Kamu Hizmetlerinin Görülüş Usullerinden Ruhsat (Lisans, İdari İzin, Yetkilendirme) Yöntemi ve Düzenleyici ve Denetleyici Kurumların Lisans Konusundaki Yetkilerinin Danıştay Kararları Çerçevesinde Değerlendirilmesi

Tam metin

(1)344.

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5) . .$08+ú=0(7/(5ú1ú1*g5h/hû868//(5ú1'(1 58+6$7 /ú6$16ú'$5úú=ú1<(7.ú/(1'ú50(

(6) <g17(0ú9('h=(1/(<ú&ú9('(1(7/(<ú&ú .8580/$5,1/ú6$16.218681'$.ú<(7.ú/(5ú1ú1 '$1,û7$<.$5$5/$5,d(5d(9(6ú1'( '(ø(5/(1'ú5ú/0(6ú /,&(1&( $'0,1,675$7,9(3(50,7$87+25,=$7,21

(7) 0(7+2' 2))8/),//0(172)7+(38%/,&6(59,&(6$1'(9$/8$7,21 2)5(*8/$725<$1'683(59ú625<$87+25,7,(6·32:(56 $%287/,&(1&(:,7+,17+()5$0(:25. 2)7+(67$7(&281&,/·6'(&,6,216. Mesut EROL Özet:

(8)

(9)

(10)

(11)

(12)

(13)

(14)

(15)

(16)

(17)

(18)

(19)

(20)

(21)

(22)

(23)

(24)

(25)

(26)

(27)

(28)

(29)

(30)

(31)

(32) !

(33)

(34)

(35)

(36)

(37) .

(38)

(39)

(40)

(41)

(42) Anahtar Sözcükler:

(43)

(44)

(45)

(46)

(47)

(48) Abstract: " # $ #$$

(49) $

(50)

(51) $

(52) # #

(53) #

(54) #

(55) % #

(56)

(57) $

(58) #

(59)

(60)

(61) & Keywords: '

(62)

(63)

(64)

(65) & . *ú5úû

(66)

(67) . .

(68) !"" # $ %&.

(69) !". $ %&'. 345. '

(70) ' (

(71) '

(72) "

(73) )

(74)

(75)

(76) & *"

(77) + ', % ' & '. % & (

(78)

(79) & & &

(80)

(81)

(82) .

(83) & ' . " % ' +

(84) , & %" 1 .

(85)

(86) "" . '

(87) +

(88) ' "

(89) + ,

(90) ( ', "

(91)

(92) ' % (

(93) '

(94) " "

(95)

(96) .

(97)

(98)

(99)

(100) (

(101) ' . *"

(102)

(103) ( ' '& ' +. , (

(104) + '

(105) +

(106)

(107) , "

(108)

(109) . '. % " ( %" "

(110) . /

(111) 0

(112) %

(113) , "

(114)

(115)

(116) *

(117) ,, & , " +

(118) & " . . 'h=(1/(<ú&ú9('(1(7/(<ú&ú.8580/$5$ *(1(/%ú5%$.,û. .

(119)

(120) %" ,

(121)

(122) +

(123) , '

(124) + %

(125) % '

(126) +

(127) . "

(128)

(129) .

(130) ' "

(131)

(132) -. 1. 2 !

(133)

(134)

(135)

(136)

(137) *34

(138) 5 6 789: ; 7::< 7.

(139) 346.

(140)

(141)

(142)

(143) . + 7 '& .

(144) "

(145)

(146) =:>9

(147) # 2 % # #? "

(148)

(149) ( *"

(150)

(151) ' ' . % "

(152)

(153) ,

(154)

(155)

(156) """ +

(157)

(158) ' < % " "

(159)

(160) .

(161) & & ' , % % , ". 4 ' . '

(162)

(163)

(164) ' '& ". & ' "

(165) .

(166)

(167) & %" = ' %

(168)

(169) "

(170) 8

(171) . ", '& " %" " +

(172) ""

(173) . &

(174) ' & " ' & """ 7 2

(175) ,

(176) . " +"

(177) ' %" " " . 9. 7. <. 4 =. 8. 7 9. ; B( %"'"

(178) " ) 4 4 4 #' ; >CC9 798 ! ! ;

(179) 4 #' > . ; 7::8 <>9 ! ! ;

(180) D& F 4"

(181) G

(182) H ! ; 7::8 I J >K7 78: ;

(183) "#" "! <>9 ! ! ;

(184) DN $ & F /F? 06 P' #

(185) $!% & ' ( & ) *! ; 2 7:::

(186) . 8 =Q S"T * D4"

(187) ? & F H +

(188) #

(189)

(190) ! ;. 2 >CCU I <:

(191) > Q %"'"

(192) " ) 4 "#" "! 79U.

(193) !". $ %&'. 347. *"

(194)

(195) % % , '& "

(196) % 9 , '&

(197) % ' '

(198) . ' ,

(199) % '&

(200) ( >: & '&

(201) """ '& " W ,

(202) . ' ' & "

(203) '

(204)

(205) .

(206) ( 11 *"

(207)

(208) , " %

(209)

(210)

(211)

(212) &. T & "

(213) % % (

(214) """ + "

(215) , ' '" '& . " + '%

(216) ' '

(217) ', ' ' & >7 P"

(218) + "

(219) % %

(220) %" & ' ' &. & '%

(221) T

(222)

(223) %%>< *"

(224)

(225) ' ' % (

(226) '

(227)

(228) .

(229) % ' & ' " % ,

(230) + & ,

(231) '

(232) +

(233)

(234) % ' % 14. 9 >: 11 >7 >< 14. ; G

(235) ,**

(236) .

(237) 4 #' ; 7::< . >= ! "#" "! >77 ;

(238) ,**

(239) .

(240)

(241) /#* 7U: G

(242) ,**

(243) .

(244) 7C G

(245) ,**

(246) .

(247) 79 ; # D0 * 0

(248)

(249) H P' *

(250) 9 =.

(251) 348.

(252)

(253)

(254)

(255) . "

(256)

(257) ( X "

(258)

(259) % '

(260)

(261) .

(262) ,% % *

(263) >< *? , '

(264) X& *

(265) >< * 7=>77::8 !6 7::=)C<U= #67::8)QC>C

(266) "

(267) ' % " % " ' +

(268) %" "

(269) % '

(270) "

(271) +

(272) & % ' & ' >= ;

(273) 2 QU<<

(274) 4"" 4"" 2 4. ; 2"" "&"" + . 4"" 4"" 2 , * ; Q:Q8

(275) # 7<<

(276) # $"" # *& + * #? ' + . , , 1 ! 2

(277) + 3

(278) '

(279) * !

(280) 4 4

(281) 5

(282) 6! 5

(283)

(284) # + 7 * 89:"

(285) # (!

(286) #

(287) &

(288)

(289) (

(290)

(291)

(292) 5

(293) &

(294) " ! , **

(295)

(296)

(297) (

(298)

(299)

(300)

(301)

(302) &****!

(303)

(304) & 5

(305)

(306)

(307)

(308) (* * " """ 2

(309) + 3

(310) '

(311) * !; * #

(312)

(313) 3 3 !

(314)

(315) 3

(316) 6

(317) *

(318)

(319) #

(320)

(321) 6

(322)

(323) 5

(324) 6

(325) "+ * ! 6

(326)

(327)

(328) #

(329)

(330) . **6** * *

(331) #*

(332)

(333) &

(334)

(335) "$>8 """ .

(336)

(337) & % "

(338)

(339) . * ' ' (

(340) '

(341) "

(342)

(343)

(344) &>= >8. +6))YYY

(345) )) Z .+[ \] \ ] \<:>97 7>:>7:>: +6))YYY

(346) ))#;P;PS;P)^34;S^4^P;_)#7::<) #7::<K>:: >>:77:>:.

(347) !". $ %&'. 349.

(348) , *" % '. +

(349) , & %

(350) ' , % ''" (

(351) "

(352) . ' X""

(353) +

(354) .

(355) ' %

(356) "

(357)

(358) . " & """ .$08+ú=0(7ú.$95$0, # " & &

(359) % " ' , %

(360) ' ' '' " &

(361) + 17 # ,

(362)

(363) % +

(364) & , &

(365)

(366) "" " & ' >9 # .

(367) ' ' +

(368)

(369) &

(370)

(371) '

(372) " & "

(373) % % ( % " ,

(374) """ " " . >C 7: ' (

(375) , % (

(376) & ' ""

(377)

(378) ( '

(379)

(380) "" " " . ' & ' ( " (

(381) 7> # . % (

(382)

(383)

(384) & '

(385)

(386) + , % & + X . (

(387) +

(388) " % '

(389) 17 >9 19 7: 7>.

(390) ;

(391) ) 2 ) I #

(392) ,

(393) ; 7::C Q=9 ). 3 ) 4

(394) ( ;" *

(395) ,"" ' 7::9 C=< ;

(396) "#" "! QU9 "#" "! C== ; G

(397)

(398)

(399)

(400) #+ ' 7::Q. ><.

(401) 350.

(402)

(403)

(404)

(405) .

(406) ,

(407) % 77 # '

(408) , & ''

(409) , ( & & 7<

(410) ' ' & ( ;

(411) 2? % ' & %" ' & ' %.

(412) & " (

(413) . ' % .

(414)

(415) , & ,

(416) + + ' " " 7Q $ % '& ' , %" ', " &

(417) ( ' % 7= 78 %

(418) ''

(419) . ' '"""

(420) ;

(421) ' ' 7U & &

(422) . ,, &

(423)

(424)

(425) 79 $,' % . & '

(426) X .

(427) &

(428) '

(429) % % )

(430)

(431) ' &. ' ' & , 77 7<. 7Q 7= 78 7U 79.

(432)

(433) ' 7::C U7 ; G

(434) D ;

(435) * # $ # $ %" " G #H

(436) ' 6

(437) < / * 5

(438)

(439)

(440) ! S'

(441) ;7::> 7> +6))YYY

(442) ))#;P;PS;P)^34;S^4^P;_)#>CCQ) #>CCQKQ7 <::Q7::C "#" "! C8Q $ X

(443) *(** ;

(444) N #' ' 7::Q 7<= X

(445) "#" "!. 7<< ;

(446) "#" "! Q=C.

(447) !". $ %&'. 351. & `

(448) % ,

(449) %

(450)

(451) , ' 7C # ' & ' ( " # '. " (

(452) """ ' & '. . ' ' " &

(453) % " & (

(454) """ ' <: " (

(455)

(456) + + ' %' . ' ' ' & <> *"

(457)

(458)

(459) . ' "

(460) + % (

(461) '

(462) , " .

(463)

(464)

(465) ' % (

(466) ' "" &

(467)

(468) ' % (

(469) '

(470) "

(471)

(472)

(473)

(474)

(475) . . .$08+ú=0(7/(5ú1ú1*g5h/hû868//(5ú1'(1 58+6$7 /ú6$16ú'$5úú=ú1<(7.ú/(1'ú50(

(476) <g17(0ú. 3 (

(477) %

(478)

(479) % " " %" " "

(480) % W

(481)

(482) %

(483) . / 0

(484) ",

(485) ' <7 P ' '

(486) +' , & . "

(487) (

(488) + W<< '

(489)

(490) + , (7C <: <> <7 <<. ;

(491) "#" "! =:9 G

(492)

(493)

(494)

(495) <> X

(496) "#" "! 7Q9 G

(497)

(498)

(499)

(500) <=K<U !.

(501) = ; >CC8 8CU.

(502) 352.

(503)

(504)

(505)

(506) . <Q ' + %" & " '

(507) + , . ( *"

(508)

(509) , .

(510)

(511) . ' ,

(512) + Q879

(513) ! 3

(514) #? 1=

(515) >

(516) (

(517) 6

(518) )

(519) # &

(520)

(521)

(522) 3

(523) & * )*

(524)

(525)

(526) $! Q:8

(527) . 4 ( 4 ( #? 1

(528)

(529) >,

(530)

(531) 5

(532)

(533)

(534)

(535)

(536) 3

(537) !, * )*

(538) (

(539)

(540) &

(541) # ( , *

(542) *6* ** &

(543)

(544)

(545) #

(546)

(547)

(548) ( $!1

(549) 5*>(

(550) )*

(551) 5* &

(552)

(553)

(554) 5

(555)

(556)

(557)

(558) ? 6** *

(559) (

(560)

(561)

(562) 3

(563) , * )*

(564) 5$! =9:C

(565) ! $' #? 1;

(566)

(567) >

(568) 5& ( 5

(569)

(570)

(571) * ?

(572) 5& ( ( &

(573) * *

(574) (

(575)

(576) !

(577) * * * * *&

(578)

(579) &(

(580)

(581) 5& ( 5

(582)

(583) !&

(584)

(585) 5

(586)

(587) $ ,, %

(588) """ '

(589) %

(590) % &

(591) ' ( " %. %" ' <=

(592) ' . & % %"" ' ' (

(593)

(594) + <8 4 &

(595) & .

(596) "" " "

(597)

(598) %

(599) """ ' <U , '

(600)

(601) + . " ' .

(602) ""

(603) + ' ' "

(604) %"<9. <Q <= <8 <U <9. "#" "! =:: ;

(605) "#" "! Q8< 2 "

(606) .

(607) C ; 7::Q <7= %"'"

(608) " ) 4 "#" "! Q=8 G

(609)

(610)

(611)

(612) <4.

(613) !". $ %&'. 353. P

(614) % % ' ` ' W ' % &

(615) " <C P " "

(616)

(617)

(618) +K K ( % %

(619) + Q: . "

(620) " ' '

(621) .

(622) "

(623) a"" ` ' .

(624) % ` ' 41 X

(625) """

(626) '

(627)

(628) + ' & ` % &

(629) " Q7

(630) + & ,& '

(631) ""

(632) " /

(633) % " 0 % . ' Q< X % .

(634) "" " " '%

(635) ' (

(636) ' "

(637) '+ % . ' 4 +

(638) . (

(639)

(640) + ,' 44 # "

(641)

(642) "" % " % ' + . % & + ' % % , & Q= P " %"" ' & & % % " ' %.

(643) Q8 ' "

(644) +

(645) <C Q: 41 Q7 Q< 44 Q= Q8. # % I ^^ ! #' 7::< <== "

(646) "#" "! <7Q % "#" "! <== ;

(647) "#" "! =:> G

(648)

(649)

(650)

(651) <9 X

(652) "#" "! 7QC % "#" "! <=8 "

(653) "#" "! <7=.

(654) 354.

(655)

(656)

(657)

(658) . '

(659) "" " "&" 47 X ''" . "

(660) & ". &

(661) ' . ; + . (

(662) " . "

(663) " %%"&" "

(664) + &

(665) '

(666) ' % '

(667) ' ' Q9 # ' & " %"" P " ' % % ' '

(668) & '

(669) & " ', '

(670) + & $

(671) "

(672) & ' 49 P ""

(673) + ' ,. & &

(674) % ' ' & ' & ' .

(675) & "

(676)

(677) + ' =: P '

(678)

(679) '.

(680) """

(681) % % ". & +

(682) % (

(683) & % ' ' .

(684)

(685)

(686) %" " ' .

(687)

(688) "" % " ""

(689)

(690) & '. % " ""

(691)

(692) .

(693) '

(694)

(695)

(696) ,%" "=>. 47 Q9 49 =: =>. ;

(697) "#" "! Q8Q X

(698) "#" "! 7=: "

(699) "#" "! <7= ;

(700) "#" "! =:7 % "#" "! <=8.

(701) !". . $ %&'. 'h=(1/(<ú&ú9('(1(7/(<ú&ú.8580/$5,1 /ú6$16.218681'$.ú<(7.ú/(5ú1ú1 '$1,û7$<.$5$5/$5,d(5d(9(6ú1'( '(ø(5/(1'ú5ú/0(6ú. 355. . , ' . %

(702) ""

(703)

(704) ""

(705) % , ' 5

(706) % "

(707)

(708) , ' %& . / & . + S30

(709)

(710)

(711)

(712) & '

(713) % '=7 4 "

(714) ' ,. %%"

(715) % 7::9

(716) =9:C

(717) ! $' #?

(718) "" "&

(719)

(720) ( . S & "

(721)

(722) + &

(723) . & '

(724) % , +. % S

(725) % % ( + %" '

(726)

(727) "

(728)

(729) '

(730) " ,,

(731)

(732) + '.( '& =<. ,, "

(733)

(734) + &

(735) & '

(736) , & /LVDQV9HUPH<HWNLOHUL *"

(737)

(738) %

(739) " & ' % (

(740) '

(741) . , " "

(742)

(743) .

(744)

(745)

(746) . & ' =Q>>

(747) #? 1 =7 =<. G

(748)

(749)

(750)

(751) ! <9 G

(752)

(753)

(754)

(755) <9.

(756) 356.

(757)

(758)

(759)

(760) . (

(761) 7 @&

(762)

(763)

(764) +3

(765) $ ' 8 % 4"

(766) ? ' '

(767)

(768) ' ' 4"

(769) ? ' , *" * # ;

(770) “

(771)

(772) $ ' >: % ' *" * # ?

(773) (

(774) 7QCC

(775)

(776) . 3

(777) #? 1

(778)

(779) $ ' <> %

(780) +

(781) (

(782) '

(783) 3

(784) # <C9Q

(785) P

(786) 4

(787) #

(788) $ #b? “ , * 5

(789)

(790) ;

(791)

(792) $ ' >8 % " %.

(793)

(794) ( '

(795)

(796) ' +

(797) P

(798) 4

(799) # ? QU<<

(800) 4"" ; 3

(801) *" # 4 % $ #?. 1

(802)

(803)

(804)

(805) ** **!

(806)

(807)

(808) !

(809)

(810)

(811) $ ' 8 % 4"

(812) ? "". "

(813) #? " . )

(814)

(815) ' =9:C

(816) ! $' #? 1

(817) & (

(818)

(819)

(820) ;

(821)

(822)

(823)

(824) $. ' 9 % 4 . #?

(825) +

(826)

(827) "+ ' ' & )

(828) ' '

(829)

(830) + + ' & " Q879

(831) ! 3

(832) #? 1

(833) '

(834) *

(835)

(836) $ "

(837) 7 +

(838) ! 3

(839) # "" .

(840)

(841)

(842) ' (

(843) (

(844) %' " " . Q879

(845) #? & ' ' % %""

(846)

(847) % % ', %

(848) % ' % %""

(849) % ' 3

(850) (

(851) ' " (

(852) ' % ' (

(853) ,. % (

(854) ' (

(855) "" . ' ,

(856)

(857) =Q . =Q. "

(858) "#" "! <78.

(859) !". $ %&'. 357.

(860) ,

(861) ' (

(862) ' %&

(863) ' .

(864)

(865) ""

(866) " " .

(867) ,. "

(868) "" " "&" ( ' %" & " "

(869)

(870) % (

(871) '

(872) , "

(873)

(874) . ; ' (

(875) & ` == *"

(876)

(877) ' % (

(878) '

(879) , " '

(880)

(881) .

(882)

(883) + (

(884) ' "" & . /LVDQVûDUWODU×Q×%HOLUOHPH<HWNLOHUL *"

(885)

(886) ' ,,

(887)