• Sonuç bulunamadı

Hakemli Makale: İptal Edilmiş Hakem Kararlarının Tanınması ve Tenfizi

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Hakemli Makale: İptal Edilmiş Hakem Kararlarının Tanınması ve Tenfizi"

Copied!
16
0
0

Yükleniyor.... (view fulltext now)

Tam metin

(1)TBB Dergisi 2010 (90). Zeynep Derya TARMAN. 123. ú37$/('ú/0úû<$%$1&,+$.(0 .$5$5/$5,1,17$1,10$6,9(7(1)ú=ú 5(&2*1,7,21$1'(1)25&(0(17 2)$118//(')25(,*1$5%,75$/$:$5'6. Zeynep Derya TARMAN. Özet:   

(2)   

(3)  Yukos Capital 

(4) 

(5)

(6) . Rosneft          

(7)    

(8)   

(9) 

(10)          

(11) 

(12)     

(13) 

(14)    ! " . #  $     %     % 

(15) 

(16) #   

(17) &' ! ()

(18) *+, ./ " 

(19)  0 "  "

(20)         

(21)  0

(22) 1

(23) 

(24)   

(25) 

(26)     "

(27)   

(28)   2

(29)    1 

(30) 

(31) .   

(32)   

(33)     

(34)  "   

(35) 

(36)  . 

(37) 

(38)  0 "         &' ! ()

(39) 

(40)        

(41) 

(42)

(43) 11       0

(44) . 21  2

(45) 

(46)  3    )

(47)    0  

(48)  

(49)

(50) 2 

(51)  3 0     "  0   

(52)   

(53) 

(54) 

(55) 

(56) 4Yukos5         .

(57) 

(58)  Anahtar Sözcükler: ! "      

(59)       

(60) . &' ! ()

(61)    1

(62)   

(63) 

(64) "      Abstract: % 

(65)    '

(66)   4Yukos Capital5 

(67) 

(68) .

(69)  "0    6   

(70) 

(71)  7889 %   6  :

(72)  ;     

(73) 0   

(74) 

(75) .   

(76)  

(77) 2 

(78)   '    . 

(79) . "' Yukos Capital  Rosneft  

(80) 2   &' ! 6  

(81)    2

(82) 

(83)   <     :

(84) 2 "

(85)   ' .  *+, ./  2

(86) 

(87)       . 

(88) 2 "

(89)   ' .  0 " 

(90)   '    "  

(91)  "0.   

(92) 0      "

(93)  

(94)   < 2  

(95) .    

(96)   '     6   

(97) 2 . Yrd. Doç. Dr., Koç Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Devletler Özel Hukuku Anabilim .

(98) 124.  

(99)    .  

(100)    

(101) 

(102)       2

(103) 

(104)  .       "

(105)   ' 

(106)  &  %

(107)  

(108) 

(109) . 2

(110)  

(111)    0

(112)  

(113)   =

(114)  '

(115)   . 

(116) 0 0  2 Keywords: :

(117) 2 "

(118)   '   

(119)  .  /  2

(120) 

(121)       &' ! 6  

(122)   "

(123) 

(124) 0

(125)   0 

(126)  

(127) 

(128) 0   =2.  

(129)             ! "  #$% &! "  #$%'(     

(130)  

(131)  "))) *

(132)    

(133) * *

(134)  + "/% ))

(135)  1 ! "  #$%0 2 ( /     

(136)  

(137)  3/   *

(138)   4)  / 

(139)  3    /  4)  % %  5    

(140)  /

(141)  3 " ** 6  ! "  #$%0 2   +  &' (2   %

(142)  

(143)  

(144)  %/ % *    5

(145)     /  

(146)    )

(147)   4) * 3$ ( 5

(148)  %     

(149)  )

(150) "6  ) 5 6 * 

(151)  /6 "))    ! "  #$%0      3 5 5

(152)  6 "))  * ))

(153)        5

(154)  

(155)  3 

(156)    ))   %

(157)   ! "  #$%(

(158)  3

(159) %  5

(160)  5  "))  8 3

(161)  % ")6)( 5

(162)  51. 2.         9   ! "  #$% :/ ;/3) 4)))6)  )( ) "< =>=( )  <   &RG, ? @?B >>' CC *

(163)  + ")6) #$%  3% 3 8  !!!)

(164) " 3@)

(165) @@)

(166) E

(167) G

(168) @ 

(169) 

(170) "@ I"

(171) "E

(172) 

(173) )

(174) . ! "  #$%  2@+<  

(175) . 

(176)   .     

(177) 

(178) 

(179) .   

(180)    

(181) 

(182)   

(183).

(184)          

(185)  

(186) .    

(187)    

(188)   

(189) . . ! "  # #  

(190)

(191)      

(192) 

(193)     $   

(194)    

(195).

(196) .      #

(197) # #  %  

(198)    &.

(199) TBB Dergisi 2010 (90). Zeynep Derya TARMAN. 125.   8 ))  +  * / / 5

(200)  5  /  % "  ) 5  )) 

(201)  + +  % /" ) ***  J  /" ) "))(      5

(202)  5 (     6 */ 3$  6% 3$

(203)  

(204)   4)) /  (       )) ( ))  

(205)  /

(206)   )/3) *%/ **  

(207)  5

(208)   $ ")) "  ! "  #$%(     5

(209)  

(210)  3 "  ) 

(211)  6( )/3)  

(212)   5

(213)      

(214)       3$ *

(215)  = 4) 5(

(216) 

(217)   %) )  5

(218)  %     

(219)  5 

(220)  "))

(221)  /

(222)  ")5 "6  3   ! "  #$%0 2  % 93 

(223)  6  

(224)  * 

(225)    %%

(226)  6(

(227)   /

(228)    6 /"

(229)  3   6  

(230)  

(231)   /*** * ")6) ")) +  /" ) /5

(232)   4) " )( $ #$%0 2LL C 8 8(

(233)      "  8 ))))     5

(234)  6 * ))) /  5

(235)  5  /  % " ) )) $   ! "  #$%  2LL )/ (

(236)  * /* * *

(237)  "     

(238)  

(239)  "))   % % / 6 )

(240) **  )/3)     "//

(241)  

(242)  8 ))) 5

(243) (

(244)    6( ) 

(245)  ! "  #$%0

(246)  + " 5

(247)  %    

(248)  

(249)  3

(250) % 

(251) /

(252)   ! "  #$% 2@+ &' ( 5

(253)  %     

(254)  /")) 5

(255)   2LL ( 5

(256)  %     

(257) + 8 5     "  % 3$ 

(258)   =. C. O) P!@P") Q

(259) @#

(260) +  $( '

(261) . (   '

(262)

(263)       P/ ?BB=(  >> S ) / U%( )*+ .    /0 1  2

(264)  

(265) ..    3 4 9

(266) ) ?BB(  >V S 4) W

(267) ( 

(268) ..    3 

(269) 3 4 X  ?BB (  V ! "  #$% 2LL@+< 9%) $% **  [

(270) 

(271)    *0

(272)     

(273)  /    (  /)

(274) 8"

(275)  \ %  )

(276)  6  3

(277)    [

(278)  \  8    **( ))  / 6 

(279)  )

(280)  )  [   +/ (  "   ) etmez..

(281) 126.  

(282)    .  

(283)     ! "  #$%0 /* * *6 3  "   /  /( 5

(284)  %      %  *

(285)  ")) 8"

(286) 

(287) % )) 6(5 "  3*** 2@+&' 

(288)  3 "    * **6*

(289)    / 

(290) %

(291)   4     5

(292)  % "

(293)  " 

(294)  ")) / %%  /  )/3) /"

(295) )  ;/3)( * */ 6%

(296)   X40 ")6) 3( / * 8  ) ")   / 8%      

(297) lamak da mümkündür.V 95

(298)  %      6 * 

(299)  5 /6 ")) "

(300)  +  3$ *%   * **%

(301) * > 9 /% *  /  4) 3$ (

(302)  

(303)  *   % *  /

(304)  /3 3$

(305)    )) ")) / 5

(306)     ( 5

(307)     %

(308)  

(309)   4) /%( ")8 "  5

(310)  %      %  *

(311)    "

(312)   )  "  Çin, Almanya,8 9

(313) /( 98  98 

(314)  + 

(315)   "// ) /%  6

(316)  ( 5

(317)  %       ** 

(318)  6 *

(319)  + )  3 6 )    ! "  #$% )/ 

(320)  

(321)  $ ")) "/

(322)  9      6  *5. V. > 8. 9. X

(323) O   4 3( 3)*+    '   6789 P/ C(  =C I ""/  U3/5

(324) ` +    '

(325)

(326)       &YCA' ccLL &>'(  BBf X  ")/ Q( 5

(327)  %     

(328)  "))  

(329)  /

(330)  ")6) *

(331) %

(332)   X X    )    "  3$ *% 6%

(333)  %  / 5

(334)      

(335)    )) "))

(336)   3 

(337) 6    %

(338)  ` 4 Q   I " &YCA ccL2 &'(  B'S #5  I

(339) ) "  & YCA c2LLL &?BBB'(   'S  " "  U

(340) "  & YCA cccL &?BBV'(  C >f U%(  > S W

(341) (  VS P!@Q

(342) @ $(  >g>?B 4/ h)/0 5

(343)  %     

(344)  6   / Q &I")

(345) "+ X55  ( j /'    8  YCA cccLLL &?BB '(  BS 3  @j"

(346)

(347) ! q

(348)  ( L

(349)  

(350) " w5 " 

(351) ( $ ?BB>(  ?B X

(352) O   4 3( U+" 

(353) "+ X) X! x( ('' :(    '

(354)  '

(355)

(356)  (   '    ; 7, No. 2, 1998, s. 15V.

(357) TBB Dergisi 2010 (90). Zeynep Derya TARMAN. 127.    % 6  * 38   % ** "6) ( 

(358)      3 /  ")8 "6)    ) 3$ *% 3$ (      % /   

(359)  + 5

(360)  % "( "    

(361) * 6 *  )) 

(362)  

(363)  + 

(364)   w  5

(365)        8 )))(     )) 

(366)  ")) $  " ))

(367) )  { /%(  3$ *% "  % " $  %

(368)  

(369)  10 9 /%( 5

(370)       6 * ")8 "6) 6 /" 8  6 *    ) 5

(371)    / 6 "  /$* 11 4) /%(  ) )))    */ 6 "   

(372) 

(373) 

(374)  

(375)  / 

(376)  ) " /

(377)   4) "/ 

(378)   

(379)  /       5

(380)      

(381)  5  "))  

(382) ")  ri sürülmektedir.12 4) /%( ! "  #$%0 2   +  &'  +/  

(383) 8

(384)   } 4     ~ + /  } 4     ” ifadesi )  %  

(385)        

(386)  /

(387)   ")6)) 

(388) 

(389)  = "// ) 3$ *% 3$ ( ! "  #$%0 2  / 

(390)  3   6 6( 

(391) 

(392)  

(393)  /****6* 

(394)  6  € J    % * 5

(395)  %      J 0

(396)  

(397)  6 ")  3$ *

(398)   Q ( ! "  #$%0 2  / 5   6    

(399) 

(400)  

(401)  "))

(402)  /

(403)  5 ")  *%*  "//      6 * 5

(404)  % " . 10. 11 12 =. O q)"( U+" 3 X 

(405)  X!  "

(406) !

(407) 

(408) 3  P" #

(409)   X)

(410) &P#X'( (''(   '    ; 7 No.1, 1998, s. 20. U%(  >S W

(411) (  V? P!@Q

(412) @ $(  > }h"3

(413) "  +" 

(414) "+

(415)  !  /  +)~ % 93 

(416)   6(

(417)   2  %

(418)  )/     

(419) 

(420)  

(421)  "))

(422)  /

(423)  ")6)   q)"(  >.

(424) 128.  

(425)    . %  *  6  38 6 )+  C 4) /% $  " ( ' 

(426)     &   <2%:' 

(427)        

(428)  3$

(429)   15 ' 

(430)      Q 

(431) 0  %

(432)  J 0  X40

(433) 5 

(434) %

(435)   j$ *

(436)  "

(437)    ( Q 

(438) (     Q ))) /  ")6) 3 8/ Q 0 / %) )%    9

(439) + Q $ "))     5

(440)  

(441) %

(442)  V Ancak bu iptal   ( J   X       

(443)       3 "%

(444)   X  ( ! "  #$%0 2 ( /

(445)     5   "))  

(446)  

(447) 6S )) /  ( ! "  #$%0 2LL  )/ (     #$%0/     ** 8  )) ))  / 

(448)    % **  3$ 

(449)  6 

(450) %

(451)  > J  ( / 3 8/ =   3 >&? &)  @& 18 /%

(452)    ) ))(  *  % 

(453)  " =   3 >&?   J  )  @   

(454)  $% / )/)%6 *  ))   ) 3$ *% )   /  8$*%

(455) *   /  2/ " / 2/0 8 5

(456)  ( 2/ 9

(457) + Q(  ) ))) /

(458)  3$      /

(459)  % "  6  %      5

(460)  

(461) %

(462)  19 J 0 8

(463)  ( J  * Q( $* "

(464)  "      (

(465)   #$%0 2@+ &' ** 6 "   8 )))) $ "-. C. 15 V. >. 18 19.      6 / 

(466)  + 5

(467)  

(468)  3/6 % X   J       8  U%( s. 81 vd.    ") " "/  3 8  U%(  =  X  

(469)     9

(470) + Q0 &I " I")

(471) "+ X55'    için bkz. YCA ccL2 &'(  ?V g?V  = ) V

(472)   X  ")/ Q0    8  YCA ccLL &>'(  BB ?V U >

(473)       8  YCA Lc & C'(  B ? :  ?

(474)   2/ 9

(475) + Q &2 I")

(476) "+ X55'    8 bkz. YCA 2LLL & ='(  =V .

(477) TBB Dergisi 2010 (90). Zeynep Derya TARMAN. 129. ))

(478)    5  /6 ))))  3 

(479) 6 

(480) %

(481)  20 4)   ( 5

(482)  %     

(483)       J      " / $

(484) %

(485)   4)

(486)  

(487)  "          5

(488)  %      J 0

(489)  % 

(490)     )/3) %%

(491)  21 )  $*  ' 

(492)        

(493)  8 X4 % J 0  / %) ))%

(494) )  q  9

(495) + Q(

(496)    6 $

(497) * *  *

(498) " J  )))) #$%0 2LL  )/  )/3)6  /  J  Q ;) ))0)  B?  )/3) ) 

(499) / Q 0 5

(500)  %    

(501)     %

(502)  22 95

(503)  %     

(504)  % "      ( X

(505)   9

(506) + Q

(507)  +  %

(508)   + '  &<  ?= )  "))) ")%

(509) ) 

(510)   

(511)    

(512)     ?BBC / )  X6)

(513) " / ( + '   &$*8  '    B '

(514)   3 )) 6 +%  %  % 

(515)  &$*8 ' $

(516)

(517)  / $*8 $% 

(518) %   4) $% ( $*8 $% "6 )/)% (

(519)  /  Q"" " * ( ;)      Q &LIXI'?C **  )/  8$*6 % ) ) 

(520)  %

(521)  8 

(522) / h)/ J /") Q/ 460 + B0  ")6) +%   %     "/  -. 20. 21. 22. ?=. ?C.  U  C

(523)   J  * Q &J  #)5  I")

(524) '    8 bkz. YCA cL & V'(  C C 4 q" : P  O" / ` IX cLc &C'(  VV?fS 

(525) " P

(526)   :)   

(527) 

(528)  

(529)  2" 

(530) " ` YCA cc & '(  VV=f C : >

(531)   q  9

(532) + Q0 &q  I")

(533) "+ X55'    8 bkz. YCA ccLL &>'(  VgV  ?  ?BB

(534)    ?BBBB ?V@B / X

(535)   9

(536) + Q &X

(537)   I")

(538) "+ X55'    L

(539)  

(540) " I")

(541) "+ I"  X 

(542) 

(543) " h)/ J /")  

(544)  #/ : */ ))   

(545)  * ))

(546)   X/ 

(547)  3 8  

(548)

(549) 5<@@!!!

(550) 55 +g ).

(551) 130.  

(552)    .   (  X  ?BBC

(553)   /5 

(554)

(555)  

(556) 

(557) +çi olan ;  D /    h) % 

(558)  

(559) %

(560)   X

(561)

(562)    8 +

(563)  $ ) ) ;  D /  % 

(564) ( ?VB / h) &> / U) "'  %6 +%  % 0 

(565)  %

(566)   X

(567)

(568)   $

(569) 3* " (   8"6) h)/ J /")0) 5 ")6) <  % 

(570) ( ;  D / 0))

(571) *   

(572)  %

(573)   ?> X  ?BB

(574)   +  '   +%  % 0  %( )gX6)

(575) " ?BBC $ % " $*8 $%  /  ;)      Q &LIXI'

(576)  )   )/3) "  Q""0 $

(577)

(578) 

(579)  5 "* * %

(580) %

(581)    U/* ?BBV

(582)     $

(583)    ( +%  % 0 + '  0 +   \ % = / h) $    %

(584)   + '  (   

(585)  5 X

(586)  0   %%( U ?BBV

(587)     % ")) +%   % 0 

(588)   < (     Q""     5

(589)  

(590)

(591)  %

(592)  25 LIXI     5

(593)  *8  /%

(594)  < g U%

(595)    / 3  < < Ein, ek delillerin ))) 8 ) )% 

(596)   *  )

(597) 

(598)  %  )  <   )  /")  %

(599)   g LIXI )   <  5 "* *  ( LIXI )   88 / 6 + '   yeni taleplerde bu))%

(600) )  4%38

(601)  + '   / $*8 $% )/  $*8   5  +

(602) 5 

(603) %(  "  $** 3     $*8 $%  $ "    / ")%    

(604) 5 

(605) %

(606)   g  ) )))

(607)  \  % + ")%< LIXI tahkiminde +  '   "" )) 4* ")0) "

(608) 6

(609)  +

(610)  %

(611)   #$ ")) )) * ")( Q""  

(612) 25.  Q/ ?BB>

(613)   X 

(614)  &I"  #

(615) 

(616) ' I")

(617) "+ Q""!    &q

(618)  

(619) "@Q

(620)   "5( h"3

(621) "  U+" 

(622) "+ X) X 

(623)  X! ( #2w ?BB(  ?>C(  ?B' h)/ J /")0

(624)   )/)%  8$**  3$  

(625)  }X 

(626) ~  "   %

(627)  .

(628) TBB Dergisi 2010 (90). Zeynep Derya TARMAN. 131. :    Q""0 *  

(629) %   ")% "  / 6  "+   

(630)  6%

(631)   4)) /  ( "" )) 4* ")   / ")% "  / 6 2/0 %  "+  5"" )6)) *

(632) %

(633)     < 0 ) ") $ 3  ri, < 0   

(634) 5   ")%

(635) )  9   (    ) * / 

(636) % 

(637)

(638) 6 "))  %( Q"" 4$3 J  X 

(639)  Qkemesi?V ve Rusya Federasyonu Arbitrazh Yüksek Mahkemesi?> yuka  /  

(640)  ))**  

(641)

(642) 6 

(643) %  5

(644)     "%

(645)   !"   #$    h) 

(646)  +   5

(647)     6( +  '  (     " ;) Q)  )) B> )/  "0

(648) 

(649) 5 

(650) %

(651)   X

(652)       %( ! #$%0 / )

(653)  

(654) %

(655)  28 Q( ! "  #$%0 3$ ( h)    2@+ &'  )/ ( 5

(656)  ")) *  /

(657)  ")6))  )   5

(658)     )  "  

(659)   3 

(660) 6 

(661) %

(662)   Q(  2@+ &' *** J 

(663)  * #$%0 6   8   

(664)  6

(665)  % 6  #$%0 93 

(666)  

(667)  6 5

(668)  %     

(669)  /6 

(670) %

(671)   95

(672)  %     

(673) * *  / 

(674) 

(675) * " / 

(676) 6 "%)

(677) ))6) 

(678)   ( 5

(679)  %      ! "  #$%0 3$ 

(680)   

(681)  ) )  $ ")) "6 **?V. ?>. 28. ?V ) ?BB>

(682)    gXCB@V>> gB> / Q"" 4$3 J  X 

(683)  Q &J  X 

(684)  I")

(685) "+ Q""! h3"'    &

(686) "@ "5(  ?>C(  ?' B X  ?BB>

(687)    C @B> / h)/ J /") X 

(688)  * Q &#)5  X 

(689)  I")

(690) "+

(691)  h) J 

(692) "'    &

(693) "@ "5(  ?>C(  ??' ? W)

(694) ?BB

(695)    =V BC j h B>g> B / X

(696)       &

(697) 

(698) I")

(699) "+ X

(700)  '    &

(701) "@ "5(  ?>C(  ?C'.

(702) 132.  

(703)    .   %

(704)   4) 

(705)  ) ) $  " (  $  / 3  ( /

(706)  "

(707) " 

(708) 

(709)  +  6 "     3 8 " /%

(710)   + '  ip

(711)  %     

(712)  ) ) % ")6) 8

(713)   3 

(714) 6   * *%  ( ( )  /

(715)   $8* 

(716) 6 "))  %     

(717)  

(718) %

(719)   4)   * ( +  '   X

(720)   9

(721) + Q0 %) )%          "  h)/ J /")0 5

(722)  %     "0

(723)    %

(724)  29 X

(725)   9

(726) + Q(    3 8  ! "  #$%0      3 %  $% "   h)/ J /") ))  

(727)  +       "6 )

(728)  /****6* 3

(729)  6 

(730) %

(731)        

(732)  

(733) ( " ) 

(734) + )   3   /6 + 

(735) %

(736)   4) )  8 8( "  h)/ J /")      / 3   

(737)

(738) 6 / 5

(739)    

(740)  " ) *  6%/6 "))    5

(741)     

(742)  /

(743)   "// X

(744)   9

(745) + Q( "   5

(746)  % /     

(747)    

(748)  " ) "  

(749) %

(750)   4) 5( X

(751)   9

(752) + Q( h)/ J /") X 

(753)  * Q0 5

(754)      / 3  8 8  5  6( + '  

(755)  + h) / 3 6 

(756)  + "6  

(757)  *  / )) 

(758)   %6 6  %

(759)   4) ler, > F@   % raporu,=B 3 . (   H6 EU-. 29. =B. =. ?  ?BB

(760)    ?BBBB ?V@B / X

(761)   9

(762) + Q &X

(763)   I")

(764) "+ X55'    X )5 "/ q 

(765) ") */ " # P)

(766) ) g#  30 5" ) 8  

(767)

(768) 5<@@/"

(769) @")

(770) @„" 3"@"BC@ U:IB=V 

(771)  ;)    

(772) "5) $ 3*

(773) * " 3   (   

(774)  +   }h*%

(775)  9~ 5" ) 

(776)  8  ?  ?BB

(777)    ?BBBB ?V@B / X

(778)   9

(779) + Q &X

(780)   I")

(781) "+ X55'    = C ") 4$*.

(782) TBB Dergisi 2010 (90). Zeynep Derya TARMAN. 133. < '  32 ve D 

(783)  33 5"   /  ( 93( 98re ve Litvanya mahkemelerinin + '  E  * " / 3 h)/ J /")0  ")%

(784) )  %     =C Q( /  +  B '

(785)  0 \ % h)     " ) * /  ")6) * = U ?BB>

(786)   X

(787)          

(788) +

(789)  )))%

(790) ) = X

(791)   9

(792) + Q( < 0 h) **

(793)   " / % 

(794) 8%   /$

(795)   h)/ J g /")0)    "  3$    

(796) %

(797)   +  '  

(798)  + ))   < 0 /

(799)   $8* 8* *

(800) % " / h) / 3 $ "))  6 

(801)  + "6 "))  %

(802)   Q( < 0 ))   h) / 3

(803)  \  6 ")6)) 3$

(804)   "6 )  "6 /$* )

(805) 

(806)   )%

(807)   w  6 

(808)  +    5

(809)  )) 6  Q( h)    / 3   

(810)

(811) 6 "))  6     "0

(812)  ** ")5 "6 )))) / 6  %

(813)   #")8 " ( h)/ J /") X 

(814)  * Q

(815)  +   5

(816)     "0 

(817)  /6( X

(818)          ")  LIXI    

(819)     %

(820)  . =?. ==. =C. =. ;)    

(821) "5) $ 3*

(822) * " 2LF<  '  

(823)  +  }h)/0 )) #

(824)  466  ))) {

(825) **6*~ %  

(826)  8  ?  ?BB

(827)    ?BBBB ?V@B / X

(828)   9

(829) + Q &X

(830)   I")

(831) "+ X55'    =  ") 4$* D 

(832)    X   

(833) "5) $ 3*

(834) *0* }h)/0 " ( 9    #/ €3* * ~  5" ) 

(835)  8  ?  ?BB

(836)    ?BBBB ?V@B / X

(837)   9

(838) + Q &X

(839)   I")

(840) "+ X55'    = V ") 4$* X )5 *  8%

(841)   ( )" : I"5/ /$

(842)    % h)/ J /")0 8  ")%

(843) )   /  

(844)  86 *

(845) %

(846)   4)    8  ?  ?BB

(847)    ?BBBB ?V@B / X

(848)   9

(849) + Q &X

(850)   I")

(851) "+ X55'    =  ") 4$* 4 ?  ?BB

(852)    ?BBBB ?V@B / X

(853)   9

(854) + Q &X

(855)   I")

(856) "+ X55'    = B ") 4$*.

(857) 134.  

(858)    . !% &   h)/ J /")0  ( +  '   & <   %     ) *  % " /  5

(859)  

(860) %  =V Rus mahkemeleri, kamu düzeni kav  +   3$ **6* *   *         5

(861)   /     

(862) => % ")8 3% /" )

(863)    h) **

(864)  88 )) /  "  * )))6) + '  &< da( X

(865)   9

(866) + Q( h)/ J /")0 5

(867)  % "     

(868)      ) 

(869) / ! "  #$% 2@+&' **/   /

(870) / /  )%

(871)   X

(872)   9

(873) + Q0 3$ *%* 3$ (

(874)  /  * ) *  6 3 8/    5

(875)    (   ! "  #$% 2@+&' ** / 

(876)  3 "   )/3) ))    )/)%

(877)  (  ) )))  * †$ 

(878)   / 3 

(879)  

(880) + "  3$ **6* * † **

(881) 

(882)  / 3  3  % )) /  "  * )) ) ) 

(883)  %   /")) 8  X

(884)   9

(885) + Q0   ( ))  

(886)   3 "  ))   / 3 $ 5 "     88 %3) " )    "  6 dirilebilir. !    '( '  )* 

(887)  + 

(888) 

(889) 95

(890)  %     

(891)  " ))  *    *  %%%

(892)   4) ")    

(893) )

(894) ) izleyecekleri merakla beklenmektedir.=. =V =>. =. 4  ?V( ?>( ?  ;

(895)  „"  P

(896)    / " (    

(897)   / " 0) \  "6  )) h)/ J /")0) ""     ")%

(898) ) 6  

(899)    

(900)  h) ) *  6 "))  %

(901)  &

(902) "@ "5(  ?>C(  ?>' U%(  =>.

(903) TBB Dergisi 2010 (90). Zeynep Derya TARMAN. 135. ! "  #$%  2@+ 0 3$ (

(904)  3/ ) )   ( /

(905) 

(906) 5 

Referanslar

Benzer Belgeler

Göç sonrası biyografik deneyimi içinde mücadeleci bir göçmen habitusuna sahip olanlar eğer göç öncesinden yeterli bir kültürel sermayeye sahiplerse,

Ruh ve arkadaşları [16] montajlı parça üretiminde boşluğu sinterlemedeki hacimsel çekme farkından dolayı gerçekleştirmiş, ancak iki farklı besleme stoku kullanıldığı için

Ancak uzun dönemli bakım hizmetleri kurumsal tabanlı hizmetler (resmi), gayri resmi hizmetler ve topluma dayalı hizmetler olarak üç ana başlıkta ele alınabilir. A- Gayri Resmi

Her bir tabloda toplamı on olan ikilileri boyayarak tabloda son sayı kalana kadar devam et.. Kullanmadığın sayıyı noktalı

In performing sacral ESPB, local anesthetic is administered to the facial plane under the erector spinae aponeurosis and multifidus muscle, as in the thoracolumbar region;

8) Emir'in bir miktar balonu vardı. Emir 23 tane daha balon satın alınca toplam 70 tane balonu olmuştur. Buna göre Emir'in başlangıçta kaç tane balonu vardı?.. PROBLEMLER

Taraflar arasında geçerli bir sözleşmenin vücut bulabilmesi için saik şarttır. Tahkim anlaşmalarında tüm tarafların uyuşmazlığın tahkim anlaşması yolu ile

Hem seçilen hem de seçilmeyen mahkemenin davay› reddetmesi ha- linde, Konvansiyona üye baflka bir devlet mahkemesinin davaya ba- kaca¤› varsay›lmaktad›r. Bu aflamada