45@93D!C<1= +85C53?E>DB95C1B5C9DE1D54 9> D85 %944<5 1CD &?BD8 6B931 1>4 5>DB1< C91 +12<5 ?<?B 7B55> 3B5C35>D 1>4 D85 CD1B 1>4 D85 3B5C35>D C81@54=??>B5@B5C5>D!C<1= D9@@54G89D521>4C9>D856<17?618B19>1>4D85 1>7<54CD1B9>D85%?B?331>6<17 B5@B5C5>D D85 69F5 @9<<1BC ?6 !C<1= +1;29B <<18E ;21B ?4 9C B51D C3B9@D 9> D85 !B1A9 6<17 1>4 #1<9=1D 1C8 *8181418 9C !C<1=93 3B554 G8938 453<1B5C 25<956 9> D85 ?>5>5CC ?6 ?4 1>4 1335@D1>35 ?6 %E81==14 1C ?4C @B?@85D C3B9@D54 9> *1E49 B1291> 6<17 CI=2?<9J5 !C<1= 1>7<54 CD1B 9> D85 6<17 ?6 "?B41> B5@B5C5>DC D85 F5BC5C ?6 D85 *EB181D981D8569BCDCEB18?6D85 ?<I#?B1>1>4D85B56?B5D856<1745@93DCD8525<956?6!C<1=. <17C ?6

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

(38) ?6D85@?@E<1D9?><9F9>79> 8ED1> +819<1>4 *B9 $1>;1 1>4 1=2?491 1B5 E4489CDC B14C81G

(39)

(40)

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

(42) 122. Alaattin Kızılçaoğlu / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 116 –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

(43) ,)'0'!)%#,%.-&4 *?=53?E>DBI6<17C9>3<E455<5=5>DCB5<1D54D?@?<9D931<75?7B1@8I ?<?BCD81D B5@B5C5>DD85*<1F>1D9?>G89D5 2<E51>4B541B545@93D549>D856<17C?6)ECC91*5B291B?1D911>4*<?F1;91 <E59CB5@<13542I17B55>21>49> D85E<71B91>6<17. +85D89?@91>6<179>3<E45C7B55>I5<<?G1>4B543?<?BC D89?@919CD85?<45CD9>45@5>45>D6B931>3?E>DBI +85 D8B553?<?BCEC549>D85 6<1781C255>1CC?391D54G9D89>45@5>45>352ID85?D85B6B931>3?E>DB95CG945<IEC54 1>4 B571B454 1C (1> 6B931> 3?<?BC +85 3?E>DB95C D81D EC5 D85 61=?EC (1> 6B931> 3?<?BC ?6 D89?@91 1B5 5>9> EB;9>1 1C? 1=5B??> )5@E2<93 ?6 +85 ?>7? 81>1 E9>51 E9>51 9CC1E %1<9 *1?+?=5 1>4 (B9>39@5 *5>571<1>4+?7? +856<17?65>DB1<6B931>)5@E2<933?=29>5C(1> 6B931>3?<?BCG9D8D853?<?B?6D856<17?6 B1>35E>45BG8?C53?<?>I9DC5BF549>D85@1CD. +8545C97>1>4D853?<?BC9>D85,>9D54#9>74?=5C@5391<<ID853?<?B2<E5B5@B5C5>DD85?D85B>1D9?>CC?9<C1>4 D85 3?==?>G51<D8 @B?F9>35C 1>4 >7<9C8 ?F5BC51C B579?>C +89C 6<17 81C 255> D85 21C9C 6?B =1>I ?6 D85 G?B<4 6<17C +853?E>DB95CD81D81CD85,>9D54#9>74?=6<17?>D85=1CD?6D859B6<17C1B5ECDB1<919:9&5G051<1>4 >7E9<<1 5B=E41 B9D9C8 !>491> '351> +5BB9D?BI B9D9C8 -9B79> !C<1>4C 1I=1> !C<1>4C ?B1< *51 !C<1>4C 1<;<1>4!C<1>4C%?>DC5BB1D(9D319B>!C<1>4C*19>D 5<5>1C35>C9?>1>4+B9CD1>1E>81*?ED85?B7911>4 *?ED8*1>4G938!C<1>4C+EB;C1>4193?C!C<1>4C +853?E>DB95CE>45BECDB1<91G9D8,>9D54#9>74?=6<17?>D85 E@@5B@1BD?6D85=1CD9>D859B6<17C1B5C8=?B51>41BD95B!C<1>4C?3?C#55<9>7!C<1>4C?B1<*51!C<1>4C 51B4!C<1>41>4%3?>1<4!C<1>4C +853?E>DB95CE>45B&5G051<1>4G9D8,>9D54#9>74?=6<17?>D85E@@5B@1BD ?6D85=1CD9>D859B6<17C1B5??;!C<1>4C1>4&9E5!C<1>4C 85;5<911>4;B?D9B9EC5D85C1=56<171C D85,>9D54 #9>74?=. +8545@5>45>D>1D9?>CG8?EC5D85B5>386<171B5<9@@5BD?>!C<1>4B5>38*?ED85B>1>4>D1B3D93$1>4C&5G 1<54?>91*19>D1BD85<5=I1>4*19>D%1BD9> +85B5>38<17?>D85E@@5B@1BD?6D85=1CD9>D856<17?6.1<<9C 1>4EDE>1 !C<1>4B5@B5C5>DD85613DD81DD859C<1>49C45@5>45>D?>B1>35 +8545@5>45>D3?E>DB95CD81DEC5D856<17 ?6,>9D54*D1D5C?6=5B9311B5&1F1CC11>4,>9D54*D1D5C(139693!C<1>4.9<4<965)56E755C +856<17C?6?EF5D !C<1>43?>>53D54D?&?BG1I1>4D85 6<17C?6"1>%1I5>!C<1>41>4*F1<21B4!C<1>4C1B5D85C1=5G9D8D856<17?6 &?BG1I <17C?6 ?>7#?>71>4%131EG5B545C97>5416D5BD8589>5C56<17 +853?<?B9>D856<17?6 ?>7#?>7 B5@B5C5>DC D85 8?=5 <1>4 1>4 D85 C1=5 3?<?B 9C EC54 1<C? 9> D85 89>5C5 6<17 +85 CD1BC 9> D85 %131E 6<17 1B5 9>C@9B542ID8589>5C56<17.

(44) Alaattin Kızılçaoğlu / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 116 – 123. *?=53?E>DB95C5=@81C9J5D85CD1D5CDBE3DEB5EC549>D853?E>DBI +85CD1BC9>D856<17?6-5>5JE5<1B5@B5C5>DD85 CD1D5C9>D853?E>DBID85CD1BC9>D856<17?6B1J9<B5@B5C5>DD85CD1D5C1>4D85

(45) CD1BC9>D856<17?6,>9D54 *D1D5C?6=5B931B5@B5C5>DD85CD1D5C9>D853?E>DBI. +85@?<9D931<CDBE3DEB59C1<C?B5@B5C5>D549>C?=56<17C ?<?B2<E59>D856<17?6+819<1>41>4D855=2<5=9>D85 6<17?6BE>59BE<542ICE<D1>1D5B5@B5C5>D=?>1B38I ?<?BC9>D856<17C?6B1>351>4*5B2911>4D853?<?BB549> D856<17C?689>1-95D>1=1>4&?BD8#?B51B5@B5C5>DB5F?<ED9?> *D1BC9>D856<17C?6&?BD8#?B511>4-95D>1= CI=2?<9J5C?391<9C=. *?=5B5=1B;12<5B5CE<DC 81F5255>?2D19>541C1B5CE<D?69>F5CD971D9>7D85=51>9>7C1>4D85B51C?>C2589>4D85 EC56<17CED9<9J541CCI=2?<C?63?E>DB95C1>445C97>54G9D8F1B9?ECCI=2?<C1>43?<?BC !>F5CD971D9>7D85=51>9>7 ?63?E>DBI6<17CC8?GCD81D=1:?B9DI?6D85=9>3<E45 75?7B1@8931<5<5=5>DC &1D9?>C81F5B5@<13549>D859B6<17CD85 @8IC931< 1>4 8E=1> 75?7B1@8I 5<5=5>DC D81D 1B5 9=@?BD1>D 6?B D85= %?CD ?6 D85 G?B<4 3?E>DB95C 9>3<E45 5<5=5>DC B5<1D54 D? 75?7B1@8931< 381B13D5B9CD93C +85 4?=9>1>D 5<5=5>DC 9> D85 >1DEB1< 1>4 8E=1> 5>F9B?>=5>D1< 3?>49D9?>C81F5255>5=@81C9J549>6<17C <17C85<@ECD?@5B359F5D8575?7B1@8931<381B13D5B9CD93C?6D853?E>DB95C. 9C39@<9>5C?D85BD81>75?7B1@8I=1I3?>DB92ED5D?C395>352IE>45BD1;9>7B5C51B3812?ED6<17C1CG5<<. >?>I=?EC 8DD@C GGG 391 7?F <92B1BI @E2<931D9?>C D85 G?B<4 613D2??; 4?3C 6<17C?6D85G?B<4 8D=< >?>I=?EC8DD@ GGG ?><9>5D5B3E=1><9; 3?= E<;5 21IB1;<1B9 >?>I=?EC8DD@ GGG G?B<41D<1C 3?= G529=175 6<17C 6<173>DI 8D= >?>I=?EC8DD@ GGG F9C9D5CD?>91 3?= 5> 8?<941I 45CD9>1D9?>C <1>4C31@5C 6?B5CDC >?>I=?EC 8DD@ GGG 1>7E9<<1 251385C 3?= 4?<@89> 49C3?F5BI 1>7E9<<1 8D=< D1<1IU

(46)

(47) 5?7B1@8I?6 ?>D9>5>DC1>4?E>DB95C UJ=9B. D1<1IU

(48)

(49) .?B<45?7B1@8IG9D8(8?D?C1>4%1@C U>;W<1@#9D1@5F9 !CD1>2E<. B14C81G%

(50)

(51)

(52) .?B<4)579?>1<5?7B1@8I+85&5G<?21<'B45B *53?>449D9?>. ?85BDI<1I2?EB>5 1F94C?>*

(53) 5?7B1@8I>3I3<?@5491.9D8?=@<5D5.?B<4D<1C +B1>C<1D542I%58=5D0?B +R29D1; (?@E<1B*395>35??;C&?1XFEBE#9D1@<WSW>;1B1. ?X7QB5>/ %19>$9>5C?65?=?B@8?<?7I!! UCD1>2E<,>9F5BC9DI(E2<931D9?>C&? 13E<DI?6$9D5B1DEB5 (E2<931D9?>C&? . L1>D1I#9D1@5F9 UCD1>2E<. NJ5I)

(54)

(55) 5?7B1@8I?6C91 ;D96/1IW>5F9 UCD1>2E<. NJ5I)

(56)

(57) 5?7B1@8I?6?E>DB95C ;D96/1IW>5F9. +R=5BD5;9> NJ7RP& 3?>?=935?7B1@8I<?21<9J1D9?>1>45F5<?@=5>D L1>D1I#9D125F9 UCD1>2E<. 123.

(58)