• Sonuç bulunamadı

View of Blood Vessels Segmentation Using Independent Component Analysis

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "View of Blood Vessels Segmentation Using Independent Component Analysis"

Copied!
9
0
0

Yükleniyor.... (view fulltext now)

Tam metin

(1)

4605

Blood Vessels Segmentation Using Independent Component Analysis

N.C. Santosh Kumar

1

, Sreenidhi Thoutam

2

,

Dr.S. Narasimha Reddy

3

, MD Sharfuddin

Waseem

4

1Assistant Professor, Dept. of CSE, Kakatiya Institute of Technology& Science, Warangal, TS, 2M.Tech student, Dept. of CSE, Kakatiya Institute of Technology& Science, Warangal, TS, 3Associate Professor, Dept. of CSE, Kakatiya Institute of Technology& Science, Warangal, TS, 4Assistant Professor, Dept. of CSE, Kakatiya Institute of Technology& Science, Warangal, TS,

Article History: Received: 11 January 2021; Revised: 12 February 2021; Accepted: 27 March 2021; Published online: 16May2021

Abstract: The blood vessel segmentation and exposure method perform a valuable clinical position in a computerized

retinopathy research method. But, the expertise requires for manual segmentation of vessels. It is a long and time-taking task. Applying computational statistics for this determination would benefit in the practical retinal study. This retinal fundus image involves modifying low variations, which threaten the achievement of the segmentation method. A user-friendly GUI that is a MATLAB-based tool is used to segment the blood vessels using various services on the retinal image, including Grayscale conversion, Image Binarization, Gabor filtering, Independent component analysis. This paper has implemented an automatic retinal blood vessel segmentation method for the early diagnosis of diseases. The machine learning-based Independent Component Analysis (ICA) primarily employed for noise elimination and architecture, including varous stages such as image pre-processing, filtering, blood vessels segmentation, classification. We validated ICA architecture on fundus and retinal colour imaging. The empirical results show that the suggested model provides higher accuracy with 98.2% compared with previous algorithms.

Keywords: Segmentation, retinal, colour conversion, Independent Component Analysis.

1. Introduction

Blood vessel analysis plays a vital role in specific medical areas, including oncology [1], laryngology, ophthalmology, and neurosurgery, both for diagnosis, planning, and treatment provision, as well as for comparison and providing treatment. Results. The significance of engineering evaluation is sustained by natural advances in the scientific practice of modern medical strategies aimed at improving angiography, including narrow-band imaging (NBI) and computed tomography (CT). Simultaneously, new technologies, along with magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) and computerized tomography angiography (CTA), are constantly advancing to improve the visualization of the vascular tree. Manual vascular segmentation is a time-consuming method that lacks internal replication and proliferation.

On the other hand, semi-computerized or automated vessel segmentation strategies require at least one expert to quantify or compare segmentation's consequences. Also, improving and evaluating these algorithms remains vulnerable, as publicly available photographic datasets with currently applied usual gold standard (GS) are limited to subtle anatomical regions and the retina. Nevertheless, automatic or semi-automatic vascular segmentation should assist clinicians and thus understand a first-class hobby topic in clinical research, as evidenced by the use of the large number of articles published annually in this field. There is already in-depth literature on ship segmentation, and various assessments about ship segmentation algorithms have been published in recent years, such as [2]. However, due to the significant improvement in the subject matter, updated assessments must analyse and summarize the art's actual state.

The retinal anatomy can be discovered with the help of fundus imaging. Fundus images provide valuable assistance in retinal research. The anatomical structure includes the optic disc, atypical structures, retinal blood vessels, and the macula. The optic disc marks the beginning of the optic nerve head (the white inventory) that connects attention with the mind and is also an access point for the eye's essential blood vessels. The "macula" is a minimal area (located in the retina centre) that is loaded by the pin factor and increased vision. A tree-shaped structure known as a vasculature (a completely hyper-frequency component) extends across the fundus image. The retina's blood vessels are the essential structures that supply blood to the retina and indicate the presence and severity of diseases such as diabetic retinopathy, retinal occlusion, glaucoma, etc.; if not detected at the initial level, it can result in an imaginary and prophetic loss. Therefore, the correct automatic division of blood vessels in the fundus image is a critical issue in analysing retinal vascular disease. Even for ophthalmologists, examining vascular function through manual segmentation is a time-consuming endeavour that is susceptible to human effort due to complex vascular systems. Using the computerized segmentation method can make it easier for the ophthalmologist to divide the blood vessels intelligently within the fundus image. This could help in the early detection of retinal diseases and prevent you from imaginative and prophetic decline.

(2)

4606

This assessment aims to provide comprehensive records of the latest ship segmentation algorithms by summarizing their uses. Each segmentation technique is discussed first in the general context of optical segmentation and then in the specific context of vessel segmentation.

2. Review of the literature

Various algorithms were deployed for blood vessel segmentation, which achieved different results and performances. Mathematical morphology approach based retinal blood vessel segmentation for diagnosis of disease was used by Gehad Hassan et al.(2015). Some of the approaches developed by researchers discussed below, S. Prabha and K.Sakthidasan Sankaran (2020) The retinal vessel image structure is an essential marker of glaucoma, diabetic retinopathy, and high blood pressure. The veins' precision in splitting retinal images influences the nature of retinal imaging research used in the analysis strategies in modern ophthalmology. Improving differentiation is one of the urgent steps in any area of retinal vein division. This well-known document shows an assessment of the appropriateness of a recently established spatially multifaceted discrimination development strategy for improving fundus imaging of venous section. The upgrade device was changed and worked with a slight variation on Tyler Coye's account, which was upgraded using the Hough Line Exchange-based hobby boat strategy. The proposed system was categorized into two groups of open and functional data: "search" and "engine." Retinal blood vessels are removed using Tyler Cowie's algorithm. After segmentation, the extracted blood vessels are inserted into unique device learning algorithms to detect diabetic retinopathy disease. Thus, the proposed pipeline is useful for avoiding disease that causes eternal blindness in the early stages. A person can take essential precautions to treat diabetic retinopathy before it is affected by eternal blindness.

Lee et al (2019) a novel deep learning method was suggested for vessel segmentation. Current strategies that typically employ CNN have relied on local appearances detected on the daily image network without considering the container shape's graphical structure. To address this, we integrated a convolutional graphics network into a unified CNN architecture, where the final segmentation is inferred by combining the unusual patterns of the features. The proposed approach could be implemented to extend any CNN-based vessel segmentation techniques to decorate overall performance. Experiments have shown that the proposed technique outperforms the latest current methods in two retinal imaging data sets plus a coronary X-ray angiography data set.

Oliveira et al. (2018) Retinal vascular condition is a reliable biomarker for many eye and cardiovascular diseases, so that automatic vascular division can be necessary for analysis and detection. This text recommends a new technique that combines the presented multidisciplinary evaluation with fixed wavelike transport with a multi-region convolutional neural network to address the presentation and alteration of the vessel shape pathway in the retina. Our idea uses continuous processes to present an extraordinary approach to each increment and anticipation of data, allowing us to discover which records are at some point in the training to hear the segmentation better. The technology was evaluated in three publicly available databases, with an average accuracy of 0,9576, 0.9694, 0 .9653. The area is below the ROC curve of 0.9821, 0,9905, 0, and 9855 within the DRIVE STARE and CHASE_DB1 databases. Moreover, it appears to arise from civic education's scope and diversity, indicating its capacity for mere international assertiveness.

J. Son, et al (2017) Retinal vessel segmentation is a vital step in the automated detection of retinal pathology using fundus imaging. Although many processes are suggested, current strategies tend to bypass exceptional vessels or allow false positives in terminal branches. Let's leave this lower segmentation alone. Excessive segmentation is also a problem, while quantitative studies should yield the ideal width of vessels. This article presents a method that generates an appropriate map of retinal vessels using hostile obstetric education. Our technologies get a cube coefficient of 0.829 in the DRIVE dataset and 0.834 in the STARE dataset, the very recent overall performance on both datasets.

Welling et al. (2016) they introduced a scalable technique for studying static, semi-supervised information in graphs, totally relying on a green model of convolutional neural networks running directly on the charts. We stimulate the selection of our convolutional morphology by in situ approximation of the first order of the spectral graph convolutions. Our model linearly scales within the edges of the graph and learns hidden layer representations that encode the graph's shape for each neighbourhood and the properties of the nodes. A combination of experiments with inventory buy and sell networks, and a Knowledge Graph dataset found that our approach outperforms related technologies by a huge margin.

G. Azzopardi and N. Petkov (2015) Retinal imaging It gives the non-invasive possibility to analyse many medical diseases. The automated partitioning of the trash tree is an essential pre-processing step that enables the

(3)

4607

following automated actions that contribute to such an analysis. They presented a novel method for automated segmentation of vascular shrubs in fundus retinal imaging. We support regulations that respond selectively to ships called B-COSFIRE, a B-COSFIRE case for tape, which is a ship stripping. It is primarily based on the current COSFIRE approach (a set of displaced filter responses). The B-COSFIRE filter achieves directional selectivity by calculating the weighted geometric inclusion of the output of an array of Gaussian difference filters whose struts are linearly aligned. Efficiently achieve rotational stability through simple movement operations. The proposed cleaning is flexible as its selectivity is determined from any typical container-like sample in an automatic preparation procedure.

Barman et al (2013) Retinal blood vessels' appearance is a primary diagnostic indicator for many scientific questions regarding care and the body. Retinal blood vessels have been shown to provide clues in terms of change in diameter or branching or zigzag angles attributable to the eyes' location. This article discusses improving a mechanical technique for retinal vascular segmentation. A specific set of strategies presented to discover the retina's vascular skeleton and multidirectional morphological bit-level segmentation to extract blood vessels from retinal colour images. The skeleton of primary vessels extracted by applying differential directional factors evaluated the combination of secondary product markers and common by-product values. Mathematical morphology has emerged as an efficient approach to identifying retinal blood vessels in fundus shots. An omnidirectional operator was used with rotating structuring factors to emphasize ships on a particular route, and statistics are extracted by cutting the bit level. The repeat site growth approach is implemented to incorporate the primary skeleton and images due to the bit-level reduction of the morphological filters based on the antigenic pathway. The method is examined in two publicly available databases, DRIVE and STARE.

Krizhevsky et al. (2012) they trained a deep and meaningful convolutional neural network to classify 1.2 million high-resolution images in the ImageNet LSVRC-2010 competition into 1,000 different lessons. Our verification info ended up with the top five error charges of 37.5% and 17.0%, which may be much better than previous charges today. The neural network, which includes 60 million parameters and 650,000 neurons, includes five convolutional layers, some of which have maximal confrontation layers and three layers perfectly linked by a thousand SoftMax strategies. To make teaching faster, we use unsaturated neurons and an environmentally friendly GPU application of torsion shape. To reduce the over-allocation of the viable layers, in the long run, we assigned a currently cutting-edge company method known as “letting go,” which has been very effective. Also, we inserted a replica of this version in opposition to ILSVRC-2012 and had a top 5 wins with an error loading of 15%, compared to the 26.2% performed with the second successful entry.

Cheung et al (2011) one suggestion for the automated segmentation of retinal vasculitis, which becomes a crucial diagnostic technique in ocular vasculitis, includes vascular types, that is, thin vessels and large vessels. Therefore, the segmentation approach may also require great strategies for dealing with unmarried vessels. However, traditional segmentation algorithms never differentiate between long and thin vessels and treat them en masse instead. The main problems with these strategies are: (1) if more emphasis is placed on removing the thin vessels, the larger vessels tend to be over-observed; Additional industrial vessels are also being constructed. (2) If you pay higher interest for jumbo boats, slim and fast rating boats are likely not available. This article presents a unique retinal vascular removal scheme that relies on radial projection and a semi-supervised approach to overcome these issues. The radial projection technique is used to detect the initial effects of thin, low-contrast vessels.

3. Proposed methodolgoy

We use ICA to decorate retinal vasculature in contrast To your records by suppressing noise in three neutral RGB additions to the fundus image. ICA has architectures used in signal processing packages; in this paper, each normalization frame's overall performance for comparison is cited. It facilitates choosing the right ICA frame for fundus imaging of the retina. This document makes important contributions illustrated in the following information.

1) As it is known, the retina image consists of 3 unique pigments due to melanin, hemoglobin, and yellow macula, which can be compared to the three shadow channels of the retinal image. ICA can define three as three color channels to improve ICA, most likely without noise.

2) To put into practice the proposed image enhancement method, we shortened a 3-step procedure based on ICA. The first step is to tackle noise difficulty. The second step is to use ICA to decorate the visualization of retinal vasculature, even when lane 0.33 converts color-unbiased RGB additions directly into a single grayscale image.

(4)

4608

Independent Component Analysis (ICA) is a machine learning technique to divide the independent sources from the embedded signal. In contrast to extensive object analysis, which specializes in maximizing statistical point variance, independent problem assessment specializes in autonomy, i.e., independent component

X = AS (1)

Equation 1 represents the analytical version of ICA that represents unbiased additions. It is taken into account that the general vector X and the neutral emission vector S are random vectors with mean 0 (focused) and unit variance. The vector A is known as the matrix A of the neutral object. Matrix A is an unknown square matrix. Likewise, the independent emission vector S is assumed to have a non-Gaussian distribution.

In ICA analytic modes, the independent emission has a non-Gaussian distribution. The main feature of the ICA version is its ability to strike non-Gaussian cases. The evaluation is entirely dependent on the random vector X. The critical objective is to estimate the unknown additives A and S using X. If the estimation of the unknown aggregate matrix A is possible, it is easy to compute the inverse of it including W and harvest the unbiased emission vector S, given by using:

S = A−1X = WX (2)

After a forced evaluation of the contrast enhancement technique, we observed its effect on retinal vascular segmentation. When it comes to the range of treating rolls, we use various proven boat improvement plans. More specifically, a multi-band Laplacian Gaussian reagent for vascular beautification has been proposed. Finally, a dual switch is lowered that mainly relies on sunken morphological reconstructive technology for vessel synchronization.

The ICA might be best configured by your common model, as shown in Equation 1.

The primary purpose is to observe the exceptionally functioning ICA architecture in the retina image to beautify retinal vasculature evaluation.

The proposed algorithm for retinal vessels segmentation is outlined as follows

Step 1: The first grade addresses the problem of confusing facts. Morphological strategies to overcome the intermittent illumination for each channel are realized from the fundus staining image of the retina.

Step 2: The proposed ICA optimization is implemented when all channels exit the image above to obtain acceptable contrast.

Step 3: The third step deals with converting color image to grayscale image, while PCA is implemented, so that retina images obtain a gray image with adequate contrast.

Step 4: This step is afraid with the boosting the vessels, which depends entirely on the normalization parameters of the detector scale of the second class of the so-called α and β

Step 5: After normalization of the scale, the vessels' uneven depth, But it is present with some broken ridges. To deal with this inconvenience, anisotropic directed diffusion filter is used.

Step 6: Flood-filled morphological reconstructions are used to imaging well-segmented vessels.

The proposed system is developed using MATLAB based Graphical User Interface (GUI) tool. This provides a non-technical user to recognize the result merely using a button operation. In this work, an algorithm was formulated to segment the blood vessels in fundus images by utilizing the above-explained steps. Load input image, Grayscale conversion, Gabor filtering, Image Binarization, Independent component analysis are the stages proposed in the work.

4. System architecture

As shown in the figure, 1 the proposed framework divided into various stages to classify the blood vessels from the given retinal image.

a) Pre-processing

Pre-process is done to extract the region of Interest (ROI). In the instrumental diagnosis of diabetic retinopathy, treating the extensive historical past and noisy areas in the retina image is not vital and takes longer to treat at any level. The main goal at this stage is to eliminate noise from the retinal image. Cutting or cropping the place that comprises the retina's photographic function reduces the diversity of operations on the image of the retina.

(5)

4609

Fig.1 system architecture

b) Filtering

In this filtering stage Gabor filter used to perform parameter filters. Gabor filter is the most commonly used method for vascular optimization, and its performance is highly dependent on parameters. Therefore, various parameter settings have been tested, and the quality results produced by Gabor Filter Out are mentioned here. We initialized the filter parameters, including wavelength, bandwidth, orientation, etc. and using these parameters, we calculated the size of the Gabor filter core and built a mask grid, and then built a two-dimensional Gabor cleaning core with the correct selection of the parametric values and finally, we combined Image with filter core.

c) Blood Vessel segmentation

The monochromatic RGB retinal image is taken as a 2D Gabor wavelet, and it uses to optimize the vascular sample, especially the thin and less transparent vessels that optimizes with a Gabor wave. Before removing the vessels to get a better image of the retina, the vessels sharpens with a spike cleaner. A binary vessel segmentation mask is created by detecting the vessel’s edges from a sharp image. The vasculature differentiates with a guard operation which assigns one for all vessels and zeroes for the nonvascular pixel. The final, refined vessel segmentation mask is constructed using the morphological expansion operator.

d) Classification

The method familiar to most studies of the vessel class in bottom photos includes five steps: Vessel segmentation.

Selection of ROI for classification of your vessels.

Typical extraction characteristics of particular vessel components.

The characteristic vector class and combine the results to determine the container's final designation.

In general, three functional extraction procedures are considered: totally pixel-based and mainly based on profile and phase-based feature extraction tactics. The side profile is a small boat with a pixel thickness perpendicular to the direction of the boat.

The proposed container class technologies can be classified into two broad categories, which are automatic and semi-automatic. In semi-automatic strategies, dominant vessels usually classify by an expert as a vein or artery in their primary factors. These labels are then propagated through the vessel community through vessel monitoring algorithms that use the vascular tree's contact records and structural features. On the other hand, the traditional

(6)

4610

approach to automatic strategies is as follows: first, the vessels' central line's pixels that make up the skeleton of the vessel extracted from the segmented image of the bottom.

Many writing routines use functions that describe color and hue differences within containers. The main problem with classification is that the tone of blood released into the vessels varies between images or even the same difficulty. This discrepancy is the amount of oxygen saturation with hemoglobin, aging, development of cataracts, differences in flash intensity, flash spectrum, and nonlinear optical distortions of a digital camera, flash effects, and consciousness.

The final image also includes noise and some unwanted elements. Noise is removed through image erosion. Unwanted elements are eliminated by contemplating the function of which the most straightforward blood vessels are linear in appearance. Figures shows the results of blood vessel segmentation algorithm applying on the retinal image (a) (b) (c) (d)

Fig.2 a) Given input image of fundus b) Output of CLAHE on green channel c) Subtraction result of (b) d) Segmented blood vessels.

(7)

4611

Tests of the proposed technique are completed to recognize the accuracy of vessel segmentation through the use of a publicly available DRIVE database and retina images with various features. The DRIVE database consists of forty RGB color photographs of the retina. The images are 768 x 584 pixels long, 8 bits per color channel. The image set is divided directly into the Verification and Education Set, and each consists of 20 images. Test equipment is used to quantify the overall performance of vessel segmentation algorithms. Manual labeling is available for all 20 images in the test kit captured by a single human observer. The manually segmented image to the first human observer is used as the core fact. The slices of group B are examined instead of the group a, which serves as a reference for the human observer of the overall performance comparison fact. Group B's classifications are compared with those of group a, serving as a reference for the human observer for overall performance variance. The most common metrics in evaluating classifiers in standard responses and vessel segmentation are primarily used to assess release performance. These metrics include Accuracy (ACC), True Positive Rate (TPR), True Negative Rate (TNR), F-measure (F1).

We get four measurements: the vessel pixels are referred to as true positives (TP), overhead pixels predicted as non-vessels are referred to as false negatives (FN), and non-vessels pixels are referred to as true negatives (TN), and pixels non-vessels pixels projected vessels where vessels are indicated as false positive (FP). Each metric, as the equation is shown below

𝐴𝑐𝑐𝑢𝑟𝑎𝑐𝑦 = 𝑇𝑃+𝑇𝑁

𝑇𝑃+𝑇𝑁+𝐹𝑃+𝐹𝑁

𝑇𝑃𝑅 = 𝑇𝑃/(𝑇𝑃 + 𝐹𝑁) 𝐹𝑃𝑅 = 𝐹𝑃/(𝐹𝑃 + 𝑇𝑁)

Machine learning models Accuracy Error

ANN 0.946 0.308

Naïve Bayes 0.95 0.26

ICA 0.982 0.0218

Fig.3 Accuracy comparison between various algorithms

As shown in the figure, 3 the proposed algorithm shows higher accuracy with 0.982 when compared with other algorithms.

6. Comparison between various methods

Table Comparison between various authors implantation in Blood vessels segmentation Author with

year

Method used Accurac y Proposed work Independent component analysis (ICA) 98.2%. S. Prabha et al[2020] Tyler Cowie's algorithm 84% Lee et al [2019] Convolutional neural network (CNN) 83% A.Bernisha et al.[2018] Naïve Bayes (NB) algorithm 95% 0 0.5 1 1.5

ANN Naïve Bayes ICA

A cc u rac y Algorithms Accuracy Error

(8)

4612

Dr. Kulwinder et al [2017] Artificial neural network(ANN) 94.6% Jung et al[2017] Generative Adversarial Networks (GAN) 82.9% Kipf et al[2016] Graph Convolutional Network ( GCN) model 82.5%

Fig.4 Accuracy comparison between various authors

As shown in the figure.4, the accuracy comparison of various authors taken and evaluated accuracy of various methods. The proposed method shows the higher accuracy when compared with previous author’s implementation.

7. Conclusion

The automated vessel image investigation device has been confirmed as a reliable tool for the correct segmentation of retinal images. In this study attempt, we implemented and established an image evaluation optimization technique based on a machine learning-based ICA model. The purpose was to solve the issue of intra-image contrast and its detrimental impact on accurate intra-image segmentation. In this paper we have implemented an automatic retinal blood vessel segmentation technique for the early diagnosis of diseases. Our algorithm successfully detects the blood vessels from the background and accomplish an accuracy of 98.2%.

References

1. Carmeliet P and R. Jain K., 2000, “Angiogenesis in cancer and other diseases”, pp. 249–257.

2. A. R. Rudnicka and M. M. Fraz, 2012, “Blood vessel segmentation methodologies in retinal images–a survey,” pp. 407–433.

3. Abullah M.Shoeb and Gehad Hassan, 2015, "Retinal blood vessel segmentation approach based on mathematical morphology", pp. 612 – 622

4. K.Sakthidasan Sankaran and Prabha S, 2020, “Retinal Image Analysis Using Machine Learning”, pp.1410-1413.

5. K. M. Lee and D. Yun, 2019, “Deep vessel segmentation by learning graphical connectivity,” p. 101556. 6. C. A. Silva and A.Oliveira, 2018, “Retinal vessel segmentation based on fully convolutional neural networks,”

pp. 229–242.

7. K.-H. Jung and Son J, 2017, “Retinal vessel segmentation in fundoscopic images with generative adversarial networks”.

8. Kipf T. N. and M. Welling, 2016, “Semi-supervised classification with graph convolutional networks,” 9. Petkov N. and Azzopardi G, 2015, “Trainable cosfire filters for vessel delineation with application to retinal

images,”, pp. 46–57.

10. S. A. Barman and Basit A, 2013, “Application of morphological bit planes in retinal blood vessel extraction.”,pp. 274–286.

11. Krizhevsky and G. E. Hinton, 2012, “Imagenet classification with deep CNN,” pp. 1097–1105.

12. J. Lei and Y.-m. Cheung, 2011, “Segmentation of retinal blood vessels using the radial step and semi-supervised method,” pp. 2314–2324.

98.20%

84% 83%

95% 94.60%

(9)

4613

13. Dr. Kulwinder S Mann and Sukhpreet Kaur, 201“Segmentation of Retinal Blood Vessels using Artificial

Neural Networks for early detection of Diabetic Retinopathy”, pp. 0200261- 0200269.

Referanslar

Benzer Belgeler

Cep Sanat Galerisinde Kişisel Sergi Bursa Devlet Güzel Sanatlar Galerisi Kişisel Sergi ve. Çeşitli Karma Sergilere

zîrîadığv muhit sanatıyla ilgili bir ^ eser, estetik güzellikle koku hissi v arasında çarpışmaya yol açmış,. , mücadelede burun galip gelmiş

MERÎKAN Associated Press Haber Ajansı ünlü şair Nâzım Hikmet ile ilgili bir makale yayınladı.. Ajans, ‘Nazım ülkesini sevdiğini söyledi, yıllarca

Among the groups in which there is a statistically significant difference, sports managers with 7 years or more of professional experience in the sub-factor of

Tahsin, ayrıca “sıkıntı melankolisi”, “aşk melankolisi”, “dini melankoli” (1920: 201) gibi çeşitlerden söz edildiğini, kadınlarda menapozla birlikte ortaya

• Düşük su/çimento oranı, • Düşük kıvamlı beton (10-14 cm), • Çimento dozajının arttırılması, • C 3 S miktarı yüksek çimento kullanımı, • Yüksek

Table 5.3, shows false positive rate, true positive rate, segmentation accuracy, specificity and area under curve results of all 20 test images of DRIVE

The blue and black points show the received power and threshold for User 1, respectively; the red and green points show the received power and threshold for User 2, respectively;