• Sonuç bulunamadı

Perfumes and policies – a 'Syrian bottle' from Kinet Höyük and Anatolian trade patterns in the advanced Third Millennium BC

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Perfumes and policies – a 'Syrian bottle' from Kinet Höyük and Anatolian trade patterns in the advanced Third Millennium BC"

Copied!
9
0
0

Yükleniyor.... (view fulltext now)

Tam metin

(1)

' Lg' g 661 raur.{cBqcs/euqc?qcs t 'LE-7E '996t lnflz1 i'plQl q 'Enl-Dil'166I s^ou s '1002 ssnrd i9661 reuqceqcspouqceqcs :166I e^o1 JC, 'I 'td :9-I 's?r7 2y-trp'666t orufl g 'St-Zn i6E'666t erug igg-yg it€'9861 }nflzg

, prru e1iloq lrglln{I roJ Suurdsul pue pue 'suorssncsp ueg ol uoslcooJ zse?lC Eurredsrd rog 's8ur,r.erp eql

1M9I{ leuD1 eq1 qsrlqnd ol uorssrrrJed eru Eurlr8 JoJ se1e9 e$orJueH-er&IAI JoJd ol pelqopur rrre I '€JBIUV ',$lsre,rrun rue>lllg I '(erdns) .&olsrq eEy ezuorg ,(lreg ul e1el elsp eq Nntu selnoq ped?qs -uo4s?q€l? Jo -pro^o l3g1 uo4decJod eql qllA,r IIe 4. elpb eJoru ecuo seprcuroc lesse^ eqtr Jo uoqrsod lecqdurEpens eqJ 'e{olus wo{ {celq pel$olu sr ec€Jrns s}r 6Je{"1 ilrrnqrm rrB uro{J srue}s ule{ sq} qEnoq}lv 'qsnilnq Iuensd }qEgs e s€q eceJrns scel$oq erlJ '(I'I 'EIc) €cnu prre JFqc esreoc gllm peJedruetr 'urtrorq-qsp(erE sr crJqsJ sll '?rlol?uv ruels€fl {tnog ur ecurlord.(epg 'lo,{Ugq 5pdgg 1eU1;1 1e le^el gg }se}el .(geco1 eq} ol pauErsse 1xeluoc € rlr prmoJ seryl ed,$ uo4s€qep-pro^o eqlJo .elilog u?lJ,(s, p?lul ue t00(, f1n1 u1 'rseuoluelur eAeJE peqm5ryun ol queql slxeluoc I€Jeurg ur pe$e$€ sr EurddelJeAo lerodurel ur€uec e JeAeA\oH'II-€I sJefel ut luurJel ruroynd oql ,(q pe/y\olloJ 91 re,(e1 JoJ cllsrrelc€rerlc sl ed,q rulnqolE eql :euorldumsse sql errord ol sruees edellry w ecuenbes lecrqder8lrcRs Jreql 'sslxoluoc cqseruop ut Neel w '(V-Z ed,{1enog) s1xeluoc-Ill rn pue crlseu{C,(peg o1eT ruo4 el$oq pedeqs-prolo eql sepecerd (etn ed,fi e.rro5) rueFea repqolE crlseu(q f,lmA eql lsql ruees plno{\ }I 'ossru4 'iI pu€ reuqc€qcs 'Vl'S 'e,ro5 'g dq peqsqqnd ueeq oasrl ,ffio1od,$ rleql uo

selpn1s pell"teq 'prolo peqcler5

ro plnqolE pegenbs olw

pepplp .{gEnor eq uec

edeqs rleql '€eleclpq dpeelc

Ferre) um.reyedelm) ut slxeluoc-1 eEy ezrrorg elpplntr uro4t leeg Eu1pru1ord pue $lceu /r\orreu rlil/rr sel$oq w 'Jg rrmuuapur

puz pecuulp€ penu4uoc sr eql q pue dpee

saploq ed,$ .uelilS, Jo uoqcnpord eql 'rsgodrur IBer roJ e8urg 1sourue6seguoN eql 'Brcopedde3 rue5eg ur ede1111;1 sB rBJ su prmoJ eg ol sol$oq uelilS leurErro Wuvr '(sprelruo Jg 00S'Z ulo{I ,{gEnor) slxetuoc-m Vgg m peqgrcun eq ol .(lureur 'uqoleuy rne5ee-qmos JeAo ,(p1cmb peerds spodun 'enue1odosetr41 reddn ur pern1c€Jrureu ,(1pu1EFO 'eEV ezuorg ,(peg rrre$€g reeN elBI eql ur sed,$ Iessal Eutn8t4ul pue crlsouEerp Noru eqlJo euo sr 'uru EuueU {tlqEp e pu"

>lcou l\oJJeu 'uo{s €

tOFt rel prorro Jo JelnqolE ezrs-urnlpout ol geurs e '.e1ilog uepfs, or{I tuuDultautwlz s0tltoqJ

cfl urnluueruru

prlrll peruBApv

eql ur

surellBd epBJI

usrloluuy puu

{n,(gH laulx

ruo4 eelllofl

uBIrfS, y

- SflIJITOd

11NV SflI

Indgfld

9OOZ.XXX Vf,ITOIVNV

(2)

r62

T. ZIMMERMANN

The multi period site Kinet Hdyiik, identified as ancient Issos, with an occupation history from the third millennium BC until the Medieval ages, was of both strategic and economical importance throughout the ages due to its location at the Gulf of Iskender*8. It is thus not surprising that this settlement was involved in medium-range trade activities in the late third millennium BC, linking the North of Mesopotamia with the South East of modern Turkey. A large and still growing group of EBA sites in the South Eastern

provinces of Anatolia yielded bottles of the 'Synan' typrn, the recent example from Kinet

Hdyiik testifying once more to the vivid trade and exchange activities in the second half of the third millennium.

As one expects, trafficking goods from the Mesopotamian plains into Anatolia did not stop atthe Taurus foothills, but went far beyond (Fig. 3). When we survey the rest of EBA Anatolia for further evidence, we come across the phenomenon that further North and Northwest no real imports from North Syria/I.{orth Mesopotamia but locally produced copies are recorded. In South Eastern Anatolian settlements imported bottles are found

together with locally made 'syrian' potterylO.

Further North East there is up to now only one isolated findspot. The settlement of Sos Hdyiik near modern Erzurum yielded a black polished Syrian bottle discovered in a

pit containing material of the 'Transcaucasian' phase, hence datable to the late third

millennium BCll.

The Westernmost distribution area where 'real' imports are amongst the bottles of

'Syrian' type could be roughly described as Central or South Central Anatolia. Besides

Kiiltepe in Eastern Cappadocia bottles of the alabastron typel2 are known from Aligar

Httytik and Kestel/Gdltepet3. A silver derivative stems from a hoard excavated in the EBA

8

For recent reports on this site see Gates 1999; Gates 2003; Gates 2004.

9

Syri- bottles in Anatolia, both imported and locally manufactured, are known from Arslantepe (Conti 1993,386;377

ftg. 12,4.12); Noriuntepe (Hauptmann 1969170, 53; fig. 12,9), Lidar Hdyiik (Mellink 1982, Pl. 73,7; lbid 1983, Pl.

58,8; both from burial context), Ziryirli (Andrae 1943, Pl. 26g,k), Gedikli (Alkm/Alkrm 1966, Fig. 32 (right side);

Alkm 1979, 140; Pl. 91,26.27), Kurban Htiyiik (Algaze 1990, Pl. 133 G(?).H.I; Pl. 149,D), Tilmen Hdyuk (Alkrm

1964, 174; frg.26), Karkemiq (Woolley l92l,Pl.27,cl from "Middle Hittite burial" with protruding foot), Titriq

Htiyuk (Algazellvfisrr/Wilkinson 1992,38:.56 Fig. 11) and Oylum H<iyiik (OzgenAlelwing/Tekin 1997, 60-72; Fig.

13,2.3; 73 frg. 74,5; 74 fig. 15,2.3.5.7; 75 fig. 16,6-8). Recent examples were unearthed in Tilbeshar

(Kepinski-Lecomte 2000,220-222 frg.7; 9 from both domestic and funeral contexts) and Gre Virike (Okse/Bucak 2002, 153-16l

fie. 10). l0

Th*k, to their characteristic fabric Mesopotamian imports can be easily identified and distinguished from copied

vessels (Schachner/Schachner 1995, 88).

tl

Sugonu et al. 1996, 37; 44fig. 10,9.

t'Cf.

S.hu"hner/Schachner 1995, 9l-93 (Type II); Rova lggl,136.

t3

(3)

'oprslq?rr Lz'?rJgL'1002 'plql Jc ieqoSuoporqll/r\ I's'39 sLl6661-plql lJ EZ 'LZ'AU 9L:29't002 eJi1-NpJA :6 8rJ Ogt !t-I 'S .s8g StI ,6661 eJE zz ' gn-vn'666I erug :Lg's661 reuqc?qcsFeur{ceqcs

IZ :'? 'oN 'e002 relsre{

T,E'9661re$re{/^olrls1o1 igg4 .oN .39 0Zg:lT,9.IggI uu€ruellqcs 0Z .19.9161euqU 6r :ZZil :1lV- 'tUI L1t 'o51 's8g :gOg :VO9 i I tt ,I 88 I uu?ulotgcs

8 r or? po1e^ecxe poqrcsap T,g'Zl uo '8S pu?

sprer.{s ^roJ oql :.ptQt

,, iLZ'tS6I u"3"lg gtl 'td '(gg ed&)

n, €["'],, sua]r reqro rEuoure Burureluoc'prrnq ref e urog,{1sno^qo irlr'Lg6r rumew ",;'tl,rff;l:JJli:fff:l 'I'9I I'ld' Llg'8661 lrlnwe715t?zg ^ .{1e1tugep edeqs osotl/y\ s>lseg peel peur€luoc aEy ezuorg .(peg eq} Jo slermq

I"roAeS osle 41,{grlzog ue pepler.( uorprJsl crloxe oqtr uo .oploq uep,($, 'eluoql

reeu >pdgrppSr_r; pu? le{rr3s->lMoqrcrrruecl Jo srlodorceu eq} ?qonilu Jo }se ^,quou }lq v 'rr(z' t 'Elg) ^(or1 Vgfl ruor;

.selnoq uep,(g, pue edeqs selqrueser clrqeJ.(gercedse eql IIo/Y\,(p1eg

IIereAo'ozls 'z1nl1\lo1 edeqs

.uep,(g, 'pelueuEe4 pecnpord .(1uco1 Jo sontoq

3o reqrunu e lqEnorq

eqonlln)

Jo lueluoples srql 'eqopuy sluoos /yrou eQ o1 suolleA"cxg :elqtssod oql }e

I"4ueJ ruo6ed[ 'ure1d rqeSqsg eql q suotleE4selur lueceJ ol s{uer{J 'urlotr"uv;o se8uu3r }sourrrre}sel[

WroN sll sl soAIleAIJop Iucol eql q4zll

l€q1 ',eploq ueu.(g, oql Jo euoz uortrnqr4srp rrerlo]Buv Ie4ue3 pue tuels€g qlnos oql {uil ol cq€ruelqord elrnb s"/v\ U f1}uecer 11lun ',.Cfl runluuollru puocos.(pee eql ol pJIril ppu erp ruo4 Eurpuelxe edfl lossel slql Jo s8uer pcr8olouoJt{c umtuF€ul eql gll/r,l eprcuroc plno^ . eurry pue uuetue{qcs dq peuolluetu soliloq Je$el eril 'surral pcrqderElp4s w seuo elq€r1eJ lsotu eql era uoISSru llsclroruv aql fq peqsqqnd spreqs eq1 qEnoqllV '0.E1 ,(or; [e^el o1 peuErss€ eq o1f1e>1q dUE1q ',eJnseo4 s.tuslJd, s" u 4,ou{ Je$eq',y, ernble4 pepqep,{1toq pue snoureJ qfoq oql IuoU {seg ueploE eq1 fq pelueserdor sr ed,{1 lessel sn{l 3o gedre}unoc

I"}eru ,(11eco1 uell(s, epetu uelo .ep}oq ,(or; o} or{I 'orA

euo peuErsse eurm) .H .r,lueuleliles qilnoJ orll ruou seploq peqsqod {celq eJoru orvrl .f1rc }urnq prlrp,, eql uro4 spreqs seplseq peuolluetu osle uu"rue${cs 'H 'rrIII ,,(or; go srs,(e1 oql ol uo4rpedxo rrucrJeuv eqt ,(q pel"A€cxe spreqs rrroJ eql peu8ri-se oq rle 1e ue8elg ,{q paqsqqnd eru souo pelueluncop-lseq erlJ 'ed,q ,u€1ils, Jo $lseu serdoc dlelrugep edeqs slr ,uoplpe4

I"col qEnoqltV 'n,,folJ,;o ur raErel pu€ ezls pemlmJnuelu ,(lsnornqo € w

sre.(e1 eEy ezuorg dpeg eql q sreedde ueEelg 'l['J.,(q..Sg,, peileqel ed,g 1es5eA ueesun ,,(lsnour.erd

pue lreu e '(,for;,

se .,(epol ulKorDI regeq) {rlJesrH punotu oql }e ,lsol11 qiloN orl} ur Jec

rsorrrurelse,v\qlnos

eql srueserde.r

{rr,{srl"re;1-e.(uo11

ruo,l rtii::JTTrlffii,?,*?t]5lfi

E9I SOOZ .IXXX VJI'IOJVNV

(4)

I

I

I

164 T. ZIMMERMANN

copies 'syrian' bottles2a. Although lead vessels are quite a rare phenomenon in EBA

Anatolia, they are n_ot completely unknown, as a neck fragment of a Syrian type bottle

from Tarsus attests2s. Lead itself might have served as an alternative to imitate silver, for

an object like the silver bottle from Eskiyapar (supra) was much more complicated to workt6.

We are unfortunately not informed about the ingredients of these bottles -according to their size one might assume oils or precious perfumes". Whut we indeed can suggest is that the ceramic variants were traded because of what they contained, the value

of the metal flasks from Troy treasure 'A', Demircihciytik-Sarrket,

Ki.igUkhciytik-Bozhdytik and Eskiyapar -a "blueprint" for the ceramic variants- might have come from the material of which they were made.

Concerning how these vessels were transported or stored some interesting information comes from two locally produced 'syrian' bottles from the Early Bronze Age levels of the Karum at Kane5: These two bottles have a shallow relief decoration showing some kind of net bag consisting of interwoven strings highly likely imitating the way

these vessels were usually suspended (Fig. 2,1.2)28 . Since most of our bottles have

rounded bottoms, we have good reason to assume that at least the larger variants of these bottles were usually wrapped into a net bag to carry them or hang them up, like it is assumed for water baglbottle equipment for the Roman foot soldier (Fig. 2,3)'n. To stabilize these vessels with bagel-shaped ground stones as suggested by M. Artzy for similar globular- or piriform-shaped ceramics from Cyprus could be an alternative solution3o.

The distinct intensification of trade activities between the culturally and politically different entities of Northern Mesopotamia with Southem-, Central and North West

Anatolia is best visible in the appearance of 'foreign' or 'exotic' small finds or vessel

types in contexts originally alien to them. Together with the well-known two-handled cup

called 'depos amphilqtpellon', most likely invented in Western Central Anatolia and from

24

Baykal-seeher/Seeher 1998, I l8-l2l fig. l,l-9. The unusually elongated shape of the bottleneck might derive from

the local jug forms (ibid. I 19). tt

Goldrn* 1956,302; Pl. 453, ll; Baykal-Seeher/Seeher 1998, ll7; l2l Il. 1, l0 with exmples from the

Demircihdyiik/Bozdyok necropolis plus lead beak spouted pitchers from Oymaalag and the Sadberk Hanrm museum

(the latter unfortunately lacking an archaeological context (ibid.).

'u

mia. I 17; the complex and diffrcult refinement process called 'cuppelation' where silver is separated from the lead

ores under highly oxidating circumstances wurs obviously known as early as the mid third millennium BC in the

Aegean/Anatolian world (cf. Pernicka 1990; Kohlmeyer 1994; Primas 1995).

'7

cf. Goldrnan 1956,302.

28

Ct.6tgr9 1986, 36 fig. 3:8 (from burial contex t);37 frg.3:13 (from domestic context).

'n

A r"u.onable reconstruction for such a water container is published athttp:llwwr,v.larp.com/l6gioxx/packs.html.

to

(5)

'BI'l I 'Eg 0yT,:16I '2002 ^oletQmf Oe 'LT,'ErJ gL'I0OZ egg-,ty7egg '.ggl '666l rJS

,, zeqr,{4g ees '88I 'S66I

deu uo4nqrlsrp len1ce w rog !9661 re8ueuruo4gTsouedg -' '0t t-tt I :16 '886t egg) ,{org Jo lszg qlnog uot8er € tuo.lJ sollrop -eu4l etu€s eql rc fgtnor sreedde pq1- ed,(1 lessol srql turcnpord rog snledur eql leqt elqlsruld suroos t1 'erlopuy lerlueC ruor; ser,uoc ',(or; ur $eel 1e,fie11odgo 41nq e8nq e JoJ crrqq lerld,{l'enbruqcol teoc per eqt eculs :eJg 'I {q pecnporlur sEAr srseql Surlpuru e i(gg 1966I low4ceqcs4eur1r"qcs :gt 'g461 souudg 3c) eturelodose1A1 uJeqiloN s€ JeJ se pepeJl pue perdoc 'pegodrur ',(or1 ur poluenu peepu su/r\ pJe>Itrul rmls pe1prruq-olrl eql leql pe^olloq ,{1puor1rper1 surrt 1t 'frnluec q}6I olel eql ecurs f,or1 }e pels^ecxe sern edep ;o Joqumu aErel e ecWS , , 'r€elreElng rrJeN"g gmos ur ((63Jessy") onoqel€oJo lueweliles eql Iuo4 {s€U podeqs-uoJ5€qele peilodul,{lsnor.rrqo ne f,q pe1e4snlll Neq ffJ os sr }s?c ere/v\ BIIoleuV IIJe$€g {$og $eel l€ q}l/r\ slc?luoc 6lceJlp, JeJ /v\oq 'pueq Jeg}o oq} uO '€€crrqeJ peqsqod por I€uorllperl oql q pernlceJruI€u '(erdns) eqoRIIIl) pu€ dorl ruo4 saldruexe eqt ere suoplpe4 I€col pue ol,qs 6cl1.oxe, uee $eq op€ru se \ l€ql .osrruoJdruoc, eql qEUqE1q ol eldurexe poo8 V 'uorlelndod pcol eqt ,(q peldop€ oouorqsey Jo reJsrrerl, E sr €qo1euv Fe/v\quoN plre I€J}ueC luelso6 .(le1cedse-plre IErtueJ ul selrl€Arrep I€col eql qll/y\ sseulr/y\ lqEpr o/tr l€qlfi 'leul) e{{ seceld 1e4uac pu? slueruol$es EurmoqqEreu o1 spre \r{ilou pep€D eJet\ srluelodoseny"ufs trro.g seploq FurErJo ',{lEursrrdrns }oN 'zeesJea ecrl /tpcsxe pelecol eJ€ spueleuoq IsulEIJo Jleql JoJ (suor8eJ elorueJ uee/Kleq suorlceuuoc eEueqcxe JOJ Joleclpw pooE Jotlloue eJe .seliloq ueu,(g' ffo "reprelodosal4l s3 J€J w pepe4 eJerll

s9r

SOOZ.IXXX VJITOIVNV

(6)

166 T. ZIMMERMANN

References

Algaze, G', 1990 - Town and Country in Southeastern Anatolia Vol. II - The Stratigraphic Sequence at

Kurban H0yiik. Oriental Institute publications l l0, Chicago.

Algazn, G', Msr, A., Wilkinson, T., Carter, E., Gomy, R., 1gg2- $anhurfa Museum/[Jniversity of Califomia

Excavations and surveys at Titris H6yuk, 1991: A PreliminaryReport, Anatolicaxvlll,:g-ko.

Alktm, 8., 1964 - islahiye B0lgesinde Ttirk Tarihi Kurumu adma lgss-lgl2Yrllal arasmda yaprlan Tarihi

ve Arkeoloj ik Araqtrrmalar. Atattirk Konferanslan I, Ankar a, l 6T17 g .

Alktm, H, 1979 - Gedikli (Karahuytik) Qanak-Q6mle$ine Toplu bir Bakiq. In: VIII. Tiirk Tarihi Kurumu

Kongresi 1976 (1. Qilt), Ankara, t35-142.

Alkrm, U. 8., Alkrm, H., 1966 - Gedikli (Karahoyiik) Kazrsr Birinci On-Rapor. Excavations at Gedikli

(Karah6yiik). First Preliminary - Report, Belleten30, l-57.

Andrae, W., 1943 - Die Kleinfunde von Sendschirli. Ausgrabungen in Sendschirli V. Mitteilungen aus den

orientalischen Sammlungen Heft 20, Berlin.

Artry,M., 1982 - Vessel Stabilizing Stones, Report of the Department of Antiquities Cyprus,37-3g.

Baykal-Seeher, A., Seeher, J, 1998 - Gefti8e aus Blei in der Friihen BronzezeitAnatoliens. In: Arsebiik, G.,

Mellink, M.J., Schirmer, W. (Eds.), Light on the Top of the Black Hill. Studies presented to Halet

Qambel, Istanbul, ll5-121.

Blegen, C. w., Caskey, J. L., Rawson, M., l95l - Troy II. The Third, Fourth and Fifth Settlements, princeton.

Conti, A. M., 1993 - Part I: Chronology of the Malatya-Elazrp Area.In: Conti, A. M., persiani, C., When

Worlds Collide: Cultural Developments in Eastern Anatolia in the Early Bronze Age. In: Frangipane,

M', Hauptmann, H., Liverani, M., Matthiae, P., Mellink, M. (Eds.), Between the Rivers and Over the

Mountains - Archaeologica Anatolica et Mesopotamica Alba Palnieri Dedicata, Rome, 362-3g7.

Efe, T. 1988 - DemircihdyUk III, 2.Die Keramik 2,Mainz.

Efe, T., 1999 - Kiilliioba 1997 YrhKazsr. XX. Kazr Sonuglarr Toplantrsr I, Ankara, 165-1g1.

Efe, T., Ay-Efe, D.$., 2001 - Kiilliioba: Ig Kuzeybatr Anadolu'da Bir Ilk Tung Qagr Kenti. 1996-2000

Yrllarr arasrnda Yaprlan Kazr Qahgmalan Genel De[erlendirm esi. TUBA-AR (Turkish Academy of

Sciences Journal of Archaeologt) 4,43-79.

Emre, K', 1999 - Syrian Bottles from the Karum of Kanish. In: H.I.H Prince Takahito Mikasa (Ed.), Essays

on Ancient Anatolia. Bulletin of the Middle Eastern Culture Center in Japan 11, Wiesbaaen,

:g-SO.

Gates, M.-H., 1999 - Kinet Hoyiik in Eastern Cilicia: A Case Study for Acculturation in Ancient Harbours.

In: OLBA II. I. Uluslararasr Kilikia Arkeolojisi Sempozyumu Bildirileri, Mersin,30!312.

Gates, M.-H., 2003 - 2001 Season at Kinet Htiyuk (Yegil-D<irtyol, Hatay). XXIV. Kazr Sonuglarr

Toplanfi sr, Ankara, 283-298.

Gates, M.-H., 2004 - 2002 Season at Kinet Hoytik (Yegil-Dcirtyol, Hatay). XXV. Kazr Sonuglarr Toplantrsr,

Ankara, 405-416.

Goldman, H., 1956 -Excavations at Gdzliikule, Tarsus Vol. II. From the Neolithic through the Bronze Age,

Princeton.

Hauptmann, H. 1969170 - Norgun Tep_e, Historische Geographie und Ergebnisse der Grabungen 196g/69,

Istanbuler Mitteilungen 19 120, 2l -7 t.

Htiryrlmaz,H', 1995 - Usak Arkeoloji Muzesinden bir Grup "Depas Amphikypellon". In: Erkanal, A.,

Erkanal, H., Hiiryrlmaz, H. (Eds.), In Memoriam i. Metin Akyurt, gahauin Devam. Studien iiber alte

vorderasiatische Kulturen, Istanbul, 177-l gg.

Kepinski-Lecomte, Ch., Ergeg, R., 2000 - Tilbeshar 1999. Occupations

de lflVale6 au Sajour de la Fin du

chalcolithique au Bronze Moyen, Anatolia Antiqua g,2r5-22s.

Kohlmeyer,K', 1994 - Zur frtihen Geschichte von Blei und Silber. In: Wartke, R.-8. (Ed.), Handwerk und

Technologie im Alten orient. Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der Technik im Altertum. Ini. Tagung Berlin

(7)

'ggr-LLr'eruluy 'rsr1ue1do1 uelSnuog Ee) 'IAX 'rrey5nuog lze>l t66r edeqgg - 966r ''y ,rouea 'uopuoT 'secuageq u 4.oJ eqJ - JI rlsrueqor?J - IZ6l ,.1 .,{e11oo16 ' gsz-

s vz'qcuqurug-uepl?r{sueu "g 'rezrerrrqJs (IuumqJ, '( 'rcqcsrenel^I '('spg) Jr-u urJrlcslsec 'uueugro;1 pegu€I^I

,.c ,l$e) ..s 'uJnlg ''g 'uu1sy :uI 'sernseer1 uufor; eql Jo f8olouorq3 elnlosqv prrc e^nplou er{J - 2007, ,.IN.re1sror1 'rtplry, 'UeEnn1S'seplog-soruelrd sep soqt{ru rep pun uuelllerlr.I3s 'e[or1 src 4eqcs rec - 9661 '('spg) 'f 'ru 're1s[er1 'd 'A1, (^o{rlslol reurrN Jo rnouoH ur sorpqs 'sroqqErep s{ pu? Blroreuv :,(qdefouocl

pue rv;"tfl#J#i;li? 'III u4 rol puesrcuq?f :uI 'snlsul{O 'IAI qmllelAl 'epu.to4 ''l 'lyl?zg ''g

uarurelodoseruproN

rerrKsprop pun uerloleuelse^\pJoN

ueqcsv(z ueSunqerzeg uep nz t66l ,.g ,re8ueururo4g ,'d ,souedS 'ue8uq1g'9'qleg uo8unpeprl4l

relnqustsl 'd,{lssegeg ueluueue8

,uolledK4rqdue sedep, re(uoH req uep raq4 uetrmqcnsJelun - eL6I ,.Z.d.,souedg 'oEecrq3 '61 suo4ecrlqnd emlrlsul leluelro '62il Vm gz6l lo suos?es ninH reqsllv er{J - Zt6l ,.g,}pluqcs '?vdre1'reueforl rep prre.J pun 1p"ts 'solll - IggI ,.H ,uueueqqcg '96-t8'

271 {orqcsllasag ,'v .reuqceqcS - s66I .sqcsu,{s, eqa snu eqcs?ld np uaSunyaww'ulug rua!"to uaq)sruacl

,.$ .;euqceqcS ' T,S- LZ, 9p satpn4g uD t lotauV,godeA

.&eurrurlei;4 '{n(gH sos puoces 's66I

l3 suorl?^scxiJ - 966l '1 'seuroql ''3 '?uoE?s ''IAtr ,ueuqrg ,.y ,euoEeS 'ILI.1L 'uelcruqreeg 'epter16 ut ue8unqe:tsny'61u1prqdng ueqcsu,(s rul 'rqC '^ spuesruuqul 'e sep reqgrO '('spg) 'g 'enog ''11 'uueurqgo :uI 'ploJreqgrD ruep sne >ilru?re) ol0 - 166I ''fl 'enog '6zn'T,lr'ury4uerg leupvna8 uu€urrlilO pel{ll/lyertologqcrv uoqcslt€ls€repro1 rnz e3g4reg ''V 'ssru4 ''IAI '{grroN o'1 're,(e141-a{l€?l\ :uI .e:ul[-eryne anel8 elc - I00Z ..V ,ssru4 't6-LL 'uopuol'uolsog 'lqceJlJoC '937 setrsg ISV OJVN'emlceJnu?htr pue ,{tm1e1e6 'seury41 'edorng q

ploD crrolsrqerd .lBJ .lllw :uI 'Og ''O 'nreegotr41 '1 'reloqgoN '('spA) '4

p,t eql Surmp re^lrs prre ploD - 566I,.141 .s?ruu4 ' 6Zl- IZ' LE zul0w suna snwlp4uaz uaq t suDwhD4p stwoa sap qcnqrLpf \rez roqcslrolslqprd u1 oll€lehtr rep Srmlrorqre1 pun Sunuul^\og - 066I ''g 'e1cnue4 '829-tl9'er?{uv 'dnEzg leuIIN Jo rnouoH uI selpruS 'sroqqEre5l s{ pup €rlo1euv :,(qdurSouocl puu uV

Jo spedsy ''a 'rszrurel - E66l rede,trlsg eqJ :uI 'emseer1 I 5fulllentr 'I 'eperod ''f '5g8z6 ''g '('spg) ';

''; 'in8zg ' LV-lt'ursuocsrTyl ()IqllelN.f plolqc?I Jo rnouoH ut s.{essg 'lueurdoleneq l€rn{nJ pue eEuuq3 go slcedsy '?rloluuv luercuv ,(.spg) 'J 'qcels ''g',(errrEpry opuotusls ''g 'epero4 ''A'f 'fquec :uI'J'g umruuelFl I prlqr eqt Burnp err.{g quoN pu? etloleuv l$eqmos wltr ede11g; go drqsuorlsleu oql uo suollunresqo ^\oN - 9g6l ,'J ,5g326 '06-68' 2p ua8unparilW hpquatsJ 51euo1su4 .U pun z$-I.t uon ueEg4rog llntr

T;r.,(gH ,.g ,EuynleH- .H'upleJ - L66l tqcrreg reEgngl-ron erp reqn Jne ua8unqer8snv un1,,(g ruep

,.a ,ue&z6 'zgI-lsl'€re)luv lsrlueydol rrelSnuog rze) 'IIIXX 'rsrz") 0002 e{l{A erg-rfereg Srure>puy - 7,002..g ,4ecng ..r ,e$le 'ZVV-LZV'pg t8oloaoqctyto lDumof uDcuauv.roulntr elsv q .(Soloeeqcry - €g6I ..141 51uq1e61 '99 r6opanqc"ryto 'qLS-LSS putioS uDilnwv.roulhtr ?rsv u fEoloeeqcry _ 2g61..141 ,4m11e141 'vLI-SgI'12,Eo\oaoqc.ryto lDurnof uD4bwv.roulw slsv q,{Soloeeqctv _ Lg6l,.;41 ,4uq1e141 'S I I-l0I 't96I 'L Dllotauv eelclllJ ur u8redureJ eJo uorte4snlll ue1p?)Hv uV - [96] ,.141 ,4ur11e141 ' llz-I LI .IIIAXX D)llolDuv'srloteuv rlil1!\ eceJqJ reddn ur e8y ozrrora oql Jo uorlesruoJrlcu,(5 mep e pu? ,{rego6 oloqel€g - 2002,.;tr .no>p1qse1 'ulTreg't 'pg 3mgt15 tmequedd6 uol rrelpeJd x€trAI 'rlcsroC oqcsrprserepro1 'berl urep pun

reIrnl rep 'euqsg1e4-ueu.,(5

sne uepund nz ue8unqerzeg oJril pun eJQnrlJ IIoJ uo^ {rrueJe) sle - gL6l ,-H,euq11;tr L9I 9OOZ'IXXX VJI'IOJVNV

(8)

1 6 8 T. ZIMMERMANN

Fig. 1. 1 - "Syrian bottle" from Kinet Hciytik, Hatay, Turkey;

2 - locally manufactured bottle of "Syrian" type from Kiilllioba, Eskigehir, Turkey

(drawing B. C. Coockson; Efe 1999, 175 frg.5,1 (update B. C. Coockson)) (Scale 1:2).

Fig.2. 1.2 - Locally made "syrian bottles" from the Early Bronze Age levels of the Karum Kane5, Kayseri, Turkey; with grooved 'netbag' motives; 3 - reconstruction of a water container

for a Roman foot soldier with a net bag to carry (Ozgtig 1986: fig 3:8 & 3:13;

http : //www. larp. comflegioxx/packs. html) (l : 2 ; - S cale unknown).

(9)

n

c.

g

on F EE 5 33 e, oo og uc i. g r3 - >q 5 E i€ t oc tl t *: o l rt ag EO or c| tt ao > 6' o - r r o0 g

*r

g

I

r* gt 6 o c} ffi p4 Eig x i

ffi

? rTr g t ja ge

ir

r3 FD *

?I

{* "F' F tY v o 6' f-! -.

6'

r;

:t:

f+) jj (A 1i :s ls H. I gIel xt il 5 (D CA d c) o f-t o a SOOZ.IXXX VJI'IOIVNV

69r

Şekil

ftg. 12,4.12);  Noriuntepe (Hauptmann  1969170,  53; fig.  12,9), Lidar Hdyiik (Mellink 1982, Pl
Fig. 1. 1 -  &#34;Syrian bottle&#34; from Kinet Hciytik, Hatay, Turkey;

Referanslar

Benzer Belgeler

International Community can play a major role to promote Peace building process in post conflict areas such as Peace building mission since post war areas directly face

This study contributes to the literature by investigating the importance of travel agency selection factors for undergraduate students from different countries

Moreover in case of economy and economical issues technological modernism has a huge effect. For example when there were no any airplanes or vehicles, the only way of

DÖ14, bu kategoride yer alan son test yanıtında (Şekil 5.22) yapılan fiziksel iş için kuvvet ve yerdeğiştirme kavramları arasında doğru ilişki kurmuş ve fiziksel işi

Odak figür için doğum günü hediyesi olan sarı kır çiçeği, bir başkasının hüznünü anlatmıştır ve Nermin’i hayatın gerçekleriyle yüzleştirmiştir,

In nominal condition on Figure 3, a high percentage of in-cylinder exhaust gas can flow out of the cylinder (mostly through exhaust ports, tiny fraction through

The power capacity of the hybrid diesel-solar PV microgrid will suffice the power demand of Tablas Island until 2021only based on forecast data considering the

Hayranlığın bir de hayrete düşme, şaşırıp kalma derecesi vardır ki, bu hal birdenbire karşılaştığımız ve izah etmeye anlamaya fırsat veya imkân bu