Hegel'den Derrida'ya sanatın sonu olgusu
105
0
0
Tam metin
(2) .
(3) !" "#. . . . $%&'. .
(4)
(5) .
(6) ( )*+ ,-./0) + . 1* ( 0- .+ ) 23 /1 / ,/+ ) )4
(7) ! #5+6 7 * */,*0)*+". $%&'.
(8)
(9)
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
(11) ##% !,# ! # !"# #' =# " !'## .##% -" .! ,.#"%%"#"%+%%! #(#'!(# #'."( "(! 0
(12) . .
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
(14)
(15) !" # $ ! % # % &! # # # . ).
(16) ' ((). 1,#"%+#(% #+"### ##(!" . 4.# ) )(# %4%!"# #%+#% C !=0 0 #"" ' ' .! ,.#"%% " ". (#/%"#+% %"#.% ) '" ) " !",+, ,"#.%# '. ". ) '" ( " " (#/%"#.%# ' ) (" . ()#( %4#) ' #(% %%*## . .# % #%+#%C !=0 0 %=#D#3 !'+''* 0 .# ," .#EFGH .I#+. ).
(17) $#"%+# !(,4#.'" . (*#")(%""# '#( # #)(000. ).
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
(19) #( % #( % 4"4' + '!, !"# * ,'#) #"# % # #(# ' "(#"%+%0$#"%+#%##4%: !"# %9##% ##% !, ) ##% !,# ! # ."" (" "" !', # ' #'%+ #%.%% !",+, # ".)'!,("#""=' . #3# 4(#/%"%+#"%+#"# % ,","# %)(! ,"# % # #(# '.,#'% 0. ).
(20) , (. + - . ' (() / # / *+/ , ( 0 1 0
(21) 1 0/ 23 4 ' 2 53 6)'). 7 E0G0"8".=. !, "#%)
(22) 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000J0000J0H E0E0.43)# %%I"**00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000K. @.
(23) E0L0M#4?,. #N# 3 !,000000000000000000000000000000000J00JJ000J00000000JJGF 83 25 L0G0#"1""N!"!7" !,J00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ0GL L0E08 #4.8,',(##N# 3 !,) !.#0000000000000000000000000000000000000000J0GK L0L0M#4?,. #N# 3 !,#<#"%# " O0000000000000000000000000JJ0EF L0P0 "#)!79'N9##% !,,
(24) #+##'000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ0EE 93 57 P0G0;#" 17#N'"##'"# %("#$!#"%"# "$## ##
(25) #/%%0J00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000EQ P0E0M#4?,. #4 N.,, .,",,000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ0LG P0L0 !"#1# 3.N2*""=I"**000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000J0LP P0P0M#1#, ""# N ##<!/"!.,00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000J0LQ P0P0G0 '"#% ##%O0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000J0HE P0P0E0 D(<.43 D(C!/00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000J0HH P0P0L0 D(#.# %000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000HK P0H0!#"<,./N ##% !,000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ0RR P0R0 3, #!N ##% !,# ! #000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000J0QE 73 , :7
(26) !(,:; +& ,';;. @.
(27) 1 23 (;# 3!" 2# "(/ GSRE000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ005; 5<83, ! A# GSEEA,@ !, !=1 #( GSELA GSER00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000J05= 93 2 "# #'". "" #' GSQR0000000000000000000000JJ0085 73 43# #"! 1,*)" ,'## =# '"% ,'## '4(#/# #4# # O GSLR000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ088 >3 ! #,.43 "+<!!. GSHL000000000000000JJ08> :3 1# # #< , .. T "%+) +(#/%(! , !3#")# %U GSKQ00J08; ;3 1# # #< , .. TV*4,, .#)#+#"#%U GSKS000000000000000JJ09? =3 B( 3 # .. WERG GSSE000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ092. @.
(28) 2?3 #M,C#' V1,# GSQP00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ098 223 M==<!!. 1, 7,)#1*.*XM==) "!#TB44!"#U GSSG000000000JJ097 253 2# 4",43#/ $+ GSGQYGSRP000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ09: 283 2# 4",43#/ 0000Z GSGS00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ09; 293 3 ) ,43#/# ! #$+ GSSG0000000000000000000000000JJ09= 273 3 ) ;#"' )#.# ! # WP GSKG000000000000000000000000JJ07? 2>3 (;# 3!" B#/ ""$! #"# % GSRF0000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ072 2:3 # .
(29) #+#(#1 .#%93I"**8''#.%"%% GSSG0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ075 2;3 B3 .=" 3#" GSSR000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ079 2=3 M==<!!. 243#"M#4'.!)1, ". GSSK000000000000000000000000000000JJ077 5?3 # . # % +'%# EFFQ000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ07: 523 C#"( #"# % , #0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ07= 553 C3""/.. ,4(24 # 1, """ . EFFQ0000000000000000000000JJ0>? 583 "# "#%
(30) 1". / =! #. GSSFJ000J0>2 593 #'#.32, #'# !,.V,! EFFL00000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ0>5 573 #'#.32, #'# V .#"". # #(% EFGF000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ0>8. @.
(31) 5>3 #9" A9<!=! 1 . GSSP0000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ0>9 5:3 8 #'03 ( ,32*. 1" #!T./#(#U GSSQ00000JJ00>7 5;3 2# 4Z, < #( %% GSSG000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ0>: 5=3 1 ,4#,# ' ##%" "#"# % #(#$%'# #' *(#(#
(32) # % GSRQ000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ0>= 8?3 2# 4",43#/ 1.'"' " GSGL000000000000000000000000000000000000J0J0:? 823 C !2#! ##%%+'%.% GSRG0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000JJ00:2 853 (;# 3!" 1 ""!<,,"# % GSRE0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000J0:8. @.
(33)
(34) 1 . 3&3(3 %'#/ 3&33 %#'#" (+3 1#'%% /3 $) @!3
(35) #(%). @).
(36)
(37)
(38)
(39)
(40) .
(41) !
(42)
(43) . " # $ .
(44)
(45)
(46) % $ # " $
(47) !
(48) & " ' (
(49) & )* # " .
(50). &.
(51)
(52)
(53)
(54)
(55) &+
(56) ,
(57) '
(58) &-
(59)
(60)
(61)
(62)
(63) . ' $
(64)
(65) &-
(66) /
(67) 0 12
(68) $
(69)
(70)
(71) " /"
(72) 0
(73) $
(74) 3 # 4
(75) 5 ' " 3 / 0
(76) 6%%6
(77) *
(78) * #
(79) # 7 89 , 6 # # 6
(80) % 5 : 6 :6 ;#
(81)
(82) " 6 % 4 6 4 7. 1.
(83) #
(84) #, <
(85) :4 % : % ,
(86) " 3" = > ' 6?" ? * %@5
(87) ' , ,%$@
(88) . ;6%@
(89) " ' 6
(90) . 6
(91)
(92) , , # $ . ' ' /: %8A B0
(93) .
(94) "" @
(95) 6
(96) . .
(97) % %% " 7 9 $ 6 " /0 " ,
(98) = > C 6 6
(99) $ " " 7 ,
(100) C 65 # 4 6 ".
(101) %%
(102) " # 12
(103) = " "
(104)
(105) 6% 6. D.
(106) 6 ; " " % ( % . / 0 < /" $ 0 : . 4
(107)
(108) " % " # E #
(109) / 3 0 ; . " *
(110) ;
(111)
(112) ' A " C
(113) 6 # %% ;6 7 #
(114) #7'6 '/%%0 79 A" 6: % % ( . '
(115) 6
(116) . / 0 " .
(117) /%(0 "
(118) . F.
(119)
(120) @ %. " 4
(121)
(122) .
(123) 6%5 6 #
(124) # . ;<
(125) 6 !" &-
(126)
(127) # # $ #
(128) #7"#$ ""%$&''() *+,6 # # 6: %6
(129) "
(130) *
(131) % # # . 6 # #
(132) 1
(133) E?G
(134) ". D 1. )G D % GH7? ! ""# I&. J.
(135) * . 5 : 6 :6 : 6
(136) . 6;/$ % %& '# ( ) *% + , ' '""""( - & (0F .
(137)
(138)
(139) ' J # # 65*
(140) 6
(141) ;
(142)
(143) 6 ' # '
(144)
(145)
(146) 4
(147) " %
(148)
(149)
(150)
(151) . 6 :
(152) #
(153)
(154)
(155) K %
(156)
(157) :
(158) 7 :
(159)
(160) F8 9 , .8.H .#( 4%
(161) -J ' ) 7
(162) . K.GC57< $ - )& / # K+. K.
(163) : # #
(164)
(165) 6
(166) .
(167) 8
(168) %
(169)
(170) # # /: 0
(171) 64
(172) : 6
(173) 6< : 6 6< : 6
(174) " 65 : 665*6. # # .
(175) *
(176) I *
(177) ; . # ' ; A
(178) #
(179) C
(180) . * " . * + 6 /%0; /5 '0 ,6
(181) "
(182) 5
(183) . . I7 +& +7L.E*@L* # +F23+FJ. I.
(184) '
(185) # # , #
(186) /%4 0 -.%$ / " 01 1 +' !"" '& '0 # !& % ' & 11* (,23 7 #
(187) # ""%$ -.%$ &*22)3((, 6 6M * 6 && 7 : /<
(188)
(189) # . , 4
(190) 0&1 <
(191)
(192) .
(193) /<
(194)
(195) * . . <
(196) . 0 &D <
(197) <
(198)
(199) "
(200) . -: M5*< )
(201) 4"" 5 % &2, 9 <N.:@%L.-!' - ' "&1+ &&M * )7 , <
(202) 6 * ,
(203) #5 " . * / 0 7 &1H7C<7C:67 897 ' ""& # FD+ &D7 FF1. +.
(204) "
(205)
(206)
(207) &F <
(208) 7" ' . ? 7" O O ' OO % '
(209) 7"
(210) ' &J <
(211) 6 %
(212)
(213)
(214) P # #
(215) # # " . <
(216) 6:'. /
(217) # 4
(218)
(219) . <
(220) "
(221)
(222) &-
(223) "
(224) !
(225) <
(226) #
(227) . &F7 FFJ3FFK &J, 9 <N.:@%L. )' I. -.
(228) +4 %5
(229) "" 6/ "$ % /: %0 " ?" # # /?" ;
(230)
(231)
(232)
(233) " # # # " " 0 &K !
(234) ,
(235) 4 %5
(236) "" &3+()((2, 8 ' ?" , % % 6;
(237) '
(238) ' # ' # # . # G ' ;
(239)
(240) ' ##Q R S #
(241) )G /7 #
(242) . .
(243) 0 &I 5 6
(244)
(245) !
(246)
(247) * . # ' ' " &K%%N5 # ( A 4D& &I= > '.CC*'7+; <&,# < 7% *JD. &2.
(248) 5
(249)
(250) ' 6
(251) 6M 76 " '
(252) &+ ' ?" ?" "
(253) 7 " ' 6 ' Q RS ) 8 $ # $ # ? ! ' 6 +1!"&"" % "' ') & "1' % % % '!"' " '1& ! ""& ,(2= ' " 6: %6.
(254) "
(255) ' 6 : %
(256)
(257)
(258) 75T 6 6 > '
(259) . ; / "
(260) B
(261) " . . <
(262)
(263)
(264) R
(265) S
(266) " 012. &+ P(7</ ?6 @(
(267) 1!"&" A . 4#11-D &- 5GC7<%' $ # 12D 12757C9NLA > '#&D. &&.
(268) + 7 8 9 : 8 5
(269) . $ !
(270) + * %%' %0 !# ) ) ( / " / %( ' " % (, B2 ,
(271) #
(272) # = , H R&-1F3&--+S6 66 6 . .
(273) 6 . # #
(274) 6 "" ,
(275) 5 , R&-1K3 &-+FS6 /* 4 0 6
(276) + ' & % '(, BB 1&7 &1 115 ,GPL7PH: A )0 . .&)' &&# D+I. &1.
(277) 7 , = R&-DFS
(278) ; / #
(279)
(280)
(281) " *$ " # ;H
(282) # U
(283) !
(284) &-J2 &-K2 " " "
(285) %
(286) . . "
(287) R $ S 0 1D +
(288) ;6<"
(289) " # #
(290) $ " " $ 5 " M $ #
(291) " . : ;
(292) 7
(293) ;&33)(,6
(294) . " /7 $ 0 # ? "/# 0 6;+ ' 1 # ) % %*# " )!" 1 ' '! % + ' 1 , (, BC. 1D, =75.%G<6
(295) < @( '
(296) . J- 1F' .HH+ D) 6EF &',# FKI. &D.
(297)
(298) * ' % .
(299) . /*$ #
(300) H
(301) 5
(302) "
(303)
(304) $
(305) 0 1J "
(306) "# #
(307) .
(308)
(309) . $ " , $ . E
(310)
(311) ' # , . 5 /0 , 6; + '# "'' *! " % 1 "'' ' * ) (,BG ' $ , /
(312) 0
(313) /* %0; /4
(314) 4 0 4
(315) . *
(316) * ? *
(317) . 1J' .HH F)'H A I 6& F #D-D 1K5 ,GPL7PH:J> &# K)'# '7#IK3&22. &F.
(318) 5
(319) #
(320) # . " " # *
(321) " " 4
(322) *
(323)
(324) " 7 *
(325) " " " C#
(326) , 6; + ! %* ' !' % 0 '11 ')# # # %# % % ' ' !" %* ' ) (,BL *
(327)
(328) "
(329) . " "" A
(330) . " $. * . , 6 . " # , ; /'. " ; .
(331) 0 1+/, . " . "
(332) / 3#
(333) 0 0 1'
(334) " # . 5 " " L
(335) #
(336)
(337) . " , 6 1I5 ,GPL7PH:69E$9)H & F9 M A N)# -D3-K 1+5 ,GPL7PH: 1 # ( 5 7 A 1&F 1-5 97H@.C 6& /& & # KD. &J.
(338) "
(339) . "
(340) A"
(341)
(342) . " " D2
(343)
(344) " ,
(345)
(346) .
(347)
(348) ,,
(349) D& ' ,
(350) .
(351) 3 *
(352) .
(353) # , # #
(354) 7
(355) "
(356) *
(357)
(358)
(359) *$ .
(360) $. " #. 6* % 6 R" 3S ' L6 <T% . ON
(361) ) 9 PO . ; " . D2
(362) R11S,GPL7PH:1&F D&5 ,GPL7PH: !' " ( :N
(363) F23FJ. &K.
(364) 8 ;#
(365) "
(366) #
(367) ;
(368) ". . .
(369)
(370) . '
(371)
(372) "
(373) .
(374) # 8
(375)
(376) . D1. % " " . C 6 6.
(377) . ;
(378) "
(379) .
(380)
(381) 6* % 6 . . . 8
(382) $ #
(383)
(384) $
(385) " . .
(386) # A" 3
(387) " " #
(388) D1' LG.<ON
(389) ) 9 PO DDC C7N'G::N ( 4
(390) A . &I.
(391)
(392)
(393)
(394) $ 7#
(395) # = R&-1-S; $ A
(396) #
(397) 4
(398)
(399)
(400) 5
(401) <3
(402) /*$ 8
(403) $ " #
(404) . $ *$
(405)
(406)
(407)
(408) . " . " 0DF G H 6*$ %6; " #
(409) " $ : " H6"" $ #. "
(410)
(411) .
(412) . $ " +" %=> 6/ "$ 7 " % => &3?, A
(413) . $
(414) DF7 .A5.<+2=( " ' B3( " ' / ' ,#' 4
(415) 1DF. &+.
(416) ,6; /,
(417) ' # 3 * " . 7 ,
(418) ' H % 5 ,
(419)
(420) A
(421) . " $ 0 DJ ? : , . 5V6 , ; / " A 5V R&+&+3&++DS
(422) 0 DK .
(423) 5V # A .
(424)
(425)
(426) 5V +5 " *' ' *( - # %' '( - %* ' " %(, QL : # .
(427) " 5V6 A :",:" A"
(428) A
(429) , H 3 A"
(430) "
(431) / "
(432) "
(433)
(434) # # * )
(435) " 0 D+. DJ, ,PAP?757 + ,#( @ # ' 1&D DK7 &13&D DIA57CW2RCC ' #( A%D-3F2 D+, ,PAP?757 P# &F3&J . &-.
(436) * # , ; /H " . . ; "
Benzer Belgeler
Engels, eski materyalist tarih anlayışının her şeyi eylemin güdülerine göre yargıladığını, hareket ettirici güçlerin arkasındaki kendi hareket ettiricilerinin
Marx’ın eleştirilerinin akla getirdiği gibi, eğer Hegel realiteyi mantıksallaştırmakla suçlanacaksa, bu durumda Marx’ın da aynı şeklide
- Eğer inanç için rasyonel bir temel söz konusu değilse, Kierkegaard’a dayanarak söylenecek olan şey, içeriğinden bağımsız olarak, içeriği dikkate alınmaksızın,
Alçalan yolda, merdiven lerden inilip küçük bir köprüyle dere geçili yor, sağa doğru yükselerek kaleye gidiliyor.. 00:10 Kaleye ulaşılınca, yol takip edilerek sola
6 Kubilay Ünsal, “Nâmık Kemâl: Celâleddin Harzemşah”, Atatürk Üniversitesi Türkiyat Araştırmaları Enstitüsü Dergisi, Sayı 39, 2009, s.115.. Aka Gündüz tarafından
Dünya tarihi yalnızca bir tek usun görünüşüdür, kendisini açımlaığı tikel oluşumlarından biri, kendisini tikel bir öğe olarak, halklarda sergileyen bir
Felsefi tarih: felsefi dünya tarihin genel bakış noktası soyut-genel değil, somut ve bugüne ait bir bakış noktasıdır.. Dünya tarihi tinsel bir zemin üzerinde
Cumhurbaşkanı, hükıimet üyelerine ve ekonomi büokra tlanna büytik projelerin 1.ıinitiilrnemşi durumun da enerji darboğaa yaşnabil eceguu so yledi.. den
