Geomorphological evolution and sedimentation characteristics of Biga plain (NW Turkey)

Tam metin

(1)Available online at www.sciencedirect.com. ScienceDirect Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 423 – 432. -96C5 "?E6C?2E:@?2= 6@8C2A9J,J>A@D:F> (&

(2) . 6@>@CA9@=@8:42=6G@=FE:@?2?5D65:>6?E2E:@?492C24E6C:DE:4D@7 :82A=2:?'0-FC<6J =2655:?[6?42?2 +646A763 #,%.-&4#!&#.'+'/0.4,$"1!0',+/0+ 1) )5(#/'.+'2#./'04 !1)04,$.0/+"!'#+!#/ #-.0*#+0,$#,%.-&4

(3) 8 )'(#/'.1.(#4. -96AFCA@D6@7E9:DDEF5J:DE@ 567:?6E9686@>@CA9@=@8:42=762EFC6D7@C>2E:@?2?556G6=@A>6?E@7E96:82)=2:? -96DEF5J:D 32D65@?7:6=5@3D6CG2E:@?DD2?52?58C2G6=2?2=JK6D2?5=:E6C2EFC6C6G:6H 5:8:E2=6=6G2E:@?>@56=H2DAC@5F4653JFD:?8

(4)

(5)

(6) D42=65 E@A@D966ED ,2E6==:E6 :>286D H6C6 FD65 E@ :?E6CAC6E6 E96 AC6D6?E 86@>@CA9@=@8:42= 762EFC6D -96 A=2:? 32D6 :D 4@>A@D65 @7 56?5C:E:4 6=6>6?ED 36=@?8:?8 E@ E96 *F2E6C?2CJ )6C:@5 "? E9:D =@H :?4=:?65 2C62 C:G6CD 5:D2AA62C :? 2==FG:F> :? D@>6A=246D -96C6D49:DE2?56D:E6D2?58C2?@5:@C:E6D2C@F?5E96A=2:? 24E@CD4@?EC@==:?8E96 7@C>2E:@?2C67=FG:2=AC@46DD6D 2?5E64E@?:D> C2G6=92D=@H7=2E?6DDC2E:@2?5>65:F>C@F?5?6DDC2E:@ -9:D:?5:42E6DE92E>2E6C:2=D5@?@E8@72C2?5F?56C8@ =:EE=6AC@46DD:?8J6E2C642CC:653J27=@@5C:G6C56A@D:E652?5E92E7=FG:2=AC@46DD6DAC6G2:=@G6CE962C62 &2?J72F=ED:?E96 2C62@E96C7C28>6?ED2?5E64E@?:4=:?6D=:>:E:?8E96:82)=2:?4@?DE:EFE6G2C:@FDA2CED@7E96'@CE9?2E@=:2?2F=E%:?6 -96D6 724E@CD92G627764E65E965C2:?286:?E962C62. L

(7) -96FE9@CD )F3=:D9653J=D6G:6C © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier %E5. Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. ,6=64E:@?2?5A66C C6G:6HF?56CC6DA@?D:3:=:EJ@7+646A76&F?:C(KEFC<2?5"3C29:>E2=2J Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the Organizing Committee of GEOMED2013.. #43,."/ 6@>@CA9@=@8:42=6G@=FE:@?D65:>6?E2E:@?:82A=2:? -FC<6J. -964@2DE2=A=2:?D2C6E96H@C=5D>@DE:>A@CE2?E28C:4F=EFC2=2?5C6D:56?E:2=2C62D =2C86A@CE:@?@7E96H@C=5D A@AF=2E:@? =:G6D :? E96 4@2DE2= K@?6 @2DE2= A=2:?D 2C6 G6CJ H:56=J FD65 D:?46 E96J 2C6 2446DD:3=6 =@H 2C62D 2?5. @CC6DA@?5:?82FE9@C -6=

(8)

(9) 72I?@?6. *')"".#// C646A6769@E>2:= 4@>. 1877-0428 © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the Organizing Committee of GEOMED2013. doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2014.02.120.

(10) Alaeddin Şencan and Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 423 – 432. 424. E96J2C6E96A=246D>@DE 6IA@D65E@E9667764E@7A6@A=6 -964@2DED2C6:?E967:CDEA=246D2>@?8E96>@DE27764E65 A2CED3JE96D62 DFC72467=F4EF2E:@?D >@C@D:6E2=

(11)

(12) 2?54=:>2E6492?86DE92E@44FC:?*F2E6C?2CJA6C:@5 "E :D6IA64E65E92EE96>6=E5@H?@78=24:6CD5F6E@8=@32=H2C>:?8H:==C6DF=E:?:?4C62D6D:?D62=6G6=DH9:49 H:== =625E@D:8?:7:42?E492?86D:?E964@2DE2=A=2:?D76 3 2G:5D@? C?@EE

(13)

(14) . -FC<6JDFCC@F?5653JE96D62@?E96E9C66D:56D4@2DE2=A=2:?D92G68C62E:>A@CE2?46:?E6C>D @728C:4F=EFC62?5 D6EE=6>6?ED &@DE @7 E96 4@2DE2= A=2:?D 2C6 D:E6D E92E 92G6 >2E6C:2=D DF49 2D D2?5D A633=6D 2?5 D:=ED 56A@D:E65 3J DEC62>D "?E:>66?E:D@=D@:=92D366?56G6=@A65@?E96244F>F=2E65>2E6C:2= 2?5EFC?65:?E@76CE:=62C62D -96C62C6 2 8C62E?F>36C@7A=2:?D:?D@FE96C?&2C>2C2+68:@?7@C>653J7=FG:2=2?5E64E@?:4AC@46DD6D C56=6E2= . -64E@?:4>@G6>6?ED@44FCC65:?E96'6@ E64E@?:4A6C:@59252D:8?:7:42?EC@=6:?7@C>:?8E96D6A=2:?D[2C@V=F6E 2= !6C646

(15) (<2J6E2=

(16) 76 212=EZC2<6E2=

(17)

(18) "?E96C6DF=E@7E96D624E:G:E:6DD@>6 D:E6D 92G6 FA=:7E65 2?5 D@>6 D:E6D =@H6C65 C56= C5@D 46G:E@V=F 2?5 -@<

(19)

(20) -96 492?86D @44FCC652EE9632D6=6G6=D 92G627764E65E966C@D:@?2?556A@D:E:@?AC@46DD6D -966C@D:@?2=7@C46@7E96 DEC62>D 7C@> E96 9:896C A2CED 92G6 :?4C62D65 2?5 E96 56A@D:E65 >2E6C:2=D 92G6 7@C>65 =2C86 A=2:?D @? E96 D:E6D H96C6 E96 D=@A6 564C62D65 C:?S 2?5 :=8:? C:?S 82:? :? E96 C6DF=E @7 D2>6 AC@46DD6D E6CC246D 92G6 366? 7@C>652EG2C:@FD=6G6=D2C@F?5E964@2DE2=A=2:?D -96D6E6CC246D2C6D66?@?E96D@FE94@2DED@7&2C>2C2,622E >

(21) >

(22) >

(23)

(24) >2?5

(25)

(26)

(27) >2?56G6?2E

(28)

(29) >C@=2?5'FEE2== "E92D366?2DDF>65E92E D@>6 @7 E96D6 E6CC246D H6C6 7@C>65 3J E64E@?:4 2?5 D@>6 3J 6FDE2E:4 24E:G:E:6D C:?S

(30)

(31) CE6< 2?5 1Z=5ZCZ>

(32)

(33) C56= :=8:? C@=

(34) C@= C5@D $TAU< C@=2?5[6?42? [6?42?

(35)

(36) &2?J 4@2DE2= A=2:?D H6C6 7@C>65 3J ?6@ E64E@?:4 >@G6>6?ED &2?J @7 E96D6 A=2:?D 92G6 366? D92A653JE96E64E@?:424E:G:E:6D2?5E967=FG:2=AC@46DD6DC5@D C:?S 76 ,@J<2?2?5UC632= . -96DEF5J2C62 :D=@42E65:?E96?@CE962DE@7E96:82)6?:?DF=2 :?H6DE6C?-FC<6J -96@3;64E:G6@7E96DEF5JE@ 567:?6 E96 86@>@CA9@=@8:42= 762EFC6D @7 E96 :82 )=2:? 2?5 E@ D6E @FE E96 67764E:G6 724E@CD :? E96 AC@46DD6D @7 >@CA9@=@8:42= 6G@=FE:@? 2?5 56G6=@A>6?E @7 E96 A=2:? "? E9:D DEF5J AC6G:@FD=J AF3=:D965 C6D62C49 DEF5:6D H6C6 6G2=F2E652?52DD6DD65 5:8:E2=6=6G2E:@?>@56=H2D4C62E65FE:=:K:?8E96

(37)

(38)

(39) D42=6E@A@8C2A9:4>2A "?@C56C E@ 6IA=2:? E96 C6=2E:@?D9:A 36EH66? =:E9@=@8J 2?5 86@>@CA9@=@8:42= F?:ED 6?6C2= :C64E@C2E6 @7 &- 2?5 ," C6D@FC46DH6C6FE:=:K65. -96:82)=2:?=@42E65:?E96?@CE962DE@7E96:82)6?:?DF=2:DE96D65:>6?E2E:@?D:E67@C>653JE96>2E6C:2=D 56A@D:E653JE96:82,EC62>2?5:EDEC:3FE2C:6D6DA64:2==JE96$@42,EC62>7=@H7C@>E96A=2E62FD:E6:?E96?@CE9. -96 D65:>6?ED 56A@D:E65 :? E96 7=@@C @7 E96 A=2:?D 2C6 36:?8 5C2:?65 3J E96 :82 ,EC62> E96 $@4232\ ,EC62> C2?:4@D=:<623:83@H=2?542CC:6DE96762EFC6@72C:7EA=2:?H:E92==FG:2=7:==. C@F?5E96:82)=2:?E96C62C686?E=JC@==:?8D:E6DH9:492C6?@EG6CJ9:89 -96D62C67C28>6?E653JC:G6CD2?5 92G62A=2E62F=:<6 -96:82 2?2AZ?2CZ)=2E62F:D=@42E65:?E96D@FE9E96 UCS6D>6 $6>6C)=2E62F:D=@42E65:? E96H6DE2?5$2C23:82 $2C292>K2=2C)=2E62F:D=@42E65:?E96?@CE9 "?E96=@H9:==JD:E6:?E96D@FE92?5E96H6DE@7 E96 2C62 =:6D 56EC:E2=D D2?5DE@?6 2?5 2?56D:E6D @7 -6CE:2CJ 2?5 @46?6 A6C:@5 2?5 :? E96 ?@CE9 =:6D '6@86?6 7@C>2E:@?D. -@ E96 62DE :? E96 5:C64E:@? @7 2=Z<=ZS6\>6 ,6G=:<TJ E96 -6CE:2CJ G@=42?:4 C@4<D 2?56D:E6 EF77 2?5 56EC:E2=D D2?5DE@?6E9CFDE:?8:?E@E967=@@C@7E96A=2:?D2?5E9686@=@8:42=DECF4EFC67@C>653J=:>6DE@?6 H:E9A6?:?DF=2 D92A6 >@CA9@=@8J E96 6IE6?D:@?D @7 E96 UCS6\>6 $6>6C )=2E62F 5:G:56 E96 :82 )=2:?D :?E@ EH@ D6A2C2E6 A2CED :?8T=6E2= -967:CDE@7E96D6:D24@?E:?F2E:@?@7E96$2C2422=:4C66<2?5E96 6J:<<ZCZ4C66<5:C64E:?8E@ E9662DEH96C6E96:82)=2:?5C2:?DH2E6C:?E96H6DE2?5?@CE9 -96@E96C92=7:DE96D@FE92?5D@FE962DE@7E96:82 )=2:?H96C6E96$@4256C62?5E96$@42,EC62>5C2:?E96:CH2E6CD -96C:G6C42E49>6?E3@F?52CJH9:495:G:56DE96 EH@42E49>6?E2C62D2C6D6A2C2E65H:E92E9C6D9@=5C:D:?8FAE@E96H6DE:?E965:C64E:@?@7E96-2\E6A6

(40) >2?5 E96$2J>2<2> !:==

(41) >2?5H:E92=:?6E@365C2H?E@E9662DE@7E96H2E6CD64E:@?@7E96$2C23@V2!:==>. "? E96 62DE E@ E96 5:C64E:@? @7 D@FE9H6DE ?@CE9H6DE H96C6 E96 $@42 DEC62> E96 <<TCU /:==286 H9:49 @H? 2.

(42) Alaeddin Şencan and Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 423 – 432. 5C2:?286:E7@C>D2EC:3FE2CJ@7:82,EC62> 2?5E96 6J:<<ZCZ 4C66< :?5:42E:?82H6DE 62DE5C2:?286:DE@52J5C:65 FA2?5FD652D2?28C:4F=EFC6D:E6E96H6DE@7%2<646. :8 %@42E:@?@7 E96 DEF5J2C62. &##/0+",.0&#!0',+/,$'%)'+ -96H6DE2?5?@CE9D64E:@?@7:82)=2:?2C65C2:?653JE96 6J:<<ZCZ 4C66< 2?5:EDEC:3FE2C:6D -96DEC62>7256D 2H2J:?E9656EC:E:4D:?E967=@@C@7E96A=2:?367@C6:EC62496DE@E96:82,EC62>E@E9662DE@716?:S:7E=:< -96H62< DEC62>D:?E96?@CE9 @7E96 6J:<<ZCZ2?5$2C242=:DEC62>D2C6E9CFDE:?E@E96D@FE9:?4=:?65A2=E62FD:E6D -96D=@A6D @7E96G2==6JD:?E9:DD:E62C6?@EG6CJDE66A2?592G64C62E65=2C862==FG:2=7=@@CD:?E9632D:?. -96 DFC7246D =:?65 36EH66? E96 G:==286D @7 U=6S<TJ 2?5 NZ?2C<TACU >2E49 E96 7@C>6C =2<6 32D6 =6G6= -96 56A@D:EDC67=64E:?82=24FDEC:?6D65:>6?E2E:@?6?G:C@?>6?E2C@F?5E96 U=6SG:==286H2D4FE5F6E@E96492?86D@7 32D6 =6G6=D 2?5 7@C>65 E96 7@C>6C =2<6 32D6 DE2EFD DFC7246D &@C6@G6C E96 DJDE6>D =:?:?8 FA E@ $2C23:82 2?5 $@42252 >2?5E96DFC7246D@7E96-@<2E<ZCZ G:==286E@E9662DE@7X?4:C=:-6A6 >E96,2=<Z>=Z!:== > 2?5 $256>=:6?6S C6DE > 42CC:6D E96 EC246D @7 E96 7@C>6C =2<6 2D E96 =6G6=D 7@C>65 FA 5F6 E@ E96 4FE @7 D65:>6?E2E:@?DH9:494C62E65E9632D6@7E967@C>6C=2<6. -966=6G2E:@?=6G6=DE@E96H6DE@7%2<6462?5E@E9662DE2?5D@FE9@72V=2CC:5862?5E96K2=EZN:7E=:V:2C6 E96 DFC7246D @7 E96 7@C>6C =2<6 32D6 -96 32D6 @7 %2<6 46 H9:49 :D ?@H FD65 2D 2? 28C:4F=EFC6 D:E6 7@C>D E96 =@H6DE2C62@7E9632D:? 09:=6E967@C>6C=2<62C62H2D23@FE

(43) <>ME@52J:E:D564C62D6523@FEE@ <>M -96 7@C>6C =2<6 =6G6= H2D 23@FE > H96C62D :D :D 23@FE > :? E96 5=:J6 G:==286 $2C23:82 2?5 $2C292>K2=2C 2C6 A2E4965E@.AA6C )=:@46?6DFC7246D4FEE:?8E9656A@E:DED@7'6@86?6:?E96=@HA=2E62F -96D2C9:==>C:D:?8 7C@>E96A=2:?32D6E@E96D@FE9@7$2C23:822?5E@E96H6DE@7E96:82,EC62>:D2?6?G:C@?>6?EH96C67:?64=2DE:4 6=6>6?EDDF492DD2?52?54=2J2C656A@D:E65 -9656A@D:ED7@C>65:?E9656A@D:E:@?6?G:C@?>6?E>2E496DE964FE =6G6=D5F6E@32D6=6G6=492?86D. "? @C56C E@ 56E6C>:?6 E96 7@C>2E:@? @7 E96 A=2:? A633=6 2?5 D2?5 D2>A=6D 4@==64E65 7C@> G2C:@FD D:E6D H6C6 2?2=JK65 ,2?E2?22?5F>@?E

(44)

(45) %:C22?5):?2

(46) #F566E2=

(47)

(48) -96 4FCG65C2H?:?E968C2?F=@>6EC:4 2?2=JD:D @7 E96 D2?5 D2>A=6 4@==64E65 7C@> E96 D65:>6?ED @7 > 9:89 F?56C E96 > E9:4< 4=2J =2J6C 7@C>:?8 E96 H6586:?E96D=@A6D@7E96>65:F>G2=F6H2D7@F?5&5

(49) >> E967:CDE BF2CE6CH2D7@F?5*

(50) >>2?5 E96 D64@?5 BF2CE6C H2D 7@F?5 *

(51)

(52) >> -96D6 G2=F6D :?5:42E6 E92E DE@C286 :D 7@C>65 3J >65:F> D2?5 D:K65. 425.

(53) 426. Alaeddin Şencan and Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 423 – 432. >2E6C:2=D2?5E966=6>6?EDDF492D7:?6D:K65D2?52=D@6I:DE:?E966?G:C@?>6?E -9656A@D:E:@?@7E96=2C86D:K65 6=6>6?ED :? E96 D65:>6?ED 5C2HD 2EE6?E:@? E@@ -96 4FCG6 :D @7 2 D:8>@:5 @?6 2?5 DF49 2 4FCG6 :?5:42E6D E96 6?G:C@?>6?ED H96C6 D@>6 46CE2:? D:K65 6=6>6?ED 2C6 8C@FA65 ,:?46 E96 >:55=6 A2CE @7 E96 4FCG6 H96C6 >65:F> D:K65D2?5D6I:DE:DBF:E6DE66A2?5E964FCG6D9@H:?8E9656A@D:E:@?@7=2C862?5D>2==D:K65>2E6C:2=D:D=@H:E92D 2D=:89E8C25:6?E -96A6C46?E286C2E6D@7=2C866=6>6?ED36:?8=@H:?5:42E6E92EE967@C464@F=5?@E6I4665246CE2:? =:>:E2?596=A42CCJE9@D6 -967:?66=6>6?ED36:?8 G6CJD>2==4@F=556A@D:E:?E96D:E62?5H6?E@?E96:CH2JD -96 >65:F>D2?5D:K6C2E:@:?E96DE@C286:D (E96CC2E:@D7@==@H2D :?4@2CD6D2?5 :?7:?6D2?5 :? G6CJ 7:?6 D2?5

(54) :? G6CJ 4@2CD6 D2?5 -96 56A@D:E:@? D9@HD E92E E96 42CCJ:?8 724E@C :D AC:>2C:=J A@H6C7F=2?5>65:F>D:K6D2?536:?8A=6?EJ56A@D:ED3J2DF556?A@H6C=@DE9@H6G6C5F6E@:ED67764E8C25F2==J 564C62D6D E96 7:?6 6=6>6?ED 2C6 56A@D:E65 -96 3655:?8 :? >65:F> 2?5 7:?6 6=6>6?ED C676CD E@ >2E6C:2=D 2C6 EC2?D76CC65H:E92D=@HE6>A@36D:56E96H62<EC2?D76C7@C46. :8 :82A=2:?2?56=6G2E:@?=6G6=D:?E96G:4:?:EJ. &#,10&+",10&3#/0#!0',+/,$'%)'+ -96 >2:? DEC62> @7 E9:D D64E:@? :D E96 $@42 ,EC62> E96 XA<2:J6 DEC62> H9:49 E2<6D :ED D@FC46D 7C@> E96 >@F?E2:?@FD A2CE :? D@FE9H6DE -96 >2:? DEC62> 6?E6CD E96 :82 )=2:? H:E9 E96 EC:3FE2C:6D @7 E96 $@42S2J E96 @V2?56C62?5E96,2CADEC62> "?E96A=2:?D64E:@?:EE2<6DE96EC:3FE2C:6DDF492DE962<242<E96N2?3@V2KZ2?5 E96 -6<<6 DEC62> "E 492?86D :ED 365 :? E96 D64E:@? 42==65 E96 2E2< >2CD9J A=2:? 2CE96C :E E2<6D E96 )6<>6K=: 4C66<E96$@4256C6E96.K8F2 4C66<D2?5E96$2G2<4C66< 2?5C62496DE96:82 DEC62>:?E9662DE@7E96<<TACU G:==286. -96DECF4EFC67@C>653J@D6?7=JD96D56EC:E:4 D2?5DE@?6:?E96D@FE962DE@7E962?Z\>6?EG:==286H96C6E96 16=56V:C>6?:9:==>:D7@F?5:DE964@?E:?F2E:@?@7E96=:E9@=@8:4DECF4EFC6:?E96H6DE2?5:E:D@C:8:?2E653JE96.

(55) Alaeddin Şencan and Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 423 – 432. 4@==2AD6 @7 E96 A=2:? H:E9 ?6@E64E@?:4 >@G6>6?ED 2?5 E96 D6EE=6>6?ED @7 E96 ,2K=Z<56C6 E96 CZ=Z< 4C66< 2?5 E96 $@42DEC62>H:E9E96:C>2E6C:2=DH:E9_52E6A6`>@CA9@=@8J:?E9632D6@72==FG:2=A=2:?. -96DEC62>DH:E9?@CE9 D@FE95:C64E:@?D:?5:42E:?82DF3 A2C2==6=5C2:?286DECF4EFC6DF492DE96.K8F2 4C66< E96 JG2=Z4C66<E96$FK8F?4C66< 2?5E961@=2C2DZ 4C66< :?E96D64E:@?2>@?8E96G:==286D@7V2<TJ@V2?4Z2?5 U=6S6?E6CE96A=2E62FD64E:@?:?E96?@CE9H:E9

(56) D=@A6E@E96D@FE92?592G67C28>6?E65:?E967@C>D@7=2C86 DFC7246D@?E96A=2:?D7@C>653J56EC:E:4D2?5D6EE=65:?E@E9632D6D@72==FG:2= A=2:? -9632D6D@7E96G2==6J2C6?@E G6CJ566A=J4FE3FEE96D=@A6D2C6?@EDE66A -96DEC62>D:?E9:DD64E:@?92G629@@<655C2:?2866=3@H:?8E@E9662DE 3642FD6 @7 E96 C:G6C 365 >:8C2E:@?D @44FCC:?8 F?56C E96 4@?EC@= @7 H:E9 C:89E =2E6C2= 72F=E:?8 -96C6 92D 2AAC@I:>2E6=J366?2

(57)

(58) >C:89E=2E6C2==62A:?E96$FK8F?4C66< -962>@F?E@7>:8C2E:@?:?E96.K8F2 DEC62>:D

(59) > -961@=2C2DZDEC62>H9:49C62496DE@E96:82,EC62>7C@>E96D@FE9@7E96 U=6S<TJG:==286H:E92G6CJ =2C866=3@H2?5E96JG2=Z 4C66< :D4FEE@E96A=2E62F

(60) >2?5>566A -96D=@A6G2=F6D@7E96D6DEC62>D492?86 36EH66? 2?5. -96 :82 ,EC62> EFC?D E@ E96 62DE H:E9 2 D92CA 6=3@H 36EH66? E96 G:==286D @7 U=6S<TJ 2?5 5=:J6<TJ "E :D A@DD:3=6E@D2JE92EE96C:89E=2E6C2=72F=E:?896C692D2?67764E:?E96@44FCC6?46@7E966=3@H. +6D@FC465 7C@> E96 :82 2?2AZ?2CZ A=2E26F E96 N2?3@V2KZ 4C66< E96 $TDC6=:< 4C66< 2?5 E96 $2G2< 4C66< >2<:?8 4=62C 6=3@HD 2C@F?5 E96 EC:3FE2CJ DEC62>D @7 E96 $@42S2J :? E96 :82 )=2:? :?5:42E6 C64E2?8F=2C 5C2:?286 762EFC6D@44FC:?E9672F=E =:?6E@A@8C2A9JH9:49:D4@?EC@==653JE9672F=E =:?65:C64E65E@?@CE962DE2?5D@FE9H6DE. -96 A633=65 56A@D:ED 6I:DE @? E96 D@FE9 D=@A6 @7 E96 [232? 4C66< H9:49 :D 2 EC:3FE2CJ @7 E96 $@42S2J :? E96 =@42E:@?@7E96)UC6?=:< 9:==:?E96?@CE9@72<242<G:==286 44@C5:?8E@E96:?56I9:DE@8C2>:?E96>6E2>@CA9:4 >62DFC6>6?EC6DF=E@7E96

(61) A633=6D@7E@4>4@==64E657C@>E962?56D:E6 EF77A633=6D2E23@FEE96=6G6=D@7

(62) >E96 >65:F> G2=F6@7 7=2E?6DD:?56I:D"JD 2?5E96 >65:F> G2=F6@7C@F?5?6DD:?56I:D"JG :8. 096C62DE967=2E?6DDG2=F6D82E96C2C@F?5 @C E96C@F?5?6DDG2=F6D:?5:42E6C2E96CD6A2C2E65762EFC6D :? E96 C2E:@ "? 244@C52?46 H:E9 E9:D E96 G2=F6D @7 7=2E?6DD 36:?8 =@H 2?5 E96 G2=F6D @7 C@F?5?6DD 36:?8 >65:F> :?5:42E6DE92EE96>2E6C:2=H2D?@EEC2?DA@CE65=@?8H2J5@?@E86EAC@46DD652?542??@E86EC@F?565J6EE96J H6C6 42CC:652?556A@D:E653J2DEC62>92G:?827=@@5492C24E6C:DE:4 096?E96:?56I4@>A2C:?85:28C2>@7E96C@F?5?6DD 2?57=2E?6DD@7E96D65:>6?EEC2?DA@CE657C@>E96G@=42?:4A2CED:DG:6H652?5H96?E96>65:F>G2=F6D@7E96:?56I @7C@F?5?6DD2?57=2E?6DD2C64@>A2C65"JD "JG :E:DA@DD:3=6E@D2JE92EE9656A@D:E:@?:D@727=FG:2= @C:8:?. 44@C5:?8 E@ E96 :?56I 9:DE@8C2> :? E96 >@CA9@>6EC:4 >62DFC6>6?E C6DF=E @7 E96

(63) A633=6D @7 E@ 4> 4@==64E657C@>E96BF2CEKA633=6D2E23@FEE96=6G6=D@7E@>7@C>E96:82,EC62>:?E96D@FE9@7E96<<2JC2< /:==286E96>65:F>G2=F6@77=2E?6DD:?56I:D"JD 2?5E96>65:F>G2=F6@7C@F?5?6DD:?56I:D"JG

(64) -96 5:28C2> :?5:42E6D E92E E96 7=2E?6DD :?56I G2=F6D 2C6 36EH66? 2?5 2?5 E96 C@F?5?6DD :?56I G2=F6D 2C6 36EH66?

(65)

(66) 2?5

(67)

(68) 2AAC@I:>2E6=J

(69) -96C@F?5?6DDA6C46?E286DC676CE@E96DF556?:?4C62D6D2?5564C62D6D @7E9642CCJ:?87@C46 "?244@C52?46H:E9@FC@3D6CG2E:@?DE967=2E?6DDG2=F6D36:?8=@H2?5E96C@F?5?6DDG2=F6D 36:?8 >65:F>2?5E96762EFC6DDF492DE96C2?5@>@C56C@7E96A633=6D:?E96DE@C286 :?5:42E6E92EE96D62C6E96 A633=6D DE@C65 3J E96 DEC62>D H:E9 7=@@5 492C24E6C:DE:4D H9:49 2C6 H:E9 C2?5@> 7=@H :? 7=FG:2= 724:6D !@H6G6C H96?E965:28C2>@7C@F?5?6DD2?57=2E?6DD4@>A2C:D@?:?56I2?5E96:C>65:F>G2=F6D:?56I"JD "JG

(70) :8 2?5244@C5:?8E@E965:DEC:3FE:@?:?E965:28C2>:E42?36D2:5E92EE96>2E6C:2=>:89E92G6366?7@C>65 3JE96>2C:?6 =24FDEC:?66?G:C@?>6?E=2E6C@?. 44@C5:?8 E@ E96 :?56I 9:DE@8C2> :? E96 >@CA9@>6EC:4 >62DFC6>6?E C6DF=E @7 E96

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

(72) 428. Alaeddin Şencan and Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 423 – 432. 4@F=536D2:5E92EE96>2E6C:2=D3C@F89E3JE966C@D:@?7C@>E96D@FE9@7E96:82)=2:?H6C6=2E6C@?7@C>65F?56C E964@?EC@=@7>2C:?6 =24FDEC:?66?G:C@?>6?E. :8 -969:DE@8C2>>65:F>G2=F6"JD @77=2E?6DD:?56I@7E96 A633=6D4@==64E657@C>E96)UC6?=:<!:==:?E96?@CE9@72<242<. :8 -969:DE@8C2>>65:F>G2=F6"JG @7C@F?5?6DD:?56I@7 E96A633=6D4@==64E657C@>)UC6?=:<!:==:?E96?@CE9@72<242<. :8 -969:DE@8C2>>65:F>G2=F6"JD @77=2E?6DD:?56I@7E96 A633=6D4@==64E657C@>D=@A6D@7E96:82,EC62>:?E96D@FE9@7E96 <<2JC2</:==286. :8 -969:DE@8C2>>65:F>G2=F6"JG

(73) @7C@F?5?6DD:?56I@7 E96A633=6D4@==64E657C@>D=@A6D@7E96:82,EC62>:?E96D@FE9 @7E96 <<2JC2</:==286. -967=2E?6DD:?56IG2=F6D@7E96A633=6D2>A=6D2?2=JD:D36:?8=@H2?5C@F?5?6DDG2=F6D36:?8>65:F>:?5:42E6 E92E E96 >2E6C:2= H2D ?@E EC2?DA@CE65 =@?8 5:DE2?46 2?5 D9@CE=J AC@46DD65 7=@@5 492C24E6C:DE:4D DEC62>D >2C:?6 =24FDEC:?6 6?G:C@?>6?E A=2J65 2? :>A@CE2?E C@=6 !@77>2?? 6E 2=

(74)

(75) "E :D F?56CDE@@5 E92E E96 D:>:=2C 4=:>2E6 4@?5:E:@?DE@E@52J@44FC:?E96A6C:@5H96?E96DE@C2867:CDE7@C>65:?E962C62DF492D962GJC2:?D2?57=@@5D.

(76) Alaeddin Şencan and Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 423 – 432. :8 -967=2E?6DD:?56I9:DE@8C2>@7E96A633=6D4@==64E657C@>E96 E6CC24656A@D:ED2E>9:89E@7E96NZ?2C=Z 4C66< :?E96D@FE9@7:82 >65:F>G2=F6"JD . :8 -96C@F?5?6DD:?56I9:DE@8C2>@7E96A633=6D4@==64E657C@>E96 E6CC24656A@D:ED2E>9:89E@7E96NZ?2C=Z 4C66< :?E96 D@FE9@7:82 >65:F>G2=F6"JG . -964FCG6:8

(77) 5C2H?:?E968C2?F=@>6EC:42?2=JD:D@7E96D2?5D2>A=64@==64E657C@>E96>:55=62C62@7 E96 D65:>6?ED @7 > E9:4< @=5 365 @? E96 62DE D=@A6D @7 E96 :82 ,EC62> E96 >65:F> G2=F6 H2D 7@F?5 &5

(78) >>E967:CDEBF2CE6CH2D7@F?5*

(79) >>2?5E96D64@?5BF2CE6CH2D7@F?5*

(80)

(81) >> :8 2?5

(82) -96D6 G2=F6D D9@H E92E E96 DE@C286 92D 7:?6 D:K6 6=6>6?ED 2C6 5@>:?2?E 44@C5:?8 E@ E9:D E96 4FCG6 :D =@82C:E9>:4 D:?46 :E C62496D E@ E96 7:?6 6=6>6?ED :E D9@HD DF556? =62?:?8D !6C6 E96 7:?6 6=6>6?ED EC2G6=65 7@C 2 H9:=6 H:E9 E96 67764E @7 E96 DEC62> 2?5 =2E6C @? E96J H6C6 DE@C65 3J E96 DF556? 7@C46 :?E6CCFAE:@? ,ECF4EFC2= 6=6>6?ED36:?8G6CJ=:EE=6D9@HDE92EE967@C464@F=5?@E6I4665246CE2:?=:>:E2?5E96724EE92E29:89A6C46?E286@7 7:?66=6>6?EDD9@HDE92EE96DE@C286>:89E92G6@44FCC65:?2G6CJBF:6E6?G:C@?>6?E -9:DD:EF2E:@?DF886DEDE92E E96DEC62>EC2?D>:EE:?8E966=6>6?ED7=@HD:?2>2EFC6G2==6J -96DEC62>D@7H9:49DE66A?6DDC62496DE9632D6=6G6= 2?57=@@5DH9:49C6249E@E967=2E2C62F?56C8@2DF556?492?86:?DA665:?E9:DH2J "?E96DE@C2867:?6D2?5D:K6:D G6CJ7:?6D2?5D:K6:D >65:F>D2?5D:K6:D 4@2CD6D2?5D:K6:D 2?5G6CJ4@2CD6D2?5 D:K6:D 44@C5:?8E@E9:D?62CE9632D6=6G6=@7E96:82)=2:?E96:82,EC62>7=@H:?8:?:EDH:5632D65365 5F6E@E96564C62D654FCG692D82E96C65E967:?66=6>6?ED:?E9:D2C623642FD6@7E967@C4636:?8G6CJ=@H "?E96 C6DF=E @7 E96 DEC62> D6EE=65 :? :ED 4FCC6?E 365 E96 DE@C286D H6C6 4C24<65 2?5 E96 DEC62> 244F>F=2E:@? E6CC246 H2D 7@C>65 -964@2CD6D:K66=6>6?ED6I:DE?62CE962C62DE@E96D@FE9@7E96DEF5J 2C62 4=@D6E@E96D@FC46. &##2,)10',++"$,.*0',+,$0&#'%)'+ -64E@?:4 86@>@CA9@=@8:42= 7@C>2E:@? @7 32D:? @7 E96 :82 )=2:? 92D 366? 5F6 E@ G2C:@FD 724E@CD :? 86@=@8:42= E:>6D -96E6CC6DEC:2=2?5=24FDEC:?6&:@46?62?5 )=:@46?6D65:>6?ED7:==65E96 :8232D:? H9:494@==2AD65367@C6 E96&:@46?6:?'6@86?6 0:E9E96)=:@46?6 *F2E6C?2CJ'6@E64E@?:4>@G6>6?ED@7E96'@CE9?2E@=:2?2F=E2?5 @E96CC6=2E655:D=@42E:@?DE64E@?:4=:?6D3@C56C:?8E96A=2:?:?DEF5J2C627C@>?@CE92?5D@FE962DEC6 4@==2AD652?5 244@C5:?8=JE96E6CC6DEC:2=D65:>6?E2CJH6C6A2CE=J EC2?DA@CE65 H:E96C@D:@? -96D6H6C6C6A=2465H:E9E962==FG:2= >2E6C:2=3C@F89E3J E96DEC62>D7C@> 9:896C2C62D:?E96?@CE9 096?E9686@=@8:42==2J6CD2?5E965C:==:?852E2@7 E96DEF5J2C622?5E96:82)=2:?2C62?2=JK65E96>2E6C:2=D2?5 4=2JA633=6D:=E=:>6DE@?6>2C=3C@F89E3JE96 =:?62C2?5DFC724:?86C@D:@?67764E7C@>E969:892C62D4C62E653JE96A=2E62FD2C@F?5:E:DD66?E92EE96J4C62E65E96 E6CC6DEC:2=D65:>6?E2CJ@7E96@C:8:?@7E96*F2E6C?2CJ2==FG:2=DH9:492C6&:@46?6 ] )=:@46?6A6C:@5 DE96G:==286D @7 ,2CZ42 6>:4:<ZCZ 2=Z<=ZS6\>6 <J2AC2< $2C292>K2=2C 2?5 !24Z9UD6J:? 12J=2DZ H9:49 2C6 E96 G:==286D D:EF2E65@?E96D2>66C@D:@?2=DFC7246D 0:E9E965C:==D@A6?65H:E95:776C6?EAFCA@D6D:?E9632D6@7E96A=2:?2?5 2C@F?5 =6G6=D @7 4=2J D2?5 A633=6 D2?5 4=2J A633=6 D2?5 D:=EJ D2?5 4=2J A633=65 4=2J 4=2J65 D2?5 2?5 >2C= H6C6 7@C>65 -96 E9:4<?6DD @7 D65:>6?E @7 E96 G6CJ 7:?6 6=6>6?ED DF49 2D 4=2J :?5:42E6D E92E =28@@? 724:6D H6C6. 429.

(83) 430. Alaeddin Şencan and Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 423 – 432. 7@C>65:?E96DE:==H2E6C6?G:C@?>6?E C@>E:>6E@E:>6:E4C62E65E9656A@D:E:@?@74@2CD66=6>6?ED@77=FG:2=C@@E H:E99:896?6C8:6D7C@>2C@F?5. :8 C2?F=@>6EC:44FCG6@7:82DEC62><<2JC2<G:==286. :8

(84) C2?F=@>6EC:44FCG6@7:82DEC62><J2AC2<G:==286. -96:82)=2:?H9:49:DE96=@42=32D6=6G6=D7@CE96D=@A65A=2E62FD:E6D2C@F?5:D2=D@2A=2:?H9:4942CC:6DE96 762EFC6D @7 2 56=E2 -96 $2C23:82 4@2DED H96C6 E96 A=2:? 4@??64ED H:E9 E96 &2C>2C2 ,62 :?5:42E6D 2 =@H =:?62= 4@2DE2=762EFC6D =E9@F8992G:?8256=E2762EFC6:E5:5?@E7@C>2=6586E@H2C5DE96D62 -96>2:?C62D@?7@CE9:D:D E92E:E:?5:42E6D2DF3D:56?46762EFC6:?E96C6DF=E@74@==2AD6DH:E9E96?6@E64E@?:4>@G6>6?ED367@C6&:@46?62?5 )=:@46?6 ] *F2E6C?2CJ A6C:@5D 55:E:@?2==J 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 492?86D 5F6 E@ E96 '@CE9 ?2E@=:2? 2F=E 2?5 E96.

(85) Alaeddin Şencan and Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 423 – 432. 6FDE2E:4 >@G6>6?ED 4@2DE >@G6D 2?5 4@CC@D:@? 2?5 244F>F=2E:@? 6G6?ED @44FCC:?8 324< E@ 324< 2C6 E96 724E@CD 27764E:?8E9656=E2=6586E9FDE9656=E2?@E E@AC@8C6DDE@H2C5DE@E96D62. "? 244@C52?46 H:E9 E96D6 A:646D @7 :?7@C>2E:@? E96 6?G:C@?>6?E @7 56A@D:E:@? :D E96 C6DF=E @7 E96 2=E6C?2E:?8 E6CC6DEC:2= D65:>6?E2E:@? H:E9 E96 =24FDEC:?6 7=FG:2= D65:>6?E2E:@? 2?5 AC@8C6DD65 F?56C E96 E64E@?:4 6G6?ED 4C62E:?8E96&2C>2C232D:? -964FCC6?EG:6H@7E96A=2:?E@52J:DE96C6DF=E@7E96E6CC6DEC:2=D65:>6?E2E:@?36:?8 A2CE=JDH6AE3J6C@D:@?2?5C6A=2465H:E9E962==FG:2=7:==D@77=FG:2=@C:8:? C@H?6E2=

(86)

(87) . -96DEC:<6 D=:A72F=E>@E:@?D@44FCC65 5FC:?8 =A@C@86?6D:D:? E96-6CE:2CJA6C:@5 :?E96DEF5J2C62 -96C68:@? FA=:7E65 2?5 H2D 6C@565 :? E96 6?5 @7 2C=J @46?6 A6C:@5 "? E96 C6DF=E @7 E96 EC2?D8C6DD:@? 3682? :? E96 &:5 @46?6E96D65:>6?EDDE2CE65244F>F=2E:?8 -96 566A6?:?82?556A@D:E:?8DE@C286H6?E@?:?E96 %2E6@46?62?5 EFC3:5:E:6D56A@D:E65:?2=2C862C62. =E9@F89E96G@=42?:46G6?ED=@DEE96:C:>A24ED :?E96.AA6C&:@46?62?5)=:@46?6E96'@CE9 ?2E@=:2?2F=E H6?E @? :ED 24E:G:E:6D ,:J2<@ 6E 2= -96 :?E6?D6 E64E@?:4 6G6?ED @44FCC65 :? E96 .AA6C &:@46?6 3C@<6 E96 %@H6C &:5 &:@46?6 FAA6C =6G6= H9:49 :D E96 @FE=:?6 @7 E96 DEF5J 2C62 2?5 42FD65 E96 E@A@8C2A9:4 DECF4EFC6 E@ =@H6CE@H2C5DE96?@CE9. -96 6G6?ED 4C62E65 E96 4FCC6?E >@CA9@=@8:4 762EFC6D @7 E96 DEF5J 2C62 2C6 E96 '6@E64E@?:4 >@G6>6?ED H9:49 4@?E:?F6 FA E@ E@52J 2?5 7=FG:2= AC@46DD6D DE2CE65 2D @7 E96 &:5 &:@46?6 '6@E64E@?:4 24E:G:E:6D ?@CE9H6DE D@FE9H6DE62DE H6DE?@CE9 D@FE95:C64E65DECF4EFC2==:?6D?@CE9H6DE D@FE9H6DE62DE H6DE?@CE9H6DE=2E6C2= 2?5G6CE:42=5:C64E6572F=E:?8D64@?52CJ72F=EDH:E9E9696=A@7=2E6C2=AC6DDFC642FD65E64E@?:4C:D6D:?E964FCG6D 2?56>32C<2E:@?D2?5A=6?EJ@7>@CA9@=@8:42=EC246DDF492DE@A@8C2A9:45:D4@C52?46E64E@?:4D=@A66=3@HD2?5 D9:7ED:?DEC62>=:?62=G2==6JD92?8:?8G2==6JD2DJ>>6EC:49:==DDE6AA65D=@A6D6A:86?6E:4DEC2:EDJ@F?8/D92A65 G2==6J2DJ>>6EC:4G2==6JD6>365565>62?56CD6E4 H6C67@C>65.

(88) >@C@D: @?E2?2 ?E@?:@=: )C:>@?, @?56D2?

(89)

(90) )@DE =8>D65:>6?E2E:@?2?5!@=@46?6D9@C6=:?66G@=FE:@?:?E96'0 5C:2E:44@2DE2=2C62 6@24E2 . C56= ?25@=F92GK2=2CZ?Z?E6\6<<U=G6E6<2>U=U92<<Z?525U\U?46=6C " U 65 :=ED2JZ D7

(91) "DE2?3F= C56= -UC<:J6$ZJZ=2CZ?Z?-6\6<<U=G6-6<2>U=U?6-@A=F2<Z\ -UC<@VC 6C8 ,2JZ ?<2C2 C56= $FCE6C &2C>2C2^?Z?56?:K2=EZC6=:67: @VC ?D 6C8 ?@D7

(92) "DE2?3F= C5@D& 6?SE6<E@?:<92C6<6E=6C:?EUC<:J6^?:? ;6@>@C7@=@;:D:UK6C:?6@=2?6E<:=6C:4F>9FC:J6E:?

(93) JZ=Z?22C>2V2?: U 6563 2<. &2E D7 "DE2?3F= C5@D& -UC<:J6@G2=2CZ?Z?;6@>@C7@=@;:D:4:=E : U J2J ?@"DE2?3F= C5@D& #6@>@C7@=@;:2SZDZ?52?EUC<:J6@G2=2CZ?Z?@=F\F>=2CZG686=:\:>=6C:: U 4@VC 6C8 D2JZ D7 "DE2?3F= :=8:?- :82J2CZ>252DZ8U?6J32EZ<ZD>Z?Z?;6@>@C7@=@;:D:: U 12J 4@VC 6?D J2J D "DE2?3F= :?8T= <JUC6< $@C<>2K6C :82J2CZ>252DZ^?Z?;6@=@;:D:G6<2C2<2J27@C>2DJ@?F?F?32KZTK6==:<=6C:>E24F>9FC:J6E:?

(94) JZ=ZJ6C3:=:>=6C:<@?8C6D:E63=:V=6C 2C2=Z<D7

(95) ?<2C2 C@H?. 2C6J C<6?D F49D& !@77>2??- &242:C6# &@=56?92F6C$& 02==:?8

(96)

(97) C@>D65:>6?E2CJC64@C5D E@D65:>6?E3F586ED>F=E:A=62AAC@2496DE@42E49>6?ED65:>6?E7=FI 6@>@CA9@=@8J

(98) . 2G:5D@? C?@EE+

(99)

(100) "?EC@5F4E:@?E@4@2DE2=AC@46DD6D2?586@>@CA9@=@8JF?:G6CD:EJAC6DD42>3C:586",'

(101) 93 ",'

(102) A342>3C:586.?:E65$:?85@>. 46G:E@V=F -@<

(103)

(104) &@CA9@ E64E@?:46G@=FE:@?@7E96>2C>2C2D62:?76CC657C@>>F=E: 362>32E9J>6EC:42?5D6:D>:452E286@ >2C:?6=6EE6CD . 76+ 2 &2C>2C256?:K:8U?6J:?56<2C23:82 E29:C@G22C2DZ?52<:<ZJZ<6D:>:?:?S6GC6D6=;6@>@C7@=@;:D: - D2JZ D7

(105) "DE2?3F= 76+ 3 :82J2CZ>252DZ<FK6J5@VFDF?522C>FESF<52V=2CZ:=63:82G68T?6?S2J=2CZ2C2DZ?52<:S6GC6?:?;6@>@C7@=@;:D:" R 6?:K :=. G6:\= ?D 5@<E@C2E6K:"DE2?3F= 76+ :82J2CZ>252DZ^?52?6@E6<E@?:V:?;6@>@C7@=@;:<:K=6C: - 4 5 D2JZD7

(106) "DE2?3F= C:?S, !2GK2=2CZ?;6@>@C7@=@;:<6GC:>:92<<Z?525U\U?46=6C" R 6?:K := G6@VC ?D U=E6?:D2JZ?@"DE2?3F= C:?S,

(107)

(108) #6@>@C7@=@;:""6C12JZ?=2CZXDE2?3F= C:?S, 2?5:=8:?- -UC<:J6^56C6?2;-:A=6C:XDE2?3F=R?:G6CD:E6D:@VC27J2?DE:EUDU6C8:D: . 431.

(109) 432. Alaeddin Şencan and Recep Efe / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 423 – 432 C@=(

(110) -UC<:J6^56'6@;6?G6$FG2E6C?6C2\Z?Z>5T?6>=6C::=63F5T?6>=6C:?2\Z?Z>JUK6J=6C:J=6J2\ZE<@C6=2?E@CEF==2C28TC6 36=:C=6?>6D:;6@> 6C8 D2JZD7

(111) ?<2C2 C@=( :82J2CZ>252DZ32EZG68U?6J<6D:>:?:?;6@>@C7@=@;:D:&- @CE2< C2A@C?@. C@=( 'FEE2== ) N2?2<<2=6JTC6D:?:?32KZ56?:K6=<FG2E6C?6C56A@=2CZ4@VC C2\E 6C8 D2JZ ?<2C2 C@=( [6?42? NZ?2C4Z<G68U?6J:?:?;6@>@C7@=@;:D:-UC<-2C:9$FC @VC C2\ ,2JZ?<2C2 CE6<- 1Z=5ZCZ>

(112)

(113) &2C>2C256?:K:<ZJZE2C2S2=2CZ<@C6=2DJ@?FG6J@CF>F-UC< $FG2E6C?6C:S2=Z\E2JZ"-."DE2?3F= !6C646

(114) 16?:46 T?6?6AC6>$ZCZVZG6$FK6J?25@=F2J,:DE6>:?:?:8212CZ>252DZ?52<:.K2?EZDZ&-6C8:D:D = D !@77>2??- C<6?D 6C=249+ $=@DE6C>2??# %2?8

(115)

(116) -C6?5D2?54@?EC@=D@79@=@46?67=@@5A=2:?D65:>6?E2E:@?:?E96C9:?6 42E49>6?E 2E6?2

(117) . #F56 (82=25H:?( 52:<A@9(>@=6@>@( (>@ :C23@C2?5@D6>2CJ. (?@EF

(118)

(119) C2?F=@>6EC:42?2=JD:D2?5A633=6 >@CA9@>6EC:4DEF5:6D2D:?5:42E@CD@756A@D:E:@?2=6?G:C@?>6?ED@7E96D2?5DE@?6724:6D2C@F?5@<2?J2?2?56G:C@?D:?E9636?:?7@C>2E:@? D@FE9H6DE6C??:86C:2 0@C=52AA=:65D4:6?46D;@FC?2=

(120)

(121) $TAU< U>U\S2J@G2DZ?Z?;6@>@C7@=@;:D:X R 6?:K:=:>=6C:G6@VC27J2?DE:EUDU1U<D6<%:D2?D-6K:XDE2?3F= %:C2 2?5) ):?2

(122) C2?F=@>6ECJ@?4=2DD:7:65:>286D@7D2?58C2:?D;@FC?2=@74@2DE2=C6D62C49D:A8 A8:4D

(123) AC@4665:?8D A@=2?5:DD?

(124)

(125)

(126) 46C6?2 ] 46?EC@56C64FCD@D?2EFC2:D62>3:6?E6 (<2J X ,:J2<@& UC<2?$

(127) :82J2CZ>252DZ^?Z?;6@=@;:G6E6<E@?:<6GC:>:EA;53U=E6?:4 D7 . ,2?E2?2 2?5# F>@?E

(128)

(129) C2?F=@>6ECJ@7A633=636249C:586D:?7@CEH:==:2>DA@:?E8C66?H:49:D=2?52?E2C4E:4A6?:?DF=22 A@DD:3=6C6DF=E7C@>9@=@46?64=:>2E67=F4EF2E:@?DF D 6@=@8:42=DFCG6J2?5E96?2E:@?2=24256>:6DFD8D@7

(130)

(131)

(132) D9@CEC6D62C49 A2A6C [2C@V=F >C6P @C2J -UC<:J6^?:?5:C:72J=2CZG656AC6>D6==:<=6C:&-#6@=@;:6EUE52:C6D:C2A@C?@ ?<2C2 [6?42?

(133)

(134) :82N2JZ2EZ<6D:>:?:?;6@>@C7@=@;:D:X R ,@DJ2=:=:>=6C?DE:EUDU@<E@C2-6K:XDE2?3F= ,:J2<@& FC<2?$ (<2J % :82G6 6=:3@=F12CZ>252=2CZ?Z?-6CD:J6C#6@=@;:D:G6!:5C@<2C3@?(=2?2<=2CZ-)#U=E6?: ?<2C2 ,@J<2? UC632=X T?6?N2JZ-29:C@G2:=66=<ZD-@>3@=@DFC2DZ?Z?$ZJZ#6@>@C7@=@;:D:-UC<@VC27J26C8:D: XDE2?3F= 12=EZC2< ,2<:?S& <DF !:D4@EE+ ' 2E=63 .=86?.

(135)

(136) %2E6A=6:DE@46?6FA=:7E9:DE@CJ2=@?8E96D@FE9H6DE6C? >2C>2C2D6256E6C>:?657C@>C2:D654@2DE2=56A@D:ED2?58=@32=D62 =6G6=G2C:2E:@?D>2C86@=

(137)

(138) .

(139)