Teorik 2.Genomlar ve genetik varyasyonun kökeni

2.Genomlar ve genetik

varyasyonun kökeni

2.Genomlar ve genetik

varyasyonun kökeni

  ZD\VWRDFKඈHYHWKHVDPHJRDODQGWKHJXඈGOඈQHVZHJඈYHKHUHDUHE\QRPHDQVGHIඈQඈWඈYH+RZHYHUZH FKRRVHWRඈQWURGXFHWKHVHSUඈQFඈSOHVQRZEHFDXVHඈQRXUH[SHUඈHQFHRIGDWDDQDO\VඈVWKH\KDYHJUHDWO\ ඈPSURYHGRXUHIIඈFඈHQF\WKHFODUඈW\RIRXU5FRGHDQGWKHZD\ZHZRUNZඈWKGDWD +DYඈQJXVHG5IRUVRPHWඈPHZHKDYHFRPHWRWKHWඈG\YHUVHDSSURDFKKDYඈQJDOUHDG\OHDUQHGPDQ\RIWKH EDVඈFVඈQµQRUPDO¶RUVRFDOOHGµEDVH5¶,WFDQEHGඈIIඈFXOWWRVKDNHRIIZKDW\RXKDYHDOUHDG\OHDUQHG7KඈVඈV RQHRIWKHUHDVRQVZHDUHNHHQWRඈQWURGXFH\RXWRWKHVHDSSURDFKHVHDUO\RQWKH\ZඈOOEHPXFKHDVඈHUIRU \RXWRWDNHRQERDUGඈI\RXDUHOHVVIDPඈOඈDUZඈWKWKHµVWDQGDUG¶ZD\RIGRඈQJWKඈQJV$EUඈHIQRWHRQDSSURDFKHV  WKHUHඈVDVXUSUඈVඈQJDPRXQWRIVQREEHU\DQGHOඈWඈVPIRUDSSURDFKHVWRFRGඈQJDQGVFUඈSWඈQJWKඈVඈVWUXHIRU5 DQGRWKHUSURJUDPPඈQJODQJXDJHV:HZඈVKWRVWHHUZHOOFOHDURIWKඈVWKHPRVWඈPSRUWDQWWKඈQJඈVOHDUQඈQJKRZ WRXVHWKHWRROVDW\RXUGඈVSRVDOHIIHFWඈYHO\DQGHIIඈFඈHQWO\

*HWWඈQJVWDUWHGZඈWKWඈG\YHUVHSDFNDJHV

7RJRIXUWKHUWKHYHU\IඈUVWWKඈQJZHQHHGWRGRඈVඈQVWDOODQGORDGWKH–‹†›˜‡”•‡SDFNDJH/XFNඈO\WKඈVඈVYHU\ VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUG5XQWKHIROORZඈQJFRPPDQGV ‹•–ƒŽŽŜ’ƒ…ƒ‰‡•ſɑ–‹†›˜‡”•‡ɑƀ Ž‹„”ƒ”›ſ–‹†›˜‡”•‡ƀ $VPHQWඈRQHGEHIRUHZHZඈOOIRFXVPDඈQO\RQWKH†’Ž›”SDFNDJHKHUHRFFDVVඈRQDOO\ZHPඈJKWXVHVRPH RWKHUSDFNDJHVDQGඈIZHGRඈWZඈOOEHVWDWHGFOHDUO\7KHQH[WWKඈQJZHQHHGWRGRඈVJHWVRPHGDWDWRZRUN ZඈWK:HZඈOOXVHWKH•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWDIURP†’Ž›”\RXPD\EHQRWඈFඈQJDWKHPHKHUH«

•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʳކ’Ž›”śś•–ƒ”™ƒ”•

:KDWGඈGZHGRKHUH":HDVVඈJQHGWKH•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWDVHWVSHFඈI\ඈQJඈWZDVIURPH†’Ž›”XVඈQJWKHśśWKDW

EDVඈFDOO\PHDQVµORRNඈQVඈGH†’Ž›”IRU•–ƒ”™ƒ”•¶

,I\RXWDNHDORRNDWWKHGDWDE\W\SඈQJ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•\RXZඈOOVHHඈWඈVVWRUHGDVD–‹„„Ž‡7KඈVඈVDFRQYHQඈHQW

ZD\RIGඈVSOD\ඈQJD†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡DQGIRUDOOඈQWHQWVDQGSXUSRVHVEHKDYHVPXFKWKHVDPHZD\,WKDVWKH DGGHGDGYDQWDJHWKDWඈWMXVWVKRZV\RXWKHIඈUVWOඈQHVRIWKHGDWDNQRZQDVWKHŠ‡ƒ†,WDOVRVKRZV\RX ZKDWWKHGDWDDFWXDOO\ඈVඈHZKHWKHUඈWඈVFKDUDFWHUGDWDඈQWHJHUGRXEOHRUDIDFWRU7KHWඈEEOHVWඈOOEHKDYHV H[DFWO\DVDඈWZRXOGDVDVWDQGDUG†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡)RUH[DPSOH« •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛƒ‡ «ZඈOOSURGXFHDYHFWRUZඈWKWKHQDPHVRIDOOWKHFKDUDFWHUV6ඈQFHWKH–‹„„Ž‡RQO\VKRZV\RXWKHIඈUVW URZVRI\RXUGDWDZKDWඈI\RXZDQWWRVHHPRUH")RUWKDW\RXFDQXVHWKH’”‹–IXQFWඈRQOඈNHVR ’”‹–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řʰɨɬƀ 6RQRZZHKDYHWKHSDFNDJHORDGHGDQGWKHGDWDUHDG\ZHFDQVWDUWSOD\ඈQJDURXQGZඈWKඈW

6HOHFWඈQJFROXPQV

/HWVVD\ZHZDQWWRFKRRVHWKHQDPHDQGKRPHZRUOGFROXPQVIURPRXU•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWDKRZFDQZHGRWKDW" :ඈWKVWDQGDUG5ZHPඈJKWGRVRPHWKඈQJOඈNHWKඈV ɪ™‹–Šƒ‡• •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƃř…ſɐƒ‡ɐřɐŠ‘‡™‘”Ž†ɐƀƄ ɪ™‹–Š‹†‹…‡• •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƃř…ſɨřɰƀƄ

  :ඈWK†’Ž›”ZHFDQGRWKHIROORZඈQJ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ•‡Ž‡…–ſƒ‡řŠ‘‡™‘”Ž†ƀ :DඈWDPඈQXWHZKDWGRHVʩʴʩGR"7KඈVඈVDSඈSHඈWHVVHQWඈDOO\PHDQVWDNHWKHWKඈQJRQWKHOHIWDQGDSSO\WKH IXQFWඈRQRQWKHUඈJKWWRඈW<RXFDQXVHඈWFUHDWHFKDඈQVRIIXQFWඈRQVZKඈFK\RXFDQHDVඈO\DSSO\WRPXOWඈSOH GDWDIUDPHVඈI\RXQHHG,WWDNHVDEඈWRIJHWWඈQJXVHGWREXWඈWFDQRIWHQFODUඈI\FRGH)RUFRQVඈWHQF\ZඈWK VWDQGDUG5ZHFRXOGKDYHDOVRZUඈWWHQWKHFRGHDERYHOඈNHVR •‡Ž‡…–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡řŠ‘‡™‘”Ž†ƀ %RWKZD\VZRUNDQGXOWඈPDWHO\WKDWඈVDOOWKDWPDWWHUVEXWIRUFODUඈW\DQGJRRGSUDFWඈFHZHZඈOOXVHWKHʩʴʩSඈSH WRPDNHXSRXUGDWDKDQGOඈQJZRUNIORZV6RZKDWHOVHඈVJRඈQJRQZඈWKWKHVHWZR–‹†›˜‡”•‡ඈQVSඈUHGIXQFWඈRQ

FDOOV":HOOWKHIXQFWඈRQ•‡Ž‡…–OඈWHUDOO\FKRRVHVFROXPQVIURPRXU†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡+RSHIXOO\WKH

VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGQHVVRIWKඈVDSSURDFKඈVDGHPRQVWUDWඈRQRIKRZWKHVHSDFNDJHVFDQPDNH5FRGHPRUH UHDGDEOHDQGHDVඈHUWRXQGHUVWDQG •‡Ž‡…–ඈVPRUHSRZHUIXOWKDQMXVWWKඈV6HHVRPHH[DPSOHVEHORZ ɪ…Š‘‘•‡ƒŽŽ…‘Ž—•ƒ‡ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ•‡Ž‡…–ſސƒ‡ƀ ɪ…Š‘‘•‡‘Ž›…‘Ž—•…‘–ƒ‹‹‰ƒ—†‡”•…‘”‡ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ•‡Ž‡…–ſ…‘–ƒ‹•ſɑɏɑƀƀ ɪ…Š‘‘•‡‘Ž›…‘Ž—•„‡‰‹‹‰™‹–Šɗ•ɗ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ•‡Ž‡…–ſ•–ƒ”–•ɏ™‹–Šſɑ•ɑƀƀ

)ඈOWHUඈQJGDWD

:H¶YHVHHQQRZKRZWRVHOHFWFROXPQVXVඈQJD†’Ž›”DSSURDFKEXWZKDWඈIZHZDQWWRVHOHFWURZV"7RGR WKඈVZHQHHGWRIඈOWHUWKHGDWDRQDJඈYHQFUඈWHUඈD/HW¶VVD\ZHZDQWWRMXVWVHOHFWKXPDQVIURPRXU•–ƒ”™ƒ”• GDWD:HFDQDFKඈHYHWKඈVXVඈQJDORJඈFDODSSURDFKඈHH[WUDFWඈQJRQO\URZVZKඈFKPDWFKRXUFUඈWHUඈD ඈHZKHWKHUWKHඈQGඈYඈGXDOඈVKXPDQඈQWKඈVFDVH/HW¶VIඈUVWVHHZKDWKDSSHQVZKHQZHDSSO\DORJඈFDO RSHUDWඈRQWRWKH•’‡…‹‡•FROXPQ5HPHPEHUWKDWIRUQRZZHZඈOOMXVWXVHEDVH5 •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ—ƒɑ $OOZHGඈGKHUHඈVDVNZKHWKHUWKHVSHFඈHVGDWDඈVHTXDOWRWKHVWUඈQJµ+XPDQ¶7KඈVUHWXUQHGDORJඈFDOYHFWRURI DQG YDOXHV,IZHQRZXVHWKඈVWRVXEVHWRXU†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡5ZඈOORQO\UHWXUQURZVZKHUHWKHYDOXH ඈV)RUH[DPSOH •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƃ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ—ƒɑřƄ 1RWHWKDW\RXKDYHWRVSHFඈI\\RXPHDQVSHFඈHVZඈWKඈQWKH•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWDXVඈQJDɛRSHUDWRUEHFDXVH RWKHUZඈVH5GRHVQ¶WNQRZZKHUHWRORRN,QRWKHUZRUGVWKHIROORZඈQJZඈOOQRWZRUN •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƃ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ—ƒɑřƄ

<RXVKRXOGDOVRQRWHWKDWZHQHHGDʰʰඈQVWHDGRIDʰWKඈVMXVWPHDQVµඈVHTXDOWR¶6RZKDWඈVWKH†’Ž›”

DOWHUQDWඈYH":HFDQXVHWKHVWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGO\QDPHVˆ‹Ž–‡”IXQFWඈRQIRUWKඈV •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩˆ‹Ž–‡”ſ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ—ƒɑƀ

  1RWඈFHZHXVHWKHʩʴʩSඈSHDJDඈQWKHUHDVRQIRUWKඈVZඈOOKRSHIXOO\EHFRPHFOHDUVRRQ<RXPඈJKWEH ZRQGHUඈQJDWWKඈVSRඈQWWKDWWKHUHGRHVQ¶WVHHPWREHDKXJHGඈIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHVHWZRDSSURDFKHVRWKHU WKDQWKHZD\WKHFRGHORRNV:KHUHWKHˆ‹Ž–‡”FRPPDQGUHDOO\EHFRPHVXVHIXOඈVZKHQ\RXXVHඈWIRU PXOWඈSOHGඈIIHUHQWYDUඈDEOHV /HW¶VVXSSRVHZHZDQWWRH[WUDFWDOOඈQGඈYඈGXDOVWKDWDUH+XPDQDQGWKDWDUHIURP7DWRRඈQHDVWKHඈUKRPHZRUOG :ඈWKEDVH5ZHZRXOGGRWKHIROORZඈQJ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƃ™Š‹…Šſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ—ƒɑĺ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛŠ‘‡™‘”Ž†ʰʰɑƒ–‘‘‹‡ɑƀřƄ

1RWHWKDWKHUHDOO™Š‹…ŠGRHVඈVPDNHVXUHZHVXEVHWWKH†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡SURSHUO\:KDWDERXWZඈWK†’Ž›”"

:HOOWKඈVZRXOGZRUN •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩˆ‹Ž–‡”ſ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ—ƒɑřŠ‘‡™‘”Ž†ʰʰɑƒ–‘‘‹‡ɑƀ <RXFDQVHHKRZ†’Ž›”PDNHVIඈOWHUඈQJRQPXOWඈSOHYDUඈDEOHVPXFKPRUHVWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGDQGFOHDQHU

)ඈOWHUඈQJ$1'VHOHFWඈQJGDWD

:KDWඈI\RXZDQWWRGRPXOWඈSOHWKඈQJVWRDGDWDVHWDWRQFH"3HUKDSV\RXQHHGWRJHW\RXUGDWDඈQWRDFHUWDඈQ IRUPDWRUMXVWZDQWWRVXEVHWඈWWRRQO\WKHYDUඈDEOHV\RXDUHඈQWHUHVWHGඈQ$V\RXJHWPRUHDQGPRUH H[SHUඈHQFHGZඈWK5\RXZඈOOIඈQGWKඈVඈVVRPHWKඈQJ\RXZDQWWRGRUHJXODUO\,WPDNHVVHQVHWRPDQDJH\RXU GDWDVWUඈSSඈQJඈWGRZQWRWKHNH\YDOXHVRIඈQWHUHVW7KඈVඈVSDUWRIWKHSUඈQFඈSOHRIWඈG\GDWD KWWSJDUUHWWJPDQJඈWKXEඈRWඈG\ඈQJ /HW¶VUHWXUQWRRXU•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWDVHWZKDWඈIZHZDQWWRJHWWKHQDPHKHඈJKWDQG\HDURIEඈUWKIRUDOOKXPDQ VSHFඈHV",IZHXVHEDVH5ZHZRXOGGRඈWWKඈVZD\ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƃ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ—ƒɑř…ſɑƒ‡ɑřɑŠ‡‹‰Š–ɑřɑ„‹”–Šɏ›‡ƒ”ɑƀƄ 7KඈVVRUWRIGDWDPDQඈSXODWඈRQUHTXඈUHVXVWRIඈUVWIඈOWHURQWKHURZVXVඈQJ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ—ƒɑ 5HPHPEHUEDFNWR&KDSWHUZKHQZHXVHGVTXDUHEUDFNHWVWRH[WUDFWGDWDIURPDPDWUඈ[DQGWKHQD GDWDIUDPH"7KඈVඈVH[DFWO\WKHVDPHWKඈQJ 1H[WZHVHOHFWWKHFROXPQVZHZDQWඈQWKHVHFRQGSDUWRIWKHEUDFNHWVXVඈQJ …ſɑƒ‡ɑřɑŠ‡‹‰Š–ɑřɑ„‹”–Šɏ›‡ƒ”ɑƀ7KඈVඈVIDඈUO\VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGHYHQXVඈQJEDVH5EXW\RXFDQඈPDJඈQH KRZWKඈVFRXOGEHFRPSOඈFDWHGඈIZHZDQWHGWRVHOHFWPDQ\GඈIIHUHQWFROXPQVRUIඈOWHURQGඈIIHUHQWYDUඈDEOHV :KDWඈVWKH†’Ž›”VROXWඈRQ" •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩˆ‹Ž–‡”ſ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ—ƒɑƀʩʴʩ•‡Ž‡…–ſƒ‡řŠ‡‹‰Š–ř„‹”–Šɏ›‡ƒ”ƀ +HUHZHMXVWSඈSHWKHGDWDWRˆ‹Ž–‡”DQGWKHQDJDඈQWR•‡Ž‡…–,WඈVZRUWKQRWඈQJKHUHWKDWWKH–‹†›˜‡”•‡ VROXWඈRQPඈJKWQRWEHSDUWඈFXODUO\IDVWHURUHYHQPXFKOHVVFRGH,WඈVඈQRXURSඈQඈRQDWOHDVWHDVඈHUWRUHDGDQG WRGඈVHQWDQJOHඈI\RXFRPHEDFNWRWKHFRGHDWDODWHUGDWH7KHUHUHDOO\ඈVQRUඈJKWRUZURQJZD\WRPDQඈSXODWH GDWDඈQ5ZKඈFKHYHUDSSURDFK\RXXVHඈVXOWඈPDWHO\DPDWWHURIWDVWH+RZHYHUDV\RXZඈOOVHHඈQWKHQH[W VHFWඈRQ†’Ž›”DSSURDFKHVFDQUHDOO\OHYHOXS\RXUDEඈOඈW\WRPDQඈSXODWHGDWD

6XPPDUඈVඈQJGDWD

:KHUH†’Ž›”UHDOO\H[FHOVඈVZKHQ\RXZDQWWRH[WUDFWVRPHNඈQGRIVXPPDU\ඈQIRUPDWඈRQIURP\RXUGDWD /HW¶VVWDUWZඈWKDYHU\VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGH[DPSOHXVඈQJRXU•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWD:KDWඈIZHZDQWWRFRXQWWKHQXPEHU RIGඈIIHUHQWVSHFඈHVWKHUHDUHඈQWKHGDWD")ඈUVWOHW¶VDFWXDOO\ORRNDWWKHVSHFඈHVSUHVHQW

  •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡• <RXFDQVHHWKHUHDUHIHZGඈIIHUHQWRQHVDOWKRXJKHYHQIURPWKඈVඈWඈVIDඈUO\REYඈRXVKXPDQVDUHJRඈQJWREH WKHPRVWQXPHURXV,IZHZDQWWRFRXQWKRZPDQ\VSHFඈHVWKHUHDUHDOOZHQHHGWRGRඈVFRXQWWKHRFFXUUHQFH RIHDFKRIWKHVH%HIRUHZHORRNDWWKH†’Ž›”VROXWඈRQZHZඈOOWDNHDORRNDWRQHPRUHEDVH5ZD\WRDFKඈHYH WKඈV –ƒ„Ž‡ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡•ƀ 7KඈVZRUNVDQGඈVIDVWEXWWKHPDඈQGඈVDGYDQWDJHඈVWKDWRXURXWSXWඈVQRORQJHUD†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡,WඈVDOVRPXFK PRUHGඈIIඈFXOWWRVFDOHWKඈVDSSURDFKXSඈIZHZඈVKWRJURXSRXUGDWDVHWE\PXOWඈSOHYDUඈDEOHV%XWIඈUVWWKH †’Ž›”HTXඈYDOHQWRIDERYHඈVDOVRVWUDඈJKWIRUZDUG •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ‰”‘—’ɏ„›ſ•’‡…‹‡•ƀʩʴʩ–ƒŽŽ›ſƀ $OOZHKDYHGRQHKHUHඈVIඈUVWJURXSHGRXUGDWDVHWE\VSHFඈHVXVඈQJ‰”‘—’ɏ„›DQGWKHQFRXQWHGWKHQXPEHURI URZVඈQHDFKJURXSXVඈQJ–ƒŽŽ› ‰”‘—’ɏ„›FDQUHDOO\FRPHඈQWRඈWVRZQZKHQ\RXZDQWWRFRXQWRUWDOO\GDWDEDVHGRQVHYHUDOYDUඈDEOHV/HW¶V VD\ZHZDQWWRFRXQWWKHQXPEHURIHDFKJHQGHURIZඈWKඈQHDFKVSHFඈHV:HZRXOGGRඈWOඈNHVR •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ‰”‘—’ɏ„›ſ•’‡…‹‡•ř‰‡†‡”ƀʩʴʩ–ƒŽŽ›ſƀ :HFDQGRDORWPRUHWKDQMXVWFRXQWRFFXUUHQFHVZඈWKWKඈVIXQFWඈRQDOඈW\IURP†’Ž›”3HUKDSVZHZDQWWRNQRZ WKHDYHUDJHKHඈJKWDQGPDVVRIHDFKVSHFඈHV" •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ‰”‘—’ɏ„›ſ•’‡…‹‡•ƀʩʴʩ•—ƒ”‹•‡ſ‡ƒɏŠ‡‹‰Š–ʰ‡ƒſŠ‡‹‰Š–řƒŜ”ʰƀř ‡ƒɏƒ••ʰ‡ƒſƒ••řƒŜ”ʰƀƀ +HUHDOOZHGඈGZDVXVHWKH•—ƒ”‹•‡IXQFWඈRQWRFDOFXODWHPHDQKHඈJKWDQGPDVV6ඈQFHZHXVHGWKH‡ƒ IXQFWඈRQRQERWKYDUඈDEOHVZHFDQDFWXDOO\VඈPSOඈI\WKඈVHYHQIXUWKHUOඈNHVR •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ‰”‘—’ɏ„›ſ•’‡…‹‡•ƀʩʴʩ•—ƒ”‹•‡ɏƒ–ſ˜ƒ”•ſŠ‡‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀř‡ƒřƒŜ”ʰƀ 6RWKඈVWඈPHZHXVHG•—ƒ”‹•‡ɏƒ–DQGVSHFඈIඈHGWKHYDUඈDEOHVZHZDQWHGWRVXPPDUඈVHZඈWKWKH˜ƒ”• IXQFWඈRQ 6XPPDUඈVඈQJGDWDඈQWKඈVZD\ඈVDXVHIXOVNඈOOHVSHFඈDOO\ZKHQ\RXZDQWWRJHWDIHHOIRUZKDW\RXUGDWDVHW VKRZVRU\RXQHHGWREUHDNඈWGRZQඈQWRPRUHXQGHUVWDQGDEOHVXEVHWV$VZHWXUQQH[WWRPRUHDGYDQFHG SORWWඈQJXVඈQJ‰‰’Ž‘–ɩ\RXZඈOOVHHWKDWPDQඈSXODWඈQJGDWDඈVHVSHFඈDOO\XVHIXOZKHQ\RXZDQWFUHDWHFHUWDඈQ W\SHVRISORWV

3ORWWඈQJZඈWKJJSORW

,QWKHODVWFKDSWHUZHOHDUQHGWKDW5ඈVKඈJKO\YHUVDWඈOHZKHQඈWFRPHVWRSORWWඈQJDQGYඈVXDOඈVඈQJGDWD 9ඈVXDOඈVWDWඈRQUHDOO\FDQQRWEHXQGHUVWDWHGDVGDWDVHWVEHFRPHODUJHUDQGPRUHGඈIIඈFXOWWRKDQGOHඈWඈV ඈPSHUDWඈYH\RXOHDUQKRZWRHIIHFWඈYHO\SORWDQGH[SORUH\RXUGDWD7KඈVREYඈRXVO\WDNHVSUDFWඈFHEXWSORWWඈQJ DQGVXPPDUඈVඈQJGDWDYඈVXDOO\ඈVDNH\VNඈOOIRUJXඈGඈQJIXUWKHUDQDO\VඈVWKඈVඈVHVSHFඈDOO\WUXHIRUHYROXWඈRQDU\ JHQRPඈFVEXWඈVHDVඈO\DSSOඈFDEOHWRDQ\QXPEHURIVFඈHQWඈIඈFIඈHOGV $V\RXPD\KDYHJDWKHUHGE\QRZWKHUHDUHORWVRIRSඈQඈRQVRQKRZWRXVH5ZKHWKHU\RXVKRXOGXVHEDVH RUWඈG\YHUVHDSSURDFKHV:HZDQWWRVWUHVVWKDWWKHUHඈVQRWKඈQJZURQJZඈWKXVඈQJEDVHSORWWඈQJඈWඈVFDSDEOHRI VRPHYHU\ඈPSUHVVඈYHSORWVXVH†‡‘ſ‰”ƒ’Š‹…•ƀWRKDYHDORRN+RZHYHU‰‰’Ž‘–ɩඈVH[WUHPHO\IOH[ඈEOHDQG

  WDNHVTXඈWHDGඈIIHUHQWDSSURDFKWRSORWWඈQJFRPSDUHGWREDVH5

JJSORWEDVඈFV

7KHEHVWZD\WRJHWWRJUඈSVZඈWKJJSORWඈVMXVWWRXVHඈWEXWEHIRUHZHGHOYHඈQWKHUHඈVRQHඈPSRUWDQWSRඈQW ZHVKRXOGWDNHQRWHRI8QOඈNHEDVH5ZKඈFKFDQSORWYHFWRUVGඈUHFWO\‰‰’Ž‘–ɩUHTXඈUHVWKDW\RXSURYඈGHඈWZඈWK VRPHGDWDIඈUVWXVXDOO\ඈQWKHIRUPRIDGDWDIUDPHRUWඈEEOHOඈNHZHGHDOWZඈWKඈQWKHSUHYඈRXVVHFWඈRQ &RQWඈQXඈQJZඈWKRXUWKHPHIURPEHIRUHOHW¶VXVHWKH•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWDVHWDJDඈQ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʳކ’Ž›”śś•–ƒ”™ƒ”• /HW¶VGRDVඈPSOHVFDWWHUSORWRIWKHKHඈJKWDQGPDVVRIWKHFKDUDFWHUVඈQWKඈVGDWDVHW ‰‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡•ſŠ‡‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſƀ )ඈUVWWDNHDPRPHQWWRH[DPඈQHWKHSORWWKඈVඈVDFWXDOO\DEUඈOOඈDQWH[DPSOHRIZK\ඈWඈVඈPSRUWDQWWRSORWGDWD VඈQFH\RXFDQVHHWKDWWKHUHඈVRQHඈQGඈYඈGXDOZඈWKD+8*(PDVVWKDWGඈVWRUWVRXUGDWDYඈVXDOඈVDWඈRQ,VWKඈVඈV DQHUURU"2USHUKDSVVRPHRQHZඈWKDORWRIPDVVඈVඈQRXUGDWDVHW" %HIRUHZHඈQYHVWඈJDWHWKඈVඈWඈVඈPSRUWDQWWRXQGHUVWDQGKRZRXU‰‰’Ž‘–ɩFRPPDQGඈVEXඈOWXS ‰‰’Ž‘–ſƀඈVWKHIXQFWඈRQFDOOWR‰‰’Ž‘–ɩZHSURYඈGHWKඈVZඈWKWZRDUJXPHQWVIඈUVWO\ZHVSHFඈI\RXU GDWDVHWDQGWKHQQH[WZHVHWDQDHVWKHWඈF WKHDHVWKHWඈFඈQWKඈVFDVHƒ‡•ſŠ‡‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀඈVMXVWZKDWYDUඈDEOHVWRPDSWRWKH[DQG\D[HVKHඈJKW DQGPDVVKHUHQRWHWKDWWKඈVPHDQV\RXMXVWQHHGWRSURYඈGHWKHYDUඈDEOHQDPHVඈH\RXGRQ¶WQHHG WRW\SH•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛŠ‡‹‰Š– IඈQDOO\ZHVSHFඈI\DOD\HUIRUWKHYඈVXDOඈVDWඈRQඈWVHOIඈQWKඈVFDVHZHZDQWWRSORWWKHGDWDDVSRඈQWVRQD VFDWWHUSORWVRZHXVH‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſƀ

  QRWHDOVRWKDWZHXVHGʫWRVHWXSRXUJJSORWIXQFWඈRQWKඈVඈVEHFDXVHJJSORWDOORZVXVWRPXOWඈSOH OD\HUVRIYඈVXDOඈVDWඈRQ ,I\RXKDYHXVHGEDVHJUDSKඈFVEHIRUHඈWFDQWDNHVRPHWඈPHWRJHWXVHGWRWKH‰‰’Ž‘–ɩZD\RIGRඈQJWKඈQJV +RZHYHUDVZHZDON\RXWKURXJKPXOWඈSOHH[DPSOHVKHUH\RXZඈOOVRRQJHWWKHKDQJRIඈWDQGVHHWKDWඈWඈV SRVVඈEOHWRHDVඈO\FXVWRPඈVHSORWV %XWIඈUVWZKRKDVVXFKDKXJHPDVV" ɤɤɤ–‹„„Ž‡śɨšɨɪ ɤɤƒ‡Š‡‹‰Š–ƒ••Šƒ‹”ɏ…‘Ž‘”•‹ɏ…‘Ž‘”‡›‡ɏ…‘Ž‘”„‹”–Šɏ›‡ƒ”‰‡†‡” ɤɤʳ…Š”ʴʳ‹–ʴʳ†„Žʴʳ…Š”ʴʳ…Š”ʴʳ…Š”ʴʳ†„Žʴʳ…Š”ʴ ɤɤɨ ƒ„„ŝɨɮɬɨɪɬɯʳʴ‰”‡‡Ş–ƒŝ‘”ƒ‰‡ɭɥɥŠ‡”ƒŝ ɤɤɤŝ™‹–Šɬ‘”‡˜ƒ”‹ƒ„Ž‡•śŠ‘‡™‘”Ž†ʳ…Š”ʴř•’‡…‹‡•ʳ…Š”ʴřˆ‹Ž•ʳŽ‹•–ʴř ɤɤɤ˜‡Š‹…Ž‡•ʳŽ‹•–ʴř•–ƒ”•Š‹’•ʳŽ‹•–ʴ :HOOඈI\RX¶YHVHHQ6WDU:DUVWKHDQVZHUWRWKඈVVKRXOGQ¶WEHDKXJHVXUSUඈVH«/HW¶VIඈOWHUKඈPRXWRIWKHGDWD •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩʳވ‹Ž–‡”ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡Šʰɑ ƒ„„ƒ‡•‹Ž‹Œ‹…‹—”‡ɑƀ 1RZZHFDQUHSORWWKHGDWDDQGVHHZKDWWKHUHODWඈRQVKඈSEHWZHHQKHඈJKWDQGPDVVඈV ‰‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩřƒ‡•ſŠ‡‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſƀ $VH[SHFWHGPDVVJHQHUDOO\ඈQFUHDVHVZඈWKKHඈJKW

&XVWRPඈVඈQJDSORW

+RZGRZHFXVWRPඈVHRXUVFDWWHUSORWXVඈQJ‰‰’Ž‘–ɩ")ඈUVWO\ZHFDQDGGVRPHFRORXUWRWKHSRඈQWV





‰‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩřƒ‡•ſŠ‡‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſ…‘Ž‘—”ʰɑ”‡†ɑƀ

2UZHFDQFKDQJHWKHඈUFRORXUDQGVKDSH

  1RWHWKDWඈQERWKRIWKHVHFDVHVZHDGGHGDUJXPHQWVWR‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–WKHIXQFWඈRQWKDWFRQWUROVWKHSORWWඈQJRI WKHSRඈQWV7KHUHඈVDQRWKHUZD\WRFKDQJHWKHSRඈQWFRORXUඈQYROYඈQJWKHDHVWKHWඈFVEXWZHZඈOOGHDOZඈWKWKඈV ඈQDPRPHQW 3HUKDSVZHZDQWWRDOWHUWKHRYHUDOOWKHPHRIWKHSORW":HFDQGRWKDWE\DGGඈQJDWKHPH ‰‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩřƒ‡•ſŠ‡‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſ…‘Ž‘—”ʰɑ”‡†ɑƀʫ–Š‡‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀ

  %\GRඈQJWKඈV\RXFDQVHHDJDඈQKRZZHFDQEXඈOGDSORWE\DGGඈQJOD\HUVXVඈQJʫ,WFDQJHWPHVV\WRGRWKඈV DOOZඈWKRQHOඈQHVRDQඈFHWKඈQJDERXW‰‰’Ž‘–ɩFRGHඈVWKDW\RXFDQDVVඈJQඈWWRREMHFWVDQGHDVඈO\EXඈOGD FRPSOH[SORW)RUH[DPSOH ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩřƒ‡•ſŠ‡‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀƀ ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſ…‘Ž‘—”ʰɑ”‡†ɑƀ ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ•‘‘–Šſ‡–Š‘†ʰŽř•‡ʰ ƀ ƒʳރʫ–Š‡‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀʫ‰‰–‹–Ž‡ſɑ‡‹‰Š–˜•ƒ••‹–ƒ”ƒ”•ɑƀ ƒ

  +HUHZHDGGHGWඈWOHDQGDOVRIඈWWHGDOඈQHRIEHVWIඈWWRWKHGDWDWRYඈVXDOඈVHWKHUHODWඈRQVKඈSHYHQPRUHFOHDUO\ 7RDFKඈHYHWKඈVZHXVHGWKH‰‡‘ɏ•‘‘–ŠOD\HUDQGVSHFඈIඈHGDOඈQHDUPRGHO7KඈVඈVDWRSඈFZHZඈOOUHWXUQWRඈQ IXWXUHFKDSWHUV :KDWඈIඈQVWHDGRIMXVWFRORXUඈQJWKHSRඈQWVWRPDNHDSORWORRNQඈFHZHGඈGඈWWRDFWXDOO\WU\DQGOHDUQVRPHWKඈQJ DERXWWKHGDWD")RUH[DPSOHZHFRXOGFRORXUWKHSRඈQWVE\VSHFඈHV7KඈVKRZHYHUUHTXඈUHVWKDWZHPDSSRඈQW FRORXUWRVSHFඈHVඈQWKHƒ‡•IXQFWඈRQRIRXUFRPPDQG:HZඈOOUHWXUQWRWKHEDVඈFSORWDQGGRVREHORZ ‰‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩřƒ‡•ſŠ‡‹‰Š–řƒ••ř…‘Ž‘—”ʰ•’‡…‹‡•ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſƀ

  7KඈVඈVZKHUHWKHSRZHURIDHVWKHWඈFVVWDUWVWREHFRPHDSSDUHQWZඈWK‰‰’Ž‘–ɩඈWඈVYHU\HDV\WRPDSFHUWDඈQ YDUඈDEOHVWRDQDHVWKHWඈFDQGYඈVXDOඈVHWKHPඈQDSORW

'ඈIIHUHQWW\SHVRISORWZඈWKJJSORW

7KHUHDUHPDQ\GඈIIHUHQWZD\VWRYඈVXDOඈVHGDWDXVඈQJ‰‰’Ž‘–ɩEH\RQGWKHVWDQGDUGVFDWWHUSORWZHKDYH DOUHDG\VHHQ)RUDIXOOOඈVWZඈWKUHSURGXFඈEOHH[DPSOHV\RXVKRXOGVHHWKHJJSORWPDQXDO KWWSJJSORWWඈG\YHUVHRUJUHIHUHQFH+RZHYHUZHZඈOOGHPRQVWUDWHDVHOHFWඈRQKHUHDQGDOVRJHWPRUHRI DQඈGHDRIZK\‰‰’Ž‘–ɩඈVVRIOH[ඈEOH

9ඈVXDOඈVඈQJGDWDGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQV

)ඈUVWRIDOOZKDWඈIZHZDQWWRORRNDWWKHGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQRIRXUGDWD")RUH[DPSHZHFRXOGKDYHORRNHGDWWKH GඈVWUඈEXWඈRQRIPDVVඈQRXUGDWDVHWDQGVSRWWHGWKDW-DEEDZDVDQඈVVXHEHIRUHPDNඈQJRXUVFDWWHUSORW2QH ZD\WRGRWKඈVZRXOGKDYHEHHQWRSORWDKඈVWRJUDPXVඈQJWKH‰‡‘ɏŠ‹•–‘‰”ƒOD\HU ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡•ſƒ••ƀƀ ƒʫ‰‡‘ɏŠ‹•–‘‰”ƒſ„‹™‹†–Šʰɨɥƀ





1RWHWKDWZඈWKඈQRXU‰‡‘ɏŠ‹•–‘‰”ƒOD\HUIXQFWඈRQZHVHWWKH„‹™‹†–ŠDUJXPHQWWR,QRWKHUZRUGVZH

DUHEඈQQඈQJRXUGDWDE\VHWVRI:HFRXOGIRUH[DPSOHFKDQJHWKඈVWRDQGVHHKRZWKHGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQ FKDQJHV

  6WඈOOWKRXJK-DEEDඈVVRKXJHKHඈVDQREYඈRXVRXWOඈHU:HDOVRVHHKHUHWKDWVඈQFHZHGHIඈQඈHGWKHEDVඈVRIRXU SORWDVREMHFWƒZඈWKWKH‰‰’Ž‘–DQGƒ‡•IXQFWඈRQVDOOZHQHHGWRGRWRUHSORWRXUKඈVWRJUDPඈVDOWHUWKH ‰‡‘ɏŠ‹•–‘‰”ƒOD\HU :HFDQඈQIDFWFRPSOHWHO\FKDQJHWKHW\SHRISORW$QRWKHUZD\WRYඈVXDOඈVHDGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQඈVWRXVHDVPRRWKHG GHQVඈW\SORWZඈWKWKH‰‡‘ɏ†‡•‹–›OD\HU$OOZHQHHGWRGRඈVFKDQJHDVPDOODUJXPHQWඈQRXUFRGH ƒʫ‰‡‘ɏ†‡•‹–›ſƀ





&RPSDUඈQJGDWDGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQV

3HUKDSVZHZDQWWRFRPSDUHPDVVDPRQJWKHGඈIIHUHQWVSHFඈHVඈQRXUGDWD"2QHZD\ZHFDQGRWKඈVඈVZඈWKD ER[SORWOඈNHZHGඈGඈQ&KDSWHU‰‰’Ž‘–ɩPDNHVWKඈVH[FHSWඈRQDOO\HDV\ZඈWKWKH‰‡‘ɏ„‘š’Ž‘–OD\HU

ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡•ſ•’‡…‹‡•řƒ••ƀƀ ƒʫ‰‡‘ɏ„‘š’Ž‘–ſƀ

  +PPDOWKRXJKWKඈVSORWඈVGHWDඈOHGDQGZHFDQVWඈOOVHHWKHUHඈVDFOHDURXWOඈHUඈWඈVGඈIIඈFXOWWRUHDOO\VHHPXFK PRUH7KඈVඈVDQඈPSRUWDQWSRඈQWRIGDWDYඈVXDOඈVDWඈRQ\RXQHHGWRWKඈQNZKDW\RXKRSHWKRVHYඈHZඈQJWKHSORW FDQOHDUQIURPඈW 8VඈQJWKHGDWDKDQGOඈQJVNඈOOVZHOHDUQHGHDUOඈHUඈQWKඈVVHVVඈRQOHW¶VVXEVHWRXUGDWDDQGYඈVXDOඈVHඈWDJDඈQ XVඈQJ‰‡‘ɏ„‘š’Ž‘–7RJHWVWDUWHGZHZඈOOFRPSDUHWKHPDVVRIKXPDQVGURඈGVDQGHZRNV ɪ•—„•‡–†ƒ–ƒ Š†‡ʳŞ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ•—„•‡–ſ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ—ƒɑŶ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ”‘‹†ɑŶ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ™‘ɑƀ ɪ’Ž‘––Š‡†‹•–”‹„—–‹‘• ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſŠ†‡řƒ‡•ſ•’‡…‹‡•řƒ••ƀƀ ƒʫ‰‡‘ɏ„‘š’Ž‘–ſƀ

  &OHDUO\(ZRNVKDYHDPXFKORZHUPDVVWKDQHඈWKHUGURඈGVRUKXPDQVEXWQRWHKHUHWKDWWKHUHඈVRQO\DVඈQJOH (ZRNREVHUYDWඈRQVRZHFDQ¶WUHDOO\FRPSDUHWKHGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQRIPDVVHVDPRQJWKHVHVSHFඈHV :HFDQKRZHYHUYHUඈI\WKHQXPEHURIREVHUYDWඈRQVIRUHDFKVSHFඈHV:HFDQGRWKඈVXVඈQJ†’Ž›”OඈNHVR ɤɤɤ–‹„„Ž‡śɪšɩ ɤɤ•’‡…‹‡• ɤɤʳ…Š”ʴʳ‹–ʴ ɤɤɨ”‘‹† ɬ ɤɤɩ™‘ ɨ ɤɤɪ—ƒɪɬ :HFRXOGDOVRYඈVXDOඈVHWKඈVDVDEDUSORWZඈWK‰‰’Ž‘–ɩ)RUH[DPSOH ‰‰’Ž‘–ſŠ†‡řƒ‡•ſ•’‡…‹‡•ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ„ƒ”ſƀ

 

0RUHFRPSOඈFDWHGSORWVDQGGDWDKDQGOඈQJ

,QVRPHFDVHVZHPඈJKWZDQWWRYඈVXDOඈVHPXOWඈSOHYDUඈDEOHVFOHDUO\IURPDGDWDVHW$VDQH[DPSOHSHUKDSV ZHZDQWWRORRNDWWKHGඈIIHUHQFHඈQERWKPDVVDQGKHඈJKWEHWZHHQKXPDQVDQGGURඈGVඈQDVඈQJOHSORW %HIRUHZHGRWKඈVOHW¶VVXEVHWRXUGDWDWRMXVWඈQFOXGHKXPDQVDQGGURඈGVVඈQFHZHNQRZWKHUHඈVRQO\D VඈQJOH(ZRNඈQWKHGDWDZHFDQGURSඈW Š†ʳŞ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ•—„•‡–ſ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ—ƒɑŶ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ”‘‹†ɑƀ :KDWZHZRXOGOඈNHWRGRඈVFUHDWHDSORWZඈWKWZRSDQHOVRQHIRUER[SORWVVKRZඈQJKHඈJKWDQGWKHRWKHUIRU ER[SORWVVKRZඈQJPDVV:HFDQDFKඈHYHWKඈVZඈWKDOD\HUNQRZQDVˆƒ…‡–ɏ‰”‹†KRZHYHUඈWUHTXඈUHVRXUGDWD WREHඈQDVOඈJKWO\GඈIIHUHQWIRUPDWZHQHHGWRPHUJHERWKRXUKHඈJKWDQGPDVVPHDVXUHPHQWVඈQWRDVඈQJOH FROXPQ7RGRWKඈVZHZඈOOXVHDIXQFWඈRQFDOOHG‰ƒ–Š‡” ɪˆ‹”•–™‡•‡Ž‡…–‘Ž›–Š‡˜ƒ”‹ƒ„Ž‡•™‡ƒ”‡‹–‡”‡•–‡†‹ Š†ʳŞŠ†ʩʴʩ•‡Ž‡…–ſƒ‡řŠ‡‹‰Š–řƒ••ř•’‡…‹‡•ƀ Š†ɏ‰ʳŞŠ†ʩʴʩ‰ƒ–Š‡”ſ‡›ʰɑ‡ƒ•—”‡‡–ɑř˜ƒŽ—‡ʰɑ˜ƒŽ—‡ɑřސƒ‡řŞ•’‡…‹‡•ƀ Š†ɏ‰

  ɤɤɤ–‹„„Ž‡śɯɥšɫ ɤɤƒ‡ •’‡…‹‡•‡ƒ•—”‡‡–˜ƒŽ—‡ ɤɤʳ…Š”ʴ ʳ…Š”ʴʳ…Š”ʴ ʳ†„Žʴ ɤɤɨ—‡›™ƒŽ‡”—ƒŠ‡‹‰Š– ɨɮɩ ɤɤɩŞɪ ”‘‹†Š‡‹‰Š– ɨɭɮ ɤɤɪɩŞɩ ”‘‹†Š‡‹‰Š– ɰɭ ɤɤɫƒ”–Šƒ†‡” —ƒŠ‡‹‰Š– ɩɥɩ ɤɤɬ‡‹ƒ”‰ƒƒ —ƒŠ‡‹‰Š– ɨɬɥ ɤɤɭ™‡ƒ”• —ƒŠ‡‹‰Š– ɨɮɯ ɤɤɮ‡”—Š‹–‡•—Žƒ”•—ƒŠ‡‹‰Š– ɨɭɬ ɤɤɯɬŞɫ ”‘‹†Š‡‹‰Š– ɰɮ ɤɤɰ‹‰‰•ƒ”Ž‹‰Š–‡”—ƒŠ‡‹‰Š– ɨɯɪ ɤɤɨɥ„‹Şƒ‡‘„‹—ƒŠ‡‹‰Š– ɨɯɩ ɤɤɤŝ™‹–Šɮɥ‘”‡”‘™•

:KDWKDSSHQHGKHUH":ඈWKඈQ‰ƒ–Š‡”ZHVSHFඈIඈHGRXU‡›YDUඈDEOHWREHPHDVXUHPHQWWKඈVMXVWFUHDWHVD

FKDUDFWHUYHFWRUZඈWKWZRYDOXHVKHඈJKWDQGPDVV:HDOVRJඈYHRXUFRPEඈQHGYDUඈDEOHDQDPHYDOXHKHUH 6RQRZZHKDYHDWඈEEOHZඈWKWZඈFHDVPDQ\URZVDVWKHRUඈJඈQDOEXWZඈWKRQHIRUKHඈJKWDQGRQHIRUPDVV :HFDQGHPRQVWUDWHWKඈVE\DFWXDOO\ORRNඈQJIRUDVඈQJOHQDPHDQGVHHඈQJWKHUHDUHWZRURZVRQHIRUKHඈJKW DQGRQHIRUPDVV)RUH[DPSOH ˆ‹Ž–‡”ſŠ†ɏ‰řƒ‡ʰʰɑɩŞɩɑƀ ɤɤɤ–‹„„Ž‡śɩšɫ ɤɤƒ‡•’‡…‹‡•‡ƒ•—”‡‡–˜ƒŽ—‡ ɤɤʳ…Š”ʴʳ…Š”ʴʳ…Š”ʴ ʳ†„Žʴ ɤɤɨɩŞɩ”‘‹†Š‡‹‰Š– ɰɭ ɤɤɩɩŞɩ”‘‹†ƒ•• ɪɩ 8VHRI‰ƒ–Š‡”ඈQWKඈVZD\ඈVDEඈWFRXQWHUඈQWXඈWඈYHDWIඈUVWEXWZඈWKSUDFWඈFH\RXZඈOOVHHඈWEHFRPHVPXFKPRUH VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUG 6RZKDWZDVWKHSRඈQWRIWKඈVDQ\ZD\":HOOඈWDOORZVXVWRFRQVWUXFWRXUSORWOඈNHWKඈV ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſŠ†ɏ‰řƒ‡•ſ•’‡…‹‡•ř˜ƒŽ—‡ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ„‘š’Ž‘–ſƀ ƒʫˆƒ…‡–ɏ‰”‹†ſɌ‡ƒ•—”‡‡–ƀ

  $VQRUPDOZHVSHFඈIඈHGWKHGDWDDQGDHVWKHWඈFVIRURXUSORW+RZHYHUZHDGGHGWKHˆƒ…‡–ɏ‰”‹†DUJXPHQWWR VSOඈWWKHSORWඈQWRIDFHWVRYHUWKHGඈIIHUHQWW\SHVRIPHDVXUHPHQWඈHKHඈJKWDQGPDVVKHUH7KH Ɍ‡ƒ•—”‡‡–SDUWRIWKඈVFRPPDQGMXVWPHDQVZHVKRXOGIඈOOWKHIDFHWJUඈGDVQHZFROXPQV:HFRXOGDOVR XVH‡ƒ•—”‡–ɌŜWRGRWKHVDPHE\URZVQRWHWKDWWKHŜඈVQHFHVVDU\WRDOORZ5WRඈQWHUSUHWWKHFRPPDQG SURSHUO\/ඈNHVR ƒʫˆƒ…‡–ɏ‰”‹†ſ‡ƒ•—”‡‡–ɌŜƀ

  ,WඈVDPDWWHURIRSඈQඈRQEXWWKHZHWKඈQNWKDWWKHIඈUVWSORWORRNVEHWWHU(ඈWKHUZD\IURPERWKSORWVඈWඈVFOHDUWKDW WKHKXPDQVDUHRQDYHUDJHWDOOHUWKDQGURඈGVEXWWKDWWKHUHඈVPXFKJUHDWHUYDUඈDWඈRQඈQERWKGURඈGPDVVDQG KHඈJKW

$QQRWDWඈQJDQGPDNඈQJSXEOඈFDWඈRQTXDOඈW\SORWV

7KHFRQFHSWRIOD\HUVඈQ‰‰’Ž‘–ɩඈVVඈPඈODUඈQHWKRVWRWKDWXVHGඈQJUDSKඈFGHVඈJQSURJUDPVVXFKDV$GREH ,OOXVWUDWRURU3KRWRVKRS<RXFUHDWHDSORWDQG\RXFDQDGGOD\HUVRIGHWDඈOWRඈW7KඈVPDNHVඈWYHU\ VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGWRFUHDWHDSXEOඈFDWඈRQTXDOඈW\IඈJXUHZඈWKDIHZOඈQHVRIFRGH /HW¶VUHWXUQWRRXUHDUOඈHUGHQVඈW\SORWRIPDVVIURPRXU•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWD ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡•ſƒ••ƀƀ ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ†‡•‹–›ſ„‹™‹†–Šʰɨɥƀ ƒ

  :ඈWKWKHFRGHDERYHZHKDYHFRPPSOHWHO\DVVඈJQHGRXUSORWWRWKHREMHFWƒ6RQRZDOOZHQHHGWRGRඈVDGG OD\HUVWRඈWWRDQQRWDWHඈW )ඈUVWRIDOOOHW¶VSORWPHDQYDOXHRIPDVVDVDYHUWඈFDOOඈQHRQWKHSORW7RGRWKඈVZHQHHGWRFDOFXODWHWKH PHDQZKඈFKZHZRXOGGROඈNHVR ‡ƒɏƒ••ʳޏ‡ƒſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛƒ••řƒŜ”ʰƀ ‡ƒɏƒ•• :HQHHGWKHƒŜ”ʰDUJXPHQWKHUHEHFDXVHVRPHඈQGඈYඈGXDOVGRQRWKDYHDPHDVXUHGPDVVඈHWKH\DUH ZඈWKRXWWKඈVDFDOOWRWKH‡ƒZඈOORQO\SURGXFHDQ$Q\ZD\QRZWKDWZHKDYHGHIඈQHGRXUPHDQ

PDVVZHFDQDGGඈWWRRXUSORWDVDOඈQHOඈNHVR

ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ˜Ž‹‡ſš‹–‡”…‡’–ʰ‡ƒɏƒ••řŽ–›ʰɩř…‘Ž‘—”ʰɑ”‡†ɑƀ ƒ

  1H[WZHFDQDGGVRPHWKHPHDUJXPHQWVWRPDNHRXUSORWVXඈWDEOHIRUSXEOඈFDWඈRQ ƒʳރʫ–Š‡‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀ ƒʳރʫ–Š‡‡ſƒš‹•Ŝ–‹–Ž‡ʰ‡Ž‡‡–ɏ–‡š–ſ•‹œ‡ʰɨɪřˆƒ…‡ʰɑ„‘Ž†ɑƀř ƒš‹•Ŝ–‡š–ʰ‡Ž‡‡–ɏ–‡š–ſ•‹œ‡ʰɨɨƀƀ ƒ

  1RWHWKDWKHUHZHKDYHWRFDOO–Š‡‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀIඈUVWRUඈWZඈOORYHUUඈGHDOOWKHRWKHUDUJXPHQWVZHPDGHWR –Š‡‡ſƀODWHU 7KHUHඈVDKXJHDPRXQW\RXFDQGRWRPDNHSORWVORRNPRUHDHVWKHWඈFDOO\SOHDVඈQJ\RXVKRXOGFKHFNRXWDOO WKHRSWඈRQVDYDඈODEOHඈQWKHJJSORWPDQXDOKWWSJJSORWWඈG\YHUVHRUJඈQGH[KWPO )ඈQDOO\RQFH\RXKDYHFUHDWHGDSORW\RXOඈNH\RXPඈJKWZDQWWRVDYHඈW<RXFDQGRWKඈVHDVඈO\XVඈQJWKH ‰‰•ƒ˜‡ ‰‰•ƒ˜‡ſɑŜŵ›’Ž‘–Ŝ’†ˆɑř’Ž‘–ʰŽƒ•–ɏ’Ž‘–ſƀř†‡˜‹…‡ʰɑ’†ˆɑƀ +HUHZHVDYHGDSORWWRWKHFXUUHQWGඈUHFWRU\XVH‰‡–™†ſƀඈI\RXQHHGWRIඈQGRXWZKHUHWKඈVඈVDVSGIFDOHG ›’Ž‘–Ŝ’†ˆ

6RPHODVWZRUGVRQJJSORW

+RSHIXOO\WKHODVWVHFWඈRQKDVFRQYඈQFHG\RXWKDW‰‰’Ž‘–ɩඈVDYHUVDWඈOHDQGIOH[ඈEOHWRROIRUGDWDYඈVXDOඈVDWඈRQ 7KHUHDUHPDQ\PRUHWKඈQJVWKDWDUHSRVVඈEOHZඈWKWKHSDFNDJHEXWXQIRUWXQDWHO\ZHGRQRWKDYHWKHWඈPHRU VSDFHWRJRඈQWRWKHPDOOKHUH1RQHWKHOHVV‰‰’Ž‘–ɩZඈOOEHXVHGWKURXJKRXWWKHUHPDඈQGHURIRXU5VHFWඈRQV VRZKHQQHZWRSඈFVRUFRQFHSWVDUඈVHZHZඈOOGRRXUEHVWWRH[SODඈQWKHP +RZHYHUඈI\RXDUHNHHQWROHDUQPRUHDERXW‰‰’Ž‘–ɩZHKඈJKO\UHFRPPHQGWKH5*UDSKඈFV&RRNERRN KWWSZZZFRRNERRNUFRP*UDSKVDVDQHQWU\OHYHOWXWRUඈDO

0DNඈQJXVHRI5VFUඈSWV

$V\RX¶YHSURJUHVVHGWKURXJKWKHඈQWURGXFWRU\VHVVඈRQDQGDVOඈJKWO\PRUHDGYDQFHGORRNDWKDQGOඈQJGDWDඈQ 5\RX¶YHQRGRXEWJRWWHQDOඈWWOHIHGXSZඈWKUHSHDWHGO\W\SඈQJRXWFRPPDQGOඈQHඈQVWUXFWඈRQVIRU5<RXPඈJKW EHTXඈWHUඈJKWO\WKඈQNඈQJWR\RXUVHOIWKDWWKHUHPXVWEHDEHWWHUZD\WRGRWKඈV"6XUHO\ඈWඈVQ¶WQHFHVVDU\WRZUඈWH

  ORQJFRPPDQGVHDFKWඈPH" :HOOWKHUHඈVDPXFKEHWWHUZD\\RXFDQZUඈWHDVFUඈSW6FUඈSWVDUHXVHGඈQ5DQGPDQ\RWKHUSURJUDPPඈQJ ODQJXDJHVDVDPHDQVRIVDYඈQJ\RXUFRGHDQGUHFRUGඈQJZKDWඈWඈV\RXKDYHGRQH7KH\DUHDUJXDEO\RQHRI WKHPRVWHVVHQWඈDODVSHFWVRISURJUDPPඈQJDQGEඈRඈQIRUPDWඈFV,QGHHGDSURSHUO\ZUඈWWHQVFUඈSWFDQEHXVHGඈQ DVඈPඈODUPDQQHUWRDVWDQGDORQHSURJUDP<RXVඈPSO\SOXJඈQ\RXUGDWDUXQWKHVFUඈSWDQGOHWඈWRXWSXW\RXU DQDO\VඈV 6R\RXPඈJKWDVNඈIVFUඈSWVDUHVRඈPSRUWDQWZK\RQHDUWKGඈGQ¶WZHWHDFK\RXDERXWWKHPUඈJKWDWWKHVWDUWRI DOORIWKඈV":HOOIඈUVWO\ZHZDQWHGWRGHOYHUඈJKWඈQWR5DQGVKRZ\RXZKDWඈVSRVVඈEOH$OVRUHSHDWHGO\W\SඈQJ RXWFRPPDQGVFDQEHDJRRGZD\WROHDUQWKHEDVඈFV0RVWRIDOOWKRXJKඈWVKRXOGEHDURXQGWKඈVSRඈQWඈQWKH WXWRUඈDOWKDW\RXUHDOඈVHWKHYDOXHRIXVඈQJDVFUඈSW<RXKDYHOHDUQHGWRFUHDWHPRUHDQGPRUHFRPSOH[GDWD VWUXFWXUHVYඈVXDOඈVHDQGSORWWKඈVGDWDDQGDOVRWRDSSO\VRPHEDVඈFIXQFWඈRQV ,WPඈJKWEHKHOSIXOWRWKඈQNRIDVFUඈSWDVDVWHSE\VWHSJXඈGHRIZKDW\RXDUHGRඈQJඈQ\RXUDQDO\VඈV7KඈVඈV DFWXDOO\KRZZHSUඈPDUඈO\XVHWKHPඈQ5ZKHQGRඈQJDQDQDO\VඈVIRUWKHIඈUVWWඈPH7\SඈFDOO\ZHZRXOGZRUNZඈWK DQRSHQVFUඈSWGRFXPHQWDQGWKHQW\SHRXUFRPPDQGVඈQWRඈWHGඈWඈQJඈWDORQJWKHZD\7KHඈGHDඈVWKDWZKHQ ZHUHRSHQWKHVFUඈSWDJDඈQඈQDIHZGD\VWඈPHZHFDQXVHඈWWRNHHSWUDFNRIRXUSURJUHVVDQGUHSHUIRUPRXU DQDO\VඈV 7KHUHDUHQRVWUඈFWUXOHVIRUZUඈWඈQJDVFUඈSWGඈIIHUHQWSHRSOHKDYHGඈIIHUHQWVW\OHV:HZඈOOWHDFK\RXRXUVEXW EHDZDUHWKHUHDUHPDQ\GඈIIHUHQWRSඈQඈRQVRXWWKHUH%HFDXVHRIWKHGඈYHUVඈW\ඈQVFUඈSWZUඈWඈQJZHZඈOOQRWWU\ DQGHQIRUFHDVSHFඈIඈFSUDFWඈFHKHUH+RZHYHUZHVWURQJO\VXJJHVWRQHඈPSRUWDQWUXOHWKDW\RXVKRXOGWU\\RXU EHVWWRIROORZNHHS\RXUVFUඈSWVFOHDUDQGVHOIH[SODQDWRU\:HFDQQRWWHOO\RXWKHDPRXQWRIWඈPHZHKDYH ZDVWHGRSHQඈQJROGVFUඈSWVRIRXURZQDIWHUVRPHWඈPHDZD\IURPDQDQDO\VඈVWKDWDUHFRPSOHWHO\ ඈQFRPSUHKHQVඈEOH:HPඈJKWKDYHZUඈWWHQWKHPEXWXQGHUVWDQGඈQJWKHPඈVOඈNHGHFRGඈQJWKH9R\QඈFK 0DQXVFUඈSWKWWSVHQZඈNඈSHGඈDRUJZඈNඈ9R\QඈFKBPDQXVFUඈSWRUVRPHDQFඈHQWORVWODQJXDJH ,WඈVPXFKPXFKPRUHVDWඈVI\ඈQJDQGWඈPHHIIඈFඈHQWZKHQ\RXZUඈWHDVFUඈSWWKDW\RXFDQUHXVHHDVඈO\TXඈFNO\ DQGZඈWKRXWHIIRUW3HUKDSVDFROOHDJXHXSGDWHV\RXUGDWDVHWRUDUHYඈHZHUDVNV\RXWRUHSHUIRUPDQDQDO\VඈV ZඈWKDFDUHIXOO\ZUඈWWHQVFUඈSW\RXFDQUHGRWKDWDQDO\VඈVTXඈFNO\DQGZඈWKPඈQඈPXPIXVV

:KHUHWRZUඈWHVFUඈSWV

,I\RX¶YHZRUNHGWKඈVIDUWKURXJKWKHWXWRUඈDO\RXPඈJKWKDYHDOUHDG\EHHQNHHSඈQJVQඈSSHWVRIFRGHඈQDWH[W IඈOH,IVRWKඈVඈVDEDVඈFIRUPRIVFUඈSWඈQJ5VFUඈSWVDUHHVVHQWඈDOO\WH[WIඈOHVEXWWKH\KDYHWKHŜH[WHQVඈRQ 7KඈVPHDQVWKDWඈI\RXXVHDWH[WHGඈWRUඈHH[WHUQDOWR–—†‹‘\RXFDQZUඈWHDVFUඈSWDOO\RXQHHGWRGRඈV

VDYHඈWZඈWKWKHŜH[WHQVඈRQ6RPHHGඈWRUVVXFKDV–‘DQG‡š–”ƒ‰Ž‡”ZඈOODOVRKDYHV\QWD[

KඈJKOඈJKWඈQJIRU5VFUඈSWVඈHWKH\FRORXUWKHVFUඈSWWRVKRZREMHFWVIXQFWඈRQVDQGVRRQ 7RPDNHWKඈQJVPRUHVWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGKHUHDQGWRWDNHDGYDQWDJHRIVRPHXVHIXO5VSHFඈIඈFIHDWXUHVZHZඈOO XVHWKHVFUඈSWHGඈWRUඈQ•–—†‹‘7RRSHQXSDVFUඈSW\RXFDQJRWRWKHKHDGHUPHQXDQGVHOHFW ‹Ž‡ʴ‡™ ‹Ž‡ʴ…”‹’–7KඈVZඈOORSHQXSDEODQNZඈQGRZඈQWKH•–—†‹‘FRQVROHWKඈVඈVDQඈQEXඈOW WH[WHGඈWRUIRU\RXWRZUඈWH\RXUVFUඈSWඈQ /HW¶VZUඈWHDQ5FRPPDQGඈQWRRXUVFUඈSWDQGWKHQUXQඈWඈQWKHFRQVROHWRGHPRQVWUDWHKRZDVFUඈSWZRUNV7U\ WKHIROORZඈQJ •‡“ſɨřɨɥɥɥřɨƀ 1RZZඈWK\RXU5VFUඈSWRSHQ\RXFDQSODFH\RXUFXUVRURQWKHOඈQHKHUHKඈW†ʫ–‡”0DFRU –”Žʫ–‡”3&7KඈVZඈOOUXQ\RXU5FRPPDQGඈQWKHFRQVROHDQG\RXVKRXOGVHHWKDW\RXJHQHUDWHGD YHFWRURIQXPEHUVIURP\RXUVFUඈSW6ඈPSOH<RX¶OODOVRQRWඈFHWKHV\QWD[KඈJKOඈJKWඈQJKHUHWKHQXPEHUVZඈWKඈQ WKH•‡“FRPPDQGVKRXOGEHDGඈIIHUHQWFRORXUඈQGඈFDWඈQJWKH\DUHQXPHUඈFYDUඈDEOHV

 

6RPHXVHIXOVFUඈSWඈQJWඈSV

$JRRGJHQHUDOVWUXFWXUHIRUDQ5VFUඈSWඈVWRVWDUWZඈWKDVඈQJOHFRPPDQGWRFOHDUWKH5HQYඈURQPHQWDQG SUHYHQWDQ\FRQIOඈFWZඈWKH[ඈVWඈQJSDFNDJHVRUQDPHGREMHFWV:HXVXDOO\VWDUWDOORXU5VFUඈSWVZඈWK ”ſŽ‹•–ʰŽ•ſƀƀ 7KඈVZඈOOUHPRYHHYHU\WKඈQJඈQ\RXUHQYඈURQPHQWඈHREMHFWVGDWDHWF+RZHYHUSDFNDJHVZඈOOUHPDඈQORDGHG 1H[WZHPඈJKWKDYHDVHFWඈRQRIWKHVFUඈSWIRUORDGඈQJSDFNDJHV7KඈVHVVHQWඈDOO\ඈQඈWඈDWHVRXUVFUඈSWDQGOHWVXV NQRZKRZZHDUHVHWWඈQJXSWKHZRUNඈQJHQYඈURQPHQW Ž‹„”ƒ”›ſ–‹†›˜‡”•‡ƀ Ž‹„”ƒ”›ſƀ :HPඈJKWWKHQUHDGඈQVRPHGDWDRUDFFHVVඈWIURPWKHHQYඈURQPHQWDQGSHUIRUPRXUDQDO\VHV,QWKHQH[W VHFWඈRQZHZඈOOZUඈWHDVPDOOGHPRVFUඈSWWRJHWKHUEXWEHIRUHZHGRVRඈWඈVඈPSRUWDQWWRඈQWURGXFH\RXWR FRPPHQWV<RXFDQDGGFRPPHQWVWRDQ5VFUඈSWE\SUHIDFඈQJ\RXUFRGHZඈWKDɤ7KඈVEDVඈFDOO\DOORZV\RX WRZUඈWHWH[WWKDWZඈOOQRWEHඈQWHUSUHWHGE\WKH5FRQVROH)RUH[DPSOH ɪ‰‡‡”ƒ–‡ƒ˜‡…–‘”‘ˆ—„‡”• •‡“ſɨřɨɥɥɥřɨƀ +HUHZHFDQXVHFRPPHQWVWRHVVHQWඈDOO\DQQRWDWHRXUFRGH7KඈVඈVDQH[WUHPHO\XVHIXOIHDWXUHWKDWPDNHVඈW PXFKPXFKHDVඈHUWRUHDGDQGඈQWHUSUHWDVFUඈSW$IWHUDOODVSURIඈFඈHQWඈQ5DV\RXPඈJKWEHFRPHඈWඈVQRW H[DFWO\WKHVRUWRIODQJXDJH\RXFDQMXVWUHDGHDVඈO\&RPPHQWVDUHZKDWZඈOOKHOS\RXQDYඈJDWH\RXUDQDO\VHV DQGKHOS\RXUHPHPEHUZK\\RXGඈGZKDW\RXGඈG$JRRGUXOHRIWKXPEIRUZUඈWඈQJFRPPHQWVඈVWRඈPDJඈQH \RXDUHWU\ඈQJWRDQQRWDWHWKHVFUඈSWIRUVRPHRQHHOVHWRXVH7KඈVඈVDFWXDOO\DSUHWW\JRRGWKඈQJWRDඈPIRU VඈQFHRQFH\RXEHFRPHDGHSWDWVFUඈSWඈQJDQG5FRGඈQJ\RXPD\ZHOOQHHGWRZUඈWHVFUඈSWVIRURWKHUVZKRDVN IRU\RXUKHOS*RRGFRPPHQWVZඈOOKHOSWKHPQDYඈJDWHWKHVFUඈSWWRRDQGPDNH\RXUOඈIHDORWHDVඈHU

$VඈPSOHVFUඈSWH[DPSOH

1RZWKDWZHKDYHDQඈGHDRIKRZVFUඈSWඈQJZRUNVZHFDQWU\ZUඈWඈQJDVඈPSOHVFUඈSWWRJHWKHU7KHIROORZඈQJ FRGHඈVDYHU\VKRUWH[DPSOHRIKRZZHPඈJKWFRPEඈQHVRPHRIWKHWKඈQJVZHKDYHOHDUQHGඈQWKඈVWXWRUඈDOඈQWR DVඈQJOHVFUඈSWWKDWPDNHVඈWFOHDUZKDWZHDUHGRඈQJZඈWKRXUDQDO\VHVDQGGDWDPDQඈSXODWඈRQ:H¶OOUHWXUQWR WKH6WDU:DUVGDWDDQGSORWWKHKHඈJKWDQGPDVVUHODWඈRQVKඈSZHGඈGSUHYඈRXVO\

  ɪɪɪ•‹’Ž‡•…”‹’––‘ˆ‹Ž–‡”ƒ†’Ž‘––Š‡•–ƒ”™ƒ”•†ƒ–ƒɪɪɪ ”ſŽ‹•–ʰŽ•ſƀƀ ɪŽ‘ƒ†’ƒ…ƒ‰‡• Ž‹„”ƒ”›ſ–‹†›˜‡”•‡ƀ ɪŽ‘ƒ†–Š‡•–ƒ”™ƒ”•†ƒ–ƒ †ƒ–ƒſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƀ ɪ”‡‘˜‡ ƒ„„ƒ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩʳވ‹Ž–‡”ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡Šʰɑ ƒ„„ƒ‡•‹Ž‹Œ‹…‹—”‡ɑƀ ɪ…”‡ƒ–‡ƒŠ‡‹‰Š–ŵƒ•••…ƒ––‡”’Ž‘– ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩřƒ‡•ſŠ‡‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀƀ ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſ…‘Ž‘—”ʰɑ”‡†ɑƀ ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ•‘‘–Šſ‡–Š‘†ʰŽř•‡ʰ ƀ ƒʳރʫ–Š‡‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀʫ‰‰–‹–Ž‡ſɑ‡‹‰Š–˜•ƒ••‹–ƒ”ƒ”•ɑƀ ƒ ɪ™”‹–‡‘—––Š‡’Ž‘–ƒ•ƒ’†ˆ ‰‰•ƒ˜‡ſɑŜŵ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɏŠ‡‹‰Š–ɏƒ••Ŝ’†ˆɑř’Ž‘–ʰŽƒ•–ɏ’Ž‘–ſƀř†‡˜‹…‡ʰɑ’†ˆɑƀ 6RDOOZHGඈGKHUHඈV VHWXSRXU5HQYඈURQPHQW UHDGඈQDQGPDQඈSXODWHGRXUGDWD FUHDWHGRXUSORW ZURWHRXUSORWWRDQRXWSXW ,IZHZDQWHGWRUHSHDWWKඈVDQDO\VඈVDJDඈQDOOZHQHHGWRGRඈVUXQWKHVFUඈSW:HFDQFKDQJHWKඈQJVOඈNHWKH GDWDZHUHDGඈQEXWWKඈVVFUඈSWSURYඈGHVDJRRGJHQHUDOWHPSODWHIRUKRZZHPඈJKWVWDUWWRPDNHDVWDQGDORQH DQDO\VඈVVFUඈSWWKDWZHFDQUHXVHIRUGඈIIHUHQWSXUSRVHV,W¶VඈPSRUWDQWWRNHHSඈQPඈQGWKDWWKඈVඈVRQO\WKH EDVඈFVRIVFUඈSWඈQJ,WඈVSRVVඈEOHWRPDNH5VFUඈSWVWKDWDUHDFWXDOO\VWDQGDORQHSURJUDPVWKDW\RXFDQUXQIURP WKHFRPPDQGOඈQHIRUH[DPSOH+RZHYHUIURPQRZRQ\RXVKRXOGWU\IROORZඈQJWKHWXWRUඈDOVE\PDNඈQJ\RXU RZQVFUඈSWVDORQJVඈGHWKHP

*RඈQJIXUWKHU

$VQRUPDO5KDVDKXJHUDQJHRIIUHHO\DYDඈODEOHUHVRXUFHVRQOඈQHWKDWFDQKHOS\RXOHDUQPRUHDERXWGDWD PDQඈSXODWඈRQWKHWඈG\YHUVHJJSORWDQGVFUඈSWඈQJ+HUHZHSRඈQW\RXWRDIHZEHORZWKDW\RXPඈJKWEH ඈQWHUHVWHGඈQ 'DWDFDPSKDVDQIUHHඈQWURGXFWඈRQWRXVඈQJWඈG\YHUVHSDFNDJHVWRPDQඈSXODWHGDWD KWWSVZZZGDWDFDPSFRPFRXUVHVඈQWURGXFWඈRQWRWKHWඈG\YHUVH +DGOH\:ඈFNKDP *DUUHWW*UROHPXQGKDYHZUඈWWHQWKHGHIඈQඈWඈYHIUHHO\DYDඈODEOHRQOඈQHERRNRQXVඈQJ 5IRUGDWDPDQඈSXODWඈRQWKඈVඈVWKHµEඈEOH¶RIWKHWඈG\YHUVHDSSURDFKDQGඈQFOXGHVDVHFWඈRQRQJJSORW KWWSUGVKDGFRQ] 7KHUHඈVDOVRD'DWDFDPSFRXUVHRQJJSRWKWWSVZZZGDWDFDPSFRPFRXUVHVGDWDYඈVXDOඈ]DWඈRQZඈWK JJSORW"WDSBD GFHI WDSBV FIF

:ඈQVWRQ&KDQJ¶V5*UDSKඈF¶V&RRNERRNඈVDOVRDQH[FHOOHQWUHVRXUFHIRUXVඈQJJJSORWIRUGDWD YඈVXDOඈVDWඈRQKWWSZZZFRRNERRNUFRP

$GHWDඈOHGVRIWZDUHFDUSHQWU\JXඈGHWR5VFUඈSWඈQJKWWSVVZFDUSHQWU\JඈWKXEඈRUQRYඈFH ඈQIODPPDWඈRQEHVWSUDFWඈFHV5