• Sonuç bulunamadı

Hakemli Makale: Hukukta Bilimsel Yaklaşımın Önemi

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Hakemli Makale: Hukukta Bilimsel Yaklaşımın Önemi"

Copied!
25
0
0

Yükleniyor.... (view fulltext now)

Tam metin

(1)TBB Dergisi 2010 (90). Sedat ÇAL. 39.          . Sedat ÇAL. Özet 

(2)   

(3)  

(4)       

(5)     

(6)    

(7)              

(8)  

(9)        .     

(10) 

(11)  

(12)        

(13) 

(14) 

(15)  !!

(16) " 

(17) #     

(18)     

(19)     !

(20) 

(21)  

(22)   

(23)      

(24) 

(25) 

(26) $   % 

(27)  

(28) & 

(29) ' 

(30) 

(31)   

(32)   

(33)  

(34)       ! "

(35) 

(36)  

(37)  (        

(38)    

(39)   

(40)   

(41) 

(42)   

(43) $       &   

(44)  &  

(45)   

(46)  Anahtar Sözcükler      "" 

(47)  

(48)       Abstract)    *   &

(49)   &   +&&

(50)   

(51)   ,   

(52) .  

(53)     

(54) 

(55)  

(56)      + &&

(57)       /    

(58)    *  

(59)  

(60)  &

(61)    

(62)   

(63)     &

(64)   )      

(65)    

(66)     *      0   

(67) 0*   &   

(68)   *     

(69)     + ,  

(70)   & &

(71) 1& 

(72)  &

(73)   &        *%*     

(74)   *'2

(75) 

(76) 

(77)   

(78)   +. 

(79)  

(80)   

(81)      

(82)  

(83)   !" #$%  & '()*  +  ,

(84) +

(85) . +* '/. hakemli makaleler / refereed articles. HUKUKTA  

(86)  .

(87) 40. 

(88)    . &&

(89) 

(90) 3

(91)  

(92)    

(93)   

(94)   4    

(95)     

(96)  3 * 

(97)      * 

(98)  Keywords   + &&

(99)         

(100)    *  

(101)    &&

(102) .  

(103)

(104) 

(105)  

(106)  

(107)      

(108)        

(109)  

(110)      

(111)  !  " 0 (12 *LULü 

(112)  ' 3        (

(113)  3 %  4

(114)  ' 

(115) 3 %  (

(116) 

(117) ' 3  ,

(118) 2 (3

(119) 2 (

(120) 4

(121) 

(122) *,,1 

(123)   .

(124)  3*,,

(125) ' 3 

(126)  ,

(127) 2 ((

(128) 34 '  4,,(" 4

(129) '  

(130)  (

(131) ,(

(132)  3  (

(133) ,

(134)

(135)  ,  (

(136) *      6.

(137) 4

(138)

(139) 

(140)   ,

(141) ,%   

(142)  4,

(143)  .  (

(144) 

(145)  ,

(146) 4

(147) 

(148)

(149)  / *4 4

(150) ' 4 3  3 7 (

(151)  4

(152)  

(153)     

(154)   '     , , 

(155)  .

(156) 4

(157)

(158)  4 ,2 4 3 

(159) 4

(160)  

(161) 4,

(162) ,, (

(163) 4

(164)

(165)  % 4, 

(166)

(167) 

(168) *,, 

(169)  / 4   8

(170)  3  %

(171)  (*, ( , % ( 

(172) (

(173) 

(174) '

(175) 4  8

(176) ,3

(177) 2

(178) 2

(179)    2 1. 2. :,,, 4  (

(180)  4

(181)  

(182)   

(183)  

(184) 4

(185)   %  4, 4

(186)   *,,

(187) "  %  *,,,4

(188) 

(189) 

(190) 

(191) 4

(192) ( (

(193) (

(194) 2 ,, (

(195) 4

(196) '  3 42;

(197) :,, 1  %  < =   +  >(?"  

(198)  14

(199)

(200) #  $ %

(201)  &! ! !'

(202)

(203)  

(204) 

(205)  (#$& )@B "::(  C

(206) 3  /D4,

(207) ,D4,

(208) EBBFGH  .

(209) 4

(210)

(211) 

(212)    ' 

(213)  *,,

(214) ,%, (4 

(215) 

(216) '

(217) (  

(218)    2 4,

(219)

(220)  ((

(221)  4

(222)   *   3    4  , % 4, (

(223)  ( (

(224)  4,

(225) ,4

(226)   *   *  ,3 

(227)   / ' 

(228)

(229) 

(230)    4  3  ( 3+ >( *,, 

(231)  4 , 3 4  8

(232) 3 4*

(233) 4

(234)    4  I ,J      , , 4

(235)   I4   8

(236)  + %"J      (   

(237)  *.

(238)  3,

(239) ,

(240) ' 

(241) 4

(242) 4CK

(243)   :,, 

(244)  

(245) 14

(246) =   AÜHFD)M@(EEBBEE/? (-.

(247) TBB Dergisi 2010 (90). Sedat ÇAL. 41. , ,,  3 3 %       4  ( N,(,  (

(248)  24 3 

(249) 

(250)  3    N     ( %   7 “* 

(251) +

(252) #  ,

(253)

(254) 

(255)  -  .

(256) 

(257)  +

(258)  (/0123)  4 6  4 6 ! 4!  

(259)    !66    78

(260)  

(261) 

(262) !

(263) !9

(264) 

(265)       

(266) 

(267) 4 !4  3+"3 C   *,,,  4

(268)

(269)    ' +  4

(270)  

(271)  3   4, 

(272)

(273)    3  4 42'2   2   8 ( ( % 

(274)  P “:

(275)  + ;  6 

(276) 

(277)

(278)   !<

(279)

(280)  

(281)  !  

(282)    .

(283)  

(284)  ;    3 =

(285)   6 

(286)  

(287)

(288)   !< 

(289)

(290)  

(291)  

(292) 

(293)  4  !

(294) % 

(295)

(296)    <

(297) 

(298) 3 >   !        

(299)    !<

(300)

(301)  

(302) 

(303)  

(304)   6 

(305) 

(306)

(307)   

(308)  

(309) ;   ;  ! 6 

(310) 

(311)  

(312) 4 

(313)

(314)     3JF K  .

(315) 4

(316)

(317) 

(318)  "

(319) , "

(320) , % (      2  ,

(321)   '    ( 3 4  

(322)

(323) . 

(324)    +     4(

(325)  4  

(326)  

(327) 4

(328)  ,(

(329) 

(330) 2(

(331) 4

(332)

(333)  % 4, *,,,.

(334)  4

(335) 

(336)  (

(337) 2 42

(338) + '    4

(339) 

(340)  3

(341)  %  (

(342) ,

(343)

(344)  '    4

(345)  :,,

(346)  ' 3  ,

(347) 2  3 . .

(348) 4

(349)

(350) 

(351)  

(352) ,,' 4 

(353)  4  

(354). (

(355) 4?" Q(  

(356) 

(357)   

(358) "-M(  ,

(359)

(360)  '   % 0 . 3. F. M. 

(361) " 

(362) 3( 

(363) ,, *,,3,,    (

(364) 

(365) 4  *,,

(366) ,(' 

(367)

(368) 

(369) %   (N.

(370) 4

(371) +

(372) 8 

(373) 2

(374)    "*N I ,,  4

(375) J 

(376)   R'

(377) Q *,,

(378)     8  (

(379) I

(380)  9  J/ R  

(381) ,:,,  ? %R

(382) : " /#  $ %

(383)  &! ! !'

(384)

(385)  

(386) 

(387) (#$& )@B "::(  C

(388) 3  /D4,

(389) ,D4,

(390)  EBBFFF 

(391) 3T,* :,,

(392) % 6 

(393)  T  

(394)  R

(395)  ,,PU

(396)  V:   

(397)    R

(398) HFSA@E "::(  C

(399) 3  /I:,, U

(400)  V% (

(401)  2

(402) N$$J "(, WQ@@(

(403) 

(404) EBBFD4,

(405) 

(406) 

(407) X@D4,

(408) ,D4,

(409) EBBMGF

(410) ("

(411)     Y(  % 

(412) 2 /  4

(413) * ("R:,,U

(414)   Z EM,,

(415) ,2(

(416)  % 

(417)  (

(418) ("

(419) ,2 AÜHFM)W[QF@GMB@BQEB.

(420) 42. 

(421)    . "

(422) ,  (('      ! "36,

(423)  *,,

(424)  

(425) 

(426) ,,+

(427) 

(428)  Y+ +

(429)    % (

(430) 4 3  

(431). ( '

(432)  74,,("  

(433)   4 (

(434) 2  '

(435)   '   R4  

(436) 2 

(437) 42

(438) 

(439) 

(440)   

(441)  

(442)   '

(443)  +  4 (" 3     2 

(444) 

(445)   33 ( ,

(446)  '   +   (

(447) +  *,,

(448)  (

(449) 2   4 (

(450)  2 

(451) +  4  

(452) 

(453)  ,

(454)   

(455)  

(456)    ,

(457)  % 

(458)  4 42* "

(459) , 

(460) 4 ,, 

(461) 4

(462)    ,3

(463) 2  *,,4

(464) 

(465) 4 (

(466) 2  '

(467)   '     2   ( % 4,4

(468)  (

(469) 

(470) (3 2      

(471) 

(472)    3  (  '(, ,, ,+,   *,,, 4

(473) 

(474) 4 (

(475) 2 *' 4

(476)   ,

(477) (4

(478)     4,3

(479) 2   + 4 "  *

(480)    

(481) +   ,%LOLPVHO<DNODü×P×Q%HOLUJLQg]HOOLNOHUL C+

(482) 

(483)  %,',

(484)   '    *,, 2, ,   4

(485)    ". ,

(486)   *+ 42

(487) +

(488) '  

(489) 2'2

(490)    

(491)  % 84,

(492) *

(493)

(494) (*,2

(495) ' 4 *,,

(496)   3

(497)  2 

(498)   4  ,(',

(499)   4,

(500)  '.   ( 2 (   ( 4

(501) 

(502)  * '4 "2

(503)  : 4 V  +

(504)     ,8

(505)  . 4

(506) 4  4 

(507)  (

(508) ( (,7  9 

(509) " N*

(510) 4  (

(511) N !9 

(512) "  ( 3% 69 

(513) "2“cedel 6 "'2

(514)   4

(515)  # @

(516)    

(517) " ( 2    2    ' 4 *   N

(518)  

(519) 4

(520) % 4  4  *     ',

(521)  ( ,4

(522) 4  N 2  : 9 

(523) " 2(

(524)

(525) 

(526)   "3"   4  "4 9 6  "%     "N   ( 2

(527)   

(528)  

(529)     !    "N'  2 4

(530)  6. K :,,U

(531) 

(532)   C  ?

(533)  ,! ,

(534) 

(535) <

(536) (?,,)B    & 9! R EBB[ *"PXX]]]44 

(537) 'X(( 

(538) X 

(539)

(540) X ', +/.

(541) TBB Dergisi 2010 (90). Sedat ÇAL. 43. 

(542) ((

(543)  4

(544)  

(545)     (' 3 *

(546)   4

(547)  2 

(548) ,    

(549)  

(550) 2%

(551)  ( 

(552) * 34  2+ % ((

(553) 2 ', 42

(554)  % '  

(555)   **

(556)   "  ( 4

(557)  4 4 (  

(558) '  

(559) 7 “#

(560) 4< 6%    C &  

(561)  ; 

(562)   

(563)   EJW 8   33(( ,,  4

(564) 

(565)  %

(566)  

(567) 4

(568) 4  %  

(569)  

(570)  2+    

(571)   4

(572)   4 %* 4 

(573) N

(574) N4 2,

(575) 

(576)   

(577)     (   3 

(578) (

(579) 2 3 3 %   

(580) * 4 '+ *

(581)

(582)  * *

(583)   4 ' 3 % PD

(584)  

(585) 

(586)  2+ 

(587)   4

(588) (    

(589) ,3

(590) 4 3  

(591) 2

(592) ( 

(593) *  

(594) 34  ^*  ^*  3434 ,2

(595)  ' ( *(

(596) ,4 3 4 

(597) + (

(598)  '

(599).  HRZ    ' 4 7 “,

(600)  

(601)   

(602) <

(603) 

(604)   !   ! 6 !     

(605) !3 G  

(606) <

(607) 

(608) 

(609)

(610)  4 <

(611) 

(612)  

(613) 3! ! 6!    

(614) 4 <

(615) 

(616) 

(617) 4!  

(618)       4 <

(619) ; 

(620)

(621) 

(622) 

(623)  4 

(624)

(625) 3JG ,  4

(626) 

(627)  

(628) * 4 '2' 3 

(629)  % ((  

(630)   ',

(631)        

(632)   %   

(633)  

(634)  ,  10 (

(635) +  4  '2 * 4     % 2 W H. G. 10.  ( 0 (12Z(   D2 4,  

(636) (  4 "

(637) , (

(638)  

(639)  

(640)   + 4 ,2 3     ( 

(641)  7 4,  * 

(642)   

(643) (  ,2

(644)  

(645) 

(646)  4 3 '

(647) 2  

(648) 

(649)  ,  (

(650)  ,2

(651)  8*

(652) (

(653) + 

(654)  4,''

(655)  2,,: %4 ( N , % ((

(656)  %

(657) 

(658)   3 3 %   % '

(659)      %

(660) +

(661) (

(662) Q(  4,

(663) ,(: %4 (  

(664)    3+,

(665) (  +

(666)  ,, , '

(667)    %   

(668)     

(669)  % 4,(

(670)

(671) "

(672) , ,' 

(673)   '

(674) 2   % ' +  

(675) (.   ) * R3(

(676) 

(677) , R %     6        ( @GH@  [`[/Z PCT    ,

(678)

(679)  I

(680)  

(681)  64 (REBBW@B@ K+

(682) (2 * 34    ' 3 2 2

(683)  3, 

(684) 

(685) 

(686) '2

(687)  (

(688) "

(689) , ,( 

(690)  

(691) % 

(692)

(693) 

(694) (

(695) 4

(696)

(697) 

(698)     *

(699)  ( ' 3  

(700) 4

(701) 

(702) 

(703) 

(704) '2

(705) ((4

(706)

(707)  .

(708) 44. 

(709)    .  

(710) ((

(711) 4,'22 4,

(712)  % (

(713) 2   , (   4*

(714). ( +   

(715)

(716) 

(717) %,',

(718)  '    <   6*,,,,'

(719) 2  N 2  

(720) 4  34% %  (

(721) N

(722) 4 

(723)  2

(724) 114 4(:+Z 8  (

(725) 7 “#

(726) 4

(727)   4 

(728) 6 6! 

(729) ! @ 

(730) 

(731)     <

(732) 

(733) 3,

(734) @

(735)  

(736)  

(737) ! 

(738)  

(739)   

(740) 9 

(741) 

(742)  .      

(743) 6 ! 3#!@

(744)  !  ! 6  

(745)  3  

(746)    % 

(747) @

(748) !<  

(749) 

(750) 6

(751)  

(752) 9 

(753) 

(754)

(755) 3J

(756) !@ 

(757) !<   

(758) 

(759) <

(760)     @ 

(761)  %  !< <

(762) 

(763) 3J12 K    4   '2   8 (

(764) 7 “#   ;< 

(765) 

(766) 

(767)    

(768) 6  

(769)   

(770) 

(771)

(772)  ;< 

(773)   

(774) 

(775) <

(776)  . 6  6

(777)  

(778) 

(779) <

(780) 

(781) 6  

(782) 

(783)

(784) 

(785)  6 6! ;<  ! <;;    3J13 C (   % ((' 3 *

(786)  (,

(787) '2

(788)    4

(789)  %  (

(790)  ,,

(791)  4, ,, ,% . + 4 3 

(792) 

(793) (  

(794) (

(795)  (+: 2Z 4,(   8     

(796)    7 “K   

(797) 

(798) 9!% ;@ 

(799)   

(800) 

(801)   

(802) 

(803) 

(804) 

(805) 4

(806)   @ <

(807) 

(808) 3- @

(809)  

(810)  -. 11. 12 13. 

(811)  4,( 4 (

(812) 4

(813) '

(814) ,( * 

(815) (%  '  '

(816) 4,

(817) ,R2b (

(818) Z (*,,,  Z '  '  (*,(   

(819) %   2T3% (< 2 2Z(

(820) 

(821) (

(822) "

(823) , 

(824) ("%4/,

(825)   '2

(826)  ' 3 

(827)  %  (  +3, %* 4 + (,

(828) '2

(829)   *

(830)  '( : 2Z 

(831)   % *,,   * 4

(832) '   

(833)

(834) 

(835)  ' 3 ), *, ( Z  *,,     I (  *,,3,J (  2 

(836) 4

(837)   3  

(838) 4 %

(839)  %  (

(840) 34'   *,,, (

(841) 4

(842) '  3 4 : 2# 6:RR@GHM[W`[WW : 21 :,, D

(843) cD"% 6 8 AÜHFD)@@@GF[@GH K R 6 ( Z :,,C  ?

(844)  ,! ,

(845) 

(846) <

(847) (?,,)B   & 9!REBB[*"PXX]]]44 

(848) 'X(( 

(849) X 

(850)

(851) X  ',  +/.

(852) TBB Dergisi 2010 (90). Sedat ÇAL. 45.    

(853) 6

(854)   

(855) 

(856) <

(857)  

(858) 

(859) 4

(860)   !< <

(861)  

(862)  

(863) 

(864)  

(865) 

(866) 

(867) 3J@F >(    '

(868)  ('  

(869)  

(870)  4  ,,   8  + %  + 4 2 

(871)  3

(872) 2 

(873)  

(874) % 8

(875) '

(876) ('

(877) 2    '

(878)    (  '2* 34 4 3 (,

(879)  ' 4 *,,

(880)   (  (

(881)  

(882) 4

(883)       %   '    7 '

(884) 3 ,(    (, 2

(885)  +

(886)   

(887)  2

(888) 

(889) (

(890) '

(891)   

(892) 2 

(893) ('

(894)  (3 ,, , 4  3

(895) 2   *%  + 4 3 

(896) 

(897) (  

(898)  

(899)   3 

(900) %

(901) 

(902)   % ( 

(903)     (*,

(904) 2    '

(905)  ' 4 4,*,,(

(906) *' ( %   * *' 4 '2 '

(907)     N

(908) 

(909)     4 3 N3

(910) '

(911) 4

(912) @M,2

(913) (,(,N

(914) 

(915) ('

(916)  *(3  3+  4   

(917)  N

(918) 

(919) 

(920) 4 4 4

(921) 

(922) (

(923) 2 (  

(924) 

(925)  ,(',

(926)  ,  (

(927) 

(928)  4 3   

(929).

(930)   3  '2

(931)    334 3 (( 4 

(932) 3

(933) 2 

(934)  *. ( '

(935) 4

(936)    *,,,   4  

(937)  ( (

(938)  

(939) 4 

(940). ( (  +

(941)  16 ,,%LOLPGH(OHüWLULQLQ.Do×Q×OPD]O×ù× 

(942) 

(943)   2 '      2  

(944) 

(945)   6 " 3  

(946)      * N*

(947)

(948) 

(949)     N',

(950)   ,, ,  < %     6;" @F @M. 16. : 21 :,, D

(951) cD"% 6 8 !93

(952) 3@[W K4(R  8X66,',N #  )@F6,* 4 % EBB``HEQ`HM  466,',O !!

(953) G#  :  

(954) 6,* 4 % REB@B[W@[WE R(( ) HER(ZK  %

(955)  U

(956) ( R

(957) 6   T=D4,

(958) @GGHFEWFEH((

(959)   2/R(T*.  RT/    ((

(960)  4 42      

(961)  (

(962)  

(963).

(964)    

(965)   ( %  

(966) 

(967) , (

(968) '    4 3 N

(969) 2 

(970)   %   '2

(971)   %,',

(972)  ,  (

(973) Q 4

(974) 

(975)  (

(976) 2  '  

(977)    4(

(978) +  (  %        4 R(( ) N #  +>

(979) 

(980) 6:  P! )$$ 

(981)  % D4,

(982) EBBHGHQ@B@/.

(983) 46. 

(984)    .          2       

(985) 2     8    N% (  % 

(986)  "N   8   N

(987) 

(988) " (*, 6

(989) 6

(990) 

(991) 

(992) 6 !" %4 3

(993) ,

(994) 

(995) 4

(996)     ".  (

(997) N" 4 '   *N2  ! 

(998) 

(999)  

(1000) 4 

(1001)  

(1002)   "     

(1003) * 

(1004) N 2 4 ' 2    

(1005)   (*,,,,, * ( ' 4

(1006) +     9 

(1007) "

(1008) %

(1009) N'   3

(1010) ,,N4(4 *      7'  4

(1011) 

(1012) c'

(1013)  

(1014) ,".

(1015) 4 '  

(1016)

(1017)    2   2 4, 

(1018) 2 

(1019) (  ^ N% *

(1020) N

(1021)   

(1022)  C   4  4 

(1023) '2   

(1024)    7 “#  4 

(1025) 

(1026)  

(1027)    4!  

(1028) 

(1029)  6

(1030)  

(1031) !   6

(1032) 

(1033)  O?GNJOPKOO"     !  3 O 6

(1034) 

(1035)   

(1036)    

(1037) !

(1038) %9 !  %     Q

(1039)  

(1040)   

(1041) 6  3J@W ,,

(1042)  4 

(1043)   

(1044)   

(1045) 2    "

(1046) , 

(1047)  ("     4,'   *

(1048)  

(1049)  (     %

(1050)  

(1051) '   K    (2   

(1052) % '   3  (2   "

(1053) ,  

(1054) 

(1055)      %

(1056)  

(1057) (

(1058)  4 3  '

(1059)

(1060)  ,(',

(1061)  

(1062) 

(1063)   

(1064) 2  

(1065) ,

(1066) ,

(1067)   

(1068)  4 (   3,

(1069) ,

(1070)  ' 4 *2,,

(1071) ,

(1072) 2

(1073)  '   @H(',

(1074)   4  

(1075)  2  4       3

(1076) 2 ("

(1077) 8'  +  9 

(1078)  

(1079) 

(1080) <

(1081) 

(1082) "+ 3      '2 (

(1083) 

(1084) 2  ( ( % 

(1085)   8 + 

(1086)    <", 4

(1087)   % ,3 "4 %4  4,

(1088) (( 

(1089)  2

(1090) 2 + 4    C

(1091)

(1092) 

(1093)    (2  *,,   ( 

(1094)   

(1095) 2  ( .  

(1096).  +

(1097) 

(1098) 4

(1099) '

(1100) 2  4    +  

(1101)  2 4 

(1102)  4 '   4,( 2* (   ,%% 

(1103)   2 @W. @H. R6,,

(1104) ICJ 3  f8 :!< G ?  #  &

(1105)  

(1106) N4

(1107) 

(1108)  

(1109)  ! 6:RREBBMb$$$ ,( 4   3 4?

(1110)  R

(1111) ("U  % D2

(1112) 

(1113)  

(1114)    ,:   D  (%

(1115) @GGGR(  2 

(1116) 

(1117)  ? 3 %     2  G  6   G!%    EE TQT(Q: Q  QR

(1118) /,% ) %"

(1119)  /REBBH@@G.

(1120) TBB Dergisi 2010 (90). Sedat ÇAL. 47. 4   ( ((4

(1121) 3 

(1122) 2

(1123) 2

(1124) (

(1125)  4

(1126)   4 

(1127) 2  4

(1128)   *.    '    4,

(1129) (4    (V(  38

(1130) 

Referanslar

Benzer Belgeler

“Impact Factor” de benzer şekilde, SCI veya SCI-Expanded veri tabanına kayıtlı bir derginin önceki iki yılda aynı veri tabanına kayıtlı diğer dergilerden

ABD’nin doğrudan belirleyici olduğu veya yönetimini bü- yük ölçüde kendisinin belirlediği Dünya Bankası aracılığıyla uyguladığı dış yardım

Her bir tabloda toplamı on olan ikilileri boyayarak tabloda son sayı kalana kadar devam et.. Kullanmadığın sayıyı noktalı

Her bir tabloda toplamı on olan ikilileri boyayarak tabloda son sayı kalana kadar devam et.. Kullanmadığın sayıyı noktalı

Stamm gastrostomy was performed in 62 patients in whom oral and nasogastric tube feeding could not be given and percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy could not be performed by

8) Emir'in bir miktar balonu vardı. Emir 23 tane daha balon satın alınca toplam 70 tane balonu olmuştur. Buna göre Emir'in başlangıçta kaç tane balonu vardı?.. PROBLEMLER

Elde edilen tüm verilerin anlaşılabilir şekilde sunulması işlemi bu bölümde yapılır. Daha kolay anlaşılabilmesi için sonuçlar tablo, grafik, ya da şekillerle

Findings -The empirical results indicate that the board size, doctoral qualification, and cross-directorship of the members were positively correlatedwith the