• Sonuç bulunamadı

Teorik 2.Genomlar ve genetik varyasyonun kökeni

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Teorik 2.Genomlar ve genetik varyasyonun kökeni"

Copied!
37
0
0

Yükleniyor.... (view fulltext now)

Tam metin

(1)

2.Genomlar ve genetik

varyasyonun kökeni

(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)

2.Genomlar ve genetik

varyasyonun kökeni

(12)

  ZD\VWRDFKඈHYHWKHVDPHJRDODQGWKHJXඈGOඈQHVZHJඈYHKHUHDUHE\QRPHDQVGHIඈQඈWඈYH+RZHYHUZH FKRRVHWRඈQWURGXFHWKHVHSUඈQFඈSOHVQRZEHFDXVHඈQRXUH[SHUඈHQFHRIGDWDDQDO\VඈVWKH\KDYHJUHDWO\ ඈPSURYHGRXUHIIඈFඈHQF\WKHFODUඈW\RIRXU5FRGHDQGWKHZD\ZHZRUNZඈWKGDWD +DYඈQJXVHG5IRUVRPHWඈPHZHKDYHFRPHWRWKHWඈG\YHUVHDSSURDFKKDYඈQJDOUHDG\OHDUQHGPDQ\RIWKH EDVඈFVඈQµQRUPDO¶RUVRFDOOHGµEDVH5¶,WFDQEHGඈIIඈFXOWWRVKDNHRIIZKDW\RXKDYHDOUHDG\OHDUQHG7KඈVඈV RQHRIWKHUHDVRQVZHDUHNHHQWRඈQWURGXFH\RXWRWKHVHDSSURDFKHVHDUO\RQWKH\ZඈOOEHPXFKHDVඈHUIRU \RXWRWDNHRQERDUGඈI\RXDUHOHVVIDPඈOඈDUZඈWKWKHµVWDQGDUG¶ZD\RIGRඈQJWKඈQJV$EUඈHIQRWHRQDSSURDFKHV  WKHUHඈVDVXUSUඈVඈQJDPRXQWRIVQREEHU\DQGHOඈWඈVPIRUDSSURDFKHVWRFRGඈQJDQGVFUඈSWඈQJWKඈVඈVWUXHIRU5 DQGRWKHUSURJUDPPඈQJODQJXDJHV:HZඈVKWRVWHHUZHOOFOHDURIWKඈVWKHPRVWඈPSRUWDQWWKඈQJඈVOHDUQඈQJKRZ WRXVHWKHWRROVDW\RXUGඈVSRVDOHIIHFWඈYHO\DQGHIIඈFඈHQWO\

*HWWඈQJVWDUWHGZඈWKWඈG\YHUVHSDFNDJHV

7RJRIXUWKHUWKHYHU\IඈUVWWKඈQJZHQHHGWRGRඈVඈQVWDOODQGORDGWKH–‹†›˜‡”•‡SDFNDJH/XFNඈO\WKඈVඈVYHU\ VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUG5XQWKHIROORZඈQJFRPPDQGV ‹•–ƒŽŽŜ’ƒ…ƒ‰‡•ſɑ–‹†›˜‡”•‡ɑƀ Ž‹„”ƒ”›ſ–‹†›˜‡”•‡ƀ $VPHQWඈRQHGEHIRUHZHZඈOOIRFXVPDඈQO\RQWKH†’Ž›”SDFNDJHKHUHRFFDVVඈRQDOO\ZHPඈJKWXVHVRPH RWKHUSDFNDJHVDQGඈIZHGRඈWZඈOOEHVWDWHGFOHDUO\7KHQH[WWKඈQJZHQHHGWRGRඈVJHWVRPHGDWDWRZRUN ZඈWK:HZඈOOXVHWKH•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWDIURP†’Ž›”\RXPD\EHQRWඈFඈQJDWKHPHKHUH«

•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʳކ’Ž›”śś•–ƒ”™ƒ”•

:KDWGඈGZHGRKHUH":HDVVඈJQHGWKH•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWDVHWVSHFඈI\ඈQJඈWZDVIURPH†’Ž›”XVඈQJWKHśśWKDW

EDVඈFDOO\PHDQVµORRNඈQVඈGH†’Ž›”IRU•–ƒ”™ƒ”•¶

,I\RXWDNHDORRNDWWKHGDWDE\W\SඈQJ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•\RXZඈOOVHHඈWඈVVWRUHGDVD–‹„„އ7KඈVඈVDFRQYHQඈHQW

ZD\RIGඈVSOD\ඈQJD†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡DQGIRUDOOඈQWHQWVDQGSXUSRVHVEHKDYHVPXFKWKHVDPHZD\,WKDVWKH DGGHGDGYDQWDJHWKDWඈWMXVWVKRZV\RXWKHIඈUVWOඈQHVRIWKHGDWD NQRZQDVWKHЇƒ† ,WDOVRVKRZV\RX ZKDWWKHGDWDDFWXDOO\ඈVඈHZKHWKHUඈWඈVFKDUDFWHUGDWDඈQWHJHUGRXEOHRUDIDFWRU7KHWඈEEOHVWඈOOEHKDYHV H[DFWO\DVDඈWZRXOGDVDVWDQGDUG†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡)RUH[DPSOH« •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛƒ‡ «ZඈOOSURGXFHDYHFWRUZඈWKWKHQDPHVRIDOOWKHFKDUDFWHUV6ඈQFHWKH–‹„„އRQO\VKRZV\RXWKHIඈUVW URZVRI\RXUGDWDZKDWඈI\RXZDQWWRVHHPRUH")RUWKDW\RXFDQXVHWKH’”‹–IXQFWඈRQOඈNHVR ’”‹–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řʰɨɬƀ 6RQRZZHKDYHWKHSDFNDJHORDGHGDQGWKHGDWDUHDG\ZHFDQVWDUWSOD\ඈQJDURXQGZඈWKඈW

6HOHFWඈQJFROXPQV

/HWVVD\ZHZDQWWRFKRRVHWKHQDPHDQGKRPHZRUOGFROXPQVIURPRXU•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWDKRZFDQZHGRWKDW" :ඈWKVWDQGDUG5ZHPඈJKWGRVRPHWKඈQJOඈNHWKඈV ɪ™‹–Аƒ‡• •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƃř…ſɐƒ‡ɐřɐŠ‘‡™‘”ކɐƀƄ ɪ™‹–Š‹†‹…‡• •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƃř…ſɨřɰƀƄ

(13)

  :ඈWK†’Ž›”ZHFDQGRWKHIROORZඈQJ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ•‡Ž‡…–ſƒ‡řŠ‘‡™‘”ކƀ :DඈWDPඈQXWHZKDWGRHVʩʴʩGR"7KඈVඈVDSඈSHඈWHVVHQWඈDOO\PHDQVWDNHWKHWKඈQJRQWKHOHIWDQGDSSO\WKH IXQFWඈRQRQWKHUඈJKWWRඈW<RXFDQXVHඈWFUHDWHFKDඈQVRIIXQFWඈRQVZKඈFK\RXFDQHDVඈO\DSSO\WRPXOWඈSOH GDWDIUDPHVඈI\RXQHHG,WWDNHVDEඈWRIJHWWඈQJXVHGWREXWඈWFDQRIWHQFODUඈI\FRGH)RUFRQVඈWHQF\ZඈWK VWDQGDUG5ZHFRXOGKDYHDOVRZUඈWWHQWKHFRGHDERYHOඈNHVR •‡Ž‡…–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡řŠ‘‡™‘”ކƀ %RWKZD\VZRUNDQGXOWඈPDWHO\WKDWඈVDOOWKDWPDWWHUVEXWIRUFODUඈW\DQGJRRGSUDFWඈFHZHZඈOOXVHWKHʩʴʩSඈSH WRPDNHXSRXUGDWDKDQGOඈQJZRUNIORZV6RZKDWHOVHඈVJRඈQJRQZඈWKWKHVHWZR–‹†›˜‡”•‡ඈQVSඈUHGIXQFWඈRQ

FDOOV":HOOWKHIXQFWඈRQ•‡Ž‡…–OඈWHUDOO\FKRRVHVFROXPQVIURPRXU†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡+RSHIXOO\WKH

VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGQHVVRIWKඈVDSSURDFKඈVDGHPRQVWUDWඈRQRIKRZWKHVHSDFNDJHVFDQPDNH5FRGHPRUH UHDGDEOHDQGHDVඈHUWRXQGHUVWDQG •‡Ž‡…–ඈVPRUHSRZHUIXOWKDQMXVWWKඈV6HHVRPHH[DPSOHVEHORZ ɪ…Š‘‘•‡ƒŽŽ…‘Ž—•ƒ‡ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ•‡Ž‡…–ſސƒ‡ƀ ɪ…Š‘‘•‡‘Ž›…‘Ž—•…‘–ƒ‹‹‰ƒ—†‡”•…‘”‡ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ•‡Ž‡…–ſ…‘–ƒ‹•ſɑɏɑƀƀ ɪ…Š‘‘•‡‘Ž›…‘Ž—•„‡‰‹‹‰™‹–Šɗ•ɗ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ•‡Ž‡…–ſ•–ƒ”–•ɏ™‹–Šſɑ•ɑƀƀ

)ඈOWHUඈQJGDWD

:H¶YHVHHQQRZKRZWRVHOHFWFROXPQVXVඈQJD†’Ž›”DSSURDFKEXWZKDWඈIZHZDQWWRVHOHFWURZV"7RGR WKඈVZHQHHGWRIඈOWHUWKHGDWDRQDJඈYHQFUඈWHUඈD/HW¶VVD\ZHZDQWWRMXVWVHOHFWKXPDQVIURPRXU•–ƒ”™ƒ”• GDWD:HFDQDFKඈHYHWKඈVXVඈQJDORJඈFDODSSURDFKඈHH[WUDFWඈQJRQO\URZVZKඈFKPDWFKRXUFUඈWHUඈD ඈHZKHWKHUWKHඈQGඈYඈGXDOඈVKXPDQඈQWKඈVFDVH/HW¶VIඈUVWVHHZKDWKDSSHQVZKHQZHDSSO\DORJඈFDO RSHUDWඈRQWRWKH•’‡…‹‡•FROXPQ5HPHPEHUWKDWIRUQRZZHZඈOOMXVWXVHEDVH5 •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ —ƒɑ $OOZHGඈGKHUHඈVDVNZKHWKHUWKHVSHFඈHVGDWDඈVHTXDOWRWKHVWUඈQJµ+XPDQ¶7KඈVUHWXUQHGDORJඈFDOYHFWRURI DQG YDOXHV,IZHQRZXVHWKඈVWRVXEVHWRXU†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡5ZඈOORQO\UHWXUQURZVZKHUHWKHYDOXH ඈV)RUH[DPSOH •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƃ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ —ƒɑřƄ 1RWHWKDW\RXKDYHWRVSHFඈI\\RXPHDQVSHFඈHVZඈWKඈQWKH•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWDXVඈQJDɛRSHUDWRUEHFDXVH RWKHUZඈVH5GRHVQ¶WNQRZZKHUHWRORRN,QRWKHUZRUGVWKHIROORZඈQJZඈOOQRWZRUN •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƃ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ —ƒɑřƄ

<RXVKRXOGDOVRQRWHWKDWZHQHHGDʰʰඈQVWHDGRIDʰWKඈVMXVWPHDQVµඈVHTXDOWR¶6RZKDWඈVWKH†’Ž›”

DOWHUQDWඈYH":HFDQXVHWKHVWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGO\QDPHVˆ‹Ž–‡”IXQFWඈRQIRUWKඈV •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩˆ‹Ž–‡”ſ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ —ƒɑƀ

(14)

  1RWඈFHZHXVHWKHʩʴʩSඈSHDJDඈQWKHUHDVRQIRUWKඈVZඈOOKRSHIXOO\EHFRPHFOHDUVRRQ<RXPඈJKWEH ZRQGHUඈQJDWWKඈVSRඈQWWKDWWKHUHGRHVQ¶WVHHPWREHDKXJHGඈIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHVHWZRDSSURDFKHVRWKHU WKDQWKHZD\WKHFRGHORRNV:KHUHWKHˆ‹Ž–‡”FRPPDQGUHDOO\EHFRPHVXVHIXOඈVZKHQ\RXXVHඈWIRU PXOWඈSOHGඈIIHUHQWYDUඈDEOHV /HW¶VVXSSRVHZHZDQWWRH[WUDFWDOOඈQGඈYඈGXDOVWKDWDUH+XPDQDQGWKDWDUHIURP7DWRRඈQHDVWKHඈUKRPHZRUOG :ඈWKEDVH5ZHZRXOGGRWKHIROORZඈQJ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƃ™Š‹…Šſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ —ƒɑĺ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛŠ‘‡™‘”ކʰʰɑƒ–‘‘‹‡ɑƀřƄ

1RWHWKDWKHUHDOO™Š‹…ŠGRHVඈVPDNHVXUHZHVXEVHWWKH†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡SURSHUO\:KDWDERXWZඈWK†’Ž›”"

:HOOWKඈVZRXOGZRUN •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩˆ‹Ž–‡”ſ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ —ƒɑřŠ‘‡™‘”ކʰʰɑƒ–‘‘‹‡ɑƀ <RXFDQVHHKRZ†’Ž›”PDNHVIඈOWHUඈQJRQPXOWඈSOHYDUඈDEOHVPXFKPRUHVWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGDQGFOHDQHU

)ඈOWHUඈQJ$1'VHOHFWඈQJGDWD

:KDWඈI\RXZDQWWRGRPXOWඈSOHWKඈQJVWRDGDWDVHWDWRQFH"3HUKDSV\RXQHHGWRJHW\RXUGDWDඈQWRDFHUWDඈQ IRUPDWRUMXVWZDQWWRVXEVHWඈWWRRQO\WKHYDUඈDEOHV\RXDUHඈQWHUHVWHGඈQ$V\RXJHWPRUHDQGPRUH H[SHUඈHQFHGZඈWK5\RXZඈOOIඈQGWKඈVඈVVRPHWKඈQJ\RXZDQWWRGRUHJXODUO\,WPDNHVVHQVHWRPDQDJH\RXU GDWDVWUඈSSඈQJඈWGRZQWRWKHNH\YDOXHVRIඈQWHUHVW7KඈVඈVSDUWRIWKHSUඈQFඈSOHRIWඈG\GDWD KWWSJDUUHWWJPDQJඈWKXEඈRWඈG\ඈQJ  /HW¶VUHWXUQWRRXU•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWDVHWZKDWඈIZHZDQWWRJHWWKHQDPHKHඈJKWDQG\HDURIEඈUWKIRUDOOKXPDQ VSHFඈHV",IZHXVHEDVH5ZHZRXOGGRඈWWKඈVZD\ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƃ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ —ƒɑř…ſɑƒ‡ɑřɑЇ‹‰Š–ɑřɑ„‹”–Šɏ›‡ƒ”ɑƀƄ 7KඈVVRUWRIGDWDPDQඈSXODWඈRQUHTXඈUHVXVWRIඈUVWIඈOWHURQWKHURZVXVඈQJ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ —ƒɑ 5HPHPEHUEDFNWR&KDSWHUZKHQZHXVHGVTXDUHEUDFNHWVWRH[WUDFWGDWDIURPDPDWUඈ[DQGWKHQD GDWDIUDPH"7KඈVඈVH[DFWO\WKHVDPHWKඈQJ 1H[WZHVHOHFWWKHFROXPQVZHZDQWඈQWKHVHFRQGSDUWRIWKHEUDFNHWVXVඈQJ …ſɑƒ‡ɑřɑЇ‹‰Š–ɑřɑ„‹”–Šɏ›‡ƒ”ɑƀ7KඈVඈVIDඈUO\VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGHYHQXVඈQJEDVH5EXW\RXFDQඈPDJඈQH KRZWKඈVFRXOGEHFRPSOඈFDWHGඈIZHZDQWHGWRVHOHFWPDQ\GඈIIHUHQWFROXPQVRUIඈOWHURQGඈIIHUHQWYDUඈDEOHV :KDWඈVWKH†’Ž›”VROXWඈRQ" •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩˆ‹Ž–‡”ſ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ —ƒɑƀʩʴʩ•‡Ž‡…–ſƒ‡řЇ‹‰Š–ř„‹”–Šɏ›‡ƒ”ƀ +HUHZHMXVWSඈSHWKHGDWDWRˆ‹Ž–‡”DQGWKHQDJDඈQWR•‡Ž‡…–,WඈVZRUWKQRWඈQJKHUHWKDWWKH–‹†›˜‡”•‡ VROXWඈRQPඈJKWQRWEHSDUWඈFXODUO\IDVWHURUHYHQPXFKOHVVFRGH,WඈV ඈQRXURSඈQඈRQDWOHDVW HDVඈHUWRUHDGDQG WRGඈVHQWDQJOHඈI\RXFRPHEDFNWRWKHFRGHDWDODWHUGDWH7KHUHUHDOO\ඈVQRUඈJKWRUZURQJZD\WRPDQඈSXODWH GDWDඈQ5ZKඈFKHYHUDSSURDFK\RXXVHඈVXOWඈPDWHO\DPDWWHURIWDVWH+RZHYHUDV\RXZඈOOVHHඈQWKHQH[W VHFWඈRQ†’Ž›”DSSURDFKHVFDQUHDOO\OHYHOXS\RXUDEඈOඈW\WRPDQඈSXODWHGDWD

6XPPDUඈVඈQJGDWD

:KHUH†’Ž›”UHDOO\H[FHOVඈVZKHQ\RXZDQWWRH[WUDFWVRPHNඈQGRIVXPPDU\ඈQIRUPDWඈRQIURP\RXUGDWD /HW¶VVWDUWZඈWKDYHU\VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGH[DPSOHXVඈQJRXU•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWD:KDWඈIZHZDQWWRFRXQWWKHQXPEHU RIGඈIIHUHQWVSHFඈHVWKHUHDUHඈQWKHGDWD")ඈUVWOHW¶VDFWXDOO\ORRNDWWKHVSHFඈHVSUHVHQW

(15)

  •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡• <RXFDQVHHWKHUHDUHIHZGඈIIHUHQWRQHVDOWKRXJKHYHQIURPWKඈVඈWඈVIDඈUO\REYඈRXVKXPDQVDUHJRඈQJWREH WKHPRVWQXPHURXV,IZHZDQWWRFRXQWKRZPDQ\VSHFඈHVWKHUHDUHDOOZHQHHGWRGRඈVFRXQWWKHRFFXUUHQFH RIHDFKRIWKHVH%HIRUHZHORRNDWWKH†’Ž›”VROXWඈRQZHZඈOOWDNHDORRNDWRQHPRUHEDVH5ZD\WRDFKඈHYH WKඈV –ƒ„އſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛ•’‡…‹‡•ƀ 7KඈVZRUNVDQGඈVIDVWEXWWKHPDඈQGඈVDGYDQWDJHඈVWKDWRXURXWSXWඈVQRORQJHUD†ƒ–ƒŜˆ”ƒ‡,WඈVDOVRPXFK PRUHGඈIIඈFXOWWRVFDOHWKඈVDSSURDFKXSඈIZHZඈVKWRJURXSRXUGDWDVHWE\PXOWඈSOHYDUඈDEOHV%XWIඈUVWWKH †’Ž›”HTXඈYDOHQWRIDERYHඈVDOVRVWUDඈJKWIRUZDUG •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ‰”‘—’ɏ„›ſ•’‡…‹‡•ƀʩʴʩ–ƒŽŽ›ſƀ $OOZHKDYHGRQHKHUHඈVIඈUVWJURXSHGRXUGDWDVHWE\VSHFඈHVXVඈQJ‰”‘—’ɏ„›DQGWKHQFRXQWHGWKHQXPEHURI URZVඈQHDFKJURXSXVඈQJ–ƒŽŽ› ‰”‘—’ɏ„›FDQUHDOO\FRPHඈQWRඈWVRZQZKHQ\RXZDQWWRFRXQWRUWDOO\GDWDEDVHGRQVHYHUDOYDUඈDEOHV/HW¶V VD\ZHZDQWWRFRXQWWKHQXPEHURIHDFKJHQGHURIZඈWKඈQHDFKVSHFඈHV:HZRXOGGRඈWOඈNHVR •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ‰”‘—’ɏ„›ſ•’‡…‹‡•ř‰‡†‡”ƀʩʴʩ–ƒŽŽ›ſƀ :HFDQGRDORWPRUHWKDQMXVWFRXQWRFFXUUHQFHVZඈWKWKඈVIXQFWඈRQDOඈW\IURP†’Ž›”3HUKDSVZHZDQWWRNQRZ WKHDYHUDJHKHඈJKWDQGPDVVRIHDFKVSHFඈHV" •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ‰”‘—’ɏ„›ſ•’‡…‹‡•ƀʩʴʩ•—ƒ”‹•‡ſ‡ƒɏЇ‹‰Š–ʰ‡ƒſЇ‹‰Š–řƒŜ”ʰƀř ‡ƒɏƒ••ʰ‡ƒſƒ••řƒŜ”ʰƀƀ +HUHDOOZHGඈGZDVXVHWKH•—ƒ”‹•‡IXQFWඈRQWRFDOFXODWHPHDQKHඈJKWDQGPDVV6ඈQFHZHXVHGWKH‡ƒ IXQFWඈRQRQERWKYDUඈDEOHVZHFDQDFWXDOO\VඈPSOඈI\WKඈVHYHQIXUWKHUOඈNHVR •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ‰”‘—’ɏ„›ſ•’‡…‹‡•ƀʩʴʩ•—ƒ”‹•‡ɏƒ–ſ˜ƒ”•ſЇ‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀř‡ƒřƒŜ”ʰƀ 6RWKඈVWඈPHZHXVHG•—ƒ”‹•‡ɏƒ–DQGVSHFඈIඈHGWKHYDUඈDEOHVZHZDQWHGWRVXPPDUඈVHZඈWKWKH˜ƒ”• IXQFWඈRQ 6XPPDUඈVඈQJGDWDඈQWKඈVZD\ඈVDXVHIXOVNඈOOHVSHFඈDOO\ZKHQ\RXZDQWWRJHWDIHHOIRUZKDW\RXUGDWDVHW VKRZVRU\RXQHHGWREUHDNඈWGRZQඈQWRPRUHXQGHUVWDQGDEOHVXEVHWV$VZHWXUQQH[WWRPRUHDGYDQFHG SORWWඈQJXVඈQJ‰‰’Ž‘–ɩ\RXZඈOOVHHWKDWPDQඈSXODWඈQJGDWDඈVHVSHFඈDOO\XVHIXOZKHQ\RXZDQWFUHDWHFHUWDඈQ W\SHVRISORWV

3ORWWඈQJZඈWKJJSORW

,QWKHODVWFKDSWHUZHOHDUQHGWKDW5ඈVKඈJKO\YHUVDWඈOHZKHQඈWFRPHVWRSORWWඈQJDQGYඈVXDOඈVඈQJGDWD 9ඈVXDOඈVWDWඈRQUHDOO\FDQQRWEHXQGHUVWDWHGDVGDWDVHWVEHFRPHODUJHUDQGPRUHGඈIIඈFXOWWRKDQGOHඈWඈV ඈPSHUDWඈYH\RXOHDUQKRZWRHIIHFWඈYHO\SORWDQGH[SORUH\RXUGDWD7KඈVREYඈRXVO\WDNHVSUDFWඈFHEXWSORWWඈQJ DQGVXPPDUඈVඈQJGDWDYඈVXDOO\ඈVDNH\VNඈOOIRUJXඈGඈQJIXUWKHUDQDO\VඈVWKඈVඈVHVSHFඈDOO\WUXHIRUHYROXWඈRQDU\ JHQRPඈFVEXWඈVHDVඈO\DSSOඈFDEOHWRDQ\QXPEHURIVFඈHQWඈIඈFIඈHOGV $V\RXPD\KDYHJDWKHUHGE\QRZWKHUHDUHORWVRIRSඈQඈRQVRQKRZWRXVH5ZKHWKHU\RXVKRXOGXVHEDVH RUWඈG\YHUVHDSSURDFKHV:HZDQWWRVWUHVVWKDWWKHUHඈVQRWKඈQJZURQJZඈWKXVඈQJEDVHSORWWඈQJඈWඈVFDSDEOHRI VRPHYHU\ඈPSUHVVඈYHSORWV XVH†‡‘ſ‰”ƒ’Š‹…•ƀWRKDYHDORRN +RZHYHU‰‰’Ž‘–ɩඈVH[WUHPHO\IOH[ඈEOHDQG

(16)

  WDNHVTXඈWHDGඈIIHUHQWDSSURDFKWRSORWWඈQJFRPSDUHGWREDVH5

JJSORWEDVඈFV

7KHEHVWZD\WRJHWWRJUඈSVZඈWKJJSORWඈVMXVWWRXVHඈWEXWEHIRUHZHGHOYHඈQWKHUHඈVRQHඈPSRUWDQWSRඈQW ZHVKRXOGWDNHQRWHRI8QOඈNHEDVH5ZKඈFKFDQSORWYHFWRUVGඈUHFWO\‰‰’Ž‘–ɩUHTXඈUHVWKDW\RXSURYඈGHඈWZඈWK VRPHGDWDIඈUVWXVXDOO\ඈQWKHIRUPRIDGDWDIUDPHRUWඈEEOHOඈNHZHGHDOWZඈWKඈQWKHSUHYඈRXVVHFWඈRQ &RQWඈQXඈQJZඈWKRXUWKHPHIURPEHIRUHOHW¶VXVHWKH•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWDVHWDJDඈQ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʳކ’Ž›”śś•–ƒ”™ƒ”• /HW¶VGRDVඈPSOHVFDWWHUSORWRIWKHKHඈJKWDQGPDVVRIWKHFKDUDFWHUVඈQWKඈVGDWDVHW ‰‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡•ſЇ‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſƀ )ඈUVWWDNHDPRPHQWWRH[DPඈQHWKHSORWWKඈVඈVDFWXDOO\DEUඈOOඈDQWH[DPSOHRIZK\ඈWඈVඈPSRUWDQWWRSORWGDWD VඈQFH\RXFDQVHHWKDWWKHUHඈVRQHඈQGඈYඈGXDOZඈWKD+8*(PDVVWKDWGඈVWRUWVRXUGDWDYඈVXDOඈVDWඈRQ,VWKඈVඈV DQHUURU"2USHUKDSVVRPHRQHZඈWKDORWRIPDVVඈVඈQRXUGDWDVHW" %HIRUHZHඈQYHVWඈJDWHWKඈVඈWඈVඈPSRUWDQWWRXQGHUVWDQGKRZRXU‰‰’Ž‘–ɩFRPPDQGඈVEXඈOWXS ‰‰’Ž‘–ſƀඈVWKHIXQFWඈRQFDOOWR‰‰’Ž‘–ɩZHSURYඈGHWKඈVZඈWKWZRDUJXPHQWVIඈUVWO\ZHVSHFඈI\RXU GDWDVHWDQGWKHQQH[WZHVHWDQDHVWKHWඈF WKHDHVWKHWඈFඈQWKඈVFDVHƒ‡•ſЇ‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀඈVMXVWZKDWYDUඈDEOHVWRPDSWRWKH[DQG\D[HVKHඈJKW DQGPDVVKHUHQRWHWKDWWKඈVPHDQV\RXMXVWQHHGWRSURYඈGHWKHYDUඈDEOHQDPHVඈH\RXGRQ¶WQHHG WRW\SH•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛЇ‹‰Š– IඈQDOO\ZHVSHFඈI\DOD\HUIRUWKHYඈVXDOඈVDWඈRQඈWVHOIඈQWKඈVFDVHZHZDQWWRSORWWKHGDWDDVSRඈQWVRQD VFDWWHUSORWVRZHXVH‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſƀ

(17)

  QRWHDOVRWKDWZHXVHGʫWRVHWXSRXUJJSORWIXQFWඈRQWKඈVඈVEHFDXVHJJSORWDOORZVXVWRPXOWඈSOH OD\HUVRIYඈVXDOඈVDWඈRQ ,I\RXKDYHXVHGEDVHJUDSKඈFVEHIRUHඈWFDQWDNHVRPHWඈPHWRJHWXVHGWRWKH‰‰’Ž‘–ɩZD\RIGRඈQJWKඈQJV +RZHYHUDVZHZDON\RXWKURXJKPXOWඈSOHH[DPSOHVKHUH\RXZඈOOVRRQJHWWKHKDQJRIඈWDQGVHHWKDWඈWඈV SRVVඈEOHWRHDVඈO\FXVWRPඈVHSORWV %XWIඈUVWZKRKDVVXFKDKXJHPDVV" ɤɤɤ–‹„„އśɨšɨɪ ɤɤƒ‡Ї‹‰Š–ƒ••Šƒ‹”ɏ…‘Ž‘”•‹ɏ…‘Ž‘”‡›‡ɏ…‘Ž‘”„‹”–Šɏ›‡ƒ”‰‡†‡” ɤɤʳ…Š”ʴʳ‹–ʴʳ†„Žʴʳ…Š”ʴʳ…Š”ʴʳ…Š”ʴʳ†„Žʴʳ…Š”ʴ ɤɤɨ ƒ„„ŝɨɮɬɨɪɬɯʳʴ‰”‡‡Ş–ƒŝ‘”ƒ‰‡ɭɥɥЇ”ƒŝ ɤɤɤŝ™‹–Šɬ‘”‡˜ƒ”‹ƒ„އ•śŠ‘‡™‘”ކʳ…Š”ʴř•’‡…‹‡•ʳ…Š”ʴřˆ‹Ž•ʳŽ‹•–ʴř ɤɤɤ˜‡Š‹…އ•ʳŽ‹•–ʴř•–ƒ”•Š‹’•ʳŽ‹•–ʴ :HOOඈI\RX¶YHVHHQ6WDU:DUVWKHDQVZHUWRWKඈVVKRXOGQ¶WEHDKXJHVXUSUඈVH«/HW¶VIඈOWHUKඈPRXWRIWKHGDWD •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩʳވ‹Ž–‡”ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡Šʰɑ ƒ„„ƒ‡•‹Ž‹Œ‹…‹—”‡ɑƀ 1RZZHFDQUHSORWWKHGDWDDQGVHHZKDWWKHUHODWඈRQVKඈSEHWZHHQKHඈJKWDQGPDVVඈV ‰‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩřƒ‡•ſЇ‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſƀ $VH[SHFWHGPDVVJHQHUDOO\ඈQFUHDVHVZඈWKKHඈJKW

&XVWRPඈVඈQJDSORW

+RZGRZHFXVWRPඈVHRXUVFDWWHUSORWXVඈQJ‰‰’Ž‘–ɩ")ඈUVWO\ZHFDQDGGVRPHFRORXUWRWKHSRඈQWV

(18)





‰‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩřƒ‡•ſЇ‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſ…‘Ž‘—”ʰɑ”‡†ɑƀ

2UZHFDQFKDQJHWKHඈUFRORXUDQGVKDSH

(19)

  1RWHWKDWඈQERWKRIWKHVHFDVHVZHDGGHGDUJXPHQWVWR‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–WKHIXQFWඈRQWKDWFRQWUROVWKHSORWWඈQJRI WKHSRඈQWV7KHUHඈVDQRWKHUZD\WRFKDQJHWKHSRඈQWFRORXUඈQYROYඈQJWKHDHVWKHWඈFVEXWZHZඈOOGHDOZඈWKWKඈV ඈQDPRPHQW 3HUKDSVZHZDQWWRDOWHUWKHRYHUDOOWKHPHRIWKHSORW":HFDQGRWKDWE\DGGඈQJDWKHPH ‰‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩřƒ‡•ſЇ‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſ…‘Ž‘—”ʰɑ”‡†ɑƀʫ–Ї‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀ

(20)

  %\GRඈQJWKඈV\RXFDQVHHDJDඈQKRZZHFDQEXඈOGDSORWE\DGGඈQJOD\HUVXVඈQJʫ,WFDQJHWPHVV\WRGRWKඈV DOOZඈWKRQHOඈQHVRDQඈFHWKඈQJDERXW‰‰’Ž‘–ɩFRGHඈVWKDW\RXFDQDVVඈJQඈWWRREMHFWVDQGHDVඈO\EXඈOGD FRPSOH[SORW)RUH[DPSOH ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩřƒ‡•ſЇ‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀƀ ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſ…‘Ž‘—”ʰɑ”‡†ɑƀ ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ•‘‘–Šſ‡–Š‘†ʰŽř•‡ʰ ƀ ƒʳރʫ–Ї‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀʫ‰‰–‹–އſɑ ‡‹‰Š–˜•ƒ••‹–ƒ”ƒ”•ɑƀ ƒ

(21)

  +HUHZHDGGHGWඈWOHDQGDOVRIඈWWHGDOඈQHRIEHVWIඈWWRWKHGDWDWRYඈVXDOඈVHWKHUHODWඈRQVKඈSHYHQPRUHFOHDUO\ 7RDFKඈHYHWKඈVZHXVHGWKH‰‡‘ɏ•‘‘–ŠOD\HUDQGVSHFඈIඈHGDOඈQHDUPRGHO7KඈVඈVDWRSඈFZHZඈOOUHWXUQWRඈQ IXWXUHFKDSWHUV :KDWඈIඈQVWHDGRIMXVWFRORXUඈQJWKHSRඈQWVWRPDNHDSORWORRNQඈFHZHGඈGඈWWRDFWXDOO\WU\DQGOHDUQVRPHWKඈQJ DERXWWKHGDWD")RUH[DPSOHZHFRXOGFRORXUWKHSRඈQWVE\VSHFඈHV7KඈVKRZHYHUUHTXඈUHVWKDWZHPDSSRඈQW FRORXUWRVSHFඈHVඈQWKHƒ‡•IXQFWඈRQRIRXUFRPPDQG:HZඈOOUHWXUQWRWKHEDVඈFSORWDQGGRVREHORZ ‰‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩřƒ‡•ſЇ‹‰Š–řƒ••ř…‘Ž‘—”ʰ•’‡…‹‡•ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſƀ

(22)

  7KඈVඈVZKHUHWKHSRZHURIDHVWKHWඈFVVWDUWVWREHFRPHDSSDUHQWZඈWK‰‰’Ž‘–ɩඈWඈVYHU\HDV\WRPDSFHUWDඈQ YDUඈDEOHVWRDQDHVWKHWඈFDQGYඈVXDOඈVHWKHPඈQDSORW

'ඈIIHUHQWW\SHVRISORWZඈWKJJSORW

7KHUHDUHPDQ\GඈIIHUHQWZD\VWRYඈVXDOඈVHGDWDXVඈQJ‰‰’Ž‘–ɩEH\RQGWKHVWDQGDUGVFDWWHUSORWZHKDYH DOUHDG\VHHQ)RUDIXOOOඈVWZඈWKUHSURGXFඈEOHH[DPSOHV\RXVKRXOGVHHWKHJJSORWPDQXDO KWWSJJSORWWඈG\YHUVHRUJUHIHUHQFH +RZHYHUZHZඈOOGHPRQVWUDWHDVHOHFWඈRQKHUHDQGDOVRJHWPRUHRI DQඈGHDRIZK\‰‰’Ž‘–ɩඈVVRIOH[ඈEOH

9ඈVXDOඈVඈQJGDWDGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQV

)ඈUVWRIDOOZKDWඈIZHZDQWWRORRNDWWKHGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQRIRXUGDWD")RUH[DPSHZHFRXOGKDYHORRNHGDWWKH GඈVWUඈEXWඈRQRIPDVVඈQRXUGDWDVHWDQGVSRWWHGWKDW-DEEDZDVDQඈVVXHEHIRUHPDNඈQJRXUVFDWWHUSORW2QH ZD\WRGRWKඈVZRXOGKDYHEHHQWRSORWDKඈVWRJUDPXVඈQJWKH‰‡‘ɏŠ‹•–‘‰”ƒOD\HU ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡•ſƒ••ƀƀ ƒʫ‰‡‘ɏŠ‹•–‘‰”ƒſ„‹™‹†–Šʰɨɥƀ

(23)





1RWHWKDWZඈWKඈQRXU‰‡‘ɏŠ‹•–‘‰”ƒOD\HUIXQFWඈRQZHVHWWKH„‹™‹†–ŠDUJXPHQWWR,QRWKHUZRUGVZH

DUHEඈQQඈQJRXUGDWDE\VHWVRI:HFRXOGIRUH[DPSOHFKDQJHWKඈVWRDQGVHHKRZWKHGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQ FKDQJHV

(24)

  6WඈOOWKRXJK-DEEDඈVVRKXJHKHඈVDQREYඈRXVRXWOඈHU:HDOVRVHHKHUHWKDWVඈQFHZHGHIඈQඈHGWKHEDVඈVRIRXU SORWDVREMHFWƒZඈWKWKH‰‰’Ž‘–DQGƒ‡•IXQFWඈRQVDOOZHQHHGWRGRWRUHSORWRXUKඈVWRJUDPඈVDOWHUWKH ‰‡‘ɏŠ‹•–‘‰”ƒOD\HU :HFDQඈQIDFWFRPSOHWHO\FKDQJHWKHW\SHRISORW$QRWKHUZD\WRYඈVXDOඈVHDGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQඈVWRXVHDVPRRWKHG GHQVඈW\SORWZඈWKWKH‰‡‘ɏ†‡•‹–›OD\HU$OOZHQHHGWRGRඈVFKDQJHDVPDOODUJXPHQWඈQRXUFRGH ƒʫ‰‡‘ɏ†‡•‹–›ſƀ

(25)





&RPSDUඈQJGDWDGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQV

3HUKDSVZHZDQWWRFRPSDUHPDVVDPRQJWKHGඈIIHUHQWVSHFඈHVඈQRXUGDWD"2QHZD\ZHFDQGRWKඈVඈVZඈWKD ER[SORWOඈNHZHGඈGඈQ&KDSWHU‰‰’Ž‘–ɩPDNHVWKඈVH[FHSWඈRQDOO\HDV\ZඈWKWKH‰‡‘ɏ„‘š’Ž‘–OD\HU

ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡•ſ•’‡…‹‡•řƒ••ƀƀ ƒʫ‰‡‘ɏ„‘š’Ž‘–ſƀ

(26)

  +PPDOWKRXJKWKඈVSORWඈVGHWDඈOHGDQGZHFDQVWඈOOVHHWKHUHඈVDFOHDURXWOඈHUඈWඈVGඈIIඈFXOWWRUHDOO\VHHPXFK PRUH7KඈVඈVDQඈPSRUWDQWSRඈQWRIGDWDYඈVXDOඈVDWඈRQ\RXQHHGWRWKඈQNZKDW\RXKRSHWKRVHYඈHZඈQJWKHSORW FDQOHDUQIURPඈW 8VඈQJWKHGDWDKDQGOඈQJVNඈOOVZHOHDUQHGHDUOඈHUඈQWKඈVVHVVඈRQOHW¶VVXEVHWRXUGDWDDQGYඈVXDOඈVHඈWDJDඈQ XVඈQJ‰‡‘ɏ„‘š’Ž‘–7RJHWVWDUWHGZHZඈOOFRPSDUHWKHPDVVRIKXPDQVGURඈGVDQGHZRNV ɪ•—„•‡–†ƒ–ƒ І‡ʳŞ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ•—„•‡–ſ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ —ƒɑŶ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ”‘‹†ɑŶ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ™‘ɑƀ ɪ’Ž‘––Ї†‹•–”‹„—–‹‘• ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſІ‡řƒ‡•ſ•’‡…‹‡•řƒ••ƀƀ ƒʫ‰‡‘ɏ„‘š’Ž‘–ſƀ

(27)

  &OHDUO\(ZRNVKDYHDPXFKORZHUPDVVWKDQHඈWKHUGURඈGVRUKXPDQVEXWQRWHKHUHWKDWWKHUHඈVRQO\DVඈQJOH (ZRNREVHUYDWඈRQVRZHFDQ¶WUHDOO\FRPSDUHWKHGඈVWUඈEXWඈRQRIPDVVHVDPRQJWKHVHVSHFඈHV :HFDQKRZHYHUYHUඈI\WKHQXPEHURIREVHUYDWඈRQVIRUHDFKVSHFඈHV:HFDQGRWKඈVXVඈQJ†’Ž›”OඈNHVR ɤɤɤ–‹„„އśɪšɩ ɤɤ•’‡…‹‡• ɤɤʳ…Š”ʴʳ‹–ʴ ɤɤɨ”‘‹† ɬ ɤɤɩ™‘ ɨ ɤɤɪ —ƒɪɬ :HFRXOGDOVRYඈVXDOඈVHWKඈVDVDEDUSORWZඈWK‰‰’Ž‘–ɩ)RUH[DPSOH ‰‰’Ž‘–ſІ‡řƒ‡•ſ•’‡…‹‡•ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ„ƒ”ſƀ

(28)

 

0RUHFRPSOඈFDWHGSORWVDQGGDWDKDQGOඈQJ

,QVRPHFDVHVZHPඈJKWZDQWWRYඈVXDOඈVHPXOWඈSOHYDUඈDEOHVFOHDUO\IURPDGDWDVHW$VDQH[DPSOHSHUKDSV ZHZDQWWRORRNDWWKHGඈIIHUHQFHඈQERWKPDVVDQGKHඈJKWEHWZHHQKXPDQVDQGGURඈGVඈQDVඈQJOHSORW %HIRUHZHGRWKඈVOHW¶VVXEVHWRXUGDWDWRMXVWඈQFOXGHKXPDQVDQGGURඈGVVඈQFHZHNQRZWKHUHඈVRQO\D VඈQJOH(ZRNඈQWKHGDWDZHFDQGURSඈW ІʳŞ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ʩʴʩ•—„•‡–ſ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ —ƒɑŶ•’‡…‹‡•ʰʰɑ”‘‹†ɑƀ :KDWZHZRXOGOඈNHWRGRඈVFUHDWHDSORWZඈWKWZRSDQHOVRQHIRUER[SORWVVKRZඈQJKHඈJKWDQGWKHRWKHUIRU ER[SORWVVKRZඈQJPDVV:HFDQDFKඈHYHWKඈVZඈWKDOD\HUNQRZQDVˆƒ…‡–ɏ‰”‹†KRZHYHUඈWUHTXඈUHVRXUGDWD WREHඈQDVOඈJKWO\GඈIIHUHQWIRUPDWZHQHHGWRPHUJHERWKRXUKHඈJKWDQGPDVVPHDVXUHPHQWVඈQWRDVඈQJOH FROXPQ7RGRWKඈVZHZඈOOXVHDIXQFWඈRQFDOOHG‰ƒ–Ї” ɪˆ‹”•–™‡•‡Ž‡…–‘Ž›–Ї˜ƒ”‹ƒ„އ•™‡ƒ”‡‹–‡”‡•–‡†‹ ІʳŞІʩʴʩ•‡Ž‡…–ſƒ‡řЇ‹‰Š–řƒ••ř•’‡…‹‡•ƀ Іɏ‰ʳŞІʩʴʩ‰ƒ–Ї”ſ‡›ʰɑ‡ƒ•—”‡‡–ɑř˜ƒŽ—‡ʰɑ˜ƒŽ—‡ɑřސƒ‡řŞ•’‡…‹‡•ƀ Іɏ‰

(29)

  ɤɤɤ–‹„„އśɯɥšɫ ɤɤƒ‡ •’‡…‹‡•‡ƒ•—”‡‡–˜ƒŽ—‡ ɤɤʳ…Š”ʴ ʳ…Š”ʴʳ…Š”ʴ ʳ†„Žʴ ɤɤɨ—‡›™ƒŽ‡” —ƒЇ‹‰Š– ɨɮɩ ɤɤɩŞɪ ”‘‹†Ї‹‰Š– ɨɭɮ ɤɤɪɩŞɩ ”‘‹†Ї‹‰Š– ɰɭ ɤɤɫƒ”–Šƒ†‡” —ƒЇ‹‰Š– ɩɥɩ ɤɤɬ‡‹ƒ”‰ƒƒ —ƒЇ‹‰Š– ɨɬɥ ɤɤɭ™‡ƒ”• —ƒЇ‹‰Š– ɨɮɯ ɤɤɮ‡”—Š‹–‡•—Žƒ”• —ƒЇ‹‰Š– ɨɭɬ ɤɤɯɬŞɫ ”‘‹†Ї‹‰Š– ɰɮ ɤɤɰ‹‰‰•ƒ”Ž‹‰Š–‡” —ƒЇ‹‰Š– ɨɯɪ ɤɤɨɥ„‹Şƒ‡‘„‹ —ƒЇ‹‰Š– ɨɯɩ ɤɤɤŝ™‹–Šɮɥ‘”‡”‘™•

:KDWKDSSHQHGKHUH":ඈWKඈQ‰ƒ–Ї”ZHVSHFඈIඈHGRXU‡›YDUඈDEOHWREHPHDVXUHPHQWWKඈVMXVWFUHDWHVD

FKDUDFWHUYHFWRUZඈWKWZRYDOXHVKHඈJKWDQGPDVV:HDOVRJඈYHRXUFRPEඈQHGYDUඈDEOHDQDPHYDOXHKHUH 6RQRZZHKDYHDWඈEEOHZඈWKWZඈFHDVPDQ\URZVDVWKHRUඈJඈQDOEXWZඈWKRQHIRUKHඈJKWDQGRQHIRUPDVV :HFDQGHPRQVWUDWHWKඈVE\DFWXDOO\ORRNඈQJIRUDVඈQJOHQDPHDQGVHHඈQJWKHUHDUHWZRURZVRQHIRUKHඈJKW DQGRQHIRUPDVV)RUH[DPSOH ˆ‹Ž–‡”ſІɏ‰řƒ‡ʰʰɑɩŞɩɑƀ ɤɤɤ–‹„„އśɩšɫ ɤɤƒ‡•’‡…‹‡•‡ƒ•—”‡‡–˜ƒŽ—‡ ɤɤʳ…Š”ʴʳ…Š”ʴʳ…Š”ʴ ʳ†„Žʴ ɤɤɨɩŞɩ”‘‹†Ї‹‰Š– ɰɭ ɤɤɩɩŞɩ”‘‹†ƒ•• ɪɩ 8VHRI‰ƒ–Ї”ඈQWKඈVZD\ඈVDEඈWFRXQWHUඈQWXඈWඈYHDWIඈUVWEXWZඈWKSUDFWඈFH\RXZඈOOVHHඈWEHFRPHVPXFKPRUH VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUG 6RZKDWZDVWKHSRඈQWRIWKඈVDQ\ZD\":HOOඈWDOORZVXVWRFRQVWUXFWRXUSORWOඈNHWKඈV ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſІɏ‰řƒ‡•ſ•’‡…‹‡•ř˜ƒŽ—‡ƀƀʫ‰‡‘ɏ„‘š’Ž‘–ſƀ ƒʫˆƒ…‡–ɏ‰”‹†ſɌ‡ƒ•—”‡‡–ƀ

(30)

  $VQRUPDOZHVSHFඈIඈHGWKHGDWDDQGDHVWKHWඈFVIRURXUSORW+RZHYHUZHDGGHGWKHˆƒ…‡–ɏ‰”‹†DUJXPHQWWR VSOඈWWKHSORWඈQWRIDFHWVRYHUWKHGඈIIHUHQWW\SHVRIPHDVXUHPHQW ඈHKHඈJKWDQGPDVVKHUH 7KH Ɍ‡ƒ•—”‡‡–SDUWRIWKඈVFRPPDQGMXVWPHDQVZHVKRXOGIඈOOWKHIDFHWJUඈGDVQHZFROXPQV:HFRXOGDOVR XVH‡ƒ•—”‡–ɌŜWRGRWKHVDPHE\URZV QRWHWKDWWKHŜඈVQHFHVVDU\WRDOORZ5WRඈQWHUSUHWWKHFRPPDQG SURSHUO\ /ඈNHVR ƒʫˆƒ…‡–ɏ‰”‹†ſ‡ƒ•—”‡‡–ɌŜƀ

(31)

  ,WඈVDPDWWHURIRSඈQඈRQEXWWKHZHWKඈQNWKDWWKHIඈUVWSORWORRNVEHWWHU(ඈWKHUZD\IURPERWKSORWVඈWඈVFOHDUWKDW WKHKXPDQVDUHRQDYHUDJHWDOOHUWKDQGURඈGVEXWWKDWWKHUHඈVPXFKJUHDWHUYDUඈDWඈRQඈQERWKGURඈGPDVVDQG KHඈJKW

$QQRWDWඈQJDQGPDNඈQJSXEOඈFDWඈRQTXDOඈW\SORWV

7KHFRQFHSWRIOD\HUVඈQ‰‰’Ž‘–ɩඈVVඈPඈODUඈQHWKRVWRWKDWXVHGඈQJUDSKඈFGHVඈJQSURJUDPVVXFKDV$GREH ,OOXVWUDWRURU3KRWRVKRS<RXFUHDWHDSORWDQG\RXFDQDGGOD\HUVRIGHWDඈOWRඈW7KඈVPDNHVඈWYHU\ VWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGWRFUHDWHDSXEOඈFDWඈRQTXDOඈW\IඈJXUHZඈWKDIHZOඈQHVRIFRGH /HW¶VUHWXUQWRRXUHDUOඈHUGHQVඈW\SORWRIPDVVIURPRXU•–ƒ”™ƒ”•GDWD ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡•ſƒ••ƀƀ ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ†‡•‹–›ſ„‹™‹†–Šʰɨɥƀ ƒ

(32)

  :ඈWKWKHFRGHDERYHZHKDYHFRPPSOHWHO\DVVඈJQHGRXUSORWWRWKHREMHFWƒ6RQRZDOOZHQHHGWRGRඈVDGG OD\HUVWRඈWWRDQQRWDWHඈW )ඈUVWRIDOOOHW¶VSORWPHDQYDOXHRIPDVVDVDYHUWඈFDOOඈQHRQWKHSORW7RGRWKඈVZHQHHGWRFDOFXODWHWKH PHDQZKඈFKZHZRXOGGROඈNHVR ‡ƒɏƒ••ʳޏ‡ƒſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɛƒ••řƒŜ”ʰƀ ‡ƒɏƒ•• :HQHHGWKHƒŜ”ʰDUJXPHQWKHUHEHFDXVHVRPHඈQGඈYඈGXDOVGRQRWKDYHDPHDVXUHGPDVV ඈHWKH\DUH  ZඈWKRXWWKඈVDFDOOWRWKH‡ƒZඈOORQO\SURGXFHDQ$Q\ZD\QRZWKDWZHKDYHGHIඈQHGRXUPHDQ

PDVVZHFDQDGGඈWWRRXUSORWDVDOඈQHOඈNHVR

ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ˜Ž‹‡ſš‹–‡”…‡’–ʰ‡ƒɏƒ••řŽ–›ʰɩř…‘Ž‘—”ʰɑ”‡†ɑƀ ƒ

(33)

  1H[WZHFDQDGGVRPHWKHPHDUJXPHQWVWRPDNHRXUSORWVXඈWDEOHIRUSXEOඈFDWඈRQ ƒʳރʫ–Ї‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀ ƒʳރʫ–Ї‡ſƒš‹•Ŝ–‹–އʰ‡Ž‡‡–ɏ–‡š–ſ•‹œ‡ʰɨɪřˆƒ…‡ʰɑ„‘ކɑƀř ƒš‹•Ŝ–‡š–ʰ‡Ž‡‡–ɏ–‡š–ſ•‹œ‡ʰɨɨƀƀ ƒ

(34)

  1RWHWKDWKHUHZHKDYHWRFDOO–Ї‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀIඈUVWRUඈWZඈOORYHUUඈGHDOOWKHRWKHUDUJXPHQWVZHPDGHWR –Ї‡ſƀODWHU 7KHUHඈVDKXJHDPRXQW\RXFDQGRWRPDNHSORWVORRNPRUHDHVWKHWඈFDOO\SOHDVඈQJ\RXVKRXOGFKHFNRXWDOO WKHRSWඈRQVDYDඈODEOHඈQWKHJJSORWPDQXDO KWWSJJSORWWඈG\YHUVHRUJඈQGH[KWPO  )ඈQDOO\RQFH\RXKDYHFUHDWHGDSORW\RXOඈNH\RXPඈJKWZDQWWRVDYHඈW<RXFDQGRWKඈVHDVඈO\XVඈQJWKH ‰‰•ƒ˜‡ ‰‰•ƒ˜‡ſɑŜŵ›’Ž‘–Ŝ’†ˆɑř’Ž‘–ʰŽƒ•–ɏ’Ž‘–ſƀř†‡˜‹…‡ʰɑ’†ˆɑƀ +HUHZHVDYHGDSORWWRWKHFXUUHQWGඈUHFWRU\ XVH‰‡–™†ſƀඈI\RXQHHGWRIඈQGRXWZKHUHWKඈVඈV DVSGIFDOHG ›’Ž‘–Ŝ’†ˆ

6RPHODVWZRUGVRQJJSORW

+RSHIXOO\WKHODVWVHFWඈRQKDVFRQYඈQFHG\RXWKDW‰‰’Ž‘–ɩඈVDYHUVDWඈOHDQGIOH[ඈEOHWRROIRUGDWDYඈVXDOඈVDWඈRQ 7KHUHDUHPDQ\PRUHWKඈQJVWKDWDUHSRVVඈEOHZඈWKWKHSDFNDJHEXWXQIRUWXQDWHO\ZHGRQRWKDYHWKHWඈPHRU VSDFHWRJRඈQWRWKHPDOOKHUH1RQHWKHOHVV‰‰’Ž‘–ɩZඈOOEHXVHGWKURXJKRXWWKHUHPDඈQGHURIRXU5VHFWඈRQV VRZKHQQHZWRSඈFVRUFRQFHSWVDUඈVHZHZඈOOGRRXUEHVWWRH[SODඈQWKHP +RZHYHUඈI\RXDUHNHHQWROHDUQPRUHDERXW‰‰’Ž‘–ɩZHKඈJKO\UHFRPPHQGWKH5*UDSKඈFV&RRNERRN KWWSZZZFRRNERRNUFRP*UDSKV DVDQHQWU\OHYHOWXWRUඈDO

0DNඈQJXVHRI5VFUඈSWV

$V\RX¶YHSURJUHVVHGWKURXJKWKHඈQWURGXFWRU\VHVVඈRQDQGDVOඈJKWO\PRUHDGYDQFHGORRNDWKDQGOඈQJGDWDඈQ 5\RX¶YHQRGRXEWJRWWHQDOඈWWOHIHGXSZඈWKUHSHDWHGO\W\SඈQJRXWFRPPDQGOඈQHඈQVWUXFWඈRQVIRU5<RXPඈJKW EH TXඈWHUඈJKWO\ WKඈQNඈQJWR\RXUVHOIWKDWWKHUHPXVWEHDEHWWHUZD\WRGRWKඈV"6XUHO\ඈWඈVQ¶WQHFHVVDU\WRZUඈWH

(35)

  ORQJFRPPDQGVHDFKWඈPH" :HOOWKHUHඈVDPXFKEHWWHUZD\\RXFDQZUඈWHDVFUඈSW6FUඈSWVDUHXVHGඈQ5DQGPDQ\RWKHUSURJUDPPඈQJ ODQJXDJHVDVDPHDQVRIVDYඈQJ\RXUFRGHDQGUHFRUGඈQJZKDWඈWඈV\RXKDYHGRQH7KH\DUHDUJXDEO\RQHRI WKHPRVWHVVHQWඈDODVSHFWVRISURJUDPPඈQJDQGEඈRඈQIRUPDWඈFV,QGHHGDSURSHUO\ZUඈWWHQVFUඈSWFDQEHXVHGඈQ DVඈPඈODUPDQQHUWRDVWDQGDORQHSURJUDP<RXVඈPSO\SOXJඈQ\RXUGDWDUXQWKHVFUඈSWDQGOHWඈWRXWSXW\RXU DQDO\VඈV 6R\RXPඈJKWDVNඈIVFUඈSWVDUHVRඈPSRUWDQWZK\RQHDUWKGඈGQ¶WZHWHDFK\RXDERXWWKHPUඈJKWDWWKHVWDUWRI DOORIWKඈV":HOOIඈUVWO\ZHZDQWHGWRGHOYHUඈJKWඈQWR5DQGVKRZ\RXZKDWඈVSRVVඈEOH$OVRUHSHDWHGO\W\SඈQJ RXWFRPPDQGVFDQEHDJRRGZD\WROHDUQWKHEDVඈFV0RVWRIDOOWKRXJKඈWVKRXOGEHDURXQGWKඈVSRඈQWඈQWKH WXWRUඈDOWKDW\RXUHDOඈVHWKHYDOXHRIXVඈQJDVFUඈSW<RXKDYHOHDUQHGWRFUHDWHPRUHDQGPRUHFRPSOH[GDWD VWUXFWXUHVYඈVXDOඈVHDQGSORWWKඈVGDWDDQGDOVRWRDSSO\VRPHEDVඈFIXQFWඈRQV ,WPඈJKWEHKHOSIXOWRWKඈQNRIDVFUඈSWDVDVWHSE\VWHSJXඈGHRIZKDW\RXDUHGRඈQJඈQ\RXUDQDO\VඈV7KඈVඈV DFWXDOO\KRZZHSUඈPDUඈO\XVHWKHPඈQ5ZKHQGRඈQJDQDQDO\VඈVIRUWKHIඈUVWWඈPH7\SඈFDOO\ZHZRXOGZRUNZඈWK DQRSHQVFUඈSWGRFXPHQWDQGWKHQW\SHRXUFRPPDQGVඈQWRඈWHGඈWඈQJඈWDORQJWKHZD\7KHඈGHDඈVWKDWZKHQ ZHUHRSHQWKHVFUඈSWDJDඈQඈQDIHZGD\VWඈPHZHFDQXVHඈWWRNHHSWUDFNRIRXUSURJUHVVDQGUHSHUIRUPRXU DQDO\VඈV 7KHUHDUHQRVWUඈFWUXOHVIRUZUඈWඈQJDVFUඈSWGඈIIHUHQWSHRSOHKDYHGඈIIHUHQWVW\OHV:HZඈOOWHDFK\RXRXUVEXW EHDZDUHWKHUHDUHPDQ\GඈIIHUHQWRSඈQඈRQVRXWWKHUH%HFDXVHRIWKHGඈYHUVඈW\ඈQVFUඈSWZUඈWඈQJZHZඈOOQRWWU\ DQGHQIRUFHDVSHFඈIඈFSUDFWඈFHKHUH+RZHYHUZHVWURQJO\VXJJHVWRQHඈPSRUWDQWUXOHWKDW\RXVKRXOGWU\\RXU EHVWWRIROORZNHHS\RXUVFUඈSWVFOHDUDQGVHOIH[SODQDWRU\:HFDQQRWWHOO\RXWKHDPRXQWRIWඈPHZHKDYH ZDVWHGRSHQඈQJROGVFUඈSWV RIRXURZQ DIWHUVRPHWඈPHDZD\IURPDQDQDO\VඈVWKDWDUHFRPSOHWHO\ ඈQFRPSUHKHQVඈEOH:HPඈJKWKDYHZUඈWWHQWKHPEXWXQGHUVWDQGඈQJWKHPඈVOඈNHGHFRGඈQJWKH9R\QඈFK 0DQXVFUඈSW KWWSVHQZඈNඈSHGඈDRUJZඈNඈ9R\QඈFKBPDQXVFUඈSW RUVRPHDQFඈHQWORVWODQJXDJH ,WඈVPXFKPXFKPRUHVDWඈVI\ඈQJDQGWඈPHHIIඈFඈHQWZKHQ\RXZUඈWHDVFUඈSWWKDW\RXFDQUHXVHHDVඈO\TXඈFNO\ DQGZඈWKRXWHIIRUW3HUKDSVDFROOHDJXHXSGDWHV\RXUGDWDVHWRUDUHYඈHZHUDVNV\RXWRUHSHUIRUPDQDQDO\VඈV ZඈWKDFDUHIXOO\ZUඈWWHQVFUඈSW\RXFDQUHGRWKDWDQDO\VඈVTXඈFNO\DQGZඈWKPඈQඈPXPIXVV

:KHUHWRZUඈWHVFUඈSWV

,I\RX¶YHZRUNHGWKඈVIDUWKURXJKWKHWXWRUඈDO\RXPඈJKWKDYHDOUHDG\EHHQNHHSඈQJVQඈSSHWVRIFRGHඈQDWH[W IඈOH,IVRWKඈVඈVDEDVඈFIRUPRIVFUඈSWඈQJ5VFUඈSWVDUHHVVHQWඈDOO\WH[WIඈOHVEXWWKH\KDYHWKHŜH[WHQVඈRQ 7KඈVPHDQVWKDWඈI\RXXVHDWH[WHGඈWRU ඈHH[WHUQDOWR–—†‹‘ \RXFDQZUඈWHDVFUඈSWDOO\RXQHHGWRGRඈV

VDYHඈWZඈWKWKHŜH[WHQVඈRQ6RPHHGඈWRUVVXFKDV–‘DQG‡š–”ƒ‰Ž‡”ZඈOODOVRKDYHV\QWD[

KඈJKOඈJKWඈQJIRU5VFUඈSWVඈHWKH\FRORXUWKHVFUඈSWWRVKRZREMHFWVIXQFWඈRQVDQGVRRQ 7RPDNHWKඈQJVPRUHVWUDඈJKWIRUZDUGKHUHDQGWRWDNHDGYDQWDJHRIVRPHXVHIXO5VSHFඈIඈFIHDWXUHVZHZඈOO XVHWKHVFUඈSWHGඈWRUඈQ•–—†‹‘7RRSHQXSDVFUඈSW\RXFDQJRWRWKHKHDGHUPHQXDQGVHOHFW ‹Ž‡ʴ‡™ ‹Ž‡ʴ…”‹’–7KඈVZඈOORSHQXSDEODQNZඈQGRZඈQWKH•–—†‹‘FRQVROHWKඈVඈVDQඈQEXඈOW WH[WHGඈWRUIRU\RXWRZUඈWH\RXUVFUඈSWඈQ /HW¶VZUඈWHDQ5FRPPDQGඈQWRRXUVFUඈSWDQGWKHQUXQඈWඈQWKHFRQVROHWRGHPRQVWUDWHKRZDVFUඈSWZRUNV7U\ WKHIROORZඈQJ •‡“ſɨřɨɥɥɥřɨƀ 1RZZඈWK\RXU5VFUඈSWRSHQ\RXFDQSODFH\RXUFXUVRURQWKHOඈQHKHUHKඈW†ʫ–‡” 0DF RU –”Žʫ–‡” 3& 7KඈVZඈOOUXQ\RXU5FRPPDQGඈQWKHFRQVROHDQG\RXVKRXOGVHHWKDW\RXJHQHUDWHGD YHFWRURIQXPEHUVIURP\RXUVFUඈSW6ඈPSOH<RX¶OODOVRQRWඈFHWKHV\QWD[KඈJKOඈJKWඈQJKHUHWKHQXPEHUVZඈWKඈQ WKH•‡“FRPPDQGVKRXOGEHDGඈIIHUHQWFRORXUඈQGඈFDWඈQJWKH\DUHQXPHUඈFYDUඈDEOHV

(36)

 

6RPHXVHIXOVFUඈSWඈQJWඈSV

$JRRGJHQHUDOVWUXFWXUHIRUDQ5VFUඈSWඈVWRVWDUWZඈWKDVඈQJOHFRPPDQGWRFOHDUWKH5HQYඈURQPHQWDQG SUHYHQWDQ\FRQIOඈFWZඈWKH[ඈVWඈQJSDFNDJHVRUQDPHGREMHFWV:HXVXDOO\VWDUWDOORXU5VFUඈSWVZඈWK ”ſŽ‹•–ʰŽ•ſƀƀ 7KඈVZඈOOUHPRYHHYHU\WKඈQJඈQ\RXUHQYඈURQPHQWඈHREMHFWVGDWDHWF+RZHYHUSDFNDJHVZඈOOUHPDඈQORDGHG 1H[WZHPඈJKWKDYHDVHFWඈRQRIWKHVFUඈSWIRUORDGඈQJSDFNDJHV7KඈVHVVHQWඈDOO\ඈQඈWඈDWHVRXUVFUඈSWDQGOHWVXV NQRZKRZZHDUHVHWWඈQJXSWKHZRUNඈQJHQYඈURQPHQW Ž‹„”ƒ”›ſ–‹†›˜‡”•‡ƀ Ž‹„”ƒ”›ſƀ :HPඈJKWWKHQUHDGඈQVRPHGDWD RUDFFHVVඈWIURPWKHHQYඈURQPHQW DQGSHUIRUPRXUDQDO\VHV,QWKHQH[W VHFWඈRQZHZඈOOZUඈWHDVPDOOGHPRVFUඈSWWRJHWKHUEXWEHIRUHZHGRVRඈWඈVඈPSRUWDQWWRඈQWURGXFH\RXWR FRPPHQWV<RXFDQDGGFRPPHQWVWRDQ5VFUඈSWE\SUHIDFඈQJ\RXUFRGHZඈWKDɤ7KඈVEDVඈFDOO\DOORZV\RX WRZUඈWHWH[WWKDWZඈOOQRWEHඈQWHUSUHWHGE\WKH5FRQVROH)RUH[DPSOH ɪ‰‡‡”ƒ–‡ƒ˜‡…–‘”‘ˆ—„‡”• •‡“ſɨřɨɥɥɥřɨƀ +HUHZHFDQXVHFRPPHQWVWRHVVHQWඈDOO\DQQRWDWHRXUFRGH7KඈVඈVDQH[WUHPHO\XVHIXOIHDWXUHWKDWPDNHVඈW PXFKPXFKHDVඈHUWRUHDGDQGඈQWHUSUHWDVFUඈSW$IWHUDOODVSURIඈFඈHQWඈQ5DV\RXPඈJKWEHFRPHඈWඈVQRW H[DFWO\WKHVRUWRIODQJXDJH\RXFDQMXVWUHDGHDVඈO\&RPPHQWVDUHZKDWZඈOOKHOS\RXQDYඈJDWH\RXUDQDO\VHV DQGKHOS\RXUHPHPEHUZK\\RXGඈGZKDW\RXGඈG$JRRGUXOHRIWKXPEIRUZUඈWඈQJFRPPHQWVඈVWRඈPDJඈQH \RXDUHWU\ඈQJWRDQQRWDWHWKHVFUඈSWIRUVRPHRQHHOVHWRXVH7KඈVඈVDFWXDOO\DSUHWW\JRRGWKඈQJWRDඈPIRU VඈQFHRQFH\RXEHFRPHDGHSWDWVFUඈSWඈQJDQG5FRGඈQJ\RXPD\ZHOOQHHGWRZUඈWHVFUඈSWVIRURWKHUVZKRDVN IRU\RXUKHOS*RRGFRPPHQWVZඈOOKHOSWKHPQDYඈJDWHWKHVFUඈSWWRRDQGPDNH\RXUOඈIHDORWHDVඈHU

$VඈPSOHVFUඈSWH[DPSOH

1RZWKDWZHKDYHDQඈGHDRIKRZVFUඈSWඈQJZRUNVZHFDQWU\ZUඈWඈQJDVඈPSOHVFUඈSWWRJHWKHU7KHIROORZඈQJ FRGHඈVDYHU\VKRUWH[DPSOHRIKRZZHPඈJKWFRPEඈQHVRPHRIWKHWKඈQJVZHKDYHOHDUQHGඈQWKඈVWXWRUඈDOඈQWR DVඈQJOHVFUඈSWWKDWPDNHVඈWFOHDUZKDWZHDUHGRඈQJZඈWKRXUDQDO\VHVDQGGDWDPDQඈSXODWඈRQ:H¶OOUHWXUQWR WKH6WDU:DUVGDWDDQGSORWWKHKHඈJKWDQGPDVVUHODWඈRQVKඈSZHGඈGSUHYඈRXVO\

(37)

  ɪɪɪ•‹’އ•…”‹’––‘ˆ‹Ž–‡”ƒ†’Ž‘––Ї•–ƒ”™ƒ”•†ƒ–ƒɪɪɪ ”ſŽ‹•–ʰŽ•ſƀƀ ɪŽ‘ƒ†’ƒ…ƒ‰‡• Ž‹„”ƒ”›ſ–‹†›˜‡”•‡ƀ ɪŽ‘ƒ†–Ї•–ƒ”™ƒ”•†ƒ–ƒ †ƒ–ƒſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ƀ ɪ”‡‘˜‡ ƒ„„ƒ •–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩʳވ‹Ž–‡”ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•řƒ‡Šʰɑ ƒ„„ƒ‡•‹Ž‹Œ‹…‹—”‡ɑƀ ɪ…”‡ƒ–‡ƒЇ‹‰Š–ŵƒ•••…ƒ––‡”’Ž‘– ƒʳމ‰’Ž‘–ſ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɩřƒ‡•ſЇ‹‰Š–řƒ••ƀƀ ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ’‘‹–ſ…‘Ž‘—”ʰɑ”‡†ɑƀ ƒʳރʫ‰‡‘ɏ•‘‘–Šſ‡–Š‘†ʰŽř•‡ʰ ƀ ƒʳރʫ–Ї‡ɏŽ‹‰Š–ſƀʫ‰‰–‹–އſɑ ‡‹‰Š–˜•ƒ••‹–ƒ”ƒ”•ɑƀ ƒ ɪ™”‹–‡‘—––Ї’Ž‘–ƒ•ƒ’†ˆ ‰‰•ƒ˜‡ſɑŜŵ•–ƒ”™ƒ”•ɏЇ‹‰Š–ɏƒ••Ŝ’†ˆɑř’Ž‘–ʰŽƒ•–ɏ’Ž‘–ſƀř†‡˜‹…‡ʰɑ’†ˆɑƀ 6RDOOZHGඈGKHUHඈV VHWXSRXU5HQYඈURQPHQW UHDGඈQDQGPDQඈSXODWHGRXUGDWD FUHDWHGRXUSORW ZURWHRXUSORWWRDQRXWSXW ,IZHZDQWHGWRUHSHDWWKඈVDQDO\VඈVDJDඈQDOOZHQHHGWRGRඈVUXQWKHVFUඈSW:HFDQFKDQJHWKඈQJVOඈNHWKH GDWDZHUHDGඈQEXWWKඈVVFUඈSWSURYඈGHVDJRRGJHQHUDOWHPSODWHIRUKRZZHPඈJKWVWDUWWRPDNHDVWDQGDORQH DQDO\VඈVVFUඈSWWKDWZHFDQUHXVHIRUGඈIIHUHQWSXUSRVHV,W¶VඈPSRUWDQWWRNHHSඈQPඈQGWKDWWKඈVඈVRQO\WKH EDVඈFVRIVFUඈSWඈQJ,WඈVSRVVඈEOHWRPDNH5VFUඈSWVWKDWDUHDFWXDOO\VWDQGDORQHSURJUDPVWKDW\RXFDQUXQIURP WKHFRPPDQGOඈQHIRUH[DPSOH+RZHYHUIURPQRZRQ\RXVKRXOGWU\IROORZඈQJWKHWXWRUඈDOVE\PDNඈQJ\RXU RZQVFUඈSWVDORQJVඈGHWKHP

*RඈQJIXUWKHU

$VQRUPDO5KDVDKXJHUDQJHRIIUHHO\DYDඈODEOHUHVRXUFHVRQOඈQHWKDWFDQKHOS\RXOHDUQPRUHDERXWGDWD PDQඈSXODWඈRQWKHWඈG\YHUVHJJSORWDQGVFUඈSWඈQJ+HUHZHSRඈQW\RXWRDIHZEHORZWKDW\RXPඈJKWEH ඈQWHUHVWHGඈQ 'DWDFDPSKDVDQIUHHඈQWURGXFWඈRQWRXVඈQJWඈG\YHUVHSDFNDJHVWRPDQඈSXODWHGDWD KWWSVZZZGDWDFDPSFRPFRXUVHVඈQWURGXFWඈRQWRWKHWඈG\YHUVH +DGOH\:ඈFNKDP *DUUHWW*UROHPXQGKDYHZUඈWWHQWKHGHIඈQඈWඈYHIUHHO\DYDඈODEOHRQOඈQHERRNRQXVඈQJ 5IRUGDWDPDQඈSXODWඈRQWKඈVඈVWKHµEඈEOH¶RIWKHWඈG\YHUVHDSSURDFKDQGඈQFOXGHVDVHFWඈRQRQJJSORW KWWSUGVKDGFRQ] 7KHUHඈVDOVRD'DWDFDPSFRXUVHRQJJSRW KWWSVZZZGDWDFDPSFRPFRXUVHVGDWDYඈVXDOඈ]DWඈRQZඈWK JJSORW"WDSBD GFHI WDSBV FIF

:ඈQVWRQ&KDQJ¶V5*UDSKඈF¶V&RRNERRNඈVDOVRDQH[FHOOHQWUHVRXUFHIRUXVඈQJJJSORWIRUGDWD YඈVXDOඈVDWඈRQ KWWSZZZFRRNERRNUFRP

$GHWDඈOHGVRIWZDUHFDUSHQWU\JXඈGHWR5VFUඈSWඈQJ KWWSVVZFDUSHQWU\JඈWKXEඈRUQRYඈFH ඈQIODPPDWඈRQEHVWSUDFWඈFHV5

Referanslar

Benzer Belgeler

The results of poverty depth (0.34) among the sampled respondents implied that an average poor respondent needed 34.0% of the specified minimum bench mark (for each

DQG WR GLVFXVV WKH DGYDQWDJHV RI WKLV WHFKQLTXH LQ

FRPPDQG DQG RQERDUG GDWD KDQGOLQJ XVLQJ D &amp;276. PLFURFRQWUROOHU WR PDQDJH WR

DUH XVHG LQ WKH DOLJQPHQW 7KLV SDUDPHWHUVSHFLILHVKRZPDQ\'HFUHDVHIRUVSHHGLQFUHDVHIRUVHQVLWLYLW\ :LQGRZ6L]H 7KLV LV WKH QXPEHU RI GLDJRQDOV DURXQG HDFK RI WKH EHVW GLDJRQDOV WKDW ZLOO

41 Şekil 7: Gruplardaki endotel VEGF immünhistokimyasal boyanma değerleri…...43 Şekil 8: Gruplardaki neovaskülarizasyon alanlarının tüm kornea alanına

Çizelge 4.5 Sarı su örneği için metal iyonları konsantrasyonlarına bağlı olarak fazlar arasındaki ilişkiyi gösteren faktör skor

For the most effective antibiotic removal by the Fenton reagent 25 mg/L Fe(II) and nearly 60 mg/L antibiotic concentrations are the optimum dosages.. Percent antibiotic

The findings of this study revealed that in order to raise psychological resilience of healthcare professionals working during the COVID-19 pandemic their qual- ity of sleep,